'."'rrt!

:1
, ;1

.
.,,,
,

1990 TABLE OF CASES

..
,I
 , orr
, ) ~:
n

'
,, ,
TABLE OF CASES
From January U; December 3, '1990· ,II
,I
SCRA Vols.181 to 191
:1
I
Abad, Dolores de Mesa us, Corona ThaySomera, 187 SCRA 75
Abad, RamonL. us, Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 191
Abad Santos, Jr., Quirino D.-Roberto R. Benedicto us., 183 SCRA
434.
i,
a.
Aballe, Peter Paul y Mendoza us, People of'the Philippines,183 SCRA
196 'I
i'i"
'II
Abaquin Security and Detective Agency, Inc. us. Diego P. Atienza, 190
,I \
SCRA460
Abasolo, Romulo E.-Arturo A. Estrada us., 189 SCRA 58
II
;j
Abaya, Otilio G.-Republic of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 524
Abaya, Ramon-People of the Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 419
f'
Abejuro, Anunciacion us. Employees' Compensation Commission, 190 I;"
SCRA435 , Ik
,

Ablao, Mario-People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 658

Aboitiz Shipping Corporation-
us, Court of Appeals, i88 SCRA 387
us, Serna, Diouisio C. Dela, 184 SCRA 551
Aboitiz Shipping Employees Association us, National Labor Relations
Commission, 186 SCRA 825
Abrigo, Sofronio F.-Evelyn de Luna us., 181 ~CRA 150
Abueme, Virgilio A. es, Luis T. Santos, 190 SCRA 51
Acierto, Nicanor us, Vicente' Gacias, 190 SCRA 666
Achacoso, Tomas D.-Hortencia Salazar us., 183 SCRA 145
Acosta, Jesus-People of the Philippines us., 187 SCRA 39
Acting Chairman of the Commission on Audit-Elias B. Pacete us.,
185SCRA1
Acting Registrars of Land Titles and Deeds ofPasay City, Pasig and
Makati us, Regional Trial Court ofMakati, Br. 57,184 SCRA 622
Active Wood Products Co., Inc.-
us. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 774
us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 183 SCRA 671
Adap, Jonathan V.-People of the Philippines, us., 189 SCRA 413
Adlawan, Eleazar V. us, Valeriano P. Tomol, 184 SCRA 31
Administrative Action Board-Maria B. Lupo us., 190 SCRA 69
Adriano, Dominsdor-Adela Reformina us., 189 SCRA 723
Africa, Alfonso us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 188 SCRA 586

\ 825
 'I :'[f
, ,.,

826 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED TABLE' OF CASES 827

Agan, Alfredo-People of the Philippinesvs., 181 SCRA 856 Andaya, Nathaniel vs. People of the Philippines,186SCRA 410
Agapinay, Romeo-People of the Philippines us, 186 SCRA 812 Ansaldo, Jose Ma. vs. Francisco S. Tantuico, Jr., 188 SCRA 300
Agbayani, Aguedo F: vs., The Commission on Elections, 186 SCRA 484 Anscor Transport & Terminals, Inc. vs. National 'Labor Relations
Agne, Marcelino C. vs. Director of Landa, 181 SCRA 793 Commission, 190 SCRA 147
Agravante, Jose vs. Juana Patriarca, 183 SCRA 113 Anunciacion, Jr., K Casiano P.-Mariano R. Santiago us., 184 SCRA
Agton, Roqoe-Nordic Asia Limited vs., 186 SCRA 806 118
Agninaldo, Zoilo-BeatrizF. Gonzales vs., 190 SCRA 112 Aiionuevo, Domingo T: vs, Fidel Ramos, 187 SCRA 311
Agnirre, Alexander-Vicky A. Ocaya us., 187 SCRA 311 . Aquino, Florendo P.-Pastor Tanchoco us., 181 SCRA 73 '
Agulto, Avelino C. vs. Court of Appeals, 1,81SCRA 80 Aquino, Ju:!uito Q.-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 851
Agustin, Eduardo vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 375 Aquino, Lilia-c-Iesua C. Jakihaca vs., 181 SCRA 67
Agustin, Eulogio us..Intermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA 218 Aquino, Paulino-People of the Philippines us., 186 SCRA 208"
Alarcon Vergara, Concepcion S.-United States of America vs. 182 Aquino, Santiago vs. Guillermo -R. Luntok, 184 SCRA 177
SCRA644 ' Aranda, Fernando vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 456
Albarillo, Wilfredo-People of the Philippines vs., 188 SCRA 113 Araneta, Jr., Eliseo vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 123
Alburo, Ronilo-People of the' Philippines es., 184 SCRA 655 Arceo, Angelo y Mali-People of the Philippines v;.;187 SCRA 265
Alcantara, Melchor vs. Severino Boneo, 190 SCRA 321 Arceo, Virgiriia Franco Vda. deus. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 489
Aldeguer, Vicente-People ofthe Philippines cs., 184 SCRA 1 Arengo, Felicisimo-e-People' of the Philippines vs., 181 SCRA 344
Alegria, Dante y Arana-People of the Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 122 . Arizabal, Antonio V.-
Alejandro, Alfonso O. vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 700 . -Guerrero, Jose L. vs., 186 SCRA 109
Alemar's Sibal & Sons, Inc. vs. Jesus M. Elbiilias, 186 SCRA 94 vs. Leviste, Oscar L., 186 SCRA 108
Alfonso, Arsenio y Cawading-People ofthe Philippines vs., 186 SCRA Arizala, Pablo vs. Court of Appeals, 189SCRA 584
576 , " Armovit, Herman vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 476
Alfonso, Rodolfo vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 400 Arsenal, Wilfredo-BeIliamin L. Jalandoni, Jr., vs., 188 SCRA 56 •
Alitalia Airways vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 763 Arsenio, Alberto y De la Cruz-People of the Philippines vs., 184
Allian, Joel vs. Chairman & Commissioners,Civil Service Commis- SCRA205' .
sion, 188SCRA162 " '. " . Artex Development Co., Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commis-
Allied Banking Corporation us, L.M. Handicraft Manufacturing Cor- sion, 187 SCRA 611
poration, 186SCRA 640 ', , Asian Construction and Development Corporation vs. National Labor
Allied Broadcasting Center, Inc. vs. Republic of the Philippines, 190 Relations Commission, 187 SCRA 784
SCRA 782 ' ' Asistio, J~., Macario A.-0smundo Medina vs., 191 SCRA 218
Alonto, Jr., Ahmad E. vs. Salvador A. Memoracion, 185 SCRA 73 Aspili, Rodolfo-People of the Philippines vs., 191 SCRA 530 '
Alvarez, Heherson T.-Suzano F. Gonzales, Jr. vs., 182 SCRA 15 Associated Anglo-American Tobacco Corporation vs. Jacobo C. Clave,
Alvarez, Laura vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 185 SCRA 8 189SCRA127
Alvendia, Felicidad M. vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 181 SCRA Associated Labor Unions (ALtJ)'vs:'National Labor Relations Com-
252 ' , mission, 189 SCRA 743 '
Alvero, Donato-People of the Philippines vs., i87 SCRA 576 Associated Workers Union (PTGWO) vs. National Labor Relations
Amansec, Arthur G.-Manila Port Services, Inc. vs. 188 SCRA 123 Commission, 188 SCRA 123
Ambrosio, Antonio G. vs. Intermediate Appellate C;urt 181 SCRA 99 Astraquillo, Isabelo J. vs. Fortunato D. Oblena, 190 SCRA 28.0
Amin, Omar U.-,-Juan Ponce Enrile vs., 189 SCRA 573' Atienza, Diego P.-Abaquin Security and Detective Agency.Tne, vs.,
Ampo-an, Carlos-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 173 190 SCRA460 ' ,
Anciano, Alvino-People of the Philippines o«, 189 SCRA 519 Atilano, Vicente vs': Dionisio'C, De la Serna, 182 SCRA 886'
Andamo, Natividad V. vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 191 SCRA Atlas' Consolidated Mining & Development Corpor&tion-
195 ' vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 166
Andaya, Ernesto vs. National Labor Relations COmmission 188 SCRA vs. NationalLabor Relations Commission, 190 SCRA505
253 ' Atlas Developer & Steel Industries, Inc. vs. Sarmiento Enterprises,
828 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED TABL:E OF CASES 829

Ine., 184 SCRA 153 Bati, Regalado-People of the Philippines vs.,189 SCRA 97
Austria, Maria Alicia M.-Mariano Dlnglasan us., 191 SCRA 873 Batoy, Felicid¢o M.-Jose M. Belen vs., 182 SCRA 549
Auxilio, Jr., Porlirio vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 188 Bautista Ailgel L. vs. RamonA. Gonzales,182, SCRA 151
SCRA263 " , . ' . ,.', > .

Bautista, Benjamin vii. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 123

Aviles, Rufo-Interpacific Transit, lnc. es., 186 SCRA 385 Bautista, Crispin V.-Fortunato de la Cruz us., 186 SCRA 517
Ayala Corporation vs. Job B. Madayag, 181 SCRA 687 Bayan, Tomas us, Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 844
Ayer Productions pty. Ltd. vs. Ignacio M. Capulong, 185 SCRA 504 Baybayon, Victor-People of the Philippines vs., 184 SCRA 13
Aznar, Jose B. vs. Commission on Elections, 185 SCRA 703 Beech, Edwina Lema vs. Jose C. De GuzII)an,187 SCRA 773
Azura, Cesar P.-Qscar Palma Pagasian vs., 184 SCRA 391 Belarmino, Manuel us, Employees' Compensation Commission, 185
..
-, ,

SeRA 304
BF Homes, Incorporated vs. Court of Appeals,190 SCRA 262 Belen Jose M. us. Felicidario M. Batoy, 182 SCRA 549
Bacani, Romeo y Polioso-People of the Philippines vs., 181 SCRA 393 Bell Carpets International Trading Corporation vs. Court of Appeals,
r!

Bachelor Express, Incorporated vs, Court of Appeals,188 SCRA 216 , 185SCRA35 ' !i :!
Baclayon, Leoncia vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 761 Belstar Transportation, Inc, vs. Board of Transportation, 181 SCRA Iii:
Bacolod-Murcia Milling Oo., Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 24 209
1"1

Badilla, Danilo y Ones-People of the Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 554 Benarao, Lucio-Silliman University vs., 182 SCRA 573 , I':
II
Baduya, Salvador yTibus-People of the Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 57 Benedicto, Irene vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 41
Bagano, Domingo y Sali-en-People of the Philippines vs., 181 SCRA
747
Benedicto, Ma. Luisa vs. Intermediate Appellate Court,187 SCRA547 '.II,
I'
Benedicto; Roberto R. us. Quirino D. Abad Santos, Jr., 183 SCRA 434 i ,~ f
Baguio, Alfonso-Julio Baranda us., 189 SCRA 194
Bala, Manuel V. vs. Antonio M. Martinez,181 SCRA 459
Bengzon, AlfredO R.A.-Contad.o L. Villazor vs. 186 SCRA 110
Benigno, Teodoro C.-Dolores Garcia us., 186 SCRA 108
II
1:"1
Balansi, Bonifacio-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 566 Bernardo, Benjamin y Mariano-People of the Philippines vs., 186 I"
, I
Balt, Bayan G. vs. Lnis T. Santos,190 SCRA 50 SCRA876 ,I
Baltazar, Venancio-Baltazar Pantig vs., 191 SCRA 830 Bernardo' Jaime vs. Court of Appeals,190 SCRA 63 I 0
Baluyot, Juan A. us. Danilo B. Lacuna, 189 SCRA 58 Bersamlra, Jesw:. G.-8an Miguel Corporation Employees Union-
I

Baluyut, Victoria U. vs. Felicidad S. Baluyut, 186 SCRA 506

Banco De Oro Savings & Mortgage Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 182
SCRA464 .
Banco Filipino Savings and Mortgage Bank vs. National Labor Rela-
tions Commission, 188 SCRA 700
Bank of America NT & SA us, Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 4i 7
Banaga, Guillermo vs. Commission on the Settlement of Land Prob-
lems, 181 SCRA 599
Baranda, Julio vs. Alfonso Baguio,189 SCRA 194
Barcelona, Gideony Dequito-People of the Philippines vs., 191 SCRA
100
Barcenas, Filomena vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 187
SCRA498
Baring, Pedro-People of the Philippines us., 187 SCRA 629
Baritua, Jose vs. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 565
Barrios, Hemani T.-William Tan vs., 190 SCRA 686 . Board ofInvestments; The-Enrique T. Garcia vs., 191 SCRA 288
Barro, Jr., Alberto y Relon-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA
284
Bartolome, Resurreccion us, Intermediate Appellate Court,183 SCRA
102
PTGWO vs., 186 SCRA 496
Besa, Mamerto B. vs. Benjamin C. Tiongson,191 SCRA 184
Besa, Melchor-People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 533
illI:"
Beta Electric Corporation vs. National Labor Relations Commission, ,
t
182 SCRA 384 '
Biago, Melecio-People of the Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 411
Bi8Ia, Leonor J. vs. Court of Appeals,191 SCRA 50
Bicarme, Maria vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 294
Bicog, Laureano-e-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 556
Bicol Savings & Loan Association vs. Jaime Guinhawa,188 SCRA 642
Binamira, Ramon P. vs. Peter D. Garrucho, 188 SCRA 154
Blardony, Jr., Mauro us, Jose L. Coscolluela, Jr., 182 SCRA 825
Blue Manila, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 183
SCRA 732
Board of Energy-City of Davao vs., 186 SCRA406
Board.of Trartsportation-
-Belstar Transportation, lnc. vs., 181 SCRA 209
-P";'tranco South Express, Inc. vs., 191 SCRA 581
Bocatcat, Sr., Tomas-c-Peoplaof the Philippines vs., 188 SCRA 175
 830 SUPREME COURT,REPORTS, ANNOTATED 'TABLE OF CASES· 831

Bocobo, Daniel-L; VB. Commission on Elections, 191 SCRA 576' Caldito, Rolapdo-c-People of the Philippines VB., 182 SCH!\66
Bolinao, Jr., A.N. VB; Manuel S. Padolina, 186 SCRA368 Calleja, Pura-International Catholic Migration Commlasioncs., 190
Bonamy, Bonifacio VB' Edgardo L. Paras,181 SCRA 252 SCRA130 ., ' • '"
Bondoc, Carlito P.VB. Sandiganbayan, 191 SCRA 252 Calo, Jr., Tranquilino-e-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 620
Boneo, Severino-c-MelchorAlcantara us., 190 SCRA 321 . Camarao, Robert y Laoyan-People of the Philippines us., 18S;SCRA
Bonife, Rufino-c-Mariano Reas vs., 190 S,CRA 493 671 . . , . ' '
Borja, Enemecio L.-People of,tbe Philippineses.,' 191 SCRA 120 Camas, Teodorico-c-SSK Parts Corporation vs.,.1;81 SCRA,675
Borja, Lamberto y,Martinez-People of-the Philippines us., 182 SCRA Camasis, ROmeo-c-Peopie o(the Philippines vs., 189 SQliA 649. "
581, " , Campos Rueda Corporation-Commissioner of Customs, The us., 188
Borromeo, Joaquin T. vs. Court of Appeals,186 SCRA 1 , SCRA613 ' , '. '
Brent School, Inc. vs.. Ronaldo Zamora,,181 SCRA 702 Cando, Francisco P. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 189
Brett, June Prill vs. Intermediate Appellate Court,191 SCRA 687 SCRA666., "
Breva, Augusto V.-Jose Modequillo VS;, 185 SCRA 766 ' Caneba, Doroteo N.-Eula:lio M. Ruiz vs., 191 SCRA 865,
Brillante-GarginjZedda B.-Irene P. Relucio VS., 187 SCRA 405 Caneba, Jr., Gregorio D. vs. Court of Appeal.., 181 SCRA 762
Bristol Laboratories Employees' Association VS. National Labor, Cano, Benito vs. Luis T. Santos, 190 SCRA,51 '
Relations Commission, 187 SCRA 118 Oantre.Exequiel y Bon-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 76
Brokenshire Memorial Hospital, Inc. VS. Minister of Labor & Employ- Cantuba, Pio-:.People of the Philippines vs., 183 scliA 289 .
.ment, 182 SCRA5 " , Caneba, Doroteo-e-Nestor Sandoval vs., 190 SCRA 7 7 ,
Buenaflor, Jaime y Arcilla-,-People of the 'Philippines VS., 181SCRA Capco, Fructuoso R. vs. Manuel R. Macasaet, 189 SQRA561 ,
225, " Capilitan,Gorgonio-c-People of the Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 313 ,
Buenaventura; Lily San VS. Court ofAppeals, 181 SCRA 197 Capricorn International'Travel and Tours, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals,
Buenavista, Jr.,Nicente,C. VS. MarceloG. Garcia, 187 SCRA 598 184SCRA123
Buenviaje, Carlos R.-Rinconada Telephone Company, Inc. VS., 184 Capule, Policarpio us. National Labor Relations Commission, 191
SCRA 701" , ' '. '" , '. SCRA374
Bueza, Antonio-e-Pecple of the Philippines VS., 188 SCRA 683 Capulong, Ignacio M.- "
Bugaoan, Crisostomo y Ignacio-i-Peopla 'of the Philippines vs., 183 \ ,':"'Ayer Productions Pt;J. Ltd. vs., 185 SCRA 504
SCRA62 '-McElroy, Hal us., 185 SCRA504 '
Bulaong, Romulo S. VS. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 618 ' -Ponce Enrile, Juan us., 185 SCRA 504 I
Bungnbung, Leopoldo F.-oscar M. Orbos.us., 191 SCRA 563 ' Capulong, Manuel vs. Court of Appeals,185 SCRA 215 , I

Bustamante, Rogelio vs. Executive Secretary,186 SCRA 109 Carandang, Felisa D. tis. Ceferino E. Dulay, 188 SCRA 792'" I,
Bustarde, Mario yPama-People of the Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 554 Oarbungco, Estanislao vs. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 313
Buta1id, Walerico B.-Generoso Quiban us., 189 SCRA 107 C;;"doza, Juanito es, Pabio S. Singson, 181 SCRA45 ' I
. " Carino, Virgilio S. VB. National Labor Relations Commission, 185
SCRA177 , " " I'
C.T. Torres Enterprises, Inc. vs. Roineo J. Hibionada, 191 SCRA 268 I
Caasi, Mateo us, Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 229 Carmelcraft Corporation vs. National Labor Relations Coinmission, ' i
Cabale, Demetrio-c-People of the Philippineses., 185' SCRA 140' 186 SCRA 3 9 3 ' " ,
Cabailero,Antonio-c-Pacifico Go us., 189 SCRA 57 Carmelo.& Bauermann, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commis-
Cagalingan Alfredo y Romina~People of the Philippines vs., 188 sion, iS8 SCRA364
SCRA313 Carpio, Pedro-e-Peopleof the Philippines VB., 191 SCRA108 I'
I
Caga~~~6~16~~llege vs. National Labor Relations Coinmission, Carredo, Elias vs..People of the Philippines,183 SCRA 273 ' I
Cascante, Anecito vs. Commission on Elections, 191 S'CRA229 '
Cagayan Electric Power and Light Company, Inc.s-Provinee of Mis- Castaneda, Mariano-c-People of the Philippines ."s., 187 SCRA 148'
amis Oriental, The us., 181 SCRA 38 Castiller, Adelina y Castro-s-People of the Philippines us., i88 SCRA
Calagui, Manuel VB. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 564 , ,376 ' "
Calapatia, Jr., Ga:licano vs. Hacienda Benito, Inc., 191 SCRA 357 Castillo, Dimiel vs. Luis Santos, 189 SCRA 56

