Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DT Galderma
DT Galderma
Best
Practices
in the
Treatment
of
Rosacea
Supported by
2 Best Practices in the Treatment of Rosacea
Disclosures Aqua, Bayer, Biofrontera AG, Cipher Foamix, Promius, Novartis, Aqua/
All faculty, planning committee Pharmaceuticals, DUSA Almirall, Ortho Dermatologics, Pfizer
members, editors, managers, and other Pharmaceuticals, Exeltis, Ferndale (Anacor), Aclaris, Novan, Dermira,
individuals who are in a position to Laboratories, Galderma Laboratories, Promius, Valeant, and Medimetriks.
control content are required to disclose IntraDerm Pharmaceuticals, ISDIN,
any relevant relationships with any LEO Pharma US, Mylan Technologies, Guy Webster, MD, has affiliations with
commercial interests related to this Novartis, PharmaDerm, Promius Aclaris Therapeutics, Alexar, Allergan,
activity. The existence of these interests Pharma, Sandoz, Sun Pharmaceuticals, Cutanea, Foamix, Galderma
or relationships is not viewed as Valeant Pharmaceuticals. Laboratories, Hovione, Janssen,
implying bias or decreasing the value of Sol-gel, and Valeant.
this publication. Disclosures are as James Q. Del Rosso, DO, FAOCD,
follows: FAAD, has affiliations with Galderma, Scott Kober, MBA (medical writer),
Bayer, Allergan, BioPharmX, Ferndale, has disclosed that he has no relevant
Hilary Baldwin, MD, has affiliations LeoPharma, SunPharma, Foamix, financial relationships specific to the
with Allergan, Galderma, Sun, Promius, Novartis, Genentech, Cipher, subject matter within the last 12
BioPharmX, Novan, L’Oreal, La Aqua/Almirall, Ortho Dermatologics, months.
Roche-Posay, Ortho Dermatologics, Pfizer (Anacor), Aclaris, PharmaDerm,
Dermira, and Bayer. and IntraDerm. Commercial Support
This educational supplement was
Neal Bhatia, MD, has affiliations with Linda Stein-Gold, MD, has affiliations developed by Dermatology Times with
Aclaris Therapeutics, Allergan, with Galderma, Bayer, Allergan, support from Galderma Laboratories,
Almirall, Anacor Pharmaceuticals, BioPharmX, LeoPharma, SunPharma, L.P.
An Educational Supplement to Dermatology Times 3
diffuse erythema.1 And then there Demodex.3,4 I don’t think we yet comes from genetics and the
is the progressive fixed dilatation know if there is a symptomatic other half comes from the
of the blood vessels that leads to gastrointestinal (GI) contribution environment through things such
telangiectasias and background that leads to the development of as ultraviolet exposure, alcohol,
erythema.2 The other major rosacea, but there are studies and smoking.7
component of the pathophysiology currently under way that may clear These results have me
of rosacea is augmented immune up some of the primary questions.5 convinced that there is a genetic
detection/response, which triggers Personally, I am not a big influence that drives the
pathways such as the cathelicidin believer in the link between GI development of rosacea.
cascade, which causes both parasites and the development of
erythema and, in some patients, rosacea, though there are some Dr. Del Rosso: At a recent
papules and pustules. dermatologists who will try to meeting of the Rosacea
I think about the reduce a rosacea patient’s gut International Study Group, Dr.
pathophysiology of rosacea in flora load during their treatment. Martin Schaller of the University of
much the same way as I learned to Hopefully, we’ll know more about Tübingen in Germany showed
think about the pathophysiology whether this is a reasonable photographs of mothers and
of acne over the years. We accept approach to treatment in the near children who both had very similar
the fact that there are different future. clinical presentations of rosacea.8
components of the It’s not often that we hear about a
pathophysiology of acne that are Dermatology Times: What is familial link to rosacea, and I
addressed with different known about any genetic suspect few of us consistently ask
treatments, and we don’t typically predisposing factors to the our patients about it.
treat an acne patient with just a development of rosacea?
single therapy. But for some Dermatology Times: What are
reason, we haven’t gotten to that Dr. Hilary Baldwin: We just the major clinical features of
point with rosacea. Many finished a study at the Twins Days rosacea? Which do you find to be
dermatologists do not look at the Festival in Twinsburg, Ohio, which most burdensome from a patient
rosacea patient and say, “OK, is an annual meeting of perspective?
