Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Report
Report
Catherine A. Callis
Abstract
This paper analyzes the achievement gap in America. It is broken down in multiple subtopics
discussing the history of education, causes and effects of the gap, statistics from the nation,
political arguments, legislation, and reform with recommendations. This paper is informative for
American citizens, showing what is occurring in schools nationwide, and what preventative
action is being taken to deter the growth of the achievement gap any further. It highlights the use
of funding and acts to prevent unfairness in an educational setting, that show results that either
benefit or hurt educational attainment and value. This paper explains how funding for public
education systems is more beneficial in preventing this problem, since those impoverished
students being the majority affected by the gap, attend these public institutions. The right for a
student in America to receive an equal education is critical to continue to advance, and allows
the chance for higher education to be an option, leading to hopeful future, molding the citizens of
The value of education has seen an increase from past centuries, especially in
today’s America. The need to attain higher education is challenging, and finding a job with only
a bachelor’s degree has become competitive. However, the foundation laid before the process of
college or the labor force is not being set properly to ensure that every student is meeting new
levels and milestones in their early education. From the 1990s on, our country's educators
witnessed the enlargement of the achievement gap. The achievement gap breaks down students
using gender, race, ethnicity, and household income and tests levels of educational attainment
through different criteria (Ansell, 2011). With this enlargement, students from differing
backgrounds tend to show low levels of achievement, putting them behind and isolating
individual students. The achievement gap is an intensifying matter in America, deterring the
adequate level of educational attainment vital for students to lead a prosperous life after high
History of Education
Early Education
Education has evolved through history, especially with the concern of who has the right
to receive one. The common deterrents of those trying to obtain an education during the rule of
Elizabeth I depended on socioeconomic status and gender. Although both males and females
were taught manners and etiquette during their first few years of life, males were more likely to
obtain a practical education learning core subjects, and females would learn how to run the
household ("Education in the Elizabethan Era," 2017). Those with great wealth during this time
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
period were able to afford tutors, who focused on the individual student, providing for their
needs and recognizing strong subjects and areas of weakness. This education allowed for
thoroughness and individualism. Middle class males were typically sent to school, that still
provided them with a decent education. The typical core subjects were taught in these schools.
For the wealthier males of this era that had tutors, they were also taught core subjects, along with
any other advanced topic their tutor possessed knowledge in. Females were very limited in
education during this time, with nobles and very wealthy families typically educating their
daughters. Yet a female with an education during this time period was very uncommon. Females
during this era were expected to learn how to take care of a household and rear children properly.
The breakdown of society between gender and class has since changed, however, not being a
Jamestown was one of the first permanent English settlements in the new world. Building
structures to create a stable establishment and pacifying relationships between natives was a
main focus over education. Settlers began travelling, expanding on the east coast of North
America, establishing cities and places of trade for England. These settlements were English
territory, controlled by the king of England. The expansion of cities and men working led the
women of the households left to educate the children. Children typically learned to read during
early education, primarily before attending school. Religion throughout the colonies differed,
however, studying the Bible became an important part in education during colonial times
(Patterson, 1983). Even during this early age of education, education attainment had a consistent
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
breakdown on who will receive an education and what type of school a student will attend.
Schools were separated on the basis of gender, religion, and ethnicity (Patterson, 1983).