832 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Castro, Ricardo C.-Elllmanuel Timbungco vs., 183 SCRA 140
Catholic Vicar Apostolic of the Mountain Province vs. Court of Ap-
peals, 183 SCRA 639
Cayaan, RallY-People of the Philippines V8., 183 SCRA 445
Ceballos, Josefina b.-United States of America us, 182 SCRA 644
Celerian, RUIJen E. ps. Francisco S. Tantuico, Jr.,lll0 SCRA i' .
Celi, Rogelio P. us. Cresenciano B. Trajano, 184 SCRA 442
Cempron, Alfredo-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 248
Cendana, Arnulfo y Reyes-People of the Philippines ~s., :1.90 SCRA
538
Ceniza, Restituto V8, Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 552
Central Azucarera de Bais vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 328
Central Bank of the Philippines-
vs. Cruz, Rafael de la, 191 SCRA 346 ,
-Medalla, Simeon C. VS., 189 SCRA 14
Cenzon, Pedro D.-Fidelity Savings and Mortgage Bank vs., 184 SCRA
141
Cerdon, Ildefonsa vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 198
Cerna, Dionisio C. De Ia-i-Odin Security Agency vs. 182 scRA 472
Chairman & Comissioners, Civil Service Commission-Joel Allian vs.
188 SCRA 162
Chang, Zenaida Bolor vs. Civil Service Commission 191 SCRA 663
Chavez, Francisco 1. V8. Jaime B. Ongpin, 186 SCRA 331 ;---
Chavez, Francisco R.-Iluminado Urbano V8., 183 SCRA'347
Chavez, Raquel VS. Intermediate Appellate Court 191 SCRA 211 1
Chief, Philippine Oonstabulary-e-Sixto Provido vs:, 181 SCRA 508
China Air Lines, Ltd. vs. Court of Appeals,185 SCRA 449 .
Ching, Alfredo vs. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 9
Ching ~ui Yong, Jose vS. Intermediate Appellate Court,191 SCRA 187
Choa Tiek Seng vs. Court of Appeals,183 SCRA 223
Chua, Celia B. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 190 SCRA
558
Chua, Johnson G. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, :1.82
SCRA353
Chua, Rina V. vs. Edgardo D. Nuestro,190 SCRA 424
Chua-Qua, Evelyn vs. Jacobo C. Clave,189 SCRA 117
Cina, Ernesto y Gaspar-People of the Philippines vs., 190 SCRA :1.99
Ciobal, Bonifacio y Pabrua-People of the Philippines vs. 184 SCRA
464 . . '
Citadel Lines, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA '544
City MayOi' ofZamboanga vs. Court of Appeals,182 SCRA 785
City of Bacolod-Renato be Villa vs., 189 SCRA 736
City of Davao os. Board of Energy, 186 SCRA 406
City of Manila-Testate Estate of Concordia T. Lim ve., 182 SCRA 482
I .,~
.j
I \1
TABLE OF CASES 833
I 'I
II
Civil Service Commission-
-Chang, Zenaida Bolor us., 191 SCRA 663 I,
ilI
-Esquig, Melanio N. vs., 188 SCRA 166 !"I I
-Floreza, Reyp.osoB. vs., 182 SCRA 692 I',I ~
-orbos, Oscar vs., 189 SCRA 459
-orcinQ, Zanaida vs., 190 SCRA 815 I',
-Patagoc, Vicencio B. vs., 189 SCRA 411
-Pundato, Dimasancay A. vs., 186 SCRA 109
-Reyes, Rainerio O. vs., 186 SCRA 109
-8impao, Jose Cesar D. vs., 191 SCRA 396
-Teologo, Violeta T. vs., 191 SCRA 238
Claravall, Loreto vs. Court ofAppeals, 190 SCRA 435
Clave, Jacobo C.-Associated Anglo-American Tobacco Corporation
vs., 189 SCRA 127
-Chua-Qua" Evelyn vs., 189 SCRA 117,
Clores, Norberto y Coral-People of the Philippines vs.,184 SCRA 638
Co, Nemesio G. vs. Regional Trial Court ofPasig Br.165 183 SCRA
347 ' ,
Co Keng Kian, Manuel vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 189 SCRA
112 '
Co Kiat vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 5
' Co Liong Chong-Gregorio Llantino vs., 188 !:lCRA 592
CO~lOn, Antonio S. vs. Court of Appeals,188 SCRA 719
Cojuangco, Jr., Eduardo M. vs. Presidential Commission on Good
Government,190 SCRA 226
Cojuangco, Lualhati~. vs. Purificacion Villegas,184 SCRA 374
Colet, Angel V.-Restituto Reyes vs., 190 SCRA 51
Commart (Phil.), Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission 189
SCRA 767 '
Commission on Audit-
---Cordillera Broad Coalition vs., 181 SCRA 495
-Land Bank of the Philippines VS., 190 SCRA 154
.
-Mison, Salvador M. us., 187 SCRA 445
Commission on Elections, The-
-Agbayani, Aguedo F. vs., 186 SCRA 484
-Aznar, Jose B. VS., 185 SCRA 703
-Bocobo, Daniel L. vs., 191 SCRA 576
-Cascante, Anecito vs., 191 SCRA 229
-Dimaporo, Mohamad Ali B. vs., 186 SCRA 769
-Dipatuan, Dimangadap vs., 185 SCRA 86
-Flores, Roque, vs., 184 SCRA 484
-Macias II, Emilio C. VS., 182 SCRA 137
-Quilala, Cirilo M. vs., 188 SCRA 502
-8alazar, Jr., Jesus F. vs., 184 SCRA 433
-8anidad, Pablito V. VS., 181 SCRA 529
TT .• _ T"O _ .. nn n .... T1l Ann,..,
834 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
-Ututalum. Nurhussein A. us.• 181 SCRA 335 '
Commission on the Settlement of Land Problems-s-Guillermo Banaga
us.• 181 SCRA 599
Commissioner of Customs. The-
us. Campos Rueda Corporation; 188 SCRA 613
us. Court of Tax Appeals. 185 SCRA 277; 188 SCRA 61
us. Delgado Shipping Agency. 184 SCRA 579
us. KM.K Gani, Indrapal & Co.• 182 SCRA 591
Commissioner ofInternal Revenue-
us. Court of Tax Appeals, 185 SCRA 329
-Hospital De San Juan De Dies, Inc. us.• 185 SCRA 273
us. Mitsubishi Metal Corporation. 185 SCRA 214
us. Tours Specialists, Inc., 183 SCRA 402
us. Union Shipping Corporation, 185 SCRA547
Compaiiia General De Tabacos De Filipinas us. Court of Appeals. 185
, SCRA284
Concepcion, Alfredo B.-Marina Z. Reyes us., 190 SCRA 171
Concrete Aggragates, Inc. us. Court ofTax Appeals. 185 SCRA 461
Consolacion, Francisco Z.-Heirs of Filomeno Tuyac us., 183 SCRA
396
Consolidated Bank and Trust Corporation, The us. Intermediate Ap-
pellate Court. 189 SCRA 433
Consuelo, Honorio y Portugal-People of the Philippines us., 184
SCRA402
Contacto, Jr.• Juan--8ervillano Mamaril us., 183 SCRA 780
ConfinentalArrastre and Stevedoring Co.• Inc. us. National Labor
Relations Commission. 190 SCRA 811
Continental Cement Corporation us. Court ofAppeals. 184 SCRA 728
Continental Cement Corporation Labor Union (NLU) ue, Continental
Cement Corporation. 189 SCRA 134
Cordillera Broad Coalition us. Commission on Audit. 181 SCRA 495
Coronado, Leonida us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 814
Corrales. Romeo A.-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA: 439
Coscolluela, Jr.• Jose L.-Mauro Blardony, Jr. us., 182 SCRA 825
Coseteng, Anna Dominique M.L. us. Ramon V. Mitra, Jr.• 187 SCRA
377
Cosiquien, Roberto us. Court ofAppeals. 188 SCRA 619
Cosmopolitan Funeral Homes. Inc. us. Noli Maalat, 187 SCRA 108
Court of Appeals- ' -Central Azucarera de Bais us., 188 SCRA 328
-Abad, Ramon L. es., 181 SCRA 191
-Aboitiz Shipping Corporation zis., 188 SCRA 387
-Active Wood Products Co., Inc. us., 181 SCRA 774
-Agulto. Avelino C. us., 181 SCRA 80
-Agustin, Eduardo us.• 186 SCRA 375
-Alejandro, Alfonso O. us., 191 SCRA 100
TABLE OF CASES 835
Court of Appeals-e- , ,".. "
-Alfonso. Rodolfo us., 186 SCRA 400
-Alitalia Airways us., 187 SCRA 763
-Aranda, Fernando us., 186 SCRA 456
-Araneta, Jr.• Eliseo us.,.187 SCRA 123
-Arceo. Virginia Franco Vda. de us" 185 SCRA 489
-Arizala, Pablo us.• 189 SCRA 584
-Armovit, Herman us., 184 SCRA 476
-Atlas Consolidated Miriing & Development Corporation us.
182 SCRA166
-BF Homes. Incorporated us., 190 SCRA262
-Bachelor Express, Incorporated us.; 188 SCRA 216
-Baclayon. Leoncia us., 182 SCRA 761
-Bacolod-Murcia Milling Co., Inc. es., 182 SCRA 24,
-Banco De Oro Savings & Mortgage Bank us., 182 SCRA 464
-Bank of America NT & SA us., 186 SCM 417
-Baritua, Jose us., 183 SCRA 565 !
-Bautista. Benjamin us., 187 SCRA 123 ;
-Bayan, Tomas us., 181 SCRA 844, :
-Bell Carpets International Trading Corporation us., 185 SCRA
35 I
-Benedicto, Irene es., 182 SCRA 41 I
-Bernardo, Jaime us., 190 SCRA 63 \
-Biala, Leonor J. es., 191 SCRA 50 I
-Bicarme, Maria us., 186 SCRA 294
-Borromeo. Joaquin T. us., 186 SCRA 1
-Buenaventura. Lily San us., 181 SCRA 197
-Bulaong. Romulo S. us., 181 SCRA 618
-Caasi, Mateo. vs., 191 SCRA 229
-Calagui. Manuel us., 186 SCRA 564
-Caneda, Jr., Gregorio D. us., 181 SCRA 762
-Capricorn International Travel and Tours. Inc. us., 184 SCRA
123
-Capulong. Manuel os., 185 SCRA 215 ' '
-Carbungco, Estanislao us.• 181 SCRA 313 ,
-Catholic Vicar Apostolic of the Mountain. Province cs., 183
SCRA639
-Ceniza, Restituto es., 181 SCRA 552
-Cerdon. Ildefonsa us., 184 SCRA 198
-China Air Lines, Ltd. us., 185 SCRA 449
-Ching. Alfredo us., 181 SCRA 9 '
-Choa TiekSeng us., 183 SCRA 223
-Citadel Lines, Inc. us., 184 SCRA 544
-City Mayor ofZamboanga us.• 182 SCRA 785
 "J'I

836 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED

TABLE 01,<' CASES 837

Court of Appeals-
-Claravall, Loreto us., 190 SCRA 435 Court of Appeals-
-Co Kiat us., 187 SCRA 5 -Heirs of John Guilles, Sr., us., 191 SCRA 687
-Cohon, Antonio.S, us. 188 SCRA 719 -Heirs of John Z: Sycip us., 191 SCRA 262 '
-<;ompafiia De Tabacos Iie Filipinas us., 185 SCRA 284 -Heirs of Juan Dacasin es., 187 SCRA 86, '
-Continental Cement Corporation es., 184 SCRA 728 -Heirs of Maria De la Cruz y Gutierrez us., 182 SCRA 638
-Coronado, Leonida us., 191 SCRA 814 -Hodges, Joe us., 184 SCRA 281
-Cosiquien, Robertous., 188 SCRA 619 - Ho1Ue Insurance Company es., 184'SCRA 318
-Cruz, Florentino us., 191 SCRA 170
-Cruz, Quirin!> dela us" 187 SCRA 165
-Imperial Textile Mills, Inc. us., 183 SCRA 584
, -Industrill1 Enterprises, Inc. es., 184 SCRA 426, .r ,

-Daez, Lope 0., us.• 191 SCRA 61 -Insular Bank of Asia & America, Incorporated us 190 SCRA ,;1 '

-Dalion,Segundo us., 182 SCRA 872 6 2 9 "

Ii
-David, Deocrecio us., 182 SCRA 675 -Jacob, Tomasa Vda. de us., 184 SCRA 294 , ,
, ,

-Del Monte Corporation us., 181 SCRA 410 -Javier, Jose M. us., 183 SCRA 171 •;>,
.', ~,',
", I' !'
-Demamay, Flavio us., 186 SCRA 608 --.)'ocson, Enrique T. us., 183 SCRA 589 j •• :

-Department of Education, Culture and Sports us., 183 SCRA -K.K. Shell Sekiyu Osaka HatsubaiBho us. 145 SCRA 188
555 -L.M. Handicraft Manufacturing Corpor;tion us 186 SCRA' i,Iii
-Director of Landa us., 181 SCRA 450
640 '' ., il-. Ii i
-Dolorfino, Rolando us., 191 SCRA 880 -Labrador, Rosita us., 184 SCRA 170 )
-Dulos, Juan B. us., 188 SCRA413 -Lagman, Felicidad Abuton Vda. de es., 188 SCRA 198 , ,
-Land Bank of the Philippines us. 181 SCRA 610 ,
-Eastern Shipping Lines, Inc. us., 190 SCRA 512 ..i",:
-Echaus, Luisa us., 187 SCRA 672 -Lans<m,g, Jr., Jose R. es., 184 SCRA 230 , :'
-Embassy Farms, Inc. us., 188 SCRA492 -Lao Lim, Francisco us., 191 SCRA 150
-Estella, Pedro M. us., 185 SCRA 732 -Lauron, Flora us., 184 SCRA 215
-Estoesta, Maria Luisa us., 191 SCRA 303 -Leon, SylViaLichauco de us., 186 SCRA 345
-Ferrian, Thelma us., 181 SCRA 546 -'Lim, Sr. Emilio E. us., 190 SCRA 616
-Fernandez, Florentino L. es., 189 SCRA 780 -Lim, Enrique us., 182 SCRA 564
-Fiestan, Dionisio us., 185 SCRA 751 -Liin, Felix us., 188 SCRA 23
-Filamer Christian Institute us., 190 SCRA 477 ~Lorenzo, Severo M. us., 189 SCRA 260
-Filinvest Land, Inc. vs., 182 SCRA 664 -Lugtu, Domingo V. us., 183 SCRA 388
-Ford, Maria G. us., 18,6 SCRA 21 -Ma-ao Sugar Central Co., Inc, uS.,189 SCRA 88
~Fulgado, Ruperto us., 182 SCRA 81 -Maersk-Tabacalera Shipping Agency (Filipinas) Inc us 187
-Gapusan-Chua, Ligaya us., 183 SCRA 160 SCRA646 ' . .,
-Gl!I'cia, Jr., Antonio u~., 191 SCRA 493 -Mag~alena ~omeowners Association, Inc. es., 184 SCM 325
-Garrison, John L. us., 187 SCRA 525 -Mamla Banking Corporation us., 187 SCRA 138
-Gaspar,Augusto L. us., 190 SCRA 758 -Manila Electric Company us., 187 SCRA 200
-Gaw, Joaquin S. us., 191 SCRA 77 -M~a I~ternational Port Terminals, Inc. us., 183 SCRA 156
-German Management & Services, Inc. us., 187 SCRA 513 -M~la Lighter Transportation, Inc. us., 182 SCRA 251
-Great Pacific Life Insurance Corporation us., 184 SCRA 501 -Manila Remnant Co., Inc., The us., 191 SCRA 622
-Gregorio, Felipa us., 187 SCRA477 -Manila Surety & Fidelity Co., Inc. es., 191 SCRA 805
-Guevarra, William us., 187 SCRA 477 -Manlapaz, Francisco us., 191 SCRA 795
-Gundayao, Eligio us., 185 SCRA 606 -Manzauilla, Celedonio es., 183 SCRA 207
-Heirs of Amparo de los Santos us., 186 SCRA 649 -Marabeles, Raymundo us., 181 SCRA 105
-Heirs ofCelso Amarante us., 185 SCRA585 -Mari~me Agencies & Services, Inc. us., 187 SCRA 346 ,
u ...~ ...... .... f'Tl........... "'... ri f'1.....C!1TItl R~hA 1HL 1R4 geRA 647 ~:"!a:m.:es,_Cen.on us.,. ~~8_~~RA.306'

