Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BRSM Form 009 QMSMDD
BRSM Form 009 QMSMDD
BRSM
Systems: ISO 9001:2008 QMSMDD ISO 13485 (2003)-OHSAS 18001:2007‐ISO 14001:2004
Assessment Report/Checklist
Form 009
CLIENT‐ORGANIZATION (NAME): Mehran Teb Med
PHYSICAL LOCATION(s): No 107, 8th Eastern St, Farvardin BLVD, Safa Dasht,
Industrial Zone, Shahriyar, Iran
Stage II Audit Date(s): 26 to 28 Jan 2016
Stage I Audit Date(s): 3 Jan 2016
NAICS (or NACE) CODE 32.5/ Non‐active medical devices other than specified
above (MD0404), Active devices for patient
positioning and transport (MD1109)
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
We pursuit to assure that client‐organization adheres to the protection of communities and consumers. This is to
1 follow the intent to the substitution of the word “identify” to the word “determine” as part of the importance to
the processes being capable of achieving desired outputs (including consumer’s well‐being).
According to Q/M/02:
Design, Manufacturing, Sales and after Sale Services in the field of Hospital
Furniture including Beds, Stretchers, over bed tables, Trolleys, Cabinets was
observed.
2 Scope of activities
Outsourced processes are : Calibration, sewing of mattress cover , produce of
dresser from ABS material , framework of trolley, over bed table and
dresser/cabinet
Excluded clauses are : 7.5.1.3/7.5.1.2.2/7.5.2.2/7.5.3.2.2/7.5.4
MOH (IMED) requirements for production of class A,B
Legal status
products
3 BS 1694:1990, ISIRI 10339 , BS 5402:1976 , BS 2838-1:1988
Obligatory applicable standard
which organization has to follow
, BS 2838-2:1991 , BS 2881:1989 , IEC60601-2-38,
IEC60601-1-2
4 Quality Management System
Process of organization observed in: F/Q/24 and are:
Production-preventive and maintenance-quality control-sale-
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
after sales service-warehouse-health and safety-training-
Does the organization establish, document, management-quality assurance-design-purchasing.
implement, maintain and continually improve a
Quality Management System (QMS) with due
Interaction between processes defined in F/W/06.
consideration given to identification of HR,
processes needed for the QMS and their
application throughout the system;
Index : average of personnel staying at company
determination of sequence and interaction of Responsible: MD
4.1
these processes, determination of criteria and
methods required to ensure effective operation
Inputs: information, human resource, feedback
and control of these processes; availability of Output: motivation, penalty, encouragement
resources and information required to support
the operation and monitoring of processes;
Control of documents and records had defined in FTS-WP-
measurement, monitoring and analysis of the 005
processes; implementation of action to achieve
planned results and continual improvement Technical files for productions documented and observed.
‐If any, are the outsourced processes are They are according to MOH requirements.
defined?
the organization has established, documented, implemented
and maintains and continually improves EMS and OHSAS
systems
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 2 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 3 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 4 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
The organization established a procedure for risk/aspect evaluation:
Risk and environmental aspects is identify in each activities and work
units including:
Warehouse, production (cutting, welding, coating, assembling,
packaging and delivery), admin, QC activities.
Is there a procedure for The method used is FMEA including severity, occurrence and
identifying environmental detective.
aspects relevant to the Acceptable RPN is 50 for each Risk and environmental aspects.
activities, processes, e.g for significant environmental aspects and risks:
1‐ To work safely with the machine> RPN:40‐
products, and services of the
Action for control: use safety equipment
4.3.1
organization, et all
2‐ Well earth and risk electrocution> RPN: 36
considering risk? Action control: periodic assessment to check the well
and 3‐ Painting and fan filter exhaust.> RPN: 32
Hazard identification, risk Action control: periodic change the filter and measuring exhaust in
assessment and determining annually
controls
All significant environmental aspects and risks are evaluated since
2009 and there are not any residual significant environmental aspects
and risks.
The entire legal requirement is identified according to procedure.
