Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Australian HiFi-May - June 2018
Australian HiFi-May - June 2018
REVIEWED
Turntable
Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary
Loudspeakers
Richter Thor 10.6
Subwoofer
Dynaudio Special Forty
Loudspeakers
Micromega M-100
Int. Amp/DAC/Streamer
Nagra CDP
CD Player
B&W 800 D3
May/June 2018 $9.99 aushifi.com
Loudspeakers
ON TEST
B &W
800 D3
B&W has slashed the
«ÀVivÌÃy>}Ã
«`it
INTERVIEW
Sound Gallery
celebrates its
2nd anniversary
03
comes alive – with more dynamics, improved • extra heavy-duty medical-grade outlets
custom manufactured by Hubbell
imaging, and cleaner, enhanced bass. Video • individually addressable outlet zones
is crisper, with darker blacks, and brighter • event scheduling
• IP addressable with built-in web
colours. That’s why TORUS POWER is browser interface
the consistent choice of knowledgeable • remote/cloud-based monitoring
• JEYPXRSXMƤGEXMSRF]IQEMP
audiophiles, home theatre enthusiasts and • password protection
custom electronic system integrators. • RS-232 for Crestron and other control
TORUS POWER.
8LI[SVPHƅWƼRIWXGPIERTS[IVWSYVGIJSV
EYHMSZMHISERHGSRXVSPW]WXIQW
EDITOR’S LEAD IN
HEARING DAMAGE
ON THE RISE
I
have been rather intrigued by a motor vehicle advertisement
that’s currently in high rotation on television which shows a car
warning its driver that a pedestrian has stepped out in front of
said vehicle, allowing the driver to apply the brakes and prevent
an accident. I honestly can’t remember what type of car it is at
the moment that I am writing this, and I am so close to dead-
line that I won’t have the opportunity to watch enough television to see
the advert again so I can make a note of the make of the car in time to
include it in this editorial… but the fact that I can’t remember tells you
something about the effectiveness of television advertising, in that not
only can’t I remember the model of the car, but I can’t even remember
the make. (Then again, it might just be telling you something about my
shot-term memory!)
What intrigued me about the ad is that the person who steps out
in front of the car is wearing headphones, the passenger in the car is
wearing headphones… and in fact every single person in the commercial
is wearing headphones except for the driver… and in my experience as
a commuting motorcyclist, most drivers these days are wearing either
headphones or earphones as well. I guess that since wearing headphones
(or earphones) whilst driving is actually illegal, they wouldn’t have been
able to get the commercial to air if the driver had been wearing a pair.)
This advert certainly has a ring of truth about it to me, because the
large majority of people I see on the street in commercial suburbs—on
week-days at least—are wearing headphones. While this is certainly great
news for the audio industry (particularly those companies which man-
ufacture headphones, which seems to be all of them these days) it’s not
so great news for the people wearing those headphones, because many
of them will be listening at volume levels that will result in either short-
term or permanent damage to their hearing.
When I say ‘many’ listeners, I mean around one in every ten. Na-
tional Acoustic Laboratories recently measured the headphone playback
volume levels most often used by more than 3,500 regular headphone
users and found that just over ten percent of them were listening at levels
that have been proved to result in hearing damage. At present, statistics
show that around 15 per cent of Australians will experience some form
of hearing loss in their life. National Acoustics Labs estimates that as a
result of the increase in popularity of using headphones, this figure will
increase to 25 per cent by 2050.
Hearing damage isn’t only about losing high frequencies, or dimin-
ished acuity; it can also mean tinnitus, which causes sufferers to con-
stantly hear ringing or buzzing sounds in their ears for the rest of their
Embodying the spirit of the Jamo brand,
life. And like hearing loss itself, tinnitus is incurable. The take-away here
is to ensure that you do not to listen to your headphones at sound pres- STUDIO 8 series delivers contemporary design,
sure levels that could result in hearing damage, which based on current high performance, and balanced, natural sound.
research into hearing loss, means levels of 85dBSPL or more. But how are In traditional bookshelf and floorstanding speakers
you supposed to be able to establish if you’re listening to your music at and with optional Dolby Atmos ® integration.
sound pressure levels that are too high?
Home theatre and music systems never looked so good.
If you use headphones, a rough and ready method is to load an SPL
app onto your mobile phone, and then hold one of your headphones’ jamo.com.au
ear-cups as close as possible to your phone’s microphone and measure
the volume level using the app. If you use earbuds, I don’t even have
a rough and ready method, so you’ll need to watch this space, because
we’re working on a solution for you. greg borrowman
DANISH SOUND DESIGN
May/June 2018, Vol. 49 No. 3
52 SOUND GALLERY
ÀƬǚŽɁˁʁȭƬɻʊȭƬ˹ƬʊǜǒǔȊǞʊǜɁʁƬǔʊ
also one of its most upmarket stores,
ŘȭƞɁȭƬ˹ǒƬʁƬ˿ɁˁƋŘȭǞȭƞŽʁŘȭƞʊ
that are not available anywhere else
in Australia. And there’s a very good
reason for that.
58 HIGH-END REVIEW
Almost all high-end loudspeaker
manufacturers depend on specialist
driver manufacturers to build their
drivers for them… which why many
of them sound similar. But when you
build all your own drivers, you can
ƋʁƬŘǜƬŘǜʁˁǚ˿ƞǔǏƬʁƬȭǜʊɁˁȭƞNJ
DEPARTMENTS
Audio News 6
Behind The Scenes 52
Blu-Ray Reviews 70
Dealer Directory 72
FEATURES DVD Reviews 70
Editor’s Lead-In 3
6 AUDIO NEWS
Esoterica 51
New releases including the Perreaux 255i, Open
Jazz Track 68
Audio Designs CP1 & UF1, Audio Research Ref
160M, Denon AVR-X8500H, Audio Analogue AA-
Hi-Fi Marketplace 73
Phono, Audio-Technica AT-LP7, DS Audio ST-50, High End 58
Audioquest Beetle, BlueSound, Clearaudio Tracer, Interview 52
Exposure XM9, Chord Qutest, Devialet Phantom, Obituary 82
Astell&Kern AK70MkII, Musical Fidelity M6S, and Rock On 66
Focal Listen Wireless. Shop Talk 52
MUSIC
SoundSites 50
52 INTERVIEW
Subscriptions 4
John Ong has been an integral part of the Mel- 66 ROCK ON
bourne audio scene for more than twenty years, ‘Who cast John Legend as Christ in this version
ŘƋʁɁʊʊ ǜǒƬ ǞƬǚƞ Ɂnj ʁƬǜŘǔǚǔȭǷƙ ʁƬʊƬŘʁƋǒƙ ƞƬʊǔǷȭƙ of Rice and Webber’s classic musical Jesus Christ
Music Hall mmf 1.5
REVIEWED
Turntable
Harbeth 30 2 Anniversary
Loudspeakers
Richter Thor 10.6
manufacturing, and now retailing (again!)… Superstar?’, asks an incredulous Jez Ford. But he
Subwoofer
Dynaudio Special Forty
Loudspeakers
Micromega M-100
Int. Amp/DAC/Streamer
Nagra CDP
82 OBITUARY
68 JAZZ TRACK
ON TEST
years, but he also authored several books, cre- half-dozen new releases, one of which was in-
ated a world-famous website and was a famous spired by Donald Trump, whilst another was in-
broadcaster… spired by WA’s Mungo National Park. That’s jazz INTERVIEW
Sound Gallery
for you!
celebrates its
second anniversary OUR
FRONT
03
3 EDITOR’S LEAD-IN
John Ong reveals why…
9 771442 125002
COVER
The number of Australians with music-induced 70 BLU-RAY REVIEWS
Taking pride of place on this issue’s front
hearing damage is on the rise, with National If you’ve already heard of Alter Bridge, you’re cover is a B&W 800 D3 Loudspeaker.
Acoustics Laboratories predicting that if things ŘǒƬŘƞɁnjƬǏÄɡǜƬʁƙŽˁǜǔȭnjɁʁŘǜʁƬŘǜƙŘȭƞǔnj˿ɁˁɻʁƬ For a full review and laboratory test of a
ƞɁȭɻǜƋǒŘȭǷƬƙǔǜ˹ǔǚǚŘǏƬƋǜɁȭƬǔȭnjɁˁʁÄˁʊǜʁŘǚǔŘȭʊ a fan of Barbra Streisand you won’t want to miss pair of 800 D3s, turn to page 58.
by the year 2049. this blast from the past.
Australian Hi-Fi 5
PERREAUX | OPEN AUDIO DESIGNS
PERREAUX 255i
INTEGRATED
AMPLIFIER
Perreaux has released a new integrated amplifier, the 255i, which it
says is the most powerful Class-AB integrated amplifier it has ever
built, being rated at 250-watts continuous per channel into 8Ω and
500-watts continuous per channel into 4Ω.
The new Perreaux 255i can optionally be fitted with a
32-bit/384kHz DAC and a phono preamplifier which can accommo-
date both moving-magnet (MM) and moving-coil (MC) cartridges.
The 255i has three separate power transformers and four independent
power supplies. According to Martin van Rooyen of Perreaux: ‘The 255i
is designed to handle difficult speaker loads. Its MOSFET output stage is
capable of continuously delivering a genuine 360-watts into an 8Ω load and
OAD RELEASES
530-watts into 4Ω, so it will drive difficult speakers with ease, producing
controlled, quality audio.’
FIRST AMPLIFIERS
On the rear panel, the 255i has one balanced line-level input (via OAD (Open Audio Designs) has released its first two amplifiers, the CP1
XLR) and four unbalanced line-level inputs (via RCA). The front panel control preamplifier and UF1 power amplifier. Although Open Audio
includes a line-level auxiliary input via 3.5mm socket and a head- Designs is a new company, the man behind it, Melbourne electronics
phone output via 6.5mm socket. You can also bypass the preamplifier designer Jon DeSensi, will be well-known to Australian audiophiles,
section of the 255i and connect directly to the power amplifier via an having previously founded Music Labs Australia. ‘OAD is a performance-
‘Amp In’ pair of RCA sockets. oriented company that strives to advance state-of-the-art music reproduction
The optional DAC/Phono module uses the top-of-the-line ESS at all times,’ said DeSensi. ‘Driven by genuine advances in technology and
Technology ES9038PRO Sabre DAC and has two coaxial digital inputs, performance, the OAD brand uses “ultrafidelity” as both its trademark and
two optical inputs and a USB input. The coaxial and optical inputs hallmark, as this underpins everything that we do.’
can handle up to 32-bit/192kHz, while the USB input goes up to The first two products available from OAD are the CP1 control
32-bit/384kHz and also handles DSD 64, 128, and 256. This new DAC/ preamplifier and UF1 power amplifier. The CP1 has an 11cm colour
Phono module can also be factory retrofitted to the Perreaux 150i and TFT LCD full colour display with a touch capability, so that all features
250i integrated amplifiers as an upgrade. of the CP1 are controlled from the display, effectively eliminating the
All functions on the 255i are controlled by a microprocessor, ac- need for mechanical potentiometers and switches. ‘Unlike its mechanical
cessed via front-panel pushbuttons and rotary encoder. The amplifier’s counterpart, an electronic touch display also has the advantage of allowing
operational status is clearly shown via a large LCD display. Volume the shortest possible signal path from inputs to outputs, thus ensuring the
and balance is done via microprocessor-controlled resistor banks, so integrity of the audio signal,’ DeSensi told Australian Hi-Fi Magazine. For
there are no noisy potentiometers in the signal path. those who’d prefer to control the CP1 from the comfort of their couch,
The microprocessor also monitors the amplifier’s output stage to it comes with a remote control that duplicates all the functions of the
protect it against mains power in-rush, over-current, over-temperature, touch display, including input switching, volume control, mute and
d.c. offset, internal a.c. supply variations and d.c. at the output. ‘The standby modes.
protection is non-invasive and does not degrade the signal path’, said van The OAD SP1 has eight discrete power supplies, four for each chan-
Rooyen. ‘You really need to audition this amplifier to appreciate its innate nel, and input selection is via high-quality gold-plated Swiss-made
sound quality,’ said Mark Gusew of BMC Wholesale, which distrib- relays. Once you’ve selected the input you want, all the other inputs are
utes Perreaux in Australia. ‘The amount of top-to-bottom control over the isolated. Volume and balance control is all achieved via a resistor ladder
speaker is remarkable—with inherent speed and dynamics. This is one of the that uses laser cut precision, low-noise and zero-induction resistors.
most musical amplifiers you will ever hear!’ The Perreaux 255i retails for OAD rates the power output of the UF1 power amplifier at 200-watts
$7,995, with the optional DAC/Phono upgrade at additional cost, and per channel, both channels driven into 8 ohms. The output stage is
is available now. comprised of Thermaltrak bipolar transistors that enable it to have an
ultra-wide bandwidth coupled with a high-current capability. ‘Thanks
For further information, please contact BMC Wholesale on to the UF1’s unique technology, including the latest in cutting-edge bipolar
(03) 8683 9910 or visit the website at www.bmcw.com.au transistors, the UF1 offers superb sound characteristics as well as incredible
power and low level detail,’ said Rom Beyerle of Sonic Purity, which
was the first retailer in Australia to demonstrate the new amplifiers. ‘An
amplifier must be able to cope gracefully with impedance dips to 4 ohms and
lower. The transistors used in the UF1 are in a different class from conven-
tional transistors in that the current gain is completely maintained over the
full power bandwidth.’
Available now, the Open Audio Designs Ultrafidelity CP1 Control
Amp sells for $6,500 (RRP), while the Open Audio Designs UF1 Power
Amplifier sells for $6,300 (RRP).
1 2 3
➜
➜
4 5 6
There is a lot happening It is still rated at 70 watts RMS/channel, Digital to Analogue componentry,
and sells for $2,650. releasing the world’s first high-end DAC,
at Len Wallis Audio The ND8006 is an excellent solution the Digilog, in 1987. Their expertise
at the moment, with for today’s market. It incorporates a high shows in this uni.
both new product quality CD player, along with streaming
facilities for on-line and stored content. 5 The wave of price readjustments
releases and with the It has AirPlay, Bluetooth, Internet Radio continues – the most dramatic being
continuing flurry of and is compatible with Spotify, Amazon, from PANASONIC. Their TH77EZ1000
price adjustments... TIDAL and Deezer among others. It has 77” OLED TV is without doubt one of
HEOS multi-room technology on board the finest TV screens ever produced –
allowing you to add additional wireless but at $34,000 sales were very limited.
1 STAX, who we believe manufacture speakers around your home as well. It Panasonic have just repositioned this
the finest headphones on the market, can also be used as a quality DAC. At at $19,995. If you are considering a
turns 80 this year. To celebrate they have $1,990 this unit has a lot to offer. very high performance large screen TV,
released a very limited anniversary model drop in and have a look – you will not
based on the existing SRS-3100 system. 3 We now have the AVID Acutus SP be disappointed.
They have upgraded the specifications turntable on display. We have been
of the SR-L300 Earspeaker (pictured) singing the praises of AVID turntables 6 BLUESOUND has been steadily
to approximate the performance of the for a long time now, but this is the gaining a reputation as one of the best
SR-L700. The changes to the SRM-252S first time that we have shown their wireless multi-room streaming systems
driver are mostly cosmetic. flagship model. This is fitted with an on the market – they have also recently
There are only 13 of these systems SME 309 tonearm, and sells for a little repositioned (reduced) their prices to
available for Australia, so if you have over $23,000. bring them closer to parity with overseas
an interest it would be wise to act now. markets (joining the likes of Krell,
The system sells for $2,698. 4 The other exciting new product is the Musical Fidelity and Stax). With the
MUSICAL FIDELITY M6s DAC. This availability of higher resolution streaming
2 MARANTZ have released a new is a 32bit/768kHz Digital to Analogue now available from companies like
amplifier (PM8006) and a matching CD/ Converter that sells for $2,699. Superb TIDAL the demand for higher
Streamer (ND8006). The amplifier is an performance and great value. Musical performance systems is growing,
update of the very successful PM8005. Fidelity were one of the pioneers of and this is where Bluesound steps up.
AUDIO RESEARCH ‘The result is a new benchmark in musicality in every criterion of sound
quality,’ Sawyer told Australian Hi-Fi Magazine.
REFERENCE 160M The Ref 160M is rated at 140-watts continuous, with less than
1.0% THD at rated output and less than 0.04% THD at 1 watt. The
Audio Research has released its Reference 160M Vacuum Tube Monau- frequency response is 0.5Hz to 110kHz –3dB and the power bandwidth
ral power amplifier. It uses a new audio topology for Audio Research, is 5Hz to 70kHz –3dB. Available in silver and black finishes, the Audio
with fewer and better components in the signal-path than in previous Research Reference M 160 monobloc power amplifiers will retail for
designs, switchable ultralinear/triode operation, proprietary auto-bias, $49,990 per pair.
and output tube monitoring and protection. ‘The array of features fitted
to the new Ref 160M has never been offered before in any Audio Research For more information, contact Synergy Audio Visual on
amplifier,’ said Philip Sawyer, of Synergy Audio Visual, which (03) 9459 7474 or at www.synergyaudio.com
distributes Audio Research in Australia. ‘The designers at Audio Research
have created a new style that features a transparent faceplate that allows
you to see the KT150 vacuum tubes while integrated into
that faceplate is an innovative power meter whose output-
level markings are illuminated by hidden LEDs.’
The four KT150 power tubes are automatically and
continuously biased using Audio Research’s
proprietary auto-bias circuit, which is flexible
enough to allow you to substitute KT88 or
KT120 valves. The driver tubes are 6H30s. The
power supply uses solid-state power regulation.
‘The best circuit path is a short path,’ says Sawyer,
‘so Audio Research engineers created a new audio
circuit topology with the shortest signal path and
the fewest components, all of which are incorporat-
ed on a special four-layer circuit board that lowers
the noise floor to unprecedented levels.’
DENON AVR-X8500H (Enhanced Audio Return Channel) and HLG (Hybrid Log Gamma)
compatibility are also supported. eARC will be enabled via firmware
13.2-CH AV RECEIVER
update in 2018.
The AVR-X8500H also comes with the full Audyssey Platinum
suite of DSP algorithms including MultEQ XT32 automatic room
Denon has released its AVC-X8500H 13.2 channel, 150-watt per chan- acoustic correction, which can analyse each speaker’s output at up
nel AV Receiver with support for Amazon Alexa, Dolby Atmos, DTS:X, to eight measurement locations and generate precision digital filters
and Auro 3D in Australia. to optimise each channel for the correct frequency and time domain
The AVR-X8500H uses thirteen custom-made discrete monolithic response. Also included is the MultEQ Editor App that allows users
amplifiers each rated at 150 watts into 8Ω, enabling it to deliver Dolby to view and customise the sound to address specific problems in the
Atmos or DTS:X without any external amplification. The AVR-X8500H room, and tailor the sound to personal preferences.
also supports Auro 3D surround sound decoding via firmware update, The AVR-X8500H receiver is not being mass-produced,
up to Auro 13.1 channel, three-layered speaker layout including top but is instead being hand-built in Japan in small batch-
and height centre channels. It offers full wireless connectivity via es and is available in Australia now for $5,999 (RRP).
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and streaming capabilities with Apple AirPlay and
wireless multi-room audio technology. For further information, please contact Qualii on 1800 242 426
The AVR-X8500H is fully compatible with the latest HDMI con- or visit the website at www.qualii.com.au
nectivity and HDCP 2.2 specifications on all eight HDMI inputs and
triple HDMI outputs. The receiver
also supports 4K Ultra HD 60Hz
video, 4:4:4 Pure Colour sub-
sampling, High Dynamic Range
(HDR), 21:9 video, 3D and BT.2020
pass-through support. As such,
the AVR-X8500H is prepared for
4K Ultra HD Blu-ray disc play-
ers, set-top boxes and other 4K
Ultra HD sources. Additionally, it
can support legacy
systems by upscaling
standard and high
definition analog and
digital video content
to 4K Ultra HD.
