Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mexitronica PDF
Mexitronica PDF
com
2
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Purpose:
All information presented in this conference is focused in “Solving Process
Problems” that we have day to day in Flextronics. Using Six Max
Methodologies for existing processes (DMAIC).
Scope:
Based on Laser Soldering Process for SMT connectors that can not be
processed in Reflow Oven because of the plastic properties, they can not
support high temperatures beyond 150°C. Also, the q uantity of connector pins
(200, 300, 400) does not guarantee an acceptable quality soldering by hand.
This project was developed on Flextronics Campus South in Building Five.
3
4
Laser Soldering Process
Six
SixSigma
SigmaProject
Project Project
ProjectDescription:
Description:
Department:
Department:D&ED&EGuadalajara
GuadalajaraSite
Site –The top detractor (Solder Empty Defect in J1
–The top detractor (Solder Empty Defect inGDL,
J1 is
Connector)
Connector) for
forthe
theCustomer
Customer ininFlextronics
Flextronics GDL, is
Review # R0
Review # R0 generating
generatingananunstable
unstableprocess
process with
withaaCPK
CPK ofof 0.7
0.7
(Laser
(LaserSoldering
SolderingProcess).
Project
ProjectTitle:
Title:Laser
LaserSoldering
SolderingProcess
Process Process).
Project
ProjectLeader:
Leader:Enrique
EnriqueDuarte
Duarte
Customer Issue:
2.5% 17.0%
55.6%
Project
ProjectGoal:
Goal:Reduce
ReduceDefects
Defectsfrom
from2.5%
2.5%to
to Project
ProjectResults:
Results:Defects
Defectsreduced
reducedto
toless
less
0.5%.
0.5%.To
Toprobe
probeififthe
themachine
machineisiscapable
capablewith
with than
than0.5%.
0.5%.The
Themachine
machineisisnot
notcapable
capableto
to
customer requirements
customer requirements . . work with customer requirements
work with customer requirements ..
5
Laser Soldering Process
What is the High Level Problem? and Why Is It Important? , Who Are Customers
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
and Stakeholders?
:
ol s
To
r o ces
s M ap
H
.
elp
. VOC
•P l
n ic a s.
e c h hart
•T C .
r e tos D iag
•P a
on
e
m ent
B ve
sh pr o
•F i I m
ic k
• Qu
Escapes
Escapesto
toChina
China, ,ItItcauses
causesproblems
problemsfunctions
functionsin
inCustomer
Customerproducts
products&&
Operations
Operationslineslinesin
inFlextronics
FlextronicsGuadalajara.
Guadalajara.
6
Laser Soldering Process
How many connector families will be involved?, What are the projected business
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
YES
$$$
Frecuency= 100% (Families UN's, TN's and KBN's)
Solder Wire Consumption per board= 0.30 grs (Kester Solder Wire P/N 00500098)
Description Sec Opr-Hour-cost (Dlls) Opr-sec-cost (Dlls) Total cost (Dlls) Facilities (10%) Total (Dlls)
Flextronics is loosing
Touch-Up time(Second time)=
Inspector time (Second time)=
120
120
3.66
6.42
0.001016667
0.001783333
0.122
0.214
0.0122
0.0214
0.1342
0.2354
0.3696
200k usd per year
Description
Solder Wire=
Cost per gr. (Dlls)
0.48
Consumption per board (grs)
0.3
Total (Dlls)
0.144
because of the problems
Production per Year (include all families)= 180000
GRAND TOTAL PER BOARD (DLLS)= 0.5136
generated in laser
PCB's burned per year =
PCBA Cost per Unit (USDollar) =
104
1200
Amountof Loss per
soldering process.
Year(Dlls)= $217,248.00
7
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Basic Understanding LSP, Mode: “Continuos Pad” Basic Understanding LSP, Mode: “Continuos Pad”
ed PARAMETERS TO
(Models: “A) (Models: “B”) Spe PostHeat
Beam Power A rm CONTROL:
off PARAMETERS TO
PARAMETERS TO 15.-Arm Speed(mm/sec)
CONTROL:
CONTROL:
1.- D1
1.- D1 2.- φ RevF
d
2.- φ Softbeam 3.- Pwr0(watts) Pre-heat Softbeam
3.- Beam Power(watts) Laser Light 4.-Beam Diam (mm) Laser Light
s
in
(x2,y2,z2)
ig th e
RevLn
n e tta
NOISE: NOISE:
Suspipe
ee
Sp
Φ φ
t
bo
r e
Origin r Wi α
Ro
Y=
Y=Solder
Solderempty,
empty,X’s
X’s==Connectors
ConnectorsAssembly,
Assembly,Machine
MachineParameters,
Parameters,Quality
Qualityinspection.
inspection.AAplanning
planning
was established to attack the problem: 2 phases (Machine validation & Process Control).
was established to attack the problem: 2 phases (Machine validation & Process Control).
