Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(UNESCO) Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia PDF
(UNESCO) Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia PDF
Formula
Published in 2015 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
7, place de Fontenoy, 75352 Paris 07 SP, France,
and
© UNESCO 2015
This publication is available in Open Access under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 IGO
(CC-BY-SA 3.0 IGO) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/igo/). By
using the content of this publication, the users accept to be bound by the terms of use of
the UNESCO Open Access Repository (http://www.unesco.org/open-access/terms-use-
ccbysa-en).
The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication
do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO concerning
the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the
delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors; they are
not necessarily those of UNESCO and do not commit the Organization.
TH/EPR/14/037-200
Foreword.....................................................................................................................................................................................V
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements...........................................................................................................................................................VI
Acronyms................................................................................................................................................................................. VII
Executive Summary............................................................................................................................................................1
1 Introduction................................................................................................................................................................. 12
2 Research Framework............................................................................................................................................... 15
Part A: Girls and Women in STEM: Where do we stand? ....................................................................... 21
3 Level of Participation in Higher Education.................................................................................................. 21
4 Learning Achievement in Secondary Education..................................................................................... 34
Part B: Girls and Women in STEM: What led us here? ............................................................................. 45
5 Educational Impacts................................................................................................................................................ 45
6 Psychosocial Influences......................................................................................................................................... 56
7 Labour Market Effects............................................................................................................................................. 68
Part C: Girls and Women in STEM: Where to from here? ....................................................................... 77
8 Reflections..................................................................................................................................................................... 77
9 Conclusions.................................................................................................................................................................. 79
Bibliography.......................................................................................................................................................................... 82
Annexes.................................................................................................................................................................................... 90
Annex 1. Student Questionnaire............................................................................................................................ 90
Annex 2. Classroom Observation Sheet.......................................................................................................... 100
Annex 3. Guiding Questions for Semi-Structured Interviews in Indonesia................................. 104
Annex 4. Statistical Tables on Female Participation in STEM-Related International
Olympiads by Country/Jurisdiction in 2014............................................................................. 105
Annex 5. Country-specific Policy Suggestions............................................................................................ 109
III
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
FIGURES TABLES
CONTENTS
Figure 1 Number of female and male Nobel Laureates and Table 1 Urban and rural research locations by country ............................ 17
Fields Medallists in STEM-related fields.............................................. 2 Table 2 School and student sample per country........................................... 18
Figure 2 How can we get more girls and women into STEM?............ 10 Table 3 School and classroom sample for classroom observations........19
Figure 3 Analytical framework: the gender dimension Table 4 Participation in higher education across all fields and
of learning achievement and progression to STEM............... 15 female participation in science programmes ............................... 21
Figure 4 Proportion of female graduates in science Table 5 PISA 2012 results for participating countries and
programmes in tertiary education in Asia (%)............................ 27 jurisdictions in the Asia-Pacific................................................................ 35
Figure 5 Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in Table 6 TIMSS 2011 results in Grade 8 for participating countries
selected universities in Indonesia by sex (%).............................. 29 and jurisdictions in the Asia-Pacific ...................................................... 36
Figure 6 Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in Table 7 Proportion of female teachers by level of education in
higher education in Malaysia in 2012 by sex (%)...................... 29 the Republic of Korea as of 2013 (%).................................................... 47
Figure 7
Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in Table 8 Interactions between students and teachers in upper
higher education in Mongolia as of 2013 by sex (%)............. 30 secondary mathematics and science classes by sex
Figure 8 Proportion of students enrolled in selected STEM in Vietnam.............................................................................................................. 49
disciplines in higher education in Nepal as of 2011/2012 Table 9 Proportion of students reporting having received
by sex (%)............................................................................................................ 31 private tutoring across all subjects in the 2013/2014
Figure 9 Proportion of female students enrolled in academic year (%) ........................................................................................... 52
selected STEM and non-STEM disciplines in higher Table 10 Proportion of female and male students reporting having
education as of 2014 in the Republic of Korea (%).................. 31 received private tutoring in mathematics and science subjects
Figure 10 Percentage of female students enrolled in science in the academic year of 2013/2014 (%).............................................. 53
and engineering in higher education by level, Table 11 Most and least enjoyed subjects reported by students by
Republic of Korea as of 2011 (%)......................................................... 32 country and by sex .......................................................................................... 58
Figure 11 Average Gender Parity Index (GPI) in selected Table 12 Student perceptions of subject performance by country
STEM-related technical and vocational programmes and by sex.............................................................................................................. 60
in selected institutions in Indonesia.................................................. 33
Table 13 Student attitudes towards mathematics and science
Figure 12 Trends in mathematics and science achievement in the seven countries under review by sex (%)........................... 64
in TIMSS Grade 8 by sex in Malaysia.................................................. 37
Table 14 Economic and development context of the seven
Figure 13 Trends in mathematics and science achievement countries under review as of 2013......................................................... 68
in TIMSS Grade 8 by sex in the Republic of Korea.................... 39
Table 15 Headcount and proportion of researchers in science,
Figure 14 Proportion of female medallists in STEM-related technology and innovation in Asia as of the latest
International Olympiads in 2014 among participating available year by sex (%)............................................................................. 70
Asia-Pacific countries and jurisdictions (%).................................. 40
Table 16 Female labour participation in the labour market
Figure 15 Trends in achievement among 15-year-old students and wage differences in the seven countries under
in the Malaysian Lower Secondary Assessment review as of 2013............................................................................................... 71
(PMR)...................................................................................................................... 42
Figure 16 Proportion of students passing the Malaysia
Certificate of Education (SPM) in mathematics and
BOXES
science in 2013 by sex (%)....................................................................... 43 Box 1 Proportion of women in science fields by academic
level in China and Japan (%)...................................................................... 26
Figure 17 Representation of students in Grade 7 science
textbooks in Indonesia............................................................................... 50 Box 2 A story from Jingmei Li of Singapore, 2014 UNESCO-L’Oréal
International Fellowship Winner ............................................................ 66
Figure 18 Grade 9 science textbook Illustration on the
central nervous system in Cambodia............................................... 51 Box 3 Reflections from Kayo Inaba of Japan, 2014 Laureate of the
L’Oréal-UNESCO For Women in Science Awards ........................ 78
Figure 19 Frequency of mathematics and science subjects
reported by female and male students as most and
least enjoyed and highest and lowest perceived
performance..................................................................................................... 61
Figure 20 Level of perceived parental and teacher encouragement
and students’ perceived importance of mathematics and
science reported by students in Cambodia ............................... 65
Figure 21 Proportion of female and male STEM professionals
by profession in Malaysia (%)................................................................. 73
Figure 22 GPI of grant-receiving senior STEM researchers
in Indonesia....................................................................................................... 74
Figure 23 Proportion of female professionals in science and
technology by institute and employment type in
the Republic of Korea as of 2012 (%)................................................ 75
IV
n Foreword
FOREWORD
In today’s fast-paced and ever-changing Through analysis of female participation
world, new opportunities for growth and in these fields, learning achievement and
development occur alongside new challenges educational, psychosocial and economic
to peace and security. On the one hand, influences, it answers three important questions
we enjoy the benefits of technological with regard to girls and women in STEM:
advancement in communication, travel and Where do we stand? What led us here? Where
innovation. On the other, we bear witness to from here? This report, which focuses on
to the growing threat of climate change, seven country studies in Cambodia, Indonesia,
global health epidemics, migration, mounting Malaysia, Mongolia, Nepal, the Republic of
poverty and increased income inequality. Our Korea and Viet Nam, is a significant report for us
world today requires of us to find solutions here in Asia, one which provides the foundation
to exploit opportunities for sustainable for further study and policy formulation in this
and inclusive growth and mitigate these region and beyond. Ultimately, the report tells
simultaneous threats. But when we look into us that early and targeted intervention through
the fields of Science, Technology, Engineering education can greatly facilitate girls’ and
and Mathematics (STEM), we must increase women’s increased participation in STEM fields.
our capacities to cope with these persisting
challenges, and for that we need to increase While we continue to promote STEM fields
women’s participation in STEM fields. among girls and women, we commend this
report for exploring the deeper influences and
To help encourage more girls and women uncovering new solutions for attracting more
to pursue careers in STEM, UNESCO has been girls and women into STEM. It is our wish that
working to promote their integration in all women pursue freely their career ambitions
STEM fields through its work in education. with confidence, without fear of prejudice, with
In particular, UNESCO has driven the For joy and with a thirst for new knowledge. May
Women in Science Programme which today this report help build the greater foundation
represents 16 years of collaboration with for this here in our region. Finally, we would
the L’Oréal Corporate Foundation. It is an also like to express our heartfelt thanks to the
initiative which recognizes and celebrates the many students, teachers and all others who
achievements of female science researchers in contributed to this study, who through their
addressing the opportunities and challenges stories have enriched this report.
taking place in our world today.
V
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
n Acknowledgements
This regional report is the synthesis of case Headquarters, Mioko Saito from UNESCO
studies conducted in seven countries and International Institute for Educational Planning
was prepared by the UNESCO Asia and Pacific (IIEP), Mageswary Karpudewan of Universiti Sains
Regional Bureau for Education (UNESCO Malaysia and Mark Bray from the University of
Bangkok). This is the second in a series of Hong Kong.
studies, as part of a joint research project
in collaboration with the Korean Women’s We would also like to express our sincere
Development Institute (KWDI). gratitude to all the students, teachers, school
principals, education officers and community
We would like to thank our partners who have members who participated in and facilitated the
made this study possible by conducting data collection in the seven countries, and whose
in-country research and producing the national perspectives and insights represent a large part of
reports in Cambodia: Whitney Szmodis and the findings presented in this report. Our special
Sothy Eng from Lehigh University; Indonesia: thanks also goes to Kayo Inaba of Japan, the
Ridwan Abdullah Sani from the State University Asia-Pacific Laureate of the 2014 L’Oréal-UNESCO
of Medan; Malaysia: Akbariah Mohd Mahdzir Women For Science Award, and Jingmei
and Nor Liza Ali from the Malaysia-Japan Li of Singapore, the 2014 UNESCO-L’Oréal
International Institute of Technology (MJIIT), International Fellowship winner, for sharing their
and Zainuriah Abd Khatab and Hanizah Hamzah inspiring stories as part of this report.
from the Ministry of Education; Mongolia:
Khishigbuyan Dayan-Ochir; Nepal: Basu Dev This regional synthesis report was prepared by
Kafle of Tribhuvan University; Republic of Korea: a team led by Ramya Vivekanandan Rodrigues
Jiseon Choi and Insuk Kim from the Korea of UNESCO Bangkok. The report was written by
Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation (KICE); Aliénor Salmon with inputs from the UNESCO
Viet Nam: Do Thi Bich Loan from the Vietnam Bangkok review team, including Gwang-Chol
National Institute of Educational Sciences (VNIES). Chang, Ramya Vivekanandan Rodrigues,
Tserennadmid Nyamkhuu and Antony Tam.
Our thanks also goes to colleagues and partners The report was edited by Rachel McCarthy
in these countries, namely: Santosh Khatri and technical assistance was provided by
from UNESCO Phnom Penh (Cambodia), Ferry Ratchakorn Kulsawet, while Akané Nozaki and
Yulmarino from the Ministry of Education and Warren Field are gratefully acknowledged for
Culture (Indonesia), Asmah Ahmad from the their support with publication preparation and
SEAMEO Secretariat (Malaysia), Tap Raj Pant graphic design respectively.
from UNESCO Kathmandu (Nepal), Jimin Cho
and Yunhee Gong from KICE (Republic of Korea), This research, and the production of this report,
and Sun Lei from UNESCO Ha Noi (Viet Nam). would not have been possible without the
generous support of KWDI, and in particular
In addition, our appreciation goes to the peer Dr Eun Kyung Kim, Head of the International
review panel, namely Min Bista and Jonghwi Development and Cooperation team at
Park of UNESCO Bangkok, Maki Hayashikawa, KWDI and her colleagues, all of whom have
L. Anathea Brooks and Sonia Bahri of UNESCO contributed to this successful collaboration.
VI
n Acronyms
ACRONYMS
APEC KWDI PISA
Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Korean Women’s Programme for International
ASEAN Development Institute Student Assessment
Association of Southeast Asian Nations MDGs PMR
BCG Millennium Development Goals Lower Secondary Assessment (Malaysia)
Boston Consulting Group MEDS PT3
DoHE Ministry of Education and Form 3 Assessment (Malaysia)
Directorate of Higher Education Science (Mongolia) SEAMEO
(Indonesia and Nepal) MoE Southeast Asian Ministers of Education
EFA Ministry of Education (Malaysia) Organization
Education for All MoEC SPM
GENIA Ministry of Education and Malaysia Certificate of Education
Gender in Education Culture (Indonesia) (Malaysia)
Network in Asia-Pacific MoEYS STEM
GPI Ministry of Education, Youth Science, Technology, Engineering
Gender Parity Index and Sport (Cambodia) and Mathematics
GPN MoHE TIMSS
National Average Grade Ministry of Higher Education Trends in International Mathematics
(Malaysia) (Malaysia) and Science Study
GSO MoHR UGC
General Statistics Office (Viet Nam) Ministry of Human Resources University Grants Commission (Nepal)
IBO (Malaysia) UNESCO
International Biology Olympiad MoNE United Nations Educational, Scientific
ICT Ministry of National Education and Cultural Organization
Information and Communication (Indonesia) UNDP
Technologies MoSTI United Nations Development
IIEP Ministry of Science, Technology Programme
International Institute for and Innovation (Malaysia) UNGEI
Educational Planning MSIP United Nations Girls’ Education Initiative
ILO Ministry of Science, ICT and Future UPSR
International Labour Organization Planning (Republic of Korea) Primary Achievement Test (Malaysia)
IMO NAEA WISET
International Mathematical Olympiad National Assessment of Educational Center for Women in Science,
Achievement (Republic of Korea) Technology (Republic of Korea)
IOI
International Olympiad in Informatics NGOs
Non-Governmental Organizations
KEDI
Korean Educational NIS
Development Institute National Institute of Statistics
(Cambodia)
KICE
Korea Institute for Curriculum OECD
and Evaluation Organisation for Economic Co-operation
and Development
VII
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
“
I was first interested in science when I started primary school.
What touched me was the wonder of living creatures. Growing
up in the countryside, I saw tadpoles become frogs and watched
the metamorphosis of caterpillars into butterflies – all these beautiful
creatures that took flight before my eyes. It was these early adventures
that led me to study biology and still inspire my love of experimentation.
VIII
results of my work, which was research and so I worked hard to publish
as many papers as I could. I also feel that I had unique experiences as
a woman, for instance I could talk openly to high-ranking men from
academic societies or universities, since they did not usually consider
women as competition. However, female researchers often work in
administration and management which are not directly related to our
field of expertise, and having more women involved would change the
atmosphere of discussions to become more fruitful and successful. This is
why we need to hire and promote more women in Science, Technology,
Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) in all societies.
There are still a number of issues in getting women into STEM, but we
need to remember that STEM fields are incredibly vast. We can exclude life
sciences including biological sciences and see that the fields with the least
women are more often mathematics, physics, engineering, informatics,
and chemistry. We need more role models, and more female teachers
in STEM-related subjects at the secondary level. Girls need to develop
an attitude to be self-motivated and learn independently, and it also
”
depends a lot on improving students’ and parents’ attitudes to be more
familiar with STEM fields to overcome the fear of their
daughters obtaining a job in the future.
Kayo Inaba
University of Kyoto, Japan
Asia-Pacific Laureate of the 2014 L’Oréal-UNESCO
For Women in Science Awards
X
Executive Summary
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
n
Our world today faces a multitude of in STEM fields, and with women representing
increasingly interlinked challenges. Climate approximately half the world population, one
change, global health epidemics, demographic may consider the magnitude of untapped
changes, pressures from rapid technological potential and talent at a time in which STEM
advances and unprecedented inequality are fields are all the more important.
but some of our most pressing concerns.
In this context, the technical knowhow As we arrive at the target date for achievement
and capability to uncover new solutions to of the Education for All (EFA) Goals and the
overcome these challenges requires advanced Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in 2015,
skills in Science, Technology, Engineering and it is important that the post-2015 development
Mathematics (STEM). agenda reflects a number of areas related
to the context of this study, such as learning
Despite this, there exists a serious labour achievement and more broadly the quality of
shortage in STEM fields, particularly among education, as well as the importance of STEM
women. Indeed, in the Asia-Pacific, a global sectors in their contribution to economic and
survey indicates that as of 2014, the region social development. While there has been
faces ‘talent shortage’ of 45 per cent, with the remarkable progress in achieving gender equality
most in-demand categories mainly comprising both in terms of access to and achievement in
STEM-related occupations (ManpowerGroup, education (IIEP, 2012), a lack of gender parity
2014). It is also estimated that globally, women from the secondary level onwards persists in
represent less than 30 per cent of researchers in many countries of the world (UNESCO 2014a).
science, technology and innovation (UIS, 2014a).
These are no easy questions given the diversity
This is reflected in the most prestigious awards of Asia and the differing obtacles to attracting
in STEM fields – including the Nobel Prize more girls and women to STEM fields across
in Chemistry, Medicine and Physics, as well different countries. Nonetheless, the dearth of
as the Fields Medal in Mathematics – where research and understanding and the significant
awards to women are few and far between need for increasing numbers of women in
(see Figure 1). With a global labour shortage STEM, justifies a thorough investigation into
1
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Figure 1 Number of female and male Nobel Laureates and Fields Medallists in STEM-related fields
Nobel Prize in Chemistry Nobel Prize in Medicine Nobel Prize in Physics Fields Medal in Mathematics
4 11 2 1
Female
Male
this area. This report thus aims to address science as opposed to mathematics at the
the lack of information in the area of gender, secondary level, which may explain why
learning achievement and progression to females prefer to choose science-related
study and work in STEM fields in Asia, as well as fields of study in higher education and
enhance knowledge and inform policy among occupations, such as biology, chemistry
education stakeholders and policymakers. and medicine as opposed to more
Combining existing data with the views and mathematics-oriented fields such as physics
perspectives of young people in the region, and engineering. Although these differences
this report focuses on seven countries in Asia are impacted by wider sociocultural and
– Cambodia, Indonesia, Malaysia, Mongolia, labour market preconceptions, education
Nepal, the Republic of Korea and Viet Nam, has a significant role to play to address this
while drawing upon relevant examples from problem: 1) by stimulating interest among
other countries of the region. female students in STEM-related subjects,
2) by ensuring that educators are equipped
to take more gender-responsive approaches
Ultimately, this report reveals that gender
and encourage female students to pursue
differences in STEM fields do not start in the
STEM fields, and 3) by taking policy
labour market, nor even in higher education
measures that are conducive to increasing
– they begin in student performance as
the number of women in these fields.
young as 15 years old. In countries where
Stimulating, encouraging and supporting
the gender gap in student performance
fair and equal opportunities for girls and
at the secondary education level is at
boys to perform in STEM-related subjects
the expense of girls, women tend to be
at school, therefore, would equate to more
underrepresented in STEM fields of study in
girls and women in STEM fields of study in
higher education and in the labour market.
higher education and the world of work.
Girls also tend to do relatively better in
2
In reaching this conclusion, this regional gender gap in student performance in the
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
synthesis report asks three fundamental results of both international and national
questions with regard to girls and women in assessments also shows variances by country,
STEM – Where do we stand? What led us here? while among the highest performing students,
Where to from here? such as those participating in International
Olympiads for instance, very few females were
Where do we stand? identified across all countries.