Dolby Vision, eARC
GLOBAL
TECHNOLOGY
AWARDS
Celebrating the best life-enhancing,
cutting-edge consumer products
The European Imaging and Sound Association is the unique collaboration of 55 member
magazines and websites from 25 countries, specialising in all aspects of consumer electronics
from mobile devices, home theatre display and audio products, photography, hi-fi and in-car
entertainment. Now truly international with members in Australia and the USA, and still growing,
the EISA Awards and official logo are your guide to the best in global tech!
AUDIO ANALOGUE
AAPHONO
PHONO STAGE
Italian high-end hi-fi manufacturer Audio Analogue has released
the second product in its ‘PureAA’ line, the AAphono… which is,
obviously, a phono stage!
‘Audio Analogue’s PureAA line draws key ideas from its Anniversary
amps, released to celebrate the company’s 20th anniversary, but aims to
apply them in a slightly different way,’ said Boris Granovsky, of |
Absolute HiEnd, which distributes Audio Analogue in Australia.
‘Whereas the Anniversary amplifiers are totally minimalist, models in
the PureAA line have loads of features for music lovers who need a wider
range of functions and connections in a single product.’
The Audio Analogue AAphono accommodates both moving-
magnet and moving-coil cartridges, offering a selection of different
gain and loading options for MC cartridges as well as a range of
input capacitance and resistance options for MM cartridges. ‘Selecting
options is as simple as pressing a button,’ said Granovsky. ‘And any
adjustments you make are saved and will be remembered if the unit is
switched off or even if it’s disconnected.’
The AAphono’s circuitry includes three toroidal transformers: one 89dB (MM) and 72dB (MC). It measures 87×220×372mm (HWD),
for each channel plus one for the control circuitry. The amplifica- weighs 5.8kg and sells for $2,800 (RRP).
tion is split between two separate gain stages with an infrasonic filter
placed between. Audio Analogue specs the frequency response of the For more information, contact Absolute Hi End on (04) 8877 7999
AAPhono at 10Hz–20kHz ±0.25dB, and the signal-to-noise ratios as or at www.absolutehiend.com
DS AUDIO ST-50
STYLUS CLEANER
Japanese optical cartridge pioneer DS Audio has just launched its first
audio accessory, the ST-50 stylus cleaner. The ST-50 isn’t your typical
stylus cleaner. It comprises a cleaning pad made of the same urethane
resin used to filter the air in high-tech clean rooms. To use it, you sim-
ply tape your turntable’s platter in place so it can’t rotate, then place
the ST-50 onto the turntable platter and lower the tonearm (preferably
using a tonearm lifter) so the phono stylus sinks into the gel pad. Do
this three times and DS Audio claims your stylus will be completely
free of dirt and dust. ‘In the same way that the urethane resin prevents
dust from contaminating a clean room by absorbing micro-level dust
particles, the ST-50 effortlessly removes particles of dust and dirt from the
stylus tip,’ said Boris Granovsky of Absolute Hi End, which distrib-
utes DS Audio in Australia. ‘Compared to using brushes and solvents, it is
extremely gentle and safe, because no force is being applied to the stylus tip
and there is no risk to cartridges that use cement-bonded styli, whose bond-
ing can sometimes be dissolved by certain solvent-based cleaning liquids.’ casing and rinse it in tap water, then allow it to dry at room temperature for
The ST-50 stylus cleaner presents with a sleek aluminium casing around 30 minutes.’ Available now, the DS Audio ST-50 stylus cleaner
with a nickel-plated finish, with an underside padded with leather so sells for $115 (RRP).
as to present a soft surface for the turntable’s platter. ‘Best of all, the
ST-50’s urethane gel pad is washable and re-usable,’ said Granovsky. ‘So For more information, contact Absolute Hi End on (04) 8877 7999
to maintain optimal cleaning power, you simply remove the pad from the or at www.absolutehiend.com
Come to us for
Ex DEMO special
Upto 40% off
Included Euro Speakers
CLEARAUDIO ‘But beneath the seeming simplicity of its sleek design lies a wealth of
workmanship and a raft of smart details.’ Sitting only three steps down
TRACER TONEARM from Clearaudio’s flagship Universal arm in the company’s range of
tonearms, the Clearaudio Tracer sells for $3,495 (RRP).
German manufacturer Clearaudio has released a new tonearm, the
Clearaudio Tracer, taking its tonearm line-up to ten, if you count For further information, please contact Advance Audio
both its standard radial tonearms, of which the Tracer is one, and its on (02) 9561 0799 or visit the website at
tangential tonearms. www.advanceaudio.com.au
‘When creating the Tracer tonearm, Clearaudio’s design team drew on a
number of engineering tricks typically associated with high-end watchmak-
ing,’ said Nigel Ng of Advance Audio. ‘Its design features a high-pre-
cision, low-friction tungsten/sapphire bearing and a carbon tonearm tube,
which means the design is both extremely rigid and very lightweight, giving
a just-right combination of stability and agility.’
Anti-skating force is adjustable using a simple dial, rather than
some more complex method, and the azimuth of the aluminium
headshell is also easily adjusted. The underslung counterweight
reduces the overall centre-of-gravity of the arm, yet tracking force is
still a straightforward adjustment. The Tracer tonearm is available with
a black carbon arm-tube or a silver carbon arm-tube. Aluminium parts
are anodized to match the colour of the arm-tube. ‘The Clearaudio Trac-
er is an elegantly minimalist design that places particular emphasis on the
stable positioning of the phono cartridge above the record surface,’ said Ng.
FOCAL IN COLOUR
Australian Hi-Fi 13
CHORD ELECTRONICS | DEVIALET | ASTELL & KERN
MUSIC HALL
mmf 1.5
TURNTABLE
R
oy Hall, the founder of United States was the Crosby Executive Then there’s the cartridge that comes sup-
Music Hall, is the person Black turntable, which sold for $109 with plied with the mmf 1.5. The Melody is made
responsible for the very tonearm and cartridge and was, in Hall’s especially for Music Hall by Audio-Technica,
modern trend for quality personal and considered opinion, ‘a heap of so I have no idea what it costs Music Hall,
turntables to be supplied rubbish!’ Hall designed his Music Hall USB-1 but Audio-Technica’s most popular low-cost
all set up and ready to go. turntable as a direct competitor to it. cartridge is its AT-95, which usually retails for
Before Music Hall started Music Hall’s new mmf 1.5 turntable isn’t around $80. So if you had to buy a dustcover,
to build its ‘plug ‘n play’ machines, the exactly a ‘turn-key’ model, because you do a preamp and a cartridge, you’d be up for
manufacturers of audiophile-grade turnta- have to do some assembly and alignment $330, which is already more than half what
bles worked on the principle that one of the yourself, but it’s pretty straight-forward, as Music Hall is asking for its mmf 1.5 which
indicators of the quality of a turntable was you’ll soon learn… comes standard with all three.
how much work the buyer had to do before But there’s something else that’s remarka-
being able to play an LP. THE EQUIPMENT ble about the Music Hall mmf 1.5 turntable.
At the extreme high end of the turntable The Music Hall mmf 1.5 is a three-speed Whereas most companies that manufac-
market, this meant not only assembling the (33.33, 45 and 78rpm), belt-driven turnta- ture budget turntables seem to feel that it’s
turntable by putting oil into the bearing, ble—with dustcover—that comes complete necessary to make those turntables look like
fitting the platter, locating the motor and with a tonearm into which has been pre-in- budget turntables by compromising their ‘fit
wrapping the belt around both the drive stalled a ‘Melody’ moving-magnet phono ‘n finish’, Musical Hall has instead seemed
pulley and the platter, but also fitting cartridge, and also has a built-in phono pre- to have gone overboard making the mmf 1.5
the tonearm, then attaching the phono amplifier, so the mmf1.5 can be connected look as flash as possible, from its high-glossy
cartridge to that tonearm and aligning it. directly to the line input of any amplifier… cherry-wood veneered finish and nicely en-
Ensuring correct alignment involved pur- quite handy given that not a few amplifier gineered S-shaped tonearm (which has a re-
chasing test records and alignment tools. manufacturers are not including phono movable headshell, about which more later)
For machines using springs for isolation, inputs on their products these days. to its high-quality hinged Perspex dustcover.
even more tuning was required. Some If you don’t think there’s anything at all
manufacturers say their machines are so remarkable about the previous paragraph,
complicated they’ll only work correctly if it’s because you haven’t peeked at the
installed and tuned by a factory-trained recommended retail price of the Musical
technician. Hall mmf 1.5. No need to peek. I’ll tell you.
Even at the opposite end of the market, You’ll get change from six hundred bucks.
most turntable buyers were required to fit Why do I think that’s remarkable? Musical Hall has
instead seemed
the platter and dustcover and install and Because I have reviewed a great many
align the phono cartridge and Hall realised turntables whose dustcover is an optional
that even this level was a hurdle for many extra that will set you back around $100.
And most turntables don’t have a phono
to have gone
overboard making
buyers and as a result they were buying
cheap, poor-sounding turntables simply preamplifier built in, so if you need one,
because they were ‘ready-to-go’ out of the
box. According to Hall, the result of this
you’ll be up for anything from $150 for a
basic no-frills Rek-O-Kut model, to maybe
its mmf 1.5 look as
was that the best-selling turntable in the $350 for a Musical Fidelity V90-LPS. ǡŘʊǒŘʊɡɁʊʊǔŽǚƬ
Australian Hi-Fi 17
ON TEST M u s i c H a l l m m f 1 . 5 Tu r n t a b l e
the Music Hall Melody cartridge, that you’ll than elliptically shaped ones, for example. Readers interested in a full technical appraisal of the
be listening to it quite happily until the Serious audiophiles have their stylus exam- performance of the Music Hall mmf 1.5 Turntable
should continue on and read the LABORATORY
stylus needs replacement (usually around ined under microscope (100× magnification
REPORT published on the following pages. Readers
1,000 hours of listening… assuming you’re required) every 100 hours after they’ve should note that the results mentioned in the
not playing 78s!). notched up around 400 hours of play. This report, tabulated in performance charts and/or
displayed using graphs and/or photographs should
When the time for a stylus replacement is why I always factor replacement stylus
ċě ČŭŢƛƧƓƯěē ðƛ ðƐƐŗǍŁŢĴ ŭŢŗǍ Ƨŭ Ƨļě ƛƐěČŁǠČ ƛðŠƐŗě
does come around you have a few options. cost into my buying decision whenever I am tested.
One is to buy an elliptical replacement purchasing a cartridge. It’s far better to buy
stylus for the Melody cartridge. The ‘Carbon a cheaper cartridge on which you can afford
Fidelity’ CFN3600LE stylus sold by US outfit to regularly replace the stylus, than to buy an
LP Gear will slot straight in. Another is to expensive cartridge and not replace the stylus LABORATORY
buy a brand-new cartridge already fitted with regularly because you can’t afford it! TEST
an elliptical stylus (Audio Technica’s AT-95E
or AT100E, for example) and a new headshell
But no matter what cartridge or stylus you
use, its performance would be for naught
RESULTS
with slots that allow correct alignment. One unless the basic performance of the turntable
Newport Test Labs is now measuring the
option you won’t have in Australia is to to which it’s fitted is not up to par, and I’m
frequency response of phono cartridges
buy a replacement stylus, because the local happy to report that the performance of the
using two different measurement
distributor sells only complete cartridges for Music Hall mmf 1.5 is not just ‘up to par’, but
techniques. Graph 1 shows the frequency
$80 (RRP) and not replacement styli. The exceptionally good!
response and channel separation of the
advantage of having a second cartridge fitted Despite me using the slowest piano music
Music Hall Melody moving-magnet
to a separate headshell is that because you I had available, I could not hear anything in
phono cartridge when is reproducing
can swap headshells in a matter of seconds the reproduced sound that I could attribute
a pink noise test signal. This is a
on the Music Hall mmf1.5, it would be easy to either wow or flutter. The pitching was
particularly difficult test for any cartridge
to use your more expensive, elliptical stylus rock-steady and sustained high-frequency
because pink noise means that the
on your newer records, and the Melody with sounds were perfectly pure. Neither could I
cartridge is simultaneously reproducing
its conical stylus on your older records (and hear any low-frequency contributions from
all frequencies between 20Hz and 20kHz.
when playing 78s). either the main platter bearing or the drive
Reproducing this pink noise test signal
If you do decide to buy a new cartridge motor whilst I was listening to music. The
you can see that the Music Hall Melody
and headshell you’ll also need to purchase an sound was as clean as a whistle.
cartridge delivered a very flat frequency
alignment tool. The tool I always recom-
response between 70Hz and 1kHz, where
mend is the Pro-Ject ‘Align-It’ which retails CONCLUSION the response was within ±3dB. The overall
for around $199 (RRP). If you don’t want to The Music Hall mmf 1.5 is a superb turntable
frequency response was 22Hz to 20kHz
spend this much, Turntable Basics sells one whose performance belies its price... big-time.
±5dB. You can see the overall flatness
for $20 (plus shipping, as it’s only available And it’s not only an exceptional performer;
of the response was pulled down by the
on-line). If even this is too much, grab your- it also looks exceptionally good into the
low-frequency boost centred at 55Hz and
self a Garrott Bros cartridge alignment card bargain. Best budget turntable of the year? It
the high-frequency roll-off above 15kHz.
for $10. (It would have been so much easier if certainly has my vote! Nigel Cullen
Across the range between 150Hz and
Music Hall had included an alignment card.)
14kHz the frequency response was a truly
Incidentally, if 1,000 hours from a stylus
doesn’t seem very long to you (despite the
CONTACT DETAILS excellent ±1dB.
Channel separation was 21dB @ 1kHz,
fact that it would involve listening to three Brand: Music Hall which is good, as well as being better
albums per night, five days a week, for two Model: mmf 1.5 than specification. More importantly,
years), consider the fact that when playing an
RRP: $599 channel separation was maintained at
LP, essentially what’s happening is that you’re
Warranty: Three Years 15dB or better all the way from 300Hz up
dragging a diamond through a ditch (groove)
Distributor: Convoy International Pty Ltd to 9kHz.
made of vinyl. If you straightened out the
Address: Unit 2. 314 Horsley Road Graph 2 shows the frequency response
‘ditch’ on both sides of an LP and joined
Milperra NSW 2214 of the Music Hall Melody cartridge
them together, that ditch would be around
measured using a spot frequency
1 kilometre long, so 1,000 hours of playing T2: (02) 9774 9900
time equates to dragging your stylus around E: info@convoy.com.au
1,560 kilometres. W: www.convoy.com.au
Also, I was also being rather generous
when I stated stylus life at 1,000 hours. Stylus
manufacturer’s suggestions regarding stylus Ɗ Performance
life usually range between only 400 hours Ɗ Appearance
and 800 hours, with all of them noting that Ɗ Phono stage built in
actual stylus life will depend on the align- Ɗ Adjustable speed
ment of the stylus (overhang, azimuth, etc)
as well as the tracking and anti-skating forces Ɗ Stylus availability
you use… plus, of course, the condition of Ɗ Strobe card
your records and the playback speed. Ɗ Alignment card
Stylus life also depends on stylus shape. Ɗ Non-adjustable feet
Conically-shaped styluses wear out faster
dBm
-10
technique, where Newport Test Labs measured Graph 1. Graph 1. Frequen-
only one frequency at a time, then presented cy Response and channel -15
cartridge because at any given time it’s only 1kHz. Music Hall Melody
reproducing one frequency, and only in Cartridge. -30
Graph 1. -50
0.00 Hz 4000 00 8000.00 12000.00 16000.00 20000.00 0.00 Hz 100.00 200.00 300.00 400 00 500.00
well-controlled ringing and the only notice-
able anomaly being that the overshoots and Graph 3. THD at 1kHz @ 3.54cm/sec RMS. Music Hall Graph 4. Rumble and noise re 1kHz at 3.54cm/sec RMS.
ringing are not symmetrical on both halves Melody Cartridge. Green trace shows background noise and hum (disc not
rotating). Black trace shows noise and hum when record
of the waveform.
ŁƛƓŭƧðƧŁŢĴ̻sƯƛŁČQðŗŗŠŠij˘̻˜»ƯƓŢƧðċŗěǠƧƧěēLJŁƧļ
When the turntable’s adjustable speed Melody moving-magnet cartridge.
control was in its default (detent position)
Newport Test Labs measured platter speed
as 2.4% fast at 33.33rpm and 1.8% fast at the Australian standard, which is 0.15% a bit of low-level noise below 30Hz, though
45rpm. This means that a 3kHz signal played RMS unweighted. When Newport Test Labs the left-most of the two peaks is the tonearm
back at 3,073Hz at 33.33rpm and at 3.054Hz measured the wow and flutter components resonance frequency, but otherwise, below
at 45rpm. From a musical perspective, this separately, the result for wow came in at 150Hz, any noise from the turntable itself is
difference represents less than one quarter 0.12% (unweighted) at 33.33rpm and for indistinguishable from the background envi-
of a semitone in pitch, so it might just be flutter, at 0.08% (unweighted). Again, both ronmental noise. Above 150Hz bearing and
audible to someone with perfect pitch, but are excellent results. motor noise is essentially more than 90dB
not to anyone else. Turntable rumble is shown in Graph 4. down, which is an excellent result.
After the rotational speeds were correctly The green trace shows measured noise when Power consumption of the Music Hall
adjusted (necessary in order to be able to the platter is stationary, so it’s just show- mmf 1.5 is negligible, with the turntable
perform accurate wow and flutter measure- ing mains hum (the peaks at 50Hz, 150Hz, pulling 2.9-watts when playing at 33.33 rpm
ments), via the speed control at the rear 250Hz, 350Hz and 450Hz.) Except for the or 45 rpm, and 3.05-watts when playing at 78
of the turntable plinth, Newport Test Labs 50Hz and 150Hz hum components, all others rpm. When the turntable is switched off via
measured the total wow and flutter of the are more than 80dB down. You can see that the plinth control, the power pack continues
Music Hall mmf 1.5 turntable as 0.05% at low frequencies, the background noise is to consume 0.16-watts of power on its own.
RMS unweighted at 33.33rpm and 0.04% sitting at around –70dB, so this represents the Overall, both the Musical Hall mmf1.5
RMS unweighted at 45rpm, both of which limit of the measurement. Once the platter turntable and the Melody cartridge returned
are excellent figures, and ‘way better than is rotating (black trace) you can see there’s excellent results in all tests. Steve Holding
For authorised dealers and more information visit www.pioneeraudio.com.au or call Powermove
Distribution on 08 8338 5540.
PioneerHomeAU
ON TEST
HARBETH
RADIAL2.
