Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strategic Management Semester 2
Strategic Management Semester 2
Strategic Management Semester 2
STRATEGIC ALLIANCE
A strategic alliance is an agreement between two or more parties or firms to work together to
achieve certain objectives. Generally , the alliance agreement is for a certain specific period .
When the Objectives are achieved , partners terminate the alliance . The firms remain
independent organisations and work together without forming new entity .The alliance
usually allows transfer of technology , share expense and risks.
An alliance can be defined as a collaborative relationship between two or more entities that
share complementary assets and strength and strength to create greater value for their
customer and their own organization which otherwise could not be accomplished
independently.
It is to be noted that some authors make a difference between strategic alliance and a joint
venture . they state that partners to be a joint venture contribute towards the equity , whereas ,
in a strategic alliance , they don’t . secondly , a joint venture is a long term alliance with a
distinct identity , whereas , a strategic alliance is of temporary nature for a specific purpose .
however , in reality this distinction does not hold valid .
The emerging globalization due to liberalization is opening up yet another major dimension
in the field of strategic management –the strategic alliance . The concept of strategic alliance
is causing far more impact than that of mere business management practice.
According to Ratan Tata, very few Indian businessmen have the capability of competing on
their own in the emerging environment of globalization . The businessmen are concerned
about their individual soverignty whereas they should be looking at alliances and aggregation
of companies as it so often happens abroad .
1
permits the partner to complement their competencies , which in turn
generates synergetic advantage .
The following are some of the problems with Indian strategic alliance or joint venture.
1) Lack of planning A more serious reason for the mismatch , however, is that there is
very little planning that goes into setting up an alliance ,determining the interest of
each partner, analysing their respective contribution and accordingly structuring the
alliance . Some alliance fail due to lack of planning .
2
For instance , Godrej soaps entered into a joint venture with P7G to manufacture and market
soap brands. Godrej reserved its soap making capacity at Mumbai , to manufactureits own
and P&G brands. However, it appear that no attempt was made to examine the working
relationship closely . Mr Press and Godrej more Intuitive or gut feel approach to marketing
was in sharp contrast to P&G’s approach based on extensive market research to build lasting
brands. When the sales of the JV ‘s brands fell short of projections, relations between the
partners began to sour.
2 ) Difference of opinion :
Most JV’s get derailed due to difference in aspirations and approaches. The mismatch of
aspiration and approaches become a bone of contention between the alliance partner. A case
in point is HDFC –Chubb General Insurance – non life insurance alliance which came into
existence in 2002. In 2007 , the Indian company called off its JV with Chubb Corporation,
the world’s largest non-life insurance company, after 5 yrs due to differences on pace of
growth . Obviously , there was a clash of ideologies and culture. This became a bone of
contention between the partners . It became a barrier for the Jv’s rapid roll out, especially in
the commercial segment. .
3) Continuous Disagreements:
There are cases , where there are constant disagreement between the alliance partners that
lead to the collapse of the alliance . For instance , Kinectic India and Honda entered into a
join venture with the objective of manufacturing scooter and mopeds in 1984. As Honda had
another joint venture with Hero to produce motorcycles the joint venture between Kinectic
and Honda was confined to mopeds and scooters.
During the operational phase of the joint venture, several sources of disagreements emerged
among the partners. Kinetic felt that Honda was not sufficiently committed to the venture
.For Eg , Kinectic wanted the company to spend more on advertising but Honda was
reluctant to do so. Kinectic also felt That Honda was more focused on markets such as
Indonesia and Thailand , which were growing rather rapidly. The continuing difficulties led
to the split between Honda and Kinectic in 1998.
3
from Timex ‘s technological expertise. The strategy worked well for some time but long term
problems gradually cropped up.
Problems began to emerge between the partners from 1996 onwards. Timex wanted to gain a
controlling share in the joint venture , to which titan was opposed . At the time , Titan began
to compete in lower markets segments, which violated the non compete clause in the
agreement . To counteract this, Timex began its entry in the up scale market segment.
On march 1998 they announced the break up of the venture.