8
Laser Soldering Process
Can we Understand better how the Laser Machine works? Lets see some videos…
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Laser characteristics….
Approximate beam diameter: 0.7mm a 3.0mm
Wavelength: 920nm a 960nm
Max Power or Energy: 4w to 60w
9
Laser Soldering Process
Model: “A” Beam Power
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
off
PARAMETERS TO
CONTROL:
1.- D1
2.- φ
3.- Beam Power(watts) Laser Light
s
in
4.-Beam Diam (mm)
n) p
(x2,y2,z2)
ig th e
5.-Wait Time. (sec) Pre-heat Pre-heat
Soldering
D d to
6.- (x,y,z) Beam Diam PCB
or e
es
ct ch
n e tta
NOISE:
on s a
(C ar i
Beam
.-Clamps
B
er
.- PCB Color
ld
So
.- PCB Thickness
.- Bent Pins or misaligment
Power
D1 .- Residuos
P)
(C
ed
pe
tS
Φ
bo
Ro
Origin
(x1,y1,z1)
PARAMETERS TO 7.-Robot Speed CP (mm/sec)
CONTROL:
10
Laser Soldering Processeed Model: “B” PostHeat PARAMETERS TO
p
Ar mS CONTROL:
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
PARAMETERS TO
CONTROL: 15.-Arm Speed(mm/sec)
1.- D1
2.- φ RevF
d
3.- Pwr0(watts) Pre-heat
4.-Beam Diam (mm) Laser Light
5.-Tpre (sec)
6.- Pwr1(watts) Feed Feed
Pre-heat (x2,y2,z2)
Beam Diam PCB
RevLn
NOISE: PARAMETERS TO 16.- Pwr2(watts) Postheat
.-Clamps CONTROL: 17.- Tpst(sec)
.- PCB Color 18.- RevFd (mm/sec)
.- PCB Thickness 19.- RevLn(mm)
.- Bent Pins or misaligment 20.- Tdly(sec)
D1 .- Residuos
Suspipe
Origin φ r Wir
e
α
ld e
So Diam
w
Feed
Wire Adjust 7.- (x,y,z) 11.-Feed (mm/sec)
(x1,y1,z1)
PARAMETERS TO 8.- D2 12.-Solder Wire Diam
CONTROL: 9.- α 13.-Wire Adjust (mm)
D2 10.- w 14.-Tmov (sec)
11
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
X1 = Solder Wire
X2 = Parameters (pw0-watts, pw1-watts, pw2-watts, Tpre-sec, Tmov-sec,Tdly-sec,
Tpst-sec, Arm Speed-mm/sec, Feed-mm/sec, Diameter, RevFn-mm/sec, RevLn-mm,
Y= Solder Empty
Y = Discrete Data
(Atributes)
12
13
Laser Soldering Process
ls :
Too
.
R. s Z st
R & is y
a ge A nal
• G ty
p a b ili
•Ca
Gage R&R Study (This study was made only for operators R&R Study. Results
because of LSP machine doesn’t have automatic inspection)
Attribute Agre e me n t Wo rk S he e t
A preliminary Gage R&R study was done to identify quickly all the Parameter SOLDER EMPTY
Performed By G Barajas & E Duarte
improvements to guarantee the acceptable inspection criteria.
Known Population RAMON MAURA FELIPE Y/N Y/N
Sample # Expert Tri al 1 Trial 2 Tri al 3 Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3 Trial 1 Tri al 2 Trial 3 Agree Agree
In this case 10 pieces were utilized of model A and only the top 10TR
9TR
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
N
Y
N
Y
sides were inspected. Current microscope which is available in 8TR
7TR
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Y
Y
Y
Y
Note:
Y = Discrete Data Operators
Operatorsneed
needtotobe
bere-trained
(1) If % Appraiser Score is low training needs to occur, focus on specific areas (within inspector error)
re-trained
(2)
(3)
% Score vs. Expert is an error against known population as deemed by experts
>90% is the target for Screen % Effectiveness Score
(Atributes) The overall efficiency of all the included inspectors with respect to each other
(4) Screen % Effective vs. Expert is an error against a known population as deemed by the experts
The overall efficiency of all the included inspectors with respect to external standard
14
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
2.5
DPMO’s = 1500
DPMO’s = 17667
1.5 A B
CP = 0.70 CP = 0.99
Good Control
1.0 Category of
&
Worldwide Class!
