Professional Documents
Culture Documents
James O'Brien 261 MTRP-2
James O'Brien 261 MTRP-2
by
University of Toronto
Toronto, Ontario
2018
CTL7015
COPING WITH STRESS 2
Introduction
Adlaf, Henderson, & Mann, 2016). This statistic represents an alarming leap from research
psychological distress (Boak et al., 2014). The same study found that students in upper grades
are more stressed. For example, Grade 12 students were four times more likely than Grade 7
students to report elevated levels of stress. This is an alarming statistic because students are
about to leave the structure and relative safety of high school and enter into the world of work or
post-secondary education. This trend also indicates that the education system must call into
question its teaching and learning if students are not effectively coping with stress, and solving
What is causing these high school students to report elevated stress? Lohman and Jarvis
(2000), examined 42 adolescents’ ranging from 11-18 years of age. The participants were asked
to list the top 10 stressors they had experienced in the past 2 months in order of magnitude.
Sixty-three percent of students rated ‘school’ as their top cause of stress. The next most
commonly reported causes of stress were peers, family, extracurricular activities, and job/money.
requirements require a higher average. Anglin and Meng (2016) have identified that grade
inflation is a casual factor in the more demanding entry requirements. The more restrictive
university entry requirements has placed significant stress on high school students with post-
secondary aspirations.
COPING WITH STRESS 3
High levels of stress have been found to have a negative impact on adolescent mental and
physical health. Mental health disorders currently impact 7% of adolescents aged 13-18 and
stress has been established as a contributing risk factor (Connor-Smith & Compas, 2002).
Furthermore, high levels of stress has been linked to adolescent physical health problems
(Steiner, Erickson, Hernandez, & Pavelski, 2002) and substance abuse (Chassin, Ritter, Trim, &
King, 2003). If these stressors cannot be reduced and their causes not addressed, the adolescents
will be at a greater risk for mental and physical illness later in life.
Literature Review
The Transactional Model, proposed by Lazarus and Folkman (1984) details the
individual, their personality and coping strategies, and the transaction between the environment
which is placing a stress on the individual. A person will encounter an environmental stressor,
then appraise the stressor related to the threat or challenge the stressor poses. However, if an
individual perceives a stressor as positive or a challenge, instead of a threat, and if the person is
certain that they possess sufficient coping resources, stress may not occur despite the presence of
perceived, are not sufficient to counter demands, actual and/or perceived. Coping is an
demands (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). Following a coping response, an individual must deal with
the immediate effects on physiological, psychological, and social functioning. These effects can
be positive if the coping was successful, or negative if the coping was unsuccessful. These
effects may improve or hinder future encounters with stressors (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984).
COPING WITH STRESS 4
No environmental stimuli is inherently stressful in and of itself, and as such an individual
must first appraise the environmental stimuli as stressful. There are two steps to the appraisal
process, primary and secondary appraisal. During the primary appraisal, an individual evaluates
the situation, determines the importance of the situation to his or her well-being, and evaluates
the congruence to the individual’s goals (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). If the situation/stressor
threatens a person’s well being or harms their goals then it moves to the secondary appraisal of
the stressor. Secondary appraisal involves an individual’s evaluation of their resources and
options for coping (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). If the individual believes they have insufficient
resources the situation results in a stressful encounter. A review by Seiffge-Krenke (1995) has
shown clear evidence supporting the validity and applicability of Lazarus and Folkman’s (1984)
In the literature, the most frequently cited definition of coping is by Lazarus and Folkman
(1984), coping is defined as “constantly changing cognitive and behavioural efforts to manage
specific external and/or internal demands that are appraised as taxing or exceeding the resources
of the person” (p. 140). Coping is interdependent and is based in a person’s appraisal of the
event, goals, physiological responses to stress, focused attention, and the social context. Coping
Research Problem
High levels of stress have been found to have a negative impact on adolescent
psychological and physical health. Research has indicated that stress levels are related to
2008). Approximately 1 in 3 adolescents will meet the criteria for an anxiety disorder before they
anxiety disorders developed in young people are associated with greater severity and more
frequent anxiety episodes (Ramsawh et al., 2011). Stress negatively impacts health and overall
well-being, however, effective coping can buffer against the negative impact of stressors
Teachers are key moderators and influencers of student stress (Rockoff, 2004). Teachers
can help identify stress in students and direct them towards effective coping strategies. However,
despite the fact that teachers are involved in moderating stress and teaching effective coping
strategies the literature has not studied their perspectives. To my knowledge no study has
qualitatively examined teachers’ perceptions of student stress and effective coping strategies.
