Professional Documents
Culture Documents
European Shopping Center Development Report
European Shopping Center Development Report
SHOPPING
CENTRES
THE DEVELOPMENT
STORY
MAY 2018
CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1
KEY HIGHLIGHTS 2
WESTERN EUROPE 8
CAVEATS 16
Western Europe recorded a 23% decrease in new Following the fall in development in 2017, the level
shopping centre completions in 2017. While France of completions is expected to remain unchanged
was the most active country in terms of development, in 2018 and the 2018/19 development pipeline with
the volume of completions declined by 28% due to 6.6 million sq m currently under construction is
the electoral uncertainties at the start of the year in line with the two years forecast, 12 months ago.
(presidential and then legislative), growing pressure
from the local authorities to limit out-of-town The development of technology, changing
development and increasing investor and developer consumer behaviour and the growth of e-commerce
interest in retail parks and new hybrid formats. A have created a challenging environment but
similar development trend has been seen in the also opportunities for shopping centre owners
majority of Western European countries. Increased and retailers. Today’s shopping centres are very
activity was recorded in only a handful of markets different from those which emerged twenty years
(Spain, Portugal, Finland and Denmark), supported ago and they will need to continue evolving in
by an improved economic backdrop, urbanisation order to stay relevant to the increasingly savvy and
and growing tourism. discerning consumer.
166.5
MILLION SQ M
AS OF 1 JANUARY 2018
EUROPE WE CEE
IN H2 2017 IN 2017
2.4
MILLION SQ M
3.8
MILLION SQ M
NEW SHOPPING 2,417 1,068 1,349 NEW SHOPPING 3,791 1,497 2,294
CENTRE SPACE CENTRE SPACE
ADDED IN H2 2017 ADDED IN 2017
(‘000 SQ M) (‘000 SQ M)
Y-Y GROWTH -17.0% -13.7% -19.4% Y-Y GROWTH -23.0% -22.7% -23.3%
600
75% 25%
Thousands
500
400
APPROXIMATELY
300
3.8
MILLION SQ M
OF NEW SHOPPING
CENTRE SPACE IS
200 EXPECTED TO BE
DELIVERED IN 2018
100
WHILE A
FURTHER
2.8
MILLION SQ M
IS DUE TO BE
COMPLETED IN 2019
EUROPE WE CEE
Russia
Poland
France
Spain
United Kingdom
Portugal
Italy
Finland
Denmark
IN 2018 – 2019
(MILLION SQ M)
10 200
Millions (sq.m)
Millions (sq.m)
9 180
8 160
7 140
New Shopping Centre GLA Per Annum
6 120
Total GLA
5 100
4 80
H2
3 60
2 40
1 20
H1
0 0
2000
2004
2006
2009
2008
2003
2005
2002
2007
2001
2010
2014
2016
1999
1998
2013
2015
Est. 2019
2012
2017
1997
Est. 2018
2011
WESTERN EUROPE
NORWAY FINLAND
857 464
SWEDEN
380 ESTONIA
725
DENMARK
328 LATVIA
349
UNITED
KINGDOM
261 NETHERLANDS
375
POLAND
281
AUSTRIA LITHUANIA
GERMANY
177
371 377 RUSSIA
144
CZECH
IRELAND REPUBLIC
346 220
BELGIUM
133
SLOVAKIA
SWITZERLAND
227
347 SLOVENIA
LUXEMBOURG 377
594
HUNGARY
127 ROMANIA
FRANCE
ITALY 107
286 229
BULGARIA
103
BOSNIA
SPAIN
PORTUGAL HERZEGOVINA
56 147
MALTA SERBIA
262 88
SLOWDOWN EXPANSION
Growth Decreasing & Above Trend Growth Increasing & Above Trend
Denmark
Slovakia
Hungary
Czech Republic
Greece Portugal
Poland
Sweden
Bulgaria
Finland
United Kingdom
Turkey
Switzerland
Romania
Netherlands
Luxembourg
Latvia Ireland
Austria
Estonia
Germany
DOWNTURN RECOVERY
Growth Decreasing & Below Trend Growth Increasing & Below Trend
DOWNTURN SLOWDOWN
UNITED KINGDOM, TURKEY, ROMANIA, SLOVAKIA, HUNGARY, GREECE,
LATVIA, LUXEMBOURG, IRELAND, PORTUGAL, BULGARIA, FINLAND, SPAIN,
ESTONIA, AUSTRIA AND GERMANY. SLOVENIA, SERBIA, NORWAY, FRANCE
AND BELGIUM.
Annual rental growth Q4 2017 in the leading
shopping centre is decreasing and is below Annual rental growth Q4 2017 in the leading
the five-year average. shopping centre is slowing and is above the
five-year average.
