Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Worthy Companions: Assurance Through Association in Evelina and Young Werther (March 2005 Scanned)
Worthy Companions: Assurance Through Association in Evelina and Young Werther (March 2005 Scanned)
Worthy Companions: Assurance Through Association in Evelina and Young Werther (March 2005 Scanned)
y
Patrick McEvov-Halston
English 376B_
Eric Miller
10 March 2005
associatethemselveswith very different kinds of people. We note that Evelina is very careful to
associateherselfwith thosewho will help differentiateherself from the lowly, the base,while
Wertheractuallyseeksthemoutinaneffortffiseffromexactlythosesortsof
\....-
sensitivepeoplethat Evelina seeksto associateherselfwith. However,both charactersare similar
themselvesto those they gaugesuperior, and we therefore have causeto think of them both as
.$r
sheis sensible,or well bred, is very strong indeed. Evelina attendsmost closely to how Lord
r hqs
OrvillerSjudged her. In the letter in which she informs Mr. Villars of their assessments
of her, she
ruminates(for the moment) only on thosewords Lord Orville usedto describeher-"'A poor
Paul Gordon Scott arguesthat the social order in eighteenth-centuryEngland required the
gazeis ideal for this purpose;for his vision is informed by "the cold eye of unimpassioned
allowing "the heart t. . .] to interfereand make all objectsbut one (i.e. a beautiful woman) insipid
but rather a"pretty modest-lookinggirl" (38). Lovel, having beenhumiliated by her preferenceof
recovering her characterso that she seemsfitting sport for libertine play. He knows she
mortification" (40), and understandsthat regardlessof whether or not her behaviour was born out
examinationof her motives, doesnot meanthat we should facilely assumethat both possible
J
explanationsfor her behaviourareequallydamning. They're not. That is, if her behaviourwas the
result of her being ignorant, sheis doomed: shehas no chanceof deemingherselfworthy of Lord
Orville. But, if sheis and was mischievous,the novel provides evidencewhich suggeststhat the
instance,Mr. Villars at one point expresseshis wish that he could changeMadameDuval's plans,
,^
but arguesthat "[h]{ characte}nd the violence of her disposition, intimidate me from making the
"H-/ tF
attempt: she is too ignorant for instruction, too obstinate for entreaty,and too weak for reason"
6i'
nn rc
(142). We also know that Evelina gaugesthe Branghtons as so obstinatethat she doesnot believe .[-
oof*
that their mannersmight be improved upon; in fact, sheguessesthat they probably alreadythink of )o
A,, )
themselvesas genteel(195). aee
)
'k7
Severalcharacterswho are characterizedas libertines (with the exception of Lord Merton),
tr,
er
on the other hand, are not only redeemable-witness what happensto Evelina's true father at the '1
,
end of the novel-but possesspositive qualities which make them fundamentally similar to rather
hearing how Evelina humiliated Lovel, but he is also someonewhose own statusas genteelis not
u
compromisedin doing so. In this, Sir Clement bearsresemblanceto the restoration libertines who
*
engagedin "shaming rituals [which boar resemblanceto that] of non-urbaneand impolite society''
Y G\t
4
(245),but which were employedin an effort to "enforce rather than dissolve socialhierarchy''
(JamesGrantham Turner 247.i And we note that throughout the novel, Sir Clement involves
himself in activities which help distinguish the genteel from the lowly, and which seemdesigned
/
t"-i"d th. t"*ly r If we understandSir Clement and Lord Orville as
: f^l"n
representingtwo different sorts of gentlemen,both of whom had their time as socially sanctioned
t rfl
establishtheir intrinsic similarity as much or more than it doestheir fundamental difference. For
according to Evelina, it is "unjust" (199) to comparepeople who are fundamentally different from
one another. Shewill not, for example,compareSir Clement and Mr. Smith, owing to the fact that
to Sir Clement. Though Evelina overtly refusesSir Clement's suggestionthat they possessa
similarly "frank t. . .] disposition" (49), wo note that in someways she establishesthe link she
(perhaps)more overtly avows shedoesnot want to effect. We note that Evelina is keenly awareof
every key word usedby the three men to assessher characterthe night of the private ball. Lord
renembrancefor a word used-"Noboily" (320Fby the leastof the tlree men (i.e., Lovel). We
- havereasonto conclude,therqthat sheknew that by calling Sir Clementa "genius" (52) in a letter
I v*-
/
V so soonafter Sir Clementusedthe sameword to describeher (40), that shewashelpingcernentin
"$
her own mind the connectionbetweenthe two of them that Sir Clernentattemptsto forge.
character,she suggeststhat they seemdesignedfor one another,like lock and key perhaps. She
writes: "[a]nd thus was my deviation from truth punished;and thus did this man's determined
boldnessconquer" (48).
