Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Way Finding Design Guidelines
Way Finding Design Guidelines
Way Finding Design Guidelines
R Y
S T
GO
U
V
IND
ER
Department of Main Roads
NM
ENT
E
R
SE
AR
CH
Wayfinding design guidelines
compiled by
Ron Apelt, John Crawford and Dennis Hogan
© Icon.Net Pty Ltd 2007
Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation
L Block, Level 9, QUT Gardens Point 2 George Street, Brisbane, Qld, Australia 4000
Telephone: +61 7 3138 9291
Email: enquiries@construction-innovation.info
Web: www.construction-innovation.info
All intellectual property in the ideas, concepts and design for this publication belongs to Icon.Net Pty Ltd.
The authors, the Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation, Icon.Net Pty Ltd, and their
respective boards, stakeholders, officers, employees and agents make no representation or warranty
concerning the accuracy or completeness of the information in this work. To the extent permissible by
law, the aforementioned persons exclude all implied conditions or warranties and disclaim all liability
for any loss or damage or other consequences howsoever arising from the use of the information in
this book.
Disclaimer
This non-mandatory guideline document Wayfinding design guidelines is designed to assist in making
such information easily available. However, neither the CRC for Construction Innovation, nor the groups
which have endorsed or been involved in the development of the guidelines, accept any responsibility
for the use of the information contained in the guidelines and make no guarantee or representation
whatsoever that the information is an exhaustive treatment of the subject matters contained therein
or is complete, accurate, up-to-date or relevant as a guide to action for any particular purpose. Users
are required to exercise their own skill and care with respect to its use. In any important matter, users
should carefully evaluate the scope of the treatment of the particular subject matter, its completeness,
accuracy, currency, and relevance for their purposes, and should obtain appropriate professional
advice relevant to their particular circumstances.
In particular, and to avoid doubt, the use of the guidelines does not:
• guarantee acceptance or accreditation of a design, material or building solution by any entity
authorised to do so under any laws
• mean that a design, material or building solution complies with the Building Code of Australia
• absolve the user from complying with any Local, State, and Territory or Australian Government
legal requirements.
First published 2007 by Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation, for Icon.Net Pty Ltd.
Cover images © Queensland Department of Public Works
For further information on our publications, including Wayfinding system audit, please visit our website:
www.construction-innovation.info
RRP $27.50
ISBN 978-0-9804262-9-8
This publication is printed on 9lives 80 by Spicers Paper. This paper is derived from well-managed
forests and contains 80% recycled fibre from post-consumer waste and 20% totally chlorine-free pulp.
The Disability Services Act 2006 aims to ensure that the conditions of everyday life
for people with a disability are the same as, or as close as possible, to the conditions
enjoyed by the general community.
This Wayfinding design guidelines booklet is an important resource that provides
practical and cost-effective solutions to help designers, developers, property owners
and managers do their part in improving access to buildings, properties and spaces
for all people.
It complements a range of strategies introduced by the Queensland Government which
aim to enhance people’s ability to participate fully in their communities.
It is my pleasure to support this very practical booklet which offers people with a disability real solutions
for wayfinding through their community, and I commend it to you.
iii
Contents
Preface .................................................................................................................................................... v
Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................... vi
About the Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation ..................................................viii
Definition of terms .................................................................................................................................. ix
1 Wayfinding ..........................................................................................................................................1
Inclusive design and environmental access ...................................................................................1
Principles of Universal Design ........................................................................................................2
2 Wayfinding design principles ...........................................................................................................4
Wayfinding maps .............................................................................................................................4
3 Wayfinding devices, systems and technologies .............................................................................6
4 Design solutions and strategies .......................................................................................................8
Communicating spatial information .................................................................................................8
Issue: informative material ...............................................................................................................8
Issue: arrival point or address of the facility or building .................................................................8
Issue: unidentified main entry or arrival point .................................................................................8
Issue: internal arrival point ..............................................................................................................9
Issue: graphic communication ........................................................................................................9
Issue: restrooms and toilet facilities ..............................................................................................11
Issue: lifts .......................................................................................................................................11
Issue: signage ...............................................................................................................................11
Issue: viewing distance to signage ...............................................................................................11
5 Signage hierarchical structure .......................................................................................................12
Sign legibility .................................................................................................................................12
System design criteria ...................................................................................................................13
Types of signs ...............................................................................................................................13
Identification signs.........................................................................................................................13
Information signs ...........................................................................................................................13
Directional signs ............................................................................................................................13
Safety, regulatory, prohibition and advisory signs ........................................................................13
Recommended reading .................................................................................................................18
6 References ........................................................................................................................................19
7 Further reading.................................................................................................................................21
Appendix A ..........................................................................................................................................22
Principles of Universal Design ......................................................................................................22
Appendix B ..........................................................................................................................................24
Suggested letter height .................................................................................................................24
Appendix C ..........................................................................................................................................25
Wayfinding systems matrix ............................................................................................................25
v
Acknowledgements
Wayfinding design guidelines compiled by Ron Apelt, John Crawford and Dennis Hogan is based
on the outcomes of the Cooperative Research Centre (CRC) for Construction Innovation project
documented in the research report Wayfinding in the Built Environment.
Project researchers
Ron Apelt Queensland Department of Public Works
John Crawford CSIRO consultant
Project affiliates
Michael Small Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission
Jo Higginson Office of Commonwealth Games Coordination
Without the financial and collaborative efforts bringing together such teams, this valuable report
could not have been successfully delivered to our industry.
The Wayfinding project participants would like to thank and acknowledge Colleen Foelz
(Communication and publications, CRC for Construction Innovation) for the management
of this publication.
Publication sponsor
vii
About the Cooperative Research Centre for
Construction Innovation
The CRC for Construction Innovation is a national research, development and implementation
centre focused on the needs of the property, design, construction and facility management
sectors. Established in 2001 and headquartered at Queensland University of Technology under
the Australian Government’s Cooperative Research Program, Construction Innovation is developing
key technologies, tools and management systems to improve the effectiveness of the construction
industry. Construction Innovation is supported by investment from its industry, government and
research partners, leveraged by a Commonwealth grant. More that 350 individuals and an alliance
of 27 leading partner organisations are involved in and support the activities of this CRC.
ix
Continuous An uninterrupted path of travel to, from or within a building, providing access
accessible path to all required facilities. A continuous accessible path of travel should not
of travel (refer incorporate any step, stairway, turnstile, revolving door, escalator or other
also ‘universal impediment that would prevent it from being safely negotiated by people with
accessway’) disabilities. AS1428.1, part 1: General requirements for access — New building
work, Building Code of Australia (2007).
Contrasting Contrasting textures act as tactile markers, which people can identify by touch.
textures: Examples include carpet matting on a vinyl floor surface, domed buttons on
handrails to indicate the end of the stairway or ramp is approaching, and tactile
ground surface indicators (TGSIs) at the top and bottom of stairs. Building
Code of Australia (2007) Section D3.8 Tactile Ground Surface Indicators (TGSI)
and Royal Blind Society (2003).
Colour contrast: Viewing of any object involves the concept of ‘figure–ground relationship’
— the more an object contrasts with its surrounds, the more visible it is.
The concept of ‘figure-ground relationship’ also includes the relationship
between ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ space and the effective use of colour
combinations. The basic guidelines for making effective colour choices
use Itten’s devised seven colour contrasts: saturation, light, dark,
extension (or contrast of proportion), complements, hue, warm and cool.
These devised seven colour contrasts (or methodologies) for coordinating
colours use the hues’ contrasting properties (not physical and chemical
properties) of colours. Primary colours, yellow, red and blue, produce the
strongest contrast.
