Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nguyen Research Proposal
Nguyen Research Proposal
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
Fall 2017
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 2
ACHIEVEMENT
Table of Contents
Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………………3
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………….….4
Discrepancies in Licensure…………………………………………………….….………7
Specificity of Certification………………………………………………….………….….8
Methodology…………………………….….……………………………………………………11
Participants………………………….…...….……………………………………………11
Research Design/Variables…….….……………………………………...…...…………12
Data Analysis……………………….…...….…….…………………………………...…13
Time Schedule………….…...…...….……….…...….…….……………….……………14
Budget………………………………...….….……………………………………...……14
References…………………………………………………………………...……………...……15
Abstract
Teacher certification and credentials have long been widely agreed on as being
imperative to education and student achievement, yet recent research tends to prove otherwise.
state-to-state. Degree level (credentials) and certification level are all aspects that have been
student achievement can be difficult to measure, students’ results on standardized testing proved
Introduction
Public schools in the U.S. are constantly striving to improve student performance and
achievement. According to the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB), one of several requirements
for teachers of core academic areas is to hold full state certification, which is determined and
defined by each state (U. S. Department of Education, 2009). Licensing standards are noticeably
different from state to state and can lead to ambiguity in consistency regarding what type of
credentials for certification are acceptable per NCLB standards (Darling-Hammond, 2000).
No Child Left Behind’s goal to close the achievement gap also required teachers to be
highly qualified, meaning teachers must meet state certification requirements and
“…demonstrate mastery of the content area in which they teach, either by passing a content
(“Teacher Quality and Student Achievement”, 2005, p. 1). This is a goal that has proven to be a
Prior research on teacher training showed highly inconsistent results. Some studies find
that “…formal education is important and these have been interpreted as support for
on post-college training” (Harris & Sass, 2008, p. 2). Just as common, however, is the finding
“School leaders have long been aware of the potential impact of an excellent teacher on
student achievement” (Jacob, 2012, p. 3). Professor William Sanders (as cited in Johnson,
2000,) stated, “the single most dominant factor affecting student academic gain is teacher effect”
(p.1). The varying levels and requirements for teacher certification (which are often differing
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 5
ACHIEVEMENT
from state-to-state and can be non-specific to education) have a direct effect on student
achievement, although research done in the past two decades (Goldhaber & Brewer, 1996; Harris
& Sass, 2008) provided data in surprising, and not ways commonly assumed.
The varying levels and requirements for teacher certification have a direct effect on
student achievement. Most assume that a more highly-certified teacher, over a less credentialed
teacher, results in students with higher achievement. Current research (Johnson, 2000; Jacob,
The purpose of this study will be to discover the effect teacher certification and
graduate level, completion of a major or minor the field(s) being taught, having taken additional
education credits, and successful completion of student teaching (Darling-Hammond, 2000) i.e.
licensure. Credentials, while encompassed as a part of teacher certification, for the purpose of
this study will refer to the level of education a teacher holds, such as a Bachelor’s degree,
Master’s degree, etc. Student achievement will refer to student scores on standardized tests.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 7
ACHIEVEMENT
Although licensure varies from state to state, a standard teacher’s license is given to
achieved the necessary college credits, and completed a student teaching experience” (Jacob,
2013, p. 9). Paths for attaining each type of certification vary across states in a number of
respects, including the standards for admission into certification programs and the amount of in-
classroom experience required (Guarino, 2009). The specifics of the classes needed for a teacher
preparation program vary greatly, as there is no “universal” slate of curriculum in place for
Discrepancies in Licensure
Many discrepancies can be found in the licensure process from state to state. For
example, potential teachers in Louisiana can receive licensure without a minor in the field they
management, or working with special needs students. Only six weeks of student teaching is
including a full major in the subject area to be taught, classes in learning theory, child
development, effective teaching strategies, and education of children with special needs, just to
name a few. Student teaching occurs over 18 weeks, and must be supervised by a cooperating
teacher that meets the minimum standards. Consequently, Minnesota students have consistently
scored in the top distribution on national assessments, whereas Louisiana students typically
While lower certification standards appear to correlate with lower student test scores, the
relationship between student achievement and teacher credentials bears a greater significance, in