While differences across country contexts are Turning to the seven country case studies,
undeniable, a number of major challenges three major findings were identified with
can be identified when it comes to the regard to female participation in higher
participation of girls and women in STEM education and gender differences in learning
fields across Asia. In some countries, access to achievement in mathematics and science:
higher education for young women remains
a challenge in itself. This was especially true
Female participation in STEM fields in
for Cambodia, for instance. In others, a higher
higher education varies by country, with
proportion of females may be enrolled, yet
females often concentrated in certain
remain the minority in specific disciplines
disciplines, and their participation falling
within STEM such as physics, mathematics
as the level of education increases.
and engineering such as in Malaysia, Mongolia
and the Republic of Korea. Despite increasing
access to higher education for girls, this does First looking at the proportion of female
not always translate to participation in STEM graduates in science programmes in tertiary
fields of study. Globally, data shows that despite education in Asia, data shows that as of
increased parity in enrolment at the Bachelor’s1 2011, this stood at 59 per cent in Malaysia as
level (or equivalent) in higher education, in opposed to just 11 per cent in Cambodia as
STEM disciplines male students outnumber of 2008 (UIS, 2014c). Looking more closely at
female students in 91 per cent of countries with national data within STEM disciplines among
available data (UNESCO, 2010b, p. 5). Findings the seven countries, a higher proportion of
from the OECD also argue that young women females are found in certain disciplines such as
are far less likely to opt for STEM fields of study pharmacy, medicine and biology yet remain
at the Bachelor’s level, and this only declines underrepresented in others such as computer
further from the Master’s level and above science, physics and engineering. For instance
(OECD, 2011, p. 2). in Malaysia, which among the seven countries
showed the highest proportion of female
This also raises important questions as to the graduates in science programmes, 72 per cent
possible linkages between participation in of students enrolled in pharmacy were female,
higher education and student performance as opposed to just 36 per cent of students
at the upper secondary level with regard to in engineering as of 2012 (MoHE, 2013). As
STEM-related subjects such as mathematics of 2013 in Mongolia, 73 per cent of students
and science. Looking at this age range, the enrolled in biology were female as opposed
to 30 per cent in computer science and just
24 per cent in engineering (MEDS, 2013). With
1 The levels of higher education cited in this publication reflect the a similar situation identified among other
2011 International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) as
developed by the UNESCO Institute of Statistics. countries, this indicates that further analysis
3
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
may be required to better understand the prominent gender gaps occur at the highest
low participation of women in specific STEM levels of performance with boys outperforming
disciplines such as computer science, physics girls markedly (Stoet and Geary, 2013). When it
and engineering. Among those women who comes to student participation in prestigious
are enrolled in STEM fields however, data competitions in STEM-related fields such as
shows that the proportion of female students the International Olympiads for instance, data
tends to fall as the level of education increases shows that in the year 2014, female medallists,
beyond Bachelor’s level or equivalent within and more generally female contestants, were
and beyond STEM fields of study. As of 2011 significantly underrepresented. For instance,
in the Republic of Korea for instance, while the the percentage of female contestants stood
proportion of females enrolled at Bachelor’s level at just 4 per cent for informatics, 5 per cent for
stood at 52 per cent in science and 19.5 per cent mathematics and 6 per cent for physics, yet it
in engineering, at doctoral level female reached an average of 28 per cent in biology
enrolment was 38 per cent in science and just among countries in the region, the latter
12 per cent in engineering (WISET, 2014). reflecting the findings on female enrolment
within STEM disciplines in higher education
(IBO, 2014; IOI, 2014; IMO, 2014; IPhO, 2014).
Learning achievement among females
Even among delegations from countries where
and males in mathematics and science
learning achievement in mathematics and
is mixed. Yet females are significantly
science is largely in favour of female students,
underrepresented among the highest
this was not reflected. In delegations from
levels of achievement.
Malaysia and Thailand for instance, there
were no female contestants in the
In international assessments such as the International Olympiads in informatics or
Programme for International Student Assess physics (IOI, 2014; IPhO, 2014).
ment (PISA) for instance, results show that
overall females appear to be increasingly
There are linkages between gender
catching up to males in STEM-related subjects,
differences in learning achievement and
particularly in science. At the same time a
female participation in STEM fields of
more noticeable difference in achievement
study in higher education.
is observed in mathematics – either in favour
of boys or in favour of girls – showing very
different patterns with regard to the gender Based on the analysis in this report, linkages
gap in achievement both among the highest can be identified between gender differences
and lowest performing countries. According to in learning achievement in mathematics and
PISA 2012 results for instance, boys outscored science and the proportion of females entering
girls in mathematics by 18 points in both Japan STEM fields of study in higher education.
and the Republic of Korea – two countries that For instance in countries where the gender
rank among the highest performing, whereas gap in achievement is in favour of boys, it
girls outscored boys by 8 points in Malaysia and appears that a comparatively lower proportion
by 14 points in Thailand – two countries which of females are enrolling or graduating in
perform below the OECD average (OECD, 2014). STEM fields of study as opposed to countries
where the gender gap in achievement is
According to a study analyzing PISA results in favour of girls. At the same time, data on
over ten years, it appears that the most female participation in STEM fields in higher
4
education, even among countries that show a
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
higher degree of participation, shows that they Gender-responsive teacher training in
tend to be concentrated in specific disciplines STEM-related subjects is lacking.
within STEM. This implies that a number
of wider influences may be at play beyond The findings also indicate that there is a lack
learning achievement and enrolment issues. of teacher training policies to properly prepare
teachers in STEM-related subjects through
How did we get here? gender-responsive teaching strategies. This
was reflected in the findings based on the
Educational impacts data collected from classroom observations
At the policy level, specific gender-sensitive or for the purpose of this study. While broadly
STEM-related policy frameworks on education there appeared to be equal treatment of
are difficult to identify, and where they exist, both female and male students by teachers
it is difficult to see how far these have been in mathematics and science classes, different
implemented. Looking more broadly at how patterns were identified in some cases. For
educational aspects may influence interest in instance in Indonesia, female students were
STEM among female students, the following shown to be more engaged and to participate
findings have been identified: more actively in asking questions that their
male peers. In Cambodia however, it was
found that while female students tended to
There are fewer female teachers in
give more correct answers, they demonstrated
STEM-related subjects and at higher
higher levels of reluctance, shakiness and
levels of education.
anxiety in answering questions, with some
female students even waiting until the class
At the school level, there are a limited number was over to ask specific questions to their
of female teachers in mathematics and science teachers. In Viet Nam, while male students
subjects, which limits the number of role seemed less confident in presenting in front
models for female students in learning these of the classroom, the number of interactions
subjects. Out of 20 classes observed in Nepal as between teachers and male students were far
part of this research, eight out of ten teachers higher than with female students, averaging
were male in science classes, and nine out of at 65 per cent for mathematics and 61 per
ten teachers were male in mathematics. Even cent for science. This indicates that gender-
in countries that have seen the increased responsive teacher training in these subjects
feminization of the teaching profession, could help address the different needs and
the proportion of female teachers tends to behaviours of female and male students.
drop, across all fields of study, as the level of
education increases. In the Republic of Korea
Resources and equipment can stimulate
for instance, data from 2013 shows that while
interest among girls in learning
the proportion of female teachers stood at
STEM-related subjects.
99.2 per cent at the pre-primary level and
78.2 per cent at the primary level, they made
up 46.7 per cent of teachers at the upper Looking more closely at teaching strategies, there
secondary level and just 34.1 per cent in higher is a need for gender-responsive teacher training
education, and we may only assume that these with regard to STEM. In addition, availability of
rates would be lower in STEM-related subjects. resources and equipment for the teaching of
5
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
6
however, some scholarships for students to Based on the results from the student
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
pursue STEM disciplines include quotas in questionnaire conducted as part of this study,
order to increase opportunities for female it appears that while female and male students
students (MSIP, 2014b). Greater opportunities often choose mathematics and science among
for gender-sensitive career counselling in their most enjoyed subjects, mathematics is
schools, scholarships as well as mentoring more likely to appear among the most enjoyed
opportunities for young female professionals for males, and science subjects are more likely
would arguably help not only attract but also to appear among the most enjoyed subjects
retain more females in STEM fields. for females. At the same time, mathematics is
also more likely to appear among the lowest
Psychosocial Influences perceived performance and science among
Psychosocial aspects can significantly the highest perceived performance subjects
impact upon female participation in STEM for female students. This indicates that male
fields. The importance of these influences students appear to prefer mathematics
in shaping student attitudes, achievement whereas females appear to prefer science,
and eventually participation in STEM fields which to a certain extent may be consistent
has been increasingly recognized through with the patterns observed in the gender
a growing body of research. In particular, differences in achievement in international
studies point to the need to recognize the assessments.
vulnerability of female students to the threat
of negative stereotypes and the importance
Females may experience higher
of students developing a ‘growth mindset’
rates of anxiety around mathematics
where capability or talent is developed over
and science subjects.
time – it is not predetermined at birth (Hill,
Corbett, and St Rose, 2013). Related to the
wider issue of negative stereotype threat, the Looking at student attitudes towards
gender dimension of student interest and mathematics and science subjects in terms of
attitudes towards mathematics and science interest, perceived importance, confidence,
may not only affect learning achievement in anxiety, as well as motivation and perseverance,
these subjects but also choices for further study different findings arose among the seven
and careers. According to a 2011 OECD report countries. The questionnaire results showed
on gender equality in education, employment that females may experience higher rates
and entrepreneurship, it appears that gender of anxiety around mathematics and science
differences in these choices could be more subjects. This appeared to be consistent
influenced by psychosocial aspects such as across all countries where the gender gap in
motivation, confidence and perseverance than participation and learning achievement was
by one’s ability or performance (OECD, 2011, either in favour girls or boys in mathematics and
p. 2). This study considered these influences, science. This suggests that even when females
particularly through the collection of primary perform better in mathematics and science,
data in the seven countries, which brought they may experience higher anxiety towards
about a number of key findings: these subjects than their male counterparts.
There are gender differences in subject The importance of parental and teacher
preferences and perceived performance. encouragement cannot be underestimated.
7
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Parental and teacher encouragement with (Hill, Corbett, and St Rose, 2013, p. 41). Estimates
regard to mathematics and science can impact show that women make up just 30 per cent of
student attitudes towards these subjects, and science researchers globally (UIS, 2014a), and
could provide an important area for further the OECD argues that the lack of professional role
investigation. Based on the questionnaire models for young women in STEM professions
results, female and male students equally could be a factor influencing lower levels of
perceived encouragement from their parents participation (OECD, 2011, p. 28). There also
and teachers as important. Analysis from appears to be a mismatch within STEM fields
Cambodia also shows that based on the that females are choosing to pursue as opposed
results of the questionnaire, correlations to those for which there is demand. For instance
exist between the perceived importance of in Mongolia, female STEM professionals may find
parental encouragement towards mathematics themselves unemployed due to lack of demand
and science and the student’s perceived in certain STEM fields, while at the same time the
importance of those subjects. Parental and country is facing a high demand for engineers
teacher encouragement, therefore, could be due to its booming mining sector (Khishigbuyan,
fundamental for all students in addressing 2014). In other countries such as the Republic of
environmental and psychosocial influences Korea, data shows that female graduates in STEM
which have so far limited the participation of fields are also less likely to be employed than their
women in STEM fields. male counterparts.
8
“We need more role models, and more female
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
teachers in STEM-related subjects at secondary
level. Girls need to develop an attitude to be
self-motivated and learn independently, and it
also depends a lot on improving students’ and
parents’ attitudes to be more familiar with STEM
fields to overcome the fear of their daughters
obtaining a job in the future” – Kayo Inaba
Asia-Pacific Laureate of the 2014 L’Oréal-UNESCO For Women in Science Awards, Japan
Looking at participation within STEM fields, Women are also concentrated at lower levels
women appear to be concentrated in specific and ranks within STEM occupations, where they
occupations – a similar pattern to enrolment are less likely to reach higher level positions. In
of female students in STEM by field of study in the case of the Republic of Korea for instance,
higher education. Here, a higher proportion of women are more likely to be in non-regular
women work in professions related to medicine or temporary work, which can greatly affect
or biology as opposed to a low proportion of their prospects for promotion to higher level
women working in physics or engineering, positions. At the same time, it appears that
which relates to the proportion of female limited support offered to women working
students enrolled in these respective fields in STEM fields may affect retention as well as
of study in higher education. In Malaysia for progression in these fields due to the difficulties
instance, 72.9 per cent of pharmacists are female faced in maintaining a balance between family
as opposed to just 10.6 per cent of professional responsibilities and professional life – a balance
engineers (DoHE, 2014). In Indonesia, the which could also be shared by male scientists.
Gender Parity Index (GPI)2 among senior STEM
researchers receiving grants in the year 2013 was
Gender differences in learning achievement
1.8 in biology and just 0.1 in physics (Directorate
and the number of female researchers in
of Research and Community Services, 2014).
STEM fields are likely related.
9
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
in Malaysia (49 per cent) and Thailand factors allows one to critically assess how
(51 per cent), girls tend to outscore boys in their impacts may be carefully unwound.
these subjects in international assessments The following provides a summary of
(UIS, 2014d). In countries where a lower the key recommendations governments
proportion of researchers are female such and policymakers of Asia may consider in
as the Republic of Korea (17 per cent) and addressing this important shortage:
Japan (14 per cent), boys tend to outscore
girls in mathematics and science (Ibid). • Further data disaggregated by sex is needed
to conduct in-depth analysis at country level
and help provide a clearer picture of women
Where to from here? and girls’ participation within STEM, which will
As these findings illustrate, women are inform policies and programmes for increased
poorly represented in STEM fields of study participation of women in STEM-related
education and employment sectors such as
and occupations in most, if not all countries
engineering and physics.
under analysis. This trend is not surprising,
given the dearth of female representation in • G
ender-responsive action from
STEM worldwide and the concerning statistics governments, through education and
regarding female 'talent shortage' in STEM labour market policies, enforcement of
related fields of occupations. Findings here gender-related laws, as well as specific
have also demonstrated the multivariate initiatives for advocacy and awareness
factors and influences contributing to the raising, is needed to attract more women
lack of engagement of women in STEM: and girls into STEM fields.
educational, psychosocial and economic, • In order to ensure the effective
and their compounding nature; these factors implementation of policies related
undoubtedly intersect to inform and shape to education, gender and/or STEM,
attitudes as part of an ongoing feedback loop. coordination between ministries
should be strengthened. This may
This is not to suggest that these factors are involve joint programmes across various
irreversible and the greater engagement government sectors such as ministries
of women in STEM study and occupation of education, women’s affairs or gender
is somehow out of reach. On the contrary, equality, science, technology and
the identification of these multivariate innovation, as well as labour.
ROLE MODELS
ASPIRATION
EQUALITY
Girls and
Women in
STEM
10
• C
urricula and learning materials should learning but also increasing student interest
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
undergo further rigorous review from a in learning these subjects.
gender perspective to ensure that they do not
• S tructured and formalized gender-
perpetuate gender stereotypes. This would
responsive career counselling
ideally involve a representative group of
programmes should be considered in order
stakeholders with male and female experts in
for both female and male students to have
order to ensure different perspectives.
support and objective guidance as they
• T
eacher education and policies begin to shape their career choices.
on recruitment must ensure a fair
• S
cholarship programmes targeted
representation of both male and female
at women and girls in STEM would also
teachers in all subjects, including
contribute to increased opportunities for
mathematics and science, at all levels of
young women to pursue further study
education and especially in higher levels
and eventually careers in STEM fields.
of education where students look to their
teachers as role models as they begin to • Promoting more female role models in
shape career perspectives and choices. STEM fields, whether female teachers in
• T eacher education, be they pre- and mathematics and science at the secondary
in-service programmes, should be transformed level, female students and faculty members
to ensure that teachers are trained in gender- in higher education, and more broadly
responsive teaching strategies so that more women working in STEM fields, is an
female and male students can develop their important strategy to attract women and
full potential in STEM-related subjects. girls into STEM fields.
ppropriate funding for equipment and
• A • Finally, adequate support programmes and
resources should be allocated in order to initiatives for female STEM professionals
stimulate student interest in mathematics and would help to address some of the factors
science, particularly among female students. which can cause them to discontinue their
Allowing students to practically apply their careers, including family responsibilities. This
learning in real-life situations as well as will also help them be equipped with the most
creative and hands-on experiments will not up-to-date knowledge and skills in fields which
only contribute to enhancing the quality of experience fast-paced change and innovation.
11
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
1 Introduction
Gender disparities in learning achievement, declines at every stage of upper secondary and
particularly in mathematics and science, have higher education, as does the proportion of
been subject to intense policy debates in the women choosing to pursue careers in STEM
field of education (Griffin and Nguyen, 2011). fields and advancing to the highest positions
Although the latest results from international (Hill et al., 2013). Based on the findings from a
assessments such as the Programme for study conducted in 14 countries4 (BCG, 2014,
International Student Assessment (PISA) show p.1), it is estimated that on average, female
that boys continue to outperform girls on students in upper secondary have a 35 per
average, this gap varies by country and tends cent probability of enrolling in STEM, an 18 per
to be narrow, especially in science (OECD, cent chance of graduating with a Bachelor’s
2014). While girls are increasingly perceived as degree in a science-related field, an 8 per
‘catching up’ to boys in terms of performance in cent probability of graduating with a Master’s
these subjects at the secondary education level, degree in science, and a 2 per cent probability
this does not always lead to the furtherance of of becoming a Doctor in science. By contrast,
these subjects or related fields of study at the the probabilities for males are 77, 37, 18, and
level of higher education and eventually to 6 per cent respectively.
flow on career choices in Science, Technology,
Engineering and Mathematics fields (STEM).3 At In terms of the most prestigious awards in
the same time, as demand continues to rise for STEM fields, only a small proportion have been
professionals in STEM (ManpowerGroup, 2014), awarded to women. Looking at the Nobel
these remain fields in which women are largely Prize for instance, out of 199 laurates in Physics,
underrepresented, making up less than 30 per 169 in Chemistry and 207 in Medicine, there
cent of researchers globally (UIS, 2014a). were only two female laureates in physics,
four in chemistry and 11 in medicine between
Studies indicate that while there may be 1901 and 2014 (Nobelprize.org, 2014). The
gender equality in achievement at the primary Fields Medal, which was initiated in 1936 and
and lower secondary school level with regard to is considered the most prestigious prize in
STEM-related subjects, the proportion of female mathematics, was only obtained for the first
students opting for these subjects rapidly time by a woman, Maryam Mirzakhani from
3N
ote that a precise definition or categorization of disciplines 4 This citation refers to findings based on 14 countries analyzed:
or occupations within STEM may differ from country to country. Argentina, Brazil, China, Egypt, France, Germany, India, Indonesia,
For the purpose of this study, STEM refers to a broad definition Japan, Morocco, South Africa, Spain, United Kingdom and the
including natural sciences, computer science and engineering United States.
as well as medical science.
12
Iran, in 2014 out of a total of 56 medallists in secondary education (UNESCO, 2014a). In
1 INTRODUCTION
(IMU, 2014). At the same time, data on student Asia, a number of contrasting characteristics
delegations participating in STEM-related can be identified. In some countries reviewed
International Olympiads5 also shows that female in this report, such as Malaysia and Mongolia,
students have been and continue to be largely a reversed ‘gender gap’ can be observed as
absent, and even more so among medallists enrolment rates at secondary and higher
(Ellison and Swanson, 2010; Jones, 2006). education are now higher for girls than for boys
(UNGEI, 2012). Other countries in the region,
While overall access and participation in however, show that a substantial gender gap
STEM fields of study may reflect one aspect remains with girls making up just 41 per cent
of the gender gap, STEM fields are vast, with of students enrolled in secondary education in
stark differences in levels of participation in Pakistan and just 34 per cent in Afghanistan as
fields such as biology or medicine, as opposed of 2011 (UNESCO, 2014b).
to other fields where they remain far less
represented such as chemistry, physics and Looking more closely at performance in
engineering, among others (Hill, Corbett, mathematics and science through a ‘gender
and St Rose, 2013). This raises important lense’, this stark contrast can also be identified
questions with regard to the factors which in the results of international assessments. In
may affect young women and men’s interest the Republic of Korea for instance, both 2012
and performance in mathematics and science PISA results as well as 2011 results in the Trends
subjects, their prospects of progressing to in International Mathematics and Science
study STEM fields in higher education, and Study (TIMSS) show that boys outscore girls in
eventually in pursuing a career in STEM. mathematics and science, whereas in Thailand
girls outscore boys in mathematics and science
As we arrive at the target date for achievement (OECD, 2014). Perhaps relatedly, the proportion
of the Education for All (EFA) Goals and the of female researchers in science stands at
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) 51 per cent in Thailand as opposed to 17 per
in 2015, it is important that the post-2015 cent in the Republic of Korea (UIS, 2014a). At
development agenda reflects a number of the same time, a global annual talent survey
areas related to the context of this study, such conducted by ManpowerGroup indicates
as learning achievement and more broadly the that as of 2014, the Asia-Pacific has a regional
quality of education, as well as the importance talent shortage of 45 per cent,6 reaching 81
of STEM sectors in their contribution to per cent in Japan alone, and with the most
economic and social development. There in demand categories comprising mostly
has undeniably been remarkable progress in STEM‑related jobs with engineering in first
achieveing gender equality both in terms of place (ManpowerGroup, 2014).
access to and advancement in education
(IIEP, 2012). As of 2011, however, globally only This report seeks to explore the various factors
60 per cent of countries had achieved gender that influence female and male student
parity in primary education, and a mere performance, interests, and perspectives on
38 per cent of countries had achieved parity study and career choice in STEM fields, by:
5 I nternational Olympiads are held each year in various fields, 6 A talent shortage refers to a shortage of labour in terms of
where each participating country usually sends a delegation specific skills and abilities.
of 4-6 highest achieving upper secondary students
13
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
14
and learning conditions, private tutoring, 2 Reflect different geographical distributions
2 RESEARCH FRAMEWORK
career counselling as well as scholarship and and various sub-regions of Asia, for example,
mentoring opportunities are then analyzed Central Asia (Mongolia), East Asia (Republic of
in Chapter Five. Chapter Six considers Korea), South Asia (Nepal), and Southeast Asia
psychosocial influences, including student (Cambodia, Indonesia, Malaysia and Viet Nam);
attitudes, self-belief, motivation and aspiration
towards mathematics and science subjects. 3 Examine more generally different cultural
Labour market effects, including the proportion backgrounds and perspectives. In addition,
of female professionals in STEM fields both by countries from Asia that currently participate
occupation as well as by type of employment in international assessments such as PISA
are then examined in Chapter Seven. Finally, and TIMSS are referred to in Chapter Four
Chapter Eight reflects findings presented in the of this report, which of the seven countries
previous chapters in order to provide policy reviewed, include Indonesia, Malaysia, Viet
suggestions, while Chapter Nine provides a Nam, and the Republic of Korea. Across
conclusion to this report. these seven countries, different social and
cultural contexts, contrasting issues with
regard to gender, learning achievement and
2 Research Framework the varying proportions of women in STEM
fields are reflected.
