Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final BRP Pro
Final BRP Pro
Submitted To Submitted By
Prof. Pukhraj Kaur Sonu Raj
1
DECLARATION
I, student of Post Graduation Diploma in Management, hereby declare that I have successfully
2
Acknowledgement
I would like to extend my sincere thanks to SRMSIBS LUCKNOW for granting me this project.
My sincere thanks to prof. Pukhraj Kaur of the faculty of SRMSIBS, for his valuable
suggestions and who has been a great source of inspiration for me to work hard with sincerity.
I would like to give special thanks to Prof. Shyamal Gupta Director of my college without his
guidance and entering support this project would not been completed successfully.
I would also like to extend my gratitude towards my college guide Prof. Pukhraj Kaur and also
other members who has directly and indirectly helped in the successful completion of this
project.
Sonu Raj
3
ABSTRACT
Fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) or consumer packaged goods (CPG) are products that are
sold quickly and at relatively low cost. Examples include non-durable goods such as packaged
foods, beverages, toiletries, over-the-counter drugs and many other consumables. In contrast,
durable goods or major appliances such as kitchen appliances are generally replaced over a
period of several years.
Many fast moving consumer goods have a short shelf life, either as a result of high consumer
demand or because the product deteriorates rapidly. Some FMCGs, such as meat, fruits and
vegetables, dairy products, and baked goods, are highly perishable. Other goods, such as pre-
packaged foods, soft drinks, chocolate, candies, toiletries, and cleaning products, have high
turnover rates. The sales are sometimes influenced by holidays and seasons.
Favourable demographics and rise in income level to boost FMCG market FMCG market in
India is expected to grow at a CAGR of 20.6 per cent and is expected to reach US$ 103.7 billion
by 2020 from US$ 49 billion in 2016 Total consumption expenditure is set to increase at a
CAGR of 22.57 per cent from 2016-2021.Total consumption expenditure is expected to reach
nearly US$ 3600 billion by 2020 from US$ 1,595 billion in 2016 Rise in rural consumption to
drive the FMCG market .The rural FMCG market in India is expected to grow to US$ 220 billion
by 2025 from US$ 29.4 billion in 2016
CAGR
Nestlé S.A. is a Swiss transnational food and drink company headquartered in Vevey, Vaud,
Swit-zerland. It is the largest food company in the world, measured by revenues and other
metrics, since 2014. It ranked No. 64 on the Fortune Global 500 in 2017 and No. 33 on the 2016
edition of the Forbes Global 2000 list of largest public companies. Nestlé's products include baby
food, medical food, bottled water, breakfast cereals, coffee and tea, confectionery, dairy
products, ice cream, fro-zen food, pet foods, and snacks. Twenty-nine of Nestlé's brands have
annual sales of over CHF1 billion (about US$1.1 billion), including Nespresso, Nescafé, Kit Kat,
Smarties, Nesquik, Stouffer's, Vittel, and Maggi. Nestlé has 447 factories, operates in 194
countries, and employs around 339,000 people. It is one of the main shareholders of L'Oreal, the
world's largest cosmetics company.
Maggi is an international brand of seasonings, instant soups, and noodles that originated in
Switzerland in late 19th century. The Maggi company was acquired by Nestlé in 1947.
Different types of brand awareness of Maggi have been identified, namely brand recall and brand
recognition. Key researchers argue that these different types of awareness operate in
fundamentally different ways and that this has important implications for the purchase decision
process and for marketing communications. Brand awareness of Maggi is closely related to
concepts such as the evoked set and consideration set which describe specific aspects of the
consumer's purchase decision. Consumers are believed to hold between three and seven brands
in their consideration set across a broad range of product categories. Consumers will normally
purchase one of the top three brands in their consideration set.
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER – 1 INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER – 5 FINDINGS………………………………………………………………
CHAPTER – 7 CONCLUSION…………………………………………………………
BIBLOGRAPHY……………………………………………………….
ANNEXURE……………………………………………………………
5
Introduction
6
Retail means selling goods and services in small quantities directly to customers. Retailing
consists of all activities involved in marketing of goods and services directly to consumer for
The Indian retailing industry is becoming intensely competitive, as more and more payers are
Vying for the same set of customers. The major retail players are Pantaloon Retail, Shoppers
Retailing is one of the biggest sectors and it is witnessing revolution in India. The new entrant in
retailing in India signifies the beginning of retail revolution. India's retail market is expected to
grow tremendously in next few years. According to AT Kearney, The Windows of Opportunity
shows that Retailing in India was at opening stage in 1995 and now it is in peaking stage in 2006.
India's retail market is expected to grow tremendously in next few years. India shows US$330
billion retail market that is expected to grow 10% a year, with modern retailing just beginning.
India ranks first in 2005. In fact, in 2005 and 2006, India is the most compelling opportunity for
Sector details
2. Retail word is derived French word retailer means to cut off a piece.
3. Retailing includes all the activities involved in selling goods or services to the final
4. Supermarket is a retailing of a wide variety of consumer products under one roof, ample
7
History of retailing
Retail concept is old in India. World’s first departmental store started in Rome.
Haats, Melas, Mandis& door to door salesmen are traditional Indian retail.
Vishal Mega Mart is a retail sector, which is providing good quality of products in very
reasonable price than its competitors. Retailing and wholeselling consist of many organizations
designed to bring goods and services from the point of production to the point of use.
Retailing includes all the activities involved in selling goods or services directly to final
consumers for their personal, non-business use. Retailers can be classified in terms of store
Store retailers include many types, such as specialty stores, department stores, supermarkets,
stores, and catalog showrooms. These store forms have had different longevities and are at
different stages of the retail life cycle. Depending on the wheel-of-retailing, some will go out of
Non-store retailing is growing more rapidly than store retailing. It includes direct selling (door-
to-door, party selling), direct marketing, automatic vending, and buying services.
Much of retailing is in the hands of large retail organizations such as corporate chains, voluntary
merchandising conglomerates. More retail chains are now sponsoring diversified retailing lines
and forms instead of sticking to one form such as the department store.
Retailers, like manufacturers, must prepare marketing plans that include decisions on target
8
And place. Retailers are showing strong signs of improving their professional management and
their productivity, in the face of such trends as shortening retail life cycles, new retail forms,
increasing intertype competition, and polarity of retailing, new retail technologies, and many
others.
Wholesaling includes all the activities involved in selling goods or services to those who are
buying for the purpose of resale or for business use. Wholesalers help manufacturers deliver their
products efficiently to the many retailers and industrial users across the nation. Wholesalers
perform many functions, including selling and promoting, buying and assortment-building, bulk-
breaking, warehousing, transporting, financing, risk bearing, supplying market information, and
providing management services and counseling. Wholesalers fall into four groups. Merchant
wholesalers take possession of the goods and include full-service wholesalers (wholesale
truck wholesalers, drop shippers, rack jobbers, producers' cooperatives, and mail-order
wholesalers). Agents and brokers do not take possession of the goods but are paid a commission
for facilitating buying and selling. Manufacturers' and retailers' branches and offices are
wholesalers include agricultural assemblers, petroleum bulk plants and terminals, and auction
companies.
Wholesalers, too, must make decisions on their target market, product assortment and services,
pricing, promotion, and place. Wholesalers who fail to carry adequate assortments and inventory
wholesalers, on the other hand, are adapting marketing concepts and streamlining their costs of
doing business.
9
TECHNOLOGIES USED IN RETAILING SECTOR
In-store technologies-
Interactive kiosks
Body scanning
Online technology-
Online shopping
CHALLENGES
10
High stamp duties.
Lack of infrastructure.
FUTURE STRATEGY
It is projected that up to 2010 retail sector will be worth around US $ 300 billion.
FDI is going to increase rapidly, up to 2010 retail sector will become biggest industry in
India.