what’s happening from a approximately 2500 biologic twins.
pathophysiologic perspective that We looked at 65 twin sets whom Dr. Guy Webster: There are many
can be addressed with an we identified with mild-to- ways to think about rosacea. You
individual treatment?” We need to moderate rosacea—only 1 twin can think of it as several different
begin correlating different signs set had severe disease—and while subtypes of the same disease, or
and symptoms with different the results of our study have not you can think about it as a general
treatments instead of that “one for yet been published, I can report predisposition that may have 1 or
all” or subtype approach. that there was a great deal of more of the subtypes. In general,
symptom concordance between you’ve got the red face, you’ve got
Dr. Neal Bhatia: There has been a the identical twin sets, even the pimples, and you’ve got ocular
lot of recent discussion about the among twins who had lived apart rosacea that includes styes and
possible connection between for 5 or even 10 years.6 Our results blepharitis where there has been an
rosacea and Helicobacter pylori are in line with what a similar study overgrowth of sebaceous glands.
and other concomitant parasites in from Case Western Reserve What bothers the patient most?
the gut that mimic or resemble a concluded in 2015, showing that It varies, but in general, the
hypersensitivity response similar about half of the contribution to pimples seem to be most
to what is proposed about the development of rosacea bothersome, although some
An Educational Supplement to Dermatology Times 5
patients—especially women—with
erythema can be made to feel
“These days, you have so many
really self-conscious and
uncomfortable. people with static erythema or
Dr. Baldwin: While my structural telangiectasias who were
experience would lead me to
agree with Dr. Webster, there was told they have rosacea by their
a study published in June 2017
with which both Dr. Del Rosso and neighbor, by “Dr. Google,” or by
I were involved that found
otherwise. In the study, we the guy at the bar. They come in
collected patient surveys that
explored a variety of questions having already made up their mind
and found that it was patients’
erythema and not their pimples that they have rosacea, and my
that were the most bothersome
reported aspect of rosacea.9
The bottom line, however, is
number 1 charge is to convince
that the most bothersome feature
of rosacea is whatever the patient
them that they either have it or
has. A gentleman who comes in
with a great deal of rhinophyma
they don’t.”
but with none of the other aspects
of rosacea is going to be bothered
by rhinophyma the most. Clearly,
it’s in the eyes of the possessor. bar. They come in having already components of their condition,
made up their mind that they have primarily because I will be treating
Dermatology Times: How, if at rosacea, and my number 1 charge them based on the pathophys-
all, are you utilizing rosacea is to convince them that they iology of their unique constellation
phenotyping during the either have it or they don’t. That of signs and symptoms. I also think
diagnostic process? How is the can be a little daunting without a it’s important to have the patient
grouping of rosacea patients by clear family and medical history. hold up a mirror so that I can point
phenotype different than Assuming that the diagnosis of out to them the many signs of the
grouping by subtype? rosacea is eventually confirmed, disease that they may not have
then it becomes important to noticed. This allows me to talk to
Dr. Bhatia: When I see a new stratify them based on their the patient about which signs and
patient with suspected rosacea, symptoms: Are they papular, are symptoms we’re able to treat,
my first order of business is to they more erythematous, or are which we’re not able to treat, and
confirm the diagnosis. These days, they a combination of both? That how we might develop an overall
you have so many people with then will help guide treatment. treatment plan.
static erythema or structural
telangiectasias who were told they Dr. Baldwin: When a patient Dermatology Times: Does the
have rosacea by their neighbor, by walks into my office, I take a good presence of inflammatory papules
“Dr. Google,” or by the guy at the deal of time looking at the various and pustules as a primary
6 Best Practices in the Treatment of Rosacea
presenting feature alone typically patient’s background erythema person said an individual had mild
signify the presence of rosacea? under control with topical disease and another insisted they
What about centrofacial treatment. Probably the thing had severe disease. This grading
erythema? that’s going to require the most system discussion is only important
skill to treat is rhinophyma, for clinical research purposes.