This report presents the research findings of
a desk study prepared by UNESCO Bangkok Analytical Framework:
which examined the current global and
regional situation of girls and women in The analytical framework for this study
STEM, in addition to in-country research. informed both regional and in-country research.
Seven countries were reviewed across various This is displayed in Figure 3 where learning
sub-regions of Asia – Cambodia, Indonesia, achievement in mathematics and science, as
Malaysia, Mongolia, Nepal, the Republic of well as student progression to study STEM fields
Korea and Viet Nam. The report also draws of study in higher education, are influenced by
upon relevant findings from other countries three main dimensions – educational, psycho
in the region and beyond. The selection of social and labour market influences.
countries reflect those proposed for review by
the Korean Women’s Development Institute Figure 3 Analytical framework: the gender dimension of
(KWDI) including Cambodia, Indonesia and Viet learning achievement and progression to STEM
Nam, as well as four other countries, Malaysia,
Educational
Mongolia, Nepal and the Republic of Korea,
included by UNESCO for a wider regional
review. Overall, the selection of these seven
countries was made in order to: Learning
Acheivement Progression
in Maths and to STEM in
1 Reflect countries with different income
▲
Science in Higher
Secondary Education
levels, for instance high income (Republic Education
of Korea), upper middle income (Malaysia),
lower middle income (Indonesia, Mongolia Psychosocial Labour Market
15
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
In-country research was carried out by national 6. Reflections and analysis, with the
researchers to provide a detailed analysis aim of analyzing the possible links
based on the analytical framework provided between the different factors explored in
(Figure 3) and three main research methods: previous chapters while keeping in mind
the country context.
1 Desk studies;
7. National level policy
2 Student questionnaire; and recommendations, in order to identify
3 Classroom observations. overarching regional as well as country-
specific issues.
Country reports adopted the following outline:
16
Table 1 Urban and rural research locations by country
2 RESEARCH FRAMEWORK
Country Urban Rural
Phnom Penh, Kampong Chhnang,
Cambodia Kampong Chhnang, Kampong Speu, Kandal.
Preah Sihanouk.
Jakarta, Medan, Palembang, Pangkalan susu, Perdagangan, Indralaya,
Indonesia
Makassar, Samarinda. Stabat, Babalan, Tebing Tinggi, Lumbung, Percut.
Malaysia Kuala Lumpur, Petaling Jaya, Seri Petaling. Alor Setar, Kulim, Jitra.
17
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Classroom sample 5 5
10
(total of 10 classrooms) (1 classroom from each school) (1 classroom from each school)
25 25
Student sample Female (5 female students from each (5 female students from each 50
(total of 100 students in classroom) classroom)
8-9th grade (or equivalent for 25 25
students that are 15 years old) Male (5 male students from each (5 male students from each 50
classroom) classroom)
7 S tudents 15 years of age were chosen for the survey because this: a) corresponds to the age at which inter-
national assessments are taken; b) reflects the age at which students in most countries are at a crossroads
with regard to the end of basic education; and c) reflects different expectations in forming choices on
further study and careers for 15 year old girls and boys in different sociocultural contexts.
8 Some of the questions in this questionnaire have been adapted from the OECD’s PISA 2012 survey, which
can be found at: http://www.oecd.org/pisa/pisaproducts/PISA%202012%20framework%20e-book_final.pdf
18
Table 3 School and classroom sample for classroom observations
2 RESEARCH FRAMEWORK
Classroom observations
Grades 8-9th grade (or equivalent for students that are 15 years old)
Schools Urban Rural
4 (1 school from each district) 4 (1 school from each district)
Subjects Mathematics Science Mathematics Science
2 2 2 2
Total classes 8 classes in 8 different schools
19
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
In two countries, national researchers resources and thus provided differing levels
collected additional primary data through of analysis. Because of this, it was not always
interviews and group discussions in order to easy to draw correlations from responses.
supplement existing findings. In Indonesia In addition, some countries may have
for instance, semi-structured interviews were experienced complications in carrying out the
carried out with a total of ten respondents, data collection which may have affected the
including five teachers and five female STEM results. For instance in the Republic of Korea,
professionals working in diverse fields (e.g. the majority of teachers initially contacted
physics, pharmacy, and electronics). These to conduct the student questionnaire
interviews were conducted over a period of and classroom observations declined to
90 minutes, and focused on teaching, learning participate, meaning that those who eventually
and working conditions in STEM, based on participated in this research were those that
guiding questions (see Annex 3). In Nepal, allowed open access. This could potentially
group discussions were conducted in each have positively skewed the results of the data
of the sample schools involving both the collection in terms of teacher preparation for
school head teacher and mathematics and class, teacher interaction with students, and
science teachers in a total group comprising teacher influence on student attitudes. At the
five respondents. Questions explored in these same time, analysis of previous experiences
group discussions were also derived from the indicates that the reason why teachers at the
original research questions as presented in the secondary level may hesitate to open their
research framework. classrooms to the public is due to the fear
that their performance would be assessed
(Yun, 2012).
Limitations
Due to limited resources, time and In addition, findings on parental and teacher
location-specific factors, primary data collection influences on student attitudes in learning
was limited to small samples in a number mathematics and science were based on
of provinces in each of the seven countries student responses to the questionnaire as
under review. Therefore, this regional synthesis opposed to teacher or parent responses.
report aims to provide only examples in these However, in some cases such as Cambodia,
country case studies and others in the region the results of the questionnaire and classroom
based on the data that was collected for this observations were shown to be consistent
study. It cannot, therefore, claim to reflect with findings from previous studies on
regional trends or be fully representative of related topics in the country. With regard to
the population of the seven countries or of the secondary data analysis, a lack of available data
entire region. In addition, while all countries meant that comparability could not always
followed the research guidelines as far as be ensured among countries. Therefore,
possible, the sample size varied slightly above the latest available data in some countries
or below the recommended figure. While included in this report may not be up to date
in general, most countries showed a high in comparison to others. Nonetheless, this
response rate, in other countries the response regional synthesis report presents the findings
rate was lower for some questions. In terms of of an exploratory study, which despite these
questionnaire analysis, countries used various limitations, does not diminish the value of the
methods for data analysis depending on local overall findings, analysis and conclusions.
20
n Part A
Social and cultural norms towards women can whether through the family, community
greatly influence their opportunities in access and wider society can also influence the
and participation in STEM. According to a choices of young women and have been
regional report by the World Bank (2012), social identified as one major cause behind the
norms, especially with regard to the perceived lower proportion of women in STEM fields. In
role of women as caregivers, can impact their fact, academics have often described the low
chosen fields of study and careers. For instance, proportion of women in science as caused by
the higher rate of women choosing to pursue “subtle messages in the media and society”
professions such as teaching may (BBC, 2011). Before exploring the seven country
be due to the perception that such professions cases in more detail, Table 4 presents an
allow more flexibility to balance family and overview of female participation in higher
work responsibilities (World Bank, 2012, p. education both across fields of study as well
36). A multitude of social and cultural factors, as within science programmes.
Table 4 Participation in higher education across all fields and female participation in science programmes
Proportion of female
Gender Parity
Gross Enrolment Ratio (GER) students in science
Index (GPI)
programmes (%)
Total Female Male
Cambodia -1
15.83 12.01 19.59 0.6135 13.9 -3
Indonesia -1 31.51 32.05 30.98 1.0347 -
Malaysia -2
35.97 39.08 32.70 1.19531 48.19
Mongolia -1
61.10 72.38 50.03 1.44695 40.2
Nepal -2 14.49 11.42 17.93 0.63685 26.17
Republic of Korea -1 98.38 83.55 111.48 0.74951 30.63
Viet Nam -2
24.60 -1
24.63 24.24 1.01619 -
Notes: Data as of year -1 = 2012, -2 = 2011, -3 = 2004 for all fields by country unless indicated. Proportion of female students in science
programmes not available for Indonesia and Viet Nam.
The levels of higher education cited in this publication reflect the 2011 International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) as
developed by the UNESCO Institute of Statistics.
Source: UIS, 2014b
21
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
In examining the gender dimension of access system established in 1924, which presented
to and participation in STEM, particularly in the first opportunity for female students to
higher education, it is important to briefly enrol in formal schooling (Szmodies and
consider the sociocultural context of the Eng, 2014). Following the genocide war
seven countries reviewed, before providing between 1975-79, approximately 75 per cent
an overview of participation in STEM fields of of teachers at all levels of education were
study in higher education as well as examples killed, as well as 96 per cent of university
in technical and vocational education at the students and 67 per cent of students in
tertiary education level. Together, these areas primary and secondary education; leaving 90
will be explored in this chapter as contextual per cent of education infrastructure entirely
background not only with regard to the destroyed (Ayers, 2000; Clayton, 1998). It was
region and countries under review, but also not until the 1990s that improving political
as background to the subsequent chapters stability allowed for the education system to
in this report. reorganize (Chandler, 2008).
22
Indonesia Malaysia
23
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
24
in higher education which includes 69.4 per this report shows that in recent years, the
25
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
reflected in the participation of female and and health fields being female, as opposed
male students in STEM fields of study in higher to an average of 75 per cent of graduates in
education. This section is comprised of two mathematics and engineering being male
parts and will first provide an overview at the (Ibid, p. 25). Within Asia, a substantial gap
regional level based on the desk study, before was identified in Japan with regard to tertiary
a more focused analysis on the seven country degrees in engineering, manufacturing and
case studies. construction, where only 11 per cent of
graduates were female, compared to just over
Regional overview 50 per cent of female graduates in Indonesia
Despite increasing access to education for girls as of 2008 (Ibid). The following case study on
in higher education, this may not necessarily China and Japan presented in Box 1, which
reflect participation specifically in STEM fields of is based on a study by the Boston Consulting
study in higher education. Globally, data shows Group, further illustrates the decline in the
that despite increased parity in enrolment at proportion of women in science fields as
the Bachelor’s11 level (or equivalent) in higher the level of education increases.
education, in STEM disciplines male students
outnumber female students in 91 per cent of Among countries in Asia, different levels of
countries with available data (UNESCO, 2010b, participation can be identified with regard to
p. 5). Findings from the OECD also argue that female enrolment in STEM fields of study in
young women are far less likely to opt for STEM higher education. Based on available data by
fields of study at the Bachelor’s level, and this country, the proportion of female graduates
only declines further from the Master’s level in science programmes in higher education is
and above (OECD, 2011, p. 2). In addition, the presented in Figure 4. Here, countries such as
study also shows that in OECD countries there Malaysia and Mongolia show a relatively higher
is a significant gender difference with regard proportion of female graduates at 42 and
to fields of study chosen, with an average of 43 per cent respectively, compared to others
71 per cent of graduates in the humanities such as Japan at just 14 per cent and Cambodia
Box 1 Proportion of women in science fields by academic level in China and Japan (%)
A study by the Boston Consulting Group further explores this growing gender gap in science starting from upper secondary
level up until high-level academic positions with specific data available from China and Japan. In the case of these two
countries, the point at which the gap occurs is identified at the Bachelor's level (BCG, 2014, p. 6).
Researcher
High school Bachelor Master Doctorate
Career
China 46% 28% 28% 18% 25%
Japan 51% 23% 14% 24% 14%
26
Figure 4 Proportion of female graduates in science programmes in tertiary education in Asia (%)
Myanmar – 2 67.22
Uzbekistan – 2 59.36
Malaysia – 2 58.86
Kyrgyzstan – 1 53.61
Mongolia – 2 42.89
Cambodia – 3 11.18
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Notes: T his data reflects graduates of levels 5 and 6 of the 2011 International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED), which are
equivalent to Diploma (level 5) and Bachelors (level 6) or equivalent.
Data as of 1= 2012; 2= 2011; 3= 2008; 4= 2006. Data not available for Indonesia, Nepal and Viet Nam.
Source: UIS, 2014c
at a mere 10 per cent (UIS, 2014c). These others. For some countries, however, accessing
findings bring forward questions as to what higher education in general presents in itself a
factors may influence female students in their significant setback, let alone entering specific
distinct choices for further study and careers STEM fields. For instance, despite increased
across different countries of the region. enrolment in higher education in Cambodia
for more than a decade (MoEYS, 2014), overall,
Country case studies only 15.83 per cent of Cambodian students
Looking more closely at enrolment in STEM were enrolled in higher education across all
fields of study within and across the seven fields as of 2012, with the latest available data
countries revealed that while women make for the proportion of female students standing
up a sizeable proportion of students in some at 13.9 per cent as of 2004 (UIS, 2014b). Indeed,
disciplines, they may also remain a minority in despite slight increases in the last decade,
27
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
the proportion of female students across all (MoET, 2014). Though the latest available data
fields of study in higher education remains by field of study is from 2006, it is possible
low with a Gender Parity Index (GPI)12 of 0.61 to observe that at that time, female students
as of 2012, enrolling at half the rate of their were more likely to specialize in education, the
male counterparts (UIS, 2014b). Nonetheless, humanities and arts – fields in which 41 per
results from the questionnaire conducted in cent of all female students were enrolled as
Cambodia indicate that parental engagement opposed to 26 per cent of all male students. By
in education, specifically concerning STEM contrast, men were more likely to specialize in
disciplines, does not differ significantly by engineering, manufacturing and construction,
sex, while parents and students both place fields which included 29 per cent of all male
more importance on mathematics education students enrolled in higher education as
compared to science education. Based on opposed to just 11 per cent of all female
this, choices in higher education show that students (World Bank, 2011, p. 29). The data
a majority of Cambodian students enrol in shows an even greater concentration of male
business and accounting fields, which rely students when it comes to engineering, which
heavily on mathematics. By contrast, the is consistent with findings in other countries.
sciences remain one of the least popular
fields of study, which could be a result of both In the case of Indonesia, a country in
parental and student ideas surrounding the which women are generally well represented
most profitable and prestigious career in higher education in comparison to other
choices (HRINC, 2010). countries, variations can also be observed
within STEM fields of study. Based on data from
The seven country case studies provide selected universities, women are concentrated
more detailed findings in terms of female in certain disciplines within STEM, and are better
participation in higher education, particularly represented in disciplines such as pharmacy and
with regard to fields of study within STEM. biology, yet slightly underrepresented in others
These data sets will be presented by country, such as physics (DoHE, 2014). Nonetheless, the
and while it would be ideal for subjects proportion of women in general among STEM
to follow the same categorization and fields in these Indonesian universities is notable
classification, these may differ across countries. as reflected in Figure 5.
In Viet Nam for instance, opportunities for
young women to enter higher education also An even higher proportion of women in
remained limited, where large increases in STEM fields of study can be found in Malaysia,
participation can be observed. For instance, a country which presents an exceptional
in comparing new entrant rates at the case in this study. For instance, overall, the
university level between the academic years of entrance, enrolment and graduation rates
2012-2013 and 2013-2014, the rate of female of female students are higher than that of
students increased from 30.29 per cent to their male counterparts with female students
52.49 per cent, whereas it declined in male representing approximately 63 per cent of
students from 69.71 per cent to 47.51 per cent total student enrolment across all fields of
study as of 2012 (MoHE, 2013). Looking more
specifically at enrolment rates in higher
12 The gender parity index (GPI) is the most common measure
of gender parity in access to education for female and male education by STEM disciplines, as observed
students where the figure 1 would constitute perfect gender
parity, whereas a figure below 1 would show access in favour of
in Figure 6, the latest available data from
male students and above one in favour of female students. 2012 shows that female students outnumber
28
Figure 5 Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in selected universities in Indonesia by sex (%)
Medicine 73 27
0 20 40 60 80 100
Female Male
Note: A
ll data presented in this figure is based on enrolment rates at the undergraduate level at the Bandung Institute of Technology and the
University of Indonesia (Jakarta), with the exception of pharmacy, which is based on data from Gajah Mada University.
Source: DoHE, 2014; Yogyakarta Statistics, 2013.
Figure 6 Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in higher education in Malaysia in 2012 by sex (%)
Pharmacy 72 28
Medicine 62 38
Manufacturing, Processing
54 46
and Technology
Information Technology 51 49
and Communication
Engineering 36 64
0 20 40 60 80 100
Female Male
Source: Adapted from MoHE, 2013
male students in all STEM disciplines with the The concentration of female and male students
sole exception of engineering, where 36 per in certain disciplines is also identified in the
cent of students enrolled are female. While case of Mongolia, where despite the relatively
this latter finding may be consistent with high average of female graduates in science
findings from other countries, comparatively, and technology at 43 per cent (as highlighted
female students in Malaysia remain better in Figure 4), female students are both over-
represented in engineering at 36 per cent and under-represented in certain disciplines.
than in other countries. For example, while they made up the majority
29
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Figure 7 Proportion of students enrolled in STEM disciplines in higher education in Mongolia as of 2013 by sex (%)
Biology 75 25
Mathematics 58 42
and Statistics
Manufacturing 45 55
Technology
Physics, Chemistry, 41 59
Geology and Geography
Computer Science 30 70
Construction Architecture 26 74
Engineering 23 77
0 20 40 60 80 100
Female Male
Note: Data for the field, Physics, chemistry, geology and geography, is only available in this grouped category.
Source: MEDS, 2013
in biology and mathematics, they were a the other hand, the low proportion of female
minority in others, with the lowest proportion students enrolled in engineering, which
in engineering (23 per cent), followed by overall holds the largest proportion of students
construction architecture (26 per cent) and in any STEM field (Ibid), could present a source
computer science (30 per cent). This data is of employment for women in one of the most
more closely examined in Figure 7. in-demand professions (Khishigbuyan, 2014).
Based on the data presented in Figure 7, the In Nepal, a total of 46 per cent of students
level of female participation in STEM fields of enrolled in higher education are female (UGC,
study in Mongolia may be influenced by the 2013). As in other countries, while female
fact that the country has seen enrolments in students are a minority in fields of study such
higher education increase across the board by as engineering (19 per cent) and science and
almost 80 per cent between 2002 and 2013, technology (29.5 per cent), they are however, a
or by a 65 per cent increase for women and majority in other STEM-related disciplines such
almost 100 per cent increase in men (NSO, as medicine (53 per cent) and forestry (63 per
2012). At the same time, data from 2013 shows cent), as displayed in Figure 8. One possible
that while 88 per cent of degrees awarded point for analysis is that nursing is often included
were at Bachelor’s level, of which 57 per cent within medicine, and is a profession often
of graduates are female, female students perceived as predominantly female, which could
continue to outnumber their male peers at explain this higher rate; a point also applicable
all levels of higher education, particularly at to other countries included in this study.
the Master’s level where they made up 63 per
cent of graduates, as well as 57 per cent of On the other hand, education indicators
those graduating with a Doctorate (Ibid). On demonstrate that the highest numbers of
30
Figure 8 Proportion of students enrolled in selected STEM disciplines in higher education in Nepal as of 2011/2012 by sex (%)
Medicine 53 47
Engineering 19 81
0 20 40 60 80 100
Female Male
Figure 9 P roportion of female students enrolled in selected STEM and non-STEM disciplines in higher education as of 2014 in
the Republic of Korea (%)
Medicine 61.6
Education 57.3
Humanities 55.2
Engineering 15.4
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Female
Source: KEDI, 2014
female students are enrolled in non-STEM students enrolled at the Bachelor’s level were
fields of study (Ibid). Nonetheless, it is also female. This declined to 42 per cent at the
interesting to note that even in non-STEM fields Master’s level, and to just below 28 per cent at
of study, the participation of women declines the Doctoral level or equivalent (UGC, 2013).
substantially as the level of education increases,
suggesting that beyond the issue of enrolment, Analysis from the Republic of Korea also
the issue of retention of women at the highest shows that considering the high rate of female
levels of education continues to be problematic. students entering higher education at 67.9 per
Looking at students enrolled in educj1ation, cent (Statistics Korea, 2014), the rate of female
for instance, reveals that 53 per cent of Nepali students entering STEM disciplines is not
31
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
high (see Figure 9). This suggests that while The data presented in Figure 10 shows the
medicine reflects high female participation at extent to which female enrolment declines
61.6 per cent, only 15.4 per cent of those enrolled by level of education in the Republic of Korea,
in engineering are female, an observation that in both engineering as well as science. Indeed,
appears consistent with other countries. looking at the proportion of female students
enrolled in engineering at the Bachelor's level for
As in the case of Nepal, even when a notable instance, enrolment decreases at Master’s level,
proportion of female students are enrolled in and decreases even further at the Doctoral level.
higher education, this proportion tends to drop
as the level of education increases. Arguably, While the previous section focused on
this is even more prominent in the case of university education with an academic focus,
enrolment in STEM fields of study. Indeed, data STEM fields of study are also taught in different
from the Republic of Korea shows that 28.3 streams of post-secondary education, for
per cent of all students enrolled in science and instance in vocationally-oriented institutions.
engineering in higher education are female, Findings on the proportion of female students
and as displayed in Figure 10, not only is enrolled in such institutions also highlight
there a higher proportion of female students varying participation by discipline across
enrolled in science as opposed to engineering, countries. Cambodia, for instance, has one
but the proportion of female students in these of the smallest shares of students enrolled
two fields gradually reduces as the level of with approximately 6 per cent of Cambodians
education increases. between the ages of 20–24 having attended
Figure 10 Percentage of female students enrolled in science and engineering in higher education by level, Republic of Korea as of 2011
60
50 53.3 52
50.7
40
37.7
30
20
19.5
17.6
14.1
10
12.3
0
Associate Bachelor’s Master’s Doctoral
Science Engineering
Note: A
ssociate degree programmes refer to 2-3 year colleges, whereas Bachelor’s degree programmes refer to those offered
by general 4-year universities.