According to Indian Retail Report top 10 players in modern retail trade are going to
11
SECTOR DETAILS
In India, the most of the retail sector is unorganized. In India, the retail business contributes
around 10 percent of GDP. Of this, the organized retail sector accounts only for about 5 percent
share, and the expected annual growth rate is 5% per annum and remaining share is
contributed by the unorganized sector. The main challenge facing the organized sector is the
competition from unorganized sector. Unorganized retailing has been there in India for centuries,
theses are named as mom-pop stores. The main advantage in unorganized retailing is consumer
familiarity that runs from generation to generation. It is a low cost structure, they are mostly
operated by owners, has very low real estate and labor costs and has low taxes to pay. And it also
In late 1990's the retail sector has witnessed a level of transformation. Retailing is being
perceived as a beginner and as an attractive commercial business for organized business i.e. the
pure retailer is starting to emerge now. Organized retail business in India is very small but has
tremendous scope. The total in 2005 stood at $225 billion, accounting for about 10% of GDP. In
this total market, the organized retail accounts for only $8 billion of total revenue. According to
A T Kearney, the organized retailing is expected to be more than $23 billion revenue by 2010.
In organized retailing will grow faster than unorganized sector and the growth speed will be
responsible for its high market share, which is expected to be $ 17 billion by 2010-11.
The organized sector is expected to grow faster than GDP growth in next few years driven by
favorable demographic patterns, changing lifestyles, and strong income growth. This organized
retail sector mix includes supermarkets, hypermarkets discounted stores and specialty stores,
12
departmental stores. For example, Spencer network has 69 stores, which includes seven Spencer
hypermarkets, three Spencer super markets and 49 Spencer Daily’s. Now the company is
planning to open 20 stores in 10 cities in six months. The top 10 retailers account only for 2% of
total market, today modern retailing is expected to enter a boom phase, which has major players
and these players might capture 10% of total market, within next five years. The retail sales in
India for future are shown below (data from 2005-2008 is based on estimates)
13
The trend in the Industry
Another credible factor in the prospects of the retail sector in India is the increase in the young
working population. In India, hefty pay packets, nuclear families in urban areas, along with
increasing working-women population and emerging opportunities in the services sector. These
key factors have been the growth drivers of the organized retail sector in India which now boast
of retailing almost all the preferences of life - Apparel & Accessories, Appliances, Electronics,
Cosmetics and Toiletries, Home & Office Products, Travel and Leisure and many more. With
this the retail sector in India is witnessing rejuvenation as traditional markets make way for new
14
Existing competition
Reliance fresh.
Shopper’s Shoppe.
Subhiksha.
Big bazaar.
Patanjali Stors
The untapped scope of retailing has attracted superstores like Wal-Mart into India, leaving
behind the kiranas that served us for years. Such companies are basically IT based. The other
important participants in the Indian Retail sector are Bata, Big Bazaar, Pantaloons, Archies, Cafe
Indian Retail Industry is standing at its point of inflexion, waiting for the boom to take place.
The inception of the retail industry dates back to times where retail stores were found in the
village fairs, Mela’s or in the weekly markets. These stores were highly unorganized. The
maturity of the retail sector took place with the establishment of retail stores in the locality for
15
convenience. With the government intervention the retail industry in India took a new shape.
Outlets for Public Distribution System, Cooperative stores and Khadi stores were set up. These
retail Stores demanded low investments for its establishment. International Brand Outlets, Hyper
Future of organized retail in India looks bright. According to recent researches it is projected to
grow at a rate of about 37% in 2007 and at a rate of 42% in 2008. It will capture a share of 10%
India retail industry is the largest industry in India, with an employment of around 8% and
contributing to over 10% of the country's GDP. Retail industry in India is expected to rise 25%
yearly being driven by strong income growth, changing lifestyles, and favorable demographic
patterns.
It is expected that by 2016 modern retail industry in India will be worth US$ 175- 200 billion.
India retail industry is one of the fastest growing industries with revenue expected in 2007 to
amount US$ 320 billion and is increasing at a rate of 5% yearly. A further increase of 7-8% is
expected in the industry of retail in India by growth in consumerism in urban areas, rising
incomes, and a steep rise in rural consumption. It has further been predicted that the retailing
industry in India will amount to US$ 21.5 billion by 2010 from the current size of US$ 7-billion.
16
Shopping in India has witnessed a revolution with the change in the consumer buying behavior
and the whole format of shopping also altering. Industry of retail in India which have become
modern can be seen from the fact that there are multi- stored malls, huge shopping centers, and
sprawling complexes which offer food, shopping, and entertainment all under the same roof.
India retail industry is expanding itself most aggressively; as a result a great demand for real
estate is being created. Indian retailers preferred means of expansion is to expand to other
regions and to increase the number of their outlets in a city. It is expected that by 2010, India
In the Indian retailing industry, food is the most dominating sector and is growing at a rate of 9%
annually. The branded food industry is trying to enter the India retail industry and convert Indian
consumers to branded food. Since at present 60% of the Indian grocery basket consists of non-
branded items.
As the contemporary retail sector in India is reflected in sprawling shopping centers, multiplex-
malls and huge complexes offer shopping, entertainment and food all under one roof, the concept
of shopping has altered in terms of format and consumer buying behavior, ushering in a
revolution in shopping in India. This has also contributed to large-scale investments in the real
estate sector with major national and global players investing in developing the infrastructure
17
Growth Drivers
Rising incomes and improvements in infrastructure are enlarging consumer markets and
Advent of dual income families also helps in the growth of retail sector.
Shift in consumer demand to foreign brands like McDonalds, Sony, Panasonic, etc.
The Internet revolution is making the Indian consumer more accessible to the growing
Channels are helping in creating awareness about global products for local markets.
About 47% of India's population is under the age of 20; and this will increase to 55% by
2015. This young population, which is technology-savvy, watch more than 50 TV satellite
channels, and display the highest propensity to spend, will immensely contribute to the
18
Employment opportunities in retail sector in India
India's retail industry is the second largest sector, after agriculture, which provides employment.
Retail companies are starting retail management courses in partnership with management
institutes, roping in talent from other sectors and developing comprehensive career growth and
Top players like Pantaloon Retail India Limited, Trent, Shopper's Stop, RPG Group and ebony
Consider the plans of largest player, The Pantaloon Retail India Ltd, the company has developed
a comprehensive strategy, where in it expects that in 2years, it will not recruit any new managers
from outside.
"The estimated need is 1 lakh of employees till 2011", said Mr. Sanjoy Jog, HR Head at
Pantaloon Retail India Ltd. Pantaloon has the concept of partnership with educational Institute to
run retail courses across the entire chain. Trent has also started in-house learning programmers
Since, the job market is hugely receptive to this with more and more business schools focusing
19
Challenges of Retailing in India
In India the Retailing industry has a long way to go, and to become a truly flourishing industry,
* The first challenge facing the organized retail sector is the competition from unorganized
sector.
* Organized retail sector has to pay huge taxes, which is negligible for small retail business.
Many agencies have estimated differently about the size of organized retail market in 2010.
The one thing that is common amongst these estimates is that Indian organized retail market
will be very big in 2010. The status of the retail industry will depend mostly on external factors
like Government regulations and policies and real estate prices, besides the activities of
retailers and demands of the customers also show impact on retail industry.
Competition in retail
IndiaRetailBiz attempts to capture excitement of Retail Business in India by aggregating the best
in news, views, research, analysis, trends, technology, and competition dents retail sector
growth.
20
The performance of the retail sector in the last quarter of financial year 2008-09 has been a
gloomy one. Not only has the quarter-on-quarter growth declined by 700 basis point, on year-on-
year (YoY) basis, sales growth fell drastically from 67.8% to 49.1%. Including the recently listed
Koutons and Vishal Retail, all big retailers continue to be on an aggressive expansion mode. This
kind of competition is having a negative impact on margins of retailers, as the target audience for
The slowdown has triggered a volume game in the industry. Strategies like promotional
campaigns, freebies, promoting private labels and online discounts are just some of the avenues
that retailers are looking at to lure customers. According to analysts, this is a knee-jerk reaction
by the industry to fight the inflation-induced dent in the purchasing power of customers. As they
say, retail is a number game, so, big retailers are trying to push volumes. For some, it comes at
the cost of profit. Meanwhile, in contrast to YoY sales growth of 49% for the sector, the interest
cost has registered a whopping 96% growth. Though growing at a lesser 39%, depreciation cost
The cost factor too is adding to the woes. For instance, during the quarter, Shoppers Stop opened
its new stores in various formats. Provogue and Pantaloon followed soon. The companies are
increasing their geographical presence in the wake of increasing competition. Launch of new
formats continues to catch the attention of these retailers. In fact, a couple of these new formats
are already generating profit at the operating level, thus showing a positive sign towards growth.