Evelina calls Sir Clementher "champion" (39), and it is appropriateto deemhim someone
sheneedsto help protect her senseof herself as different from her ignorant, baserelatives. Evelina
is often surroundedby coarserelatives throughout the novel, yet through this monstrouscrowd, Sir
Clement persistently seeksher out. And by doing so, he does her an enonnous favour.
1"1 t
( .rt\
Specific ally, though we might normally be preparedto deem his attentionsa threat to her *c ,\ dr
L onLt
reputationas a lady, sinceher biological and physical closenessto basefolk alreadyprovidesher
5 tn.r
with a reasonto suspectthat shetoo is lowly, they actuallywork to help to establishher senseof t."\
"(o
herselfassomeone--alady-who hassomethingpreciousto lose. Early in her associationwith
t" ,l
c.
MadameDuval and CaptainMirvan, Evelinasaysthat "the[ir] continualwrangling and
L\rl
ill-breeding [. . I made[her] [. . .] blushthat [she] [. . .] belongedto them" (65). Fortunatefor her,
Captain;he "stud[ies] all [his] [. . ] humours"(83); but only so asto ensurehis accessto Evelina.
'!a[id] courtto the grossCaptainMirvan, andthe virago MadameDuval" only
, He tells her that he
'
soasto "procure[for] [him]self'(381) her company.And thoughhe dealswith the coarseonly so
One obvious example of such a service occurs when Sir Clement helps Captain Mirvan
"sport" with Madame Duval. Madame Duval, being the "prey," endsup on the ground covered
with dirt, disassembled,and inarticulate, while Evelina remains both the particular subject of Sir
MadameDuval down to earth(i.e. lowly). That is, he helps createa memorablemoment for
Evelina which she can use to help understandherself as incomparably different from her horrid
lookedat Mr. Smith' (225) after seeingthe resultsof what his suddenawarenessof Sir Clement's
Sir Clement also helps Evelina in that he provides her with good reasonsfor reproving him,
and, until shemeetsMr. Macartney, it is primarily her reproof of him which permits her to behave
in a fashion which likens her to Orville. But it is the fortuitous discovery of Mr. Macartney which
provides Evelina with the opportunity to behavein a way which might easily be construedby her
early modern period [read I6-I8th century]" (72). Indeed,plays and literature of the time often
But though Mr. McCartney servesto help elevateEvelina's character,she obtains the
meansby which to gaugeherself equal to Lord Orville in part by lowering his. Sheportrays her
involvement with both Sir Clement and Mr. Macartney asmaking Lord Orville jealous. He shows
signsof social unease-"he lookfs] away''(369) at a social gatheringwhen Evelina looked upon
him (the only time this event occursin the novelFand displays a lack of grace. Shewrites: "Lord
Orville's receptionof us was grave and cold: far from distinguishingme, as usual,by particular
civilities,Lady Louise herself could not have seenme enterthe room with more frigtd unconcern"
Orville, doesnot: shedoesnot devolve, shenever allows her initial burst of laughterat Lovel's
8
with the lowly, and he plots his narrative so that he moves from being (fairly) happy to being a
perpetually tormented person. Yet, since in his imagination the heavenly can be found as much
The sort of people Werther doesn't want to be associatedwith are thosewho in some
*f'cJ,5
exactly the safety, the senseof security, which Evelina likely imaginesbeing married to Lord
Orville will provide her with. But he also believesthat suchpeople,sincethey are interested
primarily in placement and not in love, "will be done for" (33). He draws our attention to the fate
of a wealthy woman who, like Evelina, was powerfully concernedwith barricading herself from
Orville is the best of men. For in somerespectsArthur is describedso that he seemsto possess
J, w,,
t\*. n
similar charactertraits to Lord Orville's, only they aren't any where near as flatteringly portrayed.