Source: Adapted from WISET, 2014
32
vocationally-oriented institutions at both conducted in Indonesia as part of this study
Figure 11 Average Gender Parity Index (GPI) in selected STEM-related technical and vocational programmes in selected
institutions in Indonesia
0.22 0.26 0.51 3.65
Low GPI High GPI
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 3.6
Notes: T he figure 1 would constitute perfect gender parity, whereas a figure below 1 shows an advantage to males and above one in favour of
females. In the absence of national level data, this figure shows the average GPI for these study programmes based on enrolment data
from the following institutions: Gajah Mada University, Bandung State Polytechnic, Medan State Polytechnic, Jakarta State Polytechnic,
Pontianak State Polytechnic, Ujung Pandang States Polytechnic, Samarinda State Polytechnic and Bandung Manufacturing Polytechnic.
33
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
34
a study conducted by Stoet and Geary (2013) results by sex for participating countries and
Table 5 PISA 2012 results for participating countries and jurisdictions in the Asia-Pacific
Mathematics Science
Country/Jurisdiction Average Score Difference Average Score Difference
Female Male Female Male
Australia 498 510 +12 519 524 +5
Hong Kong- China 553 568 +15 551 558 +7
Indonesia 373 377 +4 383 380 -3
Japan 527 545 +18 541 552 +11
Kazakhstan 432 432 0 429 420 -9
Macau- China 537 540 +3 521 520 -1
Malaysia 424 416 -8 425 414 -11
New Zealand 492 507 +15 513 518 +5
Republic of Korea 544 562 +18 536 539 +3
Shanghai- China 610 616 +6 578 583 +5
Singapore 575 571 -4 552 551 -1
Thailand 433 419 -14 452 433 -19
Turkey 444 452 +8 469 458 -11
Viet Nam 507 517 +10 528 529 +1
Note: + indicates a score difference in favour of boys, and – indicates a score in favour of girls.
Source: OECD, 2014
13 In analyzing the gender differences in both PISA and TIMSS how far students are able to apply their knowledge and
as outlined in Tables 5 and 6, it is important to note that the skills within the context (OECD, 2014), TIMSS is a curricu-
overall scores from these two international assessments are lum-based assessment which helps to assess if students
not comparable since they follow different methodologies. have learnt what they have been taught (IEA, 2012c).
While PISA is a competency-based assessment examining
35
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Table 6 TIMSS 2011 results in Grade 8 for participating countries and jurisdictions in the Asia-Pacific
Mathematics Science
Country/Jurisdiction Average Score Difference Average Score Difference
Female Male Female Male
Australia 500 509 +9 511 527 +16
Hong Kong- China 588 583 -5 536 534 -2
Indonesia 392 379 -13 409 402 -7
Iran 411 418 +7 477 472 -5
Japan 566 574 +8 554 562 +8
Kazakhstan 486 488 +2 434 419 -15
Republic of Korea 610 616 +6 558 563 +5
Malaysia 449 430 -19 434 430 -4
New Zealand 478 496 +18 501 522 +21
Singapore 615 607 -8 589 591 +2
Thailand 435 417 -18 458 443 -15
Turkey 457 448 -9 491 475 -16
Note: + indicates a score difference in favour of boys, and – indicates a score in favour of girls.
Source: IEA, 2012a; IEA, 2012b
knowledge application, yet further exploration gap in achievement in favour of male students
to confirm these differences is required. and also higher average scores, whereas the
opposite is found in non-OECD countries, in
Looking more closely at the overall results with particular in Southeast Asian countries such
regard to the gender gap in achievement, one as Thailand and Malaysia. In these countries,
consideration may be the gap in achievement there is a substantial gender gap in favour
itself while the other may be the actual of girls, yet lower average scores. Viet Nam,
score. In countries with a higher gender gap however, presents an exception. Having first
in favour of males, such as the Republic of participated in PISA in 2012, Viet Nam scored
Korea, female students scored higher in PISA above the OECD average, outperforming some
2012 and TIMSS 2011 than females in other OECD countries such as Australia and New
countries. Indeed, studies have shown that Zealand in mathematics and science (see Table
the gender gap in favour of boys tends to 5), while at the same time, a ten point score
be greater in more economically developed difference was identified in favour of boys in
countries as well as among the highest– mathematics. Looking beyond the countries
performing students (Stoet and Geary, 2013), reviewed, the cases of Hong Kong- China and
which to some extent is consistent with Singapore provide an example of those with
the results presented in Tables 5 and 6. high levels of achievement in mathematics
According to these results, OECD countries and science, yet with a smaller gender gap
such as Australia, Japan, New Zealand and the in performance (with the exception of Hong
Republic of Korea show a substantial gender Kong- China for mathematics in PISA 2012
36
results). For instance in TIMSS 2011, girls in their female counterparts – by 18 points in
Figure 12 Trends in mathematics and science achievement in TIMSS Grade 8 by sex in Malaysia
1995 1999 2003 2007 2011 1995 1999 2003 2007 2011
521 515
520 510
517 512 498
505
505 488
475
479
466
468
449
434
440 430
430 419
Mathematics Science
Female Male
Source: Adapted from IEA, 2012a; IEA, 2012b
37
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
education stakeholders (Ibid). While female since 1995, show that the gender gap in
students have consistently outscored their male achievement narrowed considerably in
counterparts in mathematics, trends in science mathematics (2007) as well as in science (2011)
performance show that initially, male students as displayed in Figure 13.
scored higher until the year 2003, with female
students scoring higher from 2007 onwards. While in mathematics the gender gap in
Nonetheless, since Malaysia’s first participation achievement reduced to near parity by 2007
in TIMSS in 1999, the decline in performance and in science by 2011, the results from
follows a similar trend among both female and TIMSS Grade 8 in both subjects show a steady
male students as illustrated in Figure 12. increase in scores over time for both subjects.
They also show that the gap in performance
Overall, trends in TIMSS results in Malaysia between female and male students is gradually
between 1999 and 2003 show a growing narrowing. In 1999, boys outscored girls by
gender gap in performance in favour of girls. 17 points in mathematics and by 29 points in
For instance, while in 1999 girls outscored boys science. By 2011, this had changed significantly
by four points in mathematics and 10 points with boys outscoring girls by just six points in
in science, in 2011 they outscored boys by 19 mathematics and five points in science. The
points in mathematics and 15 points in science. increase in student achievement over time in
Perspectives on the general decline in Malaysia’s the Republic of Korea has been perceived as
performance in TIMSS suggest that it may the result of sociocultural influences and policy
stem from a number of factors beyond gender, interventions. For example, the importance of
namely a potential language barrier, sampling education has been reinforced by strong family
methodology, unfamiliarity with lengthy support, as well as education reforms which
questions and application of problems as well as have been seen to increase structural efficiency
interpretation and reflection in the case of PISA, and the quality of the education system. (Lee,
unfamiliarity with ‘higher order thinking’ skills, 2014). Others have argued that this is due to
variance in standards in terms of curriculum the pragmatic approach to learning and the
content and focus on application and reasoning importance given to examinations, while at
(MoE, 2013a; MoE, 2013b). More specifically, the same time, the favourable characteristics
the decline in performance has been linked of Korean language in describing the number
to the introduction of English for the teaching system (Park, 2014). Looking back to the
of mathematics and science (ETeMS) in 2003 case of Malaysia, studies have indicated that
(Mahdzir et al., 2014). Studies commissioned by the language of instruction can in fact have
the Ministry of Education showed that students an impact on academic achievement in
and teachers (from rural areas in particular) had mathematics, often citing East Asian languages
greater difficulty understanding the teaching in particular as better suited to mathematical
of these subjects through English (Ibid). The concepts than English (Wall Street Journal,
staggered reversal of this policy in 2009 saw the 2014). This could perhaps explain the overall
teaching of mathematics and science in Bahasa decline in achievement in Malaysia and the
reintroduced from Grade 1 in 2011. This reversal increase in achievement in the Republic of
may cause further difficulties for students to Korea among both female and male students.
adapt to different terminologies (Ibid). Both of these cases also suggest that other
influential factors, including changes in
By contrast, trends in TIMSS Grade 8 in the education policy in Malaysia, could have played
Republic of Korea, which has participated an important role in not only affecting changes
38
Figure 13 Trends in mathematics and science achievement in TIMSS Grade 8 by sex in the Republic of Korea
620 570
616
564 563
559 559 557
610 560
610
558
552
600 599 550
549
590 592
588 595
590 540 538
586
585
580 530 530
571
570 520
95
99
03
07
11
95
99
03
07
11
19
19
20
20
20
19
19
20
20
20
Female Male
in scores, but also in how these may affect gaps occur among the highest performing
differences in achievement between female students (Stoet and Geary, 2013), with the
and male students. results of International Olympiads providing
a particularly interesting case for further
B. International Olympiads in exploration. Indeed, a gender analysis of the
STEM-related fields 2014 results of relevant International Olympiads
for Asia-Pacific countries, which was conducted
Some countries and jurisdictions from the by the research team at UNESCO Bangkok,
Asia-Pacific region14 also participate in revealed significant gender gaps and covered
International Olympiads in STEM-related fields the following: International Biology Olympiad
such as mathematics, physics, chemistry, (IBO), International Olympiad in Informatics
biology and informatics. These Olympiads are (IOI), International Mathematical Olympiad
usually held annually and consist of international (IMO), and the International Physics Olympiad
competitions whereby participating countries (IPhO).15 Overall, what these results show is that
send a delegation of four to six of their highest by total delegation (including both medallists
achieving upper secondary students in that and non-medallists) female contestants are
particular field. As was observed in the previous largely absent or underrepresented, which
section on international assessments, studies may be due to the lower proportion of girls at
have argued that the most prominent gender the highest levels of achievement. For instance,
39
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
the percentage of female contestants stood may also be a possible link to the smaller or
at just 4 per cent for informatics, 5 per cent for in some cases reversed gender gap in science
mathematics and 6 per cent for physics, yet it performance in international assessments
reached an average of 28 per cent in biology as opposed to mathematics. Nonetheless, in
among countries in the region, the latter countries with a substantial gender difference
reflecting the findings in the previous chapter in achievement in favour of female students,
on access and participation by STEM discipline. such as Malaysia and Thailand, data indicates
Looking more closely at the proportion of that this does not necessarily correlate with the
female medallists in these Olympiads, these number of female contestants in these country
figures are shown to be even lower, as delegations. For instance, in the Informatics
displayed in Figure 14. and Physics 2014 Olympiads, both country
delegations consisted of four male contestants
The higher proportion of female medallists for (IOI, 2014; IPhO, 2014). Of these two countries,
biology as opposed to the remarkably smaller only Thailand participated in the areas of
proportion in informatics, mathematics and biology and mathematics in 2014. For Thailand,
physics, appears to be consistent with female there was just one female of a total delegation
participation by field of study in STEM at the of four for biology, and in mathematics all six
higher education level, as seen in Chapter Three. contestants were male (IBO, 2014; IMO, 2014).
Here, a higher proportion of female students
tend to be enrolled in biology as opposed to Another possible assumption from the results
mathematics or physics. At the same time, there of these 2014 International Olympiads could be
Figure 14 Proportion of female medallists in STEM-related International Olympiads in 2014 among participating
Asia-Pacific countries and jurisdictions (%)
30
28
25
25
20
15
14
10
7 7
5 6 6
4
0 0 0 0
0
Biology Informatics Mathematics Physics
Note: Overall proportion calculated based on participating countries from the Asia-Pacific region (see Annex 4).
Source: Compiled from IBO, 2014; IOI, 2014; IMO, 2014; IPhO, 2014.
40
found in the proportion of female contestants students in these fields, but they also provide
41
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Figure 15 Trends in achievement among 15-year-old students in the Malaysian Lower Secondary Assessment (PMR)
Mathematics Science
2.2 2.2
2.4 2.4
2.6 2.6
2.8 2.8
3 3
3.2 3.2
3.4 3.4
09
10
11
12
13
09
10
11
12
13
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Female Male
Note: This score is based on the national average grade (GPN) from grades A-E per subject, 1 being the highest and 5 being the lowest,
with 1 being equivalent to A and 5 equivalent to E.
Source: MoE, 2013a
years old, the Malaysia Certificate of Education choice questions via paper format at the SPM
(SPM) taken at 17 years old and the Malaysian level. With regard to learning achievement
Higher School Certificate, also known as ‘form in mathematics and science, data from the
six’ (STPM) which is taken by students as a PMR assessment which is taken by 15-year-old
pre-university examination (Mahdzir et al., students may show consistency with the results
2014). From August 2014 onwards, the PMR of international assessments specifically with
is replaced with a school based assessment regard to the higher performance of female
system together with the centralized Form students. In addition, trends in these results
3 Assessment (PT3), which could present indicate that the gender gap in achievement
opportunities to adapt to a student’s individual has been sustained over the last four years. In
learning styles and to perhaps better adapt the case of science however, the gender gap
to the different learning styles of female and appears to have been closed in the year 2013,
male students. as male achievement increased. This is reflected
in the national average grade in the PMR as
For mathematics and science subjects, however, displayed in Figure 15, which is carried out in
testing instruments tend to maintain their paper national schools16 and makes up approximately
and pencil form (Ibid). Students are tested under
the UPSR through multiple choice questions, a
16 National schools refer to government-funded schools where
combination of multiple choice questions and the medium of instruction is Bahasa, as opposed to national-type
coursework beyond the exam at PMR level, schools which are government-funded schools where the
medium of instruction is either Chinese or Tamil language
and both multiple choice and non-multiple (UNESCO IBE, 2004).
42
80 per cent of the total school population. students passing as opposed to just 74.8 per
43
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
support to those female students concentrated in gaps remain in favour of male students in
intermediate and basic levels of achievement. mathematics, they also show that female
students are increasingly catching up in
In the case of Viet Nam, differences in the gender science. At the same time, while some
gap are also observed with female students countries show a substantial gap in favour
outscoring their male counterparts in national of male students such as Japan and the
Republic of Korea, other countries such as
assessments as opposed to PISA 2012 where
Malaysia and Thailand show a substantial gap
male students outscored female students by ten
in favour of female students with very different
points in mathematics and by just one point in
patterns among countries in Asia.
science as was observed earlier in this chapter. In
2009, a survey was conducted on achievement • F
emale medallists and contestants were
in mathematics and physics among Grade 9 very few and far between in the 2014
students at the national level in order to supervise International Olympiads, even in those
countries where female students scored
and evaluate learning outcomes of students as
higher in international assessments and
well as to inform adjustments in education policy
even in biology where they tend to be more
(Do, 2014). According to the results of this survey,
greatly represented in higher education.
an 8.4 point difference in mathematics and an
8 point difference in physics were found in favour • F inally, the results of national assessments
of female students, which appears to suggest a also show a similar situation with regard to
different pattern to those observed in the gender differences in achievement, especially
results of PISA 2012. While in the case of in the cases of Malaysia and the Republic of
Korea. In Malaysia for instance, both the results
Viet Nam, the gender gap appears to differ
of national and international assessments
between international and national assessments,
show higher scores in both mathematics and
to some extent the difference in performance
science among female students. In the Republic
in favour of female students is reflected in
of Korea however, where boys outscore girls
both international and national assessments
in international assessments, higher scores
in Malaysia, and in favour of male students in are identified in female students at the lower
international and national assessments at upper secondary level, yet are higher in male students
secondary level for the Republic of Korea. at the upper secondary level in national
assessments. By contrast, Viet Nam shows minor
This chapter has sought to explore the point differences between female and male
gender dimension of learning achievement in students in favour of females in mathematics
mathematics and science in three main areas: and physics in national assessments, yet in
results of international assessments such as PISA the results of international assessments males
and TIMSS, results of International Olympiads scored slightly higher, especially in mathematics.
in STEM-related fields, and results of national • W
hile the data presented in this chapter
assessments in countries with available data. The provides a picture on the gender dimension
main findings can be outlined as follows: of achievement, it is now important to
further explore the wider factors that
• L inkages between these three areas may not
could potentially influence the differences
be statistically verifiable, yet they do provide
in achievement between female and male
useful insight into gender differences in
students, and ultimately, their participation
learning achievement.
in STEM fields.
hile data from international assessments
• W
indicates that on average significant gender
44
Part B
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
n
Girls and Women in STEM:
What led us here?
5 Educational Impacts
45
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
46
may be found in other countries. For instance strategies and teaching and learning materials
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
in Thailand, the successful Development and including textbooks.
Promotion of Science and Technology Talents
Project (DPST) appears to have almost equal
Female teachers
numbers of male and female graduates since
its inception, aiming to nurture friendship Female teachers can serve as one of the
among project participants, exposure to role first female role models that girls are exposed
models, the organization of field trips, and to (UNESCO, 2014a, p. 43). Despite the
the encouraging 'learning for learning’s sake', feminization of the teaching profession in
meaning that students are encouraged to lower levels of education and in lower positions
have a positive attitude towards mathematics in many countries in Asia, when looking more
and science regardless of whether they excel specifically at mathematics and science, it is
in the subject or not (APEC, 2010, p. 11). common for teachers to be predominantly
Arguably, such policies and programmes, and male and also as the level of education
in particular the initiatives in the Republic increases in most countries. Looking at the
of Korea and Thailand, are a positive step in proportion of female teachers in these subjects
providing support for learning in mathematics in Nepal based on 20 classes observed as part
and science, as well as in stimulating interest of this research, eight out of ten teachers were
in STEM fields among students. male in science classes, and nine out of ten
teachers were male in mathematics classes. The
B. Teaching and learning conditions opposite situation can be seen in Mongolia,
which traditionally has a highly feminized
The school environment – in terms of teaching workforce, with national level data
how gender-sensitive and supportive the showing that on average approximately 90 per
environment is for both female and male cent of teachers in chemistry and biology, as
students – also presents a crucial area for well as 75 per cent of teachers in information
analysis in terms of how female and male and communication technologies (ICT),
students may be influenced in learning in mathematics and physics are female (NSO,
mathematics and science. This section is 2012). While the high concentration of female
therefore structured to explore teacher sex, teachers at the primary and lower secondary
for instance with regard to the proportion of level was also identified across all subjects in
female teachers who are often the first role the Republic of Korea, this was shown to
models that female students encounter in decline as the level of education increased as
these fields, the relationships and interactions displayed in Table 7.
between teachers and students, teaching
Table 7 Proportion of female teachers by level of education in the Republic of Korea as of 2013 (%)
47
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
In the Republic of Korea, the majority of assigned equally mixed groups comprising
teachers at the pre-primary level are female both female and male students. In Nepal, a
at 99.2 per cent, a proportion which gradually contrasting situation was identified in urban
decreases to 46.7 per cent at the upper and rural locations with regard to the level of
secondary level and to just 34.1 per cent in participation and support in the classroom.
higher education. It could be inferred that While boys were observed to be significantly
subject-specific data would show a similar more active and confident and received
situation, and perhaps even lower proportions more teacher support in urban areas, quite
for mathematics and science, especially at the opposite was found in rural areas, where
higher levels of education. girls were observed as having more teacher
support, as well as higher level of participation
and confidence in both mathematics and
Relationships between students
science classes. The same findings arose
and teachers from classroom observations conducted
In terms of relationships and interactions in Viet Nam where male students seemed
between students, as well as between teachers less confident in presenting in front of the
and their students, the results from the classroom in rural areas than their female
classroom observations conducted across the counterparts. At the same time, important
seven countries for this study seem to indicate differences were observed with regard to
equal treatment and equal levels of participation the number of opportunities given to female
of female and male students in mathematics and male students to interact with their
and science classes. However, different patterns teachers or respond to questions, especially in
were identified in some classes. For instance in mathematics as demonstrated in Table 8.
Indonesia, analysis of classroom observations
shows that female students seem more These observations in Table 8, which are based
engaged, participate more actively and ask on eight classroom observations conducted
more questions in these subjects than their male in mathematics and science classes as well
peers. In Cambodia, however, there were overall as in both urban and rural areas, suggest that
equal levels of activeness, teacher support perhaps there is more frequent interaction
and sharing of opinions in class between male between teachers and their male students
and female students, yet with some important as opposed to female students. For instance
differences. While female students tended to in mathematics, the number of interactions
give more correct answers to questions than observed with teachers for male students
their male counterparts, they demonstrated stood at 65 per cent as opposed to 35 per cent
higher levels of reluctance, shakiness and for female students. In science, a similar pattern
anxiety in answering questions, with some was observed with 61 per cent of student-
female students even waiting until the class was teacher interactions being for male students
over to ask specific questions to their teachers, as opposed to 39 per cent for female students.
whereas male students were perceived as
braver and more confident, despite their
Teaching strategies
answers more often being incorrect.
