Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FACTS: A Pickup Owned and Operated by National Irrigation Administration, A
FACTS: A Pickup Owned and Operated by National Irrigation Administration, A
FACTS: A Pickup Owned and Operated by National Irrigation Administration, A
government agency, then driven officially by Hugo Garcia who was employed as
their regular driver, bumped a bicycle ridden by Francisco Fontanilla, son of SPS
Fontanilla, and RestitutoDeligo, at Maasin, San Jose City along the Maharlika
Highway. As a result of the impact, Francisco Fontanilla and RestitutoDeligo were
injured and brought to the San Jose City Emergency Hospital for treatment.
Fontanilla was later transferred to the Cabanatuan Provincial Hospital where he
died.
The NIA was held liable for damages resulting to the death of the son of Spouses
Fonatanillacaused by the fault and/or negligence of the driver of the said agency.
The NIA maintains, however, that it does not perform solely and primarily
proprietary functions, but is an agency of the government tasked with governmental
functions, and is therefore not liable for the tortuous act of its driver Garcia, who
was not its special agent.
ISSUE: Whether or not the award of moral damages, exemplary damages and
attorney's fees is legally proper in a complaint for damages based on quasi-delict
which resulted in the death of the son of herein petitioners.