t"I
Admittedly, just as Evelina judges Lord Orville as "the most amiable man in the world" (Evelina |
"oQ
)nu
41), Werther actually writes that Albert is "the best fellow on earth" (59). However, Werther is
quite ready to doom him in his own estimation by associatinghim with all other "sensible people"
(61). In the letter in which he does so, Albert makes an declarationconcerning bad behaviour
9
which we know it is very easyto imagine Lord Orville making. Albert says,"[b]ut you will grant
Clementsonce did with Lord Orville, to suggestthat motives do matter and can and should affect
whether we deem a behaviour wrongful or not, but Albert won't budge. Indeed, Werther portrays
whose fundamentalbelief in the rightnessof his opinion along with his desireto preach,make him
favour by treating him with disdain. For instance,he describesa doctor who "considered [his]
would be embracedby
t. . .] conductbeneaththe dignity of sensiblepeople" (45). This assessment
Werther, however, for he despisesthe ostensibly dignified and finds fabulous things when he
"lie[s] t. . .] closeto the earth" (27). He saysthat he prefersto associatewith thosemost frequently
accusedof lacking dignity: the "rabble," "[t]he commonpeople" (28). Though there are
exceptions-e.g., foul youth who ruin others' moods, the grumpy lady who cut down the walnut
tree (mind you, she is one with pretensionsto be respectable[94]Fit is clear to Werther that the
common people are in fact avery fine lot. They have not lost their capacity to love, somethingthe
sensiblehave in fact done, ffid, as English Tories like to imagine them, they possessan intrinsic
awarenessof and attractionto those who are truly noble (they can't help but love Werther). "The
conrmonpeople," he says, "already know and love [him], the children in particular" (28). He is
particularly apt to identify himself with children-those who are, in one senseat least, the lowest
of the low. He describeshis encounterswith children or youth in some detail, and in eachcase
demonstratehis gentility, wo have reasonto wonder if he thinks that being "interred in the cold
conceivesof Nature as somethingwhich is always grand and noble (if not always beneficent), and
is constantly despondent,as a processwhich prepareshim for atomic integration with Nature. But
we shouldnote that, for the most part, Werther imagineshimself in his after-life as, so-to-speak,
"in the clouds," along side God. And we must not fail to suspectthat Werther might well be
A
making somethingout of his associationwith the low for the samereasonEvelina makes vvJrh
somethingout of her relationship with Sir Clement, that is, becausebarriers exist which prevent
"f
CV,s1, o-
( o.uL.. -
him (at this time) for long associatingwith thosehe truly wants to be with, i.e., thosewho possess
e\v
high rank and unquestionablygood nature. Werther writes that, in death,he is bound to be by his
\;'
Father's (i.e., God's) side, and that his Fatherwill "comfort" (I28) and value him. We know that sLJI
6.
he has glimpses of this reality while counting himself amongstthe livin g, that is, that he has 9, r11
associatedwith the truly high and noble-worthy Baronesses,Counts, and Princes-and that he
portrays them as prizing his presenceabove that of all others (especially with the Baronessand
Prince),but also that he couldn't for long associatehimself with them in peace. Just as Evelina's
coarsefamily relatives work againsther effort to associateherself with Lord Orville, those
Both Evelina and Werther, then, are similar in that both are charactenzedso they portray
the kind of artfulness,cunning, they pretend to abhor. They differ in that Evelina can admit to
take "some pleasurein cutting up" "fools and coxcombs" 13261)becausethere is an established
tradition amongstthe genteel shewants to count herself amongstthat entitles them to police
through the use of ridicule [note that even Lord Orville calls Lovel a "coxcomb" (37)], while
Werther needsto make claim to a more simple purity so as to distinguish himself from cutting
time, it actually servesEvelina's intentions to portray herself as a bit devilish, while Werther is the
ttt"l\
one who must try and make sure he doesn't appearthe least bit like a rogue. Both, however, are )k
tnrly beneficent in that they both provide their readerswith the meansby which to conceive of
rJ
1vo1
t Lff;
their own ostensiblecharacterflaws and lack ofplacement as signswhich point to their possession
rt( rl(u,
of intrinsic merit. Of course,if you are unwashedand uncouth, you would be better senredto [.r
t\.t"
attendto Werther, and if you possessa tendency to snicker at the misfortunes of othersbut /
,h,
otherwisepossessrespectablemanners,you'd be better servedif you affend to Evelina. But there r"f
\t,
is no doubt that associatingourselveswith them has its benefits. No wonder many once did.
f."v A
//
t
I am not suggestingthat Sir Clement is not also in some respectsvery much the proper eighteenth-century
gentleman. For, according to Philip Carter, the eighteenth-centurypolite male "was expectedto be more relaxed or
'easy' in company, to move more freely across social divisions" (124).
Al-lINkl
? \ )
, )r ! .
- - a
Works Cited
PearsonEducationLimited,2001.
Carnbridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2002.
CanrbridgeUniversityPress,2002.
Books,1989.
2001.
ChrisMounsey.Cranbury:AssociatedUniversityPresses,
PatrickMcEvov-Halston
doessherequireinstruction?
If Mme Duval hassucha super-plusof character,
A+/A-