Alliance agreement may be signed for a certain specific period. After the specific period ,
The parties to the alliance may renegotiate terms and condition. Parties may try to dictate
terms at the time of renegotiation, and may adopt independent plans which may sour the
relation between the alliance partners.
A joint venture between Hero cycles of India and Honda of Japan came into existence in
1984 as motorcycle and scooter manufacture in india . In 2007 , hero Honda became the
largest two wheeler manufacturing company in India over a million units produced as well as
the “World Number One” in terms of terms of the unit volumes sales for the calendar year
.The technology for manufacturing the bikes was provided by Honda whereas Hero was
strong in its distribution and service network spread across the country.
In 1999, Honda announced that it would set up a subsidiary Honda whereas Hero was strong
in its distribution and service network spread across the country .At the same time , Honda
allowed Hero to have a minority stake in hmsi , and allowed Hero to examine the mororcycle
that Hmsi would release in the market .Thus, Hero Honda was unable to bring out new bikes
with better technology while competitor came out with better versions, as innovation was
solely in the hands of Honda. .In December 2010, both the companies decide to part ways in
a phased manner because of unresolved differences and independent plans. Honda decided to
sell its stake of 26%to the Munjal family and to exit from the venture.
6) Problem of Resource : At times , lack of resource or funds either with one of the parties
or with both the parties to the alliance lead to break up of the alliance .Matters came to a head
in 1994, when Maruti Udyog Limited felt an urgent need to increase capacity .With its
internal resource generations not being adequate , Suzuki proposed a combination of
additional debt and equity .Due to financial constraints, Govt of india finally had to reduce its
shareholding from 76% in 1982 to 50%in 1992 and less than 20% in the subsequent years. As
4
of December 2013, Suzuki motors hold over 56 % of the total equity , and the remaining by
FII’s, DFi and others.
7)Lack of Trust :
Quite often, the lack of trust between the alliance partners is responsible for the break up.
The alliance partners are reluctant to share ideas and support due to lack of trust.This is
possible , when strangers are brought together to form an alliance, and therefore , there is no
mutual connection. In many cases, one party to the alliance blames the other for the failure.
Shifting the blame does not solve the problem, but increase the tension between the alliance
partners. Several alliance in India and overseas have failed due to lack of trust causing
unsolved problems, lack of understanding and despondent relationships.
Building trust is the most important and yet most difficult aspect of a successful alliance.
Only people can trust each other and not the firms. The alliance must form the three forms of
trust equality , reliability and responsibility . Developing trust in each other will move
towards a mutual win/win situation
8) Cultural Clashes:
Clash of cultures is probably a major problem that alliance face today worldwide. The
cultural problems include language barriers, egos, and different philosphies towards business,
which can create problems in the functioning of an alliance.
Language barriers can affect the parties working together. Also, alliance partners may have
different philosophies and priorities. At times there are ego clashes between the alliance
partners. Thus a good number of strategic alliances have broken up within a few years of
operation.
9) Government Regulations:At times , Govt regulations may not favour certain types of
alliance , the alliance are called off. The two companies have reached an agreement to
independently own and operate separate business formats in India. Bharti retail will continue
to operate “easyday” retail stores across all formats and invest to expand the business.
Walmart on its part will continue its investment in India , including cash –and –carry
business, supply chain infrastructure, direct farm programme and supplier development.
Also, at the state level, a change in government may reverse the stand taken by the earlier
State Govt .With this, Delhi has become the first state to withdraw permission for FDI
funded retail stores. The previous delhi government under Sheila dikshit had allowed FDI in
5
multi brand retail in delhi . The DIPP is now examing the letter sent by the delhi government
on withdrawing permission for FDI in multi brand retail. States have to imitate DIPP about
allowing FDI funded stores . The states that allow FDI funded stores include Maharashtra ,
Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh .
Doing away with FDI was one of the steps AAP had mentioned in its manifesto before
elections in Delhi in December 2013. With this , Delhi has become the first state to
withdraw permission for FDI funded retail stores.
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is a long term direct investment in business in a foreign
country by an individual or a company of another country, either by buying a company or
trough equity participation or by expanding operations of an existing business in a foreign
country. FDI differs from portfolio investment, in that portfolio investment is generally short
term passive investment in the securities of firms in foreign country.FDI brings certain
benefits to the host country such as :
Capital inflows which improve capital account balance and if there is a tie up with
local firms, the local firms can use the capital for expansion and modernisation.