‐ labor office regulation
‐ waste management, Environmental Protection Agency
‐ Self‐declaration environmental
Legal Requirements and
4.3.2
Others
‐ Protection of public workshops procedures
‐ TLV requirements
‐ environmental codex
The organization used those requirements to evaluation of risk and
significant aspects
4.4 Environmental/ Oh&S implementation and operation
the organization With regard to its environmental aspects and
Communication environmental management system established, implement and
maintained a procedure for internal communication among the
various levels and functions of the organization and receiving,
4.4.3
4.4.3.2 documenting and responding to relevant communication from
external interested parties and Communication with contractors
Participation and
consultation and other visitors to the workplace.
The HSE expert was responsible to make those communications.
The organization make some operational control for which significant
aspect and risk that was out of range. We check some example:
‐ Well earth approved with “Imen faraz mehr co.” for 3 well at
94/10/19(Jan) –report ID: 94/639, the test method is: fall‐of‐poetical.
‐ Preparation the PM for painting system. This program has a plan for
4.4.6 Operational control changing back filters.
‐ Contract for transferring chemical waste.
‐ We can see warning signage in Throughout of the organization.
e.g: use the safety equipment, eye glass…
‐ MSDS for Ferro Phosphate is available.
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 5 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
There is no record for accident.
For emergency situation in workshop, there are many bran new first
aid boxes.
4.4.7 Emergency preparedness The emergency preparedness procedure observed.
and response Earth quick and fire mock at 94/7/15 (Oct) observed. This Maneuver
had to approach: environment and Oh&S
They have developed an annually plan for Maneuvers.
4.5 Checking
The organization establishes, implement and maintain a procedure to
Environmental/ Performance
monitor and measure significant environmental impact/OH&S
4.5.1 Monitoring and performance on a regular basis.
Measurement To monitoring/measuring the significant environmental impact/OH&S
performance, the organization uses some checklists. To name Fire
Evaluation and Compliance inspection, restaurant, rest rooms, assembly unit, ergonomic
4.5.2.1 situations, admin aria and warehouse.
a‐ labor office mandatory periodic clinical test for 93/10/9 (Jan‐15)
Consistent with its commitment to
compliance observed. The last test report not received yet. HSE expert check and
analyze that result for Biennial. Record of analyze for 92 and 93
observed.
b‐ Measure of Harmful factors at workshop including: sound(max 85
4.5.2 db), light(max 200 Lux), ray, oil mist, particle and ergonomic.
4.5.2.2 According to report all the factors is in range. For some place the staff
needs to use the safety equipment.
Evaluation of Compliance with other
Also, monitoring and measuring the environmental factor is in range.
requirements the organization
subscribes to BOD: 35 / 50
COD: 90 / 100
Not only that factor is in the range, but also according to test report
result, we can see the evaluation of compliance. We can name range
of particle, light, noise and radiations.
The organization established, implemented and maintained a
procedure for dealing with actual and potential nonconformity and for
taking corrective action and preventive action.
4.5.3.1 They used that procedure for covered Evaluation and Compliance and
4.5.3 make a decision for bad situations.
Incident investigation
Record: to Decrease noise in polishing process, they have issued a
corrective action to buy a new machine.
There is no record for accident yet.
5 Management responsibility
MANAGEMENT COMMITTMENT
Has the top management ensured that
requirement for meeting customer conditions Top management communicated requirement for meeting
and legal conditions should be understood by all customer conditions and legal conditions to personal by
5.1
personnel?
Is a quality policy available? weekly meetings. quality policy is available in production line
Are quality objectives available? and office. Management review has established and holds
Is management review established?
Does the management provide required sources annually. Equipments for production processes provided.
for QMS?
CUSTOMER FOCUS
Does top management have methodologies to
Methodology to customer relation has determined such as :
5.2 ensure that customer needs and expectations
are determined and met for increasing customer feedback forms.
customer satisfaction?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 6 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 7 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
MANAGEMENT REPRESENTATIVE
Has top management appointed a member as
Management Representative with responsibility
and authority to ensure that the processes of Management representative is factory manager and he is
5.5.2 the QMS are established, implemented and
maintained; report to top management on the
aware about his responsibilities in QMS.
performance of the QMS, including needs for MD appointed through letter on March 2015.
improvement and promote awareness of
customer requirements?