Looking in more detail at teaching strategies
In terms of grouping of students during team and effectiveness in these subjects, studies
activities, observations in Mongolia found show that teacher training and preparation,
that in all except one class observed, teachers student access to practical ‘hands-on’ and
48
Table 8 Interactions between students and teachers in upper secondary mathematics and science classes by sex
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
based on classroom observations in Viet Nam
Mathematics Science
Urban Rural Total Urban Rural Total
No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % No. %
Female 8 32 5 42 13 35 4 18 16 55 20 39
Male 17 68 7 58 24 65 18 82 13 45 31 61
creative activities, and increased use of In addition, findings from another study
student-centred methods using cooperative conducted in Cambodia have shown that
learning can strengthen students’ positive provision and use of science labs can not
attitudes towards science (Haladyna, Olsen, only have a positive impact on student
and Shaughnessy, 1982; Myers and Fouts, participation and interest, but could also
1992). Studies also argue that for girls in help overcome preconceived notions of girls’
particular, interest and performance in STEM- inability to perform well in science (Kelley et al.,
related subjects increase substantially through 2013). The lack of adequate facilities was also
an interactive learning environment that observed in Mongolia, where lack of funding
allows for team-based learning and hands-on has meant that teachers lack resources and
activities (Christie, 2005; Sanders, 2005). With equipment in order to carry out experiments
regard to gender-responsive teacher training in science classes, and with some schools
and generally in the teaching of science in relying on outdated equipment from the
Cambodia for instance, few opportunities socialist era, especially in rural areas. Arguably,
for teacher education and more broadly the increased resources for experiments,
capacity development in this area has meant which offer the opportunity for students to
that there is little room for teachers to fully apply their knowledge in practice, could help
integrate gender equality through their stimulate interest among female students to
teaching strategies. Findings from a school potentially pursue these disciplines in further
supported by an NGO showed the extent to study. More broadly across the seven countries,
which such training could potentially have a the importance of gender-responsive teacher
positive impact on girls’ learning achievement education with regard to both mathematics
in science. For instance, in a school in Siem and science was raised as important in order to
Reap province supported by the NGO Caring address the different learning needs of female
for Cambodia where teacher training and and male students.
resources for conducting science experiments
were provided, the national exam pass rate Teaching and learning materials
for female students was the highest of all 19
schools in that province. This demonstrates Another important factor within teaching and
the importance of necessary equipment and learning conditions is that of textbooks and
resources in teaching science, but also of learning materials and in particular, the ways
gender-responsive training for teachers. in which they portray the roles of females and
49
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
males. Indeed, analysis of textbooks among In explaining brain function, it could be argued
the seven countries reviewed indicates that in that this illustration depicts males as thinking
some cases, textbooks and curricular teaching and exercising as opposed to females who
and learning materials continue to permeate are depicted as smelling flowers and tasting
gender stereotypes. For instance in the case of food. Indirectly, it could be inferred that this
Indonesia, while the 2013 curriculum content illustration communicates subtle messages
in mathematics and science is considered regarding the most basic human functions
gender-sensitive, the learning materials used (Szmodies and Eng, 2014).
in its implementation could be considered
as quite the opposite (Sani, 2014). As shown But this concern is not limited to the cases of
in Figure 17, images used in the Grade 7 Indonesia and Cambodia. Other countries such
science textbook, developed by the MoEC and as the Republic of Korea, Nepal and Viet Nam
implemented in all schools nationwide at this have also sought to raise the need for a gender-
level, mostly portray students as male. sensitive review of learning materials. In the
Republic of Korea for instance, the dominance
In the case of Cambodia, another illustration is of male characters in textbooks, which tends
taken from a Grade 9 science textbook under to increase as the level of education advances,
the lesson plan on the central nervous system, could arguably reinforce gender stereotypes
presenting another example of how textbooks with regard to certain types of professions,
may be perpetuating subtle gender stereotyping especially if they are represented by one
as displayed in Figure 18 (MoEYS, 2012). gender (Choi and Kim, 2014). In turn, this could
Food as an
energy source
50
potentially contribute to fuelling negative also showed cases of under-representation of
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
attitudes or perceptions of mathematics and women and girls, but also subtle biases in the
science subjects as well as affecting levels of ways in which they are portrayed. For instance,
achievement of female students. girls and women are presented as kind and
caring, often in professions such as weaving,
In Nepal, a study commissioned by DFID and the nursing or teaching, whereas boys and men in
Royal Norwegian Embassy looked at a sample of mathematics textbooks are portrayed as strong
school textbooks to analyze how gender roles and able to use modern technology (UNESCO Ha
and relations are depicted. The review found Noi, UNESCO IBE and MOET, 2010; Do, 2014).
that while on the whole, males and females are
represented in a balanced manner and most of C. The gender dimension of private
the textbooks reviewed are free from harmful tutoring in mathematics and science
gender stereotypes, a few textbooks still feature
stereotypical presentations of men and women’s With persisting competition in education
roles (Terry and Thapa, 2012). The findings are in Asia, which has in part been driven
broadly in line with previous reports which by benchmarking through international
have noted the progress made in incorporating assessments, the gender dimension of
contents on gender sensitivity and removing supplementary and fee-paying private tutoring
negative gender stereotypes from textbooks can provide some interesting insights into
in Nepalese schools. In Viet Nam, similar cases the relationship with learning achievement.
were observed in a textbook analysis conducted According to Bray and Kwo (2014), this
by UNESCO between 2009 and 2010, which emerging phenomenon in the region and
Figure 18 Grade 9 science textbook Illustration on the central nervous system in Cambodia
51
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Table 9 Proportion of students reporting having received private tutoring across all subjects in the 2013/2014 academic year (%)
% students receiving
Country Of which % female Of which % male
private tutoring
Cambodia 87 51 49
Indonesia 52 63 37
Malaysia 68 59 41
Mongolia 14 71 29
Nepal 73 53 47
Republic of Korea 74 54 46
Viet Nam 66 53 47
Note: In the case of Mongolia, only half of the total surveyed students responded to this question.
Source: Based on results from the student questionnaire (Annex 1)
52
Table 10 P roportion of female and male students reporting having received private tutoring in mathematics and science
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
subjects in the academic year of 2013/2014 (%)
Chemistry 50 50
Viet Nam Mathematics 47 53
Physics 50 50
findings from the questionnaire results as will countries plan to pursue higher education,
be presented in the subsequent chapter on with high interest in STEM fields of study.
psychosocial influences, showing that girls, Based on the findings of the first study in this
contrary to analysis in previous studies, may series on career perspectives and choices as
have higher motivation and perseverance in mentioned in Chapter One of this report, it
mathematics and science subjects. appears that female and male students may
have an internalized bias as to what types of
D. Career counselling occupations are better suited to women or
men, as well as a higher preference among
As has been examined in previous chapters, male students towards STEM occupations
a number of determinants may shape such as engineering and a higher preference
career perspectives and choices of female among female students towards medicine
and male students. Looking more closely at (UNESCO and KWDI, 2013). At the same time,
some aspects of both formal and informal it also appears that appropriate and gender-
career counselling, namely perspectives of responsive career counselling services and
students on future study and career plans, it scholarship programmes may be lacking,
appears that most students across the seven as will be considered in this section. In
53
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Cambodia for instance, 95 per cent of likely to perceive mathematics as important for
students surveyed plan to pursue further study their future career at 83 per cent, as opposed
in higher education, of which 54 per cent to just 39 per cent of male students. A similar
plan to pursue a career in a STEM-related field. observation is found in science where 78 per
In addition, a regression analysis based on cent of female students consider the subject
these questionnaire results showed that this important for their future career, compared
outcome was highly associated with subjects to 35 per cent for their male counterparts.
which students most enjoy, those in which
they perceive highest performance, as well In Mongolia, both female and male students
as those in which they felt they had parental plan to study and pursue a career in the subjects
and teacher support. However, the country that they enjoy most, yet at a higher rate for
report argues that there is a questionable female students at 88 per cent as opposed to
level of understanding of these subjects, and 70 per cent of male students. When students
in particular in the explanations of why they were asked to explain their choices through
enjoy these subjects and wish to pursue these open questions, no gender difference was
in the future (Szmodies and Eng, 2014). At the identified in responses, with students stating
same time, a negative correlation was found reasons such as interest and market demand,
between those receiving private tutoring as well as to support their parents and develop
in mathematics and science and those who their country. A high number of students also
were more likely to wish to pursue non-STEM plan to pursue higher education in Viet Nam at
related subjects in higher education. While no 97 per cent, of which 87 per cent plan to pursue
significant gender differences were observed, a subject which they most enjoy. Here there was
in rural areas, female students tended to agree no significant gender difference.
more with the statement that STEM related
professions were suitable for women than The role of career counselling in schools could
male students. arguably play a positive role in guiding female
and male students in their future study and
In Indonesia, linkages between career career choices, yet structured programmes
aspirations of students and participation by remain limited across the seven countries.
STEM discipline in higher education were In Nepal for instance, there are no such
also identified when students were asked programmes, but rather career counselling
to state their career aspirations in open is offered informally by teachers. The most
questions of the questionnaire. For instance, important element for teachers in giving career
among students who reported enjoying advice to students, however, is academic
science and who wished to pursue a career achievement, with those scoring above 90 per
in science, female students reported the cent in the Grade 10 exam usually encouraged
choice of career of medical doctor, as opposed to pursue medical science or engineering
to male students who reported interest in regardless of their gender (UNESCO and KWDI,
becoming engineers. This suggests that 2013, p. 30). By contrast, career counselling
many of the patterns identified in enrolment services do exist in the Republic of Korea.
in higher education by discipline, as well as Of those available, however, some argue that
labour market participation by occupation most of these programmes are not gender-
within STEM, may already be shaped by the sensitive (Choi and Kim, 2014). According to
perspectives of students at 15 years old. At analysis presented in the country report, this
the same time, female students were more might indicate that at present, educational
54
policymakers and administrators may not to earlier in this chapter, seeks to promote
5 EDUCATIONAL IMPACTS
have considered gender equality issues in educational and career programmes for
developing career counselling programmes. women and girls to foster their interest in
At the same time, it was found that when mathematics and science, develop their
female students seek advice from parents and potential, and support their progression to
teachers, there is a tendency for them to stress study STEM disciplines in higher education.
the lower number of female professionals In addition, WISET also provides a mentoring
in STEM fields and the difficulties that may programme whereby female students and
be faced as a result of gender should they professionals in STEM fields are paired to
eventually choose to pursue a career in STEM provide students with a female role model
fields, which could arguably have a negative and mentor. This programme has continued
influence on their career choices to grow from 219 such pairs in the years of its
and perspectives (Ibid). initiation in 2002 to 3,667 pairs in 2013.
E. S
cholarship and mentoring Such a mentoring programme could be a
opportunities source of great support for female students
as they progress through their studies and
In addition to career counselling, scholarship eventually move into STEM careers. Finally,
programmes also present an encouraging the WISET award programme seeks to inspire
initiative for students to pursue STEM fields of female scientists and engineers by giving
study in higher education, with two examples recognition to female students in upper
identified among the seven countries. For secondary education for outstanding papers
instance in Indonesia, such programmes are and posters in this field (WISET, 2013a).
available, yet not specifically targeted at female Looking more closely at job training, WISET
students. When looking at the proportion of supports female job seekers in STEM fields
students who received scholarships for further through information on employment trends,
study in STEM fields of study, however, the interview preparation, communication
figure is slightly higher for male students at skills as well as training opportunities in
8.65 per cent as opposed to 7.76 per cent for research aimed to develop competencies
female students (Statistics Indonesia, 2013). such as leadership, creativity, writing and
project management for undergraduate
A similar finding is observed in the Republic of and graduate level female students. It also
Korea where there is a lower representation provides temporary job opportunities for
of female students in programmes for graduate students in early stages of their
students gifted in science, in particular as the careers, as well as education and training for
level of education increases (MSIP, 2014a). women scientists and engineers that have
Nonetheless, a number of initiatives in the taken career breaks (Ibid).
country are striving to promote women’s
and girls’ education and career prospects in Educational factors can have a great impact
STEM fields. In higher education for instance, on student performance and attitudes
scholarships for students to pursue STEM towards mathematics and science, learning
disciplines include quotas in order to increase achievement as well as student choices for
opportunities for female students (MSIP, further study and careers in STEM. Some
2014b). The Centre for Women in Science, reflections on the educational factors
Engineering and Technology (WISET) referred explored in this chapter are also follows:
55
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
56
children such as dolls for females or cars for differences in these choices could be more
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
males (BBC, 2011). Another study conducted influenced by psychosocial factors such as
by Dweck (2008) argues that the ability motivation, confidence and perseverance than
of female students to develop a ’growth by one’s ability or performance (OECD, 2011,
mindset’, whereby students are taught that p. 2). The report also identifies that even among
intelligence is not fixed but rather achieved female students enrolled in higher education
overtime through experiencing failure and in STEM fields of study, they are less likely to
perseverance, could potentially help to reduce continue a career in these fields than their male
this gap in achievement (Dweck, 2008, p. 4). counterparts (Ibid). Even among those who
Through teaching a growth mindset, this could are enrolled in STEM fields in higher education,
make them far less vulnerable to the threat female students tend to be concentrated in
of negative stereotypes, for instance from the specific disciplines such as biology or medicine
negative stereotype that girls are ‘not good’ as was observed in Chapter Three.
at mathematics and science. From various
experiments cited in the study whereby According to Gibbons (2009), “Certain
‘growth mindset groups’ (having been taught STEM sub disciplines with a clearer social
about growth mindset) and ‘control groups’ purpose, such as biomedical engineering and
(taught about a fixed mindset) were followed environmental engineering, have succeeded in
over a length of time, results from growth attracting higher percentages of women than
mindset groups showed that female students have other sub-disciplines like mechanical or
made the biggest gains in assessments in electrical engineering.” Indeed, it is important
mathematics and in some cases even greater to consider how psychosocial factors may
than those of male students, whereas female influence student performance, choices and
students performed much lower in control attitudes within the unique Asian context
groups with male students largely unaffected where gender differences in participation
(Ibid, p.7). Experiments for minority groups in and achievement vary greatly by country. The
the United States show a similar trend with the findings based on responses to the student
largest gains in achievement found in African- questionnaire, conducted in the seven
American students who were placed in the countries under review, also reflect these
'growth mindset' group (Ibid). Considering the variances. At the same time, they point towards
gender differences in learning achievement possible linkages between the attitudes of
that were observed in the previous chapter, male and female students in mathematics
these findings may imply that the ‘growth and science, the gender gap in learning
mindset’ approach targets those who may be achievement, as well as the representation of
less confident as a result of their vulnerability female students in higher education.
to negative stereotype threat.
A. Student subject preferences
Related to the wider issue of negative stereotype and perceived performance
threat, the gender dimension of student interest
and attitudes towards mathematics and science In order to better understand the attitudes of
may not only affect learning achievement in female and male students towards different
these subjects but also choices for further study subjects, the questionnaire17 asked students
and careers. According to a 2011 OECD report to select their three most and least enjoyed
on gender equality in education, employment
and entrepreneurship, it appears that gender 17 See questions 4-5 in Annex 1.
57
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
subjects, as well as the three subjects in mathematics and science. For instance,
which they felt they performed best and worst. mathematics was chosen as one of the
These were then compiled as the three most most enjoyed subjects by male students in
frequently occurring subjects for each category six countries, but by female students in just
by country and by sex. Looking at subject three countries. Nonetheless, mathematics
preferences, linkages could be identified subjects only appeared as one of the least
with female and male enrolment in higher enjoyed for both male and female students
education by field of study, while at the same in two countries – Cambodia (calculus) and
time some interesting exceptions are displayed Indonesia (general mathematics). Science was
in Table 11. selected as one of most enjoyed subjects by
female students in four countries and by male
Based on the overall subject preferences students in three countries, whereas it was
presented in Table 11, some observations chosen as one of the least enjoyed subjects in
can be found when looking specifically at four countries by female and male students
Table 11 Most and least enjoyed subjects reported by students by country and by sex
58
respectively. This could perhaps be due found that students in Indonesia felt that
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
to the different ways in which science may subjects such as physical education and art
be taught in schools across the seven were perceived as ‘easier’, perhaps in terms
countries, which presents an area for further of assessment, and therefore more enjoyable,
analysis. While these findings are based whereas mathematics and science subjects
on small samples and correlations with were considered too difficult to understand,
participation in STEM fields of study in higher full of formulae and too fast-paced in the way
education may not be determined at first in which they were taught.
glance, upon further analysis by country
however, they do provide interesting insight By contrast, Mongolia presents rather
as demonstrated in the cases of Cambodia, different results from the questionnaire, with
Indonesia, Mongolia and Nepal. both female and male students choosing
mathematics and physics among their
Based on the questionnaire results in most enjoyed subjects, with art and music
Cambodia, it was found that there was no among those least enjoyed. Mathematics,
statistically significant gender difference and in particular physics, are two STEM-
with regard to interest in mathematics and related subjects that are usually shown to
science. However, analysis presented in the have higher participation of male students in
country report argues that this anomaly may higher education as was observed in Chapter
simply exist due to indicators suggesting an Three. While mathematics showed a higher
overall lack of interest in these subjects for all preference among male students as selected
students (Szmodies and Eng, 2014). Another by 46 per cent of male students as opposed
study previously conducted in Siem Reap to 36 per cent of female students, physics
province of Cambodia with more than 900 showed a slightly higher preference from
students between Grades 7-12 also showed female students selected by 34 per cent as
similar results with no significant gender opposed to 30 per cent of male students.
differences in STEM interests (Kelley et al., Similar results emerged in Nepal where both
2013). Nonetheless, when looking at the three female and male students selected STEM-
most and least enjoyed subjects in Cambodia, related subjects such as general science and
while those subjects least enjoyed appear quite mathematics among the top three subjects
similar among female and male students, only that they most enjoy along with biology
female students state biology, a STEM-related for female students and algebra for male
subject, as one of their most enjoyed subjects. students. A difference however, was observed
This similarity between female and male with regard to computer science in terms
subject preferences, as well as a possible low of students located in urban and rural areas,
interest in mathematics and science, is also ranking as the third preferred subject for both
identified in Indonesia where both female urban female and male students, yet not
and male students showed a preference for among the top three most enjoyed subjects
non-academic curricular subjects such as in rural areas, which could perhaps be due to
physical education, art and music, while also the lower availability of computer equipment
choosing a number of STEM-related subjects in rural areas more generally. At the same time,
among least preferred subjects, namely other STEM-related subjects were among the
chemistry, mathematics and physics. Further three least enjoyed subjects such as geometry
analysis based on open questions related to for female students and chemistry in the case
subject preferences in the questionnaire also of male students.
59
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
While this can provide insight into the At first glance, the findings in Table 12 reveal
subjects that students enjoy most and enjoy that science was more often perceived among
the least, it is important to also consider how students’ highest performing subjects, and
female and male students perceive their own mathematics was more often perceived as
performance in different subjects. As part among students’ lowest performing subjects.
of the questionnaire, students in the seven For instance, mathematics was perceived by
countries were also asked to identify the female students in three countries and by
three subjects in which they felt that they male students in four countries as among
perform highest, as well as those in which their highest performing subjects, while it was
they felt that they perform lowest with the perceived by both female and male students
most frequent responses by country and by as among the lowest in six countries. Science
sex displayed in Table 12. subjects, however, were equally perceived as
60
among highest performance subjects in five and male students. Looking more broadly at
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
countries by both female and male students, all subjects chosen by female and male
yet among lowest performance subjects by students in each of the seven countries,
female students in five countries and by male those chosen as the most enjoyed subjects
students in just two countries. tended to also be chosen among the highest
perceived performance in 27 subject choices
Looking more closely at possible linkages (13 among female students and 14 among male
between most and least enjoyed subjects students), whereas those least enjoyed were
(Table 11) and highest and lowest perceived less likely to be chosen in the lowest perceived
performance (Table 12), mathematics is more performance subjects across 16 subject choices
likely to appear among the most enjoyed (7 among female students and 9 among male
subjects, especially for male students, yet it is students). Figure 19 displays this information
also more likely to be perceived as among the for mathematics and science subjects in order
lowest performance subjects for both female to highlight the frequency with which these
Figure 19 Frequency of mathematics and science subjects reported by female and male students as most and least enjoyed
and highest and lowest perceived performance
Mathematics subjects Science subjects
9 9
8 8
7 7
Female Male Female Male
6 6
5 5
25 25
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
Most Least Highest Lowest Most Least Highest Lowest
enjoyed enjoyed perceived perceived enjoyed enjoyed perceived perceived
performance performance performance performance
Country Country
Cambodia ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Cambodia ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Indonesia ✓✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Indonesia ✓✓ ✓
Malaysia ✓ ✓ ✓ Malaysia ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Mongolia ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Mongolia ✓ ✓ ✓✓ ✓
Nepal ✓ ✓✓ ✓ ✓✓ ✓✓ ✓✓ ✓✓ Nepal ✓✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Notes: For mathematics subjects, each ✓ refers to general mathematics as well as topics such as algebra, calculus and
geometry. For science subjects, each ✓ refers to general science as well as topics such as biology, chemistry and physics.