Skills development through training and development by the foreign firm.
Transfer of technology by the foreign investing firm
1) Greenfield Investment -A foreign firm may invest fresh equity capital investment
by setting up a new firm in a foreign country . This may be in response to the
initiative taken by the governments of the country where FDI is invested . The govt
may provide special incentives to attract FDI.
For instance, the GOVT may encourage FDI by increasing the FDI limits. At present
100% FDI is allowed in sectors like hotels and tourism industry, export sector,
pharmaceutical sector, telecom sector, etc. some countries such as china encourage
FDI through various incentives such as lower corporate rates for foreign firms. This
mode , a development perspective is usually the most desirable.
6
2) Reinvestment of earning – Several countries encourage reinvestment of earnings by
foreign firms by providing special incentives such as tax benefits. This strategy Does
not result in outflow of foreign exchange by way of dividend or transfer of profits
.This strategy adds to the host-country’s capital stock and as such the productive
capacity increases. The host country may also benefits by way of transfer of
technology by the investing firm from abroad.
3) Intra company loans – Usually this strategy is followed by parent company when it
provides additional funds to its subsidiary by way of loans. Initially this strategy may
lead to foreign capital inflows which can be used by the subsidiary for expansion and
modernisation . However, This strategy may require larger outflow of capital by way
of interest payments and repayment of loans by the subsidiary to the parent firm.
Generally ,countries may not prefer this type of investment as compared to equity
participation by foreign firms, because in equity participation there is no obligatiob to
pay dividends or profits to the investing firm and secondly equity participation
involves long term commitment of capital flows.
4) Mergers and acquisition- At times , the govt of the host ountry may attract FDI
through merger and acquisition route. Generally, it is not most desirable mode of FDI
unless FDI is crucial to the success of the privitization of a loss making public
enterprise , or in the case where the merger of a domestic company with a foreign
company takes place on equal terms . Where a domestic firm becomes sick
,acquisition by a foreign firm may be deemed desirable.
Merger by parent companies of leading global MNC’S are outside the control of the
host country where subsidiaries of both MNC’S where operating before the merger .
Such a merger may lead to suppression of competition in the host country.
5) Non Equity forms of FDI – These may involve arrangements in the form of
subcontracting , licensing, franchising , etc. Such arrangements may not involve capital flows
from abroad . However, such arrangement contribute to the development of the host country
economic growth and development.
a) Franchising- Certain firm may adopt franchising route to enter in foreign market .
Franchising is a contract between two parties , especially in different countries involving
transfer of right and resource . The franchisor enters into a contract with thefranchisee ,
7
whereby the franchisor agrees to transfer to the franchisee a package of rights and resources ,
such as :
Production processes
Patents, trade marks and brand names
Loans and equity participation.
Product ingredients, etc.
b) Licensing - Licensing makes sense when a firm with valuable technical know-how or an
unique patented product has neither the organisation capability nor the funds to enter foreign
markets. This strategy also becomes important if the host country makes entry difficult
through investment. However , there is a danger that the licensee might develop its
competence to a point that it becomes a competitor to the licensing firm.
Under a licensing agreement, the licensing firm grants rights to another firm in the host
country to produce and/or to sell a product . The licensee pays compensation to the licensing
firm in return for the rights to use technology or patent.
Corporate Governance
Corporation pool capital from a large investor base both in the domestic and in the
international capital markets. In this content , investment is ultimately an act of faith in the
ability of a corporation management. In this regards, investor expect management to act in
their best interest at all times and adopt good corporate governance practices.
It is about commitment to values , abaout ethical business conduct and about making a
distinct between personal & corporate funds in the management of a company .
8
1) Major Stakeholders: The management needs to manage its affairs of the firm in the best
interest of its stakeholders. The major stakeholder in the area of corporate governance are:
a) Within the Firm: The stakeholders within the organisation include management ,
shareholders , and employees.
b) Outside the Firm : The stakeholder outside the organisation include lenders such as banks
, and other investors such as Debenture holders . It also include customer , suppliers and
society.
a) The first is the commitment of the board of directors and management towards integrity
and transparency in business operations.
b) The second is the legal and administrative framework of the government . If public
governance is weak , we cannot have good corporate governance.