These colour contrasts add other variations to the intensity of the hues:
contrasts may be obtained due to light, moderate or dark value. The colour
contrast becomes weaker with secondary or tertiary colours or as the
saturation decreases.
Disability A condition or state of being, which is covered by the broad Disability
Discrimination Act 1992 (Cwlth) definition. The term includes physical, sensory,
psychiatric, intellectual and neurological disabilities, physical disfigurement
and the presence in the body causing, or capable of causing, disease.
CRC for Construction Innovation (2006).
Forward-up The upward direction on a map which must always show what is in front of
equivalence the viewer. Levine (2003).
principle
xi
(d) pedestrian crossings in high-use vehicular areas, e.g. car parks
(e) vehicle pick-up and drop-off areas
(f) railway platforms
(g) passenger wharves
(h) car park crossings
(i) bus stops
(j) trams/light rail
(k) level path/carriageway junctions
(l) projecting hazards in circulation spaces
(m) change of direction, directional indicators
Adapted from AS1428.2:1992 Design for access and mobility, part 2: Enhanced
and additional requirements — Buildings and facilities and AS/NZ1428.4:2002
Design for access and mobility, part 4: Tactile indicators.
Universal A universal accessway is a dedicated and marked route within the public
accessway (refer domain that provides a continuous accessible path of travel:
Continuous • within the boundary of the site from transport stops, accessible parking,
accessible path accessible passenger loading zones, public streets or walkways to
of travel) building entrances
• that connects accessible buildings, facilities and spaces on the same site
and connects building, entrances with all accessible spaces and facilities
within a building, and connects the entrances of each building with exterior
and interior spaces and facilities
• that minimises the distances travelled between all elements of buildings
and spaces.
As a guideline dimension for an external universal accessway, the space
should have an optimum minimum vertical and horizontal clearance of
2000 mm. Wherever possible, an all-weather cover is recommended to and
from a building, but it is essential that an all-weather cover is placed at the
building entrance.
Vision impairment Vision impairment is any significant loss of sight. Adapted from AS1428.4:2002
part 4: Tactile indicators.
1
CIDEA (2001) discusses the importance Principles of Universal Design
of structuring a wayfinding system around
The Principles of Universal Design were
the design of spaces. Wayfinding requires
developed by The Center for Universal Design
designers to organise and communicate
(1997) in collaboration with a consortium of
the dynamic relationships of space and the
universal design researchers and practitioners
environment to allow people to:
from across the United States. The US
• determine their location within a setting by Department of Education’s National Institute on
identifying and marking these spaces Disability and Rehabilitation Research (NIDRR)
• identify their specific destination by funded the project. Appendix A contains the
grouping and linking similar spaces Principles of Universal Design and guidelines
of key elements that should be present in a
• develop a plan that will take them from design that adheres to the principles, as shown
their location to their destination by linking on The Center for Universal Design’s website.
and organising spaces through both
architectural and graphic means in a safe The Principles of Universal Design show that
barrier-free direction of travel. inclusive design can accommodate people with
varying abilities.
Applying design principles that are largely
inherent to the way people visualise the The seven principles may be applied to
physical world helps identify cues within the evaluate existing designs, guide the design
built and natural environments. The language process and educate designers and
used to describe environmental cues for consumers about the characteristics of
wayfinding is derived from many design more usable products and environments1
disciplines such as architecture, landscape Following these principles leads to a
architecture, town planning, surveying, non-discriminatory design approach and
geography and the now recognised profession provides increased usability for everyone
of ‘access consulting’. without the need for adaptation or
Lynch (1960) is credited with coining the term specialised design.
‘wayfinding’ in The Image of the City, where he
referred to maps, street numbers, directional
signs and other elements as ‘wayfinding
devices’. The terminology has developed into
five main architectural wayfinding elements:
• paths and circulation
• landmarks or markers
• nodes
• edges
• zones or districts (Lynch, 1960).
These architectural wayfinding elements and
the graphic wayfinding elements, together
with the criteria for design and organisation of
landscape, urban amenities and buildings are
largely responsible for a highly legible
and comprehensible urban environment.
Wayfinding systems need to take account of
the way people with varying abilities negotiate
1
Center for Universal Design. (1997). Compiled by Connell, B.R.,
Jones, M., Mace, R., Mueller, J., Mullick, A., Ostroff, E., Sanford,
the built environment. An understanding of the J., Steinfeld, E., Story, M., Vanderheiden, G. The Principles of
‘Principles of Universal Design’ is necessary Universal Design. Version 2.0. Raleigh, NC: North Carolina State
University. Retrieved 20 March 2007 from:
so that built spaces are accommodating www.design.ncsu.edu/cud/about_ud/udprinciplestext.htm
for everyone. www.design.ncsu.edu/cud/about_ud/docs/use_guidelines.pdf
3
2 Wayfinding design principles
Wayfinding design principles provide a • When considering a naming protocol of
structure to organise the environment into an alpha-numeric coding system such as
a spatial hierarchy capable of supporting ‘Room B3.7’, provide consistency within the
wayfinding tasks. coding system. For example:
The basic wayfinding design principles are – Room B3.7 reads Building ‘B’, Level 3
as follows. Room 7
• Analyse the building or site for access
– Room C4.6 reads Building ‘C’, Level 4
points, taking into account the physical and
Room 6
aesthetic characteristics of the building or
site. How will the site be accessed? – Block BS1 reads Building ‘B’ South,
Entry 1
• Divide the large-scale site into distinctive
smaller parts, or zones of functional use, – Block MN2 reads Building ‘M’ North,
while preserving a ‘sense of place’ and Entry 2.
connectivity between spaces. • Consider incorporating information in
• Organise the smaller parts under a simple multiple languages or incorporating
organisational principle, such as ‘use’. pictograms when devising a naming
Devise a zonation plan with a logical and protocol.
rational structure. • Ensure the physical placement,
• Provide frequent directional cues installation and illumination of signs
throughout the space, particularly at is suitable for all users.
decision points along journeys in both
directions. Wayfinding maps
• The design of decision points must be Although maps are not appropriate for every
logical, rational and obvious to a sighted situation, being able to quickly extract spatial
user, ensuring the directional cues relate information makes them a powerful navigation
directly to a building or landscape space. aid.
Ensure sequencing and that the priority Ideally, this information should be flexible, as if
and grouping of message signs the user has obtained it from direct experience.
is unambiguous. Therefore, map design principles should
• Design and implement a ‘naming protocol’ present spatial information and represent
by choosing a theme for segregating places the environment in a flexible and
and spaces. Use names and symbols that orientation-independent way.
can be easily remembered by users from Map design principles
diverse cultural backgrounds. Any naming
protocol must be flexible enough to be 1. Organise the environment into clear spaces
adapted to changing functions in a building either by abstraction or inclusion.
or throughout a landscape or public space. 2. Show all organisational elements
• Use a sequential, logical, rational and (paths, landmarks, districts) and use the
consistent naming protocol for places such organisational principle of only including
as hospitals or educational institutions important and memorable connections.
where buildings have been master planned 3. Show the user’s position.
and organised into a logical arrangement.
4. Orient the map to the user, applying the
‘forward-up equivalence principle2’.
2
Forward-up equivalence principle’: The upward direction on a
map that must always show what is in front of the viewer. Levine
(2003)
3
This document provides information about touch-screen directories
that are able to change text size, have colour contrast, text-to-speech
systems and navigational access keys. Retrieved 20 March 2007 from
www.equalityhumanrights.com/pages/eocdrccre.aspx
5
3 Wayfinding devices, systems and technologies
Wayfinding is the ‘…ease with which one Equally, the degree of sophistication of
proceeds and is facilitated through an innovative devices maybe a psychological
environment from one point of interest to barrier, as well as an economic barrier,
another…’ and the ‘…techniques used by for many people. This issue means greater
people who are blind or visually impaired as emphasis should be placed on the design
they move from place to place independently of the built environment.
and safely’ (Queensland Health, 1996).