Source: Compiled from student questionnaire results (Annex I)
61
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
62
While only minor gender differences were Turning to questions related to student
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
observed in some countries with regard to motivation and perseverance in mathematics
interest in mathematics and science subjects and science, there also appears to be a
among female and male students, taking a closer degree of consistency in relation to interest,
look at questionnaire results related to student confidence and anxiety towards these subjects.
confidence and anxiety towards these subjects Student responses relating to these aspects as
provide further insight into student attitudes.18 part of the questionnaire in the seven countries
In Viet Nam for instance, male students were are reflected in Table 13.
found to be more confident in mathematics
with 30 per cent agreeing with the statement These questionnaire responses displayed in
as opposed to 22 per cent of female students. Table 13 provide an indication of student
In Indonesia however, a higher proportion of attitudes towards mathematics and science. In
female students reported that they felt confident particular, it can be observed that overall while
in mathematics at 23 per cent as opposed to 17 female students tend to have slightly higher
per cent of male students. Looking specifically levels of motivation and perseverance, more
at levels of anxiety, these varied by country. female students reported anxiety towards
In Indonesia and Nepal for instance, anxiety these subjects than male students.
towards mathematics performance was near-
equal among female and male students. In For instance in Indonesia, female and male
the case of Indonesia this was reported at 34 students both felt that their learning could
per cent in female students and 33 per cent in improve if they tried very hard. Among
male students. In the Republic of Korea where students who agreed with the statement, the
male students tend to outscore their female figure was 49 per cent of female students and
counterparts in mathematics and science in 46 per cent of male students in mathematics,
international assessments, higher anxiety was and 47 per cent of female students and 44 per
reported among female students at 37 per cent cent of male students in science. In Mongolia
in mathematics and 31 per cent in science, as and the Republic of Korea however, higher
opposed to 30 per cent in mathematics and levels of motivation and perseverance were
24 per cent in science among male students. observed among female students in these
In Malaysia however, where female students subjects, despite the fact that each country
outscore their male counterparts in international showed different levels of confidence and
assessments, greater anxiety towards these anxiety. In Mongolia, when asked to respond
subjects was also identified among female to the statement, “I want to do well in
students. In mathematics, 60 per cent of female mathematics”, 86 per cent of female students
students reported anxiety as opposed to reported that they agreed with the statement
56 per cent in male students, whereas in science as opposed to 62 per cent of male students,
82 per cent of female students reported anxiety which may perhaps be consistent with the
as opposed to 78 per cent of male students. To lower levels of confidence among male
a certain extent, one may consider how far the students. In the Republic of Korea however,
attitudes of female and male students link to where female students reported lower levels
gender differences in learning achievement as of confidence and higher levels of anxiety,
was observed in Chapter Four. they also reported higher levels of motivation
and perseverance. For instance, in responding
to the statements, “I want to do well in
18 See questions 14 for mathematics and questions 24 for science
in Annex 1. mathematics/science”, 39 per cent of female
63
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Table 13 Student attitudes towards mathematics and science in the seven countries under review by sex (%)
Mathematics
Confidence Anxiety Motivation Perseverance
Country %F %M %F %M %F %M %F %M
Cambodia 51 55 77 70 85 91 91 85
Indonesia 23 17 34 33 49 45 49 46
Malaysia 34 30 60 56 100 100 78 66
Mongolia 16 15 30 26 43 31 46 29
Nepal 30 29 30 30 44 42 44 44
Republic of Korea 23 23 37 30 48 44 43 41
Viet Nam 22 30 8 12 47 47 40 45
Science
Confidence Anxiety Motivation Perseverance
Country %F %M %F %M %F %M %F %M
Cambodia 57 55 66 60 77 89 91 87
Indonesia 26 29 27 27 46 41 47 44
Malaysia 40 54 82 78 42 50 74 76
Mongolia 31 32 16 20 46 37 47 36
Nepal 39 37 29 23 48 45 48 44
Republic of Korea 23 26 31 24 47 43 38 38
Viet Nam 12 19 17 20 43 45 36 46
Notes: P
ecentage refers to the proportion of students reporting 'agree' and 'strongly agree' within each category.
Low response rates to these questions in Mongolia.
Source: Based on responses to questions 11 and 21 of the student questionnaire (Annex 1).
students and 28 per cent of male students level of motivation and perseverance may
strongly agreed with regard to mathematics, perhaps be a result of feeling the need to
and in science 32 per cent of female students try harder than their male counterparts in
strongly agreed with the statement as order to perform well in these subjects. At the
opposed to 22 per cent of male students. The same time, the equal level of anxiety reported
findings suggest that despite higher levels by female and male students in Indonesia
of anxiety towards mathematics and science may reflect near-equal levels of learning
subjects among female students, their higher achievement.
64
C. Perceived parental and 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree)
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
teacher influences students ranked their perceived parental
and teacher encouragement as well as their
Having explored the attitudes of students own perceived importance with regard to
towards learning mathematics and science mathematics and science.
subjects, it is now important to consider
parental and teacher influences with This mean comparison of parental and
regard to these subjects. As part of the teacher encouragement along with perceived
questionnaire, students were asked a number importance of mathematics and science among
of questions related to parental and teacher students in Cambodia suggests that while
encouragement, their influence on grades, parents and teachers both play an important
and their perceived importance of these role in student interest in STEM education, the
subjects. Based on these findings, different level of perceived parental encouragement for
results arose among the seven countries, mathematics (3.78 on a scale of 1-5) seems to
with the most interesting cases highlighted in be more closely linked to students’ perceived
this section. Overall, it appears that there are importance in mathematics (3.81 on a scale of
no statistically significant gender differences 1-5) of these subjects as opposed to the level
among female and male student responses perceived teacher encouragement. Overall,
to questions regarding perceived parental it also appears that in the case of Cambodia,
and teacher influences with perhaps the students’ perceived importance of these
exception of Mongolia where more female subjects might be more greatly influenced by
students perceived parental encouragement their perceived level of parental encouragement
as important for mathematics and science at as opposed to teacher encouragement.
82 per cent for mathematics and 80 per cent In addition, parental encouragement with
for science, as opposed to 48 per cent and regard to mathematics is much higher than
40 per cent among male students respectively. for science, which is also observed in other
At the same time, a slight difference was
identified when students were asked
whether their teachers interacted with them Figure 20 Level of perceived parental and teacher
in mathematics class. In this case, a higher encouragement and students’ perceived importance of
proportion of male students supported the mathematics and science reported by students in Cambodia
statement at 70 per cent as opposed to
60 per cent for female students. 3.8 3.81
3.78
Overall, one finding which appeared in most of 3.7
3.7 3.7
the seven countries was that based on student 3.59
65
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
countries such as the Republic of Korea, Nepal Having explored various psychosocial
and Viet Nam. In Viet Nam in particular, the influences in this chapter, as well as the
level of perceived parental encouragement most pertinent results from the student
was not only higher for mathematics, but was questionnaire among the seven countries of
also reported by a high number of students focus, Box 2 puts these findings into context by
compared to other countries. For instance, presenting the perspectives of Jingmei Li from
among both female and male students, 95 per Singapore, who was among the 2014 UNESCO-
cent of students agreed or strongly agreed that L’Oréal International Fellowship Winners, an
their parents encouraging them in mathematics initiative which awards fellowships to 15 young
was important as opposed to 70 per cent of women from across the world with promising
students for science. research projects in science. Specialized in
“
Box 2 A Story from Jingmei Li of Singapore, 2014 UNESCO-L’Oréal International Fellowship Winner
When I first wondered why the sky is blue, passionate about work, I feel inspired to be passionate
or rather, when I first started asking questions about my own work. True passion is contagious!
– those are my earliest memories of my passion for
I've always likened my scientific career to a relationship -
science. Everything was a wonder then! Science was a
it sometimes feels like I'm married to my work! The secret
lot of being outdoors in the sun, learning about plants
to any relationship is to keep the love alive, and it’s the
and insects. Apart from learning the biology of plants
same with science. Because we’re doing basic science,
and animals, I feel that I gained a lot from just being
it’s not always clear that all the countless experiments
outdoors and appreciating nature as well, especially
and endless analyses we do and re-do have a direct
since I grew up in a ‘concrete jungle’. I used to go
impact for the good of humankind. And when we don’t
around with this mini book called “A Guide to the Wild
get the results we expect after all the hard work put in,
Flowers of Singapore”, and tried to identify as many
well, that can make a scientist quite mad and jaded.
roadside plants as possible. As we progressed through
Maybe, just maybe, women need to hear more words
primary school we learnt about other aspects of science,
of encouragement to keep them going! The biggest
which included wires, circuits and light bulbs – these
challenge is to maintain the faith that everything is
are still things we can see, touch and feel. Science in
worthwhile, and that every small puzzle we solve would
primary school was more hands-on, and I enjoyed every
contribute to a bigger picture.
moment of it! Then in secondary school we went into
biology, chemistry and physical laws, which took a little T here is an obvious disparity between women and men
more appreciation and imagination to understand in science, but I also believe that the situation is getting
what goes on beyond what we can see and made me better. Doors have very much opened to women for
realize how much there is to know. higher education. In Singapore, it is not uncommon
to see an even number of female and male students
hen girls perform poorly in mathematics and science,
W
in many of the science majors. I’m optimistic that it
the cause is environmental. I believe the explanation
will only be a matter of time before more women are
does not lie in a gender gap in terms of learning
celebrated in science, but of course that would take
achievement, but rather, it is what female students like
some commitment from the science community to
better. In some studies, female students are said to prefer
nurture and support them as well. There are challenges
medicine to mathematics and science, but that doesn’t
such as managing family, children, as well as their
mean they can’t be as good as their male counterparts
careers, but major accomplishments are that some
in other disciplines.
women manage to strike a really beautiful balance, in a
”
good dose of encouragement and motivation from
A great working environment, doing the thing they truly
my teachers and peers has gone a long way in kindling enjoy. We need more shining role models of women
my passion for science. When I see other people being in science to inspire more young women!
66
human genetics, Jingmei Li’s story, which is among both female and male students within
6 PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES
based on an interview conducted by UNESCO countries rather than by sex. At the same
Bangkok for the purpose of this study, expresses time, it was found that among all students,
the impact of relationships and encouragement science was more likely to be perceived as
from family, teachers and peers, as well as among the highest performance subjects
the importance of stimulating interest in as opposed to mathematics which was
mathematics and science among students. more likely to be perceived among lowest
performance subjects.
While the findings presented in this chapter can • Looking at student attitudes towards
only provide an indication of student attitudes mathematics and science subjects in
and perceptions based on the questionnaire terms of interest, perceived importance,
data sample, these findings, as well as those confidence, anxiety, as well as motivation
from other studies examined earlier in this and perseverance, different findings arose
chapter suggest that psychosocial influences among the seven countries. Some interesting
arguably play a significant role, if not perhaps linkages can be identified between student
the most significant role in influencing student attitudes reported through the questionnaire
achievement and participation in STEM fields of with participation in STEM fields of study in
study in higher education. The main reflections higher education and learning achievement
from this chapter can be summarised as follows: in mathematics and science as examined in
Part A of this report. For instance, in countries
• T he importance of psychosocial influences where the gender gap in participation and
in shaping student attitudes, achievement learning achievement was in favour of either
and eventually participation in STEM fields girls or boys in mathematics, female students
has been increasingly recognized through reported higher levels of anxiety across most
a growing body of research. In particular, countries towards this subject.
studies point to the need to recognize: 1)
• B
eyond the issue of gender differences
the vulnerability of certain groups, such as
in student performance in mathematics
female students, 2) the threat of negative
and science subjects, there may be further
stereotypes, and 3) the importance for psychosocial influences where female and
students to develop a growth mindset where male students are affected in different ways
capability or talent in any given subject is in terms of their attitudes to these subjects,
developed over time for any student rather and could provide an important area for
than something predetermined from birth. further investigation. The importance of
• W
ith regard to the results of the student parental and teacher encouragement
questionnaire, responses on subject must also be acknowledged, and as was also
preferences and perceived performance presented in Box 2, these encouragements
show that for both female and male students, are fundamental to all students in addressing
mathematics and science subjects often environmental and psychosocial influences
appear among the most enjoyed subjects, which have so far limited the participation of
though mathematics is more likely to women in STEM fields.
appear as among the most enjoyed for male
students and among the lowest perceived
performance subjects for female students as
illustrated in Figure 19. It also appeared that
subject preferences tend to be more similar
67
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Table 14 Economic and development context of the seven countries under review as of 2013
Republic of
Cambodia Indonesia Malaysia Mongolia Nepal Viet Nam
Korea
Lower Upper Lower Lower
Income level Low Income Middle Middle Middle Low Income High Income Middle
Income Income Income Income
Population 15.14 million 249.9 million 29.72 million 2.84 million 27.8 million 50.22 million 89.71 million
Gross National
USD USD USD USD USD USD USD
Income (GNI)
950 3,580 10,400 3,770 730 25,920 1,730
<per capita>
Female labour
participation 79 51 44 56 80 50 73
rate* <%>
Note: *Proportion of the female population aged 15 years old and above (rates as of 2012).
Source: World Bank, 2013
68
relate to what is known as occupational women enter professions in STEM, particularly
69
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Table 15 H
eadcount and proportion of researchers in science, technology and innovation in Asia as of the
latest available year by sex (%)
Notes: D
ata as of: -1 = 2012, -2 = 2011, -3 = 2010, -4 = 2009, -5 = 2007, -6 = 2005, -7 = 2002. Data on headcounts not available for
Cambodia and Viet Nam.
Source: UIS, 2014d Abbreviations: HC - Headcounts
– as was displayed in Table 5. At the same time, in favour of girls in science, while TIMSS 2011
Thailand, which showed the highest gender results show just two points in favour of boys in
gap in favour of girls in PISA 2012 results – mathematics and 15 points in favour of girls in
14 points in mathematics and 19 points ahead science. In Indonesia and Singapore however,
in science – shows an equal proportion of where scores were either near-equal or higher
women working as science researchers at 51 per in females in these assessments, the proportion
cent. This is also observed in Kazakhstan where of female researchers in science, technology
50 per cent of science researchers are female and innovation is lower than 50 per cent. It is
and where PISA 2012 scores in mathematics in fact 30 per cent in Singapore and 31 per cent
were equal among boys and girls, and 9 points in Indonesia.
70
A. Labour
participation in STEM fields levels of poverty and low levels of education
Table 16 Female labour participation in the labour market and wage differences in the seven countries under review as of 2013
Republic
Cambodia Indonesia Malaysia Mongolia Nepal Viet Nam
of Korea
Female labour
participation rate* 79 51 44 56 80 50 73
<%>
Wage differences** 0.70 0.69 0.81 0.82 0.62 0.51 0.63
Notes: * Proportion of the female population aged 15 years old and above (rates as of 2012).
** Scale: 0.00 = inequality; 1.00 = equality.
Sources: Female Labour Participation Rate (World Bank, 2013); Wage differences (World Economic Forum, 2014).
71
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
72
Taking a closer look at the proportion of female are often presented in literature as very
Figure 21 Proportion of female and male STEM professionals by profession in Malaysia (%)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Female Male
Source: Adapted DoHE, 2014, Table 1.4 19 Data collected from three universities: Gajah Mada University,
University of Indonesia, and Bogor Institute of Agriculture.
73
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Figure 22 Gender Parity Index (GPI) of grant-receiving senior STEM researchers in Indonesia
Social
0.58
0.1 0.15
0.2 0.25
0.3 0.35
0.4 0.45
0.5 0.55
0.6 1.7 1.75
1.8
Low GPI High GPI
0.1 0.32 0.4 0.56 1.8
Note: T he figure 1 would constitute perfect gender parity, whereas a figure below 1 shows an advantage to males and above one in favour of females.
Source: A
dapted from Directorate of Research and Community Services, 2014.
mechanical engineering (2.5 per cent) (Ibid). reviewed, a similar situation can also be
In addition, the Gender Parity Index (GPI) for observed to varying degrees. Looking at the
senior STEM researchers that received grants in level of positions that women hold in Malaysia,
the year 2013 shows an even lower proportion data from 2012 shows that they comprise
of female researchers, even in some fields 21.5 per cent of managers, 55.1 per cent of
where they tend to make up a majority, as professionals, and 32.5 per cent of technicians
displayed in Figure 22. and associate professionals (DoS, 2014). This
indicates that even in a country where women
This data shows that in the cases of Indonesia, tend to participate equally in the labour market
Malaysia and Mongolia, a higher proportion of as examined earlier in this chapter, they remain
female students are enrolled in STEM fields of a minority in top positions.
study in higher education and women who are
working in STEM fields tend to be concentrated When looking specifically at STEM fields, the
in sub-fields such as biology or health as Republic of Korea provides an interesting
opposed to engineering or physics. case when looking at the proportion of
women working in STEM-related fields by
C. Vertical segregation within type of institute and by employment. As
STEM fields displayed in Figure 23, female science and
engineering professionals working in research
Taking a look at vertical segregation (or and development are often concentrated
distribution of females and males by rank or in non-regular employment as opposed to
grade) in higher level managerial and decision- regular employment,20 and overall, they are
making positions within and beyond STEM least represented in private research institutes
fields, as in many other parts of the world, and universities as opposed to public research
women remain largely underrepresented in institutes, factors which may affect their
Asia. For instance across all fields, the share of prospects of progressing to higher positions.
female directors ranges from 10 per cent in the
Philippines, 7 per cent in China and Thailand to
5 per cent in Indonesia and under 2 per cent in
20 While regular employment refers to employees appointed for
the Republic of Korea and Japan (CWDI and an unlimited period of time, non-regular employment refers to
IFC, 2010). Among the seven countries employees contracted for temporary or fixed periods of time.
74
Figure 23 Proportion of female professionals in science and technology by institute and employment type in the
50
45
41.9
40
35
33.2
31.7
30
25
25 24.1
20
19
15
13.2 13.4
12.3
10
0
Science & Private Research Public Research Total proportion
Engineering Institute Institute female in S&T
Universities
Regular Non-regular
As shown in Figure 23, a high proportion Republic of Korea, this indicates less job
of female professionals in STEM fields are stability for women, which has also been
classified as non-regular workers, and only a considered as a barrier to women’s career
minority of women make up regular workers prospects across all fields in the labour
at 19 per cent as opposed to 81 per cent of market in various countries (UNESCO and
men working in science and technology. KWDI, 2013). In addition, retention of women
Looking more closely at science and in the workplace is another constraint for
engineering universities and both private and progressing to higher positions. Among female
public research institutes, between 12.3 and professionals who decided to discontinue
13.4 per cent of those in regular employment their profession in STEM fields for instance,
are women, as opposed to between 86.6 and the main reasons included having children
87.7 per cent of men. In the case of the (53.1 per cent) and marriage (17.9 per cent)
75
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
(WISET, 2013b). The lack of childcare facilities there appears to be a mismatch between
may further hamper the ability of women the fields within STEM fields that females
working in STEM fields to balance life and are choosing to pursue as opposed to those
work commitments. For example, data shows for which there is demand. In others, such
that childcare facilities in the workplace are as the Republic of Korea, data shows that
established and operated by only 326 out of female graduates in STEM-fields are also less
2,583 (11.2 per cent) of STEM institutions likely to be employed in STEM fields than
(MSIP, 2014c). their male counterparts.
ith regard to horizontal segregation,
• W
This chapter demonstrates that a number it appears that women are concentrated
of gaps remain with regard to women’s in specific occupations within STEM and
participation in the labour market overall, and that there may be a link to the enrolment
in particular in specific STEM fields where they of female students in STEM by field of study
remain largely underrepresented. The main in higher education. For instance, a higher
findings can be outlined as follows: proportion of women work in professions
related to medicine or biology as opposed
• L ooking at economic and development to a low proportion of women working in
indicators across the seven countries physics or engineering, which relates to the
under review, female participation in proportion of female students enrolled in
the labour market and wage differences these respective fields of study in higher
between women and men are still unequal education.
across all fields of work.
• Looking at vertical segregation in terms
• The proportion of women in STEM, of the distribution of women by rank or
or as displayed in Table 15, the number of status within STEM, women are less likely to
female researchers in science, technology be in higher level positions. In the case of
and innovation, can vary widely by country the Republic of Korea for instance, women
yet in most countries in Asia, women are more likely to be in non-regular work,
remain a minority. which can greatly affect their prospects
• It could be argued that there may be a for promotion to such positions. At the
potential link between the gender gap same time, it appears that limited support
in learning achievement in mathematics offered to women working in STEM fields
and science and the proportion of female may affect retention as well as progression
researchers. For instance, in countries in these fields due to the difficulties faced
where boys outperform girls in mathematics in maintaining a balance between family
and science in international assessments, responsibilities and professional life – a
there tends to be a lower proportion of balance which could also be shared by
female researchers than in countries where male scientists.
boys and girls have equal scores or where
girls outscore boys.