Harbeth rates the cone in the 30.2 Anni-
30.2 ANNIVERSARY
versary as being 200mm in diameter, however
the Thiele/Small diameter, which is what’s
used by designers to determine the volume
of the cabinet and the size and length of
LOUDSPEAKERS the bass reflex port(s) in that cabinet is just
164mm, which results in an effective cone
area (Sd) of 212cm². The cone’s roll surround
H
arbeth does seem to be Limited Edition’ badges, plus the grille has a is made from rubber, which is excellent news
stringing out its 40th metallic black and gold anniversary badge. for Australians, because the extremely high
anniversary models The coup de grâce is the silver eucalyptus levels of ultraviolet radiation in Australia
a tad (given that the veneer, which is exclusive to Harbeth’s ‘Anni- mean that roll surrounds made from foam
company celebrated versary’ models. usually start to fall apart after about five
that anniversary ‘way years, whereas rubber roll surrounds are virtu-
back in 2017) but so THE EQUIPMENT ally indestructible.
long as we keep getting models finished in The Harbeth 30.2 is a two-way bass reflex The 30.2 Anniversary’s bass reflex port is
those beautiful silver Eucalyptus Anniversary design with a 25mm soft-dome tweeter, a 50mm in diameter and 55mm long, and is
veneers we won’t be complaining! 200mm bass driver and a single front-firing positioned quite a long way from the driver
As you’ll likely already guessed from the circular bass reflex port. You can’t really whose output it is intended to augment,
model number, the 30.2 is an upgraded see the dome of the tweeter, because it’s which is quite unusual. As you can see, it is
version of Harbeth’s M30.1 model, the review protected by a steel mesh that Harbeth calls also positioned at the top of the front baffle
of which you can find at www.tinyurl.com/ a ‘Hexgrille’ presumably by virtue of the fact rather than at the bottom, which is the more
AHF-Harbeth-30p1-Review. The M30.2 Anni- that the holes in the mesh are hexagonally usual placement. When I reviewed the 30.1
versary model sports WBT ‘Nextgen’ binding shaped, rather than the circular, square or I surmised that this location was chosen in
posts, Harbeth’s ‘new-look’ tweeter, au- diamond shapes that are usually found in the order that the cabinet could be smaller (ex-
dio-grade polyester capacitors that are made metal grilles used to protect tweeter domes. cept that despite being advertised by Harbeth
in England specifically for Harbeth plus, of Although Harbeth reportedly manufac- as a ‘space-saving reference monitor’ it’s not
course, being an ‘Anniversary’ model, it is tures one of its tweeters, the one used in particularly small!) but I suggested that the
badged front and rear with ‘40th Anniversary the 30.2 is made especially for it by SEAS, same result could have been achieved by
using two ports, located slightly above and If you look at the size and weight of the on both sides. This dual-side veneer tech-
to either side of the bass/midrange driver… a 30.2 Anniversary, one thing should strike nique is much better than using just a single
configuration that Harbeth already uses on its you immediately, which is that for a speaker veneer on the outer wall (a technique used
Monitor 40.2. whose cabinet measures 460×277×275mm by most speaker manufacturers) as it seals the
The bass reflex port on the 30.2 Anniversa- (HWD) it doesn’t weigh very much—only fibre-board better against climatic conditions
ry does not have same problem that I noted 11.6kg in point of fact. The reason for this is and ensures dimensional stability. Where-
on the 30.1, which is that if you operate the that all the panels on the speaker except the as the Monitor 30.1 is available in a fairly
speakers without the grilles fitted (as many front baffle are only 12mm thick… less wide range of veneers that are made from
passionate audiophiles are wont to do) you than half the thickness usually real wood, the 30.2 Anniver-
will see a piece of white damping foam at found in a loudspeaker of sary is only available in
the inside end of the port. It seems Harbeth this size. Even the front Silver Eucalyptus. The
has paid heed to the comments in my earlier baffle of the Monitor veneers on my review
review and although the foam is not black, 30.2 is only made sample were grain-
as I recommended, it’s now grey and is dark from 18mm-thick matched and
enough not to be visible through the port if stock, whereas finished with a
you use the speakers without the grilles. the front baffles thin coat of cel-
If you’re now thinking to yourself that you of most speak- lulose lacquer
could simply leave the grilles on when the ers are between that according
speakers are not being used and take them 25 and 32mm to Harbeth’s
off when you are using them, you’ll have to thick. This very Owner’s Man-
think again, because the grilles on the 30.2 lightweight ual can be kept
Anniversaries are very, VERY difficult to re- construction clean by wiping
move. This is because instead of being made is intentional, it lightly with a
from the usual wood or plastic and attached because Harbeth damp cloth.
to the front panel using plastic pegs, the prefers to control As presaged in
frame of the grille on the 30.2 Anniversary panel resonances not by the introduction, the
is made from flat mild steel, which has to be increasing the mass of the rear of the Harbeth 30.2
pressed into a rather deep and very narrow panels, but by controlling the Anniversary sports original WBT
groove that runs around the periphery of resonances with tuning devices (damping Nextgen binding posts that are made in
the front baffle. This technique means you mats) attached to the inside of those panels. Germany (the 30.1 has very nice standard
won’t get any unwanted reflections from the Unlike some Harbeth models, however, there gold plated binding posts). Having used both
grille frame when you’re using the speakers is some cross-bracing inside the Monitor 30.2 types, my vote is definitely for the WBTs—
with the grille in place (and those reflections to help constrain panel movement. they’re great!
are one of the reasons audiophiles remove Unlike most modern loudspeaker cabinets, Inside the Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary you’ll
loudspeaker grilles in the first place!). which are constructed without any visible find a large printed circuit board that is home
However this construction technique also seams, joints or fixings, the Harbeth 30.2 to four ferrite-cored inductors, nine capaci-
makes the grilles very difficult to remove— Anniversary cabinets have more than a few tors and six cermet resistors. As stated in the
indeed, a previous reviewer had actually visible joints and fixings, in particular the introduction, the 30.2 Anniversary uses very
damaged the cabinet of my review sample 12 screws that hold the rear panel to the two high-quality audio-grade polyester capacitors
side panels and to the that are made in England specifically for
Australian Hi-Fi 25
ON TEST Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary Loudspeakers
However, although the 30.2 Anniversary was cient, and if you want more bass, it’s simply a Once more, having played exactly the same
designed by Alan Shaw and takes advantage matter of moving the loudspeakers closer to a recording on the 30.1 and made copious
of the new processes and materials that are rear wall… as I discovered, though I preferred notes about what I was hearing, I scored the
now available, Shaw himself says that it’s not the overall sound when the speakers were 30.2 fractionally higher.
really a ‘new’ design, just an evolution of an a couple of metres from that wall, so that’s
original BBC design (in this specific case, it’s where I conducted almost all my auditioning. CONCLUSION
an evolution of a design known as the LS5/9). I was totally blown away by the clarity It is my guess that almost every single person
For best performance you’ll need to mount and precision of the bass delivery, which was reading this review will be doing so in order
the Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary on stands, yet particularly evident when playing Schu- to make a decision about whether to buy a
Harbeth itself doesn’t make any for them. As bert’s piano trios, as realised by Trio Alba pair of Harbeth Monitor 30.1s or a pair of
it happens, Harbeth speakers are so popular on SACD (Audiomax 9023013-6). Listen to Harbeth 30.2 Anniversaries, and it’s a hard
in the UK that two British manufacturers the openness of the sound of Chengcheng decision because they’re both superb-sound-
make stands specifically for the various Har- Zhao’s piano, and to the dynamics. I thought ing speakers that, not surprisingly given their
beth models. Two that are already available that perhaps Philipp Comploi’s cello was a many similarities, sound very similar.
for 30.1 (and thus are perfect for the 30.2 An- bit more ‘out front’ in the sonic mix, but If it were a horse race, and I were the stew-
niversary as well) are made by TonTräger and perhaps all the better just to hear the utter ard, I’d put the 30.2 Annniversaries ahead by
HiFi Racks, and are available in Australia from gorgeousness of the sounds he is able to a nose!
importer/distributor Audio Magic for $1,700 extract from it. But it’s not a horse race, and so after lis-
and $1,190 per pair, respectively. Alternative- This same SACD also was perfect to reveal tening to the two side by side, you may well
ly your local hi-fi dealer may have Australi- the performance of Harbeth 30.2 Anniver- decide you prefer the sound of the Harbeth
an-made stands available to suit the Harbeth sary’s tweeter, because Livia Sellin’s violin Monitor 30.1s.
30.2 Anniversary. The only real requirements has been recorded to perfection. Listening In the end, it will probably come down
are that the stands are solid, elevate the to the opening bars of D897 Notturno was a to having to make exactly the same decision
speakers at least 50cm above the floor and truly magical experience, as the sounds of you have to make every time you book an
don’t have a flat metal plate at the top. both the cello and the violin seemed to issue aeroplane flight, and that is that whether you
As always when I listen to a pair of Har- from almost nothingness then solidify in the choose to fly First Class or Business, you’re
beth speakers, I was impressed by the way the atmosphere directly in front of me. Impor- going to arrive in exactly the same place, at
30.2 Anniversaries were able to create a real, tantly, the higher harmonics of the violin exactly the same time… but it’s ‘way nicer up
palpable sense of acoustic space to the music sound were almost ethereally pure, with no at the pointy end. Hugh Douglas
that was reproduced… and they managed to ‘edge’ at all. I paid particular attention to the
Continued on Page 28
deliver this ‘air’ and ‘ambience’ irrespective of presentation of the very highest frequencies,
the ‘scale’ of the music being played. It didn’t because, as I noted in my review of the 30.1s, Readers interested in a full technical appraisal of
the performance of the Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary
matter whether it was a solo performer or a I thought the highs on the 30.1 were slightly
Loudspeakers should continue on and read the
full orchestra—or any type of ensemble in held back. I am happy to be able to say that LABORATORY REPORT published on the following
between—the sound was seemingly suspend- the high-frequency sound on the 30.2 Anni- pages. Readers should note that the results
ed in the room, neither constrained within versaries is not ‘held back’ in any way at all… mentioned in the report, tabulated in performance
the cabinets nor ‘larger than life’, but just, it’s perfect. Not only is there no roll-off at all, charts and/or displayed using graphs and/or pho-
tographs should be construed as applying only to
somehow, ‘there’. but also the sound itself is rather more pure
ǜǒƬʊɡƬƋǔǞƋʊŘȧɡǚƬǜƬʊǜƬƞƖ
Listening to Tomorrow, the opening track and more translucent.
on Rachel Collis’s album Nightlight, the 30.2 As for the midrange from the Harbeth 30.2 CONTACT DETAILS
Anniversaries’ delivery was so ambient that Anniversary, it was perfection itself, and as
if I closed my eyes, I could really imagine she the late great J. Gordon Holt famously said: Brand: Harbeth
was singing there in the room, and the sound ‘If you don’t get the midrange right, nothing else Model: 30.2 Anniversary
of her piano was superbly realistic. When the matters.’ One of the discs I use for assessing RRP: $6,950 per pair
percussion chimes in, the percussive nature vocal clarity is a BBC recording of Dylan Warranty: Five Years
of the sonic was like a sudden aural shock Thomas’ famous ‘play for voices’, ‘Under Distributor: Audio Magic Pty Ltd
to the ears after the fluidity of the vocal and Milkwood’—which was very likely monitored Address: 482 High Street
piano. It’s this sense of naturalistic space— with BBC speakers. If a loudspeaker can’t Northcote VIC 3070
and of image height and depth—that I think articulate correctly, you’re going to miss half
T: (03) 9489 5122
is probably the Harbeth 30.2 Anniversaries’s the dialogue of the play, and if it can’t sepa-
E: info@audiomagic.com.au
greatest strength. rate different voices speaking simultaneously
W: www. audiomagic.com.au
I trialled the bass delivery of the Harbeth you’ll miss the whole ‘feel’ of the hubbub of
30.2 Anniversary first with Machine Gun the play. The Harbeth Monitor 30.2s didn’t
Fellatio’s Unsent Letter and was surprised to let me down… I heard not only every single
Ɗ Superb midrange
hear rather more punch and depth than I word, but also every single syllable of every
Ɗ Ambience retrieval
might otherwise have expected from what is single word. Glorious!
Ɗ Gorgeous highs
essentially a relatively small two-way loud- The perfection of the Harbeth 30.2
speaker, but the bass was certainly not overly Anniversary’s midrange sound was further Ɗ Stands
extended, which I proved to my satisfaction revealed when I listened to the amazing Ɗ Grille removal
by continuing the listening session first with soprano sound of Berit Norbakken Solset on Ɗ Single veneer choice
piano and then with pipe organ. However, ‘The Image of Melancholy’ (BIS 2057), which
in smaller rooms it should be more than suffi- is not only riveting, but hauntingly beautiful.
PM10S1
Reference Stereo
Integrated
Ampliier
MADE IN JAPAN
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
20 Hz 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K 500 Hz 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 1. Frequency response. Trace below 900Hz is the averaged result of nine Graph 2. High-frequency response, expanded view showing response with grille
individual frequency sweeps measured at three metres, with the central grid point ɁǏɤŽǚŘƋǘǜʁŘƋƬɦ˸ƬʁʊˁʊǷʁǔǚǚƬɁȭɤʁƬƞǜʁŘƋƬɦƖďƬʊǜʊǜǔȧˁǚˁʊǷŘǜƬƞʊǔȭƬƖÀǔƋʁɁɡǒɁȭƬ
on-axis with the tweeter using pink noise test stimulus with capture unsmoothed. placed at three metres on-axis with dome tweeter. Lower measurement limit
This has been manually spliced (at 900Hz) to the gated high-frequency response, 500Hz.
an expanded view of which is shown in Graph 2.
dBSPL Ohm Deg
110 30 180
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 150
100 120
20
95 90
90 60
85 30
80 0
75 -30
10
70 9 -60
8
65 -90
7
60 -120
6
55 -150
50 5 -180
10 Hz 20 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 3K 10 Hz 20 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 3.³Ɂ˹njʁƬɴˁƬȭƋ˿ʁƬʊɡɁȭʊƬɁnjnjʁɁȭǜȊǞʁǔȭǷŽŘʊʊʁƬǡƬ˾ɡɁʁǜɤʁƬƞǜʁŘƋƬɦŘȭƞ Graph 4. Impedance modulus of Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary Loudspeaker (black
ŽŘʊʊʤȧǔƞʁŘȭǷƬƞʁǔ˸ƬʁƖÂƬŘʁǞƬǚƞŘƋɴˁǔʊǔǜǔɁȭƖñɁʁǜʤ˹ɁɁnjƬʁǚƬ˸ƬǚʊȭɁǜƋɁȧɡƬȭʊŘǜƬƞ trace) plus phase (light blue trace). Dark blue trace is reference 6 ohm precision
njɁʁƞǔǏƬʁƬȭƋƬʊǔȭʁŘƞǔŘǜǔȭǷŘʁƬŘʊƖ calibration resistor.
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
20 Hz 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20 Hz 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 5. In-room frequency response using pink noise test stimulus with capture Graph 6.,ɁȧɡɁʊǔǜƬʁƬʊɡɁȭʊƬɡǚɁǜƖõƬƞǜʁŘƋƬǔʊɁˁǜɡˁǜɁnjŽŘʊʊʁƬǡƬ˾ɡɁʁǜƖ<Řʁǘ
unsmoothed. Trace shown is are the averaged result of nine individual frequency sweeps blue trace is anechoic response of bass driver. Black trace is the frequency response
measured at three metres, with the central grid point on-axis with the tweeter. (from Graph 1).
most modern speaker designs with 8Ω nomi- The in-room response of the Harbeth 30.2 them… unless you have a small room and lis-
nal impedance ratings, but it means that the Anniversary is shown in Graph 5 with New- ten at lower levels, in which case 40–50-watts
30.2 Anniversary is a true ‘eight-ohm’ design. port Test Labs using a pink noise test stimulus, would likely be sufficient.
The kink in the impedance trace is that panel averaging nine different sweeps measured at Looking back at the conclusion I drew
resonance I noted earlier. The saddle between three metres, with the upper frequency of the about the Harbeth Monitor 30.1 after exam-
the two resonant peaks is at 45Hz, showing measurement limited at 10kHz. As you’d ex- ining its test results, I wrote that it ‘was a
that you will get little effective output from pect, the response is superbly flat and there’s very well-designed loudspeaker, with a higher
the bass/midrange driver below this frequen- absolutely no ‘skew’ to the trace—it almost efficiency than I would have expected for its
cy. The rather high impedance of the system tracks the 85dBSPL graph horizontal. size and driver configuration.’
around 1.3kHz means some amplifiers might Newport Test Labs measured the sensitivity I am going to say exactly the same thing
reduce their output in this region as a result, of the Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary as being about this Harbeth 30.2 Anniversary model,
so amplifier matching will assume greater im- 86.5dBSPL at one metre for a 2.83Veq input, but add the note that its measured frequency
portance with this design than it might with which is a touch lower than the average for responses are superior to those which Newport
some other speakers. The way the impedance all speakers, so I’d suggest that you use an Test Labs measured for the Harbeth Monitor
rises above 15kHz ensures the speaker will be amplifier with an output power rating of 30.1, and the efficiency is identical.
very ‘amplifier-friendly’ however. at least 60 or 70-watts per channel to drive Steven Holding
Australian Hi-Fi 29
t would seem that Richter is using one of the
other common methods of stating driving
diameter, by referencing either the overall
diameter of the driver frame, or the distance
between the mounting holes in that frame.
Ultimately, it’s the cone area that dictates
how much air the cone will displace (along
with cone travel… or ‘throw’ of course).
As you can see from our photograph, the
ichter has two bass reflex ports on the front
panel. The beauty of having ports on the
front, rather than on the side of the cabinet
(like some earlier Richter models!) or at the
back or underneath the cabinet, is that it
means you can recess the subwoofer into
a wall—or into a cupboard or cabinet—to
completely remove the subwoofer from the
istening room. In the case of the Thor 10.6
this will be made easier by the relatively
small size of the cabinet, which measures just
442×308×390mm (HWD). Then again, the
mall size means you also might think it’s
o small in your room that you can hide it
somewhere (such as behind a couch or chair)
so that there’d be no need to go to such
engths… and you’d be right.