Dr. Webster: There’s a threshold because it often requires a
for every symptom beneath which surgical intervention. Dr. Stein-Gold: At the end of the
you don’t have disease. To some day, it really isn’t terribly important
degree, that’s cultural. If you walk Dermatology Times: How do you if you judge a patient to have mild,
around in Dublin, Ireland, you’ll determine if a patient should be moderate, or severe rosacea. A
see that almost everyone has a classified as having mild, patient is a dynamic being. Maybe
little bit of rosacea. When you get moderate, or severe rosacea? Do we would have judged them to
to the point where there’s you use any sort of formal have “mild” disease today, but
blushing that the patient notices diagnostic tool during the yesterday they would have had
and they have some fixed process? “moderate” disease. And last
erythema, that’s probably the week, when they were in a flare,
bottom end of the rosacea Dr. Del Rosso: There aren’t any they would have had “severe”
spectrum in my book. And while I consensus definitions of mild, disease. Because rosacea is such a
can make a formal diagnosis moderate, and severe rosacea in cyclical disease, it needs to be
based on pimples with proper the clinical setting, so that treated based on a patient’s
morphology and location alone, delineation is often up to the symptoms over a course of time.
there are usually pimples along investigator’s overall visual So while it’s important in clinical
with erythema. “gestalt.” The severity ratings are trials to ensure that patients meet
based on what are used in clinical a specific standard of disease
Dermatology Times: Which trials for study purposes. You go in severity, in real life, our goal is to
features of rosacea are most the room, you look at the patient, get patients clear regardless of
difficult for providers to and you decide whether the the status of their disease on a
successfully treat? patient’s presentation is specific day.
consistent with what you rate as
Dr. Linda Stein-Gold: As has mild, moderate, or severe disease Setting treatment
been mentioned previously, based on global assessment goals in patients
symptom control really requires a definitions in the study protocol. with
multimodal approach for a lot of In our minds in the clinic, we all papulopustular
our patients, because we have to probably have different rosacea
look at each of the aspects of their thresholds, but I doubt there is
disease. much variation. Dermatology Times: What are
In today’s environment, we’re I was involved in a few projects the primary considerations when
very fortunate in that we have a lot with several colleagues where we recommending treatment options
more in our toolbox than we had were shown pictures from studies for a patient with papulopustular
several years ago, and I think we and asked individually whether we rosacea? How often is cost
have agents that are quite judged the patient to have mild, factored into the equation?
effective in getting a patient’s moderate, or severe disease. The
papules and pustules under results were generally close across Dr. Webster: Cost is always a
control fairly rapidly. In addition, the board, but I don’t ever factor. Insurance companies are
we’re now able to get some of a remember a case where one trying to take the management of
An Educational Supplement to Dermatology Times 7
rosacea away from medical ambitious expectations of therapy? some of their bumps flattening in
dermatology by calling it a the first month, but we won’t see
“cosmetic” condition. Some Dr. Stein-Gold: This is one of our the skin clearing for a while.
insurance companies will make a biggest challenges. Rosacea is a The other thing I try to
patient fail 5 or 6 options before chronic disease. It isn’t something emphasize during the initial
allowing them a trial of ivermectin, that a patient “got” last week like conversation is the importance of
even with the clinical data we have poison ivy. Many of our new good skin care (Table 1). Many
showing its efficacy and safety.10–12 patients will have seen on TV or patients will often tell me that they
Cost alone, of course, isn’t the online something that promises have been using toners or other
only determining factor. Whether “RESULTS OVERNIGHT!” So, that alcohol-based products that are
a drug works to help with the is their expectation no matter how not good for patients with
patient’s primary presenting serious their symptoms. It’s our rosacea. It’s important to get
symptoms is a big deal. How bad job to explain upfront the realities patients to stop using these
the disease is to the patient is of treatment rather than wait to irritating topical agents and focus
important. So is the question of talk to the patients a few weeks or on the importance of simple
whether the patient will use the months later when their things like a gentle cleanser,
medicine. Some people won’t put expectations haven’t been met. moisturizer, and sunscreen.
on a cream, while others won’t What I usually focus on is a
take a pill. The length of time they discussion of results we’ve seen Dr. Baldwin: Teaching patients
need to be on the medication is from rosacea clinical trials. For how to utilize cosmetics to help
also an issue that is tied into cost. instance, for topical medications, conceal their erythema and
So as dermatologists, we need it might be 12 weeks before we perhaps even their papules while
to think about all of those things see clearance of the skin. I will tell we wait for the medications to take
before deciding on a plan—in patients that we can expect to see effect is something I am
conjunction with the patient—that
is going to have the best chance Table 1 Skin care guidance for rosacea patients
of being effective.
Cleanse your face—gently—at least once a day.