Like for Shoppers Stop, the average transaction size increased by about 7% for the current
quarter over the same quarter in the previous year. Players like Provogue and Pantaloons too
have witnessed a similar upward movement. Also, though growth in total expenses as a whole
21
has almost been equivalent to the growth in sales at about 47%, some individual cost items like
staff costs, selling and administration costs are under control. On a YoY basis, staff cost has
grown at 26% against 44% in the corresponding quarter of the previous year.
Nonetheless, raw material cost continues to remain high - it grew by 66% in the last quarter and
now is equivalent to 74% of the industry's aggregate net sales. This is the reason why operating
margins have reduced to 4.8% of the revenue sale compared with 5.7% during the corresponding
Among individual retailers, Pantaloon Retail continues to outgrow the industry - it recorded 57%
a YoY growth in net sales during March 2008 quarter. Although it is lower compared with the
63% growth recorded during the December quarter, momentum continues to favor the company.
New stores drove the growth in value-for-money format - strategies such as KB's Fair Price and
online shopping are picking up. Their home store division has also been doing well. Next on
growth charts is Provogue, which grew 40% in the last quarter, similar to the previous quarter.
In short, setting up of new stores has resulted in higher working capital funding, which has raised
the industry's interest outgo. For Pantaloon, interest cost has almost doubled during the current
quarter - as a proportion of sales, it has increased from 2.7% to 3.2% on a YoY basis. Provogue
seems to be an exception in this as it recorded the highest increase of 100 basis points in interest
cost for March 2008. Overall, the profitability margin has seen a sharp decline.
Only Shoppers Stop has registered some profit compared with its performance in the
corresponding quarter of the previous year. The company's net profit margin now stands at 0.7%
of net sales as compared to -1% in March 2007 quarter. It can be concluded that margins of retail
22
companies seem to have been hit by costs related to their ambitious expansion programmer.
Expansion plans for some of them are running behind schedule. It has led to higher interest cost,
yet retail companies are trying hard to cut costs by keeping inventory and carrying costs under
control.
July 8, 2008
23
Big retailers at loggerheads with MNCs over brands
A serious conflict is brewing between Indian retailers and multinationals over imports of global
brands. To stay afloat in the dog-eat-dog world of retail, local retailers have reached
arrangements with overseas players to bring in some international brands, rattling many MNCs
who manufacture or market these products locally. In some cases, these brands have not yet been
introduced in India.
Several major MNCs with a long presence in India are invoking the Intellectual Property Rights
(imported goods) Enforcement Rules 2007 to stop retailers from importing foreign brands.
Hindustan Unilever, L’Oreal, Lancome Perfumes, Oakley Inc, Nivea and Mico have already
registered several brands with the Customs department. Sources said other MNCs are expected to
follow suit.
Market circles perceive this as a move to prevent Indian retailers from getting first access to
these brands. Some of the retailers are debating plans to legally contest the move, since they
possess a free sale certificate from the source of import. Retailers like Big Bazaar & Food
Bazaar, Reliance Retail, Spencer’s and Sankalp Retail (MyDollarStore), among others, have
begun importing sizeable consignments of leading consumer brands and their variants for better
However, the multinationals are not amused, and claim that it leads to loss of business
opportunity, unfair competition and product cannibalization. The fundamental issue here,
according to analysts, is that the Indian arms of the leading FMCG companies would like to
24
control the way their brands are marketed and sold. They would also like to determine when new
A key reason for retailers to step up imports is bottom lines. Profit margins on imported products
are around 20% more than local brands, where producers and retailers are at loggerheads over
sharing margins.
“We are concerned over issues like protecting the properties of our brands, including quality and
consumer perception. Such unplanned imports create brand confusion in the minds of consumers,
since the properties of an imported brand are completely different from the domestic ones, which
are localized to suit the specific region’s requirements. An unpleasant experience may work
against our brand,” said a high-ranking official in a leading multinational, which makes personal
care products.
Retailers claim they are creating ‘demand in advance’ for the multinationals, which would
otherwise have to invest heavily in marketing and ad spends to promote the brands. Analysts say
the developments are the natural effects of a globalised market that India is moving towards,
July 7, 2008
25
Types of Retailing
There are several types we can see in Retailing. They are like:
Specialty Store:
Narrow product line with deep assortment, viz apparel stores, book stores etc. A clothing store
would be a single line store, men's clothing store would be limited line store &men's custom-
Departmental Store:
Several products lines-typically clothing, household goods, home furnishings- with each line
Supermarkets:
Relatively large, low-cost, low-margin, high volume, self-service operation designed to serve
Convenience Stores:
Relatively small store located near residential area, open long hours, seven days a week and
26
Discount Store:
Standard merchandise sold at lower prices with lower margins and higher volumes. True
discount stores regularly sell merchandise at lower prices and offer mostly national brands.
Off-price retailer:
Merchandise bought at less than regular wholesale prices & sold at less than retail; often-leftover
goods, overruns and irregulars obtained at reduced prices from manufacturers or other retailers.
Factory outlets are owned and operated by manufacturers and normally carry the manufacturer's
Independent off-price retailers are owned & run by entrepreneurs or by divisions of larger retail
corporations.
Superstore:
Averages 35,000 square feet of selling space traditionally aimed at meeting consumers' total
needs for routinely purchased food and non-food items. Usually offer services such as laundry,
A new group called "category killers" carries a deep assortment in a particular category & a
knowledgeable staff.
27
Combination stores are a diversification of the supermarket store into the growing drug-and-
prescription field. Combination food & drug stores average 55,000 square feet of selling space.
Hypermarkets range between 80,000 and 220,000 square feet and combine supermarket, discount
& warehouse retailing principles. Product assortment goes beyond routinely purchased goods &
includes furniture, large & small appliances, clothing items and many other items. Bulk display
& minimum handling by store personnel with discounts offered to customers who are willing to
carry heavy appliances and furniture out of the store. Hypermarkets originated in France.
Example: Carrefour and Casino (France), Pyrca, Continente and Alcampo (Spain).
28
EMERGING TRENDS IN INDIAN ORGANIZED RETAIL SECTOR
BPO (Business Process outsourcing) is one of the fastest growing segments of the Information
Technology Enabled Services (ITES) industry in India. Business Process Outsourcing refers to
the delegation of one or more IT-intensive business process to an external provider that in turn
owns administers and manages the selected process based on defined and measurable
performance criteria. The Indian BPO industry is constantly growing and a lot of fortune 500
companies are outsourcing services to India. There are several reasons for India’s emergence as
one of leading outsourcing destinations. India is very rich in educated and talented human
resource. India is one of the pioneers in software development. India has an excellent technical
facilities and infrastructure for setting up call centers. Time zone difference between India and
America has also worked to the advantage of Indian BPO industry. India has an 8-12 hour time
zone difference with respect to the US and other developed markets. Most of the Indian cell
centers servicing American customers have timings between 5:30 pm to 9:30 am this time zone
difference allows Indian companies BPO’s to service American clients by working in the nights.
last but not the least India has huge pool of English speaking workforce that provides excellent
voice based services at extremely competitive costs resulting in huge savings for companies.
GE capital.
Converges
Dell
29
ICICI One Source
MphasiS.
Inflation in India
Inflation in India is at an acceptable level and remains much lower than in many other
developing countries. But off late prices of essential commodities such as food grain, edible oil,
vegetables etc have risen sharply and in the process driving up the inflation rate.
Inflation is defined as a sustained increase in the general level of prices for goods and services. It
is measured as an annual percentage increase. As inflation rises the value of currency goes down.