I have to say that although I am not
personally particularly perturbed about the
actual physical size of any subwoofer (though
my better half certainly is!) I do care about
ts shape, as I particularly dislike subwoofers
that are as wide as they are high and deep,
The arrival of the new Thor 10.6 proves because I don’t find this squat look very
THOR 10.6
that Gosnell met the design brief. It’s 20 per appealing. So I particularly liked the profile
cent smaller than the Thor MkV, 30 per cent of the Thor 10.6, which is higher than it is
lighter, and its amplifier is rated at 450-watts, wide. I also liked the fact that the feet are
B
ig is bad, ports are poxy if you leave the loudspeaker grille fitted) and, which seems to me rather strange, since
and vinyl sucks. These are miracle of miracles, there’s no vinyl to be a floor doesn’t magically ‘flatten out’ just
the three things Richter’s seen, just a very classy matte-painted surface because you’re positioning a subwoofer on
managing director, Brian that’s so black it’s probably the same finish it rather than a main loudspeaker. And, just
Rogers, discovered when he that was used on Hotblack Desiato’s stunt as you don’t want a normal loudspeaker to
went on a tour of Australian ship. (You know, the one Zaphod Beeblebrox ‘wobble’, you also do not want a subwoofer
hi-fi retailers. He was asking ‘borrowed.’) to ‘wobble’—indeed it is essential that it is
them about subwoofers, of course, and the completely stable.
consensus was that their customers wanted THE EQUIPMENT But back to those bass reflex ports. Each
subwoofers that were small, they didn’t like Remove the front grille of the Thor 10.6 and one is 75mm in diameter and 225mm long,
bass reflex ports to be visible, and they didn’t you’ll instantly see this subwoofer’s most with radiused curves at the exit. They come
like vinyl finishes (due to problems with the imposing feature, a dish-shaped polymer with tight-fitting grey foam ‘port plugs’
vinyl splitting and peeling at the corners, cone with an unusually distinctive neoprene which you can insert to block one or both
according to Rogers). roll surround that was tooled by Richter ports. This allows you to ‘tune’ the sound
So when he returned from his road trip, he itself. Richter rates this driver at ‘10-inches’ of the subwoofer to better-suit the size of
asked his Senior Engineer, Dr Martin Gosnell, in diameter, and it’s this ‘10’ that informs the your room, where you have the subwoofer
to start developing a brand-new Richter sub- model name: 10.6. The ‘6’ bit shows that it’s positioned, what you’re using the subwoofer
woofer, one that was smaller and lighter than part of Richter’s ‘6 Series’. for (type of music, type of movie etc) and,
the company’s award-winning Thor MkV, and Richter might rate the single front-firing of course, your own personal tastes. For
to make sure it was either a sealed design, or bass driver as a 10-incher (254mm), but my example, in larger rooms, leaving both ports
if it had to have one or more bass reflex ports, reviewer tape measure put the overall moving unplugged will deliver higher sound pressure
that customers wouldn’t be able to see them, diameter of the cone plus roll surround at levels in the 30–100Hz area, but the frequen-
and that Gosnell could specify any finish he 226mm. The important diameter, the Thiele/ cy response will roll off more rapidly below
liked, so long as it wasn’t vinyl. Oh, it would Small diameter, is 210mm, which puts the 35Hz than if both ports were plugged. If you
be good if he could squeeze in a more power- effective cone area (Sd) at 346cm². plug both ports, the deepest bass frequen-
cies (those below 35Hz) will be reproduced The Richter Thor 10.6’s low pass filter is preferable to use the speaker level terminals,
at a higher (relative) volume, but the bass not only adjustable, it’s also switchable (or then connect your main speakers to the ‘To
between 35Hz and 100Hz will be slightly ‘defeatable’, if you prefer this terminology): Speakers’ terminals on the Thor 10.6. With
attenuated. In terms of how the settings will You can switch it out of circuit by setting the this wiring arrangement, the Thor 10.6
affect the music, the sound will be quicker ‘Low Pass’ switch to ‘Off’. Setting this switch ‘strips’ the low frequencies from the signal
and punchier with both ports left open, but to ‘Off’ is recommended if you’re using the going to your main speakers, relieving them
smoother and more extended with both ports LFE output from an AV receiver to provide from any low-bass duties, which will improve
the subwoofer’s signal, their performance as a direct result.
as most AV receivers The Richter Thor 10.6 also has a ‘Pass
When they coined the phrase pre-filter the signal Through’ output that allows you to ‘dai-
ɽǜŘˁǜŘȭƞǜƬʁʁǔǞƋɻƙǜǒƬ˿ƋɁˁǚƞ
presented at their LFE sy-chain’ multiple subwoofers to improve
output. (And you’d also performance. When you use only a sin-
LISTENING SESSIONS
As with any subwoofer, for it to perform at
its best it is absolutely essential that the sub-
woofer be correctly positioned in your listen-
ing room and that its volume, crossover fre-
quency and phase controls are set so that the
output of the subwoofer integrates smoothly
with the output of your main speakers. Rich-
ter’s excellent 20-page instruction manual
(the information is excellent, but I found the
type rather too small for us vision-impaired
types) has outstandingly good advice about
all of this, but my advice is to work out where
the subwoofer should be positioned in your
room by following the specific procedure
outlined in this article: www.tinyurl.
com/subwoofer-placement and that
you should then tune the Thor 10.6 using
the specific procedure outlined here: www.
tinyurl.com/subwoofer-calibration manufacturer in the world. Despite this, sales and very musical, is also very wrong, because
That’s what I did, and the result was that really didn’t take off until a little band called the pitch of E2 should actually be 82.407Hz,
the Richter Thor 10.6 sounded amazing in The Beatles appeared on the Ed Sullivan show because we’re talking about the tempered
my living room! OK, so the Thor 10.6 was the in 1964, with the word ‘Ludwig’ emblazoned scale here. The beautiful sound of the bottom
major reason for the amazing sound, but the on Ringo’s bass drum. This single appearance string of the bass remains faithfully delivered
tuning certainly helped! literally doubled Ludwig’s sales, forcing them even if the guitarist has tuned it to D, which
When I say that the Thor 10.6 sounded to switch to seven day, 24-hour production is common for songs in the keys of D or G,
amazing, a large part of my amazement was to keep up, and Ludwig would thereafter because it makes playing the bass easier… it
that I simply wasn’t expecting such a small dominate drum sales in North America for also helps if you play a lot of Pink Floyd!
subwoofer—and one with a relatively small the next twenty years. But it’s not only the fundamentals that are
bass driver—to deliver such prodigious levels Although it’s still in business, Ludwig is precisely and accurately reproduced by the
of deep bass. This thing really kicks arse. no longer the largest drum manufacturer in Richter 10.6, it’s also the harmonics, which is
And it’s not only kick-arse bass, the bass it the world, but it’s certainly the most famous, essential in order to enable instant recogni-
produces is as tight as a fishes… well, let’s and by mere happenstance the timing of this tion of, say, the sound of a Fender Precision
not spell it out in a family magazine. Suffice review (2018) co-incides with the 100th an- bass versus the sound of a Rickenbacker 4001,
to say that when they coined the phrase niversary of Theobald’s death (he was one of though most people will be more easily able
‘taut and terrific’, they could well have been the 50 to 100 million victims of the influenza to pick the musician playing it—in this case
talking about the Thor 10.6. Listen to kick- epidemic of 1918). maybe Steve Harris versus Peter Buck, for
drum for example and you’ll hear the Richter Impressive though the Richter’s perfor- example.
deliver the perfect sound of the beater head mance with kick drum is, it’s equally impres- The harmonic rendition of the Richter
smacking the drum skin: depthy, realistic sive with other low-pitched instruments that Thor 10.6 is perfect, with the frequency of
and with the lower frequency of the full skin regularly appear in most musical groups— the harmonics delivered exactly… as well as
stretch hitting you in the stomach while the double-bass, cello, bass guitar, and keyboards the levels of those harmonics. Outstanding
higher-frequency harmonics provide the fill. (acoustic and electronic). Firstly, the bass is performance indeed.
If you’re into percussion trivia, you might ‘pitch perfect’, as they say, so that when a Distortion is exceeding low. Listening to
be interested in learning that the bass drum bass guitarist strikes the bottom string of his my favourite performance of Beethoven’s Cel-
pedal mechanism that drives the beater four-string electric bass, what you hear from lo Sonata No 3 (Steve Isserlis with Robert Lev-
head was invented by brothers William and the Richter is a beautifully rich-sounding ‘E1’ in on Fortepiano, available on Hyperion), the
Theobald Ludwig in 1909. Their American with a very obvious fundamental frequency aural clarity of both instruments is stunning,
company, Ludwig & Ludwig (they hailed of 41.203Hz, and not what you often hear and the contrasts between them achingly
from Germany, after all) was an extraordinar- from a subwoofer, which is a sound that revealed, and most appropriately both are
ily successful manufacturer of bass drums as primarily consists of the ‘E’ the octave above, given equal sonic weight, as the performers
a result, so by 1923 it was the largest drum at 82.406Hz… which, although it sounds fine (and no doubt the composer!) intended.
Cello sound is glorious no matter what’s CONCLUSION that when the low-pass filter is active,
being played, but one that I always recom- Aussie company Richter has succeeded where the high-frequency response rolls off at
mend to friends asking about cello is Elgar’s most other subwoofer manufacturers have around 18dB per octave above 150Hz,
superb Cello Concerto in E minor. Listen to not. It’s managed to build a small subwoofer whereas when the low-pass filter is defeat-
this on a lesser subwoofer and you may that doesn’t sound small at all, exhibiting ed, the natural roll-off of the driver is at
wonder if you’re hearing a human voice, marvellously deep bass performance, with a much more leisurely 12dB per octave.
but listening via the Richter 10.6, there is tuneful, rhythmic musical delivery and su- The traces show that when one bung is
no room for doubt. I don’t think the great perbly low levels of distortion. fitted, the cabinet is tuned to 30Hz and
Jacqueline Du Pre would be my first choice Even if it didn’t have the extraordinarily when both ports are left open, the tuning
for either performance or sound quality, but high level of connectivity, multiple EQ modes is 43Hz. The output of the ports is shown
she’s certainly my sentimental favourite, and classy finish the Richter 10.6 would have in Graph 4.
so for this work, emotion trumps both been on my short list. But because it does In Graph 2, Newport Test Labs has
performance and sound quality, with the have all these extras, it elevated itself right to shown the effect of the three equalisation
steely Maria Kliegel’s performance coming the top of that list. Samuel White curves on the near-field response of the
in a close second. Richter 10.6’s bass driver when both ports
Readers interested in a full technical appraisal of
Recognising that many readers of this are plugged and the low-pass filter is not
the performance of the Richter 10.6 Subwoofer
review will be primarily looking to purchase should continue on and read the LABORATORY in circuit. The ‘Music Mode’ equalisation
a subwoofer to enhance their enjoyment of REPORT published on the following pages. results in the flattest and most extended
movie soundtracks, with music as a second- Results displayed in the graphs and associated response, with the frequency response
ary reason, I also evaluated the Richter 10.6 comments about those results should be con- extending from 20Hz to 220Hz ±4dB, as
in a five-channel home theatre system (I’d strued as applying only to the sample tested. you can see from the black trace. In ‘Mer-
like to go Atmos, but my better half told lin Mode’ (blue trace) the Richter 10.6’s
CONTACT DETAILS
me six loudspeakers in our smallish family high-frequency response is rolled off
room—though I like to call it my home Brand: Richter above 60Hz at around 12dB/octave, and
theatre room—were more than enough). Model: Thor 10.6 the very low-frequency response is given
Watching movies, I was impressed by the RRP: $1,499 a little added extension below 20Hz. The
speed and stopping power of the Richter Warranty: Two Years ‘Home Theatre Mode’ equalisation deliv-
10.6, as well as its ability to deliver the Distributor: Richter Audio Pty Ltd ers maximum output at 60–70Hz, but is
very lowest sounds on my Blu-rays. The rolled off above and below these frequen-
Address: PO Box 231
‘depthiness’ is certainly enough to rattle cies, at around 30dB per octave below
Church Point NSW 2015
furniture and create an intensely powerful 60Hz and at around 12dB per octave
T2: (02) 4962 1594
sound field in the listening room, no mat- above 70Hz, so the response is around
E: info@richteraudio.com.au
ter whether you’re experiencing a pitched 45Hz to 140Hz ±4dB and, as you can see,
battle, a factory scene or just the director W: www.richter audio.com.au is the least flat of all the responses.
injecting low-frequency FX to generate Graph 3 shows the Richter 10.6’s
tension in the audience. • Amazing bass! response in Music Mode with both ports
Now you’re probably imagining that • Connectivity unplugged. You see the bass driver’s
I used the ‘Home Theatre’ mode when low-frequency response (the black and
• EQ modes
watching movies, but you’d be wrong. blue traces) rolling off below 70Hz to the
I did switch to the Home Theatre mode minima at 43Hz, before rising to peak at
• Two colour choices
when I first started watching, but I wasn’t around 22Hz before rolling off again. The
• Single grille colour
convinced by the sound I was getting so I red trace shows the output of the two
experimented with the other modes and in- bass reflex ports, and you can see that the
terestingly enough, found that in my home ports start contributing to the output at
theatre system, which has fairly small front 15Hz and are fully operational at 22Hz,
speakers, I preferred the overall sound when after which the output is linear until
the subwoofer was set for ‘Merlin Mode’
and both ports were unplugged.
LABORATORY 65Hz, where it starts rolling off, neatly
intersecting with the roll-on of the bass
Also interesting is that when I was using TEST driver. Note that the blue trace was meas-
REPORT
the Richter 10.6 in my main system, I pre- ured with the low-pass filter in circuit and
ferred the ‘Music Mode’ equalisation, but set to 160Hz, and the black trace was with
with the ports plugged when I was listening the low-pass filter out of circuit.
to classical music and unplugged when I Graph 1 shows the effect of bungs and Graph 4 also shows the Richter 10.6’s
was listening to anything else. This might low-pass filter on the near-field frequency response in Music Mode but this time
sound like a bit of a bother, but it only response of the Richter 10.6 subwoofer’s bass shows the difference between operating
takes a few moments to plug or unplug the driver. The black trace shows the driver’s the subwoofer with both ports unplugged
ports, and mostly I listen to either one type response when both bungs are fitted, the (the black traces, with the solid trace
of music or the other in any one listening blue trace shows the driver’s response when being the near-field response of the bass
session… I tend not to chop and change only one bung is fitted, and the red trace driver, and the dashed trace the near-field
between the two genres, so it took only a shows the driver’s response when no bungs response of the port) and with only one
few seconds of my time per day to make are fitted. The trace also shows the difference port plugged (the green traces, with the
the switch… though admittedly I had not between the response when the low-pass filter solid trace being the near-field response of
bothered to fit the grille, so the switching is out of circuit (black and blue traces) and the bass driver, and the dashed trace the
process was quicker than it would have when it’s in circuit, but set to its maximum near-field response of the port). You can
been if I had. crossover frequency of 160Hz. You can see see the cabinet seems better-tuned when
Australian Hi-Fi 33
LAB REPORT Richter Thor 10.6 Subwoofer
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500
both ports are unplugged than when just a Richter 10.6’s response extends from 17Hz ±3dB. With the low-pass filter set at 160Hz
single port is plugged. to 51Hz ±4dB. When the low-pass filter is set (maximum), the frequency response of the
The low-pass filter’s action is shown in to 70Hz, the response extends from 18Hz to Richter 10.6 was measured as extending from
Graph 5 for three settings of the low-pass 120Hz ±4dB. 24Hz to 220Hz ±3dB. Finally, Newport Test
filter control, with the Richter 10.6 operat- The far-field in-room frequency response Labs measured the response without the low-
ing with both ports plugged. Again we see of the Richter 10.6 subwoofer is shown in pass filter in circuit (black trace) as 26Hz to
that with the low-pass filter set at maximum Graph 6. With the low-pass filter set at its 260kHz ±3dB.
(black trace), the near-field response is 20Hz minimum (40Hz) setting, Newport Test Labs As you can see, the Richter 10.6 returned
to 220Hz ±4dB. With the low-pass filter set measured the frequency response of the outstanding results in all Newport Test Labs’
at its minimum point (40Hz, red trace) the Richter 10.6 subwoofer as 15Hz to 68Hz laboratory tests. Steve Holding
DYNAUDIO
SPECIAL FORTY
LOUDSPEAKERS
THE EQUIPMENT
D
ynaudio has a tradition One key approach has been to deliver a
of marking momentous Fully designed and engineered in Dynaudio tweeter with an extended response not so
occasions in its history Labs, the Special 40 is built right across the much upwards (the –3dB point is quoted at
by producing special road from those laboratories in the compa- 23kHz) but significantly downwards into the
editions of its loud- ny’s own factory in Skanderborg. It continues midrange, as low as 1kHz, while the woofer is
speakers. Yes, I know the tradition of high-quality stand-mount engineered to extend upwards as far as 4kHz.
many manufacturers do designs—not super-compact, being a me- That creates a natural crossover between
this, but Danish manufacturer Dynaudio has dium-sized speaker 36cm high and 31cm the two drivers, while one of the benefits of
been building speakers for so long that it now deep without counting protuberances—but designing its own drivers is that Dynaudio’s
has a quite a few ‘specials’ in its catalogue… certainly very room-friendly. tweeter and woofer also deliver as similar
and back-catalogue. The ‘Special One’ closed And while Dynaudio is currently creating an tonality and dispersion as the physics of the
off the company’s first decade in business. ongoing series of active and wireless models varying frequencies allow. So Dynaudio’s
The ‘Special Twenty-Five’ was designed and for the new age of streaming audio, that’s preferred first-order crossover circuit need
built in 2002 for Dynaudio’s 25 anniversary, not the ‘focus’ of the Special Forty—this is a only apply mild slopes and simple circuitry
and the ‘Sapphire’ was commissioned for the firmly traditional passive loudspeaker… no to achieve the desired impedance and phase
company’s thirtieth anniversary. built-in electronics at all—if you don’t count alignment. As the company says: ‘why ma-
So by now you should have guessed that the crossover network, that is! nipulate the musical signal to make the drivers
the Special Forty was built to commemorate Indeed Dynaudio says its goal here was gel, when you can make better drivers in the first
Dynaudio’s 40th anniversary, in 2017. to revisit the company’s 40 years of inno- place?’
But is there anything particularly special vation and bring it all together in the light Up top, then, is the Esotar Forty tweeter,
about this model other than it was built of everything it has learned since. I liked currently unique to this model, a 28mm
as an anniversary edition and is likely to Dynaudio’s description of its Special Forty soft-dome diaphragm, the coating of which,
become a collectable model? I just had to as ‘our greatest hits… re-imagined, remixed, applied in variable thicknesses for maximum
find out… remastered...’ performance, is described as ‘DSR’, apparently
a tongue-in-cheek initialisation denoting ‘Dy- because these are not age rings, as you might And the dynamics! The Who’s ‘Tommy’
naudio Secret Recipe’. Behind the diaphragm think—they are too straight and uniform, (24/96) came crashing in, the entry of 1921
is a new magnet and venting system designed for one thing. Rather multiple layers of birch making me near-jump out of my seat with its
to relieve the dome from back-pressure. wood have been coloured and compressed entry, so sharp and powerful an impulse did
into blocks before being the Dynaudios deliver.
sliced sideways to pro- IQ’s Mellotron-laden 1312 Overture com-
Australian Hi-Fi 37
ON TEST LAB REPORT
impedance of 6Ω (confirmed during testing), Readers interested in a full technical appraisal of You can immediately see that the high-fre-
so they don’t need an absolute beast of an the performance of the Dynaudio Special Forty quency response is flatter without the grille
Loudspeakers should continue on and read the
amplifier to drive them, though you should than with it fitted. When the grille is in place,
LABORATORY REPORT published on the follow-
invest in adequate power to have them de- there’s a peak in the response at 4kHz, then
ing pages. Readers should note that the results
liver their best; the large reserves of a Classé mentioned in the report, tabulated in perfor- small suck-outs at 3.2kHz and 6.5kHz. Up at
integrated amp in this case bringing them mance charts and/or displayed using graphs and/ 15kHz, where there’s already a little suck-out
thrillingly on song. or photographs should be construed as applying in the tweeter’s response, the presence of the
I also experimented with different speaker Ɂȭǚ˿ǜɁǜǒƬʊɡƬƋǔǞƋʊŘȧɡǚƬǜƬʊǜƬƞƖ grille makes it a little deeper.
positions, and clarity was certainly highest In Graph 3 Newport Test Labs has measured
with the speakers in a good amount of free the near-field low frequency response of the
space, some metre or more out from any bass/midrange driver when the port is open
walls on stands that put their tweeters at my (bass-reflex tuning, shown by the black trace)
seated ear height. If you need them further and when the port is blocked off (infinite
back, there’s some bass tuning available baffle tuning; green trace). The output of the
from those foam bungs I mentioned that port itself is shown by the red trace. (All near-
are supplied for the bass ports—either full field acquisitions.) You can see that no matter
bunged or with centres removed to tame what tuning you use, the output of the bass/
any rear reflections that might muddy rather midrange driver starts rolling off below about
than support their balance. I just kept them 125Hz. As theory predicts, it rolls off smooth-
out in free space, toed-in, their sound easily ly but only gradually at around 12dB per
filling a medium or even medium-to-large octave when the port is blocked, but rather
space, although these are speakers with such more rapidly (24dB per octave) when the port
brilliance of imaging and dynamics that is open, though in this case the output of
they are best appreciated in reasonably close the port compensates for the lack of output
proximity, where they can fully weave their from the driver. You can see the port’s output
magic. peak at 47Hz does not quite correspond with
the driver’s minima at 50Hz, presumably the
CONCLUSION result of some small compromise to get the
LABORATORY
Dynaudio has been sensible to finish these cabinet to work well with the triple tuning
speakers so strikingly in sliced birch, as possibilities (open, plugged, half-plugged).
TEST
the unusual finish draws attention to their The different tunings are also evident on
similarly high level of design and perfor- the measurement of the Dynaudio Special
mance. The Special Forty is an exceptional
standmount worthy of its anniversary
REPORT Forty’s impedance, which is shown in Graph
4. The red trace shows the classic bass reflex
status, with dynamics, tone and imaging ‘double hump’ with the saddle at exact-
highest on their long list of strengths. Put Newport Test Labs measured the frequency ly 50Hz. The resonant peaks are at 34Hz
them into a high-quality system, and hear response of the Dynaudio Special Forty and 80Hz, and both only a tad above 30Ω.
how they sing. Jez Ford as extending from 45Hz to 20kHz ±3dB. When the port is closed, there’s just a single
This is the response shown in Graph 1. resonant peak at 70Hz that tops out at 39Ω.