Table 1 Assistive devices for people who are
The aim of these design guidelines is to help blind or vision impaired
developers, designers, property owners and
managers identify viable, practical and Long cane
cost-effective solutions to assist people who Hoople
are blind or vision impaired and other people
Guide dog
who require mobility assistance. This can be
achieved by understanding the barriers that Human assistant
restrict safe travel paths and the techniques Laser cane
employed by users to find their destinations.
Mowat sensor
These guidelines are based on current
understanding in cognitive psychology, Sonic guide
linguistics and best practice in orientation Nottingham obstacle detector
and access as identified in the literature
NOMAD
and in practice throughout the world
(Jacobson, 1998). Tactile displays, maps, arrays
Appendix C contains a matrix of devices, Personal guidance system
systems and technologies that provide useful, MoBIC
on-demand navigation information and aids
for people who are blind or vision impaired, Atlas Strider
describing the environment and assisting them Talking signs
plan to reach their destinations.
Auditory beacons
Many assistive devices are discussed in the
Electronic strips
Cooperative Research Centre for Construction
Innovation project Wayfinding in the built Motion detectors
environment (Stage 1, Stages 2 and 3 Pressure detectors
— Final reports, 2004–06). Where possible,
these reports should be consulted. It is Barcode readers
generally agreed that when Tactile Ground Beacons
Surface Indicators (TGSIs), raised tactile
Braille or auditory compass
signage and braille signage are appropriately
placed and designed, they are reliable, Vision enhancing devices (monocular)
cost-effective assistive devices for people Infrared detectors
who are blind or vision impaired. They are
also recognisable to sighted people. (adapted from Golledge and Stimpson,
1997, p. 499).
The assistive devices in Table 1 are currently
available for people who are blind or vision
impaired. However, sophisticated electronic
devices have advanced rapidly, leading to
smaller, wearable devices, which are less
obtrusive but, in some cases, expensive.
7
4 Design solutions and strategies
These suggested design solutions and Issue: arrival point or address of the
strategies include wayfinding design facility or building
criteria and design principles for critical
All buildings and facilities have a number of
decision-making points within the built
entries or arrival points. However, the address
environment. The suggested design
of a building or facility provides its identity or
solutions and strategies are additional to any
arrival point for occupants and visitors.
requirements of the Building Code of Australia
for wayfinding. Clearly identify the address of the building or
facility with its name, street address and an
Communicating spatial information appropriate marker or landmark.
At a perceptual level, the sensory impairment Design the arrival point as the main entry,
of people who are blind or vision impaired not as a secondary entry.
limits information gathering from both
primary and secondary sources. Although Issue: unidentified main entry or arrival
there are sophisticated sight-compensating point
technologies, most technical aids only add For many buildings and facilities, the arrival
environmental cues to the information already point is not easily distinguishable because of
gathered through auditory, tactile, competing infrastructure such as bus stops, taxi
olfactory and kinaesthetic means. The extent to ranks, adjacent businesses or ‘A’ frame signage;
which a person who is blind or vision impaired however, what may be seen as clutter is also
has an understanding of place with spatial business infrastructure.
reference is unclear. The environment they are
able to perceive in their mind has relatively Ensure that entry points to all buildings and
few unique locational cues — tactile cues like facilities have direct access with clearly marked
kerb and building lines are often repeated and boundaries for pedestrians, are free of clutter
auditory or olfactory cues may be temporal and and are separated and protected from roads
ephemeral. There is a need to develop effective and bicycle or skating paths.
methods of communicating spatial information Directory systems should provide visitors and
by non-visual means to improve quality of life occupants with sufficient information to ensure
through increased mobility and independence a successful arrival point and ease of access
(Jacobson and Kitchin, 1997). to further destination points.
The literature reveals a number of issues Provide a directory system using the
for people who are blind or vision impaired ‘forward-up equivalence principle4’ that
that can be easily addressed through incorporates sensory elements for people of
wayfinding systems. all abilities. A directory system should include
tactile elements such as braille, surface finishes
Issue: informative material and raised character signage; graphic elements
Consider producing information such as such as pictograms; and audible elements,
locational maps, bus and train timetables which may include integrating both audio-tactile
and schedules in braille or large print. maps, visual and other forms of communication
triggered by infrared light or movement sensors.
Ensure signs on entries to buildings, complexes
and public transport vehicles are large. Where suitable, an audible directory system
should consist of short, simple and straight-
Where possible, provide an information desk forward messages, unique to the building or site.
with informed staff to assist people locate a Repeated messages should only provide key
destination. The literature reveals that touch-tone reference points such as ‘You are entering the
access to pre-recorded messages, voice-mail
or computerised query systems are universally 4
‘Forward-up equivalence principle’: The upward direction
on a map that must always show what is in front of the
disliked (Jacobson and Kitchin, 1997). viewer. Levine (2003).
9
Ensure accessible parking spaces are Many signs are not legible when viewed from
provided close to the main entry of a distance. The following recommendations can
buildings and are located adjacent assist in the optimal readability of signs.
to a universal accessway.
• Colour contrast on the sign.
Locate reception and information desks near lifts Other suggested minimum letter heights for various
so that attendants can assist visitors with directions. sign types include:
Fit lifts with backlit, large tactile buttons with raised • vehicular direction signs, internal roads,
tactile signage letters and numbers and braille carparks and service areas: 60 mm
signage. Audible outputs should indicate floor • external pedestrian direction signs: 60 mm
levels.
• internal direction signs: 30 mm
Issue: signage • building directory listings: 20 mm
Place signs in transitional areas to reassure people • door signs: 17 mm
they are on the correct route. The maximum
• tactile lettering: 15 mm (55 mm maximum)6.
distance between information or directional signs in
long corridors should be no greater than 30 metres. For road signs, the speed of travel and the number
of letters in the message bring in other factors;
Maps can be used to supplement directional
however, for lower road speed environments
information at key decision points to reduce the
such as university campuses and hospitals, the
amount of directional signage needed.
letter height used for public roads is acceptable.
Direction signs require a greater letter height than
Issue: viewing distance to signage information signs (Greg and Signcorp, 2003). Refer
Viewing distance is a concept printing and signage to Appendix B for more details on suggested letter
industries use to capture attention for an image on heights.
display. Viewing distance is also closely related with
the resolution and size of an image.
The concept of viewing distance requires an
understanding of perspective theory as the
resolution of the image, and its detail, is always
taken from where the viewer is positioned and
whether the viewer is standing, walking, sitting
or viewing from a moving vehicle. The clarity of
atmospherics such as light and shade and weather
conditions also plays a part in viewing distance.
Construction materials and the position of signs are
also important.
The simple rule of viewing distance is that the
closer a person is to an object, the higher the
resolution of the image needs to be. The perception 6
For tactile lettering, the width of the character should allow for both
of the human eye varies from person to person, sides of the embossed shape to be felt.
11
5 Signage hierarchical structure
Each sign has a hierarchal structure that • specific logos, maps, pictograms and
communicates meaningful content for other symbols or artwork layered on
individual readers. The hierarchical structure is: top of the base
• the colour scheme and general layout as • textual information and directional arrows
the base, or background, layer providing specific details.
The signage hierarchy is depicted in Table 3.
Table 3 Signage hierarchy
Sign legibility
Effective signs should communicate a clear
message. While words and phrasing are
important elements of effective signs the most
significant influence on legibility is typeface.