76
Part C
8 REFLECTIONS
n
Girls and Women in STEM:
Where to from here?
8 Reflections
Based on the review of various areas relating most determining factors in shaping the
to gender and education in this report, it perspectives and choices of female and male
could be argued that a number of links can be students with regard to pursuing further study
observed between female students’ learning and a career in STEM as observed in responses
achievement in mathematics and science and to the student questionnaire. The higher level
the participation of women in STEM fields of of anxiety reported by female students in most
study in higher education as well as in the of the seven countries under review, regardless
labour market. For instance, among countries of the gender gap in achievement in STEM-
where male students’ learning achievement related subjects, demonstrates that there
is higher in these subjects, female students is need for greater care to alleviate anxiety
tend to be less well represented in STEM fields among female students by both teachers as
in higher education and the labour market well as parents. For instance, this was identified
than in countries where female students in countries where the gender gap in learning
achieve a higher level of learning performance achievement in mathematics and science was
in mathematics and science. Several factors, in favour of girls with a high proportion of
bracketed under educational, psychosocial, women enrolled in STEM fields (e.g. Malaysia),
and labour market influences all contribute as well as countries where the gap is in favour
in one way or another to gendered learning of boys with a comparatively lower proportion
achievement and participation in STEM fields of women enrolled (e.g. Republic of Korea).
of study, which generate some important Further research is required to assess how
points for reflection. psychosocial factors affect females with regard
to mathematics and science subjects beyond
First, STEM is a vast collection of fields where the issue of learning achievement. As illustrated
women participate to varying degrees. While a in the case study in Box 2 and across Chapter
high proportion of women may be enrolled in Six, encouragement of students appears
specific disciplines such as biology or medicine particularly important, whether from peers,
in higher education, in most countries women teachers, parents or employers.
remain a minority in physics, mathematics and
engineering – a situation which continues Educational actions, such as the proportion
in the labour market. At the same time, of female role models in teaching at higher
the importance of psychosocial influences levels of education, as well as gender-
should not be underestimated. Psychosocial responsive teaching strategies, curricula,
influences arguably constitute one of the career counselling and scholarship
77
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
programmes, could also play a significant below in the form of reflections on the issues
role in addressing gender disparity and common to most countries reviewed, as well
promoting a more balanced representation as from country-specific policy considerations
of women and men in STEM fields. Case presented in Annex 5. Box 3 provides the
studies show that female and male students considered perspective of Kayo Inaba, 2014
may place equal importance on mathematics Laureate of the L’Oréal-UNESCO For Women
and science subjects, yet are not represented in Science Awards, which reflects well the
equally. Through design and implementation overall findings of this report.
of gender-responsive interventions, female
and male students may be able to pursue Areas for consideration:
fields of study in which they can excel and • Gender-responsive action from
exert genuine passion in STEM-related governments, through education
education and careers. Finally, there is a need and labour market policies, including
for governments to provide more targeted enforcement of gender-related laws, as
support to attract more girls and women into well as specific initiatives for advocacy and
STEM fields, particularly those in which they awareness raising, is needed to attract more
are underrepresented, through education and girls and women into STEM fields.
labour market policies, including enforcement • In order to ensure the effective
of laws regarding gender equality. implementation of policies related
to education, gender and/or STEM,
With this in mind, a number of gaps and areas coordination between ministries should
for improvement can be identified based on be strengthened. This may involve joint
the main findings presented in this report. programmes across various government
These areas for consideration are presented sectors such as ministries of education,
Box 3 Reflections from Kayo Inaba of Japan, Asia-Pacific Laureate of the 2014 L’Oréal-UNESCO For Women in Science Awards
Within and beyond STEM fields, there are a number of actions and measures that could be taken to
help encourage more young women to pursue careers in fields that they love:
• Teach female students in upper secondary • Set quotas at various levels for the recruitment and
about the fun side of STEM fields and promotion of women in STEM fields, including for senior
involve female teachers and female and executive positions.
university students.
• P rovide clear and fair guidelines for the recruitment,
• Organize study visits for students to retention, and promotion of female employees.
explore and practice their knowledge
• Introduce support programmes for women which include
in workplaces where they can meet
mentoring and career development, as well as provision of
female role models.
female-friendly working arrangements such as cover during
maternity leave and remote working arrangements.
• Establish a zero-tolerance policy towards any type of
harassment against and isolation of women in the workplace.
© L'Oreal UNESCO For Women in Science Source: Interview conducted by UNESCO Bangkok on 15th September 2014
78
women’s affairs or gender equality, • S tructured and formalized gender-
9 CONCLUSIONS
science, technology and innovation, responsive career counselling
as well as labour. programmes should be considered in order
for both female and male students to have
• Further data disaggregated by sex support and objective guidance as they
is needed to conduct in-depth analysis begin to shape their career choices.
at country level and help provide a clearer
picture of women's and girls’ participation • S
cholarship programmes targeted at girls
within STEM, which will inform policies and women in STEM would also contribute
and programmes for increased participation to increased opportunities for young women
of women in STEM-related education and to pursue further study and eventually
employment sectors such as engineering careers in STEM fields.
and physics. • Promoting more female role models in
• C
urricula and learning materials STEM fields, whether female teachers in
should undergo further rigorous review from mathematics and science at the secondary
a gender perspective to ensure that they level, female students and faculty members
do not perpetuate gender stereotypes. This in higher education, and more broadly
would ideally involve a representative group more women working in STEM fields, is
of stakeholders with male and female experts an important strategy to attract girls and
in order to ensure different perspectives. women into STEM fields.
• T
eacher education and policies • Finally, adequate support programmes and
on recruitment must ensure a fair initiatives for female STEM professionals
representation of both male and female would help to address some of the factors
teachers in all subjects, including which can cause them to discontinue their
mathematics and science, at all levels of careers, including family responsibilities. This
education and especially in higher levels will also help them be equipped with the
of education where students look to their most up-to-date knowledge and skills in a
teachers as role models as they begin to field which experiences fast-paced change
shape career perspectives and choices. and innovation.
79
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
and higher education as well as in the world significant gender differences in terms of
of work – several factors, be they educational, interest and attitudes towards science and
psychosocial and/or labour market effects, mathematics. Instead, the conclusions from
interact and influence in shaping the pathways these two countries suggest that the main
of the next generation of STEM professionals factor affecting the achievement of both
as has been examined in this report. female and male students lies in the quality
of education. Indeed, teaching and learning
While boys continue to outscore girls should be improved through the provision of
in mathematics and science in learning highly qualified teachers and improved teacher
assessments in some countries, the gap is preparation, as well as higher levels of student
narrowing, especially in science. In other involvement in the learning process.
countries such as Malaysia and Thailand, a
reversed gender gap can be observed in According to the results of the data collected
favour of female students. At the same time, across all of the seven countries, female
the gender differences in achievement as well students tend to have a more positive attitude
as the career pathways of young women and towards mathematics and science, as well as
men within STEM fields in these countries and higher motivation, perseverance and desire
across the seven countries are apparent. To a to pursue further education in STEM fields
certain extent, this is reflected in the proportion of study. This however, does not necessarily
of female students enrolled in STEM fields translate into a higher level of participation
of study in higher education as well as their and learning outcomes of women in these
representation in STEM sectors in the labour fields in education and the labour market. In
market in these two countries. Nonetheless, addition, the higher degree of anxiety towards
across all countries, the proportion of women mathematics and science subjects among
and girls represented in the highest levels of female students in most of the seven countries
achievement such as the Nobel Prize, Fields reviewed suggests that specific actions should
Medal or International Olympiads remain be taken to attract more girls and women
significantly low. into STEM fields of study and careers through
appropriate policy interventions. Such gender-
The different research methods used in this responsive interventions may include teacher
study have allowed for a deeper understanding recruitment and training policies, scholarships,
of these patterns, through examining the and partnerships with STEM sectors at the
gender dimension of learning achievement labour market level, including with institutes,
and participation in STEM, in light of possible universities and the private sector.
psychosocial, labour market and educational
influences. The concentration of female While a number of gaps and areas for
students enrolled in specific STEM fields of improvement remain with regard to the
study such as biology and health sciences as promotion of girls and women in STEM (as
opposed to the very low proportion in physics observed in Chapter Eight), there are also some
and engineering appears to be reflected among positive signals. The gender gap in learning
all seven countries under review, both in higher achievement in mathematics and science is
education as well as in the labour market. narrowing, especially in science, while at the
Turning to educational and psychosocial same time both female and male students
influences, findings from Cambodia and showed a positive attitude towards these
Indonesia, for example, demonstrate no subjects in the seven countries under review.
80
Although female students reported a higher to the selection and participation of student
9 CONCLUSIONS
degree of anxiety towards mathematics and delegations in International Olympiads, while
science, they also report a higher degree of promoting young medallists and in particular
motivation and perseverance in most of these female medallists as youth role models in their
countries, which shows their desire to succeed countries. Turning to psychosocial influences,
in these subjects. Looking at participation more research is needed at country level to
in higher education, in some of the seven inform governments on how student attitudes
countries under review the proportion of and interests towards mathematics and science
female graduates in science, technology are affected, and in particular among female
and innovation (see Figure 4), as well as the students, to enable them to thrive in whatever
proportion of female researchers in these fields field they wish to pursue, including STEM fields.
(see Table 15) is near equal to the proportion More broadly, countries would be encouraged
of men, particularly in the case of Malaysia and to investigate a number of the areas examined
Mongolia as well as in some other countries of in this report through in-depth review within
Asia. Looking at prestigious awards obtained their country context.
by female STEM professionals, such as the
awarding of the Fields Medal for mathematics Science, Technology, Engineering and
to a woman for the first time in 2014, as well Mathematics are fields of study which each
as the continued work of the L’Oréal-UNESCO contribute significantly to global innovation
For Women in Science Awards, these arguably and development, particularly now as we
show a positive step in highlighting female move further into increasingly knowledge-
role models in STEM fields for young women based societies. The pursuance of STEM among
worldwide. women and girls – both in education and
employment – is still limited and this is true not
This report has aimed to contribute knowledge just of developing countries but of all countries
with regard to gender, learning achievement including those of Asia. If women are to stand
and progression to STEM fields in Asia. In alongside men as equal contributors to the
exploring the role of educational, psychosocial building of just, peaceful and prosperous
and labour market influences however, it is societies, they must be ensured the equal
clear that there are areas remaining which opportunity to learn in all areas, including
require further investigation. The varying STEM. By exploring the gendered dimensions
levels of female participation within STEM of learning and participation in STEM fields,
fields both in higher education and the as well as psychosocial and labour market
labour market, in particular in fields such as influences, this report has served to expose
physics and engineering presents one area for the multivariate factors inhibiting the greater
further exploration. With regard to learning engagement of women in STEM and in doing,
achievement in international assessments, shine light of the ways in which policymakers
further analysis focused on countries that are and practitioners may together work towards
both among the highest performing and with gender equality in Asia and beyond.
a relatively smaller gender gap in student
performance in mathematics and science
(e.g. Singapore and Hong Kong- China) could
help identify determining factors and draw
lessons for other countries in the region. Further
analysis could also be conducted with regard
81
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
82
Directorate of Research and Community Gibbons, M. T. 2009. Engineering by the
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Services. 2014. Reka Data Dosen Tetap numbers. In Profiles of engineering and
Berdasarkan Jenis Kelamin [List of researchers]. engineering technology colleges. Washington, DC:
Jakarta: MoEC. American Society for Engineering Education.
Do, L. T. 2014. Viet Nam country report on Google. 2014. Made w/ code Google.
gender, learning achievement and STEM. https://www.madewithcode.com
Prepared for UNESCO Bangkok. Unpublished. (Accessed 21 June, 2014)
83
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
HRINC. 2010. Higher Education and Skills for the IOI. 2014. IOI 2014 Contestants. International
Labor Market in Cambodia. Phnom Penh: HRINC. Olympiad in Informatics - Statistics: http://stats.
ioinformatics.org/contestants/2014
IBO. 2014. IBO 2014 Results. IBO 2014: http:// (Accessed 23 September, 2014)
ibo2014.org/international-biology-olympiad/
results/ (Accessed 22 September, 2014) IPhO. 2014. Results. IPHO 2014: http://
ipho2014.kz/blogs/view/1/42
IEA. 2012a. TIMSS 2011 International Results in (Accessed 23 September, 2014)
Mathematics. Chesnut Hill, MA: IEA. http://
timss.bc.edu/timss2011/downloads/T11_IR_ Jones, G. 2006. Gender differences in science
Mathematics_FullBook.pdf competitions. Science Education, 75(2), 159-167.
(Accessed 1 August, 2014) http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/
sce.3730750202/abstract (Accessed 13
___. 2012b. TIMSS 2011 International Results September, 2014)
in Science. Chesnut Hill, MA: IEA. http://timss.
bc.edu/timss2011/downloads/T11_IR_Science_ Kabeer, N., Van anh, T. T. and Manh Loi, V.
FullBook.pdf (Accessed 1 August, 2014) 2005. Preparing for the Future: Forward-looking
Strategies to Promote Gender Equity in Viet
___. 2012c. TIMSS 2011 Assessment Frameworks.
Nam. A United Nations World Bank Thematic
Boston MA: IEA. http://timss.bc.edu/timss2011/
Discussion Paper. Ha Noi: UNDP. http://www.
downloads/TIMSS2011_Frameworks.pdf
vn.undp.org/content/vietnam/en/home/
(Accesed 15 September, 2014)
library/democratic_governance/preparing-
for-the-future--forward-looking-strategies-to-
IIEP. 2012. Gender Equality in Education: Looking promote-.html (Accessed 13 September, 2014)
Beyond Parity. Paris: UNESCO IIEP. http://www.
iiep.unesco.org/fileadmin/user_upload/
Kafle, B. D. 2014. Nepal country report on gender,
Cap_Dev_Training/Virtual_Institute/pdf/
Forums/2012/Report_e_Forum_gender_2012. learning achievement and STEM. Prepared for
pdf (Accessed 23 July, 2014) UNESCO Bangkok. Unpublished.
ILO. 2013. A policy mix for gender equality? KEDI. 2014. Number of Students by city/province
Lessons from high-income countries. International based on majoring field of study in higher
Institute for Labour Studies Discussion Paper. education. Korean Education Statistics Service.
Geneva: ILO. http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/ Seoul: KEDI. http://kess.kedi.re.kr/stats/school?
groups/public/---dgreports/---inst/documents/ menuCd=0102&cd=1877&survSeq=2013&item
publication/wcms_206235.pdf Code=01&menuId=m_010204_02_01020502
(Accessed 25 September, 2014) &uppCd1=01020402&uppCd2=01020502&flag
=A (Accessed 18 September, 2014)
IMO. 2014. 55th IMO 2014. Individual Results.
International Mathematical Olympiad: http:// Kelley, Plakmeyer, Shan, Sonnenberg, and
www.imo-official.org/year_individual_ Vargas. 2013. Science performance among female
r.aspx?year=2014 (Accessed 23 September, 2014) students: An evaluation of science labs, utilization
and teachers’ skills and attitudes towards the field
IMU. 2014. The Work of Maryam Mirzakhani. Press
of science at CFC schools. Unpublished.
Release. http://www.mathunion.org/fileadmin/
IMU/Prizes/2014/news_release_mirzakhani.pdf
(Accessed 30 September, 2014)
84
Kemdikbud. 2013. Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam MoE (Nepal). 2011. School Level Educational
BIBLIOGRAPHY
kelas VII SMP [Student Book of Science for grade Statistics of Nepal. Consolidated Report.
VII]. Jakarta: MONE. Kathmandu: MoE.
Khishigbuyan. 2014. Mongolia country report on MoE (Malaysia). 2013a. Examination Statistics
gender, learning achievement and STEM. Prepared Report 2009-2013, Examinations Syndicate.
for UNESCO Bangkok. Unpublished. Putrajaya: MoE.
Kim, K., Shin, J., Park, I., Yim, E., Gu, N., Han, J. and ___. 2013b. Malaysia Education Blueprint 2013-
Kim, S. 2012. Results of the National Assessment 2025 (Preschool to Post-Secondary Education).
of Educational Achievement in High School (RRE Putrajaya: MoE.
2013-2-3). Seoul: KICE.
MoE (Republic of Korea). 2014. The results of
Lee, H. 2014. Proactive educational reforms OECD education indicators in 2013. Seoul: MoE.
in South Korea: Schools for Improvement and http://www.moe.go.kr/web/45859/ko/
multicultural education. http://ries.revues. board/view.do?bbsId=294&boardSeq=48981
org/3897#tocto1n2 (Accessed 24 October, 2014) (Accessed 25 June, 2014)
Lee, I., Jo, Y. and Lee, K. 2014. Results of the MoEC. 2014. Education for All national review:
National Assessment of Educational Achievement Indonesia. Paris: UNESCO. http://unesdoc.
in 2013 - Mathematics. Seoul: KICE. unesco.org/images/0022/002298/229874E.pdf
(Accessed 24 October, 2014)
Lee, I., Shim, H., Kim, H., Lee, K. and Lee, B. 2014.
MoET. 2009. Report of a Survey on achievement
Results of the National Assessment of Educational
scores in mathematics, reading, physics and
Achievement in 2013- Science. Seoul: KICE.
english among grade 9 students in the school year
2008-2009. Ha Noi: MoET.
Lee, K. 2010. Women in Science, Engineering
and Technology (SET) in Korea: Improving
Retention and Building Capacity. International ___. 2014. Manual of Education Statistics
Journal of Gender, Science and Technology, Yearbook (2010-2011;2011-2012;2012-
2(2), 236-248. http://genderandset.open. 2013;2013-2014). Ha Noi: MoET.
ac.uk/index.php/genderandset/article/
viewFile/95/122 (Accessed 23 October, 2014) MoEYS. 2012. Science Textbook, Grade 9.
Phnom Penh: MoEYS.
Mahdzir, A. M., Ali, N. L., Hamzah, H. and Khatab,
Z. A. 2014. Malaysia country report on gender, ___. 2014. Higher Education. MoEYS. http://
learning achievement and STEM. Prepared for www.moeys.gov.kh/en/education/higher-
education.html (Accessed 15 June, 2014)
UNESCO Bangkok. Unpublished.
85
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
MoHR. 2012. Labour and Human Resouces NIS. 2012. Cambodia Social Economic Survey .
Statistics 2012. http://www.mohr.gov.my/docz/ Phnom Penh: NIS.
StatistikPerburuhan2012latest.pdf (Accessed 15
September, 2014) Nobelprize.org. 2014. Nobel Prize Facts.
http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/facts/
MoNE. 2010. Rencana Strategis Kementerian (Accessed 29 October, 2014)
Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan 2010-2014
[Ministry of National Education Strategic NSO. (2012). National Statistics Yearbook.
Plan 2010-2014]. Ulaanbaatar: NSO. http://en.nso.mn/
(Accessed 30 July, 2014)
MoSTI. 2012. Science and Technology Human
OECD. 2011. Report on the Gender Initiative:
Capital Roadmap. Putrajaya: MoSTI. http://www.
Gender Equality in Education, Employment and
mosti.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content
Entrepreneurship. Paris: OECD. http://www.oecd.
&view=article&id=2393&lang=en
(Accessed 11 September, 2014) org/education/48111145.pdf
(Accessed 5 June, 2014)
MSIP. 2013. 2012 Women in Science
___. 2013. Ready to Learn: Students’ Engagement,
and Technology Workforce Survey Results.
Drive and Self-Beliefs. PISA 2012 results (Volume
Seoul: MSIP.
II). Paris: OECD. http://www.oecd.org/pisa/
keyfindings/pisa-2012-results-volume-III.pdf
___. 2014a. The Third Master Plan for Fostering
(Accessed 24 April, 2014)
and Supporting Women in Science, Engineering
and Technology (2013-2018). Seoul: MSIP. http:// ___. 2014. PISA 2012 Results: What Students
www.msip.go.kr/www/brd/m_211/view. Know and Can Do – Student Performance in
do?seq=1664 (Accessed 12 September, 2014)
Mathematics, Reading and Science (Volume I,
Revised edition, February 2014). Paris: OECD.http://
___. 2014b. 2014 National Science and
www.oecd.org/pisa/keyfindings/pisa-2012-
Engineering Excellence Scholarships. Seoul: MSIP. results-volume-I.pdf (Accessed 24 April, 2014)
http://www.msip.go.kr/www/brd/m_211/view.
do?seq=1361 (Accessed 12 September, 2014) Park, K. 2014. Factors Contributing to Korean
Students’ High Achievement in Mathematics.
___. 2014c. 2012 Report on the status of http://matrix.skku.ac.kr/For-ICME-11/ICME/
women in science, engineering and technology. Chap6(kPark).htm (Accessed 24 October, 2014)
Seoul: MSIP.
