Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A One Dimensional Model For The Prediction of Extraction Yields in A Two Phases Modified Twin-Screw Extruder
A One Dimensional Model For The Prediction of Extraction Yields in A Two Phases Modified Twin-Screw Extruder
A One Dimensional Model For The Prediction of Extraction Yields in A Two Phases Modified Twin-Screw Extruder
Abstract
Solid/liquid extraction is performed on raw plant substrate with a modified twin-screw extruder (TSE) used as a thermo-mecano-
chemical reactor. Visual observations and experimental residence time distributions (RTD) are used to develop a solid transport
model based on classical chemical engineering method. Modeled and experimental residence times are compared. The transport
model is then coupled with a reactive extraction model in order to predict extraction yields.
Keywords: Twin-screw extruder; Solid/liquid extraction; Two-phase residence time distribution; Transport phenomena; Raw plant substrate
the basis of the example of hemicelluloses extraction 2. Scope and modeling principle
from hardwood populus by NaOH aqueous solution.
This model couples a one dimensional approach for the
2.1. Two-phase transport by the TSE
solid transport along the TSE and a kinetic description
of the solubilization process which has been established
Prat et al. [6] have proposed a qualitative description
via batch experiments. These kind of approach has been
of the functioning of the TSE and studied the two phase
successfully applied to a lot of other polyphasic pro- RTD in this particular application. The reactor has been
cesses like liquid /liquid extraction columns for instance. separated into two functional parts: before the RSE, the
The first paragraph proposes a system analysis, two phases (liquid and impregnated solid) are present,
leading to the modeling methodology. In the second meanwhile from the RSE to the die, only impregnated
paragraph, the models describing transport, reaction solid can be found. In this second part, the under-
and mass transfer are developed. The third para- pressured elements (i.e. the RSE, the half transport
graph presents the matter, the material and the experi- screw just before the RSE and the die) are totally filled
mental methods. Then, in the last paragraph, the model with the solid matter, which is not the case in the first
results are presented and compared with the experi- part of the reactor. The TSE is then not totally full of
mental data. matter under classical working conditions.
The conducted experiments gave data for hemicellu- 3. Global process model
loses concentrations in the central canal and in the bulk
phase as a function of time in different operating 3.1. Transport model
V and
t (3)
V̇ Vdie
tdie rdie (10)
where, V is the volume of the element; and V̇ the QS
volumic flow of matter in the element. where rrse is the apparent solid density in the RSE and
Since there are two phases in these elements, the rdie is the apparent solid density in the die.
volume is shared between them. The volumic flows (/V̇ sol/
for the solid and V̇ liq for the liquid) are of the form:
3.2. Reaction and mass transfer model
QS
V̇ sol (4)
QP In [8], Prat et al. proposed a first order kinetic law for
the hemicelluloses liberation (1).
and Concerning the mass transfer, as the solid matter is
QL QS ((1 v)=v) under pressure in the restrictive elements, the hemicel-
V̇ liq (5) luloses diffusion is neglected compared with the convec-
rliq
tion due to the pressure. In these elements, the solid
where, QL is the mass flow of liquid in the reactor; QS, weight percentage goes from v1 to v2 (v1 B/v2). Then,
the mass flow of solid; v the solid weight percentage in the liquid mass mliq which transfers from a solid mass
the solid phase in the element; rP, the apparent density msol to the liquid phase is expressed by the following
equation: porosity is the useful porosity for the process, i.e. the
porosity accessible to the solvent.
1 v1 1 v2
mliq msol (11) rP, rW and o are linked by the following equation
v1 v2 (without considering the contribution of air):
rP rW (1o) (12)
o and rW are intrinsic properties of the matter and can
be obtained with a single experiment: a known mass of
4. Matter, material and experimental methods
vegetable matter mw is mixed with a known mass of
solvent mliq. After the transfer equilibrium is reached
The local models previously described need different
(i.e. at the maximum of the solid impregnation), the
kind of parameters:
volume of the two mixed phases V and the solid weight
/ elements geometrical parameters (pitches, length, percentage v in the solid phase are measured. The
volumes); porosity is then filled with the solvent and the following
/ operating parameters (N , QL, QS); equations can be written:
/ indirect responses of the system (v , the solid weight mw
percentages along the reactor); rw (13)
V (mliq =rliq )
/ physicochemical properties (densities, kinetic laws);
/ parameters describing the behavior of the matter (the and
b parameters, and the slip velocity).
rliq
1v (14)
Furthermore, experimental data for solid residence rliq (1 o=o)rw
time and extraction yields are to be obtained in order to
where rliq is the density of the solvent.
validate the model.
Fig. 5. Experimental vs. calculated solid residence times. Fig. 6. Experimental vs. calculated extraction yields.
