Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Relationship Between Cellular Phone Addiction and Self-Esteem of Elementary School Students in Highly Mobile Environment
The Relationship Between Cellular Phone Addiction and Self-Esteem of Elementary School Students in Highly Mobile Environment
The Relationship Between Cellular Phone Addiction and Self-Esteem of Elementary School Students in Highly Mobile Environment
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study was to investigate the cellular phone addiction status and the relationship between
cellular phone addiction and self-esteem of elementary school students in today’s highly mobile environment.
The study participants were 1,173 upper grade elementary school students in Chungnam province. Data were
collected by a self-administered questionnaire from November 5 to 26, 2012. Collected data were analyzed
using the IBM SPSS 20.0 program with descriptive statistics, Pearson’s correlation coefficient, independent
t-test, one-way ANOVA and Scheffe test. The level of the cellular phone addiction in upper grade elementary
school students was generally low but high risk students also existed. In addition, a negative correlation was
observed between self-esteem and cellular phone addiction in upper grade elementary school students. These
results suggest that various interventions to prevent and manage the cellular phone addiction should be
provided for elementary school students in today’s highly mobile environment and interventions for high risk
students of cellular phone addiction should be provided urgently. In addition, inclusion of interventions to
increase the self-esteem of upper grade elementary school students in those interventions should be also
needed.
Keywords: Cellular Phone, Addiction, Self-Esteem, Elementary School, Mobile Environment
5995
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
tendency [16, 21, 22]. In today’s highly mobile Self-esteem was measured using the Self-
environment, possibility of cellular phone addictions esteem scale translated by Cho [24]. Cho's scale
is getting higher. Therefore, it is important for consists of 20 items with a 5 point Likert scale (1-5),
healthcare providers to investigate the degree and with higher scores indicating higher level of self-
related factors of cellular phone addiction and esteem. In this study, minor word revisions and
provide interventions and strategies to prevent elimination of several items of this scale were made
cellular phone addiction based on evidence. for suitable to upper grade elementary students.
In addition, considering the fact that cellular Modified and revised scale consists of 13 items and
phone addictions may also be an indicator of other content validity of this scale was confirmed by three
problems and the age of one's first cellular phone elementary school teachers. The internal consistency
possession was negatively correlated the probability reliability was Cronbach’s α = .82 in this study.
of problematic use in the future [6], interventions and
strategies for elementary school students are critical 2.4 Data Collection
and urgent issues. An increasing number of studies Data were collected using a self-report
have focused on cell phone addictions [12], however, questionnaire from November 5 to 26, 2012.
most studies conducted for adolescent or young For the collection of research data, the
adult. Therefore, this study will investigate the researcher first contacted the teachers of upper grade
cellular phone addiction status of upper grades elementary schools and explained the research
elementary school students. And self-esteem is purpose, contents of research questionnaire, time to
suggested a critical factor influenced the cellular filling out a questionnaire, and assurance of no
phone addiction, studies on relationships self-esteem disadvantage for the nonparticipants in this research.
and cellular phone addiction of elementary school After explanations, written informed consents and
students are also insufficient. Therefore, this study research questionnaires were distributed to teachers
will also investigate the relationships between those who permit to conduct this study. Distribution
cellular phone addiction and self-esteem of upper and collection of research questionnaires and
elementary school students. informed consents from research subjects were
carried out by teachers.
2. METHODS
2.5 Data Analysis
2.1 Research design Collected data were analyzed using the IBM
This study was descriptive study to investigate SPSS 20.0 program with descriptive statistics,
the cellular phone addiction status and relationships Pearson’s correlation coefficient, independent t-test,
between cellular phone addiction and self-esteem of one-way ANOVA and Scheffe test.
upper grades elementary school students. Descriptive statistics were used to describe the
general characteristics, cellular phone addiction and
2.2 Research Subject self-esteem. Independent t-test and one-way
The study subjects were 1,173 upper grade ANOVA were used to analyze cellular phone
elementary school students from three elementary addiction according to general characteristics.