9
The reason for growing interest in corporate governance are as under:
As per clause 49 of the listing agreement , all listed companies must submit a report on
corporate governance along with their annual report . the items to be included in corporate
governance reports are:
Capital market regular securities and exchange Board of india stated in December 2013
and in January 2014 that it would soon come out with new corporate governance norms.
As several companies have operation outside India and many more would be
venturing in foreign territorities, there is a need to align rules with the best in the
world, SEBI Chairman Mr . U.K.Sinha stated.SEBI has also proposed to introduce a
new concept of “corporate Governance Rating” by independent agencies to monitor the
10
level of compliance by the listed companies, in addition to regular inspection by SEBI
and stock exchanges.
Therefore , the new set of corporate Governance principles could be based on the OECD
Principles of corporate Governance .The principles were revised in 2004 as mentioned below.
The principles are further likely to be revised in 2014.
The corporate governance framework should promote transparent and efficient markets, be
consistent with the rule of law and clearly articulate the division of responsibility among
different supervisory , regulating and enforcement authorities
1) The corporate governance framework should be developed with a view to its impact on
overall economic performance, market integrity and the incentive it creates for market
participants and the promotion of transparent and efficient markets.
2)The legal and regulatory requirement that effect corporate governance practices in a
jurisdiction should be consistent with the rule of law , transparent and enforceable.
The corporate governance framework should protect and facilitate the exercise of
shareholders’s rights.
c) Obtain relevant and material information on the corporation on atimely and regular basis.
11
Shareholders should have the right to participate in, and to be sufficiently
informed on, decision concerning fundamental corporate changes such as
c) Extraordinary transactions including the transfer of all or substantially all assets, that in
effect result in the sale of the company.
b) Shareholders should be able to vote in person or in absentia and equal effect should be
given to votes whether cast in person or in absentia.
c) Capital structures and arrangement that enables certain shareholders to obtain a degree of
control disproportionate to their equity ownership should be disclosed.
a) Transaction should occur at transparent prices and under fair condition that protects the
rights of all shareholders.
b) Anti take over devices should not be used to shield management and the board from
accountability.
12
The exercise of ownership rights by all shareholders , including institutional
investors, should be facilitated .
All Shareholders should have the opportunity to obtain effective redress for violation of
their rights.
a) Any changes in voting rights should be subject to approval by those classes of share which
are negatively affected.
b)Votes should be cast by custodian or nominee in a manner agreed upon with the beneficial
owner of the shares.
d) Company procedures should not make it unduly difficult or expensive to cast votes.
1) The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or through mutual agreement are to
be respected.
2) Where stakeholders interest are protected by law, stakeholders should have the opportunity
to obtain effective redress for violation of their rights.
13
4)Where stakeholders participate in the corporate governance process, they should have
access to relevant , sufficient and reliable information on a timely and regular basis.
The corporate governance framework should ensure that timely and accurate
disclosure is made on all material matter regarding the corporation including the
financial situation, performance ,ownership and governance of the company.
4)Channels for disseminating information should provide for equal,timely and cost
effective acess to relevant information by users.
The corporate governance framework should ensure the strategic guidance of the
company , the effective monitoring of management by the board , and the board
accountability to the company and the shareholders.
1) Board members should act on a fully informed basis , in good faith with the diligence and
care , and in the best interest of the company and the shareholders
14
2)Where board decision may effect different shareholders groups differently , the board
should treat all shareholders fairly.
3)The board should apply high ethical standards . it should take into account the interest of
stakeholders.
a) Monitoring the effectiveness of the company’s governance practices and making changes
as needed.
c)Aligning key executive and board remuneration with the longer term interest of the
company and its shareholders.
a) When committee of the board are established , their mandate composition and working
procedures should be well defined and disclosed by the board . b)Board should be able to
commit themselves effectively to their responbsibilities
15
Appointment of directors or relatives for office or place of profit needs approval by
shareholders. If the remuneration exceeds prescribed limit, Central Govt approval
required.