5.2. Extraction yields results For other TSE applications with solid/liquid flows, a
more precise study of the RSE will be needed, in order
The extraction yields prediction is obtained by to understand the behavior of such a screw element.
coupling the transport model, the reaction and the This understanding will be of first interest for raw
transfer model, as described in Fig. 1. The temperature material for instance. As there is only solid in the RSE,
used for the kinetic law is the experimental temperature developed models for polymer industries or agro-indus-
measured in the TSE at the interface barrel-matter. The try [10] will certainly be usable with some modifications
results are plotted in Fig. 6 for all the experiments. The due to the compressibility of the wood particles.
global model gives a good prediction of the experimental
data in the whole domain investigated.
These results lead to several observations on the
adopted method and on the studied process. First of Appendix A: Nomenclature
all, the good prediction justifies the utilization of
coupling between a one dimensional model for transport C (t) Hemicelluloses mass concentration function of
by screw element and a first order kinetic. Besides, the time (g l 1)
tentative method in batch reactor for the acquirement of C2F Two-flight screw element
the kinetic gives results exploitable in continuous C2FC Reversed two-flight screw element (RSE)
reactors, presumably because of the simplified reac- mL Liquid mass (g)
tional way adopted. Finally, the obtained results suggest mS solid mass (g)
that the contribution of TSE to solid/liquid extraction MAL0 mono-lobe kneading element
processes is firstly located in its ability to separate the MAL2 bi-lobe kneading element
two phases and then suppress the limitative diffusion N screw rotational speed (rpm)
step. p screw element pitch (mm)
QS solid feed rate (kg h1)
QL liquid feed rate (kg h1)
6. Conclusions R extraction yield (%)
RSE reversed screw element
Problems generated by the complexity of the vegeta- T temperature (8C)
ble matter and the important coupling of phenomena in T2F trapezoidal two-flight screw element
a reactor where the matter can not be directly observed V phase volume (m3)
are numerous. This work proposes a first approach /V̇/ the volume flow (m3 s1)
model for the prediction of solid /liquid extraction
yields in a modified TSE. The model has been con- Greek letters
structed from visual observations and chemical engi- a coefficient for the determination of the slip
neering analysis by coupling transport, reaction and velocity
transfer descriptions. b kneading element adjustable parameter
This work proposes a one dimensional model for solid o wood particle porosity
transport phenomena. The model needs a single adjus- h optimization criterion
table parameter for each screw element type. These rP particle apparent density (kg m 3)
parameters characterize the mechanic phenomena be- rLiq liquid density (kg m 3)
tween matter and TSE and depend on the couple s NaOH mass percentage in liquid phase
(chosen matter-screw element). A theoretical study of tS solid phase mean residence time (s)
these parameters could be the next step in modeling the v solid weight percentage in the exiting solid
two-phase flow transport in the TSE. As far as solid / phase
liquid extraction is concerned, the solid residence time
prediction gives usable values in all studied domain.
Reaction is based on a previous work upon hemicellu-
loses extraction in a batch reactor from poplar wood. References
The hemicelluloses diffusion is neglected and mass
transfer is due to the under pressure elements which [1] L. Rigal, Technologie d’extrusion bi-vis et fractionnement de la
cause solid /liquid separation all along the TSE. matière végétale, 40 ans d’extrusion bi-vis chez CLEXTRAL,
This study allows to point out that the main interest Recueil de conférences, Firminy (France), 8 /10 October 1996.
[2] S. N’Diaye, Fractionnement de la matière végétale: mise au point
of the TSE for solid /liquid extraction lies in the
d’un procédé thermo-mécano-chimique et modélisation du réac-
suppression of the diffusion step during the operation. teur bi-vis. doctorat thesis INPT, Toulouse, France, 1996.
Furthermore, it validates the experimental method for [3] S. N’Diaye, L. Rigal, P. Laroque, P.F. Vidal, Extraction of
the obtaining of kinetic parameters in batch reactor. hemicelluloses from poplar, populus tremuloides, using an
extruder-type twin screw reactor: influence of the main factors, [7] R.E. Altamore, P. Ghossi, An analysis of residence time
Biores. Technol. 57 (1996) 61 /67. distribution pattern in a twin-screw cooking extruder, Biotechnol.
[4] N. Bouzid, G. Vilarem, A. Gaset, Extraction des huiles essentielles Prog. 2 (3) (1986) 157 /163.
par des techniques non conventionnelles, Revista Italiana [8] L. Prat, P. Guiraud, L. Rigal, C. Gourdon, Solid /liquid
E.P.P.O.S., Agosto’97, 3 /11, 1997. reactive extraction with raw plant substrate, ECCE2 congress,
[5] S. Isobe, F. Zuber, K. Uemura, A. Nogushi, A new twin-screw 1999.
press design for oil extraction of dehulled sunflower seeds, J. Am. [9] E. Sjötröm, Wood Chemistry, Fundamentals and Applications,
Oil Chem. Soc. 69 (9) (1992) 884 /889. Academic Press, Inc, NewYork and London, 1981.
[6] L. Prat, P. Guiraud, L. Rigal, C. Gourdon, Two phase residence [10] J. Tayeb, B. Vergnes, G. Della Valle, A basic model for a twin-
time distribution in a modified twin-screw extruder, Chem. Eng. screw extruder, J. Food Sci. 54 (1989) 207 /214.
Proc. 38 (1999) 73 /83.