schools in Chungnam province. Pearson’s correlation coefficient was used to analyze
the relationship between cellular phone addiction
2.3 Research Tools and self-esteem.
Cellular phone addiction was measured using
modified and revised scale of the cellular phone 3. RESULTS
addiction scale developed by Jang [23]. Jang's scale
consists of 20 items with a 5 point Likert scale (1-5), 3.1 General Characteristics Of Subjects
with higher scores indicating higher level of cellular General characteristics of research subjects are
phone addiction. In this study, minor word revisions showed in Table 1. In gender, female students
and elimination of several items of this scale were (n=596, 50.8%) were a little more than male student
made for suitable to upper grade elementary (n=577, 49.2%). In grade, 6th grade students (n=441,
students. Modified and revised scale consists of 15 37.6%) were the most and 4th grade students (n=338,
items (learning disorder 5 items, life disorder 5 28.8%) were the least. In family type, most students
items, relationship disorder 5 items) and content (n=1,016, 86.6%) lived with their parents. In
validity of this scale was confirmed by three siblings, 50.2 percent of students (n=590) have
elementary school teachers. The internal consistency siblings with opposite sex and 10.2 percent of
reliability was Cronbach’s α = .90 in this study. students (n=120) have no siblings.
5996
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
3.2 Cellular phone addiction and Self-esteem of life disorder (8.04±3.51) were the highest and
Cellular phone addiction and self-esteem those of learning disorder (7.34±2.96) were the
degree of research subjects are showed in Table 2. lowest.
Mean scores of cellular phone addiction were Mean scores of self-esteem were 46.74 out of
22.84 out of 75.00 (30.45 out of 100.0). Among 65.00 (71.91 out of 100.0).
the area of cellular phone addiction, mean scores
3.3 Cellular Phone Addiction According To The students living with parent(s) showed
General Characteristics higher score of cellular phone addiction than other
Cellular phone addiction according to general students (t=1.98, p=.048), however, cellular phone
characteristics is showed in Table 3. The higher the addiction according to gender and siblings did not
grade, the higher the mean score of cellular phone showed significant difference.
addiction (F=50.21, p<.001).
5997
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
SD=standard deviation
3.4 Relationships Between Self-Esteem And cellular phone addiction (r=-.367, p<.001).
Cellular Phone Addiction Negative correlations were also observed between
Relationships between self-esteem and cellular self-esteem and three areas of cellular phone
phone addiction are showed in Table 4. A negative addiction.
correlation was observed between self-esteem and
4. DISCUSSION
In this study, mean scores of cellular phone of cellular phone addiction. Lee & Lee (2012)
addiction were 22.84 out of 75.00 (30.45 out of reported that there was a great deal of variability
100.0). This result consistent with previous study between elementary school students in the pattern
reporting that the pattern of cellular phone use in of cellular phone use [21]. In addition to, there is a
elementary school students did not show the severe difference between result from self-reported
addiction pattern [21]. This result also consistent questionnaires and self-implication [12]. Therefore,
with previous study reporting that the mean scores although the mean scores of cellular phone
of cellular phone addition were 37.37 out of 100.0 addiction is showed low level, it is needed to take
[25]. Researches about cellular phone addiction of an interest about elementary school students’
elementary school students were not much [21]. cellular phone addiction. It is also needed to develop
But, considering the result of previous study and and apply for interventions and strategies to prevent
this study, it is assumed that the degree of elementary school students’ cellular phone
elementary school students’ cellular phone addiction and application of interventions to
addiction is generally low. However, maximum manage of cellular phone addiction for high risk
score of cellular phone addiction was 63.00 out of students is needed urgently.
75.00 (84 out of 100.0), this score means high risk Previous study reported that group counseling
5998
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
program reduce the cellular phone addiction exhibit a higher level of attachment to ad
tendency of higher grade elementary school dependence on their cellular phone compared with
students [27]. However, other studies reported men [28, 29, 30]. However, other studies reported
conflicting results that education programs for little or no difference in cellular phone dependence
elementary school students about cellular phone use across male and female cellular phone users [25,
were not effective on self-efficacy and self-control 31]. Therefore, repeated studies about cellular
about cellular phone use [8, 26]. Therefore, phone addiction according to gender should be
continuous and repetitive studies to develop conducted. In additions, most previous studies
effective interventions and strategies for preventing about cellular phone addiction, like other additions,
and controlling cellular phone addiction of are lack of clear terminology [32], studies to
elementary school students should be conducted. In clarification of terminology also should be
this study, the higher the grade, the higher the mean conducted along with these studies.