The current rise in inflation has its roots in supply-side factors. There was shortfall in domestic
production vis-à-vis domestic demand and hardening of international pieces, prices of primary
commodities, mainly food items. Wheat, pulses, edible oils, fruits and vegetables, and
condiments and spices have been the major contributors to the higher inflation rate of primary
articles. The inflation was also accompanied by buoyant growth of money and credit. While
GDP growth zoomed to 9.0 per cent per annum, the board money (M3) grew by more than 20
per cent.
Inflation is calculated on the bases of Wholesale Price Index (WPI) while in other countries it is
The emerging trends in the Indian organized retail sector would help the economic growth in
India.
30
There is a fantastic rise in the Indian organized retail sector in a very short period of time
between 2001 and 2006. Eventually, out of the shadows of the unorganized retail sector, India
The emerging trends in the Indian organized retail sector are also adding up to the development
of the Indian organized retail sector. The relaxation by the government on regulatory controls on
foreign direct investments has added to the process of the growth of the Indian organized retail
sector.
The infrastructure of the retail sector will evolve radically in the recent future. The emergences
of shopping malls are increasing at a steady pace in the metros and there are further plans of
expansion which would lead to 150 new ones coming up in India by 2008. As the count of super
markets is going up much faster than rate of growth in retail sector, it is taking the lion’s share in
food trade.
The growth of the Indian organized retail sector is anticipated to be heavier than the growth of
the gross domestic product. Alterations in people's lifestyle, growth in income levels, and
encouraging conventions of demography are proving favorable for the new emerging trends in
The success of this retail sector would also lie in the degree of penetration into the lower income
31
strata to tap the possible customers in the lowest levels of society. The demands of the buyers
With the arrival of the Transnational Companies (TNC), the Indian retail sector will undergo a
transformation. At present the Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) is not encouraged in the Indian
organized retail sector but once the TNC'S get in they inevitably try to oust their Indian
The Indian Organized retail sector will grow up to 10% of total retailing by 2010.
No one single format can be assumed, as there is a huge difference in cultures regionally.
The hyper mart format would be further encouraged with the entry of the TNCs
Current Scenario
47 global fortune companies & 25 of Asia's top 200 companies are retailers
32
Percentage of Organized Retail
USA - 85%
Taiwan - 81%
Malaysia - 55%
Thailand - 40%
Brazil - 36%
Indonesia - 30%
Poland - 20%
China - 20%
India - 3%
33
THE OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT
This Project work has certain objectives behind it. Without any proper objective one cannot plan
its implementation. If the objective of the study is not proper then the whole research is of no
use.
In India there are many sectors where the different companies or 34 organization functions
within, we have chosen the Patanjali, ayurvedic and herbal sector which directly deals with
people issues.
Basically our main objective was to see that the bend of the Indian people towards Patanjali is
because of it being a swadeshi brand, herbal and ayurvedic brand or some of the other factors.
To compare the brands of Patanjali with various competitors (Dabur & HUL).
Which is most preferred brand (Patanjali) in retail store like big bazaar and other stores.
34
RATIONALE FOR THE PROJECT
The rational of research to find out the retailers view about patanjali product.What are the
challenges faced by retailer. Where the company stand after five years.To analyze sell of
patanjali and their competitors and what are the perception and brand loyalty of the product
Each company makes its own strategies for its products and brand. These strategies are made
keeping in to consideration all the internal (employees, stake holders, financial conditions) and
external (customers, competitors) factors. These strategies directly help the company to increase
the demand for its customer product which then helps increase the sales. These strategies could
35
Literature review
Verma and Madan (2011)in a study conducted in Indian context highlighted that retailers
are offering newer service dimensions to create unique shopping experiences for the customers.
However, whether consumers are able to perceive newer service dimensions and getting affected
for store patronage in new store formats or not, remains to be found out. They emphasized the
fact that Indian retail environment is going through a sea change due to the introduction of
the store image perceptions of consumers here. The study attempted to find out the key factors
Jayawardhena (2011)in a study conducted in Central India, tested a conceptual model of the
effects of customer and service orientation (SO) behaviours of individual retail employees on
individual customers’ perceptions of service encounter quality (SEQ), service quality (SQ),
value, satisfaction, and behavioural intentions (BI).The sample was customers of a supermarket
in central India, and they completed questionnaires following mall intercept. To test the
hypotheses, structural equation modelling was employed. They found that service and customer
orientation (CO) behaviours are positively related to SEQ and SQ; SEQ is positively related to
36
satisfaction; and customer satisfaction is positively related to retail customers’ BI. However the
Ghosh, Tripathi and Kumar (2010) in their study conducted in Indian context, attempted
to address issues related to store attributes and their relevance in the store format selection.
Eleven variables (store attributes) had been identified based on theory and judgment. Factor
analysis had yielded three factors: Convenience and Merchandise Mix, Store Atmospherics, and
Services. The factors identified and recommendations made would be of use to retailers in
designing their outlets with store attributes that would meet the expectations of shoppers and thus
Gomtinagar area of Lucknow city analyzed a marketing strategy for a modern Food and Grocery
market based on consumer preferences and behaviour. The researchers personally surveyed a
total of 101 households having sufficient purchasing power using structured questionnaire. The
results indicated that preferences of the consumers were their priority for cleanliness and
freshness of food products followed by price, quality, variety, packaging, and availability of non-
seasonal fruits and vegetables. It was found that the consumers' preferences of marketplace
largely depend on the convenience in purchasing at the marketplace along with the availability of
37
additional services, attraction for children, basic amenities, and affordability. Results also
suggested that most of the Food and Grocery items are purchased in loose form from the nearby
outlets, whereas fruits and vegetables are mostly purchased daily or twice a week due to their
Hemalatha, Ravichandran and Lakshmi (2010) found that there is a dearth of tested
instruments which could measure customer-perceived service quality of a retail store in the
Indian context. In order to understand the driving factors of a typical Indian retail customer, the
key objective of their study was to empirically test the service quality dimensions. The study also
carried out the gap analysis and identified the areas for improvements in retail service quality.
Chakraborty (2010) in a study conducted in Hyderabad, India identified the driving shopping
motives of Indian consumer for Discount store formats. Factor analysis extracted three shopping
motives, two of which related to hedonic shopping motive and one to utilitarian. The factors
were named as diversion, socialization and utilitarian. Other three dimensions of the study were
store attributes, shopping outcomes, and shopping perceived cost. Under each dimension, factors
related to Discount store were identified. The identified factors could be the key for discount
Seock and Lin (2010) examined the cultural influences on young consumers’ loyalty
tendency and evaluations of the relative importance of apparel retail store attributes in Taiwan
and the USA. A structured questionnaire was developed to collect the data. Factor 63 analysis
was employed to identify dimensions of apparel retail store image attributes. Multivariate
analysis of variance and hierarchical multiple regression analysis were used to examine the
38
hypotheses. Results of the study showed that American consumers have significantly greater
collectivistic characteristics than Taiwanese. The study also found that country of residence is a
significant and stronger indicator in predicting loyalty tendency than individualism and
collectivism dimensions. The results of the study showed that evaluation of the relative
importance of retail store attributes is influenced by culture. Among the five apparel retail store
attribute dimensions identified in the study, Taiwanese and US respondents’ evaluation of the
whether influx of large stores is inevitable, by focusing on consumers' motivation for selecting a
retail store, and the association between these motivation dimensions and the shopping
patronage. The results indicated that consumer's preference for small stores is positively
motivated by functional benefits and familiarity with small stores; and negatively associated with
the functional benefits offered by large stores. These motivational dimensions were also found to
be positively associated with the share of wallet spent at small stores. It was found that gender
exhibited mixed effect on preference for small stores and the share of wallet. The study revealed
that women feel that large stores provide better functional benefits and support for the local
economy.