In 1896, the case of Plessy v. Ferguson was decided in the Supreme Court. The Separate
but equal doctrine allowed for the decision to be made, ruling that segregation in public facilities
did not violate the 14th Amendment (Plessy v. Ferguson, 1896). However, an era of change
began to occur in the early 1900s. Women not only could vote, but were limited to the chance of
receiving an education. The end of the Civil War and start of the reconstruction era brought the
question of African American lives and their rights after the abolishment of slavery. Jim Crow
laws deterred people of color from voting due to limiting literacy tests. Literacy tests stressed the
problem of how these people were unable to read and write properly due to the fact they were not
educated or had been provided inadequate education. The civil rights era began with the
landmark court case of Brown v. Board of Education, ruling that segregation in schools did
violate citizens 14th Amendment (Brown v. Board Of Education, 1954). This case brought
significant backlash, and change to America, desegregating schools, breaking down the barriers
Innovative technology has molded how our students are able to learn and how teachers
can provide resources and information that students utilize in the classroom. During the 20th
century, education became more common in America than ever before. While the United States
had plenty of public institutions that students could attend, the use of private schools were
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
common during this time continuing into the 21st century. The 20th century shaped American
education by creating a guideline of the certain amount of years a student should attend school,
and college becoming a more accessible luxury (Lynch, 2016). Rapid advancement in
technology has created a higher standard of education attainment of students living in 21st
century America. The amount of new and specialized jobs has shown a major increase on the
amount of people choosing higher education than just the completion of secondary school. The
value of a college level education has increased in today’s society. However, what has become a
necessity in today's society in order to obtain a job, has been priced as a luxury item (Progress in
Our Schools, n.d.). Effects of the achievement gap were noticed in the late 20th century.
Although in past decades we have seen a shrinkage of the gap, the past two decades have shown
growth in the achievement gap with differences in ethnicity and race (Haycock, 2001).
Poverty
Poverty is one of the main effects that widens the achievement gap. Studies in America
have recently shown there is growing relationship with social class that ties in with how one
performs in an educational setting (Correa, Boatright, Bonnesen, & Everson, 2015). Poor
communities are less likely to have the adequate resources and knowledgeable teachers to
provide a student with a proper education, therefore showing poor performance on standard tests.
Students who grow up in impoverished communities are a part of a repetitive cycle of poverty
because they do not have the adequate funds to obtain a higher education, making them more
likely to choose a low skilled job, that provides a low income. The achievement gap has been
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
studied over decades;however, the trend in current times has shown that the household income
plays a major factor in educational attainment today than from previous years (Reardon, 2017).
That being said, the amount a person makes can ultimately lead to the amount of resources a
child is able to receive in order to improve and learn. Families with a higher household income
can typically afford for their students to be active and participate in clubs or activities outside the
classroom, enhancing their quality of life and learning. Lower household incomes struggle to
allow their students to participate in these types of events because the money is simply not there
(Tavernise, 2012). However, with the achievement gap, household income and race correlate
with each other. While urban communities have high volume poverty, this can lead to multiple
effects such as an increase in crime, substandard living conditions, medical issues, along with
schools that lack in resources and low test scores (Ross, 2013).
Race and ethnicity are main factors that plays roles in widening the achievement gap.
Although these poor communities and race typically correlate with one another, not only is the
achievement gap affecting black students, but hispanic students as well. High volume mixed
ethnicity communities are more immune to the effects of the achievement gap by race with
poverty being a primary problem (Sparks, 2016). “A third of all black children but only one
tenth of white children live in families with incomes below the poverty line” (Thernstrom &
Thernstrom, 2003). Black children are more likely to live in poverty than white children, making
them less accessible to further resources in order to acquire a quality education. When viewing
the achievement gap, studies are based more on the differences between white and black students
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
and Hispanic and white students. This is because white students tend to score higher than these
students although there are few comparisons between black and Hispanic students (Lee, 2002).
While most studies show correlations with ethnicity and poverty being the major affect, people
also have factored in the language barrier and how Hispanic students might struggle without the
appropriate resources to help achieve a level of understanding in English. There is a wide gap in
the level of educational attainment between white and Hispanic students. According to the
census in 2000, white citizens had graduated high school 33.1% more over Hispanic citizens.