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 8
ACHIEVEMENT
part due to the coursework needed for certification, but also the specific area of study and
continuing education (if any) of teachers. Goldhaber and Brewer (1999) found that although
advanced degrees (in general) were not associated with higher student achievement, an advanced
degree that was specific to the subject area that a teacher taught was. These results suggested
that subject knowledge may be more important than the type of certification in terms of the
Specificity of Certification
Darling-Hammond and Youngs (2002) confirmed that while some teacher qualifications
may have more impact on student achievement than others, these qualifications are often
interceded by the grade level and subject matter being taught. In fact, “…being certified in the
subject (regardless of the specific subject) is predictive of higher achievement than being
certified in a related subject” (Clotfelter, Ladd, & Vigdor, 2007, para 43). Other studies
determined that greater teacher preparation in math resulted in positive effects on students’ test
scores in math. In other subject areas, however, greater teacher preparedness did not translate
into higher student achievement (Clotfelter et al., 2007). Harris and Sass (2008) found in their
research that,
…only in the case of middle school math do we find that obtaining an advanced degree
enhances the ability of a teacher to promote student achievement. For all other
Teachers with advanced degrees are often sought after by schools and district leaders to
raise student performance, and encourage existing teachers to pursue higher degrees in the hope
that this will lead “…to a deeper understanding of teaching, learning, and human development,
which in turn should lead to improved student performance” (Jacob, 2012, p. 8). While those in
education would believe that higher certification standards and an advanced degree would
significantly improve student achievement, that does not seem to be the case. Teachers with
masters or a doctorate degree do not have students with higher achievement than comparable
teachers without advanced degrees (Buddin & Zamarro, 2009), and “…research indicates either
degree by a teacher and their students’ achievement…” (Harris & Sass, 2008, p. 7).
A study done at Stanford University put forth data showing that teachers with full
certification and a major in the field “…is a more powerful predictor of student achievement that
teachers’ education levels (e.g. master’s degrees)” (Darling-Hammond, 2000, p. 32). To put it
simply, teacher quality equates to higher student achievement; while researchers showed that
teacher certification and credentials are not necessarily associated to the quality and effectiveness
of a teacher. In fact, studies showed that in regards to certified teachers, those with graduate
degrees was not predictive of higher achievement in their students compared to having a teacher
Student achievement (how a student performs on standardized testing) has often been
linked to teacher effectiveness, which encompasses many areas. When the areas of teacher
certification (successful completion and licensure to teach) and credentials (level of teacher
education) were examined more closely, teachers with advanced degrees surprisingly do no
better or worse when compared to teachers without advanced degrees. Teachers that have
certification in their subject area (regardless of having an advanced degree or not) tend to have
students with higher achievement. Teachers in Colorado need to be highly qualified, meaning
teachers have either passed the math ETS Praxis test, or obtained 24 credit hours in the areas of
The independent variable for this research study is student achievement on standardized
tests; the dependent variable is the level of education and type of certification the teacher holds.
backgrounds tend to be viewed as higher quality teachers who demonstrate greater gains in
student achievement. In action, however, do teachers with higher credentials result in students
achievement? The null hypothesis for this research study would show that there is no
statistically significant difference in student achievement between students whose teacher has a
higher degree of education (credentials) than those students whose teacher has less education.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 11
ACHIEVEMENT
Methodology
Participants
Thunder Ridge Middle School is one of ten 6-8 grade middle schools in the Cherry Creek
School District. CCSD covers 108 square miles in the Denver, Colorado metro area, serving
over 54,000 students. The school district tends to lie in the more affluent areas of the Denver
metro area, and students attending CCSD most often score well above state averages on state
As of the 2017-18 school year, TRMS currently serves an estimated 430 sixth graders,
430 seventh graders, and 460 eighth graders. Ethnic diversity at TRMS consists of a student
population that is 60% White, 17% Hispanic, 9% Black, and 6% Asian or Other. There is a
The participants in this study will be comprised of students with disabilities (on an IEP).
Thunder Ridge Middle School currently has a population where 13% of students have a
disability (more than double the state average of 6%). (GreatSchools.org, n.d.) The sample used
will be fourteen learning disabled students in math from each grade level at Thunder Ridge
Middle School will be chosen prior to the school year for the study.