Market Size
SHRINKING DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY IN THE In Germany, restrictive planning legislation has
LARGEST SC MARKETS curtailed the development of new out-of-town
France was the most active country in terms of shopping centres. In 2017, only 18,500 sq m of
new openings, adding more than 326,000 sq m new space was added to the market, with two
of new space in 2017. Nevertheless, the maturity new schemes, two extension projects and two
of the market and significant existing provision schemes which ceased trading. This represents
resulted in a 28% drop in newly built space on a 82% decline on 2016.
2016. Furthermore, due to increasing vacancy
rates in town centres, there is growing pressure DIVERSE DEVELOPMENT TRENDS IN THE
from local authorities to limit planning consent NORDIC REGION
for new out-of-town schemes. On the other hand, In Sweden, retail sales data indicate that online sales
fragile consumer spending has led to caution account for 80% of retail sales growth (excluding
among investors and developers who are focusing groceries (or non-durable goods). Shopping centre
increasingly on refurbishment of existing schemes, visits are declining and this is reflected in lower
new generation of retail parks and hybrid formats. levels of development. In 2017, only 15,000 sq m
The pace of development is expected to remain of new space was added to the market through
unchanged, with nearly 676,000 sq m of space extensions and refurbishment projects. A similar
currently under construction and scheduled for trend is being seen in Norway, where only one
completion in 2018/19. extension project was completed in 2017 and the
development pipeline remains unchanged, with
Weaker retailer demand outside of prime locations
only 27,000 sq m across three extensions expected
and an oversupply of retail space in the UK
to complete in 2018/19. Shopping centre owners
have led to a 23% decrease in shopping centre
are adding more F&B operators to their schemes,
development activity, with just 120,000 sq m
which are being repositioned from shopping centres
being completed in 2017.
towards more F&B-led destinations.
TOP 5 WESTERN EUROPEAN CITIES FOR DEVELOPMENT PIPELINE 2018 – 2019 (SQ M)
Helsinki
Metropolitan Area
Greater Paris
Luxembourg City
Madrid
Marseille
Market Size
RUSSIA: ACTIVE GROWTH PHASE NOW OVER with – the PIK, Akadem Park, Atlantik City and
In 2016, with 1.6 million sq m of newly built shopping Kontinent shopping centres in St. Petersburg
centre space, Russia became the largest shopping currently being re‑positioned. Additionally, Golden
centre market in Europe. However, the retail real Babylon Otradnoe and Golden Babylon Rostokino in
estate market has passed through its active growth Moscow will also be re-positioned and refurbished.
phase very quickly and new development fell to
just 0.6 million sq m in 2017. The main reason for DECREASING RENTS, WEAK OCCUPATIONAL
this was the economic downturn in 2014 when DEMAND AND, YET, THE STRONGEST
the number of new projects starting construction DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY?
decreased significantly. Additionally, by 2017 the In Turkey, currency volatility has had a negative
market has gained maturity and supply and demand impact on the expansion plans of many international
are now in relative equilibrium. The structure retailers and, despite falling rents, occupier demand
of the pipeline for 2018 shows that developers has remained weak. Nevertheless, shopping centre
have shifted their focus from large-scale projects supply rose significantly, with 1.1 million sq m of
to smaller schemes. Developers are focused on new space, making Turkey the most active country
their existing portfolios and ways of increasing in terms of development in 2017. Shopping centre
footfall, promoting formats and searching for new landlords are attracting new occupiers by offering
approaches to business operations. Re-positioning pure turnover rents for a limited time of up to one
and refurbishment activity remains a key priority, year. However, development is set to slow given
TOP 5 CENTRAL & EASTERN EUROPEAN CITIES FOR DEVELOPMENT PIPELINE 2018 – 2019 (SQ M)
Istanbul
Moscow
Ankara
Warsaw
Tallinn
New SC
Extensions
Western Europe
2019 2018
2019 2018
LUXEMBOURG –
SWEDEN – MÖLNDAL
GASPERICH
24,000 SQ M
75,000 SQ M
MÖLNDAL CENTRUM
LA CLOCHE D’OR
2019 2018
SPAIN – TORREJÓN THE NETHERLANDS –
DE ARDOZ UTRECHT
75,000 SQ M 22,800 SQ M
OPEN SKY LEIDSCHE RIJN CENTRUM
2019 2018
BELGIUM – HASSELT
ITALY – ROME
21,000 SQ M
60,000 SQ M
QUARTIER BLEU
MAXIMO SHOP & FUN
(KANAALKOM)
2018 2019
FRANCE – UNITED KINGDOM -
FARÉBERSVILLER LEWISHAM
55,000 SQ M 17,500 SQ M
B’EST LEWISHAM GATEWAY
2019 2018
2018 2019
2019 2018
2018 2019
BOSNIA HERZEGOVINA –
HUNGARY – BUDAPEST
BANJA LUKA
40,000 SQ M
62,500 SQ M
ETELE CITY CENTER
DELTA CITY
2018 2019
MULTIGENERATIONAL
PLACEMAKING
APPROACH
With all the convenience that online shopping can Today, consumers are represented by six different
offer, shopping centre owners will have to look generations, characterised by different behaviour,
for other ways to attract shoppers and increase preferences and attitudes to trends and technology.