838 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Court of Appeals-
Court of Appeals-
-Medina, Sr., Ricardo.us., 181 SCRA 837
-Mendiola, Reynaldo VB., 190 SCRA 421
-Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company VB:, 181 SCRA 367;
188SCRA259
-Municipality ofMakati VB., 190 SCRA 206
-Mutuc, Amelito R. VB., 190 SCRA 43
-National Power Corporation VB., 185 SCRA 169
-Navera, Genaro VB., 184 SCRA 584
,---;Northwest Orient ,Airlines VB. , 186 SCRA 440
-Ordonez, Gaudencio VB., 188 SCRA 109
c-Ouano, Patemc.Jvus., 188 SCRA 799'
-Pacubas, Cipriano B.,VB,., 188 SCRA 268
-Pan Malayan Insurance Corporation VB., 184 SCRA 54
-;-~arcon;Manuel P. VB., 191 SCR,A284
, .......Pascua, Auroraus., 183,SCRA 262
-Paz, Bienvenido VB., 181 SCRA 26
-Pelaez, Angel A. VB., 185 SCRA 97
-Pendon, ErIe VB., 191 SeRA 429
-Perla Compania De Seguros, Inc. VB., 185 SCRA,741 ' '
-Pbil-Dumez Construction Corporation VB., 191 SCRA 94
-Philippine Airlines, Inc.t'es., 1810 SCRA 557; 185 SCRA 110;
185 SCRA 449; 188 SCRA 461
-Philippine National Bank VB., 187 SCRA 735 ,
-Philippine Veterans Investment Development Corporation VB.,
181 SCRA 669 " -Toda, Jr.,.Benigno VB" 183 SCRA 713
-Piczon, Bernardino VB., 190 SeRA 31 ,
-Pineda, Antipaz L. VB., 183 SCRA 602
-Polysterene Manufacturing Co., Inc. VB" 185 SCRA,207
-Porac, Trucking, Inc, VB.; 183 SCRA 45 '
,-Posadas, Romeo y Zamora VB", 188 SCRA 288
-Puerta, Isabel de la VB., 181 SCRA861
.,-Quilisadio, Maximinous., 182 SCRA 401
-Qniombing, Nicensio Tan VB., 189 SCRA 325
-Qnisumbing, Norberto VB., 189EiCRA 605 ,
" -R!unirez, DonatovB.,-187SCRA153
, -Valenzuela, Carlos VB., 181 SCRA 524"
-Ramos, Lucy VB., 188 SCRA450
-Regala,AgusjinP. V8., 183 SCRA595" ':'
-Republic of the Philippines VB., 182 SCRA290; 182 SCRA 721;
183 SCRA 62,0 , •'
-Reyes, Elino Ong VB" 189 SCRA 46
-Reyes, 'I'omas T. VB., 185 SCRA 6012
-eRoa, Rosalinda VB., 190 SCRA 262"
-S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc. VB., 188,SCRA 579
TABL-EOF'CASES 839
-Saldana, Marietta'vB.,l90 SCRA<l86 ", {'"
-Salgado; Agustin VB., 189 SCRA304",
-San Miguel Corporation VB:, 185 SCRA 722
,-Santander, BenA. vs., 187 SCRA706, "
-Santiago, Pedro T. VB., 184 SCRA 690
-Santos, Eduardo V. vs" 189 SCRA 550
-Sapugay, Marino VB., 183 SCRA 464
'-Sentinel Insurance Co., Inc.us., 182'SCRA516
-Serrano, Ricardo VB., 189 SCRA 440
-Shauf, Loida Q. VB., 191 SCRA 713
-Shoemart,me. VB., 190 SCRA1 8 9 , '.
-S~ex International (Manila),Incorporated us., 183,SCRA 360
-Snuth Bell & Co., Inc. VB., 190 SCRA 362
-Solivio, Celedonia VB., 182 SCRA 119
-Sta. Monica Industrial and Development Corporation VB., 189
SCRA 792 " ' ." ,
,-Standard Mineral Products; Inc.-us., 184SCRA'571 ' Ii
,I'
-Staaa Incorporated VB:, 182' SCRA 879 ' , !I
-Suarez, Rodolfo VB., 1$6 SCRA 339 ' ,: 'II
I i
-Sunbeam Convenience Foods, Inc. VB., 181 SCRA 44<l
-Taer; Jorge VS., 186 SCRA 598. ' ' . '"
-Talag, Macario VB., 189 SCRA 801
'.,..Talavera, Victor VB:, 182 SCRA 778,
-Tambot, Laureana VB., 181 SCRA 202
-Tan Ang Bun VB., 182 SCRA 238
-Tomas, Elena J. VB.; 185 SCRA 627 "
-Torres; Mariano y Chavarria VB., 186 SCRA 672
-Umali, Buenaflor C. VB., 189 SCRA 529' ' I
-U~on Insurance Society of Canton, Ltd. VB., 187 SCRA 346
-Umted Realty Corporation VB., 183 SCRA 725
-Uy, Jr., Esteban B. VB., 191 SCRA 275
-Uy, Vicente F. VB.; 186 SCRA'21 I'
-'-Valencia, Eriberto G. VB., 184 SCRA 561', ' ::
'.,1,1",.1
-Valenzuela, Arturo P. v8:,191 SCRA'l
IIi I:,
-Vicmar Development Corp. VB., 185 SCRA 634
-Viray, Manuel G. VB., 191'SCRA308 ' , Iri
~Vitug,RomaricoG.vB.,183.SCRA755 "" "i
-Eastern Agro Industrial Corporation VB., 188 SCRA 709 ,I'I
-Western Guaranty Corporation VB., 187 SCRA 652 . I
-'-Yakult Philippines VB., 190 SCRA 357
-Yang, Charles L. VB., 186 SCRA 287
-Zaide, Jr., Ceferino VB., 189 SCRA 531

840 SWREME COllET, REPORTS ,ANNOTATED
Court of Appeals-
-Zamora, Paulino us., 183 SCRA 279
-Zenith Insurance Oorporatlon us., 185,sbilA 398
-Zuzuarregni, Jr., Antonio de .os., 186 SCRA 733
Court ofFirst Instance of Albay-;-Gum:ob~tan'Historical and Criltursl
Association us., 18~ SCRA 256 '
Court of First Instance 'of Capia, Br. III-Ricardo Maxi';"o .os., 182
SCRA420 . '
Court of.First Instance of'Cebu, Br, VI-Jose S. Santos es., 185 SCRA
472 . .
Court of First Instance of'Nueva Vizcaya, Br. 28-Felimon Manangan
us., 189 SCRA 217 . .
Court of First Instance ofNegros Oriental, Hr. V-Juan Sala us., 184
, SCRA694 .. .'. , ..
Court of Industrial Relations-e-ftoyal Undergarment Corporation of
the Philippines us., 186 SCRA 278
Court of Tax Appeals-
--Commissioner of Customs .os., 185 SCRA 277; 188 SCRA 61
-Commissioner ofInternal Revenue us., 185 SCRA 329
-Concrete Aggregates, Inc; us., 185 SCRA 461
-Plana, Efren 1. us., 182 SCRA 508 ' -United Housing Corporation us., 181 SCRA 285
Cruz, Carlos Dela y Venancio-e-People of the Philippines us., 189
SCRA391 . .
Cruz, Danilo De la y Ruado-People of the Philippines vs.,183 SCRA
763 . Del Monte Philippines, Inc . us. National Labor Relations Comniission
Cruz, Eduardo us, Pura Ferrer-Calleja, 188 SCRA 520
Cruz, Elfren-Domingo R. Tapay us., 186' SCRA 474
Cruz, Florentino us, Court of Appeals,191 SCRA 170
Cruz, Fortunato de la us. Crispin V. Bautista, 186 SCRA 51.7
Cruz, Januario y Hurado-e-People of the Philippines us., 190 SCRA
328
Cruz, Juan de la y Gonzales-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA
416
Cruz, Quirico dela us. Court of Appeals,187 SeRA 165
Cruz, Rafael de la--Central Bank ofthe Philippines .os., 191 SCRA 346
Cruz, Rolando-People ofthe Philippines us., 191 SCRA 377
Cruz, Romeo De la y Meda-e-People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA
160
Cruz, Bcsanro C. us. Augusto E. Villarin, 181 SCRA 53
Cruz, Jr., Ruben y Delamida-e-People of the Philippines es., 191 SCRA
127
Cuevas, Serafin R-Mariano T. Nasser .os., 188 SCRA 812
Custodio, Victor A. es, Minister of Labor and Employment, 187 SCRA
535
...;~ l"i1
"i
TABLE OF CASES 841
D.P. Lub Oil Marketing Center, Inc. us. Raul Nicolas,191 SCRA 423
Dacuycuy, Auxencio C.-Peter Nierras us., 181 SCRA 1 '
Daez, Lope O. us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 61
Dagupan Bus Company, Inc. us. National Labor Relations Cominission
191 SCRA 328 '. . '
Dalinog, Berly-s-People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 88'
Dalion, Segundo us. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 872
Dalusong, Pedro .os. Lorenzo R Mosqueda, 187 SCRA 661
Damaso, Victoriano-People of the Philippines es., 190 SCRA 595
Dames, II, Sancho-Ariel Non us., 185 SCRA 523
Daquigan, Angel A.-Romualdo F. Dumuk us., 188 SCRA 444
Datiles and Company us, Melquiades S. Sucaldito, 186 SCRA 704
David, Deocrecio us, Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 675 '
Dawandawan, Gabriel-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA 264
, ,
Day, Victorino E. us. RTC ofZamboanga City, Br. XIII, 191 SCRA 610
ii
Dayot, Lucia Vda. de-Heirs of Severo Legaspi, Sr. vs.,188 SCRA 508
I
, :1
Dayot, Rolando y Garcia-People of the Philippines es., 187 SCRA 637
Dayrit, Abelardo M.- .
,:,1i'
-Meridian Assurance Corporation es., 184 SCRA 20 !II
Degamo, Cesario-People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 6
Dekingco', Rudy-People ofthe Philippines us., 189 SCRA 512
Del Monte Corporation us. Court of Appeals,181 SCRA 410
188 SCRA 370 '
Delgado, Gualberto P.-People of the Philippines us., 189 SCRA 715
Delgado, Rosendo-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 343
Delgado Shipping Agency--Commissioner of Customs us, 188 SCRA
579 '
Deloso, Amor D. us, Manuel C. Domingo, 191 SCRA 545
Demamay, Flavio us. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 608
Demecillo, Elpidio-People of the Philippines us., 186 SCRA 161
Department of Education, Culture and Sports us. Court of Appeals
183 SCRA 555 '
Deputy Executive Secretary-
-Paper Industries Corporation of the Philippines us, 184 SCRA
606 . '
-Ysmael, Jr., Felipe us., 190 SCRA 673
Devaras, Elpidia-Philippine National Bank, The us., 183 SCRA 121
Development Bank of the Philippines-
us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 190 SCRA 653
us. National Labor Relations Commission, 183 SCRA 328' 186
SCRA841 ' ,
-Penticostes, Sr., Prudencio S. us., 187 SCRA 424
Diaz, Anselma us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 182 SCRA 427
842 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Diaz, Edward vs. Ricardo C. Nora, 1,90 SCRA 404
Diaz, Reolandi vs. People of the Philippines, 191. E;CR<\ 86
Dimaporo, Mohamed Ali B. vs. Commission on Elections, 186 SCRA
,. 769 .. . ." . Ebarle, Bienvenido A.-Juanito Ramos V8., 182 SCRA 245.
Dinglasa, Dionisio-People ofthe Philippines us., 184 SCRA'43
Dinglasan, 'Ma,rianovs. Maria Alicia M. Austria, 191 SCRA 873
Dinola, Emeterio-People of.thePhilippines us., 183 SCRA493
Dios, E,duardo.de yExconde--People ofthe Philippines vs., 187 SCRA
.. 228, .". .'. . . ,
Dipatuan, Dimangadap us. Commission on Elections, 185 SCRA 86
Director of Lands- . ... . Embasay Farms,.lnc. vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 492
-Agne, MarcelioC. vs., 181 SCRA 793
~s: Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 450
Director ofPatente-Adrian S. De la Paz vs., 187 SCRA 419
:Qi,scaya, Jaime. D.-Julian Sy us., 181 SCRA 378 . '.
Ditan, Andres E. vs. Philippine Overseas Employment Administra-
., tion Administrator, 191 SCRA 823
Dizon, -Ir., Emesto S. vs. National Labor Relations Commieeion, 181
SCRA472 . . . '.
Dolores, Antonio-People ofthe Philippines us, 188 SCRA 660
Dolorfino, Rolando vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 880.
Domingo,Bonifacio-People of the Philippines vs., 184 SCRA 409
Domingo, Eufemio C.-Maximo Gabriel cs., 189 SCRA 672
Domingo, Manuel C.-Amor D. Deloso vs., 191 SCRA 545
Dominguez, Carlosvs. Elsie Ldgot-Telan, 186 SCRA109
Dongco, Apolinarvs. The lntermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA
541 . . .
Doronio, Corazon Q.-Godofreda B. Sumalinog vs., 184 SCRA 187
Drilon, Franklin M.-
-Kimberly Independent Labor Union For Solidarity, Activism
and Nationalism-Organized Labor Association In Line Indus-
.tries and Agriculture us., 185 SCRA 190
-Meycauayan College us, 185 SCRA 50
-T.H. Valderama & Sons, In~: us. 181 SCRA 308
Dulay, Ceferino E.-
-Felisa D. Carandang vs., 188 SCRA 792
-Heirs of Pedro Pinote vs., 187 SCRA12
Dulos, Juan B. vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 413
Dumpe, Danilo y Jimenez-People of the Philippines us. 183 SCRA
547 ' .. '
Dumuk, Romualdo F. vs. Angel A. Daquigan, 188 SCRA 444
E. Conrad vs. Felipe b. Navarro,185 SCRA 230
EDCA Publishing & Distributing Corp. vs. Leonor Santos, 189 SCRA
614
TABLE OF CASES 843
Eastern Assurance & Surety Corporation vs. Secretary of Labor, 181
SCRAllO
Eastern Shipping Lines, Inc-us, Court ofAppeals, 190 SCRA 512
Echaus, Luisavs. Court ofAppeals, 187 SCRA 672 • '
Eclarinal, Marcelino-People of the Philippines V8., 182 SCRA 106
Eden, Ma. Eppievs. Ministry of Labor, 182 SCRA 840
Eduarte, Florentino-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 291
Eduarte, Henedino P.-People of the'Philippines ps., 182 SCRA 750
Elbinias, Jesus M.-Alemar's Sibal &,Sons, Inc. vs., 186 SCRA 94
Employees' Compensation Commission-
-Abejuro, Anunciacion vs., 190 SCRA 435
-Belarmino, Manuel vs., 185 SCRA 304
-Homido, Fortunata Vda. de vs., 187 SCRA 581
-Lazo, Salvador us., 186 SCRA 569
-Manuzon,.Consorcia F. vs., 186 SCRA 738
-Meris, Mauro G. vs., 189 SCRA 12
-Narazo, Amalia vs., 181 SCRA 874
-Vista!, Arcadia us., 187 SCRA 623
Esparcia, Gervacio-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA 282
Espejo, Nestor y Espino-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 627
Espiritu, Benito y Israel-People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA 503
Espiritu, Deogracias vs. Alfredo S. Lim, 187 SCRA 311
Esplana,Dorotea-Isaac Magistrado vs., 185 SCRA 104
Esquig, Melanio N. vs. Civil Service Commission, 188 SCRA 166
Estacio, Jesus y Estrella vs. Sandiganbayan, 183 SCRA 12
Estacion, Jr., Jose M.-Qffice of the Court Administrator us., 181
SCRA33
Estella, Pedro M. vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA .732
Estenzo, Numeriano G.-Cornelio Ruiz vS.,.186 SCRA 8
Estepa, Leonardo N. vs. Sandiganbayan, 182 SCRA 269
Estevan, Edgardo y Eugenio-People of the Philippines V8., 186 SCRA
34
Estoesta, Maria Luisa vs. Court ofAppeals,191 SCRA 303
Estrada, Arturo A. vs. Romulo E. Abasolo, 189 SCRA 58
Estrella, Santiago G.-Jesus S. Legaspi vs., 189 SCRA 58
Eswan, Carlito-People of the Philippines V8., 186 SCRA114
'Etemit Employees and Workers Union us, Jesus De Veyra, 189 SCRA
752
Eugenio, Sr., Tomas ee. Alejandro M. Velez, 185 SCRA 425
Executive Secretary-Rogelio Bustamante V8., 186 SCRA 109
Executive Secretary Macaraig, Jr.-Dionisio S. Ojeda, VS., 187 SCRA
797
844 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
F. David Enterprises vs. Insular Bank of Asia and America, 191 SCRA
516
Fabro, Warlito-People of the Philippines vs., 191 SCRA 386
Faderan, Ernesto A.-Vietor B. Reyes us., 186 SCRA 547
Fausto, Policarpio Y. us. Vicente Leogardo, Jr., 184 SCRA 332
Feagle Construction Corporation vs. Gavino Gayda, 186 SCRA 589
Federation of Free Workers-Lopez Sugar Corporation vs., 189 SCRA
179 ' GRF ShippingAgency, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission
Felipe, Rodante-People of the Philippines vs., 191 SCRA 176
Fernan, Thelma vs. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 546
Fernandez, Florentino L. V8. Court of Appeals, 189SCRA 780
Fernandez, Josefino-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 830
Fernandez, Melquiades-People of the Philippines vs., 183 SCRA 511
Fernandez, VicentEr-Sulpicia Jimenez vs., Hl4 SCRA 190
Ferrer-Calleja, Pura-
-Cruz, Eduardo vs., 188 SCRA 520
-Hipolito, Jr., Raymundo V8., 190 SCRA 182
-Haw at Buklod Ng Manggagawa (IBM) Local No. 56 us., 182
SCRA561
-Pagkakaisa Ng Mga Manggagawa Sa Triumph International-
Uuited Lumber and General Workers ofthe Philippines vs.,
181 SCRA119
vs. Palacol, Carmelite L., 182 SCRA 710
-Rizal Workers Uuion vs., 186 SCRA 431
Fidelity Savings and Mortgage Bank vs. Pedro D. Cenzon, 184 SCRA
141
Fiestan, Diouisio vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 751
Filamer Christian Institute vs. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 477
Filinvest Land, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 664
Filipinas Manufacturers Bank vs. The National Labor Relations
Commission, 182 SCRA 848
Filipro, Inc. vs. BIas F. Ople, 182 SCRA 1
Finman General Assurance Corporation vs. Abdulgani Salik, 188
SCRA740
Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. us, Metro Port Service, Ine., 182 SCRA
455
Flores, Dante y Ponce-People of the Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 366
Flores, Ernesto-People of the Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 303
Flores; Herminio-Omar K AI-Esayi and Company, Ltd. cs., 183
SCRA458
Flores, Roque vs. Commission on Elections, 184 SCRA 484
Floreza, Reynoso B.-
V8. Civil Service Commission, 182 SCRA 692
vs. Ongpin, Jaime,182 SCRA 692
Foodmine, Incorporated vs. National Labor Relations Commission,
TABLE OF CASES 845
188SCRA 748
Ford, Maria G. vs. Court of Appeals 186 SCRA 21
Fran"!sco, Jesus-People ofthe philippines V8.; 182 SeRA 305
FranCISCO: ~on vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 181 SCRA 731
Franco, Vll"gnua vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 190 SCRA 373
Fulgado, Ruparto vs. Court of Appeals; 182 SCRA ill'
190 SCRA418 '. "
Gil, E;~6sto y Esplanada-::-People of the Philippines us., 186 SCRA
Gabriel, Maximo us: Eufemio C. Domingo, 189 SCRA 672
Gac~, Fr~ vs..Philippine Air Lines, Inc., 183 SCRA 189
Gaeias, VIcente-NlCanor Acierlo vs., 190 SCM 666
Gallardo, Gil ,C. vs. Franco F. Rimando, 187 SCRA 453
Ganzon, Ca:lito M. V8. Eliodoro B. Guinto; 189 SCRA 57
Gapultos, Filomeno-Prtidential Bank V8., 181 SCRA 159
Gapusan-Chua, Ligaya vs. Court of Appeals 183 SCRA 160
Garc!a, Jr., Antonio us, Court of Appeals, 19i SCRA 493
Garcia, Dolores V8. .Teodoro C. Benigno, 186 SCRA Hi8
Garc!a, Enrique T. vs. The Board ofInvestmentS,191 SCRA 288
Garc~a, Marcelo G.-Vicente C. Buenavista, jr., us., 187 SCRA 598
Garc~a, Paula V8. Andres Gonzales, 183 SCRA 72
Garcia, Pedro T.-Raul H. Sesbreno vs., 181 SCRA 879
Garcia, Ramon-8alvador H. Laurel vs., 187 SCRA 797
Garciil~olando y Nievez-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA
Garrison, John L. us, Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 525
Garrucho, Peter D.-~amon P. Binamira vs., 188 SCRA 154
Gaspar, Augusto L. vs. Court ofAppeals 190 SCRA 758
Gaw, Jo~quin S. V8. Court of Appeals, Hi!SCRA77
Gaw Ching-Angelina J. Malabanan vs., 181 SCRA 84
Gayda, Gavino-Feagle Construction Corporation us., 186 SCRA 589
Germ~~:anagement & Services, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, Ui7 SCRA
Gersalino, Melitona vs. Workmen's Compensation Commission 187
SCRAI '
Gevero, Bienveuido vs. Intermediate Appell~te Court, 189 SCRA 201
GIang, Alunan C. vs. Raul S. Manglapus 190 SCRA 280
Go, Pacifico us, Antouio Caballero 189 SeRA 5 7 ' '
Go, Vic.tOria C. vs. Intermediate A~pellate Court, 183 SCRA 82
Gold CIty In~!?,ated Port Services, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations
COl1lIIllSSlOn, 189 SCRA 811
Gonong: A:'seuio M.-Metropolitan Traffic Command West Traffic
District us., 187 SCRA 432
846 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Gonzales, Andres-Paula Garcia tis., 183 SCRA 72
Gonzales, Beatriz F. vs. Zoilo'Aguinaldo, 190 SCRA 112
Gonzales, Ernesto y Pagkel-People ofthe Philippines vs., 189 SCRA
343
Gonzales, Fausta-e-People ofthe Philippines vs., 183 SCRA 309
Gonzales, Florecer vs. Presiding Judge of RTC of Bohol,Br. I, 186
SCRA101
Gonzales, Jr., Ignacio yOliveros-e-People ofthe Philippines vs., 182
SCRA393 '.,
Gonzales,' Jose Antonio U.'-Ernesto Mandant vs., 186 SCRAI08
Gonzales, Neptali A. vs. Catalino Macaraig, Jr., 191 SCRA 452
Gonzales, Ramon A.~
-Angel L. Bautista us., 182'SCRA 151
vs. Land Bank of the Philippines, 183 SCRA 520
Gonzales, Jr., Suzano F. vs. Heherson T. Alvarez, 182 SCRA 15
Gonzales, Rodolfo P. us, Regina Ordonez-Benitez, 181 SCRA 401 .
Government Service Insurance System-
-Kirit, Sr., Apolinario vs., 187 SCRA 224
-Loyola, Angelo L. vs., 189 SCRA 82
-Maddumba, Domingo B. vs., 182 SCRA 281
vs. Sandiganbayan, 191 SCRA 655
Granger Associates vs. Microwave Systems, Inc., 189 SCRA 631
Great Pacific Life Assurance Corporation- . Heirs of Deceased Cosme Rebe vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 647
vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 187 SCRA 694; 188
SCRA139
us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 501
Gregorio, Felipa vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 477
Guar~~::~:rises us, National Labor Rela~ons Commission, 191
Guazon, Eddie vs. Renato De Villa, 181 SCRA 623
GUba~~;:~~~ D. vs. ~ational Labor Relations Commission, 187
Gudez, Eladio A. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 183 SCRA
644 . .
Guerrero, Jose L. vs. Antonio V. Arizabal, 186 SCRA 109
Gupo, Magno y Gayeta-People 'of the Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 7
Guevarra, Danilo y Capillan-People of the Philippines es., 187 SCRA
586 . Hernandez, Wenceslao vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 189 SCRA
Guevarra, William vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SCRA 477
Guia, Doroteo M. De vs. Manuel V. Romillo, Jr., 183 SCRA 480
Guia, Jose De y Sales-People of the Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 336
Guiagui, John y Koteng-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA
538
Guinhawa, Jaime-Bicol Savings & Loan ASsociation vs.,188 SCRA
642
TABLE OF CASES 847
Guinobatan Historical and Cultural Association vs. Court of First
Instance ofAlbay, 182 SCRA 256
Guinto, Eliodoro B.-
~Carlito M. Ganzon vs., 189 SCRA 57
-United States of America vs., 182 SCRA 287
Guinto, Emmanuel-People of the Philippines vs., 184 SCRA 287
Gundayao, Eligio vs. Court ofAppeals, 185 SCRA 606
Gutierrez, Basilio C. us, Leonardo N. Zulueta,187 SCRA 607
Guzman, Armando De vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 128 SCRA
184
Guzman, Jose C. De-Edwina Lema Beech vs., 187 SCRA 773 .
Guzman, Oscar de y Enriquez-e-People of the Philippines us., 188
SCRA407
Guzman, Jr., Salvador P. de-Alex G. Lee vs., 187 SCRA 276
Hacienda Benito, Inc.--Galicano Calapatia, Jr. vs., 191 SCRA 357
Heirs of Amparo de los Santos vs. Court of Appeals 186 SCRA 649
Heirs of Cabalo Kusop-Jose T. Tayoto vs., 184 SCRA 355
Heirs of Celso Amarante vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 585
Heirs of Claro L. Laureta vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 184 SCRA
157 '
Heirs of Fabio Masangya vs. Diosdado Masangya 189 SCRA 234
i.
Heirs of Filomeno Tuyac vs. Francisco Z. Consolaclon, 183 SCRA 396
Heirs of John Guilles, Sr. vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 687
Heirs of John Z. Sycip vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 262
Heirs of Juan Dacasin vs. Court ofAppeals, 187 SCRA 86
Heirs of Julio Rosas us. Oscar R. Reyes, 188 SCRA 236
Heirs of Maria De la Cruz y Gutierrez vs. Court of Appeals 182 SCRA
638 '
Heirs of Pedro Pinote vs. Ceferino E. Dulay, 187 SCRA 12
Heirs of Severo Legaspi, Sr. vs. Lucia Vda. de Dayot,188 SCRA 508
Heirs of the Late Santiago Maningo vs. Intermediate Appellate Court
183 SCRA 691 '
Hernandez, Perseverando N. vs. Gregorio G. Pineda, 182 SCRA 530
Hernandez, Romeo-c-Paopla of the Philippines vs.,182 SCRA 794
758 '
Herrera-Martinez, Maria Teresita-Robert F. Ong vs., 188 SCRA 830
Herrick, Michael Charles y Beck-People of the Philippines vs. 187
SCRA364 '
Hibionada, Romeo J.-C.T. Torres Enterprises, Inc. vs., 191 SCRA 268
Hidalgo, Rafael-Prudencio Penticostes vs., 190 SCRA 165
Hipolito, Jr., Raymundo vs. Pura Ferrer-Calleja, 190 SCRA 182
Hodges, Joe vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 281