Dr. Baldwin: One thing I will often
ask patients about is whether
Apply moisturizer daily.
there is any deadline or important
life event coming up for which Protect your skin from the sun year round with sunscreen of
they want to be better. SPF 30 or higher that offers broad-spectrum protection and
Sometimes, the only reason a does not irritate facial skin.
patient will come to see me is
Choose rosacea-friendly skin care products. This includes
because, for example, their sister
avoiding products that contain alcohol, fragrances, and other
is getting married in a month, in
ingredients.
which case I’ll often use a more
aggressive combination topical/ Test new skin care products and makeup by applying a small
oral approach. amount near (but not on) your rosacea-prone skin. If it
irritates your skin (burning, stinging, etc.) and continues to do
Dermatology Times: How do you so after 72 hours, do not use it.
approach a discussion with a
patient with papulopustular Avoid rubbing or scrubbing your face.
rosacea who perhaps has overly
8 Best Practices in the Treatment of Rosacea
particularly passionate about. Dermatology Times: What are get them on a topical alpha
There is actually a funny sounding your primary initial treatment agonist as soon as possible.
word for that: farding. It means, “To options in a patient you determine
paint the face with cosmetics.”13 to have mild papulopustular Dermatology Times: What about
In my opinion, it’s very important rosacea? the approach in a patient you
for dermatologists to teach determine to have severe
patients how to fard well and Dr. Stein-Gold: I’ll often start with papulopustular rosacea?
safely. Finding the right a topical agent. Topical ivermectin
combination of moisturizers and tends to be my treatment of Dr. Baldwin: In a patient with
sunscreens can be difficult in some choice if there aren’t any insurance severe papulopustular rosacea, I
rosacea patients who complain issues. Otherwise, I’ll opt for like to start them on a
that, “Everything bothers my skin,” topical 1% metronidazole or combination of a topical agent
so it’s often a trial-and-error azelaic acid. such as ivermectin cream and
approach. either the 20 mg twice-daily or 40
Dr. Webster: Simply to head off mg daily controlled-release
Dr. Bhatia: I like talking to new potential insurance challenges, I subantibiotic dose of doxycycline.
rosacea patients in terms of a often try topical metronidazole Once the patient’s disease is
“sprint” and a “marathon.” We before ivermectin. If a patient’s under better control, I try to back
know based on clinical trials that insurance company won’t cover off the combination and use either
many of our agents will take 4 either of those, I will typically the topical or the oral alone,
weeks to start working. That’s the resort to doxycycline 40 mg. whichever the patient prefers.
sprint. The 16-week mark is our Patients with rosacea of any
other key milestone. That’s the Dermatology Times: What about severity who come to us are
marathon. the approach in a patient you generally looking for immediate
Typically, I won’t ask to see a determine to have moderate results, so it’s crucial to select a
patient back in my office until we papulopustular rosacea? regimen that gives them the best
hit that 4-week mark, and with a chance of a rapid response.
drug like ivermectin, that may take Dr. Del Rosso: I like to use a
8 weeks to start showing subantibiotic (subantimicrobial) Dr. Stein-Gold: For patients with
demonstrable results.10–12 I’ll wait dose of doxycycline if patients are really severe papulopustular
even longer. willing to try an oral agent. The rosacea, oral isotretinoin is always
I like talking to patients about a subantibiotic nature of the drug is in the back of my mind, but it’s
marathon because a marathon is key, and we’ll talk a little bit more very rare that I need to try that.
about pacing, and with the about that later. Doxycycline can Today, we’re generally able to get
treatment of rosacea—assuming also be a good choice in patients even the most severe rosacea
that a patient remains adherent to who have adherence issues with patients under control with
treatment—you see a steady topical agents. topical/oral combination therapy.
accumulation of benefits over time. There are some patients with
Patients are investing a lot of time, moderate papulopustular rosacea Dermatology Times: Which
energy, and money into these who I will start on a combination topical/oral combinations are
prescriptions, so it’s key to give of a topical agent and sub- believed to be the most effective
them realistic expectations of when antibiotic doxycycline. If I have a in treating papulopustular
they can expect to see symptom rosacea patient with both papules rosacea?
improvement and how the and pustules and background
improvement will build over time. persistent erythema, I will try to Dr. Stein-Gold: The data are
An Educational Supplement to Dermatology Times 9
currently limited, although several other tetracyclines such as If you choose to give higher
ongoing trials are exploring the minocycline that share some of doses of doxycycline to get more
question. There are some data the same anti-inflammatory of an anti-inflammatory effect, you
showing that a combination of properties of doxycycline, should be aware that your patients
topical ivermectin and topical doxycycline is the only tetracycline will develop antibiotic- resistant
brimonidine, started for which researchers have been bacterial organisms, which can
simultaneously, gets patients’ able to identify a dose-related have negative longer-term impact.