CONTACT DETAILS The section of the trace below 2kHz is the The impedance drops below 5Ω at 20Hz and
averaged result of nine individual frequen- between 150Hz and 220Hz, but is otherwise
Brand: Dynaudio
cy sweeps measured at three metres, with mostly above 7Ω. However those excursions
Model: Special Forty
the central grid point on-axis with the below 5Ω mean that the Dynaudio Special
RRP: $4,499 per pair
tweeter using pink noise test stimulus and Forty should be classified as a nominally 6Ω
Warranty: Five Years
with the capture unsmoothed other than design… which is exactly what Dynaudio has
Distributorƕ*ˁʊǔăɁǢÄĴñǜ˿³ǜƞ
by the averaging process itself. This trace done. The impedance at very high frequen-
Address: 158 Christmas Street
has been manually spliced (at 2kHz) via cies is heading downwards. An upwards tilt
hŘǔʁǞƬǚƞĴ,ʯ̋ʕƶ
post-processing to the gated high-frequen- would have been preferable, but since the
TFƕ ɍʯ̋̋ƶƶƶȴ̋ʹ
cy response, an expanded view of which impedance is still a high-ish 6.5Ω at 40kHz,
T2ƕ ɤ̋ʯɦȳƶɍ̋ʹȳ̋̋
is shown in Graph 2. You can see that the it’s unlikely to bother any well-designed
Eƕ ǔȭnjɁźŽˁʊǔʊɁǢƖƋɁȧƖŘˁ
response is not only spectrally balanced amplifier. The phase angle (blue trace) is
Wƕ ˹˹˹ƖŽˁʊǔʊɁǢƖƋɁȧƖŘˁ
(no tilts or skews in any direction), but well-controlled.
across the midrange it is particularly flat, The composite graph (Graph 6) superim-
Ɗ Highly musical essentially extending from 90Hz to 14kHz poses the various measurements and extends
Ɗ Thrilling imaging and staging ±1.25dB. the measurement range for two of them, so
Ɗ ȧȧŘƋˁǚŘǜƬǞȭǔʊǒ Graph 2 not only shows the high-fre- here you can see that the tweeter keeps on
quency performance of the Dynaudio Spe- rolling off above 20kHz and has a tiny reso-
Ɗ Not bi-wireable cial Forty in greater detail, it also shows nance at 26kHz, and that the port has a fairly
the difference in the frequency response large resonance at 700Hz. I doubt this would
Ɗ ď˹ɁǞȭǔʊǒƬʊɁȭǚ˿
depending on whether you’re listening be audible, but in the case of the Dynaudio
Ɗ Best with high-quality power
with the grille on (black trace) or the grille Special Forty you could check for yourself by
off (red trace). placing the speakers side by side, blocking the
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
20 Hz 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 500 Hz 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 1. Frequency response. Trace below 2kHz is the averaged result of nine Graph 2. High-frequency response, expanded view showing response without
individual frequency sweeps measured at three metres, with the central grid point ǷʁǔǚǚƬǞǜǜƬƞɤŽǚŘƋǘǜʁŘƋƬɦŘȭƞ˹ǔǜǒǷʁǔǚǚƬǔȭɡǚŘƋƬɤʁƬƞǜʁŘƋƬɦƖďƬʊǜʊǜǔȧˁǚˁʊǷŘǜƬƞʊǔȭƬƖ
on-axis with the tweeter using pink noise test stimulus with capture unsmoothed. Microphone placed at three metres on-axis with dome tweeter. Lower measure-
This has been manually spliced (at 2kHz) to the gated high-frequency response, an ment limit 500Hz.
expanded view of which is shown in Graph 2.
dBSPL Ohm Deg
110 70 180
Newport Test Labs 60 Newport Test Labs
105 150
50
100 40 120
95 30 90
90 60
20
85 30
80 0
10
75 9 -30
8
7
70 -60
6
65 5 -90
4
60 -120
3
55 -150
50 2 -180
10 Hz 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400 500 10 Hz 20 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 3.³Ɂ˹njʁƬɴˁƬȭƋ˿ʁƬʊɡɁȭʊƬɁnjnjʁɁȭǜȊǞʁǔȭǷŽŘʊʊʁƬǡƬ˾ɡɁʁǜɤʁƬƞǜʁŘƋƬɦŘȭƞ Graph 4. Impedance modulus of Dynaudio Special 40 loudspeaker with port open
woofer when port is open (blue trace) and when port is closed (green trace). Near- (red trace) and closed (green trace) plus phase (blue trace) with port open. Black
ǞƬǚƞŘƋɴˁǔʊǔǜǔɁȭƖñɁʁǜʤ˹ɁɁnjƬʁǚƬ˸ƬǚʊȭɁǜƋɁȧɡƬȭʊŘǜƬƞnjɁʁƞǔǏƬʁƬȭƋƬʊǔȭʁŘƞǔŘǜǔȭǷ trace under is reference 4 ohm precision calibration resistor.
areas.
dBSPL dBSPL
110 110
Newport Test Labs Newport Test Labs
105 105
100 100
95 95
90 90
85 85
80 80
75 75
70 70
65 65
60 60
55 55
50 50
20 Hz 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 10 Hz 20 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K 40K
Graph 5. Averaged frequency response using pink noise test stimulus with capture Graph 6.,ɁȧɡɁʊǔǜƬʁƬʊɡɁȭʊƬɡǚɁǜƖõƬƞǜʁŘƋƬǔʊɁˁǜɡˁǜɁnjŽŘʊʊʁƬǡƬ˾ɡɁʁǜƖ³ǔǷǒǜ
unsmoothed. Trace is the averaged results of nine individual frequency sweeps blue trace is anechoic response of bass driver. Black trace is frequency response
measured at three metres, with the central grid point on-axis with the tweeter. from Graph 1.
Upper measurement limited at 10kHz.
port of only one of them, and then feeding Forty as having a sensitivity of 83.5dBSPL at and frequency response. It’s low enough that
both speakers the same monophonic signal one metre for a 2.83Veq input, when using you should try to use a more powerful ampli-
with content at this frequency. If you can pink noise as the stimulus. This correlated fier than you might otherwise have consid-
hear a difference, choose the tuning with the quite nicely with a measurement of the Spe- ered, but I’d imagine 100-watts per channel
sound you most like. cial Forty made by Canada’s National Acoustic would be more than sufficient.
Dynaudio specifies the Special Forty has Laboratory, which reported it as being 83.5dB- Overall, the Dynaudio Special Forty
having a sensitivity of 86dBSPL but does not SPL (averaged 300Hz to 3kHz, re 2.83V/1m). returned exemplary performance in Newport
state all its measurement criteria. Newport Test It also correlates with about what I’d expect Test Labs’ suite of acoustic and electrical
Labs reported its test sample of the Special from a loudspeaker of the Special Forty’s size measurements. Steve Holding
Australian Hi-Fi 39
MICROMEGA
M-100
INTEGRATED AMPLIFIER/DAC/STREAMER
M
icromega’s M-100 paint the M-100 any colour from the central equipment rack. No matter which orientation
Integrated Am- European RAL colour chart. Reckoning you go for, you’ll be able to see the infor-
plifier is very ob- that its French customers will own French mation shown on the front-panel display
viously not your loudspeakers, Micromega also offers to match because there are two displays, one at the
ordinary integrat- Focal’s Black Lacquer, Carrara White, Imperial ‘top’ of the amplifier (this being the ‘top’ if
ed amplifier. This Red, Electric Orange and Bleu Nogaro loud- you’re flat-mounting the M-100) and one
isn’t only because speakers. (This isn’t just a patriotic offer, it’s on the thin edge of the amplifier, which
it’s not just an integrated amplifier, but also also a commercial one, because Micromega would be the ‘front’ if you were mounting
a DAC and a Streamer. It’s also because it’s now makes electronics for Focal, and in most it conventionally. The ‘top’ display has two
the wrong size, the wrong shape and doesn’t countries in the world—not Australia—the buttons either side of the display that are
have the usual array of controls you’d expect two companies share distributors.) If you used to control all the functions on the
to find on an integrated amplifier. So what choose a Focal colour option, you’ll save a amplifier. Because I had to send the M-100
was this famously French company thinking few bucks, because Focal colours add only back at the conclusion of this review I didn’t
when it brain-stormed this design? $1,490 to the retail price. wall mount it, sitting it horizontally on my
If you needed even more proof that equipment rack and one thing that annoyed
THE EQUIPMENT Micromega was thinking outside the square me about the dual displays is that whenever I
Whatever they were thinking, one thing is when it designed the M-100, consider that it’s used the remote, the ‘top’ display turned off
absolutely certain, and that’s that the de- designed to be wall-mounted. Yep, you can and simply showed the word ‘Micromega’,
signers were thinking outside the square… a attach it to the wall, so if you have optioned leaving only the ‘front’ display active. Maybe
long, long way outside the square… thinking, in a bright colour, or a multi-hued finish, there’s a way to stop this from happening… I
maybe, of a flattened rectangle, or an activity you’ll be staring at a huge expanse of it… one certainly hope so!
aid at an aerobics step class. I suspect that that’s 430mm wide and 350mm high. You How do four small buttons control all the
when you see your first M-100, you’ll either will have to purchase a wall mount to do this M-100’s functions?... and there are plenty of
love the look, or hate it. though, and a Universal M-One wall mount them! Once you have turned the amplifier
To help you love it, the M-100 is available costs $190 (RRP). Note that if you do mount on (top left button), the screen illuminates
in a myriad of finishes. The standard finishes the M-100 conventionally, watch out for the and the two buttons on the right become
are black or silver anodised aluminium (an four tiny shallow-coned feet at the bottom volume buttons (up/down), while the one at
obvious offering, as the M-100 is machined of the amplifier, they’re not actually sharp, bottom left becomes an input source button.
from a single block of the stuff, however but if you put the amplifier on a soft wooden If you press the input source button, the
Micromega has a ‘Micromega Custom Finish’ surface, or push the amplifier over any screen changes, and then the functions of the
(MCF) program in place which allows you surface, you could end up damaging and/or four buttons also change, so you can cycle
to specify any finish you want… you can scratching that surface. Micromega does actu- through inputs.
even have it covered in leather if you like. ally warn you about this in its manual, but it Other screens allow you to adjust the
In a conversation with Micromega’s Adrien doesn’t supply a manual with the M-100. You relative sensitivity of the inputs by up to
Hamdi, he revealed that at present, painted have to go on-line and download your own. 12dB, so the volume will stay the same when
finishes are the most popular option (though, You can mount the M-100 in a conven- switching between components that have
mind you, it’s an option that adds $1,800 tional fashion on a shelf—though it would different output levels, adjust balance, and
to the current RRP), with Micromega able to have to be a pretty deep shelf—or on an rename inputs (from a programmed list).
The ‘front’ display doesn’t have any Unlike many programs, it doesn’t offer much One thing Micromega’s White Paper does
buttons. What looks like a button is actually in the way of customisation: there are only not make clear is that although the output
a 3.5mm headphone jack. I would have two equalisation curves to choose between. stage of the M-100 is analogue, the signal
preferred a larger, 6.35mm jack, but at least One aims to eliminate room effects for you, path through the amplifier is not analogue,
there is a headphone jack. What’s more, the and also make the frequency response of because all internal processing is done in the
headphone circuitry has been implemented your speakers as flat as possible, while the digital domain: any signal you apply to any
very cleverly, so that no matter what level other just aims to eliminate room effects, of the analogue inputs (XLR, RCA or Phono)
you’re playing your speakers, if you plug in and leaves the frequency response of your will be converted to 24-bit/96kHz PCM at the
your headphones, the volume will instantly speakers pretty-much as the designer of those input and only converted back to analogue
revert to the one you last used when using speakers intended. just prior to the final amplifier stage.
your headphones, and the speakers them- If you order the M.A.R.S. option, you’ll As for the output of that analogue output
selves will be automatically muted. It’s no not only get the essential USB key that stage, Micromega rates the output power of
ordinary headphone jack, either. In addition activates the M.A.R.S. circuitry, but also a the M-100 at 100-watts per channel both
to using it conventionally, you can also mini-tripod, a threaded microphone holder, channels driven into 8Ω loads and 200-watts
switch between in three levels of binaural a long high-quality cable and a Dayton per channel both channels driven into 4Ω
processing. If I can jump ahead of myself, I Audio EMM-6 precision electret condenser loads. The heat from the Thermaltrak output
was impressed by the binaural headphone measurement microphone. (Hence the reason transistors is dissipated by a tunnel and fan
circuitry inside the M-100. It slightly softened for the provision of a microphone input system that does not operate all the time, but
the edges of the sound, and brought wide- above the ground terminal on the rear panel is whisper-quiet when it is operating.
ly-panned elements into the central stage of the M-100, which I didn’t mention earlier,
area, but was totally immersive… at least it because it wouldn’t have made sense until LISTENING SESSIONS
was in the ‘light’ and ‘strong’ settings: The you’d learned about the M.A.R.S. option. It’s Before you start listening I’d recommend you
‘medium’ setting was less so. this that you plug the EMM-6 into, so the download Micomega’s control App. When I
All the connections are made at the rear of M-100 can then use it to measure your room. loaded it onto my phone it found the M-100
the amplifier, and the rear panel is recessed, My review sample didn’t come with the immediately and offered easier access to var-
so that the top and sides of the aluminium M.A.R.S. option fitted, but if you do order it, ious settings and adjustments you can make
extrusion extend beyond it by 60mm. This it will cost you an additional $1,490 if you or- to the circuitry than I thought was possible
makes it more difficult to access all the der it pre-installed, and an additional $1,990 using the front panel controls, plus it allows
connectors on the rear panel, but it makes if you decide to add it afterwards. easy renaming of the inputs, rather than
it possible to hide all the cables from sight if The two sockets which look like they’re simply selecting from a preset list. For music
you’re wall-mounting the amplifier, or even if HDMI sockets are reserved for future use with operations it accesses internet radio, includes
you’re sitting it flat. I2S data streams (as are already used inter- a good search option and accesses podcasts as
On the recessed rear panel you’ll find an nally prior to the DAC), and as a final digital well as live stations, and you can go to ‘Audio
unbalanced line input (via RCA terminals) bonus the M-100 offers Bluetooth streaming, Server’ to play from UPnP and DLNA shares
and a balanced line input (via XLR termi- with the aptX codec available for so-called on your network.
nals). There’s also a phono input whose gain ‘near-CD’ quality lossy compression if your If you’d rather not use your phone to
is switchable for use with either moving-mag- sending device also supports aptX. control the system you can instead use the
net or moving-coil cartridges. So that’s three Also on the rear panel are balanced XLR remote control Micromega supplies with the
‘analogue’ (more about this later) inputs in pre-outputs, a subwoofer output, a pair of M-100. Micromega was also thinking outside
total. Then there are the digital inputs: one control triggers and a giant set of speaker the square when it designed this remote,
coaxial (RCA), one optical (Toslink), one AES/ terminals. I say ‘giant’ because they’re larger because it’s nothing like you’d expect a
EBU (via XLR) and one USB (B-type). There’s than what I normally see—great huge blocks remote to be, not least because its size, shape
also an Ethernet port. (If you load the free of gold-plated metal that can accommodate and the location of the buttons on it make
Micromega app onto your smart phone—iOS bare cable, banana plugs or spade connectors. it very difficult (I won’t say impossible, but I
or Android—you’ll be able to play internet was tempted) to use the remote with just one
radio and networked files via UPnP/DLNA.) INTERNAL CIRCUITRY hand—you have to hold onto it like you’re
The coaxial and AES/EBU digital inputs The M-100 is so narrow that I suspected the controlling a drone.
will do any sampling rate or bit configura- company might be using Class-D circuitry, My listening sessions started out with my
tion up to 32-bit/768kHz and the M-100 can but I was wrong. In fact, from the vehement favourite black vinyl spinners, and although
handle PCM DSD and DSD over PCM (up to anti-Class-D diatribe contained in the White I was acutely conscious of the fact that al-
11.2MHz DSD); the optical input is capable Paper that’s downloadable from Micromega’s though I was playing vinyl, the music was be-
of up to 24-bit/192kHz. There are two USB-A website, I don’t imagine the company will be ing ‘digitised’ on-the-fly, what I was hearing
slots on the rear panel. One is to allow firm- building an amplifier with a Class-D output through my loudspeakers was all analogue…
ware updates, plus can also be used to replay stage anytime soon! and very beautiful-sounding analogue into
music stored on a stick or a drive (though However, the power supply for the M-100 the bargain. Playing my QRP re-mastered ver-
a firmware update is required). The second is not a conventional linear type, but a sion of ‘Tea for the Tillerman’ (no, I haven’t
USB-A slot is so you can plug in a USB ‘don- switch-mode power supply (SMPS) of a type yet forgiven Yusuf Islam, but I’ve mellowed
gle’ associated with the ‘M.A.R.S.’ circuitry. Micromega calls a ‘resonance power supply’ enough to play and perform his music after
M.A.R.S. stands for Micromega Acoustic or ‘LLC’ that has a switching frequency of a two-decade hiatus), the very first moments
Room System and it’s an equaliser that’s between 90kHz and 120kHz which puts the of Where do the Children Play were enough to
designed to compensate for acoustic deficien- rectified components up at around 200kHz convince me of the sonic transparency of the
cies in your room and in your loudspeakers. and higher. M-100’s digital and analogue circuitry.
Australian Hi-Fi 41
ON TEST LAB REPORT
It wasn’t just the richness and depth of The M-100 delivered consistently silent challenge and delivered nearly 300-watts
the bass, but the incredible level of detail— backgrounds, extraordinary dynamics and per channel, both channels driven, right
such as hearing the sound of the pick hitting excelled at maintaining ruthlessly accurate across the audio band.
the strings just before I heard the note of tonality irrespective of music genre. The frequency response of the Mi-
the string itself, not to mention the lovely cromega M-100 is graphed in Graph 4
high-frequency response: sweet, airy, extend- CONCLUSION and tabulated in the accompanying Test
ed… and more gorgeous than I’ve ever heard As ‘all in one’ components become increas- Result table. Across the audio band (Graph
it sound on CD. After seriously surprising ingly common, manufacturers are pulling 4) you can see the M-100’s frequency
myself that I was so happy with the M-100’s out all the stops to make sure their products response was ruler flat from 20Hz up to
performance with black vinyl, I then slowly stand out. Micromega has pulled out so many 2kHz. Below 20Hz it rolled off to be only
worked through listening to all its digital stops building the M-100 that you have to 0.2dB down at 5Hz (and 1dB down at
inputs, a process which necessarily including peer upwards to see it (literally, if you wall- 2Hz, though this frequency was below the
evaluating everything from various streaming mount it). Brilliantly designed, lovely-sound- graphing limit) and above 2kHz it rolled
services right up to the latest high-res formats, ing, able to be optioned-up and/or upgraded off to be 0.5dB down at 20kHz and then
and found that the longer I listened to the and, thanks to the MCF customisation on 1dB down at 34kHz. The –3dB response
M-100, and the more inputs I evaluated, the offer, it can be as beautiful as your heart’s extended from below 1Hz to 45kHz.
more impressed I became by its performance: desire. Magnifique! Jules Larkin Above 45kHz, the response essentially dis-
This is one seriously cool component! (Well appears, because the sampling frequency
Readers should note that the results mentioned
not totally cool, the case could become warm of the internal ADC is 96kHz, meaning
in the report, tabulated in performance charts and
despite the fan… which I could hear up close response has to be completely rolled off
displayed using graphs or photographs should be
when no music was playing, but not from my by 48kHz in order to avoid aliasing.
construed as applying only to the sample tested.
listening position, and never when the music Channel separation was excellent at
was playing.) And speaking of streaming, CONTACT DETAILS
that process seemed to continue even when I
Brand: Micromega
switched to listen to a different input, so make
Model: M-100
sure you stop it when you’re not listening if
RRP: $6,490
you don’t want to consume bandwidth.