848 SUPREME COURT REP0RrS,ANNOTATED
Holiday Inn (Phils.), Inc. vs. The Sandiganbayan, 18.6 SCRA 447· .:
Home Insurance Company vs. Court ofAppeals, 'I.84SCRA 318
Hornido, Fortunata Vda. de vs. Employees' CompensationCommis-
sion, 187 SCRA 581 .
Hospital De San -Juan De Dios.: Inc.vs. Commissioner of Interoal
Revenue, [85SCRA 273,.
House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal-Virgilio P. Robles vs.,
181SCRA 780·
Hua Bee Shirt Factory vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 186
SCRA586
Ibatan, Gerundia vs. Meneleo C. Melicor,.188SCRA598
Icamina, Pedro M.-Eulogio Occenavs., 18LSCRA 328
Ilarde, Ricardo J.-Jose C. Tayengco vs., 183 SCRA 504
Ilaw at Buklod Ng Manggagawa.(IBM) Local No. 56 vs. Pura Ferrer-
Calleja, 18.2 SCRA 561
Iligan,Feroando y Jamito-People of the Philippinesvs., 191 ·SCRA
643
Imperial Insurance, Inc. vs. Eulalio D. Rosete, 18.3SCRA 1·
Imperial Textile Mills, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 18.3SCRA58.4
In reo Amount of the Monthly Pension of Judges andJUlitices,190
SCRA315
In reo Routine Inspection at SSK Parts ·Corp., Bgy. Pule, Cabuyao,
Llll(UIla,18.1 SCRA 675
In reo Ruperto G. Martin, 18.7SCRA477
Inciong, Amado G._Edmund Yap vs., 18.6 SCRA 664
Inciong, Rogelio vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 18.5SCRA
651 . ," , ,'.
Industrial Enterprises, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 18.4 SCRA 426
Iniego.Dresencio R-MarinaPort Services, Inc. vs., 18.1 SCRA 304
Insular Bank of Asia & America, Incorporated vs. Court of Appeals,
1905CRA629
Insular Bank of Asia and America-F. David Enterprisesvs. 191
SCRA516
Intermediate Appellate Court-
-Active Wood Products, Inc. us., 18.3SCRA 671.
-Africa,Alfonsovs., 18.8. SCRA 58.6
-,--Agustin, Eulogio vs., 187 SCRA 218
-Alvarez, Laura vs., 18.5SCRA 8.
-Alvendia, Felicidad M.:vs., '1.8.1 SCRA 252
-Ambrosio, Antonio G. us., 18.1 SCRA 99
-Andamo, Natividad V. vs., 191 SCRA 195
-Bartolome, Resurreccion.vs., 18.3SCRA 102
-Benedicto;Ma: Luisa vs., 18.7 SCRA 547,
-'Brett, June Prill us., 191 SCRA 68.7
-Chavez, Raquel us., 191 SCRA 211
'!
TABLE OF CASES 849
: ~:
"
Intermediate Appellate Court-
-Ching Sni Yong, Jose vs., 191 SCRA 187
-Co Keng Klan, Manuel vs., 18.9 SCRA 112
-Consolidated Bank and Trust Corporation, The vs., 18.9SCRA
433
-Development Bank ofthe Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 653
-Diaz, Anselma vs., 18.2 SCRA 427
-Dongco, Apolinar vs., 18.7SCRA 541 .
-Francisco, Ramon es., 181 SCRA 731
-Franco, Virginia vs., 190 SCRA 373
-Gevero, Bianvenido es., 18.9 SCRA 201
-Go, Victoria C. vs., 18.3 SCRA 82
-Guzman, Armando De us., 18.4SCRA 128
-Heirs of Claro L. Laureta vs., 184 SCRA 157
_Heirs of the Late Santiago Maningo vs., 18.3 SCRA 691
-Heroandez, Wenceslao vs., 18.9SCRA 758.
-Jimenez, Tomas vs., 18.4 SCRA 367
-Lanzona, Miguel vs., 187 SCRA 33
-Linaza, Teofilo vs., 182 SCRA 8.55
-Lumibao, Nora vs., 18.9 SCRA 469
-Mangulabnan, Edna Padilla vs., 18.5 SCRA 760
-Mondragon, Socorro Vda. de vs., 18.4SCRA 348.
-Montinola, Leonardo vs., 18.7 SCRA 616
-Napilan, Consolacion vs., 18.3 SCRA 126
-National Food Authority vs., 18.4 SCRA 166
-0landay, Pacita A. vs., 18.9 SCRA 175
-Orata, Rufina vs., 18.5SCRA 148.
-Pamintuan, Filipina G. vs., 18.6 SCRA 8.3
-Pan American World Airways, Inc. vs., 186 SCRA 687
-Paredes, Simeon vs., 18.5 SCRA 134
-Parungao, Ofelia D. us., 187 SCRA 661
-Paz, Reva us., 18.4 SCRA 720
-Peneyra, Jose vs., 18.1 SCRA 244
-Philippine Banking Corporation vs., 18.7 SCRA 257
-Philippine National Bank vs., 18.3 SCRA 133; 18.7 SCRA 757;
18.9SCRA 68.0
-Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines, Inc. us., 18.9 SCRA 158.
-Quality Tobacco Corporation vs., 187 SCRA 200
-Raneses, Vicente vs., 18.7 SCRA 397 .
-Republic ofthe Philippines vs., 18.5 SCRA 572; 18.6 SCRA 88.
-Rivera, Jose vs., 18.2 SCRA 322
-Roman Catholic Bishop of Malolos, Inc. vs., 191 SCRA 411
-Salomon, Francisca vs., 185 SCRA 352
-Santos, Vicente 1. vs., 18.6 SCRA 694
'_Q""nnl.... Cl T A:>nntna ~hu m: 1 R1 ~r:RA H4

850 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
--8inuhin, Dionisio us., 190 SCRA 469
--8ongcuan, Saturnino us., 191 SCRA 28
-Tan, Felicito us., 186 SCRA 322
-Umali, Vicente S. us., 186 SCRA 680
-United Coconut Planters Bank us., 183 SCRA 368
-Universal Shipping Lines, Inc. us., 188 SCRA 170
-Vergara, Francisco us., 185 SCRA 29
International Catholic Migration Commission us. Pura Calleja, 190
SCRA130
International Corporate Bank-Radiowealth Finance Co.,Inc. us., 182
SCRA862
International Harvester Macleod, Inc. us. Mariano Medina, Jr., 183
SCRA485
International Travel Service us. Minister of Labor, 188 SCRA 456
Interpacific Transit, Inc. us. Rufo Aviles, 186 SCRA 385
Inting, Enrique B.-People of the Philippines us., 187 SCRA 788
Isip, Jr., Narciso-People ofthe Philippines us., 188 SCRA 648
Jacob, Tomasa Vda. de us. Court ofAppeals, 184 SCRA 294
Jakihaca, Jesus C. us. Lilia Aquino, 181 SCRA 67
Jalandoni, Jr., Benjamin L. us. Wilfredo Arsenal, 188 SCRA 56
Japitana, Jr., Pio-People ofthe Philippines us., 185 SCRA 682
Jariol, Jr., Antolin us. Sandiganbayan, 188 SCRA 475
Javier, Daniel-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 830
Javier, Jose M. us. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 171
Javier, Renato Mendoza y Torres-People of the Philippines us., 183
SCRA 702
Jereza, Edgar-People ofthe Philippines us., 189 SCRA 690
Jervoso, Marcelo us. People of the Philippines, 189 SCRA 523
Jimenez, Snlpicia us. Vicente Fernandez, 184 SCRA 190
Jimenez, Tomas us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 184 SCRA 367
Jocson, Enrique T. us., 183 SCRA 589
Jolipas, Benjamin-People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA 770
Jomao-as, Reynaldo y Padilla-People of the Philippines us., 184
SCRA49
Joson III, Tomas N. us. Narciso S. Nario, 187 SCRA 453
Juanga, Octavio-People of the Philippines us., 189 SCRA 226
Juezan, Jose-Natividad Villaflor us., 184 SCRA 315
Jungco, Henry y Santiago-People of the Philippines us., 186 SCRA
714
KK Shell Sekiyn Osaka Hatsubaisho us. Court ofAppeals, 188 SCRA
145
KM.K Gani, Indrapal & Co.-Commissioner of Customs, The us., 182
SCRA591
'I
TABLE OF CASES 851
Kidagan, Anthonyy Paqnito-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA
763
Kimberly Independent Labor Union For Solidarity, Activism and
Nationalism-Organized Labor Association In Line Industries
and Agricnlture us. Franklin M. DriIon, 185 SCRA 190
Kintanar, Cesar A.-Nilo Lizares us., 190 SCRA 585
Kirit, Sr., Apolinario us. Government Service Insurance System, 187
SCRA224 ,I
Knecht, Cristina De-Republic of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 142
LBC Aircargo, Inc: us. National Labor Relations Commission, 190
SCRA274
L.M. Handicraft Manufacturing Corporation us. Court of Appeals, 186
SCRA640
Labatagos, Carmen us. Sandiganbayan, 183 SCRA 415
Labrador, Rosita us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 170
Lacson, Alberto F. us. Luis R. Reyes, 182 SCRA 729
Lacuna, Danilo B.-Juan A. Baluyot cs., 189 SCRA 58
Lagman, Felicidad Abuton Vda. de us. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA
198
Lagon, Libertad-People of the Philippines us., 185 SCRA 442'
Land Bank of the Philippines-
us. Commission on Audit, 190 SCRA 154
us. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 610
-Gonzales, Ramon A. us" 183 SCRA 520
Lansang, Jr., Jose R. us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 230
Lansang, Virgilio S.-Qflice of the Court Administrator us., 186 SCRA
646
Lantion, Filomeno N. us. National Labor Relations Commission, 181 I
SCRA513
Lanzona, Miguel us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA 33
II
Lao Lim, Francisco us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 150
Laredo, Edilberto-People of the Philippines us., 185 SCRA 383
Laurel, Salvador H. us. Ramon Garcia, 187 SCRA 797
Lauron, Flora us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 215
Lausa, Reynaldo us. National Labor Relations Commission, 187 SCRA
299
Layug, Ponciano M. us. Lourdes Quisumbing, 182 SCRA 46
Lazaro, Manuel-Anita Villa us., 189 SCRA 34
Lazo, Salvador us. Employees' Compensation Commission, 186 SCRA
569 '
Lecaroz, Aristeo M.-Joventino Madrigal us., 191 scRA 20
Lecaroz Transit us. Secretary of Labor, 191 SCRA 508
Lee, Alex G. us. Salvador De Guzman, Jr., 187 SCRA 276
Legaspi, Jesus S. us. Santiago G. Estrella, 189 SCRA 58