Also, white citizens were 16.6% more likely to have attained a 4 year degree than Hispanic
citizens (Hispanics: Education Issues, n.d.). One of the main resources available to non-English
speaking Hispanic students is English Language Learners (ELL). ELL is provided for students
no matter what their native language is; however, in the United States ELL accommodates more
Spanish speaking students than it does any other language. However, there is a lack of teachers
and staff for ELL, which presents issues in the achievement gap (Hispanics: Education Issues,
n.d.). Funding for urban schools has been low priority, making it harder to access new resources
Gender Roles
While the achievement gap is typically regarded as the differences between race,
ethnicity, and social class, people tend to lose focus on the fact there is a gap between gender..
However, there is a never ending trend with poverty going hand in hand with another effect of
the gap. Male students who come from impoverished communities or come from a different
racial or ethnic background that is not considered a majority, are affected by the gap
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
tremendously (R. Whitmire & S. M. Bailey, 2010). Male students are falling behind and not
receiving a higher level of education that will allow them to bring in a steady income later in life.
Trends show male students are less far reaching when it comes to education than female
students. Studies are showing correlations between male students and low graduation rates. Also,
there is a correlation between male students and low rates of college readiness. These trends are
showing that female students are more likely to obtain a higher education in America (R.
Whitmire & S. M. Bailey, 2010). Although women had a harder time obtaining an education in
past decades, it is positive to see an increasing trend of women obtaining a higher education.
However, the achievement gap is all about equity, with men and women having an equal chance
Statistics
National Statistics
The nation is seeing an increase in the enrollment of students in public institutes, over
those private institutes. Although it is the increase is slim, it is still showing the value of public
education. The 50.7 million students attending these schools will show that the majority of these
students are Caucasian, while minorities will make up a smaller percent of these students
attending. However, these statistics will change in the coming years due to the increase of the
Hispanic population, eventually becoming a majority. This school year alone, America is
predicting that at least $623.5 billion will be used to fund public schools (NCES, 2017). Also, the
nation has a “report card” averaging basic, proficient, and advanced students in different subjects
at certain grade levels. The nation’s report card shows that students in grade 12 are matching
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
10
basic levels or slightly above for math skills by 62% while the most advanced and above is only
3%. Meaning the majority of seniors in America are at a basic level of mathematical skills. For
writing, the level of basic or slightly above in our nation is 79% while the most advanced and
above reaches only 3% also. The rest of the percentage goes above basic and below advanced,
being proficient in these areas. However, the majority of students are skilled at a basic level, not
reaching educational milestones (NAEP, 2017). This shows the effects of the achievement gap
since these students are not receiving a quality education that shows they have been challenged.
Political Arguments
Party Platforms
While politicians and leaders can agree education is an important step in a child’s life, the
two main parties tend to differ when it comes to the topic of education and higher education.
Each party seem to differ when it comes to where funding should go, affordable higher
education, teacher’s salary, government involvement, and the separation of church and state.
Democrats in this country believe in uniform education, through the option of non-limited
schools. Also, the extension of funding for these schools is very important to this party's platform
(Democratic Party Platform, 2012). School-choice is a better term to define certain Republicans’
outlook on our education system. The use and funding of private education tends to be very
popular among the Republican party (Republican Party Platform, 2012). Analyzing, the question
that remains is who should ultimately get the funding? The poor schools with low test scores or
the schools that continue to thrive with academic success? While funding can be resourceful to
these poor schools, the focus has been put on private schools with the Trump administration.