conventional grocery stores as compared to specialty grocery stores. Their study examined store
39
attributes of product assortment, price, quality and service in order to determine which attributes
had the greatest impact on store satisfaction for each store format. The results showed that
perception of satisfaction were higher among specialty grocery store customers compared to
conventional grocery store customers. For both store formats, the study found that store price,
product assortment, service and quality positively influenced satisfaction. Stepwise regression
indicated that each store attribute contributed differently to store satisfaction for conventional
Mittal (2009)compared the consumer evaluation of store attributes for grocery and apparel
retail segment. The author emphasized that the retail format which represents the right mix of
various store dimensions, will eventually depend upon the interplay between various store
attributes. This study used a research instrument developed by the author in an earlier study for
the comparative analysis. A very significant pointer from this research was that while there is
some commonality of attributes between retail sectors, the precise importance and mix is,
arguably, determined more by the motivation of the customer behind each specific shopping
excursion. The grocery and apparel store attributes dimensions that had emerged from this study
proved that the factors were different in terms of their composition and importance.
a study on Spanish consumers, identified the factors whose perception had the greatest influence
on customer satisfaction. The authors analyzed a database of 422 Spanish consumers who
purchased from different types of self service grocery stores in a representative Spanish city. The
findings revealed that among consumers who exhibited a low propensity to buy store brands,
40
perceptions of the quality image, as well as perceptions of service and convenience, had positive
and significant influences on the maximum level of customer satisfaction. However, for those
consumers who were not prone to buying store brands, only the perception of services and
convenience influenced their maximum level of satisfaction. This research found the features
which could help retailers focus their strategies on appropriate consumer targets and thus attain a
store image attributes and customer satisfaction in the market environment of Greece and
investigated the stability of the structural relationships between store image attributes and
customer satisfaction across different customer groups. They identified four specific types of
buyers, namely, the Typical, the Unstable, the Social, and the Occasional. While four of the six
examined for the degree of invariance between the four groups only pricing and products-related
Kamath (2009) in a study conducted in context of Mangalore city of India, found that
consumer satisfaction and loyalty being closely related, the marketing strategies of retailers must
focus on customer retention. The authors emphasized that working out strategies in this direction
required a thorough understanding of the preferences of the consumers on the attributes that are
considered of much significance. They attempted to analyze the consumer’s preferences of the
specific attributes of retail store in Mangalore city. Factor analysis had been used in identifying
the main factors. These factors included shopping experience and ease, entertainment and
41
gaming facilities, promotion, discounts and low prices, add-on facilities and services, variety of
Bhardwaj (2009) measured the links between attribute perceptions and consumer
satisfaction, and between consumer satisfaction and sales performance, in the food retail sector
of India. The study relied upon an extensive data set of consumer satisfaction and sales
information from approximately 180 consumers. Hypothesis constructed addressed the inherent
nonlinearities and asymmetries in these links. The author also provided an example of how firms
could use the estimated linkages to develop satisfaction policies that are predicted to increase
store revenues. First, the author examined nonlinearities and asymmetries in the satisfaction-
sales performance links based on an empirical study. Second, the study advanced the
measurement of behavioural links between consumer satisfaction and performance in the food
retail sector with firm-specific data. Third, the study showed how firms can employ such results
to develop appropriate consumer satisfaction policies. In the case of the cooperating retail
company in this study, the results suggested that managers should focus on consumer service,
quality and value to affect overall consumer satisfaction and its ultimate impact on sales.
Chaubey (2009) in his study conducted in Garhwal Region of Uttrakhand state of India,
identified the consumer perception and their behaviour toward store image, store patronage and
store loyalty. The findings of research indicated that originality of the product is given highest
preference by the respondents and they believe that retail showroom offers original product. It
was followed by the availability of the product in large variety. The relationship and services
offered by the retailer had emerged as another important issue which was given due
42
consideration and scored better in consumer’s preference list. The importance of 66 recognition
of consumers’ value system and the discount offered by the retailer were found to be other
important factors which respondent had considered in selecting the retail showroom.
Goyal and Aggarwal (2009) examined the relative importance of the various products
purchased at organized retail outlets and the choice of format the consumer had, when
purchasing a product. The results showed that not all items are equally important for retail outlets
Choudhary and Sharma (2009) conducted a study in Chandigarh Tricity (Chandigarh and
its satellite cities of Mohali and Panchkula), keeping in view the dynamically growing organized
retail in the region. The data of 200 retailers for the study covered time frame from the year 2007
to 2008. After an extensive literature review it was pertinent that size of retail stores and their
location played a significant role in measuring the operational efficiency of retail stores. An
empirical analysis was conducted using chi-square test of independence to understand the role
and contribution of type of retail formats on operational efficiency and to examine the impact of
location on the same. It was concluded from the data analysis that there was significant influence
of format of retail stores and location on the operational efficiency. However, the degree of
Reuttere and Teller (2009) in a study conducted in Central Europe, identified store format
attributes that impact the store format choice when consumers conduct fill-in or major trips to
buy groceries. Their study found that consumers patronise multiple (store based) formats
43
depending on the shopping situation operationalized by the type of shopping trip. The study
adopted the conceptual framework of random utility theory via application of a multinomial logit
modelling framework. The analysis was based on a survey of 408 consumers representing
households. The results revealed a considerable moderating effect of the shopping situation on
the relationship between perceived store format attributes and store format choice. It was found
that consumers’ utilities are significantly higher for Discount stores and Hypermarkets when
conducting major trips. To the contrary, it found that Supermarkets are preferred for fill-in trips
Alhemoud (2008) studied the product selection processes of Kuwaiti nationals based on their
shopping habits in the Co-operative Supermarkets (Government owned grocery stores). This 67
study attempted to explore the determinant attributes that influence the patronage decisions of
accidental sampling procedure, fourteen store attributes were identified. These attributes were
personnel, accessibility, and promotion. A stepwise regression showed that merchandise image
was the most salient in determining the frequency of Supermarket shopping. The results of study
also showed that none of the demographic characteristics of consumers have an impact on the
perceived importance of the promotion image. Most of the differences among the categories of
the consumers' demographic characteristics were found in the accessibility image, providing
possible explanation for why the rank of the importance of accessibility elements varies
44
Kaul (2007) in a study conducted in the city of Banglore, examined the applicability of Retail
Service Quality Scale (RSQS) developed in the US in India. RSQS has five dimensions and six
sub-dimensions and has been found appropriate in a variety of settings — across different
countries such as South Africa and Singapore and across a variety of store types such as
Supermarkets, Department stores, and Hyper stores. The five dimensions — Physical Aspects,
Reliability, Personal Interaction, Problem Solving, and Policy are believed to capture distinct
though correlated aspects of retail service. Each of the first three dimensions has two sub-
dimensions. These six sub-dimensions, also called the first-order factors, are labelled as
Courteousness/Helpfulness. Data using a survey questionnaire from 144 adult shoppers at large
format apparel stores indicated that the RSQS dimensions and sub-dimensions were not clearly
identifiable. The study found that the dimension of ‘Physical Appearance’ is the only one that is
relatively clear. All other dimensions were found to be ill-defined. The dimension of ‘Problem-
Solving’ was found to be hazy and all the remaining dimensions of RSQS comprised one factor.
The study concluded that RSQS has limited diagnostic application and is inappropriate for
application in Indian retail. Pre-test interviews of shoppers indicated that several service aspects
Mishra (2007) highlighted that the rapid growth of retailing in recent years has necessitated the
upcoming many new firms to benchmark. Retail firms are concerned about the available
resources and their optimum utilization with respect to consumers’ need and preference. The 68
study compared the performance of some selected retail stores using benchmarking in retailing.
The study had used Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) to assess the relative efficiency of the
45
retail stores. The results of data analysis showed that only sales cannot increase the efficiency of
a retail store
Lather and Kaur (2006) in their study on Malls in India analysed the influence of selected
attributes on store patronage for doing shopping. The authors highlighted that shopper decision
on retail format depends upon store characteristics. Keeping these facts, the researchers had
studied the nine characteristics of Malls to elaborate the enthralling shopping experiences. The
study provided academics, Mall developers and retailers a richer understanding of various
components that contribute to malls experiences. In a study exploring the key factors influencing
customer preferences as applied to the concept of ‘Amul Preferred Outlets’ (which are franchisee
Rao and Kapoor (2006) identified 14 variables to study the store choice criteria. These 14
factors were subject to data reduction through factor analysis that identified three factors namely:
Sinha, Mathew and Kansal (2005) found that format choice is a cognitive process.