Arial, MS Sans Serif, Tahoma, Futura, Geneva and
Helvetica Medium typefaces are some examples
that people who are vision impaired find easier to
read. Title case (lower case with an initial capital)
or lower case are also easier to read.
Types of signs
There are four types of signs:
• identification
• information
• directional
• safety or regulatory, prohibition and advisory
(ADAS, 1999).
Identification signs
Identification signs, also referred to as ‘destination
signs’, typically identify entrances, street
addresses, buildings, rooms, facilities, places
and spaces.
Information signs
Information signs inform users about the features
and facilities of a place or space. Information signs
include directories, maps, building identification
signs, notices and interpretative signs. Orientation
maps provide a graphic layout of a building
7
For guidance refer to BS8501:2002, the withdrawn AS2899.1:1986
and ISO 7001:2007.
13
Figure 2 Map design and signage of Queensland and construction of associated
infrastructure. Project Manager: Department of
Location: State Library of Queensland and Public Works
Gallery of Modern Art (GoMA) at Stanley Place, State Library of Queensland
South Brisbane Architects: Designed in association with Brisbane-
based architectural firms Donovan Hill Peddle
This map design and signage provides the Thorp architects. The design was selected from
three major functions of basic map design the Millennium Library Project Architects Selection
principles: orientation or direction (connectivity Competition (2001).
between present location and desired location); Gallery of Modern Art (GoMA)
identification of locations; and relevant Architects: Architectus Sydney (Kerry and Lindsay
Clare, 2002) were the Design Directors for the
information for further decision making. Note winning entry of the Queensland Gallery of Modern
the use of raised tactile lettering and braille, Art International Design Competition.
the ‘You are here’ graphics and the identification Access Consultant: Disability Access Consultants
of major attractions and public facilities. The Pty Ltd (Trevor Beardsmore)
physical placement, installation and illumination Environmental Graphic Designer: Dot Dash,
Brisbane
of signage must be suitable for everyone.
Sign Contractor: Albert Smith Group, Brisbane
This sign was developed in 2006 as part of the Managing Contractor: Bovis Lend Lease
Millennium Arts Project at the Cultural Centre, an Photography by: Amanda McLucas 30 March 2007
initiative of the Queensland Government through Copyright: Department of Public Works.
Arts Queensland. The Millennium Arts Project at
the Cultural Centre included the construction of
the new GoMA, redevelopment of the State Library
The Arbour, covered in vibrant magenta Location: Southbank Parklands, South Brisbane
bougainvillea plants, acts as a spine through Along the Arbour, amid the canopy of the
the centre of the parklands for one kilometre, bougainvillea, is a ribbon of yellow steel that
leading the way to the parklands’ many attractions. provides shade and weather protection, but also
This environmental design guidance feature acts as a recognised landmark (marker), identifying
(horticultural and landscape architectural design the adjacent places of the riverside restaurants,
feature) enables visitors to orientate themselves cafes and Suncorp Piazza. Shade and shelter are
from many locations within the parklands. Although important environmental design guidance features.
not marked as a universal accessway, it is a clearly Master Planner: Denton Corker Marshall, Architecture
dedicated and marked route within the public and Urban Design, Melbourne
domain that distinguishes its importance as a Photography by: Amanda McLucas 30 March 2007
public right of way. Copyright: Department of Public Works.
15
Figure 5 Landmark (marker) and tactile TGSIs are important to assist in safe wayfinding;
wayfinding trail however, they should not be over-used or
over-prescribed. Designers should make full
Location: Brisbane Square, George and
use of the range of environmental guidance
Adelaide Streets, North Quay
features available to minimise inconvenience to
This sign acts as a recognised landmark other members of the community.
(marker) within the streetscape, identifying Brisbane Square Architect: Denton Corker Marshall
one of the entries to Brisbane Square and the Architecture and Urban Design, Melbourne
community assets of the Brisbane City Council Access Consultants (External): Andrew Sanderson
Library and Brisbane City Council Customer of Blythe-Sanderson Group, Melbourne
Access Consultants (Internal and Brisbane City
Service Centre. The marker provides important Council External Adviser): John Deshon of John
information for visitors to the square. The map Deshon Pty Ltd
design uses raised tactile lettering and braille, Environmental Graphic Designer: Dot Dash,
Brisbane
‘You are here’ graphics and shows the direction Signage Contractor: K-Vee Signs, Brisbane
of the major building attractions. Note the use Design and Construct Contractor: Baulderstone
of TGSIs at the base on the sign. The TGSIs Hornibrook
form part of a designed tactile wayfinding trail, Photography by: Amanda McLucas 30 March 2007
also referred to as a ‘tactile guide pathway’. Copyright: Department of Public Works.
17
Figure 7 Tactile wayfinding trail and shoreline
Location: Brisbane Square, North Quay
A shoreline is a very effective device that can
be easily accommodated by not placing street
furniture such as seats, rubbish bins, and
signage or drink fountains within the dedicated
accessway. This zone can easily be marked as
a universal accessway, reminding users of the
importance of an unobstructed space along
the length of the path of travel.
Brisbane Square Architect: Denton Corker Marshall
Architecture and Urban Design, Melbourne
Access Consultants (External): Andrew Sanderson
of Blythe-Sanderson Group, Melbourne
Access Consultants (Internal and Brisbane City
Council External Adviser): John Deshon of John
Deshon Pty Ltd
Environmental Graphic Designer: Dot Dash,
Brisbane
Signage Contractor: K-Vee Signs, Brisbane.
Design and Construct Contractor: Baulderstone
Hornibrook
Photography by: Amanda McLucas 30 March 2007
Copyright: Department of Public Works.
Recommended reading
ADAS. (1999). Good Sign Practices. ADAS
in association with E. Collis, Eye Catch Signs
Ltd Nova Scotia, Canada, and I. Peterson,
Automated Disability Access Systems, Brisbane
and Melbourne Australia. The original document
was modified, with permission, for the Australian
context by B. Tolliday and I. Peterson, Brailliant
Touch, Australia.
Barker, P. and Fraser J. (2000). Sign Design
Guide. London: JMU Access Partnership and
Sign Design Society in association with Royal
National Institute of the Blind, London.
19
Access, University at Buffalo, The State Royal Blind Society of NSW and ACT. (2003).
University of New York. Retrieved 17 November Accessible design recommendations for people
2006 from http://home.nyc.gov/html/ddc/pdf/ with vision impairment. Retrieved 17 November
udny/udny2.pdf 2006 from http://www.rbs.org.au/about/
factsheets/Accessible Design.doc
Lynch, K. (1960). The Image of the City.
Cambridge: MIT Press. University of New South Wales. (n.d.) Buildings
and Grounds, Signage and Directory Boards,
Muhlhausen, J. (2000). Wayfinding is not
Signage Guidelines Part 6.0. Sydney: University
signage: signage plays an important part of
of New South Wales, Facilities Department.
wayfinding, but there’s more. Signs of the
Retrieved 20 March 2007 from http://www.
Times. Retrieved 17 November 2006 from http://
facilities.unsw.edu.au/Buildings/Signage_
www.signweb.com/index.php/channel/6/id/1433/
Standards.pdf and http://www.facilities.unsw.
National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation edu.au/Buildings/signage.htm
Research. (2001) Notice of Proposed Funding
Vision Australia. (2006). Accessible Design
Priorities for Fiscal Years 2001–2003 for three
for Public Buildings Signage. Retrieved 17
Disability and Rehabilitation Research Projects.
November 2006 from http://www.rvib.org.au/info.