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
11
Teachers are the gateway to achieving higher education. Some believe teachers are severely
underpaid for their expertise and time. On a scale, with the median income being $57,200, the
75th percentile shows that high school teachers made $73,050 and over in 2015. The 25th
percentile and under made $45,520 and under in 2015. However, salary can be dependent on
expertise in education and the amount of time one has been working as an educator. Also, where
one works as an educator can be dependent on salary as well (U.S. News, 2015). One’s salary
can ultimately affect the amount of motivation and time one will put in in the workplace. A
teacher who is paid less can lack the devotion that another teacher has toward students when paid
more. This causes problems because a teacher is the ultimate guide in navigating education and
reaching educational milestones. Without the focus on individuals and their needs specifically, a
student can not reach these milestones and obtain a proper education. The need for higher
salaries in the teacher workplace is due to the expertise and years of training a teacher must
receive in order to become certified and licensed. The election of President Obama became a
focus on education during this period of America. Obama reformed education for the better,
creating grants that were resourceful on state levels. This initiative was known as the Race To
The Top. This awarded money to these states that created reform and plans in education policies
(Sanchez & Turner, 2017). Obama also had a goal of creating affordable higher education for
American citizens. He had an ambition that America would be a top country in the progression
of education (Progress in Our Schools, n.d.). The election of Donald Trump in 2016 brought
uneasiness to education experts. Trump being a vocal republican, expressed his thoughts on
funding for education through exclusive schools, pushing his support on funding parents to pay
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
12
for tuition in exclusive and religious institutions. When choosing his cabinet, Trump chose Betsy
DeVos as the education secretary, due to her similar beliefs and ideas for reform in the education
system (Brown, Strauss, & Douglas-Gabriel, 2017). Betsy DeVos sparked outrage when chosen
for education secretary under Trump's administration. DeVos has expressed her strong views
against the continuous funding for public education and is an advocate for those private schools,
and especially has solid views incorporating religion in schools (McShane, 2017). DeVos could
cause problems with public education due to her opinions on funding, therefore putting these
impoverished public schools even further behind, widening the achievement gap.
Important Policies
Different policies have been set forth in recent years and past decades in order to create
equal opportunities for education in America, making it affordable and resolving issues of the
achievement gap. Federal aid is an important step taken toward the affordability in a higher
education in America, which was established in 1965 under President Johnson's ambitious Great
Society plan for home front issues. Federal aid grants money to those students taking the next
step in furthering studies with a higher education. Federal student aid provides the most money
in the United States for those students who choose higher education. This is accessible to all
students since it’s a free application, and is based off of household income and different criteria,
granting a certain amount of money to students every year depending on certain circumstances
(Free Application for Federal Student Aid, 2017). However, there are other policies completely
focused on closing the achievement gap that have been enacted in past years focusing on primary
and secondary education. The No Child Left Behind Act was created in the year of 2002. The act
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
13
was established in order to help those students not meeting certain expectations and milestones in
their education despite a student’s personal background. However, as the years went on, the
difficulty of accommodating each individual student and their needs turned into a challenge. The
loss of control and carrying out of this act caused for reform to become inevitable. The Every
Student Succeeds Act was established in 2015 by Obama, furthering his focus in his agenda on
education. Although the goals were similar, this act was reaching for more of an equilibrium for
students and their chance of education. Since enacted, the rise of students obtaining a diploma
from high school has increased and high school dropout is becoming less and less. Completing
secondary school has also increased college rates (Laws & Guidance, 2015). The focus and
energy that Obama put toward education showed improvement in these achievement gaps, yet
the agenda of the current education secretary and her anti-public education opinion could set
America back and widen this gap that Obama worked so hard to close.
Important Legislation
Legislation for education has been a focal point for some past political leaders, but
President Johnson’s great society agenda made education a major role in benefiting society.
President Johnson's focus on problems on the homefront included those of education problems.
Johnson established many acts during his term, especially the Head Start program. Head Start
allows younger students preparation for school, emphasizing the importance of an individual
student and their school readiness (New America, 2017). Another policy enacted to protect
students is Title IX. The schools who follow the Title IX act are funded by the government and
deter the discrimination in such schools. Failure to comply can ultimately lead to the loss of
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
14
funds from the government ("Title IX- Know Your IX," 2017). This is a work of President
Nixon, created in 1972. These acts help protect the student and focuses on individuals, creating
readiness and proper learning environments where a student can feel safe and advance in their
educational journey.