852 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Leogardo, Jr., Vicente-Policarpio Y. Fausto vs., 184 SCRA 332
Leon, Fernando De-Rebecco E. Panlilio vs., 186 SCRA 217
Leon, Rosalio A. De-Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System
vs., 183 SCRA 217
-Philippine National Bank, 181 SCRA 583
Leon, Sylvia Lichauco de vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 345
Leopard Security and Investigation Agencyvs. -National Labor Rela-
tions Commission, 186 SCRA 756
Leoparte, Bienvenido-People ofthe Philippines vs.,187 SCRA 190
Leviste, Oscar L.-Antonio V. Arizabal vs., 186 SCRA 108
Libag, Roberto y Cabading-People of the Philippines vs., 184 SCRA
707
Ligot-Telan, Elsie-Carlos Dominguez us., 186 SCRA 109
Lim, Alfredo S.-Deogracias Espiritu vs., 187 SCRA 311
Lim, Carmen-People ofthe Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 706
Lim, Sr., Emilio E. vs. Court ofAppeals, 190 SCRA 616
Lim, Enrique vs. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 564
Lim, Felix vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 23
Linaza, Teofilo vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 182 SCRA 855
Lincoln Gerard, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 187
SCRA 701
Lingatong, Reynaldo-People of the Philippines vs., 181 SCRA 424
Lising, Tomasito B.-Blaise McCormack vs., 187 SCRA 713
Lizares, Nilo vs. Cesar A. Kintanar, 190 SCRA 585
Llantino, Gregorio vs. Co Liong Chong, 188 SCRA592
Llenado, Romeo G. vs. Lnis T. Santos, 189 SCRA 57
Llosa-Tan, Anita us, Silahis International Hotel, 181 SCRA 738
Longboan, Felixberto M. vs. Emilio L. Polig, 186 SCRA 557
Lopez Sugar Corporation vs. Federation of Free Workers, 189 SCRA
179
Lorenzo, Severo M. us, Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 260
Loveria, David y Santos-People ofthe Philippines us., 187 SCRA 47
Loyola, Angelo L. vs. _Government Service -Insurance System, 189
SCRA82
Lucas, Jovencio y Parcutela-People of the Philippines us., 181 SCRA
316
Lugto, Edgar y Velasco-People of the Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 754
Lugtu, Domingo V. vs. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 388
Lumibao, Nora vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 189 SCRA 469
LUna, Evelyn de vs. Sofronio F. Abrigo, 181 SCRA 150
Luntok, Gnillermo R.-Bantiago Aquino us., 184 SCRA 177
Lupo, Maria B. vs. Administrative Action Board, 190 SCRA 69
, 624 .
Ma-ao Sugar Central Co., Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 88
Maalat, Noli-Cosmopolitan Funeral Homes, Inc. vs., 187 SCRA 108
'iI
TABLE- OF CASES' 853
Mabubay,Edwin-People ofthe Philippines VSi, 185 _SCRA 675
Macaraig, Jr., Catalino-NeptaIi A. Gonzalesvs., 191 SCRA 452
Macasaet,Manuel R.-Fructrioso R. Capcovs., 189 SCRA,561 -
Maceda, Bonifacio Sanz-People of the Philippines vs., 188SCRA 532
Macias, II, Emilio C. vs. Commission on Elections, 182 SeRA 137
Madali, Ricarte-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA 69
Madayag,-Job B.-Ayala Corporation us., 181 SCRA 687
Madayag, Job B.-Puma SportschuhfabrikenRudolfDassler, KG.vs., !
, ,
, ,
_ 187 SCRA592 - -
Maddumba, Domingo "B. cs. 'Government Service.InsW'ance System,
182 SCRA 281 ,
Madrigal Joventino os. Aristeo M. Lecaroz, 191 SCRA20
Maersk-Tabacalera Shipping Agency (Filipinas), Inc. vs. Court of
Appeals, 187 SCRA 646 -
Magante, Telesforo us. National Labor Relations Commission, 185
SCRA21 _
Magdalena Homeowners Association, Inc.ws, Court of Appeals,184
SCRA325 .
Magistrado, Isaacvs.DoroteoEsplana, 185 SCRA 104 ..
Maglutac, Jose M. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 189
SCRA 767
Magsino, Celso L.-Mellon Bank, N.A. us., 190 SCRA 633
Malabanan,AngelinaJ.'vs. Gaw'Ching,181 SCRA84 '
Malbago, Loreto-People ofthe Philippines es., 185 SCRA 311
Malinao, Wilfredo-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA 148
Maloloy-on, Felipe-People of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA250
Mamadsual, Hadji Ali vs. Corocoy D. Meson, 1905CRA 82
Mamaril, Servillano vs. Juan Contacto, Jr., 183 SCRA 780
Manalansan, Leonardo-People of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 619
Manangan, Felimon vs. Court of First Instance of Nueva Vizcaya, Br.
28,189 SCRA 217 .
Mananquil, Mauro P. us, Crisostomo C. Villegas, 189 SCRA 335
Mandai, Marcelino C.-People ofthePhilippines vs" 188 SCRA 526
Mandaui, Ernesto us. Jose Antonio U. Gonzales, 186 SCRA 108
Mangalino, .Semien y Lumanog-People of the Philippines us., 182
SCRA329
Manglapus, Raul S.-
-Giang, Alunan C. us., 190 SCRA 280
-Melchor, Jr., Alejandro vs., 190 SCRA 280
Mangulabnan, Edna Padilla vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 185
SCRA 760 '
Mangusan, Daniel y Butete-People of the Philippinesvs., 189 SCRA
Mauila Banking Corporation'vs. Court of Appeals, 187 SeRA 138
Manila Electric Company-us. Court ofAppeals, 187 SCRA 200
 :r

854 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED TABLE OF CASES 855

us. National Labor Relations Commission, 183 SCRA 51' 186 Medalla, Simeon C. V8. Central Bank ofthe Philippines, 189 SCRA 14
SCRA 763 . , Medina, Jr., Mariano-International Harvester Macleod, Inc. us., 183
Manila International Port Terminals, Inc. us, Court of Appeals 183 SCRA485
SCRA156 ' Medina, Osmundo VS. Macario A. Asistio, Jr., 191 SCRA 218
Manila Lighter Transportation, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals 182 SCRA Medina, Sr., Ricardo V8. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 837
251 ' Medrana, Teodoro VS. Office of the President, 188 SCRA 818
Manila Port Services, Inc. us, Arthur G. Amansec, 188 SCRA 123 Medrano & Associates, Inc. V8. Roxas & Co., 181 SCRA 580
Manila Remnant Co., Inc., The vs. Court ofAppeals 191 SCRA 622 Melchor, Jr., Alejandro us, Raul S. Manglapus, 190 SCRA 280
Manila Surety & Fidelity Co., Inc. us, Court of Appeais 191 SCRA 805 Melicor, Meneleo C.-Gerundia !batan V8., 188 SCRA 598
Manlapaz, Francisco vs. Court ofAppeals, 191 SCRA 795 Marabay, Virginia vs., 181 SORA 811
Manlapaz, Rey y Mando-People oftbe Philippines us., 183 SCRA 300 Mellon Bank, N.A. V8. Celso L. Magsino, 190 SCRA 633
Manuzon, Consorcia F. us. Employees' Compensation Commission Memoracion, Salvador A.-Alunad E. Alonto, Jr. V8., 185 SCRA 73
186 SCRA 738 ' Mendiola, Reynaldo V8. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 421
Manzanilla, Celedonio us. Court ofAppeals, 183 SCRA 207 Mendoza, Francisco L. V8. Lourdes R Quisumbing, 186 SCRA 108 I
I'
I!
Manzon, Paquito-People of the Philippines us., 190 SCRA 378 Mercado, Fortunata VS. Alberto Q. Ubay, 187 SCRA 719 I

Maiiago, Gerry V.-People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA 552 Mercado, Joselito y Del Rosario-People of the Philippines V8., 190
Mapa, Jr., Fernando-Hilda Walstrom us., 181 SCRA 431 SCRA452
Marabeles, Raymundo us. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 105 Meridian Assurance Corporation V8. Abelardo M. Dayrit, 184 SCRA
Marabay, Virginia us, Meneleo C. Melicor, 181 SCRA 811 20
Marapao, Felipe-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA 243 Meris, Mauro G. V8. Employees' Compensation Commission, 189 SCRA
Marcelo, Primitivo us, Sandiganbayan, 185 SCRA 346 12 I
Mesa, Domingo de y Pantaleon-People of the Philippines us., 188 !
Marcos, D:mte y Sibayan-People of the Philippines, 185 SCRA 154
Marcos, Pio R-Republic of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 223 SCRA48
Mariano, Apollo y Ding-Ding-People of the Philippines us, 191 SCRA Metro Port Service, Inc.-Fireman's Fund Insurance CO. V8., 182
136 ' SCRA455
Marina Port Services, Inc. us. Cresencio R lniego 181 SCRA 304 Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company-
Marine Radio Communications Association ofthe Philippines, Inc. us, V8. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 367; 1§.8 SCRA 259
Rainerio O. Reyes, 191 SCRA 205 V8. Presiding Judge,RTC, Manila Br. 39,189 SCRA 820
Maritime Agencies & Services, Inc. us, Court of Appeals 187 SCRA Metropolitan Traffic Command West Traffic District us, Arsenio M.
346 ' Gonong, 187 SCRA 432 I

Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System V8. Rosalio A. De n.1

Martinez, Antonio M.-Manuel V. Bala us., 181 SCRA 459 Ii!
Martinez, Renato M.-Prudential Bank VS., 189 SCRA 612 Leon, 183 SCRA 217
Martires, Cenon VS. Court of Appeals, 188 SCM 306 Meycauayan College V8. Franklin M. Drilon, 185 SCRA 50
Marubeni Nederland B.V. VS. Ricardo P. Tensuan, 190 SCRA 105 Microwave Systems, Inc. -Granger Associates V8., 189 SCRA 631
Masangya, Diosdado-Heirs of Fabio Masangya VS., 189 SCRA 234 Migrino, Eutropio-Republic of the Philippines V8., 189 SCRA 289
Maspil, Jr., Moises y Wayway-People of the Philippines VS. 188 Militante, Francis J.-8alem Alex Palo y Toyur V8., 184 SCRA 395
SCRA 751 ' Milleza, Rudy M. V8. National Labor Relations Commission, 186
Mathay, Ponciano G.A.-Francisco P. Tesorero VS., 185 SCRA 124 SCRA615
Matos-Viduya, Virginia y Galpa-People of the Philippines VS. 189 Minister of Labor-
SCRA403 ' -Eden, Ma. Eppie vs., 182 SCRA 840
Maximo, Ricardo VS. Court of First Instance of Capiz Br. III 182 -International Travel Service vs., 188 SCRA 456
SCM 420 ' , -Nueva Ecija I Electric Cooperative, Inc. us., 184 SCRA 25
McCormack, Lourdes VS. Jose G. Montemayor, 187 SCRA 713 Minister of Labor and Employment-
McElroy, Hal V8. Ignacio M. Capulong, 185 SCRA 504 -Brokenshire Memorial Hospital, Inc. V8., 182 SCRA 5
Medado, Sergio V8. Court of Anneals. 185 SCRA 80 . -Custodio, Victor A. V8., 187 SCRA 535
856 SUPREME COURT' REPORTS ANNOTATED
Minister of Labor and Employment- .
-Yuco Chemical Industries, Inc. es., 185 SCRA 727
Misolas, Arnel P. vs. Benjamin V. Panga, 181 SCRA 648
Mison, Salvador M. vs. Commission on Audit, 187 SCRA 445
Mitra; Jr., Ramon V.-Anna DominiqueM.L. Coseteng vs., 187 SCRA
377
Mitsubishi Metal Corporation-Commissioner of, Internal Revenue
vs., 184 SCRA 214
Mobil Employees Association vs. National Labor Relations Commis-
sion, 183 SCRA 737
Modeqnillo, Jose us, Augusto V. Breva, 185 SCRA 766
Molina, Rosalito-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA 597
Mondragon, Socorro Vda. de vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 184
SCRA348
Montemayor, Alberto-Philippine Long Distance Telephone Com-
pany vs., 190 SCRA 424
Montemayor, Jose G.-Lourdes McCormack us., 187 SCRA 713
Montesa, Felipe F. us. Luis T. Santos, 190 SCRA 51
Montesa, Jacob F. us. Lnis T. Santos, 190 SCRA 50
Montinola, Leonardo us, The Intermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA
616
Moral;;/;Bernito vs. NationalLabor Relations Commission, 188 SCRA
Moson, Corocoy D.-Hadji Mamadsual es. 190 SCRA 82
Mosqueda, Lorenzo R-Dalusong, Pedro us., 187 SCRA 661
-Reyes, Ruperto vs., 187 SCRA 661
Motoomull, Latchme us. Joffre Dela Paz, 187 SCRA 743
Munda; Sr., Dominador-e-Peopla of the philippines us., 189 SCRA425
Municipality ofMakati vs. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 206
Municipality of Talisay us. Hilario Ramirez, 183 SCRA 528
Munsayac,Edilberto us. Gnillermo P. Villasor, 185 SCRA 324
Murallon, Romenaldo-People of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 488
Mutuc, Amelito R. us, Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 43
Nabor, Ambrosio-People ofthe Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 615
Nabunat, Sergio y Asag-People ofthe Philippines us., 182 SCRA 52
Napilan, Consolacion us. Intermediate Appellate Court; 183 SCRA
126
Narazo, Amalia us. Employees' Compensation Commission 181 SCRA
874 . . . '
Nario, Narciso S.-Tomas N. Joson III es., 188 SCRA 453
Nasser, Mariano T. vs. Serafin R. Cuevas, 188 SCRA 812
National Food Autbority us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 184 SCRA
166 . .
TABLE OF CASES 857
National Labor Relations Commission-
-Aboitiz Shipping Employees Association vs., 186 SCRA 825
-Andaya, Ernesto us., 188 SCRA 253
-Anscor Transport & Terminals, Inc. vs., 190 SCRA 147
-Artex Development Co., Inc. us., 187 SCRA 611
-Asian Construction and Development Corporation es., 1/37
SCRA 784
-Associated Labor Unions (ALU) vs., 189 SCRA 743
-Associated Workers Union (PTGWO) us., 188 SCRA 123
-Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation es.,
190 SCRA505
-Auxilio, Jr., Porfirio vs., 188 SCRA 263
-Banco Filipino Savings and Mortgage Bank vs., 188 SCRA 700
-Barcenas, Filomena us., 187 SCRA 498
-Beta Electric Corporation vs., 182 SCRA 384
.-Blue Manila, Inc. vs., 183 SCRA 732
-Bristol Laboratories Employees' Association vs., 187 SCRA
118
-Cagayan Capitol College vs., 189 SCRA 658
-Cando, Francisco P. vs., 189 SCRA 666
-Capule, Policarpio vs., 191 SCRA 374
-Carifio, Virgilio S. vs., 185 SCRA 177
-Carmelcraft Corporation vs., 186 SCRA 393
-Carmelo & Bauermann, Inc. os., 188 SCRA 364
-Chua, Celia B. es., 190 SCRA 558
-Chua, Johnson G. vs., 182 SCRA 353
-Commart (Phil.), Inc. vs., 189 SCRA 767
-Continental Arrastre and Stevedoring Oo., Inc. vs., 190 SCRA
811
-Dagupan Bus Company, Inc. us., 188 SCRA 328
-Del Monte Philippines, Inc. us., 188 SCRA 370
-Development Bank of the Philippines vs., 183 SCRA 328; 186
SCRA841
-Dizon, Jr., Ernesto S. us., 181 SCRA472
-Filipinas Manufacturers Bank us., 182 SCRA 848
-Foodmine, Incorporated us., 188 SCRA 748
-GRF Shipping Agency, Inc. vs., 190 SCRA 418
-Gold City Integrated Port Services, Inc. us., 189 SCRA 811
-Great Pacific Life Assurance Corporation es., 187 SCRA 694;
188 SCRA139
-Guardex Enterprises vs., 191 SCRA 487
-Gubac, Benevio D.vs, 187 SCRA 412
-Gudez, Eladio A. us., 183 SCRA 644
,-Hua Bee Shirt Factory vs., 186 SCRA 586
. -Inciong, Rogelio vs., 185 SCRA 651

858 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
National Labor Relations Commission-
-LBC Aircargo, Inc. us., 190 SCRA 274
-Lantion, Filomeno N. us., 181 SCRA 513
-Lausa, Reynaldo cs., 187 SCRA 299
-Leopard Security and Investigation Agency us., 186 SCRA 756
-Lincoln Gerard, Inc. us., 187 SCRA 701
-Magante, Telesforo us., 185 SCRA 21
-Maglutac, Jose M. us., 189 SCRA 767
-Manila Electric Company us., 183 SCRA 51; 186 SCRA 763
-Milleza, Rudy M. us., 186 SCRA 615
-Mobil Employees Association os., 183 SCRA 737
-Morales, Bernito us., 188 SCRA 295
-Ocampo, Jr., Luis de es., 186 SCRA 360 ,
-Pabalan, Jaime us., 184 SCRA 495
-Pacific Mills, Inc. us., 181 SCRA 130
-Paramount Vinyl Products Corporation us., 190 SCRA 525
-Pearl S. Buck Foundation, Inc. us., 182 SCRA 446
-Periquet, Corazon us., 186 SCRA 724
-Philippine Geothermal, Inc. us., 189 SCRA 211
-Philippine Telegraph and Telephone Corporation os., 183 SCRA
451
-Rapid Manpower Consultants, Inc. ns., 190 SCRA 747
-Razon, Jr., Enrique us., 185 SCRA 44
-Rosello, Jr., Enrique R. cs., 190 SCRA 779
-Rosario, Francisco V. Delos., 187 SCRA 777
-Rubberworld (Phils.), Inc. us., 183 SCRA 421
-Ruffy, Diosdado V. us., 182 SCRA 365
-Ruga, Alipio R. us., 181 SCRA 266
-Sajonas, Felicito os., 183 SCRA 182
-Sealand Service, Inc. us., 190 SCRA 347
-Sealanes Marine Services, Inc. us., 190 SCRA 337
-Skillword Management and Marketing Corporation 186 SCRA
465 ' Notre Dame of Greater Manila-Delia R. Sibal us., 182 SCRA 538
-Songco, Jose os., 183 SCRA 610
-St. Mary's College (Tagum, Davao) cs., 181 SCRA 62
-Superstar Secnrity Agency, Inc. us., 184 SCRA 74
-T.C. Igna Overseas Recruitment Corporation us., 183 SCRA
458
-Tacloban Sagkahan Rice and Corn Mills Co. us., 183 SCRA
425
-Tan, Jr., Jose A. os., 183 SCRA 651
-Tingson, Diosdado us., 185 SCRA 498
-Traders Royal Bank os., 189 SCRA 274
-University ofSto. Tomas us., 190 SCRA 758; 182 SCRA 371
-liST F~P.111tv TTninn m: 1 ~~ ~I:R A ..::U)(l· 100 Qf"':R.4. 'J1 J::.
'r
, I
TABLE OF CASES 859
National Labor Relations Commission-
-Universal Textile Mills, Inc. us., 184 SCRA 273
-Vera, Diosdado De os., 191 SCRA 632
-YBL (Your Bus Line) es., 190 SCRA 160
National Power Corporation-
us, Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 169
us, Presiding Judge, RTC, Br. XXV,190 SCRA477
us, Province of Albay, 186 SCRA 198
National Telecommunications Commission-
-Philippine Long Distance Telephone Co. us., 190 SCRA 717
-Radio Communications of the Philippines us. 184 SCRA 517
National Union Fire lnsurance Company ofPittsburg us, Stolt-Neilsen '"
Philippines, Inc., 184 SCRA 682
Navarro, Felipe C.-
-E. Conrad us., 185 SCRA 230
-Ortigas, Jr., Francisco us., 185 SCRA 230
Navarro, Miguel R.-Star Forwarders, Inc. us., 184 SCRA 403
Navera, Genaro us, Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 584
'Nazarene, Narciso B. os. The Station Commander of the Muntinglupa
Police Station, 187 SCRA 312
Nepomuceno, Jose V.-Presidential Commission on Good Government,
The us., 184 SCRA 449
Ng, Alejandro-Paradise Sauna us., 181 SCRA 719
Nicolas, Nicanor P.-Romeo Paylago us., 189 SCRA 727
Nicolas, Raul-D.P. Lub Oil Marketing Center, Inc. es., 191 SCRA 423
Nierras, Peter us, Auxencio C. Dacuycuy, 181 SCRA 1
Noguerras, Benjamin y Torres-People of the Philippines us., 181
SCRA19 .
Non, Ariel us, Sancho Dames, II, 185 SCRA 523
Nora, Ricardo C.-Edward Diaz es., 19'0 SCRA 404
Nordic, Asia Limited us, Roque Agton, 186 SCRA 806
Northwest Orient Airlines us, Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 440
Nuestro, Edgardo D.-Rina V. Chua us., 190 SCRA 424
Nueva Ecija I Electric Cooperative, Inc. os., Minister of Labor, 184
SCRA25
Obando, Teofilo-People of the Philippines es., 182 SCRA 95
Oblena, Fortunato D.-Isabelo J. Astraquillo os., 190 SCRA 280
Ocampo, Jr., Luis De vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 186
SCRA360
Ocaya, Vicky A os. Alexander Aguirre, 187 SCRA 311
Occena, Rulogio us, Pedro M. Icamina, 181 SCRA 328
Odin Security Agency us. Dionisio C. De la Cerna, 182 SCRA 472
Office ofthe Court Administrator us, Jose M., Estacion, Jr., 181 SCRA