Retrieved 20 March 2007 from http://www.
aspx?page=721#Signage
ed.gov/about/offices/list/osers/nidrr/index.html
http://www.ed.gov/legislation/FedRegister/ Technical references
finrule/2001-3/070601b.html
Building Code of Australia 2007
NHS Estates. (n.d.) Improving the Patient
Experience Wayfinding. London: Department Australian Standards
of Health, UK Government. Retrieved 17 AS1288:2006 Glass in buildings
November 2006 from http://patientexperience. — Selection and installation
nhsestates.gov.uk/wayfinding/wf_content/home/
AS1428.1:2001 Design for access and mobility,
home.asp
part 1: General requirements for access
Passini, R. (1992). Wayfinding in Architecture. — New building work
New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
AS1428.2:1992 Design for access and mobility,
Pollet D. & Haskell P. C. (1979). Sign Systems for part 2: Enhanced and additional requirements
Libraries: Solving the Wayfinding Problem. — Buildings and facilities
New York: R.R. Bowker Company.
AS/NZS 1428.4: 2002 Design for access
PROWAAC. (2001). Public Rights-of-Way and mobility, part 4: Tactile indicators
Access Advisory Committee (PROWAAC) for
AS1670.4: 2004 Fire detection, warning,
the Architectural and Transportation Barriers
control and intercom systems — System
Compliance Board (Access Board) Final
design, installation and commissioning,
Report: referred to as an ‘Universal Access
part 4: Sound systems and intercom systems
Corridor’ at p.161 Appendix H Minority Report
for emergency purposes
submitted by Hol’Lynn d’Lil: What to Call
the ‘Accessible Route’. 17 November 2006 AS/NZS1680.0:1998 Interior lighting,
from http://www.access-board.gov/prowac/ part 0: Safe movement
commrept/PROWreport.pdf AS1735.1: 2003 Lifts, escalators and moving
Queensland Health. (1996). Building Guidelines walks, part 1: General requirements
for Queensland Mental Health Facilities. AS1735.12:1999 Lifts, escalators and moving
Brisbane: Queensland Government. Retrieved walks, part 12: Facilities for persons
17 November 2006 from with disabilities
http://www.health.qld.gov.au/cwamb/mhguide/
1934B_GuideSec_2.pdf AS1744:1975 Standard alphabets for
road signs — Metric units
21
Appendix A
Principles of Universal Design PRINCIPLE ONE: Equitable Use
Following are the Principles of Universal Design The design is useful and marketable to
and guidelines (1997) as displayed on The people with diverse abilities.
Center for Universal Design website, Raleigh, Guidelines:
NC: North Carolina State University.
1a. Provide the same means of use for all users:
Version 2.0 – 4 January 1997. identical whenever possible; equivalent
Compiled by advocates of universal design, when not.
listed in alphabetical order: 1b. Avoid segregating or stigmatizing any users.
Bettye Rose Connell, Mike Jones, Ron Mace, 1c. Provisions for privacy, security, and safety
Jim Mueller, Abir Mullick, Elaine Ostroff, Jon should be equally available to all users.
Sanford, Ed Steinfeld, Molly Story and Gregg 1d. Make the design appealing to all users.
Vanderheiden.
Major funding provided by The National Institute
on Disability and Rehabilitation Research, US PRINCIPLE TWO: Flexibility in Use
Department of Education. The design accommodates a wide range of
Copyright 1997 NC State University, The Center individual preferences and abilities.
for Universal Design.
Guidelines:
Universal Design: The design of products and
environments to be usable by all people, to the 2a. Provide choice in methods of use.
greatest extent possible, without the need for 2b. Accommodate right- or left-handed access
adaptation or specialized design. and use.
The authors, a working group of architects, 2c. Facilitate the user’s accuracy and precision.
product designers, engineers and 2d. Provide adaptability to the user’s pace.
environmental design researchers, collaborated
to establish the following Principles of Universal
Design to guide a wide range of design PRINCIPLE THREE: Simple and Intuitive Use
disciplines including environments, products, Use of the design is easy to understand,
and communications. These seven principles regardless of the user’s experience,
may be applied to evaluate existing designs, knowledge, language skills, or current
guide the design process and educate concentration level.
both designers and consumers about the
Guidelines:
characteristics of more usable products and
environments. 3a. Eliminate unnecessary complexity.
The Principles of Universal Design are 3b. Be consistent with user expectations and
presented here, in the following format: intuition.
name of the principle, intended to be a concise 3c. Accommodate a wide range of literacy and
and easily remembered statement of the key language skills.
concept embodied in the principle; definition 3d. Arrange information consistent with its
of the principle, a brief description of the importance.
principle’s primary directive for design; and 3e. Provide effective prompting and feedback
guidelines, a list of the key elements that should during and after task completion.
be present in a design which adheres to the
principle. (Note: all guidelines may not be
relevant to all designs).
23
Appendix B
170
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
Cap height in millimetres
20
10
0 2 4 6 8 10 20 30 40 50
25
1.0 Neighbourhood scale
Journeys of, say, 30–200 m, for example, malls, arcades, ‘pocket’ parks and urban open space
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
1.1 Tactile ground A system of raised TGSIs provide information Two types of TGSI
surface domes and stripes about changes in the tiles — warning
indicators placed in patterns on direction of the path and directional
(TGSIs) the ground to provide of travel and indicate — are used under
including tactile information. potential hazards such as AS1428.4. Local
directional The colour and platform edges, stairs and governments or
indicators luminance contrast overhead obstacles. TGSIs venue and building
of the TGSIs provide assist negotiating difficult owners, as required
See 3.1 of Stage
information to people environments such as by the Building
1 Report
who are blind or open or busy spaces Code of Australia
vision impaired about and finding specific provide TGSIs.
direction and locations such as building
potential hazards. entrances and exits.
1.2 Directional Hand-held aid Usually used in Assists with
compass designed to assist conjunction with a navigation at
orientation and traditional long cane a broad urban
See 4.1 of Stage
navigation by people or guide dog to physical scale.
1 Report
who are blind or navigate about the built
vision impaired. environment at a broader
scale.
1.3 Obstacle Hand-held navigation Assists navigation around Assists with
locator aid to help the built environment by independent
vision-impaired providing feedback on wayfinding,
See 4.2 of Stage
people detect potential obstacles such movement and
1 Report
potential obstacles. as trees, rubbish bins, navigation.
chairs, tables, pot-plants
and A-frame signage.
1.4 Enhanced or Relatively new Used as an alternative to Assists with
specialist cane navigation aid or a traditional long cane, to independent
cane to assist people navigate about the built wayfinding,
See 4.3 of Stage
who are blind or environment, providing movement and
1 Report
vision impaired avoid aural and tactile feedback navigation.
obstacles. about the position of
nearby obstacles.
1.5 Personal Generally small Can easily capture and Assists with recall
Digital hand-held computers playback detailed audio and independent
Assistants or portable electronic and video information wayfinding,
(PDAs) and note takers to store about locations or paths movement and
note takers and process spatial between facilities that a navigation.
and other information person who is blind or
See 4.5 of Stage
that may assist in vision impaired may
1 Report
wayfinding. wish to record for
future reference.
27
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
1.9 Mobile Sophisticated, yet Because SIM cards are Increasingly, these
phones and widely available tracked and automatically devices, with
communicators portable devices ‘located’ by the network, long-life battery
that receive and these devices are power, can provide
See 4.8 of Stage
transmit signals via increasingly being used to users with a range
1 Report
commercial mobile provide location-specific of information about
telecommunication information to users via facilities in an area;
networks. the 3G or ‘next-generation’ however, the user
mobile networks. must be a customer
of a mobile phone
network to receive
general data and
information.