symptoms under control more threshold that is subantibiotic.
completely and rapidly than an That can be extremely important Dr. Baldwin: While I agree with
initial start of ivermectin followed for our patients. everything that Dr. Del Rosso said,
by brimonidine 1 month later.14 if I have a patient with a
There have also been studies Dermatology Times: How does particularly challenging history of
showing that a combination of bacterial resistance to doxycycline rosacea who has tried and failed
either topical azelaic acid or develop? multiple options—and who was
metronidazole along with actually adherent to their previous
doxycycline—both a subantibiotic Dr. Del Rosso: Any time a patient regimens—I will often try a full
and higher dose—gets patients is exposed to an antibiotic, 100-mg daily dose of doxycycline
under control faster than the use whether it be a topical or an oral for a brief period. I’ve also had
of a topical agent alone.15,16 agent, an antibiotic-resistant rosacea patients who do not
There is an ongoing trial using a strain is going to emerge. It’s just respond to doxycycline but do
combination of topical ivermectin a fact of life. But in a rosacea respond to minocycline, although
and low-dose doxycycline that may patient, doxycycline is effective again, that’s not something I will
have future relevance for not because of its antibiotic use for more than a couple of
dermatologists.17 effect, so why would we want to months before switching to a
expose a patient to an antibiotic- topical agent or a subantimicrobial
Use of doxycycline resistant dose if we don’t need to? dose of doxycycline for disease
in the treatment of maintenance.
rosacea Dermatology Times: What is the
threshold of antibiotic resistance Dermatology Times: How do you
Dermatology Times: Why is for doxycycline? determine what a “brief” period is?
doxycycline believed to work in
treating the inflammatory lesions Dr. Del Rosso: Several studies Dr. Baldwin: That is great
of rosacea? have shown that use of question. The answer is “as short
doxycycline either 20 mg twice a as possible.” You will often hear
Dr. Webster: Doxycycline works day or the 40 mg modified-release that we should not be using a full
because it’s an anti-inflammatory capsule once a day, administered dose of an antibiotic for more than
agent, probably active through the over a prolonged period, is 3 months, but that’s an arbitrary
inhibition protease activation of considered to a be a subantibiotic recommendation that is not based
cathelicidin. It’s also a neutrophil dose. While there may be some on any hard evidence. Antibiotic
and is antigranulomatous, so it has limited emergence of bacterial- resistance begins after the very
a lot of anti-inflammatory effects resistant organisms at these low first pill.
that are active below the doses, this has been minimal, and
antimicrobial level.18 does not appear to persist over Dr. Del Rosso: The other
time, including controlled important factor to consider is not
Dr. Del Rosso: Although there are comparisons to placebo use.19,20 every patient will absorb a drug,
10 Best Practices in the Treatment of Rosacea
-4
Mean change in total
Doxycycline 40 mg (n=44)
-6
-8 –9.3
-10
–10.9 –12.4 –12.5
-12 –13.0
–12.3 –12.6
-14
–14.3
-16
Source: Ref 19
including an antibiotic, in the small amount of an already lower to give a patient a higher level of
same fashion, and you will have dose. Obviously, there is no easy antibiotic, I don’t sit there with a
some patients who are “low way to tell upfront if you have a calendar and determine that I
absorbers.” Certain ingested patient who is going to be a low absolutely have to get them off
substances that contain a high absorber, but it is something to antibiotic-dose doxycycline by a
amounts of metal ions, such as in consider in a patient who does not specific date in those selected
foods or vitamin/mineral respond to lower doses of cases when it is necessary. The
supplements/antacids, reduce the doxycycline, or any other antibiotic police aren’t going to be
absorption of antibiotics such as tetracycline given at a low dose. lining up outside my door. I have
minocycline and doxycycline to I will usually give a patient a to see improvement before I will
some degree.19 For those patients, month on topical therapy and a ease a patient off the antibiotic
a subantibiotic dose may not get subantibiotic dose of doxycycline dose. Getting a patient better is
them adequate improvement before considering a higher dose my top priority.
because they are absorbing only a of doxycycline. While I don’t want
An Educational Supplement to Dermatology Times 11