860 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
33
vs. Lansang, Virgilio S., 186 SCRA 646
vs. Racadag, Pablo R., 187 SCRA 510
Office ofthe President-Teodoro Medrana vs., 188 SCRA 818
Ojeda, Dionisio S. vs. Executive Secretary Macaraig, Jr., 187 SCRA
797
Olaes, Albert y Amoroso-People of the Philippines vs.,188 SCRA 91
Olanday, Pacita A vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 189 SCRA 175
Olib, Oscar T. vs. Edelwina C. Pastoral, 189 SCRA 692
Olivares, Romeo-People of the Philippines es., 186 SCRA 536
Omar K Al-Esayi and Company, Ltd. vs. Herminio Flores, 183 SCRA
458
Ong, Robert F. vs. Maria Teresita Herrera-Martinez, 188. SCRA 830
Ong, Vicente S.-Pacific Products, Inc. vs., 181 SCRA 536
Ongpin, Jaime B.-Francisco 1. Chavez vs., 186 SCRA 331
Ongpin, Jaime-Reynoso B.Floreza vs., 182 SCRA 692
Ople, BIas F.-
-Filipro, Inc. vs., 182 SCRA 1
-Pakistan International Airlines Corporation vs., 190 SCRA 90
-Velasco, Alfredo vs., 191 SCRA 636
Orata, Rufina vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 185 SCRA 148
Orbos, Oscar M.-
vs. Bungubung, Leopoldo F., 191 SCRA563
vs. Civil Service Commission, 189 SCRA 459
Orcino, Zenaida vs. Civil Service Commission, 190 SCRA 815
Ordonez, Gaudencio vs.Court ofAppeals, 188 SCRA 109
Ordonez-Benitez, Regina-Rodolfo P. Gonzales vs., 181 SCRA 401
Orita, Ceilito-People ofthe Philippines vs., 184 SCRA 105
Ortega, Cecilio vs. Dominador Agripa Tan, 181 ,sCRA 350
Ortigas, Jr., Francisco'vs: Felipe C. Navarro, 185SCRA 230
Ortiz, Rafael y Aqnine;--cPeople of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 239
Ortiz, RodolfoA-Ely Chan Sa Velasco vs., 184 SCRA303
Ortiz, Romeo y Ballares-People of the Philippines vs., 191 SCRA 836
Ouano, Paterno J. vs. Court ofAppeals, 188 SCRA 799
Pabalan, Jaime vs. National Labor Relations Commission,184 SCRA
495
Pacete, Elias B. vs. Acting Chairman of the Commission on Audit, 185
SCRA1 ' Paterno, JacobaT. vs. Beatriz Paterno, 183 SCRA 630 '
Pacia, Romeo y Geron-People ofthe Philippines vs., 186 SCRA 529
Pacific Mills, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 181
SCRA130
Pacific Products, Inc. vs. Vicente S. Ong, 181 SCRA 536
Pacubas, Cipriano B. vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA268
Padolina, Manuel S.-A.N. Bolinao, Jr. vs.,186 SCRA 368
,r
I
,
TABLE OF CASES 861
i
i'"
Padrones, Alex-People of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 496 ;il
Pagasian, Oscar Paima vs. Cesar P. Azura, 184 S9,RA 39.1. , . ,'I
Pagkakaisa ng mga Manggagawa sa Triumph InternatIonal-Umted ,I
Lumber and General Workers of the Philippines vs. Pura Fer- "
rer-Calleja, 181 SCRA 119 '
Pagtalunan, Celso us. Roque A. Tamayo, 183 SCRA 252 .
Pakistan International Airlines Corporation vs. BIas F. Ople, 190 I
SCRA90 "
Palacol, Carmelito L. vs. Pure Ferrer-Calleja, 182 SCRA 710 '
Palino, Lito y Mercado-People of the Philippines vs.,,183' SCRA 680
Palo, Salem Alexy Toyur us. Francis J. Militante, 184 SCRA 395 '
Pamintuan, Filipina G. vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 186 SCRA
83
Pan American World AIrways, Inc. vs. Intermediate Appellate'Court,
186 SCRA687
Pan Malayan Insurance Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA
'54
Panga, Benjamin V.-Arnel P. Misolas vs., 181 SCRA 648
Pangilinan, Bienvenida vs. Fidel Ramos, 181,.SCRA 359
Panlilio, Rebecco E. es. Fernando De Leon, 186 SCRA 217
Pantig, Baltazar vs. Venancio Baltazar, 191 SCRA830.
Pantranco South Express, Inc. es. Board of Transpdrtation, 191 SCRA
,581
Paper Industries Corporation of the Philippines vs. Deputy Executive
Secretary, 184 SCRA 606 '
Paradise Sauna vs. Alejandro Ng, 181 SCRA 719
Paramount Vinyl Products Corporation vs. National Labor Relations
Commission, 190 SCRA 525
Paras', Edgardo L.-Bonifacio Bonamy vs., '181 SCRA 252
Parcon, Manuel P. vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 284
Paredes, Simeon vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 185 SCRA 134
Pareja, Carollo-People ofthePhilippines es., 189 SCRA 143
Paringit, Dominador-People of the Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 478
Parungao, Ofelia D. vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA 661
Pasco, Virgilio y Santos-c-People ofthe Philippines vs., 181 SCRA 233
Pascua, Aurora vs. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 262
Pastoral, Edelwina C.-oscar T. Olib vs., 188 SCRA 692
Patagoc, Vivencio B. vs. Civil Service Commission, 185 SCRA411
Patriarca, Juana-Jose Agravante vs., 183 SCRA 113
Paylago, Romeo vs. Nicanor P. Nicolas, 189 SCRA727 ,
Paynmo, Virgilio y Paguna-People of the Philippines vs., 187 SCRA
64
Paz, Adrian S. Dela us. Director of Patents, 187 SCRA 419
Paz. Bienvenido us. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 26 '

862 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Paz, Joffre Dela-Latchme Motoomull vs., 187 SCRA 743
Pearl S. Buck Foundation, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commis-
sion, 182 SCRA 446
Pelaez, Angel A vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 97
Pendon, Erie vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRk429
Peneyra, Jose vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 181 SCRA 244
Penticostes, Sr., Prudencio S. vs. Development Baok of the Philip-
pines, 187 SCRA 424
Penticostes, Prudencio S. vs. Rafael Hidalgo, 190 SCRA 165
Perla, Teodoro-Aleja Sibayan Vda. de Pineda vs., 187 SCRA 22
People of the Philippines-
-Aballe, Peter Paul y Mendoza ns., 183 SCRA 196
vs. Abaya, Ramon, 185 SCRA 419
vs. Ablao, Mario, 183 SCRA 658
vs. Acosta, Jesus, 187 SCRA 39
vs. Adap, Jonathan V., 189 SCRA 413
vs. Agan, Alfredo, 181 SCRA 856
vs. Agapinay, Romeo, 186 SCRA 812
vs. Albarillo, Wilfredo, 188 SCRA 113
vs. Alburo, Ronilo, 184 SCRA 655
vs. Aldeguer, Vicente, 184 SCRA 1
vs. Alegria, Dante y Arana, 190 SCRA 122
vs. Alfonso, Arseuio y Cawading, 186 SCRA 576
vs. Alvero, Donato, 187 SCRA 576
us, Ampo-an, Carlos, 187 SCRA 173
us, Anciano, Alvino,189 SCRA 519
-Andaya, Nathaniel vs., 186 SCRA 410
vs. Aquino, Juanito Q., 186 SCRA 851
vs. Aquino, Paulino, 186 SCRA 208
vs. Arceo, Angelo y Mali, 187 SCRA 265
us, Arengo, Felicisimo, 181 SCRA 344
vs. Arsenio, Alberto y De la Cruz, 184 SCRA 205
vs. Aspili, Rodolfo, 191 SCRA 530
us. Bacani, Romeo y Poliosco, 181 SCRA 393
vs..Badilla, Danilo y Ones, 185 SCRA 554
vs. Baduya, Salvador y Tibus, 182 SCRA 57
vs. Bagano, Domingo y Sali-en,181 SCRA 747
vs. Balansi, Bonifacio, 187 SCRA 566
vs. Barcelona, Gideon y Dequito,191 SCRA 100
vs. Baring, Pedro, 187 SCRA 629
vs. Barro, Jr., Alberto y Relon, 188 SCRA 284
. vs. Bati, Regalado, 189 SCRA 97
vs. Baybayon, Victor, 184 SCRA 13
vs. Bernardo, Benjamin y Mariano, 186 SCRA 876
'1.':. Beaa. Melchor. 183 SeRA 533
,i
r
TABLE OF CASES 863
People of the Philippines-
vs. Biago, Melecio, 182 SCRA 411
vs. Bicog, Laureano, 187 SCRA 556
vs. Bocatcat, Sr., Tomas, 188 SCRA 175
vs. Borja, Enemecio L., 120 SCRA 191
us, Borja, Lambeito y Martinez, 182 SCRA 581
vs. Buenaflor, Jaime y Arcilla, 181 SCRA 225
vs. Bueza, Antonio, 188 SCRA 683
vs. Bugaoan, Crisostomo y Ignacio, 183 SCRA 62
vs:Bustarde, Mario y Pama, 182 SCRA 554
vs. Cabale, Demetrio, 185 SCRA 140 .
vs. Cagalingan, Alfredo y ROmina, 188 SCRA 313
vs. Caldito, Rolando, 182 SCRA 66
vs. Calo, Jr., Tranquilino, 186 SCRA 620
vs. Camarao, Robert y Laoyan, 188 SCRA 671
vs. Camasis, Romeo, 189 SCRA 649
vs. Cantre, Exequiel y Bon, 186 SCRA 76
vs. Cantuba, Pio, 183 SCRA 289
vs. Capilitan, Gorgonio, 182 SCRA 313
vs. Carmina, Valerio, 185 SCRA 59
vs. Carpio, Pedro, 191 SCRA 108
-{)arredo, Elias vs., 183 SCRA 273
vs. Castaiieda, Mariano, 187 SCRA 148 ',I";
vs. Castiller, Adelina y Castro, 188 SCRA 376 ,
,
vs. Cayaan, Raffy, 183 SCRA 445 I
vs. Cempron, Alfredo, 187 SCRA 248 i
vs. Cenda, Arnulfo y Reyes, 190 SCRA 538 1
us, Cina, Ernesto y Gaspar, 190 SCRA 199 ~
vs. Ciobal, Bonifacio y Pabrua, 184 SCRA 464 ,I
vs. Clores, Norberto y Coral, 184 SCRA 638 ,I
vs. Consuelo, Honorio y Portugal, 184 SCRA 402 Ii
vs. Corrales, Romeo A., 182SgRA t39
vs. Cruz, Carlos Dela y Venancio, 189 SCRA 391
vs. Cruz, Danilo De la y Ruado, 183 SCRA 763
vs. Cruz, Januario y Hurado, 190 SCRA 3'28
vs. Cruz, .Juan de la y Gonzales, 184 SCRA 416
vs. Cruz, Rolando, 19\SCRA 377
vs. Cruz, Romeo De la y Meda, 191 SCRA 160
vs. Cruz, Jr., Ruben y Delamida, 191 SCRA 127
us, Dalinog, Berly, 183 SCRA 88
vs. Damaso, Victoriano, 190 SCRA 595
us, Dawandawan, Gabriel, 184 SCRA 264
vs. Dayot, Rolando y Garcia, 187 SCRA 637
vs. Degamo, Cesario, 183 SCRA 6
us, Dekingco, Rudy, 189 SCRA 512
864 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
People of the Philippines-
vs. Delgado, Gualberto P., 189 SCRA 715
vs. Delgado; Rosendo, 182 SCRA343 .
us. Demecillo, Elpidio;186'SCRA161
-Diaz, Reolandi vs., 191 SCRA 86.
vs. Dinglasa, Dionisio, 184 SCRA 43
us, Dinola, Emeterio, 183 SCRA 493
us. Dios, Eduardo de y Exconde, 187 SCRA 228
vs. Dolores, Antonio 188 SCRA 660
»s. Domingo, Bonifacio, 184 SCRA 409
es, Dumpe, Danilo y Jimenez; 183 SCRA 547
vs. Eclarinal, Marcelino, 182 SCRA 106
vs. Eduarte, Florentino; 187 SCRA 291
vs. Eduarte, Henedino P., 182 SCRA 750
vs. Esparcia; Gervacio, 187 SCRA282
vs. Espejo, Nestor y Espino, 186 SCRA 627
vs. Espiritu, Benito y Israel, 191 SCRA 503
vs. Estevan, Edgardo y Eugenio, 186 SCRA 34.
vs. Eswan, Carlito, 186 SCRA 174
vs. Fabro, Warlito, 191 SCRA 386
us. Felipe, Rodante, 191 SCRA 176
vs. Fernandez, Josefino, 186 SCRA 830
us, Fernandez, Melquiades, 1838CRA 511
vs. Flores, Dante yPonce, 185 SCRA 366
vs. Flores, Ernesto, 186 SCRA 303 .
vs. Francisco, Jesus, 182 SCRA 305.. . :
us. Ga, Ernesto y Esplanade, 186SCRA 790 .
vs. Garcia, Rolando y Nievez, 187 SCRA 518 .
us, Gonzales, Ernesto y Pagkel, 189 SCRA 343
vs. Gonzales, Fausta, 183 SCRA 309
vs. Gonzales,Jr., Ignacio y Oliveros, 182 SCRA 393
vs.. Guevarra, Danilo y Capillan, 187 SCRA 586
vs. Guia, Jose De y Sales, 185 SCRA 336
vs. Gniagui,John y Koteng, 184 SCRA 538
us, Guinto, Emmanuel, 184 SCRA 287
vs. Gupo, Magno y Gayeta, 190 SCRA 7
vs. Guzman, Oscar de y Enriquez, 188 SCRA 407
vs. Hernandez, Romeo, 182 SCRA 794
vs. Herrick, Michael Charles y Beck, 187 SCRA 364
vs. lligan, Fernando y Jamito, 191 SCRA 643
us; Inting, Enrique B·., 187 SCRA 788
vs. Isip, Jr., Narciso, 188SCRA 648
vs. Japitana, Jr., Pio, 185 SCRA 682
vs. Javier, Daniel, 182 SCRA830
vs. Javier, Renato Mendoza y Torres, 183 SCRA 702
TABLE OF CASES 865
People of the Philippines-
vs. J ereza, Edgar, 189 SCRA 690
-Jervoso Marcelo us., 189 SCRA 523
vs. Jolipa~, Benjamin, 191 SCRA 770 .
vs. Jomao-as, Reynaldo y Padilla, 184 SCRA 49
vs. Juanga, Octavio, ~89 SCRA 226
vs. Jungco, Henry y Santiago, 186 SCRA 714
us. Kidagan, Anthony y Paquito, 188 SCRA 763
vs. Lagon, Libertad, 185 SCRA 442
vs. Laredo, Edilberto, 185 SCRA 383 .
vs. Leoparte, Bienvenido, 187 SCRA 190
vs. Libag, Roberto y Cabading, 184 SCRA 707
vs. Lim, Carmen, 190 SCRA 706
vs. Lingatong, Reynaldo, 181 SCRA 424
vs. Loveria, David y Santos, 187 SCRA 47
vs. Lucas, Jovencio y Parentela, 181 SCRA 316
vs. Lugto, Edgar y Velasco, 190 SCRA 754
us, Mabubay, Edwin, 185 SCRA 675
vs. Maceda, Bonifacio Sanz, 188 SCRA 532
r~.
us. Madali, Ricarte, 188 SCRA 69
vs. Malbago, Loreto, 185 SCRA 311
us. Malinao, Wilfredo, 184 SCRA 148 .
vs. Maloloy-on, Felipe, 189 SCRA 250
vs. Manalansan, Leonardo, 189 SCRA 619
vs. Mandal,MarcelinoC., 188SCRA526 i
vs. Mangalino, Semion y Lumanog, 182 SCRA 329
vs. Mangusan, Daniel y Butete, 189 SCRA 624
vs. Manlapaz, Rey y Mando, 183 SCRA 300
vs. Manzon, Paquito, 190 SCRA 378
vs. Maiiago, GerryV., 191 SCRA 552
vs. Marapao, Felipe, 188 SCRA 243
vs. Marcos, Dante y Sibayan, 185 SCRA 154
vs. Mariano, Apollo y Ding-Ding, 191 SCRA 136 .
vs. Maspil, Jr., Moises y Wayway, 188 SCRA 751
vs. Matos-Viduya, Virginia y Galpa, 189 SCRA 403 .
vs. Mercado, Joselito y Del Rosario, 190 SCRA 452
vs. Mesa, Domingo de y Pantaleon, 188 SCRA 48
vs. Molina, Rosalito, 184 SCRA 597
us. Monda, Sr., Dominador, 189 SCRA 425
vs. Murallon, Romenaldo, 189 SCRA 488
us. Nabor, Ambrosio, 185 SCRA 615
vs. Nabunat, Sergio y Asag, 182 SCRA 52
us, Noguerras, Benjamin y Torres, 181 SCRA 19
vs. Obando, Teofilo, 182 SCRA 95
vs. Olaes, Albert y Amoroso, 188 SCRA 91 .