School has an important role in the development of a young person’s life and teachers
have a critical role in their cognitive affective, psychological, and physical development.
Teachers interact with students in a variety of circumstances and can enhance a student’s ability
to cope with stress. A primary purpose of the current study is to investigate how educators equip
their students to effectively cope with stressors and acquire stress management skills.
Specifically, the current qualitative study will investigate, with semi-structured interviews, how
classroom teachers promote effective coping strategies. This will generate insight into stress-
COPING WITH STRESS 6
related programming and what classroom teachers are doing now to best serve the developmental
The second purpose of this research is to explore the perspectives of a classroom teacher
and their experiences, practices, attitudes, and beliefs as they relate to the sources of stress for
students in their care. Becoming sensitive to what teachers identify as common sources of
academic stress can be valuable in attempting to minimize the impact those stressors have on the
students. With this knowledge, teachers can try to limit the stressors in their classroom so
Research Questions
1. What can educators do to equip their students with effective coping strategies?
Methodology
Participants
The participants for this study consisted of Ontario public school teachers. In order to
qualify for this study, it was required that teachers have more than 10 years of experience to
ensure the teacher has a breadth of experiences working with students to allow for comparisons
across time. Exclusion criteria precluded interviewing teachers who are currently outside of the
classroom setting (i.e. program support teachers, guidance teachers, student success teachers).
COPING WITH STRESS 7
Secondary school teachers have been chosen, as rates of stress are significantly higher in
secondary students than elementary students (Boak et al., 2014). Prospective participants were
told that the purpose of the research is to investigate how educators equip students with tools to
effectively cope with stressors and explore what teachers see as frequent sources of stress.
Participating teachers were offered no incentive for their participation. Participants were
Design
Data for this study was obtained using qualitative research methods. A semi-structured
interview was used for this study and was conducted face-to-face and was be audio-recorded.
These interviews were the central data gathering mechanism and focused on the teacher’s unique
stories that detail their experiences. The researcher chose to use semi-structured interviews in
this study as it allows the participants to share their perceptions of student stress and coping in
their own words. Due to the limited research and the subjective nature of the respondents based
on their experience, qualitative methods were selected to explore the topic. Strauss and Corbin
(1990) report that “qualitative methods can be used to better understand any phenomenon about
which little is yet known” (p. 523). This is connected to my study because this is the first study
of its kind to interview teachers and examine their experiences, practices, attitudes, and beliefs as
they relate to assisting students who are stressed. The semi-structured interview was selected as
the primary instrument of data collection. Semi-structured interviews are “well suited to the
exploration of attitudes, values, beliefs and motives, perceptions and opinions or complex or
emotionally sensitive issues (Barriball & While, 1994, p. 334)”. This method also allowed
participants to expand and elaborate on points and allow the researcher to ask probing questions
Results from this study were collected from face-to-face, semi-structured individual
interviews. Participants shared valuable insights from their professional experience working with
secondary students. Pseudonyms were assigned to protect the anonymity of participants. Sean, a
physical education teacher in a secondary school has 13 years of experience. Erin is a physical
education teacher at an secondary school which has recently placed a school-wide focus on
The purpose of this research is to investigate the experiences, practices, attitudes, and
beliefs of experienced educators as they relate to the sources of stress for students in their care.
Moreover, the purpose of this study is to investigate, with semi-structured interviews, how
classroom teachers promote coping strategies. After transcription, coding and analysis, the
following themes have emerged from the data: (1) Sources of student stress, (2) Coping
strategies implemented by students to reduce stress, (3) Recommendations for teachers to assist
reported that getting high marks was a huge stressor. Sean stated “ Student stress at our school is
basically all around academics, its about marks.” He shared that students are not stressed about
acquiring knowledge, the students are stressed about their marks as a means to an end. He
continued, “Its all about university, and maintaining the marks required to keep advanced
placement status, and trying to get where they want to go which is university and university
scholarships.” Erin observed that between October and February is a highly stressful period for
COPING WITH STRESS 9
her students and this is caused by university applications where students would continually ask,
“will I be at the big-name school, is my future mapped out for me”. Both teachers report that
academic stress is a bigger issue in grades 11 and 12 than in grades 9 and 10.