According to them, like any other purchasing decision, format choice is also information
processing behaviour. They emphasized that a store is chosen based on the confidence that the
customer has about the nature and quality of product and service the consumer will receive. In
Indian scenario, formats had been found to be influencing the choice of store as well as
orientation of the shoppers. Their study analyzed the various factors influencing decision making
process of customers in choosing a store format. A full-profile procedure was used for the
46
Conjoint Analysis in this study. The study also helped identifying the important factor set which
Grace and Cass (2004) explored the extent to which patronage intentions of retail stores are
affected by perceived value for money, customer satisfaction and consumption feelings. In
addition, they examined the effect of store service provision as an antecedent to such consumer
evaluations of retail stores. These relationships were modelled overall and then examined in the
image and high customer service) and Discount stores (defined as massmerchandisers with an
emphasis on self-service and low prices). While all paths (except one) were found to be
significant in the overall model, differences were found when comparing the Department and
Discount store models. The study found that perceived value for money played a much more
significant role in the Discount store model, whereas consumption feelings were found to be
more central to the Department store model. In a study to determine predictors of store choice in
Sinha and Banerjee (2004) found the following factors determining store choice:
proximity, merchandise, ambience, service, and patronized store. They found that for grocery
stores the most important factors are: proximity, visiting the store for many years, and
Gómez, McLaughlin and Wittink (2004) in a study on US food retail sector, measured
the links between store attribute perceptions and customer satisfaction, and between customer
47
satisfaction and sales performance. The authors constructed a statistical model to address
nonlinearities and asymmetries in the satisfaction-sales performance links, and illustrated how
retailers can affect store revenues by managing customer satisfaction. Contributions of the study
included the analysis of behavioral consequences of customer satisfaction in the food retail
an empirical model of first differences, and a discussion of how managers could employ the
Grewal, Baker, Levy, and Voss (2003) emphasized that many factors, both obvious and
subtle, influence customers’ store patronage intentions. They experimentally manipulated the
number of visible store employees, number of customers, and music using video technology and
tested the relative importance of wait expectations and store atmosphere evaluations on
patronage intentions. These constructs were found to be critical antecedents of store patronage
intentions in the context of the service-intensive retail store at which the model was tested. They
also found support for the direct effects of gender on wait expectations and store atmosphere
evaluations. 70 Voss and Parasuraman (2003) found that the purchase preference is primarily
determined by price rather than quality during pre-purchase evaluation. Their study found that
quality perceptions. Instead, post consumption quality evaluations had a favorable impact on
price evaluations.
Solgaard and Hansen (2003) identified several store attributes that were considered
important for the consumer's evaluation of stores. These attributes included merchandise,
48
assortment, merchandise quality, personnel, store layout, accessibility, cleanliness and
atmosphere.
Veerapong and Pitsuwan (2002) examined the attitude and consumer behaviour toward
should be different depending on the type of Supermarkets. The study found that in case of
Supermarkets in discount store format, customers typically prefer the stores that offer reasonable
product price and sales promotion. In addition, store atmosphere was found to be the least
significant factor in accounting for the preferences for consumers of Supermarkets in discount
Grewal and Parasuraman (2002) proposed a comprehensive store choice model that
included (1) three types of store environment cues (social, design, and ambient) as exogenous
constructs, (2) various store choice criteria (including shopping experience costs that had not
been included in store choice models) as mediating constructs, and (3) store patronage intentions
as the endogenous construct. They empirically examined the extent to which environmental cues
influence consumers’ assessments of a store on various store choice criteria and how those
Sinha, Banerjee and Uniyal (2002) found that shoppers choose the store based on many
aspects that could be classified as primary and image based. It was also found that the
49
importance of each of these aspects changes with the kind of store the shopper wants to visit.
They attempted to understand this behaviour of the shopper. The study explored the shoppers for
the primary reasons for choosing a store. Then, using a factor analysis, the several image
dimensions were classified. Further, using multinomial logit regression, the store choice pattern
Shenoy, Nayak and Kumar (2011) attempted to understand the competition prevalent
amongst the Indian retailers and proposed a model for choice of retail format. The results showed
KPMG India (2009) identified the changing contours of retail industry in India and
highlighted the drivers which will likely to have impact across retail categories. The report 74
featured several significant developments for the Indian retail industry, including the entry of
many global players, growing acceptance of the modern formats, the success of many speciality
retail formats, and the growing competition in the regional markets beyond the metros and Tier I
cities.
According to report on ‘Grocery Retailing in Asia Pacific’ by KPMG (2009), the outlook of
retail industry in Asia had never been more promising. According to this report world’s largest
retailers are jostling not only to gain but to preserve market share in the competitive landscape.
This is especially true in the grocery sector, where maintaining differentiation is a constant
challenge. The report found that there are significant opportunities for the retailers, and whether
this growth is achieved organically, or by acquisition, joint venture or strategic alliance, thorough
50
commercial and market analysis will be critical to help ensure that the strategy fits the business
Minten, Reardon and Sutradhar (2009) in a detailed case study of Delhi, emphasized
that modern retail is shown to emerge quickly, offering more labelled and branded food products
and more choice than traditional markets. The authors highlighted that modern retail is at its
mere incipience in India selling basic foods mostly at the same or lower prices than traditional
retail and might thus become an important contributor to improved urban food security.
Sengupta (2008) captured the history of the evolution of modern Food and Grocery retail in
India. He focused on the time period from 1971 to 2001. The research was primarily exploratory
in nature. Primary research included depth interviews, focus groups and survey through
goods manufacturers, channel members, and opinion-leaders. The study found that emergence of
modern retail in India is not just a result of increasing consumer buying power but manufacturers
and unorganized retailers also have an important role to play in this process at the macro-level.
The study emphasized that at the micro-level, the trigger for growth of organized retail come
from diverse angles like entrepreneurial desire to provide better service to consumers, social
desire to provide relief to the masses in the form of lower prices, desire to capitalize on emerging
Srivastava (2008) looked at the changing scene in the retail sector in view of many MNCs
and large industries entering into this segment. Data were drawn from industry sources which
included national and international published sources from 1993-2006. They found that malls are
51
more developed in the North and West part of India. Another finding of the study was that food,
groceries and apparel purchases by customers contributed to 52 percent. Further, study revealed
that on average 75 percent of customers spend about 1-3 hours in the mall. The study also
revealed that malls with multiplexes such as cinema theatres, food courts, and play places for
children are becoming the centre for family outings. It was found that small retailers have
improved their service to cater to Indian consumers and credit limits and home service are
According to report by Cygnus India (2008), the retail sector in India is witnessing a huge
revamping exercise as traditional markets make way for new formats such as Department stores,
Hypermarkets, Supermarkets, and Specialty stores. The report stated that the retail sector in India
is at an inflexion point where the growth of organized retailing and growth in the consumption
Reynolds, Howard, Cuthbertson, and Hristov (2007) stated that a retail format is a
physical embodiment of a retail business model: the framework that relates the firm’s activities
to its business context and strategy. Such business model would entail the retailer’s key resource
and process mix aligned with its segmentation, targeting and positioning strategies. Therefore
retail formats need constant nurturing and maintenance. They stated that considering the
multiplicity of consumers needs, desires and preferences, which typify the contemporary retail
environment, numerous new forms of retailing are emerging. Many contemporary retailers have
developed their retail formats to deliver enhanced opportunities to add-value to the shopping
experience beyond the mere acquisition of sought goods. They concluded that winning retail
52
formats emerge from an opportunistic and incremental process based more on intuition than
rational analysis.