Because all teachers in the state of Colorado must be highly qualified in their subject
area, seven learning disabled students from each grade level will be chosen by the researcher
from a teacher that has gained highly qualified status via the ETS Praxis (meaning no teacher
education specific math classes were taken), and seven students chosen from teachers that gained
highly qualified status via 24 additional credit hours in math specific teacher education.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 12
ACHIEVEMENT
Research Design/Variables
An experimental research design approach with homogenous grouping of students with
learning disabilities in math was used to examine the results on the independent variable, student
achievement i.e. scores on standardized tests. The dependent variable, teacher certification and
credentials, was determined by the process (“path”) the teacher too to obtain highly qualified
status.
All math teachers at Thunder Ridge Middle School participate in an aligned curriculum,
meaning that teachers meet weekly to lesson plan and ensure that all students are receiving the
Procedures
Due to the experimental research design nature of the study, students were able to
be chosen for the study dependent on a.) being diagnosed with a learning disability in math, and
b.) having a current IEP. Students were chosen prior to starting the school year, but after
students had been assigned to a math teacher. Seven students from each of the three grade levels
were then selected to had a math teacher who obtained highly qualified status via passing the
math content ETS Praxis. An equal number of students were chosen from a math teacher who
obtained highly qualified status by taking additional 24 credit hours in math teacher education. It
should be noted that because Math EasyCBM testing is part of the special education IEP process,
and done outside of the core math classroom, the general education teachers the students were
chosen from were not required to give consent (yet, all teachers were informed of the study). For
the purpose of the study, teachers were asked informally what avenue they obtained their highly
Once students were chosen, the respective consent forms were sent to each student’s
parents/guardians, along with a follow-up phone call. Students chosen for the study were pulled
for a brief, one-on-one meeting with the investigator to explain the purpose of the study and
review the consent form. Students were not met with if their parents had not approved and given
Data Analysis
Math EasyCBM “…is standardized measures that sample from a year’s worth of
curriculum to assess the degree to which students have mastered the skills and knowledge
deemed critical at each grade level. The math assessments available on EasyCBM are based on
the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) Curriculum Focal Point Standards in
Mathematics” (University of Oregon, 2017). Data from EasyCBM were analyzed by utilizing
the EasyCBM report function, which provided information on student scores. Scores were on a
scale of how many questions correct out of sixteen, which then would correlate into a percentage
Students were tested monthly via computer/internet using EasyCBM in the area of math
number operations and applications. Each test are sixteen questions, comprised of both multiple
choice and fill-in-the-blank. Once students complete the test, answers are automatically
submitted to the site, and scores derived. Baseline data were gathered the first month of school.
Each month after, scores were accessed via the site and recorded. Scores from each group of
students were compiled to determine if growth were shown from month to month, along with
At the end of the school year, student scores (and the resulting means) of both groups
were compared utilizing a parametric test, an independent t-test. Results of the t-test determined
Time Schedule
EasyCBM progress monitoring in math is done monthly during the school year, therefore,
the time schedule for the study took the length of the 2017-18 school year. Data were recorded
each month, with a running record of updated scores. This made it possible for a final
summary/conclusion of the data to be compiled rather quickly by the final month of the school
year.
Budget
The budget for this study is minimal. Expenses included forty-two self-addressed
stamped envelopes and the printed consent forms for parents/guardians and students. Thunder
Ridge Middle School covered the cost of the EasyCBM online program, as it had in previous
years.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 15
ACHIEVEMENT
References
Buddin, R., & Zamarro, G. (2009). Teacher qualifications and student achievement in
10.1016/j.jue.2009.05.001
http://www.cherrycreekschools.org/AboutUs/Pages/default.aspx
Clotfelter, C. T., Ladd, H. F., & Vigdor, J. L. (2007). Teacher credentials and
student achievement in high school: A cross-subject analysis with student fixed effects.
Working Paper. (NBER Working Paper No. 13617). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of
10.14507/epaa.v8n1.2000
Darling-Hammond, L. & Youngs, P. (2002). Defining “highly qualified teachers”: What does