Reform
Recommendations
As a country, the overall goal is to close this widening gap. Education experts and certain
political leaders express the significance of a quality education whether it come from just
completing a secondary school or being able to access higher education. With that said, what can
the country do in order to maintain these increasing levels of high school graduation rates and
continue to lower the rates of dropouts? How can the United States continue to increase the rates
of enrollment in higher education? The focus on the individual needs to become a priority in
schools, showing that a students needs are met, and they continue to improve from past
benchmarks in their education. Programs enacted such as Obama’s Every Student Succeeds Act
is monumental to the closing of the achievement gap, helping these students obtain an equal
education at rates where they can all come to an understanding of certain topics, and stay on
track to graduate and potentially obtain a higher education. However, with the current
administration, education experts fear for the focus to be taken off all students, and put onto
those receiving an education from a private institution. This has created controversy over where
federal funding should go, with education secretary DeVos focusing on the use of student
vouchers and funding for such private schools. The achievement gap maintains its growth with
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
15
the loss of funding for impoverished public schools. While the improvement of scores is never a
bad thing, funding for private institutions is only beneficial to those students, while those in
public schools, especially poor communities, continue to lack the necessary resources that are
beneficial to a student’s educational experience and could potentially raise standardized test
scores. Funding for private institutions means less access or availability to achieve higher
education for poor students because the lack of value their education holds is weak compared to
a highly funded private school student. Federal funds need to go to those poor communities and
schools, in order to give these students a better chance of a prosperous life and break the cycle of
poverty.
In today’s society, the need for a degree from a college institution has become a
necessity. The search for a job has become extremely challenging and continues to become much
more difficult with advanced technology. A degree is very useful, however, is not exactly
accessible to all students. The cost of a year's tuition can equal the amount of a small car in
modern times. Not only is federal aid become resourceful for these students, but a quality
education can lead money granted towards a student. A student who excels in school can
typically earn money from an institution; however, with an unmotivated teacher and lack of
utilities, a student can ultimately say they did not receive a valuable education deterring them
from such opportunities. Accessible higher education should be a focus, since it teaches expertise
and skill in areas a student finds interest in, especially for occupations where a degree is required
16
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, the achievement gap affects students of all backgrounds. The need to deter
the growth of the achievement gap is crucial to a student’s equal rights in obtaining an education
that is valuable and useful. No matter the background of a student, all students in America have
the right to receive a quality education. America is the land of opportunity, and the opportunity
to an education should be a pinnacle point in every child’s life, allowing them to grow and
contain knowledge that they utilize for the rest of their lives.
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
17
References
2012 Republican Party Platform. (2012, August 27). Republican party on education: Party
http://www.ontheissues.org/celeb/Republican_Party_Education.htm
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/mar01/vol58/num06/Closin
g-the-Achievement-Gap.aspx
Adams, K. L., & Adams, D. E. (2003). Urban education. Santa Barbara, CA:
ABC-CLIO,Inc.
Ansell, S. (2017, August 30). Achievement gap. Retrieved December 10, 2017, from
https://www.edweek.org/ew/issues/achievement-gap/index.html
Brown, E., Strauss, V., & Douglas-Gabriel, D. (2017, May 17). Trump’s first full
education budget: Deep cuts to public school programs in pursuit of school choice.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/trumps-first-full-education-budget-
deep-cuts-to-public-school-programs-in-pursuit-of-school-choice/2017/05/17/2a25a2
cc-3a41-11e7-8854-21f359183e8c_story.html?utm_term=.66c539cafbf2
By: GreatSchools Staff | April 2, 2015 Print article. (n.d.). The achievement gap: Is your
18
https://www.greatschools.org/gk/articles/the-achievement-gap-is-your-school-helping
-all-students-succeed/
Camera, L. (2016, January 13). Achievement gap between white and black students still
https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/data-mine/2016/01/13/achievement-gap-betwee
n-white-and-black-students-still-gaping
Cannady, M. A., Moore, D., Votruba-Drzal, E., Greenwald, E., Stites, R., & Schunn, C. D.