customer footfall and dwell time. There will be Retailers and shopping centre owners will therefore
a strong focus on placemaking, allocating more need to clearly understand their target customer
space to community uses, with carefully curated base. Additionally, they will need to develop multiple
tenants (retailers, services providers, leisure and strategies and apply a multigenerational approach
entertainment operators) and event space. In the when attracting and engaging with shoppers.
future, placemaking will be a critical component
of a successful shopping centre.
SMALLER NEW
SCHEMES TENANTS
Growing shopping centre provision and polarisation New non-traditional tenants will also emerge. With
within the sector (convenience centres/need the direct-to-consumer model set to grow, we expect
versus super-regional centres/desire) will lead to more manufacturers to showcase their offerings.
smaller new schemes. Improved technology and Start-ups and smaller producers will be able to use
the increasing amount of available information the opportunity to interact with customers and test
will allow even small retailers and shopping centre their products or services. To attract millennials, new
owners to understand and engage with shoppers experiential F&B, health and beauty operators will
more successfully. take space in shopping centres.
Shopping centre customers will not differentiate According to the UK’s Local Government
between online and offline retail. Their shopping Association, the growth of online shopping and
journey may start with showrooming, but may number of deliveries have led to increased traffic
end up with ordering the goods online and vice and congestion, which has contributed to wear and
versa. Customers might search for products tear on the road network. A partial solution to the
online but will complete the shopping in a store. problem could be the use of shopping centres as
The various omnichannel elements will become parcel collection points, effectively turning them
ever more closely intertwined and a new hybrid into retail and logistics platforms. While this may
format of commerce will emerge. fulfil both offline and online orders, it could also
generate additional business for the retail outlets.
Smartphones and the significantly growing The amount of data and products that retailers
number of mobile apps will provide shopping work with across all channels is expected to
centre landlords and retailers with unlimited increase and operational management will become
opportunities to connect with shoppers. The data more challenging while customer expectations
assembled on shoppers and their movements will will continue to grow. Artificial Intelligence (AI)
be used to improve scheme performance through and Robotic Process Automation (RPA) will help
improvements to layout, amenities, and marketing, to provide solutions which will benefit logistics,
with the aim of more targeted advertising and marketing and customer service, helping to save
enhancing the shopping experience. resources, costs and time. They will become a
prevalent part of retail operations.
However, with the commencement of GDPR
(General Data Protection Regulation), shopping
centre landlords must ensure they adhere to the
regulations and that they use clear and transparent
systems for handling customer data.
In recent years, shopping centres have undergone a Developers and landlords will place a greater
significant transition. Retailers and shopping centre emphasis on shopping centre sustainability.
landlords have been developing multiple online and They will become increasingly mindful about
physical touchpoints to engage with shoppers. This environmental targets, such as green energy
has made the path to purchase more convenient sources, water efficiency and environmentally
for shoppers, although processes for retailers have friendly construction and management
become much more complex. While the store remains practices. Similarly, consumers will become
at the centre of the omni-channel world, the growth more sensitive as to how products have been
of online and product returns in-store have made it sourced and transported.
more difficult to evaluate the role and contribution
of the physical shop. To-date, lease structures have
remained relatively unchanged. However, future
rental models will need to try and take into account
store performance using different metrics, potentially
based around the number of visitors rather than pure
turnover which can be difficult to measure.
• All figures represent retail GLA as far as possible European shopping centre market wave uses
– some might include total GLA if retail GLA is historic quarterly data only. No forecast inputs.
not available
Markets classified into four categories of the
• Mixed use properties have been included cycle, comparing:
• City market boundaries: the figures in this report
1. The current annual rental growth
refer to the larger areas around the core city that
gives the market its name; that is, each market 2. Annual rental growth for the same period
consists of a bundle of NUTS III areas last year
• Shopping centre figures for Russia include only
3. Five-year average annual growth including
quality schemes
most recent quarter.
• All stock and pipeline figures are sourced from
Cushman & Wakefield Markets are plotted on the curve based on
the categories and the value of their y-o-y
• Population data is provided by Oxford Economics rental growth:
DARREN YATES
HEAD OF EMEA RETAIL
RESEARCH & INSIGHT
darren.yates@cushwake.com
+44 20 3296 3911
SILVIA JODLOWSKI
SENIOR RESEARCH ANALYST
EMEA RESEARCH & INSIGHT
silvia.jodlowski@cushwake.com
+44 20 3296 4233
Copyright © 2018 Cushman & Wakefield. All rights reserved. CUS101174 05/18