As a secondary area of stress, I would have to say it would be a social thing, so fitting in,
you know part of the “in-crowd”. And then there’s other peer stress, drugs play a role in
that as well but that’s much smaller are obviously that finds its way into the social scene
My interview with Erin affirmed that relationships are a big cause of stress in her
participants was student over involvement in school clubs and sports teams. Participating in too
many clubs and teams caused their students stress because of over commitment and time
pressures. Erin noted that many students overinvolve themselves in extracurriculars and fail to
schedule their time accordingly which causes stress. She reports that students are heavily
involved in the school but are not stressed because they plan out their time effectively. Sean
There are students that are part of track and field clubs, then also part of student
government and trying to be social with their friends and then trying to be in the school
play and trying to do sports teams on top of that. They end up stressing themselves out,
Sean identifies these students are spending too much time in clubs, sports teams, and
COPING WITH STRESS 10
events outside of school that they don’t have time to complete their school work. Sean spoke of
the motivation for these students to engage in the extracurricular activities is making their
university application more competitive “They are so concerned about the next step and getting
into the next program and getting scholarships they involve themselves in way too many things
Poor executive functioning. Executive function is a term used to describe the ability that
allows us to control and coordinate out thoughts and behaviours (Blakemore & Choudhury,
2006). Executive functioning skills include selective attention, organization, voluntary response
inhibition, decision-making, multi-tasking, and working memory. Behaviour studies show that
performance on tasks that demand these skills is impaired in adolescents. These behaviour skills
are associated with the frontal lobes, MRI studies have demonstrated that the frontal lobes of
adolescents are still developing. Both Sean and Erin name deficits in skills of executive
functioning as sources of stress. Teachers described students who are more stressed than their
(Marks are) all about time management, the kids that do really well, the top students, they
know what they can do and can’t do. How much time to devote to studying…the second
tier of kids that are really intelligent but don’t know when to start studying.
Erin argues that a lot of her student’s stress is self-induced. Her students are perceiving
something as more stressful than it actually is. She said “cognitive distortions create negative
thinking patterns that can induce more stress…resulting in an emotional response that is really a
Having a positive social circle. A strong social support network can help inoculate
COPING WITH STRESS 11
students against the debilitating effects of stress. Sean maintains that a positive social circle can
help prevent stress “I think number one, you need to have a good social group around you, you
have to surround yourself with individuals and friends that have similar goals to you and want to
Study groups. Sean articulated the benefits of different study groups on reducing student
stress. For example, their school has Science, Math and English study groups that meet with a
teacher to review challenging material and study. One limitation noted by Sean is that the
students have to self-advocate and attend the study group sessions and most students who would
Mindfulness sessions. The largest school-wide initiatives to mitigate student stress are
mindfulness activities. Both teachers reported having yoga, and meditation sessions in their
school. Erin said her school started mindfulness meditation 10 years ago before it was on
everybody's radar and she reported the school has seen a culture shift and the students are really
buying into the meditation program. Sean mentioned that his school has weekly morning yoga
sessions but less than 4% of the school population has taken advantage of these activities. Sean
way and getting active is a way to cope or deal with stressors”. Both participants noted that many
Building relationships between students and teachers. When asked what educators can
My biggest thing is the relationship thing, is the relationship building, and rapport
building because as soon as you go off tangent and take those moments to check in with
COPING WITH STRESS 12
your students you are so much more able to identify those red flags and they are that
much more comfortable sharing that with you and the communication line can start to get
help earlier.
More specifically, Erin addressed occasions where she was able to help students who came to her
with stressors. She was able to take the appropriate measures and referred the students to the
school guidance counselor or social worker. Erin identified that her relationship with the students
was the catalyst for those students coming to her seeking assistance with their stressors.
Executive functioning training. Both teachers believed study and organizational skills
were lacking in students and sought to teach these fundamental skills. Erin has incorporated
specifically teaching executive functioning skills in her classroom. She stated “executive
functioning has become a focus in our foundation program which is grade 9 and time
management comes with the procrastination”. She teaches organizational skills such as using an
agenda or a calendar because she sees students stressed without one, “they have a busy mind and
don’t have a clear picture of the road ahead”. Erin continues, describing the negative effects of
social media “this is a guinea pig generation and I see social media is a huge time sucker” she
views social media as a major cause of procrastination and helps her students moderate and
curtail their social media use. Both of the participants also highlighted that they have not
received any formal training on assisting students who are stressed or training on how to educate
Identification of stressed students. Teachers need to recognize when their students are
stressed so their can help them to cope successfully. Sean and Erin both outlined how they
identify students who are stressed. Sean explained that he is always available for a conversation
if a student wants to come talk to him about what is going on and causing them stress. Then once
COPING WITH STRESS 13
he understands the situation he is more accommodating with regard to deadlines on assignments
and tests. Erin described a different approach where she reaches out to the students on a regular
basis rather than requiring the student reach out to a teacher when they are suffering from stress.