1.10 Accessible Infrastructure Generally linked to traffic Fixed local and
pedestrian provided primarily signals, they are designed state government
signals at pedestrian to provide recognisable infrastructure
crossings and street audio signals to for pedestrian
See 5.1 of Stage
intersections to assist pedestrians in guiding crossings and
1 Report
users determine when them across intersections. street intersections.
it is safe to cross
the street.
1.11 Press and Fixed infrastructure Able to provide specific People who are
listen signs or installed at selected audio information about blind or vision
press-button locations to provide a location (e.g. tourist impaired may not
audible spoken information site) and widely used to realise the ‘sign’
signage about that location provide public transport is available unless
when the button is departure information other means are
See 5.2 of Stage
pressed. to travellers. used to draw their
1 Report
attention to the
availability and
location of the
‘press and
listen’ sign.
29
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
1.14 Remote Information about Useful at key travel Supplement to
(infrared) a location can be decision points or to building locational
audible obtained at a distance provide additional signage; however,
signage rather than by information about the everyone nearby
— motion- touching the sign. immediate surrounding may hear the
activated Has some similarity area. Time-sensitive (repeated) brief
to a press-button messages can also information as all
See 5.5.1 of
system, except the be replayed by a passing pedestrians
Stage 1 Report
recorded information centralised system. will trigger the
playback is triggered message.
by any person Orientation issues
passing the sign, must be considered
rather than by a in the design to
particular pedestrian ensure the user is
finding and pressing located and aligned
the button. appropriately for
the message being
delivered.
1.15 Remote Information is Messages are triggered Can indicate and
(infrared) provided remotely by the user’s handheld, or confirm which
audible rather than by worn, device and relayed direction a visitor
signage — pressing a sign. to them via a receiver or should travel in
speaking signs Single or multiple speakers. Information can to find various
transmitters are be provided from different facilities. Useful
See 5.5.2 of
installed as building directions as the trigger in train and bus
Stage 1 Report
infrastructure device is slowly moved stations, airport
(usually above around. Messages can halls, malls and
head-height) at key be tailored to the specific similar large
travel decision points, location and considered building complexes.
while individual as the audio equivalent of This system may
portable receivers a printed directional sign. be used at, for
(purchased or on example, outdoor
loan from the venue) bus terminals when
must be either worn transport vehicles
or carried about the have transmitters
venue by users. fitted, but it is not
usually used in a
completely open
space where the
location of key
facilities are less
well defined.
31
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
1.18 Enhanced Simplified and The small-scale outlines Must be
location maps scaled location map of buildings or corridors well-positioned
(raised tactile incorporating raised can be traced by touch and accessible
and braille) building outlines, by people who are blind and within reach
raised lettering or or vision impaired to for people who
See 2.3.2 of
braille beneath, or help identify their current are blind or vision
Stage 2–3
within, each area to location within the context impaired or people
Report
designate the name of the surrounding area, who are mobility
or purpose of that while other travellers may impaired. However,
area on the map. also use the map in the some travellers
usual way. can have difficulty
interpreting
maps and may
prefer aural or
printed directions.
Enhanced maps,
similar to signage
that uses symbols,
can be valuable
for illiterate or non-
English speaking
travellers.
1.19 Trail between Series of easily People who are blind or A ‘trail’ should be
one location recognisable vision impaired often use designed to lead a
and another pathways a series of discernible traveller from one
characterised by vertical surfaces to key destination to
See audit
directional tiles, ‘shoreline’ along by using another relatively
checklist
handrails, a long cane, but clearly close destination.
stepping-stones marked and distinctive
or a distinctive trail pathways or handrails can
for example, using provide other options for
particular plants or wayfinding across
water features. open areas.
1.20 On-line digital Computer-based Detailed information This area is
information systems designed generated from user changing rapidly
and maps to provide detailed queries on a spatial with new advances
spatial and location database. This system in mobile internet
See 5.7 of Stage
information to users. needs to be used before technology. See
1 Report
the journey. ‘mobiles and
communicators’.
33
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
1.23 ‘Kiosk’ (or Typically housed in An enhancement of Useful in local
network) of a small kiosk, this the computer directory government
touch-screen computer-based systems, it allows infrastructure,
or audio-based system, with large pedestrians to ask for for example as
computer TV-type screen, can and receive directions to commissioned
systems provide information specific locations for a by Melbourne
and directions for particular destination or City Council for
See 2.4 of Stage
specific locations service. Should provide iHubs, or could be
2–3 Report
in the vicinity. appropriate information provided by owners
The system may and directions for specific of commercial
incorporate large locations in the vicinity venues. Orientation
screen fonts that such as bus or train stops, issues must be
assist people who public toilets, theatres, considered in the
are vision impaired restaurants and even design to ensure
or can produce timetable and the user is located
audio through kiosk ticket information. and aligned
speakers or wirelessly appropriately for
to an individual the message being
receiving device. delivered. Any
screens should be
at an appropriate
height for use by
people who are
vision impaired or
people who are
mobility impaired.
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
2.1 Tactile ground See 1.1 above.
surface
indicators
(TGSIs)
including
directional
indicators
See 3.1 of Stage
1 Report
2.2 Directional See 1.2 above.
compass
See 4.1 of Stage
1 Report
2.3 Obstacle See 1.3 above.
locator
See 4.2 of Stage
1 Report
2.4 Enhanced or See 1.4 above.
specialist cane
See 4.3 of Stage
1 Report
2.5 Personal See 1.5 above.
Digital
Assistants
(PDAs) and
note takers
See 4.5 of Stage
1 Report
2.6 Global See 1.6 above Providing information Pedestrians must
Positioning Most suitable in and locations of key have a suitable GPS
System (GPS) open-air locations landmarks such as major receiver unit, used
position locator without interference. buildings, concert halls, in conjunction with
Combined with other churches, stadiums, specialist software
See 4.4 and
software, can be used transport interchanges, as plus electronic
4.6 of Stage 1
for locating current well as parks and lakes. data depicting
Report
position and other local streets and
landmarks. landmarks for
that area.
35
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
2.7 Talking digital See 1.7 above.
map systems
See 4.6 of Stage
1 Report
2.8 Tactile map See 1.8 above. Tactile maps of
systems specific venues
should be made
See 4.7 of Stage
available by
1 Report
the venue’s
management.
2.9 Mobile See 1.9 above. Starting to provide Users must be
phones and location-specific a customer of
communicators information to users via a mobile phone
the ‘next-generation’ or network to receive
See 4.8 of Stage
3G mobile networks, but information.
1 Report
service is aimed at the
majority of users rather
than adapted for niche
users such as people
who are blind or
vision impaired.
2.10 Accessible See 1.10 above.
pedestrian
signals
See 5.1 of Stage
1 Report
2.11 Press and See 1.11 above. If signs are networked, System acts as
listen signs or then time-specific a supplement to
press-button messages (or ‘live’) locational signage.
audible information such as However, everyone
signage timetable details can be near the sign hears
replayed when the button the brief information
See 5.2 of Stage
is pushed. repeated about
1 Report
that location.
37
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
2.17 Moving See 1.17 above.
illuminated
signage
single and
multi-line
See 3.4.4 of
Stage 2–3
Report
2.18 Enhanced See 1.18 above.
location maps
(raised tactile
and braille)
See 2.3.2 of
Stage 2–3
Report
2.19 Trail across See 1.19 above. Clearly marked and A ‘trail’ should be
forecourt or distinctive pathways or designed to ‘lead’ a
plaza handrails can provide traveller across the
options for wayfinding open space from
See audit
across open areas. one key destination
checklist
to another relatively
close destination.
2.20 On-line digital See 1.20 above.
information
and maps
See 5.7 of Stage
1 Report
2.21 Computer See 1.21 above. Can act as a directory Acts as an
directory board and supplement unattended
information signage in the area. information desk.
system However, it cannot
be read by touching
See 3.4.5 of
the board or screen
Stage 2–3
so it is not suitable
Report
for people who
are blind or who
read tactually.