Gaiha and Thapa (2007) in their discussion paper produced by the Asia and the Pacific
Division (IFAD) confirmed through an econometric analysis that Supermarkets are likely to
grow rapidly in several countries in the Asia and the Pacific region. The study prospected that 76
as diets and lifestyles change and incomes grow the demand for Supermarket services will
increase. In parallel, capital flows and dramatic changes in food supply chains will boost the
growth of Supermarkets. The study proposed that while there is considerable evidence that this
would translate into lower food prices for consumers not only in major cities, but also in small
towns in rural areas, as well as significant spill over effects by freeing up resources (and total
factor productivity growth) and technological advancement, some concerns remain about the
exclusion of smallholders. The study found that either the quality or other requirements (e.g.
traceability) are much stringent for smallholders, or smallholders simply lack access to modern
KPMG (2005) along with FICCI conducted a survey of CEOs of twenty leading retail
organizations in India to gain a better insight into the retail sector. The report highlighted that the
last few years have witnessed an explosion of organized retail formats like Supermarkets and
Hypermarkets in an otherwise fragmented Indian retail market. The study highlighted that in
order to tap this growth opportunity, Indian retail organizations need to be prepared for a quick
scale up across dimensions of people, processes, and technology in addition to identifying the
right formats and value proposition for the Indian consumer. The findings of retail survey
53
indicated that Specialty and Supermarket format have the most potential for growth in India
followed by Hypermarkets.
KPMG (2005) reported the results of survey conducted with various companies involved in
retail in India. The report revealed that many of the companies surveyed believe that the potential
size of this market is underestimated. They considered that there are considerable opportunities
for organized retailers in the kind of rural territories that many companies had failed to address.
According to the report, a critical issue was how fast and how far the consuming class will grow.
This depend both on the growth of personal disposable income and the extent to which organized
retailers succeed in reaching lower down the income scale to reach potential consumers towards
the bottom of the consumer pyramid. Companies expected retail growth in the coming five years
to be stronger than GDP growth, driven by changing lifestyles and by strong income growth,
which in turn will be supported by favourable demographic patterns. The structure of retailing
will also develop rapidly. According to the report, Supermarkets have been taking an increasing
share of general food and grocery trade over the last two decades.
Sinha and Kar (2004) highlighted that the Indian retail sector is going through a
transformation and this emerging market is witnessing a significant change in its growth and
investment pattern. Both existing and new players are experimenting with new retail formats.
The study revealed that currently two popular formats – Hypermarkets and Supermarkets are
growing very fast. They emphasized that consumer dynamics in India is changing and the
retailers need to take note of this and formulate their strategies and tactics to deliver value to the
consumer. They investigated modern retail developments and growth of modern formats in the
54
country. They also discussed the challenges and opportunities available to the retailers to succeed
in the country.
Mulky and Nargundkar (2003) found that stores in modern formats have emerged in the
metropolitan cities but the bulk of the retail sales happen through traditional retail formats. The
authors analyzed the developments in retailing in India. They carried out a literature survey of
Prasad and Aryasri (2011) made a detailed study on the effect of shoppers’ demographic,
geographic, and psychographic dimensions in terms of format choice behavior in the fast
growing Indian Food and Grocery retailing. They adopted descriptive research design by
applying mall intercept survey method using structured questionnaire for data collection. Both
descriptive (mean and standard deviation) and inferential statistical tools like factor analysis and
multivariate analysis was used to analyze the data collected from 1,040 food and grocery retail
customers from upgraded neighbourhood kirana stores, Convenience stores, Supermarkets, and
Hypermarkets in conjoint cities of Secunderabad and Hyderabad in Andhra Pradesh in India. The
study found that shoppers’ age, gender, occupation, education, monthly household income,
family size, and distance travelled to store have significant association with retail format choice
decisions. The choice decisions were also varied among shoppers’ demographic attributes.
Mortime and Clarke (2010) in a study conducted on Australian consumers identified the
differences between male and female shoppers rating related to the importance of store
characteristics within a Supermarket retail environment. Survey was used to gather data from
55
two hundred and eighty male and female grocery shoppers, across four major Supermarkets. A
revealed significant statistical differences between male and female grocery shoppers on all ten
store characteristics constructs. Significant gender differences were featured on twenty- 79 eight
of thirty scale items tested. The study also revealed that female grocery shoppers considered
Tripathi and Sinha (2008) in Indian context, argued for incorporating both the shopper
attributes and the store formats in store choice. They found that shopper attributes can be
captured through the demographic variables, as they can be objectively measured, and they also
captured a considerable amount of attitudinal and behavioural variables. The study attempted to
link store choice, format choice and consumer demographic variables, through a hierarchical
logistic choice model in which the consumers first choose a store format and then a particular
store within that format. They developed a nested logit model and the variables predicting the
ANOVA) were used to evaluate the data. The finding identified demographic variables specific
56
Internet Grocers) and examined store attributes (e.g. price competitiveness, product selection,
Bhatnagar and Ratchford (2004) developed a general model of retail format choice for
non-durable goods. They proposed that using one common model, it is possible to isolate the
states under which patronizing Supermarkets, Convenience stores, and Food Warehouses would
be optimal. The optimality of the different formats was found to depend on membership fees,
travel costs, consumption rates, perishability of products, inventory holding costs of consumers,
and cost structures of retailers. They developed several hypotheses regarding format choice by
situations.
Leszczyc, Sinha and Timmermans, (2000)formulated and tested a model of store choice
dynamics to measure the effects of consumer demographics on consumer grocery store choice
and switching behavior. A dynamic hazard model was estimated to obtain an 80 understanding
of the components influencing consumer purchase timing, store choice, and the competitive
dynamics of retail competition. The hazard model was combined with an internal market
57
( RESEARCH METHODOLOGY)
This research is based on primary data collected through questionnaires from 50 users of
Patanjali Products within lUCKNOW. The questionnaire design is built up to know the
type of products people use, the reason for their buying such product and their post
buying satisfaction level from that product. Secondary sources have been used to collect
information about ‘Patanjali’ brands. Journals, articles, research reports and government
documents were reviewed to get the insight of the previous interventions that the
stakeholders and policy makers have already in place. Also websites of natural products
manufacturing company and online document were investigated to conduct this research.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
INTRODUCTION
This chapter aims to understand the research methodology establishing a framework of
evaluation and revaluation of primary and secondary research. The techniques and concepts used
during primary research in order to arrive at findings; which are also dealt with and lead to a
logical deduction towards the analysis and results
A research process consists of stages or steps that guide the project from its conception through
the final analysis, recommendations and ultimate actions. The research process provides a
systematic, planned approach to the research project and ensures that all aspects of the research
project are consistent with each other.
RESEARCH PROCESS
The research process has four distinct yet interrelated steps for research analysis.
It has a logical and hierarchical ordering:
1. Determination of information research problem.
2. Development of appropriate research design.
3. Execution of research design.
4. Communication of results.
58
RESEARCH DESIGN
Research design is a conceptual structure within which research was conducted. A research
design is the detailed blueprint used to guide a research study towards its objective. It is a series
of advanced decision taken together comprising a master plan or a model for conducting the
research in consonance with the research objectives. Research design is needed because it
facilitates the smooth sailing of the various research operations, thereby making research as
efficient as possible yielding maximum information with the minimum effort, time and money.
The various tasks that are undertaken in the research design process are:
1. Defining the information need.
2. Design the exploratory, descriptive and causal research.
EXPLORATORY RESEARCH
The method used for exploratory research was the collection of:
* Primary Data
* Secondary data
PRIMARY DATA
Primary data is the new data gathered to help solve the problem at hand. As compared to
secondary data which is previously gathered data. An example is information gathered by a
questionnaire. Qualitative or quantitative data that are newly collected in the course of research,
Consists of original information that comes from people and includes information gathered from
surveys, focus groups, independent observations and test results.
Data gathered by the researcher in the act of conducting research. This is contrasted to secondary
data, which entails the use of data gathered by someone other than the researcher information
that is obtained directly from first-hand sources by means of surveys, observation or
experimentation.
Primary data is basically collected by getting questionnaire filled by therespondents.