INTERNAL COMMUNICATION
Has the top management ensured Communications determined in organization chart. Which has
establishment of appropriate communication
been defined appropriated? Internal communication is done
5.5.3 processes within the organization? Has the top
management ensured realization of properly verbally and through email and written
communication considering the processes of correspondence.
the QMS and their effectiveness?
5.6 Management review
TOP MANAGEMENT REVIEW Management Review meeting was conducted in accordance
Does top management review the QMS to
ensure its continuing suitability, adequacy and with plan and management review procedure PO-MA001.
effectiveness at regular and planned intervals? Management review meeting is held every six month and last
5.6.1 Do reviews include assessing opportunities for
improvement including the need for changes to meeting was on 94/3/3 (Jun)
the QMS, quality policy, and quality objectives?
Are management review records kept? All relevant inputs are discussed in the meeting for examples
REVIEW INPUT changes that could affect the QMSMDD such as changing
Does review input include current performance
and improvement opportunities related to: clean rooms ventilator in March 2015,(for ensuring the
a) results of audits; performance of new ventilator check list was filled out one a
b) customer feedback;
c) process performance and product week in April 2015 by PM unit),
5.6.2 conformance;
Following decisions were made in the meeting:
d) status of corrective and preventive actions;
e) follow‐up action from earlier management Overhauling ventilator system in Nouroz (vacation for iranian
reviews;
f) changes that could affect the QMS,
new year)
g) recommendations for improvement Changing shifts time for daylight saving from march
h) New or revised regulatory rules?
There is a management review report at 94/3/3 (Jun-15)
The input is completed (according to OH&S/ Environmental
management system).
REVIEW OUTPUT About output:
Does output from management review include
actions related to improvement of the QMS and
1- obtaining legal approval for children beds and CPR beds to
5.6.3 its processes, improvement of product related end 94
to customer requirements, actions and
decisions relate to resource needs?
2- repair of electrical earth system
3- providing a filtering system for welding unit
6 Resource Management
PROVISION OF RESOURCES
Does the organization have methods to
Human resources, infrastructure provided for support of
6.1
determine and provide resources needed to
implement and improve the processes of the processes. Refer to 6.2 and 7.4
QMS and address customer satisfaction by
meeting requirements?
6.2 Human Resources
Are personnel assigned with responsibilities
that affect product quality competent on the
Applicable education, training, skills, and experience, has
determined. Training procedure documented in: P/T/01.
6.2.1
basis of applicable education, training, skills,
and experience?
Training needs has gathered and has planned.. Training
Are trainings performed for achievement of
Required Competence? planned in every year. Such as: retraining of risk management
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 8 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 9 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
WORK ENVIRONMENT
Does the organization identify and manage
required work environment needed to achieve
conformity of product?
Are the following factors which could affect
product quality in the work environment
identified?
‐ Process equipment,
‐ Work environment,
‐ Personnel in this work environment
Are qualified and quantified limit values of the
work environment identified for a desired
quality of the work environment?
Are pollution levels of microbial and solid
particles controlled during product
manufacturing where sterile product or
pollution of solid particle which is stipulated to
be sterilized or could live or not live during its
manufacture or utilization is important?
Has exclusion been applied during all
manufacturing processes for a controlled
environment? As valid ground of exclusion, is
pollution reduced to known, consistent and
controlled level by an approved cleaning
method and packaging kept at this level through GMP principle and requirements is implementing.
control process? Periodic health care examinations of staff that are in direct
Have indicators been identified for a controlled
environment which covers valid cleaning and contact with the products have been conducted by the
packaging processes including the organizations Provincial Health Center. Health cards of production personnel
holding a valid cleaning process?
in the clean room were issued on 12/16/93(March 2015).