Poor Technology
0.5
1 2 3 4 5 6
Zst (Thecnology)
15
Laser Soldering Process
Profiling...
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Connector
PCB
side view
Connector Bottom side
297°C
274°C
250°C
16
Laser Soldering Process
Thermocouple Attachment...
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
pad pad
pcb pcb
Avoid the
pad shadow pad
pcb pcb
Thermocouple
17
Laser Soldering Process
A good recomendation to use the proper
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Soldering By Hand...
equipment for profiling Laser soldering
process....
Soldering By Laser...
18
19
Laser Soldering Process
ls:
Too Chi
t est (
si s
p o the
•Hy are).
Squ ts.
x plo
• Bo ms
t o gra
s
• Hi
Ho is rejected, while Ha is
accepted
Shift
ShiftA2
A2detect
detectthe
themajor
majorquantity
quantityof
ofdefects.
defects.Laser’s
Laser’smachines
machineshave
havebetter
better
performance
performancethan
thanXenon
Xenonmachine.
machine.
20
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
21
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
100
90 0.7mm Beam Diam
80
70
60
50
40
30 TOP BOTTOM
20
Not all the pins are covered with the same temperature
10 by beam diameter.
0
1
16
31
46
61
76
91
106
121
136
151
166
181
196
211
226
241
256
271
286
Every point means distance of each pin to the reference line.
22
23
Laser Soldering Process
How Do I Close the Gap Between Current and Desired Performance? (Critical Xs)
n
Softbeam Parameters (X’s) r
iz atio cp Arm po
we
im chi
m Sp e
O pt
pw
-m ed-m am
– agu nate
d Ln F eed-mm/sec m/se be
2-
E T io Di Re v c
w
O t c,
rac
c
D am e
at
s
e
t -
– EF Tes
v
ts
/s
et
ts
o
pw
O er Tm
Tdl
m
D it y
-wat
l
mal
m
e
0-
– on i r
Nor
w
ecti
n-
y-s
rW ec
re-s
at
vF
S e
pw 1
– ss d $5000 usd
ts
l p
ec
o T
Cro Tpst-sec
Re
S
– was the
IMC investment
DOE
–
for these
DOE’s
cp
variables the study to be chose is a
am
Two
TwoVariables
Variablesare
areCritical
CriticalX’s
X’s(Beam
(BeamPower
Power&&CP).
CP).Temperatures
Temperaturespeaks
peakswere
werereduced
reducedtotoavoid
avoidburnings.
burnings.
24
Laser Soldering Process
Can We Confirm the Solution on a Small Test?
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Tranfer Funtion:
No Of Defects = 10.000 + 3.500 Y -2.625 Z -5.250 Arm Speep PTP -4.000 Arm
Speed CP + 3.500 Beam power + 1.375 PCB Solvent -2.375 Y*Z -4.000 Y*Arm Speed
PTP -6.000 Y*Arm Speed CP + 4.250 Y*Beam Power + 2.625 Y*PCB Solvent + ei
Reducing variation
Run Confirmation:
Master Program
159
Defects Before Vs After DOE
100
87
Defects
90
decreased
Quantity of Defects
80 75
70
UN’s 60 63%
50 42
40
30
17
20
TN’s
10
0
Solder Bridge Solder Bridge Solder Empty Solder Empty
62
(Before Doe) (After DOE) (Before DOE) (After DOE)
Type of Defect
Small
Smalltest
testafter
afterimprovements
improvementsconfirmed
confirmedthat
thatfor
forUN’s
UN’swewehave
havedefects
defectsreduction
reduction
inin93%
93%(Zst
(Zst==2.10
2.10toto3.03.
3.03.For
ForTN’s
TN’swe
wehave
havedefects
defectsreduction
reductioninin77%.
77%.(Zst
(Zst==
2.97
2.97toto3.40.
3.40.
Based
Basedon
onthe
thenew
newparameters
parameterswe
wegenerated
generatedaaMaster
MasterProgram
Programon
onthe
theMachine.
Machine.
25
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Eliminating “burnings”
Connector top side
This is an example when
some plastic residuos are
Connector left over the pins and the
PCB laser burns them. The
side view
Connector Bottom side reaction is very high, then
the pcb catches a high
temperature (783°C) to be
burned.