59
SECONDARY DATA
Secondary data is the information that already exists somewhere, having been collected for
another purpose. Sources include census reports, trade publications, and subscription services.
There are two types of secondary data: internal and external secondary data. Information
compiled inside or outside the organization for some purpose other than the current investigation
Researching information, which has already been published. Market information compiled for
purposes other than the current research effort; it can be internal data, such as existing sales-
tracking information, or it can be research conducted by someone else, such as a market research
company or the U.S. government.
Secondary source of data used consists of books and websites.
DESCRIPTIVE RESEARCH
STEPS in the descriptive research:
Statement of the problem
*Identification of information needed to solve the problem.
*Selection or development of instruments for gathering the information.
*Identification of target population and determination of sampling Plan.
*Design of procedure for information collection.
*Collection of information.
*Analysis of information.
*Generalizations and/or predictions.
RESEARCH TOOL
The purpose is to first conduct a intensive secondary research to understand the full impact and
implication of the industry, to review and critique the industry norms and reports, on which
certain issues shall be selected, which remain unanswered , this shall be further taken up in the
next stage of secondary research. This stage shall help to restrict and select only the important
question and issue, which inhabit growth and segmentation in the industry.
60
DATA COLLECTION
Data collection took place with the help of filling of questionnaires. The questionnaire method
has come to the more widely used and economical means of data collection. The common factor
in all varieties of the questionnaire method is this reliance on verbal responses to questions,
written or oral. I found it essential to make sure the questionnaire was easy to read and
understand to all spectrums of people in the sample. It was also important as researcher to
respect the samples time and energy hence the questionnaire was designed in such a way, that its
administration would not exceed 4-5 mins. These questionnaires were personally administered.
The first-hand information was collected by making the people fill the questionnaires. The
primary data collected by directly interacting with the people. The respondents were contacted at
shopping malls, markets, places that were near to showrooms of the consumer durable products
etc. The data was collected by interacting with 150respondents who filled the questionnaires and
gave me the required necessary information. The respondents consisted of housewives, students,
businessmen, professionals etc. the required information was collected by directly interacting
with these respondents.
61
investigation. The audience defined in age, background, ability, and preferences, among other
things, for which a given course of instruction is intended.
I have selected the sample trough Simple random Sampling.
SAMPLE SIZE
This study targets 50people in the age group above 21 years for the purpose of there search. The
target population influences the sample size. The target population represents the Lucknow
region. The people were from different professional backgrounds.
ERRORS IN THE STUDY
Interviewer error
There is interviewer bias in the questionnaire method. Open-ended questions can be biased by
the interviewer’s views or probing, as interviewers are guiding the respondent while the
questionnaire is being filled out. The attitudes the interviewer revels to the respondent during the
interview can greatly affect their level of interest and willingness to answer openly. As
interviewers, probing and clarifications maximize respondent understanding and yield complete
answers, these advantages are offset by the problems of prestige seeking, social desirability and
courtesy biases.
Questionnaire error
The questionnaire designing has to careful so that only required data is concisely reveled and
there is no redundant data generated. The questions have to be worded carefully so that the
questions are not loaded and does not lead to a bias in the respondents mind.
Respondent error
The respondents selected to be interviewed were not always available and willing to cooperate
also in most cases the respondents were found to not have the knowledge, opinion, attitudes or
facts required additionally uninformed response errors and response styles also led to survey
error.
Sampling error
This study concludes sample size of 50, which cannot determine the buying behavior of the total
population. The sample has been drawn from only a particular region.
62
QUESTIONNAIRE:
The purpose of this survey is to know about the Customer’s level of satisfaction and the services
provided by the company. The Patanjali users are the only part of this survey.
1. Respondent Details
Name
City
Phone Number
63
3 - Do you agree the prices of the Patanjali products are fair?
6- Do you agree that you are satisfied with the patanjali product?
a) Yes [ ] b) No [ ]
64
8- Do you agree that Patanjali products are chemical-free?
9- Do you agree that Patanjali products have made a good brand image?
10- Please indicate the reason why you prefer patanjali product?
d) others [ ]
11- Which of the following retail stores do you prefer most for buying FMCG products ?
Big Bazaar
General Store
Patanjali Store
65
( Data Analysis)
Questionnaire of Patanjali
9%
25%
52%
6%
8%
77% people strongly agree that patanjali offers large variety of product while17% people
think that patanjali has not offers large variety of product.
66
2. Do you agree that Patanjali products are of how good quality?
29% 57% 2% 8% 4%
Column1
Agree Disagree Neutral Strongly agree Strongly disagree
0%
4%
29%
57%
2% 8%
86% people believe that patanjali offers good quality of product but 14% customers are
not satisfy with the quality of product.
67
3. Do you agree the prices of the Patanjali products are fair?
10%
31%
44%
10%
5%
75% customer thinks that the price of patanjali products are fair but 25% customer thinks
that the price of the product are not fair.
68
4. Do you agree that the Patanjali products have appealing packaging?
Column1
Agree Disagree Neutral Strongly agree Strongly disagree
8%
42%
29%
4% 17%
71% customer believes that patanjali product is good packaging while 29% customers is
not satisfied with the packaging.
69
5. Do you agree that Patanjali products have natural ingredients?
Column1
Agree Strongly Disagree
29%
71%
71% customer agree that patanjali products have natural ingredients and 29% customer
fully agreed that patanjali have natural ingredients.
70
6. Do you agree that you are satisfied with the patanjali product?
Column1
Agree disagree strongly agree strongly disagree
14%
45%
22%
19%
67% customers are satisfy with patanjali product while 33% customer are not satisfy with
patanjali product.
71
7. Have you faced any problem while using the product?
a) Yes [ ] b) No [ ]
yes N0
78% 22%
0% 0%
no
22%
yes
78%
78% customer are happy and they do not face any problem while 22% customer are
facing problem with patanjali product.
72
8. Do you agree that Patanjali products are chemical-free?
Column1
agree disagree neutral strongly agree strongly disagree
18%
49%
18%
10%
5%
67% customer believe that patanjali is a chemical free product while 33% people thinks
tha patanjali is not chemical free product.
73
9. Do you agree that Patanjali products have made a good brand image?
strongly disagree
2%
disagree
agree 3%
11% neutral
0%
strongly agree
84%
95% people thinks that patanjali product have made a good brand image while few
peoples are not agree with that.
74
10. please indicate the reason why you prefer patanjali product?
d) others [ ]
Sales
conveninent affordable quality others
10%
20%
30%
40%
Mostly person afford in 40% and conveninent average like 30% and who person those are clean
75
11. Which of the following retail stores do you prefer most for buying FMCG products ?
Big Bazaar
General Store
Patanjali Store
Chart Title
Big Bazaar
20%
Vishal Mega
Mart
6%
Patanjali Store
General Store
60%
14%
OUTCOME:-
According to the survey 10 out 0f 50 people will prefer Big Bazar to buy the Patanjali product
i.e. 20%, 3 out of 50 will prefer to buy from Vishal Mega Mart i.e. 6% of people, 7 out of 50 will
purchase from General Stores i.e. 14% and 30 out of 50 i.e. 60% will prefer to buy from Patanjali
store itself. So large no. of users of Patanjali directly approach Patanjali store to purchase
Patanjali products.
76
77
Findings
78
79
Recommendations
80
81
Limitations
82
The field work for the purpose of research was limited to some part of Lucknow city that
not represent the overall Lucknow. As the perception of consumer/retailers are vary from
The sample size is 50. So this can’t tell the whole scenario of the total population as well
as it is also next to impossible to conduct a survey on large population with limited span
of time.
83
Bibliography
84
Bibliography:
The project report on Retailer survey on Patanjali products in Lucknow city the topic customer
satisfaction and expectation could be successful with the co-operation of the the faculty guide.
But I had taken the help of the following books and links to know more about the subject.
Book Reference:-
By Kotler Philip, Keller Kevin Lane, Koshy Abraham, Zha Mithileshwar, Marketing
Web Reference:-
Www.Wikipedia.Com
Patanjali group
Www. patanjali.Com
85