2.22 Talking lifts See 1.22 above.
See 3.4.6 of
Stage 2–3
Report
39
3.0 Building entrance scale
Range of 5 m, for example, the immediate vicinity and building entrances
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
3.1 Tactile ground See 1.1 above. Directional indicators can
surface assist people who are
indicators blind or vision impaired
(TGSIs) to find their way unaided
including from the street to the
directional building entrance where
indicators other shorelines do
not exist.
See 3.1 of Stage
1 Report
3.2 Obstacle See 1.3 above.
locator
See 4.2 of Stage
1 Report
3.3 Enhanced or See 1.4 above.
specialist cane
See 4.3 of Stage
1 Report
3.4 Personal See 1.5 above.
Digital
Assistants
(PDAs) and
note takers
See 4.5 of Stage
1 Report
3.5 Tactile map See 1.8 above.
systems
See 4.7 of Stage
1 Report
3.6 Press and See 1.11 above. When found and pressed, Other indicators or
listen signs or external audible sign forms of signage
press-button announces address, are needed to
audible building name and alert people who
signage major tenant. are blind or vision
impaired to the
See 5.2 of Stage
availability and
1 Report
specific location of
the press and
listen sign.
41
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
3.11 Remote See 1.15 above. When any transmitter Distinct information
(infrared) Audio equivalent of is ‘triggered’ by a can be provided for
audible location sign. signal received from a different locations
signage — nearby user’s device, but is audible only
speaking signs pre-recorded audio via an individual
information such as receiver held, or
See 5.5.2 of
the building name or a worn, by the user.
Stage 1 Report
welcome message is Users may need
then broadcast wirelessly different types of
by the transmitter to that devices to receive
user’s receiver. information within
different building
complexes.
3.12 Remote See 1.16 above.
Radiofrequency
Audible
Signage
See 5.6 of Stage
1 Report
3.13 Moving See 1.17 above. As noted in 1.17 but with Must be well
illuminated more detail provided positioned and
signage for location signs and suitable for people
single and directory boards. who are vision
multi-line impaired as well as
people with other
See 3.4.4 of
disabilities. Suitable
Stage 2–3
fonts, colour
Report
and background
contrast must be
used. Not suitable
for people who
are blind.
3.14 Enhanced See 1.18 above. Map of raised outlines of Limited additional
location maps entrance or lobby can be information in
(raised tactile, traced by touch by people raised lettering
braille) who are blind or vision or braille may
impaired to assist their further assist the
See 2.3.2 of
orientation and plan their traveller to locate
Stage 2–3
journey. their intended
Report
destination.
43
4.0 Inside building scale
Range of, say, 1–20 m, for example, lobbies, reception area, lift lobbies, corridors and information
desks
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
4.1 Tactile ground See 1.1 above.
surface
indicators
(TGSIs)
including
directional
indicators
See 3.1 of Stage
1 Report
4.2 Obstacle See 1.3 above.
locator
See 4.2 of Stage
1 Report
4.3 Enhanced or See 1.4 above.
specialist cane
See 4.3 of Stage
1 Report
4.4 Personal See 1.5 above.
Digital
Assistants
(PDAs) and
note takers
See 4.5 of Stage
1 Report
4.5 Tactile map See 1.8 above. Braille, tactile or raised Any key facilities
systems maps describing access likely to be
to certain facilities at accessed by a user
See 4.7 of Stage
particular venues. These would need to be
1 Report
maps could be made known in advance
available to those who can and maps then
interpret them to produced, unless
assist in planning they are made
and subsequently available at venues.
undertaking travel.
45
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
4.11 Directional Building infrastructure In an emergency, Most appropriate
sound installed to alert distinctive sound patterns for assisting egress
evacuation occupants in an with a directional from a building
emergency and help emphasis are emitted in an emergency,
See 5.4 of Stage
guide them, using along corridors to assist but not for general
1 Report
sound, towards in guiding sighted and wayfinding around
an exit during an people who are blind or and within a
evacuation. vision impaired towards building complex
an exit. under normal
conditions. Not
suitable for people
who are hearing
impaired.
4.12 Handrail See 3.9 above. Fixed to corridor and Supplementary
system lobby walls to assist tactile, audible or
people who are blind, braille signage may
See 3.4.1 of
vision impaired or mobility be necessary to
Stage 2–3
impaired find their way help confirm that
Report
unaided from one location the user is
to another relatively travelling in the
close location. right direction.
4.13 Remote See 1.14 above. When triggered by nearby Supplement to
(infrared) movement, the audible building location
audible signs plays pre-recorded and directory board
signage messages, listing tenants signage designed
— motion- and the location of to assist people
activated key facilities. who are vision
impaired, but not
See 5.5.1 of
people who are
Stage 1 Report
hearing impaired.
4.14 Remote See 1.15 above. Pre-recorded audio Distinct information
(infrared) information such as the can be provided for
audible location of lifts, toilets and different locations
signage staffed reception desks but it is audible only
speaking signs is broadcast wirelessly via an individual
by transmitter to a worn, or hand-held,
See 5.5.2 of
user’s receiving device. receiver. Currently,
Stage 1 Report
Different message may users may need
be received from different alternative types of
directions allowing the devices to receive
user to discreetly choose information within
the direction they want to different building
travel in. complexes.
47
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
4.20 Computer See 1.21 above. System should provide Suitable for
directory individual listings of unattended
information building tenants, public or ‘faceless’
system facilities and their receptions e.g.
locations within ‘Take lift to Level 3
See 3.4.5 of
the building. then turn left and
Stage 2–3
proceed 20 metres
Report
directly along
corridor. Offices are
on your right’.
4.21 Talking lifts See 1.22 above. Useful to reinforce
warning messages
See 3.4.6 of
that travellers
Stage 2–3
should not use
Report
lifts in the event
of fire or in other
situations as set
out in the building’s
emergency
evacuation
procedures.
4.22 ‘Kiosk’ (or See 1.23 above. Allows pedestrians Could be provided
network) of to obtain appropriate by owners of
touch-screen information and directions individual buildings
or audio-based for specific buildings, or venues, or
computer such as listings of provided as local
systems building tenants and government
public facilities. infrastructure.
See 2.4 of
Users’ spatial
Stage 2–3
orientation must
Report
be considered to
ensure they are
located and aligned
appropriately for the
message
being relayed.
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
5.1 Tactile ground See 1.1 above.
surface
indicators
(TGSIs),
including
directional
indicators
See 3.1 of Stage
1 Report
5.2 Obstacle See 1.3 above.
locator
See 4.2 of Stage
1 Report
5.3 Enhanced or See 1.4 above.
specialist cane
See 4.3 of Stage
1 Report
5.4 Personal See 1.5 above.
Digital
Assistants
(PDAs) and
note takers
See 4.5 of Stage
1 Report
5.5 Tactile map See 1.8 above. Braille or tactile and
systems raised maps outlining key
facilities at an individual
See 4.7 of Stage
floor level may assist
1 Report
people who are vision
impaired, but other
options seem more
appropriate at this scale.
5.6 Mobile See 1.9 above. Other options appear
phones and more appropriate at
communicators this scale.
See 4.8 of Stage
1 Report
49
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
5.7 Press and See 1.11 above. Provided in a lift lobby or Other indicators are
listen signs/ building entrance. When needed to make
press-button pressed, the audible sign sure people who
audible announces information are vision impaired
signage about the nearby area know the specific
such as location of key location of the
See 5.2 of Stage
facilities on the floor. press and
1 Report
listen sign.