She explains:
One of the things we’ve done with wellness is really focus on checking in with kids and
someone raises a red flag in your class whether its attendance whether its emotional or
performance has dropped off than a call goes to student services, head of guidance, and
Having a system in place for teachers to actively check in with their students and inquire
into their wellbeing is a great way for teachers to identify students who are distressed and would
benefit from effective coping strategies (e.g. referral to a school resource team to assist the
student depending on the severity of the stressor). Requiring students to self-report if they are
distressed means teachers will miss students who do not communicate their stress to their
teachers.
Discussion
The major finding of this qualitative research study is that participating teachers reported
that students are most stressed about their marks, post-secondary admission, and that teachers
learn more strategies to promote effective coping to deal with stress in their students.
The purpose of this research was to investigate the experiences, practices, attitudes and
beliefs of experienced educators as they relate to the sources of stress for students in their care.
Moreover, the purpose of this study it to investigate, with semi-structured interviews, how
classroom teachers promote effective coping strategies. The use of qualitative design enabled the
COPING WITH STRESS 14
in-depth exploration of teacher’s perceptions of the sources of student stress and teacher’s
Results of the present study were grouped into three themes: (1) Sources of student stress,
(2) Coping strategies implemented to reduce stress, (3) Teacher recommendations to help
students cope with stress. Subsequent discussion will be organized in those themes to be
Sources of Stress
The participants identified that the greatest source of stress for their students was around
getting high marks and getting admission into post-secondary. These findings have been
replicated in previous literature (deAnda et al., 2000) which found that students reported
concerns regarding planning for their future and school-specific stressors with the highest
frequency. Students are most stressed about their marks and getting into university and our
research suggests that teachers are able to identify with accuracy what causes the greatest amount
of stress to the students. This study identified what the teachers believed may be one of the
underlying causes of academic stress. The teachers reported that poor executive functioning, the
ability to control and coordinate our thoughts and behaviours (Blakemore & Choudhury, 2006),
as a possible cause for the academic stress. They described students who have poor time-
management skills, organizational skills, and emotional control as being more stressed than their
peers.
The secondary sources of stress identified by the teachers include social stressors and
report peers and relationships as common stressors (Boldero & Fallon, 1995). Past research has
not identified extracurricular overinvolvment as a source of stress reported by students. This may
COPING WITH STRESS 15
be because extracurricular involvement may not be inherently stressful and the students likely
enjoyed the extracurricular activities they participated in. Rather, extracurricular overinvolvment
by students may present as academic stress. In this context, teachers may be more capable to
identify the root cause of a student’s stress that the student themselves. This is promising
because teachers may be able to assist students who are stressed due to extracurricular over
involvement and they may guide them to manage their time better.
sessions and having a positive social circle as coping strategies. The research supports that these
coping strategies are effective approaches for dealing with stress. These coping strategies are
effective, adaptive, problem-focused coping strategies, which involve taking active steps to
increased grade point average (GPA), decreased incidence of depression and reduced delinquent
behaviour. Additionally, mindfulness is an example of a specific strategy that has been found to
be helpful in managing stress in high school students (Burke, 2010; Sibinga et al., 2011).
Social support is one of the strongest mediators of coping and dealing with stressors
(Cobb, 1976; McQuaid et al., 2016; Shavit et al., 2016). There is no specific literature examining
the use of study groups as a method to cope with stress. However, study groups provide both
social support and an academic environment where students can engage in problem-focused
The coping methods identified by the teachers to assist students include: building
relationships between teachers and students, teaching executive functioning skills, and
between teachers and students indicate that students who have a close and supportive
relationship with a teacher work harder in the classroom, are more attentive to the teacher, have
greater perseverance in the face of adversity, accept teacher direction and criticism, and cope
better with stress (Little & Kobak, 2003; Midgley, Feldlauffer & Eccles, 1989; Ridley,
McWilliam & Oates, 2000; Wentzel, 1999). Further, these results showed that teachers
recognize the importance of building these relationships as a central component to help students
Both participants who are both physical education teachers reported assisting students
develop executive functioning skills into their curriculum and teaching reduced stress. These
findings are promising, as many studies have identified that executive functioning contributes to
academic achievement, not vice versa (Bull, Espy, & Wiebe, 2008; Miller & Hinshaw, 2010).
Additionally, literature supports the need for teachers to enhance executive functioning skills as a
means to assist students cope with stress (Campbell et al., 2009). The results also indicated that
teachers are novvt receiving training and professional development on assisting students deal
with stress or coping. This study suggest that despite teachers not receiving training they are
assisting students cope with stressors and providing them with effective coping strategies.
literature in this area. Based on the results of the current study, I recommend that classroom
teachers are intentionally directed to teach, develop and evaluate coping strategies and executive
functioning in school. Moreover, I recommend that schools and boards conduct professional
development opportunities to assist teachers develop strategies to assist students cope with stress.