Listening to Takatukas’ ‘Red Blood’, Warranty: One Year
which seemed appropriate given the M-100’s Distributor: Absolute Hi End
heritage, the M-100 delivered the wild roll- Address: PO Box 370
er-coaster-ride of sound for which the band Ormond VIC 3204
is famous, from the trademark machine-gun T: (04) 8877 7999
drumming of Bruno Mellier to the screaming, E: info@ absolutehiend.com
almost ear-piercing lead guitar shredding W: www. absolutehiend.com
of Gerald Ozga. It kicks in from the opener
Paranoiaque/hypochondriaque and keeps the
excitement through all 15 tracks to Ras Kouy- Ɗ Feature-packed
on. The slam and tone of Nicolas Vitry’s bass Ɗ Does everything
is a constant delight as well. Ɗ Amazing sound
I was able to confirm that the M-100’s
Ɗ No analog signal path
performance was totally consistent across all
Ɗ Display switching
the inputs using my library of cuts that are
Ɗ Remote control
identical except for format, many of which
are sourced from Soundkeeper Recordings.
REPORT
dropped just under specification when the
test frequency was 20Hz, where it delivered
186-watts per channel, since this is just 0.3dB
lower than specification, it’s inconsequential.
Newport Test Labs measured the power output The M-100 delivered the same power output
of the Micromega M-100 as 108-watts per irrespective of whether a single channel was
channel, both channels driven, at 1kHz and driven, or both channels, made possible in
all frequencies up to 20kHz (the highest part because the amplifier uses dual power
frequency measured in this test), and as 102 supplies, so one can’t deplete the other.
watts per channel both channels at 20Hz. All Good design. Newport Test Labs also tested
measurements are a little higher than Micro- the M-100 into 2Ω loads, for which it’s not
mega’s spec of 100-watts per channel into actually rated, but the Micromega rose to the
˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
M i c ro m e g a M -1 0 0 I n t e g r a t e d A m p l i f i e r/ DAC / S t re a m e r
dBFS dBFS
0 00 0.00
.EWPORT 4EST
. 4 ,ABS .EWPORT 4EST ,ABS
. B
-20 00 -20.00
40 00 40.00
0 50
floor across the audio band has dropped even
60.00
0 00 lower, down close to –140dB. There is some
-80.00 0.50 low-frequency noise (the spike at the extreme
-1.00
100.00
left of the graph) but it’s more than 80dB
-1.50
down. The slight anomalies in the noise floor
-2.00
-120.00
-2.50
are likely sampling-related.
-140.00
0Hz 10000.00 20000.00 30000.00 40000.00 50k
-3.00
10 00 Hz 100.00 1000.00 10000.00 40k
Intermodulation distortion (CCIF), as
measured by Newport Test Labs, is shown in
Graph 3. Intermodulation distortion (CCIF-IMD) us- Graph 4. Frequency response of line input at an
ing test signals at 19kHz and 20kHz, at an output of output of 1-watt into an 8-ohm non-inductive Graph 3, and shows the two test signals (at
1-watt into an 8-ohm non-inductive load, referenced load (black trace) and into a combination resistive/ 19kHz and 20kHz) just left of centre. The
to 0dB. inductive/capacitive load representative of a typical two sidebands at 18kHz and 21kHz are both
two-way loudspeaker system (red trace).
around 110dB down (0.0003% THD), and
the unwanted regenerated difference signal
low and midrange frequencies, as you can see –98dB (0.0012% THD), a fourth harmonic at at 1kHz is 100dB down (0.001% THD). The
from the tabulated results, but only 74dB at –110dB (0.0003% THD) and a fifth harmonic signals up around 40kHz are likely to be a
20kHz, rather less than I am used to seeing at –113dB (0.0002% THD). Note that in this mixture of sampling artefacts and second
from an integrated amplifier, but more than case (and with all the other measurements harmonic distortion components, but are so
will be necessary to ensure perfect stereo im- Newport Test Labs made on the M-100), the high in frequency and so low in level that
aging and channel separation. Channel phase results include not only the non-linearities they can be discounted.
errors were virtually non-existent, and even of the analogue output stage, but also of the Newport Test Labs measured the signal-
the largest of them (1.05° at 20kHz) would be analogue-to-digital and digital-to-analogue to-noise ratio of the Micromega M-100 as
completely inaudible. Channel balance was converter stages. Performance into a 4Ω 81dB A-weighted referred to 1-watt and 97dB
an excellent 0.035dB. load (not shown) was similar but with slight A-weighted referred to rated output. These are
Distortion at an output of one watt into increases in the levels of the 2nd and 4th har- very good figures, that would have been even
8Ω (Graph 1) was very low, as you can see, monics, but only to –95dB (0.0017% THD) better if the lab had used a 20kHz low-pass
with a second harmonic component at and –105dB (0.0005% THD) respectively, so filter, as the M-100 exhibited some ultrason-
ic noise that dragged down the measured
figures somewhat, but is so high that it would
ÀǔƋʁɁȧƬǷŘÀȊɍ̋̋ȭǜƬǷʁŘǜƬƞ ÄȧɡǚǔǞƬʁ ǂ ³ŘŽɁʁŘǜɁʁ˿ ďƬʊǜ õƬʊˁǚǜʊ be completely inaudible to the human ear.
The square wave performance of the Mi-
Test Measured Result Units/Comment
cromega M-100 is shown for three frequen-
Frequency Response @ 1 watt o/p 2Hz – 34kHz –1dB
cies and are ‘non-typical’ of an amplifier
Frequency Response @ 1 watt o/p <1Hz – 45kHz –3dB because they show artefacts (ringing) caused
Channel Separation (dB) 108dB / 101dB / 74dB (20Hz / 1kHz / 20kHz) by the internal A-D and D-A converters. The
10kHz wave is severely compromised because
Channel Balance 0.035 dB @ 1kHz
the essential internal filtering eliminates the
Interchannel Phase 0.02 / 0.05 / 1.05 degrees ( 20Hz / 1kHz / 20kHz)
higher-order harmonics necessary to create
THD+N 0.01% / 0.0002% @ 1-watt / @ rated output a high-frequency square wave, because only
Signal-to-Noise (unwghted/wghted) 77dB / 81dB dB referred to 1-watt output four components 10kHz, 20kHz, 30kHz and
Signal-to-Noise (unwghted/wghted) 94dB / 97dB dB referred to rated output
40kHz are available, hence the almost-sinus
shape of the waveform.
Input Sensitivity 136mV / 1.36V (1-watt / rated output)
Considering that the measured perfor-
Output Impedance ̋Ɩ̋ʹ˫ at 1kHz mance of the M-100 takes into account A-D
Damping Factor 400 @1kHz and D-A conversion as well as amplification
Power Consumption 2.58 / 44.71 watts (Standby / On) to 100-watts (8Ω) and 200-watts (4Ω) per
channel, my conclusion is that the M-100 de-
Power Consumption 62.83 / 337 watts at 1-watt / at rated output
livered an outstanding level of performance
Mains Voltage Variation during Test 235 – 253 Minimum – Maximum Steve Holding
on the test bench.
Australian Hi-Fi 43
ON TEST
NAGRA
CDP
CD PLAYER
N
agra’s CDP player is You can close the drawer by simply push- adoption of pilot lights to indicate control
like no other CD play- ing it in… though I recommend you don’t status. The person operating equipment using
er you have seen be- do this. Far better to close it using the tiny this system only had to glance at, say, an
fore, because the front spring-loaded Open/Close toggle switch that instrument panel, to see which controls were
panel display is built pokes through a slot cut in the front panel. ‘On’ and which were ‘Off’ by whether or not
into the CD drawer, The toggle switch you can see on the front a red painted bar was visible.
the front of which panel just to the right of the disc drawer Of course you don’t have to use the Na-
does not close flush with the front panel, as alters the brightness of the display (through gra’s front panel controls at all if you’d rather
with most drawer-style CD mechanisms, but six levels). Again, this is a spring-loaded, not. The CDP (along with all other variants
sits proud of it. It’s also small… so small that momentary-contact switch that protrudes of Nagra’s player, about which more later)
the face of the remote control is almost larger through a slot cut into the front panel. The comes standard with a Nagra RCU-II infra-red
than the front of the CDP. third toggle switch you can see on the front remote.
Open the drawer and you’ll see that it is panel is used to fast-forward and fast-rewind
not some piece of extruded plastic plucked through individual tracks, plus it also doubles
from the shelf of an OEM manufacturer, or as a track skip (forward/reverse) control.
even a piece of stamped metal. It’s a solid slab The rotary control at the right of the front
of aluminium alloy, through which protrudes panel controls the Nagra CDP’s other trans-
the CD drive and laser assembly (a Philips port functions. It’s a bar of aluminium that
CD-Pro2M). This thing is solid, with a capital sits in a 6mm-deep recess in the front panel.
This thing is
solid, with a
‘S’—and very obviously assembled by hand. In its horizontal (Off) position, it obscures
Once you drop a CD over the drive, you a horizontal red bar underneath it that be-
then have to hold it in place by attaching a
magnetic clamp. If you don’t do this, the Na-
comes visible when you rotate the bar clock-
wise, first to ‘Stop’, then to ‘Pause’ and finally
capital ‘S’—and
gra CDP will refuse to play… but it will give to ‘Play’ (at which point the bar is vertical). very obviously
you a warning as to why it’s not co-operating
by showing the words ‘No Clamper’ in the
The reason for the red bar is to show that the
Nagra is ‘On’. It’s a technique that was used
assembled by
front panel display. in the early day of electronics, pre-dating the hand...
44 Australian Hi-Fi ˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
Nagra CDP CD Player
This is a multi-function device that will also You could also power it with a Nagra MPS obviously, once it’s done its job of opening
control other compatible Nagra components. Power supply, which retails for $9,295, and the drawer or closing it, it’s then as silent as
In addition to allowing you to control the can supply 12V d.c. power for up to four space itself!
basic transport functions of the CDP it ena- Nagra components (but only three if one of As noted at the beginning of this review, a
bles you to access more advanced playback them is the HD DAC, which requires two sep- magnetic clamp must be attached manually
functions, including programmed play, arate power supplies to itself). One advantage every time you load a CD. Nagra says that
repeat track, repeat disc, A–B repeat, shuffle of using this unit is that it can be fitted with this clamp improves the centring and posi-
play and track scan. It’s a very large remote an optional Li-Ion battery, enabling total tioning of the CD on the transport, which is
(51mm wide, 25mm deep and 222mm long) isolation from the 240V mains. The battery certainly true. However its primary function
and a very heavy one too (it weighs 310g). can power the CDP for up to 11 hours. Local is to stop the CD from launching itself into
I particularly liked that I could stand it on distributor Advance Audio supplied the Nagra the air when the transport spins it up to
its end, which makes it easy to store, easy to MPS Power supply for this review, but with- playing speed (which varies between 200
pick up, and overall means you’re less likely out the battery fitted, so mains power was rpm at the beginning of disc and 500 rpm
to accidentally misplace it. used for all the listening sessions and for the towards the end). The only issue about drives
The chassis of the Nagra CDP is not testing by Newport Test Labs. that use a clamping system is that you have
moulded or pressed in any way, it’s entirely to remember to remove both disc and clamp
constructed from thick flat sheets of alumin- IN USE AND LISTENING whenever you transport the player from one
ium that are bolted together. It’s a technique SESSIONS location to another. If you don’t, it’s possible
that’s often used to build prototypes, or The very first thing you will notice about the for the clamp to become dislodged and fall
products not many of which will be built, Nagra CDP is that the disc drawer mechanism inside the player, which in the case of the
because it saves tooling costs. It does mean, is noisy when it’s moving inwards and out- Nagra CDP will then require you to remove
however, that appearance of the Nagra CDP wards. Very noisy. This was a surprise in part the six screws securing the top plate and ex-
is like stepping back in time to the 1950s… or because Nagra says the motor is: ‘a state-of- tract it manually before you attempt to apply
even the 1940s. It seems Nagra is celebrating the-art planetary reduction motor: a component power. This is perfectly safe to do yourself,
this by deliberately using knobs, switches and developed by a NASA-approved supplier, whose because there’s no 240V power inside the
controls that are also built in styles that hark products equipped the Mars Rover robot sent to CDP… just 12 volts.
back to these times. the red planet.’ It was only after reading this I did appreciate the fact that Nagra has
If you were thinking that the front panel that I realised that a motor designed for use helpfully included some (red!) illumination
of the Nagra CDP looks a bit bare, it’s because in space doesn’t have to be quiet, because in the drawer when it’s open, which makes
there are three different versions of this you couldn’t hear it in space… there’s no it easy to load and unload CDs in a darkened
player available, and on the ‘CDC’ version atmosphere, so no medium for the transmis- room, but I’d stab a guess that this feature
the blank space is occupied by volume and sion of sound waves. The only requirements was actually requested by Nagra’s own dealers
balance controls and an output level meter… for a motor used in a space program would be and distributors, who often do their demos in
or, as Nagra prefers to call it, a ‘double modu- that it’s accurate and reliable… the manufac- rooms that can be very dark indeed… such as
lometer’. The ‘CDT’ version looks identical to turer really wouldn’t care how noisy it was. the demo rooms at hi-fi shows!
the model reviewed here, but is only a trans- The drawer motor is no doubt accurate (it’s Loading is quite quick, but the time it
port and must be used in conjunction with accurate to within two microns, according takes to load a disc is dependent on the num-
an external digital-to-analogue converter (of to Nagra) and I have no doubt it is also ber of tracks on the CD, varying from around
which Nagra makes two, the ‘Classic’ DAC absolutely and completely reliable… but I six seconds for an 18-track disc to 24 seconds
and the ‘HD’ DAC.) do have to tell you that it’s ‘way noisy… but for a 99-track disc.
The rear panel of the Nagra CDP has both
balanced (via gold-plated XLR) and unbal-
anced (via gold-plated RCA) audio outputs
as well as three digital outputs: SPDIF (via
RCA), Optical (via Toslink), and AES (via
XLR). But what’s most notable is what isn’t
there: a 240V power socket. It doesn’t have a
240V power socket because you need to use
an external power supply to deliver power to
the CDP, via a proprietary three-pin socket
which is what you can see on the rear panel.
It appears that Nagra does not want any
high-voltage circuits anywhere near its digital
circuitry or low-voltage analogue circuits.
As for that external power supply, you
have a range of choices because there are two
different external supplies, plus the CDP can
also get its power from some other Nagra
components, such as the BPS phono pream-
plifier. Included in the price of the CDP is Na-
gra’s ACPS II, a small single-rail stand-alone
power supply that usually retails for $1,695.
Australian Hi-Fi 45
ON TEST LAB REPORT
A state-of-the- LABORATORY
Handel’s ‘Messiah’. Of all the versions I own,
my ‘go-to’ work is Stephen Layton’s wonderful
art CD player, reading for Hyperion… and it’s home-grown
TEST
hand-built in
here in Oz! The delivery of high-frequencies by
the Nagra CDP was outstanding, with beautiful- REPORT
Switzerland, ly intonated upper violin sound on every CD
I auditioned… the authenticity of the sound
that delivers a far cry from the screechy violin delivery of Newport Test Labs measured the output
Australian Hi-Fi 47
Nagra CDP CD Player
Add wireless sine wave signal recorded at 0dB) showed some sampling-related ar-
tefacts, but none fell within the audio band and all were more than
audio files to any accompanied by only two sidebands, both of which are more than
110dB down (0.0003% THD), and although there is an unwanted
difference signal generated (at 1kHz) it’s 108dB down (0.00039%
sound system with THD). The sampling-related artefacts are all higher in frequency than
22.5kHz and all but two are more than 100dB down, and those two
HEOS Link.
are more than 90dB down.
Linearity errors were low, as you can see from the tabulated
results, as were the de-emphasis errors… but at least the Nagra CDP
has a de-emphasis circuit—many manufacturers seem to be omitting
them from their CD players these days (or at least not implementing
the circuit, which is almost always present in the DAC itself) on the
basis that so few people are likely to have CDs that are old enough
to require de-emphasis (that is, discs manufactured and sold prior to
1990).
The square wave and impulse oscillograms show that the Nagra
CDP is using a standard oversampling filter and maintains correct
absolute phase.
Overall, the Nagra CDP CD player returned excellent performance
across all the bench-testing conducted by Newport Test Labs.
Steve Holding
www.heos.com.au
˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
PUT A
LITTLE
FORMULA 1
INTO YOUR
MUSIC
Wilson Benesch
Geometry Series
A.C.T. One Evolution P1
8LI%'841SRSGSUYIPSYHWTIEOIVMWXLIƤVWXIZIV
constructed using coloured carbon material from Hypetex,
developed by Formula 1 Engineers.
AVAILABLE IN
AVAILABLE IN AUSTRALIA THROUGH ABSOLUTE HI END . 0488 777 999 . info@absolutehiend.com . www.absolutehiend.com
SOUNDSITES
Class A Vinyl
HIGH QUALITY VINYL TITLES
Music Library AND RECORD ACCESSORIES
Server & Player
ONLINE AND IN-STORE, EFTPOS AVAILABLE
Helping You “A new experience Tel 03 8555 0735
Connect to Music in Switched On Living” 8/585 Blackburn Road, Notting Hill, VIC 3168
… Seven Days a Week … 1300 761 022 A DIVISION OF CLASS A AUDIO
03 8683 9910 sales@audioconnection.com.au
SYDNEY HI-FI
CASTLE HILL
sales@audiophilereferencerecordings.com.au
0411 261 822 02 9899 9079
2 Florence Street Burwood VIC 3125 castlehill@sydneyhifi.com.au
www.krispyaudio.com.au www.audiophilereferencerecordings.com.au www.castlehillhifi.com.au
REVIEWED
B&W
800 D3
STILL EXPENSIVE, BUT
YOU’VE SAVED MONEY BY
BIDING YOUR TIME!
INTERVIEW
JOHN ONG
SOUND GALLERY
Melbourne’s newest store is about
to celebrate its second anniversary!
INTERVIEW
JOHN ONG
Aushifi: The Rogers speakers seem a strange
choice for a teenager?
John Ong: When I bought my system,
it was the first time I’d ever been into a hi-fi
SOUND GALLERY
store, and I actually went in planning to buy
a pair of JBLs. When I went in there was a
bunch of old guys sitting around listening to
some music.