6.4
(Temperature, Humidity, Air Current, Filtration
of Air, Ionization of Air, Pressure differences, Cleaning checklist for clean rooms on Oct 2015 was
Lighting (along with its spectral content and
severity), Sound, Vibration, cleaning of Working Observed.
surfaces and processes, Water quality, number The record of IMED inspection was observed. There was no
of persons in the work environment)
Have dressing conditions, cleaning conditions NC in this record.
and health conditions for any person being in Regarding risk level of productions (B IMED) GMP is very
contact with the product or the work
environment including those persons who enter more than needed, and that may show management
the area sterilized prior to use or temporarily or commitment
for a short period in terms of importance
microbiologic cleaning holds been identified?
Are personnel to work in special work
conditions or a controlled environment
provided with special training and/or
supervision? In the event that any personnel
including temporary and trained personnel for
performance of special tasks in a controlled
environment are assigned for performance of
the works such as production, maintenance,
cleaning or repair, are such personnel
supervised by an appropriately trained person?
Have the procedures for product introduction,
product polluted or being likely to be polluted,
manual working for working surfaces or
personnel, cleaning or removal of
contamination in order to prevent cross
pollution of product, work environment or
personnel?
Are the records indicating appropriateness for
all conditions kept?
7 Product Realization
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 10 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 11 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
7.2 Customer‐Related Processes
REVIEW OF REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO THE
PRODUCT/SERVICE
Does the organization review the requirements In production order list FM01, all orders listed. According to time
related to the product? delivery for previous orders, determined time and duration of
Are review records kept?
Has this review been realized prior to
production for every order. Such as :
commitment of the organization for provision of Order no: 940061, production no.: 29 must be produced as soon as
7.2.2 the product to customer?
Has the organization ensured settlement of
possible. Technical specification of This order was the same as other
contract or order requirements which are
products and was in production list of organization and need no
different from previously defined? review technically. For every order the first check if there is in
Does the organization have the ability to meet warehouse or no. for example : order no.: 940044 , there are in
defined requirements?
Are the results of review and subsequent
warehouse and therefore release in same day.
follow‐up actions recorded?
CUSTOMER COMMUNICATION
Are arrangements for communication identified
and implemented relating to product
Communication with Customer is established through the website,
information, demands, applications, contracts catalogs, training of operators after delivery.
7.2.3 or realization of order including amendments?
Are required arrangements identified and
After delivery of 10 stretchers for one of customers, training has held
implemented for customer feedback and
and recorded in stretcher training form such as: training about using
communication with customers including of parts of beds.
customer complaints?
7.3 Design and Development
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 12 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT VALIDATION
Is the design and/or development validation
For order no: 940061 , stretcher tested and used in one of hospital
performed in accordance with planned and validated clinically .
arrangements to confirm that final product is
capable of meeting the requirements of
intended use or application requirements
7.3.6 defined?
Is verification completed (if applicable) prior to
delivery or implementation of product? Ara
relevant records maintained?
Are results of review and required actions
recorded?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 13 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
Have the requirements of purchasing Reference information for purchasing observed in F/P/08. Such as:
information (containing the rules related to
supplier records) including outsourced
correct function, size and type of wheels.
processes been identified to ensure product Purchasing data for motor of electrical beds observed for order no.:
and service quality?
Does the organization have the methodology to 141 . Included: linear motor for under knee with technical code (item
communicate these requirements to the no.): 170117. This order purchased and controlled on: 94.05.06 with
supplier? no.: 11836. Acceptance limit is: meet to order for size and item no.
Are purchasing contracts available?
Do the type and content of the control on Technical data for purchasing hydraulic part observed . Includes:
supplier and purchased product depend on the
next product realization of purchased product
size : 140mm . verification records observed on: 93.11.12
or final product?
Are purchasing records retained?
Entrance parts must control by QC manager. Record for above order
PURCHASING INFORMATION observed. These parts verified and were without error.
Does purchasing information define the product
to be purchased? Records of suppliers evaluation observed in form F/P/07. For
Where appropriate, does purchasing example: supplier of galvanization parts evaluated about: price,
information include product approval, quality, on-time delivery. Score was 83 and acceptance score is: 60.
procedures, requirements for process and
7.4.2
equipment, Personnel qualification and the
requirements of Quality Management System?