866 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
People of the Philippines-
us, Olivares, Romeo, 186 SCRA 536
os. Orita, Ceilito, 184 SCRA 105
os. Ortiz, Rafael y Aquino, 189 SCRA 239
us. Ortiz, Romeo y Ballares, 191 SCRA 836
vs. Pacia, Romeo y Geron, 186 SCR{\. 529
vs. Padrones, Alex, 189 SCRA 496 .
vs. Palino, Lito y Mercado, 183 SCRA 680
os. Pareja, Camilo, 189 SCRA 143
vs. Paringit, Dominador, 189 SCRA 478
vs. Pesco, Virgilio y Santos, 181 SCRA 233
vs. Payumo, Virgilio y Baguna, 187 SCRA 64
-Perez, Khalyxto us., 190 SCRA 306
us. Pilar, Floro del, 188 SCRA 37
-c-Pit-og, Erkey vs., 190 SCRA 386
us. Quintos, Franklin, 186 SCRA 14
vs. Quiiiones, Adolfo, 183 SCRA 747
vs. Rabang, Eduardo y Castro, 187 SCRA 682
vs. Rafanan, Fernando, 182 SCRA 811
vs. Rama, Lydia y Tamod, 182 SCRA 687
vs. Ramos, Rosalinda y David, 186 SCRA 184
vs. Raquipo, Felix y Tolentino, 188 SCRA 571
vs. Rebullar, Ramon y Pascual, 188 SCRA 838
vs. Repuela, Jesus, 183 SCRA 244
vs. Riego, Domer y Quiozon, 189 SCRA 445
-Rivera, Jr., Marcelino G. us., 189 SCRA 331
os. Rizo, Rodolfo y Rabino, 189 SCRA 265
vs. Ronquillo, Ruby, 184 SCRA 236
vs. Rosell, Reynaldo, 181 SCRA 679
vs. Sagun, Jr., Rufino, 185 SCRA 405
vs. Sahagun, Gina y Mendoza, 182 SCRA 91
vs. Salangoste, Valentin, 188 SCRA 422
vs. Saludar, Romeo y Mondigo, 188 SCRA 189
vs. Salvilla, Bienveuido, 184 SCRA 671
vs. Santos, Ernesto, 183 SCRA 25
-Santos, Lauro vs., 181 SCRA 487
vs. Sarra, Florencio, 183 SCRA 34
vs. Sazon, Gerardo, 189 SCRA 700
os. Simene, Melchor, 184 SCRA 99
vs. Sison, Daniel y Alegria, 189 SCRA 643
vs. Socorro, Leticia Sanidad De Del, 182 SCRA 359
vs. Solis, Joveuiano y Cabug, 182 SCRA 182
vs. Sorio, Mario y Balad, 190 SCRA 548
vs. Tablizo, Uriel, 182 SCRA 739
vs. Tac-an, Renato y Hipos, 182 SCRA 601
P'
i'I
TABLE OF CASES 867
People of the Philippines-
vs. Talingdan, Rolando, 191 SCRA 333
us. Talla, Wilfredo, 181 SCRA133
ue, Tamayo, Genaro, 183 SCRA 375
vs. Tan, Nestor y Jasmin, 187 SCRA 385
vs. Tangliben, Medel y Bernardino, 184 SCRA 220
vs. Tarlac, Donato V., 188 SCRA 607
vs. Tenebro, Julio, 191 SCRA 363
vs. Timbang, Edgar y Augues, 189 SCRA 279
us. Toring, Luis B., 191 SCRA 38
us. Torre, Raul Monegro, i84 SCRA 525
vs.Tripoli', Joel, 181 SCRA 279
us, Tumalad, Francisco, 188 SCRA 203
vs. Tumale, Calixto y Tanguin, 189 SCRA 1
vs. Uribe, Virgilio, 182 SCRA 624 I,
os. Valeriano, Mario Barredo, 188 SCRA 229 Ii
vs. Vargas, Jr., Jesus, 184 SCRA254 "
~
"
vs. Vera, Gaudencio, 182 SCRA 800
vs. Victor, Roger, 181 SCRA 818
vs. Viloria, Jr., Bernardo II Delimos, un SCRA777
vs. Vocente: Agayas y Toy-daan, 188 SCRA 100
vs. Yagong, Bouifacio, 181 SCRA 479 .
vs. Yap, Marcelino, 185 SCRA 222 ·1
vs. Yeban, Ricardo, 190 SCRA 409 'I
vs. Yutuc, Estanislao y Tellis, 188 SCRA 1
People's Homesite & Housing Corporation-'--Giogenes O. Rubio vs.,
187 SCRA656
Perez, Khalyxto vs. People of the Philippines, 190 SCRA 306 ,.
Periquet, Corazon vs. N ational Labor Relations Commission, ··186 1,
SCRA724 "
Perla Compania De Seguros, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 741
.Phil-Dumez Construction Corporation vs. Court ofAppeals, 191 SCRA
94
Philippine Airlines, Inc.-
vs. Court ofAppeals, 181 SCRA 557; 185 SCRA 110; 185 SCRA
449; 188 SCRA 461
-'--Gaca1, Franklin G. vs., 183 SCRA 189
Philippine Banking Corporation vs. Intermediate Appellate Court,
187 SCRA257
Philippine Geothermal, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commis-
sion, 189 SCRA 211
Philippine Long.Distance Telephone Company-
os. Montemayor, Alberto, 190 SCRA 424
os. National Telecommunications Commission, 190 SCRA 717
868 SUPREME COURT REPORTS 'ANNOTATED 869

Philippine National B a n k - , , ; , SCRA 101· / " ' . : . ".'

,vs.CourtofAppeals,187SCRA735:, i." " Presiding Judge, RTC, Br. XXV-N"ational Power Corporationvs.',,190
vs. Devaras, Elpidia, 183 SCRA 121;. ",;, " ' SCRA477 '
vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 183 SCRA 133;'18'7 SCRA Presiding Judge, RTC, Manila Br. 39-'-'Metropolitan Bank and Trust
757; 189 SCRA 680 , " Company vs., 189 SCRA 820, c.,' . .,,' ,.",'
vs. Leon, Rosalio AI De, 181 SCRA,583 Progresibong Samahah Ng Manggagawa Sa ITM (PSM-ITM) us.Bee-
Philippine National Ccnseructicn-Gorporation- ue. .Republie of the retory of Labor, 189. SCRA 319'" ':', '. " ,
Philippines, 188 SCRA 775 ,. " .( , ' ' Provide, Sixto vs.' Chief, Philippine ConstabuIary,181 SCRA 508"
Philippine National Railways-Manuel De la Rosa vs.;·183SCRA 475 Province of Albay-National Power Corporation vs., 186 SCRA 198
Philippine Overseas EmploymentAdiniuistration Administrator-An- Province of Misamis Oriental, The us, Cagayan Electric Power' and
dres E. Ditan vs., 1915CRA 823 ' " I Light Company, Ine., 181 SCRA 38,' , " ."
Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines, Inc. »s: Intermediate Appellate Court, Prudential Bank- ." c ,

189 SCRA 158 , ,,", , ,j vs. Gapultos, Filomeno, 181 SCRA 159
Philippine Telegraph and Telephone Corporation vs.National Labor vs. Martinez,. Renato M., 189 SCRA 612
Relations Commission, 183 SCRA 451" Puerta, Isabel de la us. Court 'of Appeals,·181 SCRA 861
Philippine Veterans Bank Employees'Union-NUBE vi. ,The Philippine Puma SportschuhfabrikenRudolf Dassler,' KG, us; Job B. Madayag,
Veterans Bank, 189SCRA14 ' . .' . , 187 SCRA592
Philippine Veterans Investment Development Corpor':tiori us, Court Pundato, Dimasancay A. vs. Civil Service Commission, 186 SCRA 109
- . . ,,' -t . " . ,
of Appeals, 181 SCRA 669
Philippine Virginia Tobacco Adiniuistration vs. RicardoP. Tensuan, Quality Tobacco Corporation' us.Tntermediate' Appellate CoiIrt,187
188 SCRA628..· . . ", SCRA200 ., .
Piczon, Bernardino vs. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 31 Quiban, Generoso us, Walerico B. Butalid, 189 SCRA 107 .
Pilar, Floro del-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA 37 Quilala, Cirilo M. vs. Commission on Election:', 188 SCRA 502
Pilipinas Bank vs. Socorro Tirona-Liviag,190 SCRA 834 ' Quilisadio, Maiiiiinino.ee.' Court ofAppeals; 182 SCRA 401 .
Pilipinas Kao, Inc.-Gerouimo Sadol liS.,. 186 SCRA491: Qnintos, Franklin-e-People of the'Philippities vs:; 186 SCRA 14
Pineda, Aleja Sibayan Vda. de vs. Teodoro,Pena, 187 SCRA 22 QUinories, Adolfo-People ofthe Philippinesvs., 183 SCRA,747
Pineda, Antipaz L. vs. Court ofAppeals, 183 SCRA'602 ." Quiombing; 'Nicencio. Tan us. 'Court of Appeals, 1:89 SCRA 325'
Pineda, Gregorio G.-"-PerseverandoN. Hernandez vs., 182 SCRA'530 Quisumbing, Lourdes R.- .
Pit-og, Erkey vs;',People of the Philippines; 190 SCRA386 .-Layug;PorieianoM.'vs" 182 SCRA46 ,,'
Plana, Efren I. vs. Court of Tax Appeals, 182 SCRA 508" ' -Mendoza, Francisco L. vs., 186 SCRA 108
Polig;,Emilio'L.~Felixberto'M.Longboan' us., 186 SCRA 557
PolystereneManufacturing Co:,lnc. vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA
.
Quisumbing, Norbertoes. Court of Appeals,189 SCRA605', ..

207 Rabang, Eduardo y ~astro-i'People ofthe.Philippinesvs., 187 SCRA

Ponce de Leon, Jaime vs. Sandiganbayan, 186·SCRA 745 682'" .;, " ',,, .
Ponce Enrile; Juan~ , Racadag, Pablo R.-0ffice of the Court AdministratOr vs., 187 SCRA
vs. Amin, Omar U., 189 SCRA 573 510 '. ;'" , ' , . , ',':!.;.:i'l-' r J '
vs. Capulong, Ignacio, 185 SCRA 504 Radio Communications, of the Philippinesus; National Telecommuni-
, vs.'Salazar, Jaime, 186 SCRA217' cations Conunission, 184 SCRA 517 ' I';' .

Ponferada, Thelma A. vs. Edna Relator, 181 SCRA698 vs. Rodriguez, Rufus K,'182'sCRA899 ' "'"
Porac-Truckingxfnc.ns. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 45 " , Radiowealtll. Finance Oc., Inc. vs. International Corporate-Bank, 182
Posadas, Romeo y Zamora vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 288 SCRA'862',: . '", ; . ,
Presidential Conunission on.Good Government-s- .' Rafanan, Fernando-People of the Philippines us., 182 SeRA 811
~ojuangco, Jr., EduardoM.vs.,,190 SCRA 226· Rama, Lydia y Tamod':':'P"ople ofthe Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 687
.vs;,Nepomuceno,Jose V.,184,sCRA449,: . Ramirez, Donato vs. Court of Appeals; 187 SCRA 153 ' .....
Presiding Judge of RTC of Bohol, Br. I-Florecer Gonzales vs., 186 Ramirez, Hilario-Municipalit)i:ofTalisay vs., 183 SCRA 528·

870 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Ramos, Anice1;o VB. The Sandiganbayan, 191 SCRA 67!'
Ramos, Fidel-
-Afionuevo, Domingo T. VS., 187 SCRA 311
-Pangi1inan, Bienvenida VS., 181 SCRA 359
-Umil, Roberto VS., 187 SCRA 311
Ramos, Juanito vs. Bienvenido A. Ebarle, 182 SCRA 245
Ramos, Lucy us, Court of Appeals,188 SCRA 450
Ramos, Rosalinda y David-People of the Philippines us., 186 SCRA
184
Rafieses, Vicente vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 187 SCRA 397
Rapid Manpower Consultants, Inc. us. National Labor Relations
Commission,190 SCRA 747
Raquipo, Felix y Tolentino-People of the Philippines es., 188 SCRA
571
Raz, Reva us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 184 SCRA 720
Razon, Jr., Enrique vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 185
SCRA44
Re: Gregorio G. Pineda, Etc., 187 SCRA 469
Re: Request of Atty. Bernardo Zialcita,190 SCRA 851
Reas, Mariano us, Rufino Bonife, 190 SCRA 493
Rebullar, Ramon y Pascual-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA
838
Reformina, Adela us, Dominador Adriano, 189 SCRA 723
Regala, Agustin P. us, Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 595
Regional Trial Court of Makati, Br. 57-Acting Registrars of Titles
and Deeds ofPasay City, Pasig and Makati us., 184 SCRA 622
Regional Trial Court, Malabon, Br. 17o-Register of Deeds of Mala-
_ bon, M.M. us., 181 SCRA 788
Regional Trial Court ofPasig, Br. 165-Nemesio G. Co us., 183 SCRA
347
Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Br. 9O-Rosa Sabadlan Valencia
us., 184 SCRA 80
RTC ofZamboanga City, Br. XIII-VictOrino E. Day us., 191 SCRA 610
Register of Deeds of Malabon, M.M. us. Regional Trial Court, Mala-
bon, Br. 170, 181 SCRA 788
Relator, Edna-Thelma A Ponferada us., 181 SCRA 698
Relucio, Irene P. us, Zeida B. Brillante-Garfin, 187 SCRA 405
Republic of the Philippines-
vs. Abaya, Otilio G., 182 SCRA 524
-Allied Broadcasting Center, Inc. us., 190 SCRA 782
us, Court of Appeals,182 SCRA 290; 182 SCRA 721; 183 SCRA
620
es. Intermediate Appellate Court, 185 SCRA 572; 186 SCRA 88
us, Knecht, Cristina De, 182 SCRA 142
vs. Marcos; Pio R, 182 SCRA 223
rr
,
TABLE OF CASES 871
Republic of the Philippines-
us, Migrino, Eutropio, 189 SCRA 289
-Philippine National Construction Corporation us., 188 SCRA
775 .
-Roldan, Maria C. es., 182 SCRA 230
vs. Sandiganbayan, ·182 SCRA 911; 184 SCRA 382; 186 SCRA
8M .
-South City Homes, Inc. es., 185 SCRA 693
vs. Sayo, Sofronio,188 SCRA 634; 191 SCRA 71
Repuela, Jesus-People of the Philippines VS., 183 SCRA 244
Reyes, Elino Ong vs. Court ofAppeals, 189 SCRA 46
Reyes, Luis R-Alberto F. Lacson vs., 182 SCRA 729
Reyes, Marina Z. vs. Alfredo B. Concepcion, 190 SCRA 171
Reyes, Oscar R-Heirs ofJulio Rosas vs., 188 SCRA 236
Reyes, Rainerio O. vs. Civil Service Commission,186 SCRA 109
-Marine Radio Communications Association of the Philippines, Inc. ,I
us., 191 SCRA 205 .
Reyes, RestitutO vs. Angel V. Colet, 190 SCRA 51
Reyes, Ruperto vs. Lorenzo R Mosqueda, 187 SCRA 661 I
I~,
Reyes, Tomas T. vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA M2
Reyes, Victor B. us, Ernesto A Faderan,186 SCRA 547
Riego, Domer y Quiozon-People ofthe Philippines vs., 189 SCRA 445 ,,',
Rimando, Franco r.-cu C. Gallardo vs., 187 SCRA 453
Rinconada Telephone Company, Inc. vs. Carlos R Buenviaje, 184
SCRA 701
Rivas, Zosimo us, Secnrities & Exchange Commission, 190 SCRA 295
Rivera, Jose vs. Intermediate Appellate Court; 182 SCRA 322
Rivera, Jr., Marcelino G. vs. People ofthe Philippines,189 SCRA 331
Rizal Workers Uuion vs. Pura Ferrer-Calleja, 186 SCRA 431
Rizo, Rodolfo y Rabino-People ofthe Philippines us., 189 SCRA 265 I
Roa, Rosalinda vs. Court of Appeals,190 SCRA 262 Ii
~
Robles, Virgilio P. vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal,
181 SCRA 780
Rodrigo, Rodolfo D.-United States of America us., 182 SCRA 644
Rodriguez, Rufus B.-Radio Communications of the Philippines, Inc. Ii
us., 182 SCRA 899
Roldan, Maria C. vs. Republic of the Philippines,182 SCRA 230
Roman Catholic Bishop of Malolos, Inc. vs. Intermediate Appellate Ii
Court, 191 SCRA 411 i!
Romillo, Jr., Manuel V.-Doroteo M. De Guia vs., 183 SCRA 480 I
Ronquillo, Ruby-People ofthe Philippines vs., 184 SCRA 236
Roque, Amelia vs. Renate de Villa, 187 SCRA 311
Rosa, Manuel De la us, Philippine National Railways,183 SCRA 475
I~
Rosario, Francisco V. Del vs. National Labor Relations Commission, II
187 SCRA 777 1,/
872 SUPREME COURT,REPORTS,'ANNOTATED TABLE OF CASES 873

Rosell, Reynaldo-s-People ofthe Philippinesus.,,181 SCRA679 C" , San Miguel Corporation EmployeesUnion-PTGWO,us. Jesus G. Ber-
Rosello, Jr., Enrique R. us. NlitiiJiia1:Lallor,Relatioris Commiasion, 190 samira, 186 SCRA 496 " . '
SCRA 779 · ..·c ."C -. •. ' .':','" <:.,/.; "'f . Sandiganbayan-
Rosete, Eulalio D.-Imperial Insurance, Inc. us., 183 SCRA 1 -Bondoc, Carlito P. us., 191' SCRA 252
Roxas & Co.-Medrano &IAssiJciates,Inc:us.;,183.SCRA 580' -Estacio, Jesus y Estrella es., 183SCRA 12
Royal Undergarment.Corporation:<iHhe :Philippines .us. 'Court of In- -Estepa, Leonardo N. vs., 182 SCRA. 269 (, .
dustrialRelations, 186 SCRA 278 " -Government Service Insurance System us., 191 SCRA 655
Rubberworld (Phils.);·Inc.,vs. National.LaborRelationsComm'ission, -Holiday Inn (Phils.), Inc. us., 186 SCRA 447
183SCRA421"',· ,:".:',;!;'.' ,.' C"'·", .... , -Jariol, Jr., Antolin us., 188 SCRA 475
Rubio, DiogenesOius. People's HciIiieSite& Housing CorporatioIl,185 -Labatagos, Carmen us., 183 SCRA 415
SCRA 656' ,", "", Ie"".: '. ,; .' ,'. .,. -Marcelo; Primitivo us., 185 SCRA 346
Rubio, Jr., Ramon C. us..Plitricia,ASto.:Tom-as;:-f83 SCRA:571', " -Pohc~ de Leon, Jaime us., 186 SCRA 745
Ruffy, DiosdadoV. .uii. National 'Labor ·Relations' Commission,182 -Ramos, Aniceto vs., 191 SCRA 671
SCRA365 , " " f ,,"'i·'.,·. :, ", .r .' -Republic of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 911; '.
Ruga; \\!ipioR us. National Labor Belafions :Gommlssion, '181.SCRA 184 SCRA 382; 186 SCRA 864
.:- ,266i. -;,~ ';_">~ '.,~!..' ':~~.: v: -Yeloso, JaseR. ue., 187 SCRA504,
Ruiz, Cornelio us. Numeriano G. Estenzo, IB6!SCRA8 Sandoval, Nestor us. Doroteo Caneba, 190 SCRA 77 :
Sanidad, Pablito V. es, Commission on.Elections, 181 SCRA 529
Ruiz, Eulalio M. us. Doroteo.N. Caneba:, 191 SCRA 865-'

S.C. Johnson & Son, llic;'us.Court ofAppeals, ,188 SCRA579

Santander, Ben A. us. Court ofAppeals, 187 SCRA 706
Santiago, Mariano R.' us. K Casiano P. Anunciacion.alr.; 184 SCRA
I
SSK Parts Corporation'us.vI'eodorieo Camas, 181 SCRA 675 118
Saba, IsidroV. us. Court of Appeals, J!l!9 SCRA50, .' ..». Santiago, Pedro T. us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 690
Sadol, Geronimo us, 'Pilipinas Kao, Inc;,.186,SCRA 491 '; c.
Sagun, Jr., Rufino-ef'eople of the Philippines us.;,185 SCRA405
Santos, Eduardo V. us. Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 550
Santos, Ernesto-e-People of the Philippines us., 183-8CRA 25 ' f
Sahagun, Gina y Mendoza-People ·of the Philippines 'us:;,182SCRA Santos, Jose S. us. Court of First Instance ofCebu,-Br.VI, 185 SCRA l
. 91 .'.' ,,' 472, .1 ;c"
Sajonas, Felicitous. National Labor-Relations.Oommlssion, 183 SCRA
'" 182
Sala, Juan us. Court of First Instance ofNegros.Oriental.l'lSd SCRA
Santos, Lauro us. People ofthe Philippines, 181 SCRA487·:·
Santos, Leonor-'EDCA Publishing & Distributing Corp. us.,184 SCRA
614
I
694 '. ''- Santos, Luis T.- j,

