"Dear Abby" Re: Tarasoff V Regents

You might also like

Download as pdf
Download as pdf
You are on page 1of 1
Setting record straight on confidentiality: Dear Abby: I have received ‘many phone calls since the appear- ance of Carol A. Tauer’s letter in your column. Her otherwise inter- sting and informative eter con ‘cerning the ethical implications of the Catholic Church's position on the seal of the confessional con- tained a of errors that I hhope you will correct. = It is well known in the Bay Area pean omni tat war tt logist (not psy- Smears? ‘Cowell Memorial Hospital on the University of Calfornia-Berkeley ‘campus forthe patient who mur ‘dered Tatiana Tarasoff. ‘Ms. Tauer, an ethics teacher in a Catholic college, said in her leter, “On appeal, the California ‘Supreme Court rejected the psy- chiatrist’s argument supporting ab- solute confidentiality, saying that a psychiatrist had a duty to war or protect an identifiable potential But Abby, I never argued for ‘complete confidentiality. When the patient told me of hs intention to ‘al Ms, Tarasof, 1 immediately in- formed the local police (in this cat, the Univer of Caliomia Campus Police Departme rot a legal eter of commitment (countersigned by the chief psychi- atrist of our department) with the intent of hospitalizing my patient, ‘This was exactly the procedure di- rected by law at that time (1968). ‘The campus police interviewed soll ert my rad point to my ers: You di, infact, warn the police on tet ocasons. You dd not rely upon any claim of confiden- tality to keep the threats seeret ‘The Supreme Court opinion cited by Ms. Tauer does not make ‘lear that you the matter Tenueee the patient committed and did not configenta

You might also like