(2017, October 20). Black and white achievement gap. Retrieved December 11, 2017,
from
https://stemeducationjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40594-017-0079-y
Archives |, Peter Reuell, Harvard Staff Writer |, Jill Radsken, Harvard Staff Writer |,
Liz Mineo, Harvard Staff Writer |, & Alvin Powell, Harvard Staff Writer |. (2016,
February 15). The costs of inequality: Education's the one key that rules them all.
https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2016/02/the-costs-of-inequality-educations-the
-one-key-that-rules-them-all/
Correa, A. M., Boatright, P. E., Bonnesen, J. A., & Everson, S. (2015). The poverty
problem within the academic achievement gap of U.S. students (Master's thesis, Saint
19
Democratic Party Platform. (2012, September 4). Democratic party on education: Party
http://www.ontheissues.org/celeb/Democratic_Party_Education.htm
Haycock, K. (2001). Closing the achievement gap. Educational Leadership, 58, 6-11.
doi:ASCD
Hosking, T. (2017, December 20). The changing landscape of student protest in higher
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/12/the-changing-landscape-of-st
udent-protest-in-higher-education/548867/
L. (2013, December 19). Achievement gap definition. Retrieved November 21, 2017, from
http://edglossary.org/achievement-gap/
Lee, J. (2002, January 1). Racial and ethnic achievement gap trends: Reversing the
http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0013189X031001003
Lynch, M. (2016, September 2). How the 20th century changed American education.
http://www.theedadvocate.org/20th-century-changed-american-education/
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
20
http://educationnext.org/betsy-devos-relatively-mainstream-reformer-education-secre
tary/
NAEP. (2017). How did U.S. students perform on the most recent assesments? Retrieved
https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=372
New America. (2017). Federal education legislation. Retrieved December 20, 2017, from
https://www.newamerica.org/education-policy/policy-explainers/early-ed-prek-12/fed
eral-education-legislation/head-start/
Porter, A. (2015, January). Rethinking the achievement gap. Retrieved November 21,
Portsmouth demographic study. (2015, June). Retrieved October 20, 2017, from
http://www.portsmouthva.gov/DocumentCenter/View/751
http://www.duq.edu/about/centers-and-institutes/center-for-teaching-excellence/teach
ing-and-learning/pygmalion
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN AMERICA
21
Reardon, S. F. (2017, July 24). The achievement gap: Rich and poor. Retrieved November
https://cepa.stanford.edu/content/widening-academic-achievement-gap-between-rich-
and-poor-new-evidence-and-possible
Ross, T. (2013, June 5). Addressing urban poverty in America must remain a priority.
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/poverty/news/2013/06/05/65268/addressing
-urban-poverty-in-america-must-remain-a-priority/
Sanchez, C., & Turner, C. (2017, January 13). Obama´s impact on America´s schools.
https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2017/01/13/500421608/obamas-impact-on-americas-
schools
Smith, A. (2013). It's not because you're black. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
Sparks, S. D. (2016, May 10). Study: Most school districts have achievement gaps.
https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2016/05/11/study-most-school-districts-have-ach
ievement-gaps.html
Students affected by achievement gaps. (n.d.). Retrieved November 21, 2017, from
http://www.nea.org/home/20380.htm
Tavernise, S. (2012, February 09). Education gap grows between rich and poor, studies
22
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/10/education/education-gap-grows-between-rich-a
nd-poor-studies-show.html
Thernstrom, A., & Thernstrom, S. (2003). No excuses; Closing the racial gap in learning.
Title IX- Know your IX. (2017). Retrieved December 20, 2017, from
https://www.knowyourix.org/college-resources/title-ix/
United States, Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education. (2017). Free
U.S. News. (2015). High school teacher overview. Retrieved December 20, 2017, from
https://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/high-school-teacher/salary
U.S. News. (2015). High school teacher overview. Retrieved December 20, 2017, from
https://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/high-school-teacher/salary
Whitmire, R., & Bailey, S. M. (2010). [Interview by Education Next]. Retrieved November
23