score of cellular phone addiction (F=50.21, In this study, a negative correlation was
p<.001). The higher the grade, the probability of observed between self-esteem and cellular phone
long time exposure to cellular phone is high. This addiction (r=-.367, p<.001), and negative
means that the cellular phone addiction risk of correlations were also observed between self-
higher grade students can be much higher than that esteem and three areas of cellular phone addiction.
of lower grade students. The result of this study can These results are consistent with previous studies
be explained in this context. Therefore, considering reporting the negative correlation between self-
the result of this study, 6th grade elementary school esteem and cellular phone addiction [16, 19, 21].
students can be the most risk group and needed Self-esteem is found in the majority of researches
more interest and interventions than any other on problematic use of cellular phone [21]. The
elementary school students. However, the younger personal trait most consistently associated with
the age of first possession of one's own cellular addictive behavior is low self-esteem and women
phone, the probability of cellular phone addictive with low self-esteem are the most vulnerable group
use is high [12]. Particularly, the greatest risks of [1]. To prevent and manage cellular phone addiction
problematic or addictive use are found when one's of elementary school students, various strategies
own phone is first obtained at an age of younger and interventions are needed. Considering the result
than 13 years [20]. The greater dependence of of this study and previous studies, self-esteem can
cellular phone exists in Korea [12], and the age of be the important factor of prediction and control the
firsts cellular phone possession is getting lower. cellular phone addiction of elementary school
Therefore, interventions and strategies according to students.
elementary school grade should be developed and In this study, mean scores of self-esteem were
applied to prevent and manage cellular phone 46.74 out of 65.00 (71.91 out of 100.0). This means
addiction. that elementary school students have generally low
In this study, the students living with parent(s) level of self-esteem. As mentioned above, many
showed higher score of cellular phone addiction previous studies for addictive behavior including
than other students (t=1.98, p=.048). Family cellular phone addiction showed that the lower the
strengths were negative correlation with cellular level of self-esteem, the probability of cellular
phone addiction of elementary school students [9]. phone addiction is high [1,21] . Addictive cellular
Parental factors were significantly related to cellular phone use is a function of the need for social
phone addiction of elementary school students, approval, time dedication writing and reading
among parental factors, open communication was message, the need for social approval has been
negative correlation, while problem communication associated with low self-esteem [3, 33]. The
and rejecting/restrictive or permissive/neglecting number of text message is frequently the result of
parenting behavior were positive correlation with addictive cellular phone use [12]. In additions,
cellular phone addiction of elementary school cellular phone is the preferred method of assessing
students [21]. However, this study investigate only the internet [6,12] and about 56 percent of internet
the family type and most students (86.6%) lived users access the web via their cellular phone [6].
with their parents. Therefore, repetitive studies Considering these fact, the probability of addictive
about family type and celluar phone addiction cellular phone use for internet searching can be also
should be conducted. highly associated with low self-esteem students.
In this study, cellular phone addiction Cellular phone addiction has been explained using
according to gender did not showed significant Attachment Theory, insecure attachment styles are
difference. Several studies reported that women associated with low self-esteem, thus, potential
5999
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
6000
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
[12] J. De-Sola Gutierrez, F. Rodriguez de Fonseca, [23] H.J. Jang, “The psychological characteristics
and G. Rubio, “Cell-phone addiction: A of adolescents addictive using cellular phone”,
review”, Front Psychiatry, Vol. 24, No. 7, Unpublished master’s thesis, Sungshin
2016, pp. 175. Women’s University, 2002.
[13] F.J. Labrador Encinas, and S.M. Villadangos [24] Y.S. Cho, “The effects of self-esteem and
Gonzalez, “Adolescents and new technologies: attatchment on interpersonal problem solving
Behaviours pointing a possibble addiction ability in adolescent”, Unpublished master's
problem”, Psicothema, Vol. 22, No. 2, 2010, thesis, Kookmin University. 1998.
pp. 180-188. [25] H.S. Yoo, K.O. Min, “Effect of mental health,
[14] J. Billieux, M. van der Linden, and L. Rochat, academic self-efficacy, school life adjustment
“The role of impulsivity in actual and on cellular phone addiction of elementary”, The
problematic use of the mobile phone”, Applied Journal of Child Education, Vol. 24, 2015, pp.
