Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MPR Paper033105
MPR Paper033105
MPR Paper033105
Table 2
Arrester Description High Current- kArms Low current-Amps
3-15 kV Rated Station 25 kA or 65 kA 400-600
21-684 kV Rated Station 25 kA or 40 kA 400-600
3-120 kV Rated Intermediate 16.1 kA 400-600
The task of measuring energy capability From the early 1950s though the late
is not nearly as simple for gapped SiC 1970s, utilities typically selected gapped
arresters utilizing current limiting gaps. SiC Station Class arresters for
The voltage developed across (and the applications requiring the best available
energy absorbed by) the gap-SiC block (lowest) arrester protective levels. These
combination is the sum of the IR drop arresters provided the largest margin of
across the block and the arc voltage protection for equipment insulation.
developed inside the gap arc chambers. High fault current locations might also
have necessitated the higher pressure block structure, grading current
relief capability of Station versus measurements only confirm the
Intermediate Class arresters. electrical integrity of the grading circuit.
An arrester mounted on an insulating
While the gapped silicon-carbide arrester subbase with a grading current meter
designs have, in general, had a very attached to the ground connection would
good service history, utilities are allow grading current monitoring while
continuing to evaluate their overvoltage the arrester is in service.
protection needs, in particular at
locations that are currently protected by Another option for an arrester that is
gapped silicon-carbide arresters. Once installed, but not energized, is to use a
they identify locations and types of Meggar or Doble test set to measure the
arresters, they need to identify arrester’s resistance or watts loss,
manufacturer and arrester type and respectively. These reduced voltage test
catalog number (vintage) stamped on the sets have traditionally proved to be
arrester nameplate. This is the first step effective in detecting arresters with
in determining the performance moisture ingress problems.
characteristic of the arrester.
While the above described techniques
VII. SiC Arrester Integrity Issue are effective at identifying an arrester in
service that might have damage to its
Determination of the operating condition grading circuit or possibly moisture
of a gapped SiC arrester can involve ingress concerns, they do not allow an
various methodologies. If the arrester is evaluation of the condition of the
in service and cannot easily be removed, arrester gaps or blocks. This can best be
infrared techniques can be used to assure accomplished by removing the arrester
that the arrester is not operating hot, a from its service location and sending to a
sign of degradation. Since larger high voltage laboratory. Performing
arresters may not be perfectly graded routine power frequency sparkover,
due to external capacitive upset, hot grading current, and IIV/PD tests are an
spots at the top end might represent a excellent first step to determining the
normal arrester. condition of the entire arrester. IEEE
Standard C62.1-1984 required that
Typically, gapped SiC station and station arrester rated 60 kV and above
intermediate arresters were constructed had a minimum allowed 60 Hz
with a resistive or resistive/capacitive sparkover of 1.35 times rating. Similarly,
grading circuit. This grading circuit, for station and intermediate designs
external to the gap-block stack, below 60 kV rating, a minimum allowed
improved the arrester sparkover 1.5 times rating was acceptable.
characteristic and performance under Sparkover levels below these required
contaminated environmental conditions. minimums could identify an arrester
At system operating voltage, these with a degraded sparkover characteristic.
arresters typically conducted up to a few
milliamperes of grading current. Since
arrester grading current at operating
voltage does not flow through the gap-
VIII. SiC Protection Issue originally installed SiC arresters. In the
unlikely event that one of these arresters
A utility with early vintage gapped SiC would fail, the excessive fault current
arresters could be afforded significantly could cause a violent failure of the
improved protection by replacing them arrester.
with MOV designs. As Table 1 showed,
the replacement of late model gapped Duquesne Light Company had such a
SiC designs will also provide situation several years ago at a
measurable margin improvements. As substation originally equipped with
the primary function of the arrester is to Intermediate Class SiC arresters, which
protect system equipment insulation at the time they were installed, had a
from being damaged by overvoltages short circuit capability sufficient to the
occurring on the line, it is critical that location. Multiple circuit upgrades and
the utility understand that margin interconnections resulted in available
improvements can be achieved by line-to-ground fault currents at this
conversion to MOV arrester designs. substation above 40 kA, well exceeding
Armed with SiC arrester nameplate the original 16 kA capability of the SiC
information, the utility has the intermediate arresters. While the
opportunity to obtain catalog protection customer was tolerant of the high
data on the subject arresters from the protective levels of the intermediate SiC
manufacturers. Comparison with the arresters, he ultimately replaced these
catalog discharge voltage data on MOV with new MOV arresters with pressure
arresters, margin improvements can be relief capability adequate to the location
determined. Combined with information (4).
on the dielectric integrity and criticality
of equipment adjacent to these arresters, X. TLD/Energy Capability Issue
the utility can make an informed
decision regarding the merits of The TLD energy absorbing capability of
replacing these SiC with MOV type gapped SiC arresters assembled with CL
arresters. gaps is a function of the design of the
valve block and gap assembly. The SiC
IX. Short Circuit Issue valve block, by design, limits the
magnitude of the TLD surge current that
Over the last 50 years, utilities have will flow through the arrester to a
continued to upgrade their quality and “critical” level. This “critical” current
level of service. Grids have been should not exceed the “critical” current
interconnected and fault current levels capability of the series connected gap. If
have significantly increased over what the magnitude exceeds this “critical”
was originally expected at various level, the gap may not be able to
locations. While SiC arresters may have successfully develop arc voltage,
had adequate pressure relief capability ultimately resulting in valve block
for the locations where the arresters were failure.
installed, system upgrades may have
caused the available fault currents at TLD tests performed on a 258 kV rated
some arrester locations to a level that Station Class gapped SiC arrester,
exceeds the designed capability of the applied on a 345 kV system, indicate
that the arrester discharges assistance to utilities concerned with
approximately 4.4-4.6 kV/kV rating per maintaining the quality of their HV
shot at an initial current level of about 1 surge protection, ultimately resulting in a
kA. Similar tests were performed on a high level of service reliability.
gapless 258 kV rated metal oxide
arrester. The resultant energy absorbed XII. References
per shot on this design was also about
4.6 kJ/kV rating at about 830 amps. For (1) IEEE Guide for the Application of
the TLD testing required by the C62.1 Gapped Silicon-Carbide Surge Arresters
and C62.11 Standards, both arresters met for Alternating Current Systems
the 20 shot durability requirement while ANSI/IEEE Std C62.22-1987.
discharging similar energy levels. (2) American National Standard Surge
Arresters for Alternating-Current Power
The energy capability difference Circuits IEEE Std 28-1974/ANSI C62.1-
between the two designs shows up at 1975.
higher current levels than are required on (3) IEEE Standard for Metal-Oxide
the standard TLD test. Because the gap Surge Arresters for AC Power Circuits
critical current is close to that required in (>1 kV) IEEE Std C62.11-1999
the TLD test, the gapped SiC arrester (4) Proceedings of the 1991 IEEE Power
energy discharge capability, at the Engineering Society Transmission and
defined waveshape, is, in reality, limited Distribution Conference , Sept 22-27,
to that shown on the TLD test. In 1991, in Dallas, Texas. Pages 424-431,
contrast, the gapless MOV arrester’s entitled “Utilization of Polymer
capability is strictly a function of the Enclosed Intermediate Class Arresters to
energy absorbing capability of the metal Improve the Performance of Modern
oxide discs. Domestically produced HV Power Systems”, authored by Dennis W.
station class MOV arresters typically Lenk, Joseph L. Koepfinger, and John D.
claim energy capabilities exceeding Sakich.
twice those demonstrated by the SiC
arresters on the TLD test. XIII. Bibliography
Bulletin EU-1542