Audit committee for public companies having paid up capital of RS 5 crore.
Shareholders holding 10% can appeal to court in case of oppression or
mismanagement .
The revised clause 49 superseded all the earlier circulars on the subject and became effective
for listed companies from January 01,2006.It is applicable to the entities seeking listing for
the first time and for existing listed entities having a paid up share capital of RS 3 crore and
above or net worth of RS 25 crore or more at any time in the history of the company.
The companies should also submit a quarterly compliance report to the stock exchanges
within 15 days from thr close of quarter as per the prescribed format. The report shall be
signed either by the compliance officer oe the CEO of the company. Apart from clause 49
of the equity listing agreement , there are certain other clause in the listing agreement,
which are protecting the minority shareholders and ensuring proper disclosures:
16
Disclosure of price sensitive information.
Disclosure and open offer requirement.
The board should focus on activities connected to its monitoring role. The areas to be
mentioned by the Board may be divided into 4 main segment:
Strategic planning
Capital allocation
Manpower planning
Performance appraisal
The eminent management expert Bernard Taylor is of the opinion that the board should
perform the following strategies tasks:
a) to improve the performance of the business of the business for the benefits of the
shareholders, the managers , the employees and others having stake in the company
like supplies , customers , local community, etc.
b) To develop a philosophy and a set of principles , which will guide the action of the
people involved in the enterprise .
c) To set the strategy and direction of the business usually for the growth in products
and markets, divestments and acquisition.
The audit committee needs to be meet at least thrice in a year. One meeting needs to be held
before finalization of annual account and one in every six months.
a) Oversee the company’s financial reporting process and the disclosure of its financial
information to ensure that the financial statement is correct, sufficient and credible.
17
b) Recommending the appointment and removal of external auditor, Fixation of audit fee and
also approval for payment for any other service .
c)Reviewing with management the annual financial statements before submission to the
board, focusing primarily on:
d) Reviewing with the management , external and internal auditor, regarding the adequacy of
internal control system.
e)Discussion with internal auditor, any significant findings and follow up there on.
f) Discussion with external auditor before the audit commences , nature and scope of audit as
well as post audit discussion to ascertain any area of concern.
h) To look into the reason for substantial defaults in the payment to the depositors, debenture
holders, shareholders and creditors.
Strategic Change
18
2)Necessitates new equilibrium :When a change takes place in any part of the organisation ,
it disturb the existing equilibrium in the organisation . A change require the need for new
equilibrium in the organisation. The new equilibrium depends on the degree of change and its
overall impact on the various parts of the organisation.
5)Changes is different from innovation: Change and innovation are 2 different concept.
All innovation is change , but not every change is innovation. . However, changes involves
any alteration or modification is an organisation established way of doing things.
6)Internal and External Forces: An organisational change can take place due to variety of
factors or forces. The forces can be internal or external. The external forces relate to
competition , government , customer , supplier , dealers, etc.
7)Degree of Change : Changes may differ in terms of degree . Certain changes may be
minor, which may not require changes in organisation structure. For instance , changes in
credit policy of the firm .
8)Risks and Rewards: Changes are subject to risk and rewards . At times , change may
result in negative outcomes due to the risk involved in respect of certain changes . For
instance , launch of new product may turn out to be a big disappointment
2)Shift in management philosophy: The management philosophy may shift from traditional
management philosophy to professional management philosophy This in turn may require
changes in various aspect and in functional areas of the organisation Therefore , there will be
changes in the organisation due to a shift in management philosophy.
4)Product Life cycle: Every product passes through a life cycle with consists of phases
growth phase, maturity phase, and decline stage. The product life cycle requires changes in
the product and marketing mix.
19
5)Environment Forces: There may be changes in the environmental forces such as,
6)Problems in the Existing Practices: There may be problems relating to the present
practices of the organisation. For instance , the present methods and procedure in respect of
production activities may be obsolete.In order to face competition effectively in the market,
changes need to be made in the organisation.
8)Changes in Union leadership : There may be changes in the union leadership This would
hesitate changes in the organisation. Management has to deal with new union leadership in a
different manner . Therefore management may have to introduce certain change in the
organisation.