How does organization ensure the adequacy of
specified requirements in the purchasing
information prior to their release to the
supplier?
Are records for the information related to
purchased product available?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 14 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
VERIFICATION OF PURCHASED PRODUCT
Has the organization identified a method in
order to ensure that the product received
conforms to the specifications, is finished, holds
appropriate identity and is free from any
damage?
Do the processes include the provisions in order
to verify that incoming product is provided
along with support documentation (e.g.
7.4.3
conformity certificates, acceptance test
reports)?
Has data been provided related to analysis of
previous acceptance inspection data, rejection
history in the plant or customer complaints,
required inspection quantity and necessity of
reevaluation of supplier?
Has the organization identified the authorized
person for conformity approval of incoming
material?
Are verification records retained?
7.5 Production and Service Provision
CONTROL OF PRODUCTION AND SERVICE
PROVISION
7.5.1.1 General rules
Has the organization identified control
requirements for production and service
process?
Is control quantity and control detail level
proportionate to criticality level of its process?
Has the characteristic qualities of product been Work instruction for cutting documented in :I/M/01 , drilling :
identified? When required, have documented I/M/02 , bending : I/M/03 , CO2 welding , acetylene welding
procedures, documented rules, work ,select welding , wire gauze welding documented in : I/M/06
instructions and reference materials reference
materials and reference measuring processes Painting : I/M/07 , assembling & packaging : I/M/08 , turnery :
been made available? I/M/12 , electrical pressing :I/M/13 ,
Has appropriate equipment been selected in
Work instruction for quality control: I/S/01 observed. Reference for
the manner that enables process and product
specifications to be obtained? quality control in operation: F/S/23.
Have the documents for using appropriate Control during production in tracing production form F/M/02 for
equipment been established?
Has it been verified that new and/or
order no: 940061 observed. Steps: cutting, bending, drilling,
significantly modified equipment meets welding, painting and assembling has done according to acceptance
purchasing/design specifications and posses the criteria.
7.5.1
ability to operate within the limits defined and
process operating limits?
The production planning for Aug-15 was observed:
Have control devices been identified? - Stretchers: 16 pcs
Has a document been prepared for using - Cabinets: 6 pcs
control devices?
Have implementation and control requirements
- Mechanical Beds: 4 pcs
for labeling and packaging been identified? - Emergency Trolleys: 7 pcs
Are the records obtained during manufacturing The record of production report for aforementioned month was
process of any product lot and facilitating
traceability and review of the manufacture of
observed:
this lot retained? - Stretchers: 16 pcs
Do the records include the following - Cabinets: 9 pcs
information?
‐ When applicable, quantity of raw materials, - Mechanical Beds: 4 pcs
components and intermediate products and lot - Emergency Trolleys: 10 pcs
numbers of those materials,
‐ When applicable, start and completion dates
of different stages of manufacture including
sterilization records,
‐ Quantity of manufactured product,
‐ Signed results of all inspections and tests,
‐ Representation of production line used,
‐ Any deviation from manufacturing
specifications.
7.5.1.2 Control of production and service‐Special rules
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 15 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
Control of product cleanliness and
contamination
Has the organization identified product
cleanliness rules?
Have the materials and substances used during
manufacturing process been adequately During packaging, removed every external part on surface of bed.
defined and labeled in order to prevent
7.5.1.2.1 complexity and process faults? After welding and before sending assembly, welded points fold up.
Have certain medical devices been cleaned This cases controlled in final product control form.
and/or cleared of contamination so as to
prevent employees and other product from
being exposed to any contamination
Have cleaning and implementation
requirements been documented?
Assembly activities
Have assembly activities and responsibility for
medical device been identified?
In the event that any medical device should be
assembled and mounted in the location where
the user is present, have guiding instructions
7.5.1.2.2 been prepared by the organization for accurate
assembly, montage, tests and/or calibrations?
Excluded
Has the organization provided the instructions
which allow assembler to confirm proper
operation of the device?
Are the results of assembly or commissioning
tests recorded?