Salangcste, Valentin -Peopleofthe Philippines us., rss SCRA 422 -Abueme, Virgilio A, us., 190 SCRA 51 ..
Salas.xluanita us. Court ofAppeals; 181SCRA.296 " -Bait, Bayan G. es.; 190 SCRA 50 ;1
Salas, Leonardo us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRAf526 -Cano, Benito us., 190 SCRA 51 0

Salazar; Hortencia us. Tomas n.Achacoso, 183 SCRA·'L45 -Castillo, Daniel us., 1&9 SCRA56 , .
Salazar, Jaime-Juan Ponce Bnrile-us., l!86:SCAA 217 -Llenado, Romeo G. us., 189 SCRA 57
Salazar, Jr., Jesus F. us. Commission on ElectioIlS,184'SCRA433 -Mon~e~a, Felipe F. us.• 190 SCFA 51 .
Saldana, Marlettaus. Court of Appeals,.190SCRA 386 -Montesa, Jacob F. us., 190 SCRA 50· I. -,

Salgado, Agustin us. 'Court ofAppeals, 189SCRA 304" .-Siete, Aniceto us., 190 SCRA 50 I'
Salik, Abdulgani-Finman General Assurance Corporation us., 188 -Sobrecaray, Elsa M. us., l8~ SCRA58. ..',"
. SCRA,740' j • -Supangan, Jr:, Johnny D., us., 189 SCRA 56 r ,
Salomon, Franeisca us. Intermediate AjJpelJate Court,l85 SCRA 352 -Vera, Placido de us., 190 SCRA 50
Saludar, Romeo y Mondigo"'-People'ofthe PhilijJpines:Vs,;·188SCRA Santos, Vicente I. us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 186 SCRA 694 .:
,'. " . 189 ;, " Sapugay, Marino us. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 464 ' .
SalvilIa, Bienvenido-e-People of the.Philippines.es., 184 SCRA671 Sarmieuto Enterprises, Inc.-Atlas Developer & Steel Industries, Inc.
San Miguel Corporation us. Court of Appeals, 185ScRA 722' 0 es., 184 SCRA 153

874 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Sarra, Florencio-People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 34
Sayo, Sofronio-Republic of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA 634; 191
SCRA71
Sazon, Gerardo-People of the Philippines us., 189 SCRA 700
Sealand Service, Inc. es, National Labor Relations Commission, 190
SCRA347
Sealanes Marine Services, Inc. us. National Labor Relations Commis-
sion, 190 SCRA 337
Secretary of Labor-
, -Eastern Assurance & Surety Corporation us., 181 SCRA 110
-Lecaroz Transit us., 191 SCRA 508
-Progresibong Samahan Ng Manggagawa sa ITM (PSM-ITM)
es., 189 SCRA 319
--8tar Security and Detective Investigation Agency us., 187
SCRA358
Secretary of Labor and Employment--8ervando's Incorporated us.,
184SCRA664
Securities and Exchange Commission-Zosimo Ricas, us., 190 SCRA
295
Senolos, Leonida Chy us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 181 SCRA 84
Sentinel Insurance Co., Inc. us. Court ofAppeals, 182 SCRA 516
Serna, Dionisio C. Dela-Aboitiz Shipping Corporation us., 184 SCRA
551
-Atilano, Vicente us., 182 SCRA 886
Serrano, Ricardo us. Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 440
Servando's Incorporated us. Secretary of Labor and Employment, 184
SCRA664
Sesbreiio, Raul H. us. Pedro T. Garcia, 181 SCRA 879
Sevilla, Lilia-Norma S. Tirado us., 188 SCRA 321
Shauf, Loida Q. us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 713
Shoemart, Inc. us. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 189
Sibal, Delia R. us. Notre Dame of Greater Manila, 182 SCRA 538
Siete, Aniceto us. Lnis T. Santos, 190 SCRA 50
Silahis International Hotel-Anita Llosa-Tan us., 181 SCRA 738
Silliman University us. Lucio Benarao, 182 SCRA 573
Simene, Melchor-People oftbe Philippines us., 184 SCRA 99
Simex International (Manila) Incorporated us. Court of Appeals, 183
SCRA360
Simpao, Jose Cesar D. us. Civil Service Commission, 191 SCRA 396
Singson, Pablo S.-Juanito Cardoza us., 181 SCRA 45
Sinuhin, Dionisio us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 190 SCRA 469
Sison, Daniel y Alegria-People of the Philippines us., 189 SCRA 643
Skillword Management and Marketing Corporation us. National Labor
Relations Commission, 186 SCRA 465
Smith Bell & Co.. Inc. us. Court of Appeals. 190 SCRA 362
r
!
TABLE OF CASES 875
Sobrecaray, Elsa M. us. Luis T. Santos, 189 SCRA 58
Socorro, Leticia Sanidad De Del-People of the Philippines us., 182
I I
SCRA359
Solis, Joveniano y Cabug-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA
182
r
Solivio, Celedonia us. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 119
Somera, Corona !bay-Dolores de Mesa Abad us., 187 SCRA 75
Songco, Jose us. National Labor RelatioIis Commission, 183 SCRA 610
Songcuan, Saturnino us. Intermediate Appellate Court, 191 SCRA 28
Soria, Mario y Balad-People of the Philippines us., 190 SCRA 548
South City Homes, Inc. us. Republic of the Philippines, 185 SCRA 693
South Motorists Enterprises us. Roque Tosoc, 181 SCRA 386
St. Mary's College (Tagum, Davao) us. National Labor Relations
Commission, 181 SCRA 62
Sta. Monica Industrial and Development Corporation us. Court of
Appeals, 189 SCRA 792
Standard Mineral Products, Inc. us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 571
Star Forwarders, Inc. us. Miguel R. Navarro, 191 SCRA 403
Star Security and Detective Investigation Agency us. The Secretary of
Labor, 187 SCRA 358
Stasa Incorporated us. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 879
Station Commander of the Muntinglupa Police Station-Narciso B.
Nazareno cs., 187 SCRA 312
Stolt-Nielsen Philippines, Inc.-National Union Fire Insurance Com-
pany of Pittsburg us., 184 SCRA 682
Su, Jr., Roque-Victoriano Zamoras us., 184 SCRA 248
Suan, Amalia Vda. de us. Eriberto A. Unson, 185 SCRA 437
Suarez, Rodolfo us. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 339
Sucaldito, Melquiades S.-Datiles and Company us., 186 SCRA 704
Sumalinog, Godofredo B. us. Corezon Q. Doronio, 184 SCRA 187
Sunbeam Convenience Foods, Inc. us. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 443
Supangan, Jr., Johnny D. us. Luis T. Santos, 189 SCRA 56
Superstar Security Agency, Inc. us. National Labor Relations Com-
mission, 184 SCRA 74
Sy, Julian us. Jaime D. Discaya, 181 SCRA 378
T.C. Igna Overseas Recruitment Corporation us. National Labor Rela-:
tions Commission, 183 SCRA 458
T.H. Valderama & Sons, Inc. us. Franklin Drilon, 181 SCRA 308
Tablizo, Uriel-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 739
Tac-an, Renato y Hipos-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 601
Tacloban Sagkahan Rice and Com Mills Co. us. National Labor Rela-
tions Commission, 183 SCRA 425
Taer, Jorge us. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 598
Talag, Macario us. Court of Appeals. 189 SCRA 801
876 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
Talavera, Victor us. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 778
'I'alingdan, Rolando-c-People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA 333
Talla, Wilfredo--People of the Philippines us., 181 SCRA 133
Tamayo, Genaro--People of the Philippines us., 183 SCRA 375
Tamayo, Roque A.-Celso Pagtalunan us., 183 SCRA 252
Tambot, Laureana us, Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 202
Tan, Dominador Agripa-Cecilio Ortega os.; 181 SCRA 350
Tan, Felicidad Barinan us: Galileo J. Trocio, 191 SCRA 764
Tan, Felicito os. Intermediate Appellate Court, 186 SCRA 322
Tan, Jr., Jose A. vs. National Labor Relations Commission,.l83 SORA
651
Tan, Nestor y Jasmin-People of the Philippines es., 187 SCRA 385
Tan, William us, Hemani T. Barrios,190 SCRA 686
Tan Ang Bun us. Court of Appeals, 182 SCRA 238
Tanchoco, Pastor os. Florendo P. Aquino,181 SCRA 73
Tangliben, Medel y Bernardino--People of the Philippines us., 184
SCRA220
Tantuico, Jr., Francisco S.-Jose Ma. Ansaldo us., 188 SCRA 300
Tantuico, Jr., Francisco--Ruben E. Celerian us., 190 SCRA 1
-Villanueva, Romulo us., 182 SCRA 263
Tapay, Domingo R. es. Elfren Cruz, 186 SCRA 474
Tarlac, Donato V.-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA 607
Tayengco, Jose C. us. Ricardo J. Ilarde,183 SCRA 504
Tayoto, Jose T. us, Heirs of Cabalo Kusop, 184 SCRA 355
Tenebro, Julio--People of the Philippines us., 191 SCRA 363
Tensuan, Ricardo P._Marubeni Nederland B.V. us., 190 SCRA 105
Tensuan, Ricardo P.-Philippine Virginia Tobacco Administration us.,
188 SCRA628
Teodoro Vano--Leopoldo Vencilao us., 182 SCRA 491
Teologo, Violeta T. us, Civil Service Commission, 191 SCRA 238
Tesorero, Francisco P. us. Ponciano GA. MathaY,185 SCRA 124
Testate Estate of Concordia T. Lim us, City ofManila,182 SCRA 482
Timbang, Edgar y Augues-People of the Philippines es., 189 SCRA
279
Timbungco, Emmanuel us, Ricardo C. Castro,183 SCRA 140
Tingson, Jr., Diosdado us. National Labor Relations Commission, 185
SCRA498
Tiongson, Benjamin C.-Mamerto B. Besa us., 191 SCRA 184
Tirado, Norma S. vs. Lilia Sevilla,188 SCRA 321
Tirona-Liwag, Socorro--Pilipinas Bank us., 190 SCRA 834 '
Toda, Jr., Beniguo vs. Court of Appeals,183'SCRA 713
Tomas, Elena J. os. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 627
Tomas, Patricia A. Sto.-Ramon C. Rubio, Jr. vs., 183 SCRA 571
Tomol, Valeriano P-Eleazar V. Adlawan vs., 184 SCRA 31
'I'orinz, Luis B.-People of the Philippines vs.. 191 SCRA 38
TABLE OF CASES' 877
i
Torre, Raul Monegro--People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA 525
Torres, Mariano y Chavarria us, Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA672
Torres, Ruben D.-University of Nueva Caceres us., 189 SCRA 315
Torres, Victorino us, Leon Ventura; 187' SCRA 96 .
Tosoc, Roque-South Motorists Enterprises·vs., 181 SCRA 386
,
Tours Specialists, Inc.-Commissioner of International Revenue us.,
l
183 SCRA 402 .
Traders Royal Bank vs. National 'Labor Relations Commission, 189
SCRA274' '.'
Trajano, Cresenciano B.-Rogelio P. Celi vs., 184 SCRA 442
Tripoli, Joel-People of the Philippines 0":, 181 SCRA 279
Trocio, Galileo J.-Felieidad Barinan Tan vs., 191 SCRA 764
Tropical Hut Employees' Union-CGW us, Tropical Hut Food'Market,
Inc., 181 SCRA 173 .. ' . , ' . .
Tuason-Toda, Rose Marie vs. Benigno Toda, Jr., 183 SCRA 713
Tumalad, Francisco-c-People of the Philippines vs., 188 SCRA 203
Tumate, Calixto y Tanguin-People of.the\ Philippines us., 189' SCRA
.
1
Ubay, Alberto Q.-'-Fortunata Mercado us., 187 SCRA 719
Umali, Buenaflor C. »s. Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 529
Umali, Vicente S. us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 186 S?RA 680
Umil Roberto vs. Fidel Ramos, 187 SCRA 311 .
Und;, Baquit S. us. Commission on Elections, 190 SCRA 827
Undersecretary of Justice-Felix A. Velasquez vs., 182 SCRA 388
Union Insurance Society of Canton, Ltd. us. Court of Appeals, 187
SCRA346 .
Union Shipping Corporation-Commissioner of Internal Reve,Due us.,
. rB5 SCRA547
United Coconut Planters Bank us, Intermediate Appellate Court,183
SCRA368 ' .
United Housing Corporation vs. Abelardo M. Dayrit,181SCRA 285
United Realty Corporationvs. Court ofAppeals,l83 SCRA 725
United States of America-
us. Alarcon Vergara, Concepcion us., 182 SCRA 644
us. Ceballos, Josefina D., 182 SCRA 644 .
us, Guinto, Eliodoro B., 182 SCRA 644
us. Rodrigo, Rodolfo D., 182 SCRA 644
Universal Shipping Lines, Inc. us, Intermediate Appellate Court, 1 fl
SCRA170
Universal Textile Mills, Inc. us, National Labor RelationsCommis-
sion, 184 SCRA 273 .
University of Nueva Caceres us, Ruben D. Torres,189 SCRA 315
University of Sto. Tomas-
vs. National Labor Relations Commission,182 SCRA 371; 190
SCRA 758

878 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED
UST Faculty Union-s-
us, National Labor Relations Commission,188 SCRA 400; 190
SCRA215
Unson, Eriberto A.-Amalia Vda. de Suan VS., 185 SCRA 437
Urbano, TIuminado vs. Francisco R Chavez, 183 SCRA 347
Uribe, Virgilio-People of the Philippines us., 182 SCRA 624
Ututalwn, NurhusseinA. us. Commission on Elections,181 SCRA 335
Uy, Jr., Esteban B. vs. Court of Appeals,191 SCRA 275
Uy, Vicente F. vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 21
Valencia, Eriberto G. us. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 561
Valencia, Rosa Sabadlan us. Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Br.
90, 184 SCRA 80 . Walstrom, Hilda vs. Fernando Mapa, Jr., 181 SCRA 431
Valenzuela, Arturo P. vs. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 1
Valenzuela, Carlos vs. Court of Appeals, 181 SCRA 524
Valeriano, Mario Barredo-People of the Philippines us., 188 SCRA
229
Valerio, Carmina-People of the Philippines vs., 185 SCRA 59
Valmonte, Ricardo C. vs. Renato de Villa,185 SCRA 665
Vargas, Jr., Jesus-People of the Philippines us., 184 SCRA 254
Velasco, Alfredo vs. BIas Ople, 191 SCRA 636
Velasco, Ely Chan Sa vs. Rodolfo A. Ortiz, 184 SCRA 803
Velasquez, Felix A. vs. Undersecretary of Justice 182 SCRA 388
Velez, Alejandro-Tomas Eugenio, Sr., vs., 185 SeRA 425
Veloso, Jose R vs. Sandiganbayan, 187 SCRA 504
Vencilao, Leopoldo vs. Teodoro Vano,182 SCRA 491
Ventura, Leon-Victorino Torres cs., 187 SCRA 96
Vera, Diosdado De vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 191
SCRA632 . Yuco Chemical Industries, Inc. vs. Ministry of Labor and Employ-
Vera, Gaudencio-People of the Philippines vs., 182 SCRA 800
Vera, Placido de vs. Luis T. Santos,190 SCRA 50
Vergara, Francisco vs. Intermediate Appellate Court,185 SCRA 29
Veyra, Jesus De-Eternit Employees and Workers Union vs., 189
SCRA 752
Vicmar Development Corp. vs. Court of Appeals 185 SCRA 634
Victor, Roger-People ofthe Philippines vs., 181' SCRA 818
Villa, Anita us. Manuel Lazaro, 189 SCRA 34
Villa, Renato De-
vs. City of Bacolod, 189 SCRA 736
-Guazon, Eddie vs., 181 SCRA 623
-Roque, Amelia vs., 187 SCRA 311
-Valmonte, Ricardo C. vs., 185 SCRA 665
Villaflor, Natividad vs. Jose Juezan,184 SCRA 315
Villanueva, Romulo vs. Francisco Tantuico, Jr., 182 SCRA 263
Vills"n. Ausrustc E.-Rosauro C. Cruz vs.. 181 SCRA 53
TABLE OF CASES 879
Villasor, Guillermo P.-Edilberto Munsayac us., 189' SCRA 324
Villazor, Conrado L. vs. Alfredo RA.
, . Bengzon
"
186 SCRA 110
Villegas; Crisostomo C.-Mauro/P. Mananquil vs., 189 SCRA 335
Villegas, Purificacion-Lualhati A. Cojuangco vs., 184 SCRA 374
Viloria, Jr., Bernardo y Delimos-People of the Philippines vs. 191
SCRA 777
Viray, Manuel G. us. Court of Appeals, 191 SCRA 308
Vistal, Arcadia us. Employees' Compensation Commission, 187 SCRA
623
Vitug, Romarico G. vs. Court of Appeals,183 SCRA 755
Vocente, Agayas yToy-daan-People of the Philippines vs., 188 SCRA
100
WesternAgro Industrial Corporation vs. Court of Appeals,188 SCRA
709
Western Guaranty Corporation vs. Court of Appeals,187 SCRA 652 1
Workmen's Compensation Commission-Gersalino, Melitona us. 187
SCRA1 '
YBL (Your Bus Line) vs. National Labor Relations Commission 190
SCRA160
Yagong, Bonifacio-People of the Philippines us., 181 SCRA 479
'
l
I
Yakult Philippines vs. Court of Appeals, 190 SCRA 357
Yang, Charles L. vs. Court of Appeals,186 SCRA 287
Yap, Edmund us. Amado G. Inciong, 186 SCRA 664
I
Yap, Mar.celino-People ofthe Philipl'ines us., 185 SCRA 222
Yeban, Ricardo-People of the Philippines vs., 190 SCRA 409
Ysmael, Jr., Felipe vs. Deputy Executive Secretary,190 SCRA 673
ment, 185 SCRA 727
Yutuc, Estanislao y Tellis-People of the Philippines vs., 188 SCRA 1
Zaide Jr., Ceferino vs. Court of Appeals, 184 SCRA 531
Zamora, Paulino vs. Court of Appeals, 183 SCRA 279
Zamora, Ronaldo-Brent School, Inc. vs., 181 SCRA 702
Zamoras, Victoriano vs. Roque Su, Jr., 184 SCRA 248
Zenith Insurance Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 185 SCRA 398
Zulueta, Leonardo N.-Basilio C. Gutierrez vs., 187 SCRA 607
Zuzuarregui, Jr., Antonio de vs. Court of Appeals, 186 SCRA 733
---000--