9)Growth and Expansion plans: The organisation may plan for growth and expansion of
the business. Without effective changes it would not be possible to achieve growth and
expansion of the organisation.
The following are the various steps involved in the planned process of management of change
1) Identifying need for a change: The first step in the process of management is to identify
the need for a change. Internal factors may require a change in the organisation. Therefore ,
such factors may force the management to introduce a change in the organisation.
2)Decision on element of change: After identifying the need for a change, the management
must decide on the element , which require a change. For instance, a company’s sales may
decline due to:
20
Problems in the product – the product may be outdated , it may not meet the
expectation of the customers , wrong channels of distribution ,etc.
After conducting a proper analysis of the problem , the management should identify
those factors or elements that require a change.
3) Planning for change: After identifying the element that require a change the
management should plan for a change . Planning for a change need to answer the
following question.
As far as the first question is concerned , the change are to be introduced by the manager who
is responsible for the tasks where changes are required. For instance , if a change is required
in the pricing strategy, then the marketing manager is responsible for such changes. As far as
the second question is concerned , a proper decision is required regarding the timing of the
changes . For instance , if sales are falling down as a result of change in competitors pricing ,
or sales promotion activities , then it makes sense to introduce such changes immediately .
All these activities would require a good amount of time . This does not mean that the
management should delay in taking decision .The 3rd question relates to the procedure of
introducing a change in the organisation .The management should decide on the sequence of
activities and the manner in which the activities to be undertaken .
4) Assessing Possible Impact: The management should also assess the impact of the change
on the stakeholders such as employees , customer , etc. For instance introduction of new
technology may have to direct impact on the workforce :
Reduction in workforce
Problem of social networking
Need for additional training
5) Communicating the change: The management must communicate the change to the
various stakeholders. Wherever required , reasons must be provided for introducing the
change .
6) Overcoming the resistance to change: At times there may be resistance to change . For
instance , employees may resist automation for the fear of retrenchment problem of
adjustment to new technology etc. Therefore , in such situation , employees need to be
counselled and trained to adjust to the new environment in the organisation .
7) Review: There must be a review to ensure that the changes is progressing in the right
direction. The change should bring the desired results. For the Purpose , the management
should constantly monitor the performance of the change process. If there are any problems
due to change , then such problems should be handled immediately .The timely identification
problems and appropriate solutions to such problems will enable the change to bring the
desired result in the organisation.
21
Causes of resistance to change
1) Individual Factors
There are several factors operating at individual level , which are responsible for resistance to
change in the organisation . some of the individual factors responsible for resistance to
change are briefly stated as follows:
a) Fear of Unknown: Individual may resent change for the fear of unknown . He/ she may
feel that the new technology may be difficult to handle and as such he /she may avoid
accepting the new technology.
b) Status quo: Most individual are satisfied with their present routine of work environment
.They feel that changes would disturb Their present pattern of work and life. A change would
require certain adjustment in the current pattern of life and work and therefore , individuals
resist change .
c)Problems of ego: Some individual enjoy present status in the organisation They satisfy
their ego needs with the present position or status in the organisation . as such , individuals
may resist change in the organisation .
2) Economic factors: Individuals may feel the economic loss due to the proposed change in
the organisation . The economic causes for resistance to change can be stated as follows:
a)Redundancy of Jobs : For instance when computers were first introduced in between
1970s and 1990s in several organisation in india , employees including managers resisted
the change for the fear of losing jobs and consequently their economic security.
2) Group Factors: Individual as members of a group may jointly resist a change in the
organisation . The group resistance to change can be explained from the viewpoint of nature
of group dynamics and vested interests.
22
a) Group dynamics: It refers to the interaction among the group members, which in turn
affects the group behaviour. The members of a group may jointly oppose a change in the
organisation, as it may affect the group interaction .
b) Vested Interest : Normally , every group has its own leader , whether elected or accepted
by the group members. The leader may use the group as a mean of satisfying his personal
interest . Therefore , the normal leader may influence the group members to resist such a
change .