Service activities
In the event that functionality of products
needs service or maintenance for proper
utilization of products, have documented
requirements been established for service
activity?
Has the organization identified service
responsibilities between distributors and users?
Have service activities carried out by the
organization or a separate agency been
planned?
Have the design and functionality of equipment
For service activities, the first Customer call to office and declare
or devices with special purpose related to failure and then this subject communicated to after sales services in
manual operation and service after assembly factory. One of them was failure in jack og bed. In form F/A/01 this
been validated?
case recorded. Specification of bed such as: serial number recorded
7.5.1.2.3 Are measuring and test equipment used for site
service and tests controlled? in this form. Another case was for order no.: 9400170. Failure
Have instructions related to the lists of spare description recorded and action for this case was: substitution of jack
parts or parts and for use in product service
been prepared?
and hydraulic handle jack. This activities approved by head of
Has the infrastructure covering technical hospital.
consultancy and technical support, customer
training and spare parts or provision of parts
been established?
Are service personnel trained?
Are specialized service personnel available?
Has the organization formed a system for
receiving customer demands so as to determine
whether customer complaints and rules are
handled?
Are service records retained?
Special rules for sterile devices
Does the organization record process
parameters related to sterilization process and
7.5.1.3 excluded
used for each sterilization lot?
Are sterilization records tracked for each
production lot related to medical devices?
7.5.2 VALIDATION OF PROCESSES FOR PRODUCTION AND SERVICE PROVISION
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 16 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
Special rules for sterile medical devices
Have sterilization processes been validated
prior to use?
7.5.2.2
Have the standards used for validation of
sterilization process been identified and excluded
implemented?
Have the requirements in the Article no. 7.5.2.1
been met?
7.5.3 Identification and Traceability
Identification
Has the organization identified and documented
Identifying and tractability is establishing according to Production
the product through appropriate methods procedure : P/M/01. All products is traceable by S/N o all steps of
7.5.3.1 during product realization?
How has the organization identified product
production and quality control results.
situations in accordance with tracing and
Order of Stretcher received on (july-2015) observed:
measuring requirements? Stretchers with mattress , 4 wheels with central locking , stands,
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 17 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 18 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
PRESERVATION OF PRODUCT
Are methods and controls established to
preserve conformity of product during internal
processing and until delivery to intended
Methods and controls established to preserve conformity of product
destination?
Has the organization established documented during internal processing and until delivery to intended destination
processes or documented work instructions for following were evaluated:
control of the product with limited shelf life or
Storage of Row Material and products was clean and all row
7.5.5 which requires special storage?
Are such special storage requirements Material and products have ID cart.
controlled and recorded? Identification and traceability is possible
Does this preservation include definition,
transport, packaging, storage and protection of
Storage general condition is appropriate with sterile product, in case
the product and the parts constituting the of temperature and moisture, 27c with 32% humidity
product?
Is there a logo on product? Is it proper to its
instructions?
CONTROL OF MONITORING AND MEASURING
DEVICES
Has the organization identified the
measurements to be made and the measuring
and monitoring devices required to ensure
conformity of product to specified
requirement?
a) Be calibrated or verified at specified intervals, According to measuring equipment list, there is 5 welding with CO2
or prior to use, against measurement standards machine. Calibration of this machine is determined annually.
7.6
traceable to international or national
measurement standards; where no such Manometer of CO2 welding No.: 54501 were calibrated according to
standards exist, the basis used for calibration or DIN EN 837. Protractor no.: 58885 were calibrated according to BS
verification s hall be recorded; 1685 and error was at acceptable range.
b) Be adjusted or re‐adjusted as necessary;
c) Be identified to enable the calibration status
to be determined;
d) Be safeguarded from adjustments that would
invalidate the measurement result;
e) Be protected from damage and deterioration
during handling, maintenance and storage.
8 Measurement, Analysis and Improvement
General
Does the organization plan to implement the
monitoring, measurement, analysis, and
improvement processes required for conformity measurement, analysis and improvement processes are carried out
8.1 of the product and QMS and improvement of its
efficiency?
through statistical techniques and applicable methods according to
Are measurement, analysis and improvement
Statistic analysis procedure: P/S/01
processes are carried out through statistical
techniques and applicable methods?