When I mentioned JBL, they said: ‘You
J
ohn Ong has been an integral part I also had lots of fun, such as arranging the should listen to this system first.’
of the Melbourne audio scene for controls into a smiley face just to hear the They sat me down and started playing the
more than twenty years, where he’s effect on the sound. The classic ‘V’ EQ could system and to my amazement, for the first
worked in audio research and devel- never go wrong… at the time anyway. That’s five minutes there was no singing… just mu-
opment, and audio design and when I learned about frequency range and sic, and to be honest I was wondering if they
manufacturing as well as in the frequency response. were for real. ‘Is no-one ever going to sing?’
retail sector. His most recent project, Sound Aushifi: What type of music were you listen- I thought to myself. But then I was blown
Gallery, is about to celebrate its second ing to back then? away by the emotional impact of the music—
anniversary, so we thought we’d check on its John Ong: Back then it was mostly just it was the first time I’d ever heard Pink Floyd
progress… pop music or whatever that was on the (I’ve been a huge fan ever since)—and it was
Aushifi: When did you first become interest- radio—Duran Duran, Michael Jackson, Def also the first time I realised that there was
ed in hi-fi? Leopard—the usual music you’d find any more to music than just the sound, that it
John Ong: I guess it would have been teenager living in Malaysia listening to. was the emotional experience of music that
when I was 12 years old. I always wondered Aushifi: When did you get your first hi-fi was the most important. As for the speakers,
how things worked… and especially how mu- system? it was quantity versus quality. The JBLs had
sic could be reproduced from a box! I started John Ong: It was when I was at high more bass and played loud but the small
pulling them apart—portable radios, cassette school. I didn’t have any money to get a Rogers moved me emotionally.
players—anything I could get my hands on decent system so I asked my parents if they’d Aushifi: So that store was in Malaysia?
really. I was really good at taking things apart, pay. They said that if I got ten straight As in John Ong: Yes, that is where I was born
but not so good at putting them together… my exams, I could have the system. Unfor- and first studied.
unfortunately! tunately I could only get eight As, but they Aushifi: So after you bought your first hi-fi
Aushifi: Was anyone else in your family were nice enough to still get me a system, so system, what then?
interested in hi-fi? I bought a pair of Rogers speakers, a Creek in- John Ong: I bought all the Pink Floyd I
John Ong: My uncle loved music and had tegrated amplifier and a Denon cassette deck. could of course, plus I discovered Dire Straits,
a really good Sansui system which had an Aushifi: Why a cassette deck rather than a the Eagles, and more. I also started helping
enormous multi-channel graphic equaliser. I CD player? out at the store while I was hanging there,
remember spending hours with that, adjust- John Ong: I was still at high school and which enabled me to upgrade my system,
ing all the controls and trying to work out I knew I couldn’t afford CDs. So I bought learn how to repair hi-fi components, and
exactly which ones I’d have to use to have blank tapes and recorded the music I wanted also build my own equipment including my
the most effect on particular instruments. to listen to instead. own speakers and a valve amplifier.
Australian Hi-Fi 53
INTERVIEW JOHN ONG SOUND GALLERY
that cost $75,000 sitting on the floor. What do course, plus a Facebook page, and I’m on that most are under the misconception that
you tell these customers? Instagram for promoting the business online, they need to use tweaks to improve their
John Ong: The first thing I do is let them but it’s all low-key because Sound Gallery sound… cables and interconnects and so on.
listen to all the systems regardless of price, so is a different concept hi-fi store… it’s not a I tell them that it’s the synergy of the whole
I can show them how good music can really box-mover shop. People who love music will system that’s the most important. If the
sound in a good system and how they all can eventually find me. ‘bones’ of a system are not right, tweaks are
also sound so different with the same music. Aushifi: What days and times are you open? simply a waste of money.
Ears have to be trained… as do all the other John Ong: Basically Sound Gallery is open Aushifi: But you do think cables and inter-
human senses. For example you might say 10.30 a.m. to 6.30 p.m. every day except connects can improve the sound of a system?
you don’t care much about wine, but once Thursdays and Sundays, but we can cater for John Ong: All cables sound different and
you’ve had good wine you can’t go back. anyone at any time by appointment. can improve the sound of a system: That’s
The same with food: Once you’ve had a great Aushifi: They seem like rather strange hours? something I demonstrate to my customers
meal, that becomes your standard. In other John Ong: Most mornings and after all the time. But you need to get the synergy
words, once you’ve experienced something hours I’m at customers’ houses delivering between the various components correct be-
wonderful, you can’t go back. It’s for this and setting up systems. Sound Gallery always fore you start looking at cables and intercon-
reason that my dad always told me that the delivers and installs what we sell—especially nects… or any other type of tweak.
five senses are the biggest evils of all. As I high-end systems—unless the customer pre- Aushifi: How do you think the availability
mentioned before, it’s the experience most of fers otherwise. This service is included in the of audio products via the Internet has affected
us want when pursuing the hi-fi journey. You price. Most people don’t realise that system ‘bricks ‘n mortar’ hi-fi retailers such as Sound
have to experience it to understand or know set-up contributes at least 25 per cent to the Gallery?
the difference. final result. If you buy a good system but John Ong: Buying on-line can be cheaper,
Aushifi: Do you have a typical customer? don’t set it up correctly it can sound terrible. but it’s also risky because you can’t be 100
John Ong: I’d have to say that most of Most dealers in Melbourne will deliver gear, per cent sure of what will be delivered—there
my customers—most of whom I regard as my but they won’t necessarily install it for you are a lot of counterfeits out there. Then you’ll
friends now—are successful family men aged professionally. have to install it yourself, and if anything
30 and up. I even have a few that are pushing Aushifi: So it’s only you at the store? goes wrong you’re usually on your own.
80. But now that you mention it, I realise John Ong: No, my wife works here at the Keeping a shop open is an expensive busi-
that I don’t have any customers who are store as well, plus I have contractors who ness, but if you have any problems, at least
single… all of them have partners. help me with big installs. there’s a physical door that you can kick! I
Aushifi: When you first opened, how did you Aushifi: Do you mostly sell complete audio always stress service, back-up and expertise. I
tell people in Melbourne that Sound Gallery was systems, or individual components? tell people up front that I’m not the cheapest,
open for business? John Ong: It’s really a combination of but they’ll have my service and can call me
John Ong: It was very low-key. I sent out both. Most of my customers have been hi-fi for help at any time.
a press release that was published in Austral- enthusiasts for some time and come to me Aushifi: With vinyl making a comeback,
ian Hi-Fi Magazine and on the aushifi.com because they’re frustrated with the sound what would you recommend for a new custom-
website, but basically it was word-of-mouth they’re getting from their existing system. er who already owns a large collection of LPs
from people I know personally. I didn’t email Many have not heard a different sound and and wants a turntable?
anyone at all. I don’t have a newsletter or are amazed when I demonstrate the different John Ong: It would depend entirely on
email address database. I have a website, of sounds you can achieve. Plus I have to say his system—everything has to match up.
TICKET OFFER!
FANTASTIC 2 FOR 1 /AUS TRALIANHIFIAVSHOW/2018
BUY NOW AT WWW.CHESTERGROUP.ORG
More than 100 top brands · Live musical performances · Great and
convenient location · World class guest speakers · Prizes galore
Older customers usually have older sys- John Ong: In an ideal world I’d like to And when you set it up for them and get it
tems, with good-quality older components. think they’re importing and distributing working, some guy from the NBN comes in
If they already own a good turntable I those brands because they really believe in and changes all the network settings and you
often recommend that they don’t buy a them. I do bring in one brand (Weiss), but have to go back and re-install all over again.
new one at all, but instead get their old only because I know the designer person- Software user interfaces aren’t the friendliest
turntable serviced—new bearing fluid, new ally and admire his philosophies and his either! Lots of improvement is necessary—
belt and so on—their tonearm correctly products. and software has to evolve to become more
aligned, then fit a new stylus,or a new Aushifi: Are looks becoming as important as user-friendly so that hopefully anyone who
cartridge. sound quality when it comes to hi-fi components? can use a smart phone will be able to stream
Aushifi: When you’re at home, do you play John Ong: Visual appearance is very music!
vinyl, CDs, from computer or stream? important in these modern days, especially Aushifi: What do you think differentiates
John Ong: I have two systems —one for when living space is scarce. Gone are the Sound Gallery from other hi-fi retailers in Mel-
music and one for home theatre. days when you could put four Genesis bourne?
On the music system I play vinyl when speaker towers in a room. Customers are John Ong: I think it’s the way I ap-
I have the time and I’m listening serious- still after sound quality, but these days proach customer service. I understand that
ly, but if I’m busy doing something else I they also look at size, colours, and the hi-fi is an emotional purchase, so I always
stream from my own collection. type of finish. At the end of the day, they listen to customers patiently in order to tru-
Aushifi: What would be your desert island have a family and everyone in the family ly understand what they need, so I can sug-
music choice if you could take only three al- has to live with the system. It does help if gest to them how to achieve what they’re
bums… in any format of your choosing? the system looks good. Sometimes there’s after and am also able to demonstrate it.
John Ong: Pink Floyd’s Division Bell, compromise involved, but in the end if I am still an audiophile at heart… I am
Keith Jarrett’s Koln Concert, and anything you can’t live with it, you shouldn’t buy it. just trying to combine my passion with
Teresa Teng ever sang! Music was once a selfish hobby, but now my profession.
Aushifi: What digital format do you usually the whole family has to be involved and
recommend for your customers? enjoy it. They have to like what it looks
John Ong: My view is that a good record- like, and be able to use it. I think that’s why SOUND GALLERY
ing will always sound good, no matter what single component all-in-one units that do 224 McKinnon Road, McKinnon, VIC 3204
format you’re using, and a bad recording everything are becoming more popular, T: (03) 9578 8658
will always sound bad. Customers often ask components such as the Bel Canto ACI 600, M: 0403 368 755
which hi-res format I’m playing when I play which is a DAC, and a streamer, and an E-mail: info@soundgallery.com.au
ECM recordings of Keith Jarrett that were integrated amplifier… just add speakers. URL: www.soundgallery.com.au
recorded back in the 70s and they’re amazed Aushifi: Is there any one area of modern hi-fi www.facebook.com/soundgalleryaustralia
when I tell them it’s standard 16-bit 44.1kHz. systems that causes the most problems? www.instagram.com/sound.gallery.australia
Aushifi: Many hi-fi stores now also import John Ong: The biggest problem area Opening Hours:
and distribute products. Do you think retailers is streaming. Few people understand how 10.30 a.m. – 6.30 p.m. (Mon, Tue, Wed, Fri, Sat)
who are also importers can offer consumers their home network works, or how to stream (Thursday and Sunday by appointment only)
unbiased advice? music via iPad or smartphone or computer.
W E W E LCO M E YO U TO T H E I M P O SS I B L E M A D E P O SS I B L E .
T H E M O ST A F FO R DA B L E M AG I CO E V E R – A 3
Machined into the metal of every Magico loudspeaker is a subtle, yet and despite constant experimentation and testing of various methods for
permanent, “M” – a symbol, which reminds every owner of a Magico reducing costs to achieve this goal, up until now the results have always fallen
product that they have invested in a product of uncompromised, build and short of earning the Magico M engraving. Not anymore.
performance excellence. Introducing the most affordable Magico ever- appealing to a wider
The standards we set for bearing our M logo are not without consequence. audience the A3 brings together a bevy of technologies unheard-of at its price
The push forward into the development of new, exotic, costly technologies and point. A fully braced and anodized aluminum enclosure, beryllium tweeter,
materials has meant that these products are accessible only to a fortunate few. carbon Nanographene cones, neodymium based motor systems and our
And though we have long pursued the delivery of a more affordable product renowned elliptical crossover, the A3 is the impossible made possible.
AVAILABLE IN AUSTRALIA THROUGH ABSOLUTE HI END 0488 777 999 . info@absolutehiend.com . www.absolutehiend.com
ON TEST
B&W 800 D3
tube in which the tweeter is housed (about
which more in a moment) is made from
aluminium alloy, so the whole surface acts as
a heatsink as well as an ‘enclosure’.
LOUDSPEAKERS
Given all the foregoing drawbacks, one
might be forgiven for asking why B&W uses
diamond domes at all. The reason is that
diamond has a hardness factor of 10 on the
Mohs scale, which means that whereas most
other tweeters enter their ‘break-up’ mode
T
he 800 D3 represents a Another cost of using a dome made from well below 50kHz (and some do so below
landmark in the company’s diamond is that—rather counter-intuitively, 20kHz, so within the audio band itself!)
history, because it was spe- diamond being the hardest mineral known B&W’s diamond tweeter does not enter its
cifically created to celebrate to mankind—the diamond dome is actually ‘break-up’ mode until a frequency of nearly
B&W’s 50th anniversary. quite fragile, so to prevent it being acciden- 70kHz. The result is that the dome is com-
As such, I expected to find tally damaged, B&W protects it with a grille pletely rigid, exhibiting perfect piston-like
some gold used in the 800 mesh that very slightly affects its frequency behaviour not only within the audio band,
D3, this being the precious metal most-often response and reduces its efficiency. B&W is but also for at least an octave above it, and
used to celebrate 50th anniversaries in most continually improving this grille to make it delivers superior sound quality as a direct re-
countries around the world. B&W has instead ever-more acoustically transparent, in order sult. (By way of comparison, aluminium rates
used diamond, a material more commonly that it has less effect on the sound waves that only a ‘3’ on the Mohs scale, and beryllium
reserved for 60th anniversaries. To be more must pass through it. The latest incarnation scores only a ‘5.5’.)
specific, the dome of the 800 D3’s tweeter is of the grille has a mesh grid that looks a little There is one other problem with using
made of diamond, which you’d have to agree like one of Buckminster Fuller’s geodesic a hard dome in a tweeter, and that is the
is quite a step up in materials science from the domes, with myriad interlinked triangles. problem of getting rid of pressure waves from
cloth and base metal domes that are usually The dome is removable, but has a childproof the back of the dome. Whereas the pressure
used to build tweeters… and by ‘base’ metals, locking system, so a special tool is required to waves at the front of the dome that are
I mean aluminium, titanium and beryllium. remove it. caused by the dome’s forward and backwards
Using a dome made from diamond is not A further ‘cost’ of using diamond as a movement are what we perceive as sound,
without its costs, and the first cost is simply dome material is that it’s heavier than fabric the corresponding waves issuing from the
that: they’re expensive! They’re so expensive or metal, which means it’s more difficult to back of the dome interfere with sound qual-
that even B&W can’t afford to damage one. drive, and somewhat less efficient as a result. ity. Some manufacturers don’t address this
In fact, to minimise the possibility of damage, B&W gets around this issue by using four issue at all, while some others use a damper
they are not even installed in the cabinet until magnets, rather than just one, to drive the or disperser immediately behind the dome.
the absolute last minute… just prior to each dome. B&W claims an increase in efficiency B&W uses a rather elegant acoustic construc-
speaker being individually measured before of around 2dB. To keep these four magnets tion that extracts unwanted energy from the
being placed in its shipping carton. cool—so they maintain their efficiency—the rear of the diaphragm by moving it away to
be dissipated inaudibly as it moves down the
tube, with the different frequencies being
absorbed at different distances down the tube
(which requires a fairly long tube). This tech-
B&W uses a rather elegant acoustic
construction to extract unwanted energy
nique is what B&W refers to as its ‘Nautilus’
from the rear of the diaphragm by technology. As you can see from the 800 D3,
moving it away to be dissipated inaudibly. the tweeter is mounted in its own ‘Nautilus’
enclosure at the top of the cabinet. This
enclosure is vibrationally isolated from the
‘head’ that contains the midrange driver, and
this ‘head’ is in turn isolated from the main
cabinet that contains the two bass drivers,
so that cabinet vibration cannot adversely
affect the motion of the midrange or tweeter
diaphragms.
As mentioned in the previous paragraph,
the midrange driver of the B&W 800 D3
is contained in its own sub-enclosure, and
this also has a Nautilus tube to absorb the
unwanted pressure wave from the rear of
the midrange cone. This cone, which is
150mm in diameter, is unlike almost all other
midrange cones ever made in that it does not
have a roll surround around its periphery to
assist with cone movement. Instead it uses
a ‘suspension’ system B&W has been using
for some years now, which it calls a ‘fixed
˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
B&W 800 D3 LOUDSPEAKERS ON TEST
Australian Hi-Fi 59
ON TEST
B&W provides short wire links to connect the If you find you do prefer the sound when What grabbed my attention the instant
two sections for those using only a single set the speakers are on spikes (note that your the music started was that I was suddenly no
of speaker cables. The ‘heads’ of the screw-on ability to hear a difference might depend on longer in my own listening room, but in a
connectors are rounded, which makes them the floor surface on which the speakers are concert hall. It was as if the acoustic char-
difficult to tighten, something I found even standing), you will appreciate B&W’s spike acteristics of my room had changed, so that
more difficult because they didn’t seem to design too, because after you’ve wheeled my overwhelming impression was of having
twist smoothly down the post threads, so the speakers into the position where they a sense of their being a huge space. Just as in
B&W should talk to its supplier about improv- sound the best, all you need to do to raise a concert hall, even before the music starts,
ing its machining standards. them on their spikes is reach underneath you can ‘hear’ the size of the hall you’re in,
As for their size, I assume that you’ve and spin three sprockets that in turn force with the B&W 800 D3s, I was hearing that
already assumed that the 800 D3 the spikes down onto the floor, size… the music was no longer constrained
cabinets are big, and you’d be simultaneously raising the to the physical dimensions of my listening
right, with each one meas- castors so they don’t touch room. This is the first time I’ve experienced
uring 1217×413×611mm the floor. And if you this sense of space so acutely. Then there was
(HWD). don’t want the spikes the glorious sound of Jane Peters’ violin (I was
If you were wonder- to damage your floor, playing Tchaikovsky’s Violin Concerto Op 35)
ing what that asterisk you can place ‘spike beautifully contrasted against the orchestra.
on the B&W 800 D3 cups’ underneath No shrillness here, just crystal clarity to her
price is for, along each spike. You don’t violin’s tone and its extraordinarily resonant
with the reference un- have to buy these sound, even when fully stopped. I was also
derneath, ‘*Includes from a furniture shop immediately aware that I was not hearing
life-time of free hi-res either: B&W supplies the left and right speakers at all. Right from
downloads from B&W’ them with each pair of the outset I found myself totally immersed in
it means that if you buy a speakers, in fact they’re the musical experience. With speakers I have
pair of B&W 800 D3s you au- not only supplied—B&W has auditioned previously, it has taken me a little
tomatically qualify for a life-time cleverly integrated these spike listening time to make this transition. Even
membership to B&W’s ‘Society of Sound’ cups into the cabinet design so they’re with the very best speakers, it’s always taken
which means you can download hi-res albums stored underneath the cabinet whenever a few minutes… and with some speakers, it’s
and tracks from B&W’s website for free and you’re not using them, making them impos- never happened. With the B&W 800 D3s,
‘forever’. The only trick to this is that every sible to accidentally misplace. there was no transition time at all: the effect
time B&W loads a new album to its download When I first fired up the B&W 800 D3s I was immediate.
site, it also removes one, which is presumably was already anticipating that the gloriously Switching to a piano concerto (Grieg’s A
part of its licensing agreement. So to get max- spine-tingling high-frequency sound of the Minor, Op 16) I was taken aback by the sheer
imum benefit from membership, you need to diamond tweeter would grab my attention, impact of the kettledrum introduction to the
download at least two albums every month, as it always has when I’ve auditioned B&W first movement (allegro molto moderato), which is
which could be annoying to keep remember- models using it on previous occasions. So I punctuated by a full orchestral climax, and then
ing to do, but is certainly a clever ploy to keep was shocked to find that with the B&W 800 even more taken aback by Simon Tedeschi’s
you involved with the B&W brand! D3s this was most definitely not the case. take on what is possibly the most famous piano
flourish in classical music, particularly when he
LISTENING SESSIONS attacks the bottom-most notes on the keyboard.
Unlike many curved cabinets, the 800 D3 is a stressed
First-off, I have to say that in a review of design, so B&W has to use an alloy beam at the rear The sound from the B&W 800 D3s was effort-
B&W’s slightly smaller 802 D3s that I wrote to contain the stresses. less—despite the fact that I was playing the
fairly quickly as a direct result of first hearing work at concert-hall volume levels.
them, I was so smitten by their sound quality
and their overall performance that I failed to
emphasise one aspect of their design that I
absolutely loved and also found immensely
practical in day-to-day use. Since that same
design feature is also found on the 800 D3s, I
will use this review to redeem myself. The de-
sign feature to which I refer is simply the fact
that these B&W speakers are fitted with wheels
(or, if you prefer a more scientifically accurate
term, ‘castors’), so they can be moved really
easily. They’re also so heavy (96kg per cabinet)
that I could hear no difference in sound
quality between listening to them whilst on
their castors and when listening when they
were spiked. The castors make it really—and I
mean really!—easy to position the speakers out
of the way whenever you’re not listening to
them, and wheel them out into the optimum
position when you are.