5.8 Printed signage See 1.12 above. Directory board providing Should be well
(location signs, listings of the services positioned and
directory and tenants on each floor designed for
boards, etc.) level, plus the general pedestrians with
featuring words direction of many key low vision, but not
or words and amenities and services. suitable for people
symbols who are blind or
vision impaired.
See 2.3.2 of
Raised tactile and
Stage 2–3
braille signage must
Report
be used to assist
these travellers.
5.9 Raised tactile See 1.13 above.
and braille
signage
See 3.2 of Stage
1 Report
5.10 Line-following See 4.10 above. Still in development.
guides
See 5.3 of Stage
1 Report
5.11 Directional See 4.11.
sound
evacuation
See 5.4 of Stage
1 Report
5.12 Handrail See 3.9 above.
systems
See 3.4.1 of
Stage 2–3
Report
51
Wayfinding
Description Application Comments
system
5.18 Trails between See 1.19 above. Pathways leading to and Designed to help
key locations from crucial facilities vision-impaired
such as such as reception, lift pedestrians to
reception, lift lobbies and toilets can locate key
lobby, meeting be highlighted through amenities unaided.
rooms or employing Principles of
tenant offices Universal Design.
See audit
checklist
5.19 On-line digital See 1.20 above. Detailed information such The availability of
information as building floor plans tactile maps at
and maps have to be obtained or individual venues
produced in appropriate may eliminate the
See 5.7 of Stage
form before the journey need to download
1 Report
is undertaken. directional and
wayfinding
information before
attending a venue.
5.20 Computer See 1.21 above. System should provide Suitable for
directory individual listings of reception areas not
information tenants and public always attended
system facilities located on by staff. Not
the floor. appropriate for
See 3.4.5 of
people who rely
Stage 2–3
on reading by
Report
tactual means.
5.21 Talking lifts See 1.22 above.
See 3.4.6 of
Stage 2–3
Report
5.22 ‘Kiosk’ (or See 1.23 above. Systems should allow May be provided
network) of pedestrians to obtain by owners of
touch-screen appropriate information individual buildings
or audio-based and directions for specific or venues. Users’
computer floor levels, such as spatial orientation
systems listings of tenants as well must be considered
as public facilities and to ensure they are
See 2.4 of Stage
conveniences located located and aligned
2–3 Report
on the floor. appropriately for
the message
being relayed.
Wayfinding design
guidelines
Project partners
Government
desks?
rmation nt
ded info Excelle
unatten 5
nes at 4
-hel p pho 3
tion self 1
2
……......
informa
there factory …………
3. Are Unsatis ………… ……..
………… …………
Yes …… ………… …… ………… ……..
…… …… …… ……
No ………… ………… ………… ……..
t: …… ………… ………… …………
system
s, Commen ………… …………
via PA ………… ………… …….. r verb
al
tions ist peo
ple ………… ………… ………… in thei
instruc ts may ass ………… ………… ………… services
………… …………
verbal mp ………… ………… s and
ION through se pro ………… ………… ………… for all
building
UNICAT ertaken ins. The ess ………… names
¬COMM is und water founta D Acc ………… nt
!UDIBLE Section ………… ………… dised Excelle
nication and the BCA with AS1428 ring
.1,
………… standar 5
ible commu ared signs airm ents. with …… k staf f use 4
ve imp comply on and 16: Hea ……
Aud
signs,
infr
cogniti must tion des 3
talking ceptual or mentati clause informa ions? 2
mu nication Hearing aug lding work, 4. Do icat 1
…… ……......
per commun ……
with audible
com t D3.7: New bui , other factory ………… ……..
lly, all ts, par access — system tation Unsatis
uiremen ation ………… …………
Genera ments
for
amplific
men
Yes ………… ………… ……..
ess Req ring aug should
and Egr l require g Systems. inbuilt ere hea d
No ………… ………… …………
Genera as an y. Wh impaire ilable must ………… ………… ………… ..
part 1: tation Listenin tation’ es onl t: …… ………… …………
augmen g purpos hearing is ava Commen …………
Augmen ‘hearing ncy warnin who are ring device for ………… ………… …………
people symbol does ………… ………… ………… ……..
defines assist istive
hea tional ………… …………
rge
The BCA used for eme system to that an ass interna ning system also ………… …………
for the st ………… ………… …………
than one d, a listenin
g
icating uire ments Where the
liste
area mu ………… ………… …… ………… nt
ind req ce. of the …… …… Excelle
is req
uire le. A sign e with the losed spa ndaries ………… ………… 5
availab ordanc to the enc the bou re ………… ………… 4
also be in acc rs space, ply whe s — …… ut? 3
vided n doo losed …………
……
ible outp 2
be pro the mai a of the enc also com m system ......
ss at s must rco interco
m have aud 1
…………
fne tota l are tem inte all lifts factory …………
dea
er the on sys trol and systems and trol and 5. Do Unsatis
..
not cov ated. unicati g, con nd con ………… …………
ign inte rcomm on, warnin t 4: Sou ning, on
Yes ………… …… ………… ..
des g and ecti ing, par
ection,
war unicati …… ……
be
warnin 670.4 Fire det mission rcomm
No ………… ………… …………
ency Fire det 4: Inte ………… ………… …………
Emerg AS1 and com AS4428.4 , part t: …… ………… ……..
with tion and ipm ent
ding or Commen ………… …………
ble,
applica design, inst
alla
poses ing equ the buil ………… ………… ………… ..
ncy pur and indicat s near ………… ………… ………… ………… 8:
System for emerge
Con trol cros sing ………… ………… ………… ………… bilities,
section
.
s
system systems — poses. estrian ………… ………… ………… with disa
Travel
Direction
ncy pur the ped Excelle
nt ………… ………… ………… persons ation of
used at
m lities for
interco for emerge uttons 5 ………… ………… 12: Faci 8.5: Indic
system
s
push-b 4 ………… ………… s part
on and
clause
tactile 3 ………… and mov
ing walk
Infor mati
audible 2 ...... …………
…… s ible nt
1. Are 1
………… 12 Lifts
, esca
lator
matic
Aud
? Excelle
8.1: Auto ntly loud 5
space? factory ………… .. AS1735. clause icie 4
Unsatis ………… ………… Current
on, part
icula rly
r and
suff 3
Yes ………… ………… Infor mati ut clea 2
………… ………… …… …….. ible outp 1
…… ……......
No …… …… …… aud ……
………… ………… ………… 6. Is the factory ………… ……..
t: …… ………… …….. Unsatis
Commen ………… ………… ………… …………
………… ………… …………
Yes ………… ………… ……..
………… ………… …….. ………… …………
………… ………… ………… lity
No …………
………… ………… ………… the faci ………… ………… ………… ..
………… ………… ………… iliar with t: …… ………… ………… …………
………… ………… are fam Commen ………… ………… …………
………… nts who ………… ………… ……..
………… ………… attenda ………… …………
………… ………… Excelle
nt ………… ………… …………
helpful ………… ………… …………
………… fed by 5
………… …………
………… des ks staf 3
4 ………… …… …… ……
informa
tion 2 ………… …………
2. Are 1
…… ……...... ………… …………
ut? …… ……
layo factory ………… ……..
……
Unsatis …………
………… …………
Yes ………… ………… ……..
No ………… ………… ………… 35
………… ………… ………… ..
t: …… ………… ………… …………
Commen ………… ………… ………… ..
………… ………… ………… …………
………… ………… ………… …………
………… ………… …………
………… …… ………… …………
……
………… ……
………… …………
…… …………
…………
tem audit
ding sys
Wayfin
34
November 2007
Established and
supported under
the Australian
Government’s
Cooperative
Research Centres
Program
ISBN 978-0-9804262-9-8