Cognitive Psychology, Vol. 22, No. 9, 2008, pp. 213-227.
1195-1210. [26] H.Y. Koo, “Effects of a prevention program for
[15] M. Choliz, “Mobile-phone addiction in media addiction on television addiction,
adolescence: The test of mobile phone internet addiction, cellular phone addiction,
dependence (TMSD)”, Progress in Health and impulsiveness in elementary school
Science, Vol. 2, No. 1, 2012, pp. 33-44. students”, Child Health Nursing Research,
[16] S.W. Jang, S.J. Kim, S.Y. Choi, and J.Y. Lee, Vol. 19, No.4, 2013, pp. 270-281.
“The effect of self-esteem, school adjustment, [27] J.Y. Lee, and H.K. Yu, “Development of a
mental health on elementary school students’ group counseling program to reduce cellular
cellular phone addiction”, The Journal of Child phone addiction tendency of elementary school
Education, Vol. 22, 2013, pp. 243-256. students in high grade”, The Korean Journal of
[17] R.A. Sansone, and L.A. Sansones, “Cell educational methodology Studies, Vol. 25,
phones: The psychosocial risks”, Innovations 2013, pp. 29-49.
in Clinical Neuroscience, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2013, [28] M. Hakoama, S. Hakoyma, “The impact of cell
pp. 33-37. phone use on social networking and developing
[18] J.C. Fondevila Gascon, M. Carreras Alcalde, among college students”, The American
J.L. Del Olmo Arriaga, and M.J. Pesqueira Association of Behavioral and Social Science
Zamora, “The impact of instant messaging in Journal, Vol. 15, 2011, pp. 1-20.
students in the form of stress and anxiety for [29] L.A. Jackson, Y. Zhao, A. Kolenin, H.E.
learning: Empirical analysis”, DIM, Vol. 30, Fitsgerald, R. Harold, and A. von Eye, “Race,
2014, pp. 1-15. gender, and information technology use: The
[19] J.H. Ha, B. Chin, D.H. Park, S.H. Ryu, and J. new digital divide”, Cyberpsychology and
Yu, “Characteristics of excessive cellular Behavior, Vol. 11, No. 4, 2008, pp. 437-442.
phoneuse in Korean adolescents”, [30] C. Jenaro, N. Flores, M. Gomez-Vela, F.
Cyberpsychology and Behavior, Vol. 11, No. 6, Gonzalez-Gil, and C. Caballo, “Problematic
2008, pp. 783-4. internet and cell-phone use: Psychological,
[20] S. Sahin, K. Ozdemir, A. Unsal, and N. Temiz, behavioral, and health correlates”, Addiction
“Evaluation of mobile phone addiction level Research and Theory, Vol. 15, No. 3, 2007, pp.
and sleep quality in university students”, 309-320.
Pakistan Journal of Medical Science, Vol. 29, [31] R. Junco, D. Merson, and D.W. Salter, “The
No. 4, 2013, pp. 913-918. effect of gender, ethnicity, and income on
[21] A.R. Lee, and K.G. Lee, “The effects of college students’ use of communication
parental factors, friend’s factors, and technologies”, Cyberpsychology, Behavior and
psychological factors on the addictive mobile Social Networking, Vol. 13, No. 6, 2010, pp.
phone use of children”, The Journal of Child 619-627.
Education, Vol. 21, 2012, pp. 27-39. [32] X. Carbonell, E. Guardiola, M. Beranuy, and
[22] O. Senormanci, O. Saracli, N. Atasoy, G. A. Belles, “A bibliometric analysis of the
Senormanci, F. Kokturk, and L. Atik, scientific literature on internet, video games,
“Relationship of internet addiction with and cell phone addiction”, Journal of the
cognitive style, personality, and depression in Medical Library Association, Vol. 97, No. 2,
university students”, Comprehensive 2009, pp. 102-107.
Pscychiatry, Vol. 55, No. 6, 2014, pp. 1385-
1390.
6001
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology
30th November 2017. Vol.95. No 22
© 2005 – ongoing JATIT & LLS
6002