8.2 Monitoring and Measuring
8.2.1 CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
Does the organization monitor the information
related to customer perception in order to Customer feedbacks evaluation about: ease of use, design and
understand whether customer requirements
beauty, information in user manual, packing, quality and painting,
8.2.1 are met or not?
Has the organization determined arterials services. Such as: evaluation of customer feedback on
methodologies for obtaining and using November 2015.
information on customer satisfaction and/or
dissatisfaction?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 19 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
of the fields and processes to be audited Ataee asked MR. Abbasi and Mr Moheghodin about quality policy,
including the results of previous audits?
Do selection of auditors and implementation of both of them were aware of it.
audit ensure objectivity and impartiality of the Planning for internal audit is Twice in year.
process? Last internal audit date is 94/5 (October 2015) and they used 2
Do auditors audit their works?
Do follow‐up actions cover verification of the different checklist for 2 standards (OH&S/Environmental
measures taken and reporting of verification management system).
results? They have 3 expert auditors to make independency.
There are 37 non-conformity in that audit.
We checked corrective action report no. 94E19 at 94/8/26 (Nov-15)
about safety warehouse Layout. And, they have some action to
change that.
In next assess activity; the affectivity of that action is approved.
Data analysis table was observed and if the Acceptance criteria are
MONITORING AND MEASUREMENT OF not met, corrective action is taken.
PROCESSES
Does the organization implement appropriate process Measuring Acceptance target result
8.2.3
methods for monitoring QMS processes and
where applicable, for measurement such WMS
Indicator criteria
processes?
production The percentage 2% 0.03% 0.035%
When planned results are not achieved, is
of waste
corrective action taken for product conformity?
8.2.4 MONITORING AND MEASUREMENT OF PRODUCT
General rules Final quality control for S/N: 931105 in form no.: 09423 observed.
Does the organization establish appropriate Specifications controlled and recorded in this form. Such as :
stages to measure and monitor product
characteristics? Strength of wheels , function of brakes , function of the head jack ,
Have verification methods been documented? function of stretcher jack , function of height setting jack , control of
Is this verification process realized in
accordance with the arrangements planned
painting and other visual check according reference quality control
during appropriate stages of product realization during production .
8.2.4.1 process?
Are conformity evidences along with
Final quality control for electrical bed S/N: 911440 , observed.
acceptance criteria maintained?
Electrical leakage test , check of function of motors and control of
Are the records approved by the authorized box , check of bedsides , has done and records observed in form no.:
person/persons in the process of product 0-94-3-1.
release?
Are product release and distribution of service,
Also the final product QC report for 21 cabinets for “Razavi
planned regulations (Article 7.1) completed Hospital” in Apr-15, for 8 stretchers for “Jam Hospital” in Aug-15
satisfactorily? were observed.
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 20 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
P/E/01
release or acceptance in agreement with
not approved. Range of allow leniency for this material has not
8.3 customer?
Are required measures taken to preclude the determined and was not specified cause of this allow leniency. AR
product’s original intended use or application?
Are records related to the nature of
nonconformities and the measures taken later
maintained?
Is corrected nonconforming product subject to
re‐verification to demonstrate conformity to
the requirements?
Do the processes ensure that appropriate
corrective action is initiated when non‐
conforming product is detected after delivery or
use has started?
Statistic analysis procedure with code: P/S/01 observed. Analysis of
DATA ANALYSIS data about customer feedback and measuring of processes observed.
Does the organization collect, identify and
analyze appropriate data to demonstrate
This analysis recorded in management review records.
efficiency and appropriateness of QMS and the About waste percentage there is analysis :
fields where QMS’s efficiency can be We
continuously improved? process Measuring Acceptance target result
Has a documented procedure been prepared Indicator criteria assum
e our
8.4
for these analyses?