M. Kanstoroom & C.E. Finn (Eds.), Better teachers, better schools (pp. 82-102).
https://www.greatschools.org/colorado/aurora/233-Thunder-Ridge-Middle-School/
Harris, D. N., & Sass, T. R. (2008, March). Teacher training, teacher quality and student
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 16
ACHIEVEMENT
Jacob, A. (2012). Examining the real relationship between student achievement and
http://www.heritage.org/education/report/the-effects-advanced-teacher-training-
education-student-achievement
The Center for Public Education. (2005). Teacher quality and student achievement: Research
Menu/Staffingstudents/Teacher-quality-and-student-achievement-At-a-glance/Teacher-
quality-and-student-achievement-Research-review.html
https://dibels.uoregon.edu/assessment/math
U.S. Department of Education. (2009). No Child Left Behind: A toolkit for teachers. Retrieved
from https://www2.ed.gov/teachers/nclbguide/toolkit_pg6.html
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 17
ACHIEVEMENT
Appendix A
CONSENT FORM for Minor Participants – Parent/Guardian Form
Invitation to Participate:
Your child has been invited to join a research study to look at student achievement scores
with their respective math teachers. Please take whatever time you need to discuss the
study with your family and friends, or anyone else you wish to. The decision to let your
child join, or not to join, is up to you.
This study is being conducted by Shasta Nguyen, a graduate student at Chadron State
College, and currently a 7th grade Learning Specialist at your child’s school.
Your child’s scores from monthly progress monitoring in math will be utilized in this
study. Monthly progress monitoring is currently a part of the IEP process, and will not
require any additional time and/or effort on your child’s part.
Potential Benefits:
Others may benefit in the future from the information found in this study.
Assurance of Confidentiality:
Your child’s name will not be used when data from this study are published.
Participation in this study is voluntary. Your child has the right not to participate at all or
to leave the study at any time.
Deciding not to participate or choosing to leave the study will not result in any penalty or
loss of benefits to which your child is entitled, and it will not harm his/her relationship
with Mrs. Nguyen.
The investigator may stop the study or take your child out of the study at any time it is
judged to be in your child’s best interest. Your child may be removed from the study for
various other reasons, without your consent.
Your child can stop participating at any time. If your child stops he/she will not lose any
benefits.
You are voluntarily making a decision whether or not to allow your child or legal ward to
participate. Your signature indicates that, having read and understood the information
provided above, you have decided to permit your child or legal ward to participate in this
research.
Relationship to Participant
Date
Signature of Investigator
Date
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 19
ACHIEVEMENT
Note: If the minor is between the ages of eight and nineteen, the minor must complete an
“Assent Form” as well. A copy of this assent form will be provided to the parent or legal
guardian.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 20
ACHIEVEMENT
Appendix B
ASSENT FORM for Minor Participants
(ages thirteen to nineteen)
Invitation to Participate: You are invited to participate in a study of your Math EasyCBM
progress monitoring scores. This study is being conducted by Mrs. Shasta Nguyen, a teacher at
Thunder Ridge Middle School, and also a graduate student at Chadron State College.
Purpose of the Research: This study is to determine if student achievement on testing depends
on the type of highly qualified status your teacher obtained.
Explanation of Procedures: If you decide to participate, you will be asked to do the following
things: Continue to monthly take the Math EasyCBM progress monitoring test for your IEP.
Potential Benefits: Although there are no benefits for you as a student, yet others may benefit
in the future from the information found in this study.
Withdrawal from the Study: I am seeking your permission to include you in this research
study; you are free to say no at this time. You can also stop your participation at any time, by
telling me that you want to stop. Before you agree to be involved, you should discuss whether or
not to participate with your parent, prior to signing this form. Your parent will also be asked to
agree to your participation.
Offer to Answer Questions: If you have any questions, please feel free to ask questions now or
at any time during the study. If you have questions, you can contact Mrs. Shasta Nguyen at 720-
886-1550 or email at snguyen29@cherrycreekschools.org, or contact the Chair of the Chadron
State College Institutional Review Board at 308-432-6203 if you have questions about the study,
concerns, etc.
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 21
ACHIEVEMENT
You are making a decision whether or not to participate in this study. By signing this form
you indicate that you have read and understood the information, and you have decided to
be involved in this study
Your parent/legal guardian will be given a copy of this assent form to keep.
Signature of Participant
Date
Date
EFFECT OF TEACHER CERTIFICATION AND CREDENTIALS ON STUDENT 22
ACHIEVEMENT
Appendix C
ASSENT FORM for Minor Participants
(ages eight to thirteen)
I am…
…Mrs. Shasta Nguyen, a teacher at your school, and a student at Chadron State College.
I invite you…
…to participate in a study of your Math EasyCBM scores.
You are making a decision whether or not to participate in this study. Please read and
understand the information above. If you agree to participate, please sign the form below
to show that you have decided to be involved in this study.
Your parent/legal guardian will be given a copy of this assent form to keep.
Signature of Participant
Date
Date