3) Organisational and management factors :At times , the organisational factors are
responsible to resist changes in the organisation . Organisation resist change due to the
following factors:
b)Stability of systems: Organisation tend to develop certain system which brings benefits to
the organisation .For instance , most educational institution are comfortable with the present
system of education , where the student are passive receivers of knowledge from the
teachers , and as such emphasis is not placed on interactive learning systems.
d)Problem of Responsibilities : managers are held responsible for the outcome of changes,
if introduced. Every change is associated with some degree of risks. There is no guarantee
that change introduction would bring positive result .
23
dynamics. The influencing members of the group, the so called group representatives can
exert strong pressure on the group members to accept the change .
4) Sharing of rewards: Management should promise sharing of rewards arising out of the
proposed change. When employees are assured of rewards they would be wiling to accept
and implement the change in the organisation . Employees are assured of rewards they would
be willing to accept and implement the change in the organisation .Employee need to be
provided both with monetary and non monetary incentives. The management may introduce
group rewards as well as individual rewards so as to implement the change effectively .
8)Union consultations: Management should consult the workers union in introducing the
change in the organisation . Union representatives should be involved before the change is
introduced in the organisation.
24
CHP 4 Disaster Management – Perspectives and Issues
Disaster management
Concept
The Webster dictionary defines a disaster as “ a grave occurrence having ruinous
results”. The world health organisation defines disaster as “any event
concentrated in time and space in which a society or a relatively self sufficient
sub division of a society , undergoes severe danger and incurs such losses to its
member and physical appurtenances that the social structure is disrupted and
the fulfilment of all or some of the essential functions of the society is prevented”
Disaster can be classified into 2 groups – manmade disaster and natural disasters:
a) Manmade disaster: Include vechicles related accident , forest fires, wars and civil
disturbance , ecological disaster due to deforestation , air , water ans soil pollution ,
industrial accident such as gas leaks and fires, etc
Characteristics of disaster
1) Borderless: Certain natural disaster are not bound by borders of a nation or state . The
disaster affect humans and other living being across the globe . For instance , earthquakes ,
cyclones , floods , drought, etc, can take place in any country irrespective of social and
economic development. At times, a single disaster may affect several countries at a time.
2) Loss: Certain disaster result in death of several people . For instance , the Gujarat
earthquake in 2001 resulted in deaths of over 20,000 people. The Orissa cyclone in 1999
killed 10,000 people. Apart from loss of human lives, the disaster result in loss of livestocks ,
destruction of houses , offices , factories , and other valuable assets.
3)Unusual Event : Disaster by their nature , are distinct from emergencies because they do
not happen all the time . Unusual , but not unexpected.
8) Emergency service are affected : Fire halls are destroyed by tornados . City halls are
flooded out. When the fire truck is crushed and the water mains are broken , the arrival of the
fire-fighters has no effect on the disaster and the situation continues to deteriorate. Hospital
are equally affected by the disaster. Whether the disaster damages the building itself , the
content of the buildings are disrupted , or staff is unable to get to orr from the hospital , the
hospital are the first to feel the effects.
9) Things get better or they get worse: Disaster never stay exactly the same . This means
your response environment will constantly be changing and the situation an hour ago may be
completely different from the latest one . Situation may deteriorate for the worst or it may be
improved for the better.
10)Things will last much longer : Things may last much longer than one expect . There is a
tendency for everyone to think that after an earthquake or a hurricane or any disaster that
things will be cleared up in a week or two . Months later, as a society continues to struggle
with rebuilding , they realize that the recovery may take months or even years
26
1)Challenges of Training: Training programme has to be practical oriented with
emphasis on different scenarios and problem solving exercises. This makes the
functionaries aware of the specific responsibilities , and to discharge the task effective
before, during and after the disaster. The specialised trainers can provide training to a
group of community trainers, who in turn can provide training to the local volunteers.
Good efforts are made by central and state government to impart training to specific
groups on disaster management . However, the effectiveness of trainers is one of the
major challenges in India and several other countries , especially in developing
countries.
27
national; boundaries , cross boundary issues of disaster management should be
addressed through enhanced regional co operation. Furthermore, an effective regional
response system should be developed to pool capacity for mutual benefits.