Do the characteristics and tendencies of the production The percentage 2% 0.03% 0.035% target
processes and products including data analysis, of waste
customer satisfaction, conformance to product less
requirements, opportunities for corrective than
actions provide information related to we should but because we did not any referable data to mine.
suppliers?
Have data types for data analysis been defined? So, one of the issues we have from QMS is that we can control our
Are data analyses recorded? processes more transparent.
8.5 Improvement
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 21 of 23
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
CONTINUAL IMPROVEMENT
Has the organization identified required
changes by using quality policy, quality
objectives, audit results, analyses of data,
corrective and preventive actions and
management review in order to ensure and
sustain ongoing conformity and efficiency of
quality management system and does the
organization implement such changes?
Has the organization established written
procedures in order that advisory warnings can
be published and implemented?
Are the records of all examinations related to
customer complaint maintained?
Have the complaints been evaluated within the
scope of the following points?:
‐ whether the organization fails to comply with
its own specifications or not,
One of continual improvement evidences is corrective and
preventive actions. This activities is doing according to Statistic
8.5.1
‐ whether the organization has caused problems
to occur despite the fact that it has complied analysis procedure: P/S/01.
with its own specifications
In the event that the activities outside the
organization are identified through examination
of the contribution of such activities to
customer complaint, has the relevant
information been shared among responsible
organizations?
In the event that any customer complaint is not
followed up through a corrective and/or
preventive action, has the reason of this failure
been confirmed and recorded?
Has the organization established a documented
procedure for notifying adverse events and
alertness within the scope of after‐sale
supervision activities?
Does the process comply with international
guides? (MEDDEV 2.12.1 – MEDDEV 2.12.2)
Are the notices for adverse events recorded
8.5.2. CORRECTIVE ACTION
Is there a documented procedure for Corrective
and Preventive Action?
Are corrective actions taken to eliminate causes
of nonconformities effective in preventing
recurrences?
Does this procedure include the requirements
8.5.2
of reviewing non‐conformities (including Follow of report no 4-11107 for penetrated test report of welded part
customer complaints), determining the causes
of non‐conformity, evaluating the actions
, and result was fail, corrective action planned. Rot cause was no
needed to ensure that nonconformities do not calibrated manometer of welding tool. Corrective action was
recur, determining and implementing the recalibration of manometer.
corrective action needed, and review of the
In website, there is section for customer complaints. Following one
results of the action initiated?
Is adequacy of corrective‐preventive actions of them about stretcher for ICU, causes of that specified and was
identified? bad design of situation of pedal jack.
PREVENTIVE ACTION
Has the organization established a documented
Corrective action was done. Effectiveness of this action evaluated
procedure for preventive action with defined according to result of load test on the bed and evaluations of strength
requirements for identifying potential non‐ of bed and approved.
conformities and their causes; evaluating the
8.5.3 need for action to prevent occurrence;
determining and implementing preventive
action needed; recording results of action
taken; reviewing preventive action taken.
What are the methods for identifying the
adequacy of corrective‐preventive actions?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 22 of 23
By exception, we indicate the specific Strengths and weakness of the organization in light of the management system, as we perceive and seen through
processes in reference to requirements of the criteria being ascribed as these apply and relate to the assessment plan and planning of the assessment.
This aspect relates to Accreditation Body as it does to the protection of consumers in the client-organization’s role within their respective supply – chain.
Disclaimers: (1) herein, we reiterate that any suggestion or opinion that the assessment team expresses does not construe to be a contractual
requirement. (2) The degree of certainty in conclusions increases by the competence of the assessment team as well as the attestation within the
assessment protocol, values, mission and vision under which we operate for the protection of consumers, still remains a certain level of uncertainty.
Strength Weakness
cleanness ‐‐‐‐
Hazard Control ‐‐‐‐
action Request Type I Form-008 – as we indicate and that each of the RA addresses the basic four (4) questions
as seen in Form-008: N/A
action Request Type II Form-008 – as we indicate and that each of the AR addresses the basic four (4) questions
as seen in Form-008:
1. Range of allow leniency for the steel profile has not been determined and was not specified cause of this alloy leniency.
END of REPORT