These results suggest that students are very stressed about grades and admissions into post-
secondary education. Additional research should examine how teachers and career/guidance
Due to the scope of this research study, there were some methodological limitations. The
sample size obtained for this research study is too small and the results are hard to generalize
across schools and education systems. A future study with a larger sample size would be useful.
Additionally, this study was limited because it only interviewing teachers, whereby interviewing
students would have resulted in a first hand account of student stress and how they cope.
Conclusion
psychological distress (Boak et al., 2016). Levels of distress in our student population are
skyrocketing and high levels of stress have been found to have a negative impact on adolescent
academic performance and student mental and physical health. This study is the first of its kind
to examine how experienced educators are responding to the explosion in stressed students.
Future research should examine student’s experiences and perspectives concerning stress and the
effects teachers have on minimizing student stress. Specifically knowledge must be identified so
teachers can assist and enhance students ability to cope with stress.
COPING WITH STRESS 18
References
Anglin, PM, & Meng, R. (2000). Evidence on grades and grade inflation at Ontario's
Barriball, K., & While, A. (1994). Collecting Data using a semi‐structured interview: a
Blakemore, S. J., & Choudhury, S. (2006). Development of the adolescent brain: implications for
Boak, A., Hamilton, H. A., Adlaf, E. M., Henderson, J. L., & Mann, R. E. (2016). The mental
Research Document Series No. 44). Toronto, ON: Centre for Addiction and Mental Health.
Boldero, J., & Fallon, B. (1995). Adolescent help-seeking: What do they get help for and from
Bull, R., Espy, K. A., & Wiebe, S. A. (2008). Short-term memory, working memory, and
preliminary review of current research in an emergent field. Journal of child and family
(2001). Coping With Stress During Childhood and Adolescence. Psychological Bulletin,
127(1), 87-127.
Campbell, L. K., Scaduto, M., Van Slyke, D., Niarhos, F., Whitlock, J. A., & Compas, B. E.
Chassin, L., Ritter, J., Trim, R. S., & King, K. M. (2003). Adolescent substance use
deAnda, D., Baroni, S., Boskin, L., Buchwald, L., Morgan, J., Ow, J., ... & Weiss, R. (2000).
Stress, stressors and coping among high school students. Children and youth services
Ghorbani, N., Krauss, S. W., Watson, P. J., & LeBreton, D. (2008). Relationship of perceived
stress with depression: Complete mediation by perceived control and anxiety in Iran and
Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, Appraisal, and Coping. Springer Publishing
Company.
Little, M., & Kobak, R. (2003). Emotional security with teachers and children's stress reactivity:
health studied in the family context. Journal of youth and adolescence, 29(1), 15-43.
Mailandt, W. (2002). Comprehensive guidance: student and parent perceptions of junior high
of Education, 2002).
McQuaid, R. J., McInnis, O. A., Paric, A., Al-Yawer, F., Matheson, K., & Anisman, H. (2016).
Relations between plasma oxytocin and cortisol: The stress buffering role of social
Merikangas, K. R., He, J. P., Burstein, M., Swanson, S. A., Avenevoli, S., Cui, L., ... &
A). Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 49(10), 980-989.
Midgley, C., Feldlaufer, H., & Eccles, J. S. (1989). Student/teacher relations and attitudes toward
mathematics before and after the transition to junior high school. Child development,
981-992.
Miller, M., & Hinshaw, S. P. (2010). Does childhood executive function predict adolescent
functional outcomes in girls with ADHD?. Journal of abnormal child psychology, 38(3),
315-326.
Ramsawh, H. J., Weisberg, R. B., Dyck, I., Stout, R., & Keller, M. B. (2011). Age of onset,
Ridley, S., McWilliam, R. A., & Oates, C. S. (2000). Observed engagement as an indicator of
child care program quality. Early Education and Development, 11(2), 133-146.
COPING WITH STRESS 21
Rockoff, J. E. (2004). The impact of individual teachers on student achievement: Evidence from
Shavitt, S., Cho, Y. I., Johnson, T. P., Jiang, D., Holbrook, A., & Stavrakantonaki, M. (2016).
Culture moderates the relation between perceived stress, social support, and mental and
Sibinga, E. M., Kerrigan, D., Stewart, M., Johnson, K., Magyari, T., & Ellen, J. M. (2011).
Mindfulness-based stress reduction for urban youth. The Journal of Alternative and
Steiner, H., Erickson, S. J., Hernandez, N. L., & Pavelski, R. (2002). Coping styles as correlates