6) Challenge during the rescue Phase: The most immediate need during the
destructive event and in its immediate aftermath is to rescue those who can be saved
. for instance , during a tsunami some volunteers may reach out and provide
assistance to other in need. The task force , specifically deployed at the affected area
may have to provide first aid to the victims, and also provide emotional support.
8)Challenge of Jurisdiction: Each of these has some basis for discretion and
authority , and each is likely to be wary of instruction issued by others. Together ,
they form a tangled web of chains of command , with ample opportunity for
confusion, resentment , and conflict .
10) Challenge for nuclear power plants: There are challenges for nuclear power
plants to improve security against disaster. There are often protest by locals protesting
the safety concerns of such plants. The protest were triggered on account of the
meltdown of fukushima daiichi power plant of japan in march 2011.The nuclear fuel
at the stricken fukushima Daiichi power plant began melting just a few hours after the
intial earthquake. On may 1oth 2013 , Prime minister of japan mr Kan announced the
Japan is Abandoming its plan to build 14 new nuclear reactors by 2030. Additionally ,
28
Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany temporarily closed seven nuclear plants built
before 1980.
a)Rest : One needs to get adequate rest to over the problem of stress arising on
account of a disaster. Adequate rest is the foundation of stress management . One
needs to establish a routine and gets to bed at a reasonable hour.
b)Exercise: One needs to exercise to overcome the problem by stress .Exercise can
be done either early in the morning or in the evening. One may consult a doctor
before starting any exercise routine.
c)Eat: One needs to eat a well balanced diet and at regular intervals, especially when
adequate food is available. At times , after a natural , there may be shortage bof food
and whatever food is available may not be adequate.
d)Relax: Whenever possible, schedule extra time for relaxing. Choose the activities
that one enjoys or that one finds relaxing . The relaxing activities may include –
reading listening to music , gardening , painting cartooning – whatever one likes to
do.
29
e)Avoid alcohol and drugs: One should avoid overdose of alcohol as a mean to cope
up with stress arising out of disaster. Also , one should not indulge in drugs , unless a
doctors prescribes certain medicine to deal with the stress or trauma.
a)Get the Facts: One should get information about the effect of the disaster from
reliable sources, rather than replying on the rumor mill to provide the information .
Also, relevant information must be obtained from authentic sources regarding the
venue , the dates and timing of relief distribution by government and NGO’s
b) Prepare a schedule : Try to establish a schedule . Set regular times for meals ,
waking up in the morning , or talking with family and friends. Coming up with a daily
, structural schedule can help you establish a sense of predictability and control.
c)Develop an action plan: One needs to decide who’s going to do what and when .
Also one needs to assess one financial situation and discuss the option with financial
advisor to alleviate stress relating to financial concerns.
d)Focus on your strength.: One needs to focus on one’s strength to cope up with the
effects of disaster . One needs to be mentally strong to handle the situation and also to
help others in the area to cope up with the post traumatic stress disorder.
e) Rely on your Spirituality: Turn the problem over to your spiritual power for
guidance and strength. It is a known fact that the humans spirit is very strong .Some
of the books that make us spiritually strong include
a) Connect with social support: Getting social support from others can be a major
factor in helping people overcome the negative effects of a traumatic event and post
traumatic stress disorder . Given that a natural disaster can impact an entire
community , your support system may be weakened by a natural disaster. However ,
even connecting with one person can have a larger impact. Identify local support
groups or available crisis counsellors to talk to. Take advantage of these
opportunities.
b)Release emotions and tension: One needs to talk about the disaster effects or
problems so to release emotions and tension . It is likely that other in the community
are experiencing similar feelings so this gives everyone an opportunity to release
negative feelings and discuss practical ways to deal with the situation.
30
c) Spend time with friends and family: One needs to spend time in enjoyable
activities with friends and family members. This may involve watching some videos ,
story telling or listening , playing some games, preferably indoor games so on.
e) Do not take out anger on relative and friends: One needs to avoid spilling one’s
anger on relative and friends . It would be difficult for them to be emotionally
supportive, if their feelings are affected by you. Get cooperation and support from
your relative and friends to overcome the feelings of anger rather than attacking them
by spilling one’s anger on to them .
31