297°C
274°C
250°C
–Theorically reflow process (tin-lead) window for SMT assembly describes: 60 secs
must be sufficient over 183°C to get peaks of temper ature between 217°C – 230°C.
–Wave Soldering Process has a work window of: 1.5 – 3 secs with peaks of 255°C.
PROCESS
WINDOW
Then we can conclude that PCB is designed to resist at least the 246°C (0.8 sec)
same work window than Wave Soldering Process and 225°C (0.8 sec)
temperatures above this process window could damage the pcb
(FR4) generating “burnings”.
Making small changes in the master program obtained of last IMC study
DOE study, we have reduced these temperature peaks in order to
work with values less 255°C (0.8sec). See the next slides to note Intermetalic joint study and
the differences with the results. cross section were performed to
asure that acceptables ranges
are achieved.
26
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
27
28
Laser Soldering Process
out of
Points
•SP
control!!!
•Gr
C
• Hi
ap
st
h
o
s
g
Too
“P”
ram
ls:
Improvements.
Laser Soldering Process
process
performance.
overtime data
We registered
Collection data is needed by Machine, yield, shift, type of defects, type of material, in order to identify
Improvements.
15 00
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
15 00
to work. /0 7 /0 7
1 /2 1 /2
22 00 22 00
/0 7
softbeam
/0 7 1 /2
1 /2
29 00 29 00
/0 7 /0 7
1 /2 1 /2
05 00 05 00
/0 7 /0 7
2 /2 2/
12 00 12 2 00
/0 7 /0 7
specified low
2 /2 2/
19 00 19 2 00
/0 7 /0 7
2 /2 2/
and high limits
machines were
26 00 26 2 00
/0 7 /0 7
2 /2 2/
master program
05 2 00
will be available.
05 00
/0 7 /0 7
deleted. Only the
3 /2 3/
20
12 00 12 07
/0 7 /0
3 /2 3/
20
19 00 19 07
/0 7 /0
3
3 /2 /2
26 00 26 00
/0 7 /0 7
3 /2 3 /2
02 00 02 00
/0 7 /0 7
4 /2 4 /2
09 00 09 00
/0 7 /0 7
4/ 4 /2
20
Date
16 00
D ate
16
/0
07 /0 7
4/ 4 /2
20 23 00
23
/0
07 /0 7
4/ 4 /2
30 2 00 30 00
/0 7 /0 7
4/ 4 /2
07 2 00 07 00
/0 7 /0 7
5/ 5 /2
2 14 00
How Will Critical Xs be Controlled?
14 00
/0 7 /0 7
5/ 5 /2
21 2 00 21 00
/0 7 /0 7
5/ 5 /2
De fe cts Reported from China (J1 Conne ctor)
2 0
Defects Reported from China (J1 Connector)
28 00 28 07
/0 7 /0
5/ 5 /2
04 2 00 04 00
/0 7 /0 7
6/ 6 /2
11 2 00 11 00
/0 7 /0 7
6/ 6 /2
18 2 00 18 00
/0 7 /0 7
6/ 6 /2
25 2 00 25 00
/0 7 /0 7
6/ 6/
20 20
07 07
29
Laser Soldering Process
machines)
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
LASER 1
Connector Inspection Final Inspection QA Pieces
Produced
YIELD
as needed.
A1 LASER 2
XENON
LASER 1
B1 LASER 2
XENON
LASER 1
A2 LASER 2
XENON
LASER 1
B2 LASER 2
XENON
Beam ó PW1
FECHA
MAQUINA
TURNO
Tmov
Ing
Feed
Tdly
Proc. X1 Y1 Y2 Z W X2 Y3 Y4
HORA Modelo
30
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
d
three months Laser Light
ee
Beam On
,F
Pwr 0 RevFd (300)/10: Es la
d
ee
velocidad the
Sp
retracción en
Z + (64.50)
of data Pw
1,
r
RevLn
RevLn (20)/10: Es la
distancia en mm
mm/seg con la
que la
soldadura es
retirada del Beam Power (14-16):
con la que la último pin. Es la potencia en
Z + (68.25)
retirada del último lo largo de todos
pin. los pines.
calculate e
Suspipe CP(2.6 – 3.0): Es la velocidad en
mm/seg con la que el
robot se desplaza a lo W
Wir largo de todos los pines.
lder
confidence So
w (60.26)
31
Laser Soldering Process
PDF Created with deskPDF PDF Writer - Trial :: http://www.docudesk.com
Thank you !
32