Australian Hi-Fi 61
ON TEST B&W 800 D3 LOUDSPEAKERS
The piano sounded ‘just right’ with its tone a single full-range driver—it’s impossible to de- Regrettably, an increasing number of
totally accurate across all the octaves. The tect the point at which the sound transitions manufacturers are rather crudely just attach-
orchestra’s sound was also completely full from the midrange driver to the tweeter. ing unjustifiably high price tags to inferior
and powerful. Stevie Wonder’s Superstition has always products in an attempt to fool consumers
Imaging from the B&W 800 D3s was per- been a favourite of mine, and through the into thinking that because their products are
fect: the best stereo imaging I’ve ever heard. 800 D3s, that spare kick drum/cymbal intro expensive, they must somehow be ‘better’
Listening to the ethereal soprano voice of got my blood pumping even before that great simply because they cost more.
Sara Macliver as she sang the Pie Jesu from syncopated keyboard riff stabs in. The B&Ws B&W has employed an entirely differ-
Faure’s Requiem was like being transported to reproduced the biting, cutting, sound of the ent selling strategy with the 800 D3. It has
a higher plane. I’d like to say it was as if she guitar brilliantly, and when Stevie chimes in created a loudspeaker whose sound speaks
and Sinfonia Australis were playing in my with ‘very superstitious, writing’s on the wall’ it for itself. Audition a pair and they’ll speak to
living room (they’d just fit), but no, I once was as if he were there in the listening room. you. They’ll say: ‘We’re the best speakers you’ve
again had been transported to the concert But as if to prove that good speakers will al- ever heard!’
hall, with all the musicians perfectly posi- ways reveal a bad mix, You Are The Sunshine of And in another bonus for Australian buy-
tioned and Macliver’s perfectly-pitched voice My Life was delivered too accurately (if there’s ers, the fact that B&W recently set up its own
centre-stage, but with the harmonics seeming even such a thing) as they made very obvious wholly-owned subsidiary in Australia means
to float through the hall. Her voice also re- the weird phasing effects that go on for about that it now doesn’t have to pay another
vealed that the transition of sound from the the first twenty bars. One dares to say that if company to distribute its products, which has
midrange driver to the diamond tweeter is this track had been monitored using 800 D3s in turn resulted in price reductions across the
seamless: it’s as if all the sound is issuing from it might have ended up sounding completely entire range, and most particularly in the re-
different! tail price of the 800 D3s, which has dropped
As I noted when I reviewed the B&W 802 significantly.
D3s, the 800 D3s’ dispersion is unbelievably The B&W 800 D3s are still expensive,
good, thanks to the almost flat-faced FST of course, but at least—like that classic
driver and that it’s essentially baffle-less, so television advertisement—you’ll be able to
there are none of the response aberrations, tell your significant other how much you’ve
reflections and timing errors that occur when saved by waiting. greg borrowman
a midrange driver is mounted on a baffle. The
result is a sound-field that was suspended in
Readers interested in a full technical appraisal of
my listening room so three-dimensionally that the performance of the B&W 800 D3 Loudspeak-
the sonic ‘sweet spot’ was almost everywhere. ers should continue on and read the laboratory
One big difference between the 802 D3 and report published on the following pages. Readers
should note that the results mentioned in the
the 800 D3 that I noted straight away was the
report, tabulated in performance charts and/
improvement in the deep bass. I thought the or displayed using graphs and/or photographs
802’s bass was fabulous, but the 800 D3’s bass should be construed as applying only to the
ʊɡƬƋǔǞƋʊŘȧɡǚƬǜƬʊǜƬƞƖ
is better again, not just for the way it extends
lower-down into the low frequencies, but
also for the way seems to have a better ‘grip’,
so that I ‘felt’ the bass as a physical presence
B&W 800 D3
Loudspeakers
in the room to a greater extent… as well as
hearing it. It would thus appear that their bass LABORATORY
power and extension are amongst the reasons
TEST
REPORT
Brand: Bowers & Wilkins the 800 D3 is able to deliver that sense of
acoustic space I noted as my ‘first impression’
Model: 800 D3
when listening.
RRP: $41,900*
But that sense of acoustic space is also
Warranty: Five Years
helped by the 800 D3’s treble response, which Newport Test Labs measured the fre-
Distributor: Bowers & Wilkins Australia
is as clear and pure as I recalled from the 802 quency response of the B&W 800 D3 as
AddressƕăˁǔǜƬʯ̋ʯƙʕǣǮñŘƋǔǞƋǔǷǒ˹Ř˿ D3: very smooth and mannered, such that extending from 28Hz to 28kHz ±3dB,
,ǒŘǜʊ˹ɁɁƞÂăĶʹ̋ȴʕ there’s none of the ‘tizz’ in the extreme highs which is an outstanding result and
T: (02) 9196 8990 that is the signature of most hard-domed very close to B&W’s spec of 15Hz to
W: www.bowerswilkins.com tweeters, yet without missing out on any high- 28kHz ±3dB. This response is shown in
ŹȭƋǚˁƞƬʊǚǔnjƬȊǜǔȧƬɁnjnjʁƬƬǒǔȊʁƬʊ end musical detail, or on any ‘air’ around that Graph 1, where the trace below 1kHz is
ƞɁ˹ȭǚɁŘƞʊnjʁɁȧ*ūĶ detailing. the averaged result of nine individual
frequency sweeps measured at three
CONCLUSION metres using a pink noise test stimu-
Fabulous bass In the world of high-end loudspeakers, man- lus with the central grid point on-axis
Airy, natural sound ufacturers use many methods to convince with the tweeter and with the capture
Superb high frequencies consumers of the superiority of their particu- unsmoothed. This response has been
lar acoustic creation. spliced using post-processing to the gated
Some use physical size, others use sculp- high-frequency response (measured at a
Aluminium spine tural devices, while a few of them provide single point at one metre directly on-axis
Speaker terminals myriad complex adjustments to encourage with the B&W 800 D3’s tweeter while its
‘listener participation’. protective cover was in place).
TonTräger.audio
Sound furniture for a new tonal dimension
dBSPL
110
You can see that the ±3dB variation is Graph 1. Frequency Newpor
Newportt Test
est Labs
a
response. Trace below
105
caused by roll-off in the low frequencies (be-
500Hz is the averaged 100
within the audio band, the trace shows that ual frequency sweeps 90
across the audio spectrum, with no ‘tilt’ that spliced (at 500Hz) to the 60
the port (the red trace) coming into play with with phase (blue trace) 120
The output of the port rolls off smoothly trace), low pass (green 60
64 ÄˁʊǜʁŘǚǔŘȭǔȊhǔ ˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
ROCK ON by Jez Ford
HIGH-PERFORMANCE
BOOKSHELF SPEAKERS
AVAILABLE NOW • D7, D9 AND D11 • FROM $995
ÜÜÜ°`iwÌÛiÌiV }Þ°V
AVAILABLE IN AUSTRALIA THROUGH ABSOLUTE HI END . 0488 777 999 . info@absolutehiend.com . www.absolutehiend.com
O TURNS
ON
ARK SIDE SALE
NOW
THE NEW ‘PROGRES
SSION’, WITH DARK MODE,
NEW YORK’S
FINEST
Meet McIntosh’s
biggest integrated ever!
HIFIMAN
SHANGRI-LA
$78,000 electrostatic
headphones, anyone?
BLU-RAY REVIEWS – Different Tastes
Director: Daniel E Catullo III Starring: Streisand, Diana Krall, Seal, Herbie
Starring: Myles Kennedy, Mark Tremonti, Hancock, Jeff Beck, LeAnn Rimes, BeBe Winans,
Scott Phillips, Brian Marshall. Faith Hill, Matthew Morrison, Barry Manilow,
Tony Bennett, Stevie Wonder, Arturo Sandoval.
Show: A– | Picture: A | Sound: A– | Extras: B Movie: A– | Picture: A | Sound: A | Extras: D
M M
y ignorance was exposed when Via Vision included this usicares is an American music industry charity established
disc with a few it had sent through for review. Alter nearly thirty years ago ‘to help artists in critical need’. Each
Bridge? Never heard of them. year it gives a ‘Person of the Year’ award to a prominent
When I get a Blu-ray review disc I first pop it into my computer’s musician who has also been sufficiently philanthropic. I’d say more,
disc drive and run an analysis program on it. That gives me useful but there’s really nothing much on the disc describing the purpose
information about such things as the average bit-rate of the video, of the concert. I assume that it raises a pile of money for the charity.
confirms (or otherwise) the claimed audio standards and so on. In 2011 Barbra Streisand was the honouree. The 65-minute con-
Then I run a Blu-ray software player which provides additional tech cert consists of a bunch of other prominent artists covering some of
data on the disc, and I pile all that into a database I’ve been main- the songs for which she was known over her career. The lady herself
taining for lo these last two decades. In the remarks field I typed does the last couple.
‘Creed similarities’. That’s because the moment I started the disc I spent much of my life dismissive of so-called MoR music, while
running in the player, I thought ‘Creed’, the huge 90s band, with its simultaneously excusing some of my favourite artists as ‘not MoR’
heavy sound, occasionally Christian themes and its 25× Platinum US for some reason or other. But the reality is that Streisand is middle
and 6× Platinum Australian album sales. of the road, and she’s one of the many artists that make much MoR
But there’s a documentary on this disc too about Alter Bridge, well worth listening to. Most of this concert is well worth listening to.
and this opened with the breakup of Creed. Aha, this is the same Streisand was the one of the first artists I heard on CD, at a CD
band as ‘Human Clay’ period Creed, with a new vocalist. player demo, before their release, at a hi-fi store here in Canberra.
The genre is variously alt metal, progressive metal and hard When I purchased my first CD player—a Sony CDP-101—hours after
rock. And, yes, it has a definite Creed flavour. The singer, Myles they were launched, I bought ‘Guilty’, that Streisand CD. I may never
Kenneday, has a classic ‘metal’ voice and the instrumentalists have have purchased her at all, except in those early days there was almost
plenty of time to show their virtuosity, with some very flashy guitar nothing available on CD.
solos scattered through the 21 live performances. As heavy groups I loved Seal’s version of Guilty. These renditions range from fairly
must, seemingly by force of custom, there’s a quite lovely acoustic faithful reproductions of Streisand’s versions, through to some which
ballad (Wonderful Life) in the middle of the concert. are almost unrecognisable. His was instrumentally identical to the
The disc has a generous play time of two hours. The excitement original, but with Seal’s gorgeously smooth vocals a fitting replace-
starts with an intro to the main menu with graphical sailing ships ment for Streisand’s. Another highlight was the Jeff Beck, LeAnn
firing canon with wonderful oomph. Rimes and BeBe Winans performance of Come Rain or Come Shine. Yes,
When you select play, you’re tossed into a two minute long ani- that Jeff Beck. I would never have thought of it, but his guitar made
mated DTS-HD logo. Then onto the concert… with the stereo (24 a superb third voice in what became effectively a trio.
bit) LPCM track engaged by default. Less successful was Barry Manilow’s by-the-numbers Memory. I
My receiver happened to have Dolby Surround mode engaged, don’t know who, if anyone else, was lip syncing, but his microphone
and clearly there’s plenty of extractable surround information even non-technique made it clear that he was.
in the two-channel track. The stereo track is a little cleaner than the The sound quality was a little variable too. Streisand herself sound-
surround. In the surround mix the underlying crowd sounds sof- ed excellent (albeit with a stack of reverb dialled in). But Diana Krall’s
tened the dynamic impact slightly by removing the ‘space’ between microphone was a big zingy, and her piano a touch too quiet, unfo-
the musical notes. Still, all the instruments and vocals are clean and cused. There was also noticeable sibilance on Leona Lewis’ superb
well-balanced, while the bass is appropriately heavy. rendition of Somewhere.
The crowd is very enthusiastic, singing along with these mighty The music comes with 24 bit, 48kHz sampling in both 5.1 chan-
songs. This isn’t challenging music, but extremely well done as it nel DTS-HD Master Audio and stereo LPCM. The surround mix makes
nicely explores the line between power ballads and heavy metal. little use of the surround channels, just feeding them some of that
There’s a nice extra in the box: a CD containing 14 of the 21 tracks. reverb for a sense of hall space, along with the audience applause.
Unfortunately, you can’t squeeze a full two-hour concert onto a CD. The disc defaults to the 5.1 mix. Stephen Dawson
FEATURES FEATURES
Running time: 118 minutes Running time: 65 minutes
Picture: 1.78:1, 1080i60, MPEG4 AVC @ 24.36Mbps Picture: 1.78:1, 1080i60, MPEG4 AVC @ 34.94Mbps
Sound: English: DTS-HD Master Audio 24/48 3/2.1 @ 5052kbps (core: DTS Sound: English: DTS-HD Master Audio 24/48 3/2.1 @ 4533kbps (core: DTS
24/48 3/2.1 @ 1509kbps); English: LPCM 24/48 2/0.0 @ 2304kbps 24/48 3/2.1 @ 1509kbps); English: LPCM 24/48 2/0.0 @ 2304kbps
Subtitles: Nil Subtitles: Nil
Features: CD with 14 tracks; Documentary (1080p24 - 55 mins); Photo gal- Features: Featurette (1080i60 - 2 mins)
lery (1080i60 - 9 mins) Restrictions: Exempt, Region Free
Restrictions: Exempt, Region Free
2017
If you want the best in
IF YOU ARE hi-fi, hear now in our
Melbourne showroom:
SERIOUS ABOUT HIFI
Audiophile & Cds, Audio
Magazines, Audiolab, Arcam, Benz
Conrad Johnson, McCormack,
Micro, Conrad Johnson, Jas,
McCormack, N.A.D., Nordost, Naim,
Jas, Vandersteen, DH Labs, Naim,
Quad, Silver Sonic, Benz Micro, Audiolab, Nordost,
Sound Reference, Vandersteen. Silver Sonics and Quad ESL’s.
8/585 Blackburn Road, Notting Hill, VIC 3168 Tel: 03 8555 0735
email: sales@classaaudio.com.au www.classaaudio.com.au
pass
labs
AUDIO SOLUTIONS.
Your one-stop shop for all things HI-FI.
We are the longest established Hi Fi business Visit us at 283 Victoria Rd, Marrickville NSW 2204
MRXLIWEQIPSGEXMSRMR7]HRI]%PPSJSYV P 1300 MY HIFI 1300 694 434
TVSHYGXWEVIKIRYMRI%YWXVEPMERWXSGO[MXL E WEPIW$ETSPPSLMƤGSQEY
%YWXVEPMERQERYJEGXYVIVŭW[EVVERX] W [[[ETSPPSLMƤGSQEY
SPEAKER
OF THE YEAR
Ask about our beautifully crafted, high quality cables and tuning accessories.
Proudly distributed in Australia by GROOVEWORKS Neerim South VICTORIA 3831 - Tel: (03) 5628 4428 - www.recordclean.com.au
High-end Audio at an affordable price.
WEISS DAC 501 AND 502 The DAC501 / DAC502 are the new state of the
art D/A Converters with an unprecedented level of
sophistication and versatility.
P 03 9578 8658 M 0403 368 755 Visit us 224 McKinnon Road, McKinnon VIC 3204 www.soundgallery.com.au info@soundgallery.com.au
SERVING
AUSTRALIANS
FOR MORE
THAN 30 YEARS
We have developed a reputation for our
expertise in high-end 2 channel audio
since 1987. Today, not only do we continue
our tradition of high-end audio, we also
specialise in smart home solutions. Speak
to our experienced team who can consult,
design and install the perfect smart home
solution for you.
Services we provide:
• Audio Video Setups • Home audio visual
• Acoustic treatments cabling advice
• Two channel and multi • Home security and
channel audio solutions access control solutions
• On-site consultations & • Full wiring schematic
advice on technologies drawing documentation
to suit your home and plans
• Wi-Fi and internet • Project Management –
solutions working with all trades
• Installation services involved
• Smart home solutions
OUR BRANDS Arcam · Autonomic · Ayre · Burmester · Clearaudio · Control4 · D’Agostino · Dali
DCS · Definitive Technology · Denon · GoldenEar Technology · Flexson · Gryphon · Hegel · KEF
Lilin Security · Linn · Lyngdorf · Mark Levinston · MBL · Nordost · Padimount · Revel · Sonos
Sony · Steinway Lyngdorf · Pass Labs · Pathos · T+A · TruAudio · VideoStorm · VTL · Wilson Audio
JOHN
SUNIER
1936–2018
W
riter and broadcaster
John Sunier, whose radio
program Audiophile
Audition was broadcast
nationally throughout
North America every week for more than a
decade, and who wrote music reviews for
many audio magazines, including Australian
Hi-Fi Magazine, has died aged 82.
Audiophile Audition was a national radio
program for audio buffs and music lovers
that entertained millions of public radio
and concert music station listeners for near- While working at WGBG-FM, Sunier studied LPs, cylinder records, and various tapes, plus
ly fourteen years. The hour-long weekly pro- part time at Boston University, where he was a pair of Tonkinese cats, and established the
gram began in April 1985 with 53 stations, awarded a Master of Science (Communica- website ‘Audiophile Audition’ [www.audaud.
and ended up being carried on 200 station tions).Sunier produced the educational radio com], which is now one of the world’s pre-
across the USA—both public and commer- series ‘The Standard School Broadcast’ for six miere sources of reviews of recorded music,
cial. years, and later became Director of Sound particularly of high-resolution recordings.
In addition to being involved in radio for Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Films. He was ‘John was recognised far and wide as a definitive
broadcasting and audio for more than five program director and/or manager for several expert in all matters audio, all matters for audi-
decades, Sunier was also a well-known clas- FM stations in San Francisco, as well as edi- ophiles,’ said Paul Henerlau, manager at Audi-
sical and jazz music reviewer. For ten years tor of FM Guide and Sound Advice magazines ophile Audition, ‘and his incredible energy and
he wrote a regular monthly column for US and founder and editor of the specialist bin- drive found a distinctive expression in Audiophile
magazine Audio, and also wrote reviews for aural recording magazine The Binaural Source. Audition. In the last year of his life, John stepped
AudiophileFile, The Sensible Sound, AudioX- When Audiophile Audition ceased broadcast- back from his beloved website, assuming more of
press, and at the time of his death had been ing, Sunier moved to Portland, Oregon tak- a Professor Emeritus role.’
contributing a regular column titled ‘Super ing along his harpsichord, his piano, loads John is survived by his wife of 32 years,
Fidelity’ to Australi- of SACDs, DVD-As, xrcds, CDs, LDs, DVDs, Donna (Dorsett). Rod Easdown
an Hi-Fi Magazine for
more than fifteen Pictured at the piano on his
75th birthday, taking requests.
years. He also au-
thored three books
about audio, one of
which, ‘The Story of
Stereo 1881–’, pub-
lished by Gernsback
Library (New York),
is now available in
pdf format at avhub.
com.au/story_ste-
reo_sunier. It was
largely based on the thesis for his degree
of Master of Science from Boston Universi-
ty, which is also available in pdf format at
avhub.com.au/stereo_sound_sunier. Sunier’s
other books were ‘A History of Stereo Sound’
and ‘Slidesound and Filmstrip Production’.
Born John Henry Sunier on Novem-
ber 30, 1936, in Iowa City, the son of
John Henry Senior and Johanna (Graf) Su-
nier, Sunier studied at the University of
Iowa, where he received his Bachelor in
Music in 1959, after which he worked at
radio stations WSUI and KSUI. He then
moved to Boston to work at WGBH-FM.
82 ÄˁʊǜʁŘǚǔŘȭǔȊhǔ ˹˹˹ƖŘˁʊǒǔǞƖƋɁȧ
The biggest small music system
LS50 Wireless – Immerse yourself in power and finesse
Prepare to be swept away. Never before have bookshelf speakers produced such scale and detail.
The KEF LS50 Wireless is a complete system that delivers audiophile-grade sound in real stereo.
Five minutes from unboxing, just add your music and enjoy. No wonder respected reviewers call
it the future of Hi-Fi. Listen for yourself. …au.kef.com