Resos, A. 2014. The Empowerment of Women
Myers, R. E., and Fouts, J. T. 1992. A cluster in South Korea. (J. o. Articles), Editor).
analysis of classroom environments and http://jia.sipa.columbia.edu/online-articles/
attitudes toward science. Journal of Educational empowerment-women-south-korea/
Research, 29, 929-937. (Accessed 15 September, 2014)
Griffin, P. and Nguyen, T. 2011. Gender Sanders, J. 2005. Gender and Technology in
differences in student achievement in Vietnam: Education: A Research Review. In: Handbook of
Findings from the 2007 national survey of Gender Equity and Information Technology in
student achievement. Gender Equality in Education. http://www.montana.edu/wrt/
Education: Looking beyond parity. UNESCO, IIEP. GenderandTechnology.pdf
Paris, 3-4 October 2011, UNESCO. Unpublished. (Accessed 27 October, 2014)
86
Sani, R. 2014. Indonesia country report on Terry, G. and Thapa, N. 2012. Gender Audit of
BIBLIOGRAPHY
gender, learning achievement and STEM. Nepal’s School Sector Reform Programmes. A Study
Prepared for UNESCO Bangkok. Unpublished. Commissioned by DfID and the Royal Norwegian
Empassy as part of the Mid-term Review.
Schechter, R. 2010. Malaysian Women
redefine gender roles in technology.
UGC. 2013. Status of higher education in
http://gender.stanford.edu/news/2011/
Nepal 2011/12. Kathmandu: University Grants
malaysian-women-redefine-gender-roles-
Commission.
technology (Accessed 13 September, 2014)
Shapiro, J. R. and Williams, A. M. 2012. The Role UIS. 2012. Global Education Digest 2012.
of Stereotype Threats in Undermining Girls’ and Opportunities lost: The impact of grade repetition
Women’s Performance and Interest in STEM and early school leaving. Montreal: UIS. http://
Fields. Sex Roles; February 2012, Vol. 66 Issue 3/4. www.uis.unesco.org/Education/GED%20
http://www.academia.edu/806308/The_role_ Documents%20C/GED-2012-Complete-Web3.
of_stereotype_threats_in_undermining_girls_ pdf (Accessed 30 July, 2014)
and_womens_performance_and_interest_in_
STEM_fields (Accessed 12 June, 2014) ___. 2014a. Quantifying Women in Science:
Smith-Hefner, N. J. 1993. Education, gender, Interative Tool. http://www.uis.unesco.org/
and generational conflict among Khmer ScienceTechnology/Pages/women-in-science-
refugees. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, leaky-pipeline-data-viz.aspx
Vol. 2010, No. 1 pp3457-3460. (Accessed 9 June, 2014).
Statistics Indonesia. 2013. Women and Men in ___. 2014b. Education: Participation. UIS
Indonesia 2013. Jakarta: Statistics Indonesia (BPS). Database. http://data.uis.unesco.org/Index.
aspx?DataSetCode=EDULIT_DS
___. 2014. National Labour Force Survey 2014.
(Accessed 7 November, 2014)
Jakarta: BPS. http://www.bps.go.id/
(Accessed 30 July, 2014)
___. 2014c. Database. Education: Percentage
Statistics Korea. 2014. Women’s Lives of female graduates by field of study. UIS
through Statistics. http://kostat.go.kr/ Database. http://data.uis.unesco.org/Index.
portal/english/news/1/1/index. aspx?DataSetCode=EDULIT_DS
board?bmode=read&aSeq=307628 (Accessed 7 November, 2014)
(Accessed 12 September, 2014)
___. 2014d. Database on science, technology
Stoet, G. and Geary, D. C. 2013. Sex Difference
in Mathematics and Reading Achievement Are and innovation. Human Resources in research
Inversely Related: Within- and Across- Nation and development (R&D). Researchers. UIS Data
Assessment of 10 Years of PISA Data. PLoS ONE Centre. http://data.uis.unesco.org/Index.
8(3): e57988. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0057988. aspx?queryid=64 (Accessed 29 October, 2014)
http://www.plosone.org/article/fetchObject.ac
tion?uri=info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.po UN. 2011. Statement by the Honourable
ne.0057988&representation=PDF Mr. Nur Jazlan Mohamed. Member of
(Accessed 9 January, 2014) Parliament and Representative of Malaysia at
the Third Committee of the 66th Session of
Szmodies, W. and Eng, S. 2014. Cambodia the United Nations General Assembly. New
country report on gender, learning achievement York, 11 October 2011. http://www.un.org/
and STEM. Prepared for UNESCO Bangkok. womenwatch/daw/documents/ga66/Malaysia.
Unpublished. pdf (Accessed 13 September, 2014)
87
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
UNESCO. 2009. GENIA Toolkit for Promoting UNGEI. 2012. Why are Boys Underperforming
Gender Equality in Education. Paris: UNESCO. Girls? Gender Analysis of Four Asia-Pacific
Paris: UNESCO. http://www.unescobkk.org/ Countries. New York: UNGEI. http://www.
education/gender/resources/genia-toolkit/ unicef.org/eapro/report_why_are_boys_
(Accessed 5 June, 2014) underperforming_FINAL.pdf
(Accessed 23 July, 2014)
___. 2010a. Advocacy Brief. Gender Issues in Higher
UNIFEM. 2009. Time for Action: Implementing
Education. Paris: UNESCO. http://unesdoc.
CEDAW in Southeast Asia. Bangkok: UNIFEM.
unesco.org/images/0018/001898/189825e.pdf
(Accessed 23 October, 2014) http://unwomen-asiapacific.org/docs/
cedaw/archive/timeforaction/2_chapter1.pdf
(Accessed 22 October, 2014)
___. 2010b. Women’s and Girls’ Access to
and Participation in Science and Technology. Wall Street Journal. 2014. The Best Language
Paris: UNESCO. http://www.uis.unesco.org/ for Math. Confusing English Number Words
ScienceTechnology/Documents/unesco-egm- Are Linked to Weaker Skills. 15 September
science-tech-gender-2010-en.pdf 2014. http://online.wsj.com/articles/the-best-
(Accessed 30 July, 2014) language-for-math-1410304008?mod=e2fb
(Accessed 24 October, 2014)
___. 2014a. Gender Summary. EFA
WISET. 2012. 2011 Korea report on women in
Global Monitoring Report. Teaching and
science and technology. Seoul: WISET.
Learning: Achieving quality for all. Paris:
UNESCO. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/ ___. 2013a. WISET Programs. http://www.wiset.
images/0022/002266/226662e.pdf re.kr/eng/wedo/info01.jsp
(Accessed 3 July, 2014) (Accessed 12 September, 2014)
___. 2014b. EFA Global Monitoring Report. ___. 2013b. Survey of voluntary job
Teaching and Learning: Achieving quality for discontinuation in Women. Seoul: WISET.
all. Paris: 2014. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/ http://www.wiset.re.kr/return/data/data03_
images/0022/002256/225660e.pdf view.jsp?sc_board_seq=503&pk_seq=15234
(Accessed 24 July, 2014) (Accessed 12 September, 2014)
88
___. 2012. Toward Gender Equality in East
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Asia and the Pacific. A Companion to the
World Development Report. Washington
DC: World Bank. http://siteresources.
worldbank.org/EASTASIAPACIFICEXT/
Resources/226300-1339798342386/eap-gender-
full-conference.pdf (Accessed 5 June, 2014)
89
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
n Annexes
Annex 1. Student Questionnaire
Instructions School Subject Preferences
Please answer all of the questions in this Q4. Which of the following subjects do you
questionnaire and read each one carefully. most enjoy at school?
The questionnaire aims to obtain your views
Please tick your top three choices.
and attitudes on different subjects you are
studying at school, with specific sections on
Algebra
mathematics and science, as well as your
views on further study and career interests. Biology
When answering the questions, reflect on how Chemistry
you feel about each statement. Note that this Design/Technology
survey is anonymous and that your name will
not be recorded or shared at any time. Geography
History
Life Skills
Background Questions Moral and Ethics Education
Q1. What grade are you in?
Physical Education
...................................................................................................................................
90
Q5. Which of the following subjects do you Q6. Which of the following subjects do you
ANNEX 1
not enjoy at school? think you perform best at in school?
Please tick your bottom three choices. Please tick your top three choices.
Algebra Algebra
Biology Biology
Chemistry Chemistry
Design/Technology Design/Technology
Geography Geography
History History
Life Skills
Life Skills
Moral and Ethics Education
Moral and Ethics Education
Physical Education
Physical Education
Science (general)
Art
Art
Calculus
Calculus
Computer Science
Computer Science
Foreign Languages
Foreign Languages
Geometry Geometry
Language and Literature Language and Literature
Mathematics (general) Mathematics (general)
Music Music
Physics Physics
Social Science Social Science
................................................................................................................................... ...................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................... ...................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................... ...................................................................................................................................
Q6. continued Please specify why you think you perform best in these subjects :
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
91
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Q7.Which of the following subjects do you Q8. During this academic year [or during
think you perform worst at in school? the last 12 months] have you received
any fee-paying supplementary tutoring
Please tick your bottom three choices. beyond official school hours (at school,
in a tutoring centre, at home or
anywhere else)?
Algebra
Biology Yes
Chemistry
No
Design/Technology
Geography If yes, please specify which subject
History (tick all that are applicable):
Life Skills
Biology
Moral and Ethics Education
Mathematics
Art
Calculus Chemistry
Computer Science Physics
Foreign Languages Other subjects (please specify):
Geometry
Language and Literature
Please indicate the reasons for receiving
Mathematics (general) tutoring (tick all that are applicable):
Music
Physics To improve examination score
Q7. continued Please specify why you think you perform worst in these subjects :
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
92
Mathematics
ANNEX 1
Views and attitudes towards mathematics
Please tick one topic below: Please explain in the space below:
..................................................................................................................................
Algebra
..................................................................................................................................
Geometry
..................................................................................................................................
Calculus
..................................................................................................................................
Other (please specify):
..................................................................................................................................
Q10. Which mathematics topic do you Q13. What do you like the least about
like the least? mathematics class?
Please tick one topic below: Please explain in the space below:
Algebra ..................................................................................................................................
Geometry ..................................................................................................................................
Calculus ..................................................................................................................................
Other (please specify): ..................................................................................................................................
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
A I enjoy mathematics class.
B I feel confident about my abilities in mathematics.
C I do not feel confident about my abilities in mathematics.
D I want to do well in mathematics.
E I look forward to mathematics class.
F If I study very hard I think I can improve in mathematics.
G I can solve mathematical problems easily and quickly.
I have trouble solving mathematical problems and take time to
H
understand.
93
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
A I worry about my mathematics grades.
B My grades in mathematics are good.
C My grades in mathematics are poor.
D I feel I perform better in mathematics than most of my classmates.
E I feel that most of my classmates perform better in mathematics than me.
94
Q17. M
y teacher(s) in mathematics class. ..................................................................................................................................
ANNEX 1
Please state if your mathematics
..................................................................................................................................
teacher in the current school year is
female or male: ..................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................
Female
..................................................................................................................................
Male
..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
Q18. M
y parent(s)’ views on mathematics.
Please state how far you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Please tick one box for each row only.
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
95
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Science
Views and attitudes towards science
Q19. W
hich science topic do you like Q22. What do you like the most about
the most? science class?
Please tick one topic below: ..................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................
Biology
..................................................................................................................................
Physics
..................................................................................................................................
Chemistry
..................................................................................................................................
Other (please specify):
..................................................................................................................................
Biology ..................................................................................................................................
Physics ..................................................................................................................................
Chemistry ..................................................................................................................................
Other (please specify): ..................................................................................................................................
Q21. V
iews and attitudes towards science in general.
Please state how far you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
A I enjoy science class.
B I feel confident about my abilities in science.
C I do not feel confident about my abilities in science.
D I want to do well in science.
E I look forward to science class.
F If I study very hard I think I can improve in science.
G I find science easy and learn quickly.
H I find science difficult and take time to understand.
96
Q24.Grades in science.
ANNEX 1
Please state how far you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Please tick one box for each row only.
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
It is important for me to do well in science so that I can also do
A
well in other subjects
B Science is important for my everyday life.
C Science is important for my future education.
D Science is important for my future career.
97
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Q27. M
y teacher(s) in science class.
Please state if your mathematics teacher ..................................................................................................................................
in the current school year is female or
..................................................................................................................................
male:
..................................................................................................................................
Female ..................................................................................................................................
Male
..................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................
If you have more than one teacher for general
science in the current school year or for specific ..................................................................................................................................
topics e.g. biology, chemistry or physics, please
state their gender for each in the space below: ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
Strongly Strongly
Agree Not sure Disagree
Agree Disagree
A My parent(s) encourage(s) me to do well/better in science.
98
Plans for Higher Education
ANNEX 1
and Future Career
Q29. Do you plan to pursue higher education Q31. Do you think that the subject chosen in
after graduating high school? the previous question (30) is the field of
If yes, proceed to the next question, if no then study that you wish to pursue as a future
you have completed the questionnaire. career?
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
..................................................................................................................................
No
..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................
99
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Urban Rural
Location (please
√ or fill relevant Name of school: Name of City/town:
information):
Grade:
Algebra Biology
Calculus Chemistry
Class Subject
Geometry Mathematics (general)
(please √):
Teacher Gender
Female Male
(please √):
100
Classroom/Seating arrangement:
ANNEX 2
Draw a classroom map to show the learning environment and seating arrangement. Please note
that in science classrooms, some space may be allocated for science experiments and equipment.
Please label the front and back of the classroom, the board, where the teacher stands, student
desks, as well as any doors, windows, heaters, fans or other relevant points. Please ensure classroom
desks by gender, it may be possible to see if students tend to sit separately by gender or mixed.
Clarify with the teacher if there is a fixed seating arrangement which they have implemented.
Lesson description:
Include a short description of the lesson: this can include researcher’s impressions and reflections
as opposed to general description of facts.
101
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Teacher attitudes/support:
Are the boys and girls receiving equal amount of attention/support from the teacher?
Does the teacher seem fully prepared and confident with the subject content?
When asked to clarify a question or provide more support, does the teacher equally give this attention to female
and male students?
How would you describe the way the teacher calls on students to talk in front of the class?
Can any differences be observed in terms of frequency or attitudes with regard to female and male students?
If applicable, how does the teacher assign groups for exercises/experiments (are they gender mixed or segregated)?
Do you notice any gender stereotyping towards students (particularly with regard to ability of female and male
students in the subject)?
How often do students ask for help from their teacher in the class? Can any differences be observed between female
and male students?
102
Is there a difference between female and male students when they express themselves in class?
ANNEX 2
Do female or male students seem confident when talking in front of their classmates?
How would you describe their behaviour?
Are boys and girls equally participating in classroom activities such as asking questions, answering teachers’
questions, participating in discussions and taking part in project work?
If applicable, how involved are female students in group exercises as opposed to male students?
Do you have any observations in regard to the level of motivation of female and male students?
If they are limited, how does the teacher allocate these to specific groups of students?
Additional Information:
103
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Annex 3. G
uiding Questions for Semi-Structured
Interviews in Indonesia
These guiding questions were developed as part Q8: Did your teacher encourage you to
of the country research conducted in Indonesia, pursue further education in mathematics,
and were based on the initial research science or technology? What kind of
framework for this project. support/encouragement
is given to you?
Q1: Are there any norms or special rules that
Q9: Are there any career counselling
have been implemented for women’s
programmes available in schools?
education based on your experience?
Are they gender-sensitive?
Q2: What are the social perceptions of
Q10: What was your reason of choosing
women working in paid employment
career in science, technology, or
in general?
mathematics?
Q3: What are the social perceptions of
Q11: W
hat factors encouraged you in
women working in paid employment in
choosing career in the field?
science, mathematics and technology
sectors?
Q12: What factors discouraged you from
choosing this field of work?
Q4: Are there any particular social or
cultural factors that may cause women
Q13: What factors might have discouraged
not to work in paid employment jobs?
you to be successful in this field?
Please describe any factors that you think
might exist.
Q14: F rom your perspective, what factors
affect women in choosing career of
Q5: How far did your parents encourage your
science, mathematics, or technology?
education with regard to mathematics,
science and technology career?
Q15: Are there any rules or regulations
specifically for women in your
Q6: A
s far as you know, what government
profession? If so, please describe.
employment schemes for graduates
to enter STEM sectors exist? Are these
Q16: If you did not choose to pursue a career
schemes equal for men and women? If
in science, mathematics or technology
there is any difference, please describe.
what are your reasons?
Q7: As far as you know, are there any
private sector employment schemes
for graduates to enter STEM sectors?
Are these schemes equal for men and
women? If there is any difference,
please describe.
104
Annex 4. S tatistical Tables on Female Participation in
ANNEX 4
STEM-Related International Olympiads by
Country/Jurisdiction in 2014
Total Number 2 12 5 13 3 9 10 34 19 49
F M F M F M F M F M
% 14 86 28 72 25 75 23 77 28 72
Note: Delegations of four students per participating country/jurisdiction.
Source: IBO, 2014
105
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
Total Number 17 1 13 16 1 46 3 81
F M F M F M F M F M
% 0 100 7 93 0 100 2 98 4 96
Note: Delegations of four students per participating country/jurisdiction.
Source: IOI, 2014
106
ANNEX 4
INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIAD IN MATHEMATICS 2014
Total Total
Country/Jurisdiction Gold Silver Bronze
Medallists Delegation
F M F M F M F M F M
Australia 1 3 2 6 6
Bangladesh 1 1 2 6
China 5 1 6 6
DPR Korea 1 4 5 6
Hong Kong- China 1 3 2 1 5 1 5
India 1 3 4 6
Indonesia 2 1 2 1 4 1 5
Iran 4 1 1 1 5 1 5
Japan 4 1 1 6 6
Kazakhstan 1 1 4 6 6
Kyrgyzstan 1 5
Mongolia 5 5 6
New Zealand 1 1 2 6
Pakistan 1 1 6
Philippines 1 3 4 1 5
Republic of Korea 2 4 6 6
Singapore 3 2 1 6 6
Sri Lanka 2 2 6
Tajikistan 2 2 6
Thailand 4 2 6 6
Viet Nam 3 1 1 1 1 5 1 5
107
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
108
Annex 5. Country-specific Policy Suggestions
ANNEX 5
Introductory note:
The following country-specific policy suggestions are drawn from the country case studies
produced by national researchers in the seven countries under review. They provide a more
detailed set of policy suggestions based on the country context.
• C onduct further research to inform policy in • E nsure that higher education enrolment policy
addressing the emerging gender gap which has takes a number of credentials into account in
resulted in alarming trends in male students’ addition to academic achievement such as the
underperformance and lower participation in diverse competencies, abilities and potential of
education, in order to avoid the marginalization of both female and male students.
Malaysia young boys and men.
• D evelop and introduce specific education strategies
targeting performance in mathematics and science
that are gender-sensitive, in order to help bridge
the gender gap in achievement and help support
performance of male students in these subjects.
109
A Complex Formula: Girls and Women in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Asia
• Include the notion of negative stereotype threat • R aise awareness of role models in STEM
with regard to gender in STEM education as part careers for both female and male professionals,
of teacher education curricula to increase teachers’ including through better partnership between
gender sensitivity in the teaching of mathematics, public and private sectors.
science and other STEM-related subjects. • Ensure more effective coordination between
• Consider the need for necessary equipment and education and science and technology policies,
resources in implementing science and mathematics in view of creating schemes that can increase
Mongolia curricula, particularly in rural areas, so that female job opportunities, encourage STEM research in
and male students are able to better learn through universities, strengthen the capacity of national
practical activities that can fuel their interest and institutes such as the Academy of Science –
perspectives in pursuing a career in these fields. all while encouraging equal participation from
• Introduce scholarship programmes for students to both women and men.
pursue study in STEM disciplines in higher education
with gender disparities taken into consideration.
• Introduce career counselling, scholarship and • Increase gender parity in primary education,
loan opportunities in schools as well as in higher to ensure that all female students, particularly
education to encourage female students to pursue those in rural areas, have an equal opportunity
further study and careers in STEM. to progress into secondary education through an
• Address the importance of parental education and overall higher investment in girls’ education.
engagement through education policy, in order to • Address gender disparities in the labour
Nepal address the heavy workload and burden of domestic market through interventions that provide
duties that are often borne by girls and which have a equal opportunities for women and men to
great impact on their opportunities to learn at home. pursue careers in STEM.
• Ensure more equal representation of female and
male teachers at all levels of education through
teacher recruitment policies, in order to improve
the increment and retention of female students.
• D evelop appropriate learning and support • P rovide training and guidance to teachers and
strategies for the minority of female students in career counsellors, so that they may promote
the highest levels of achievement, as well as those the benefits of entering a career in STEM for
concentrated in intermediate and basic levels of young women.
achievement in mathematics and science, in order • Extend technical and professional development
to enable them to thrive in STEM-related subjects. for female STEM professionals who have
Republic • Place a stronger emphasis at policy implementation taken career breaks, in particular due to family
of Korea level, as well as review of policy effectiveness for responsibilities, to enable them to catch up
initiatives that seek to promote women and girls’ with fast-paced development and innovation in
participation in STEM in order to ensure their impact. STEM fields and equip them with the updated
• Consider the decline in proportion of female knowledge, skills and techniques that are required
teachers as the level of education increases in future in order to eventually return to their profession.
research, particularly in terms of teacher-student
relationships and learning outcomes.
• E nsure concerted efforts to support and implement • P rovide increased training and incentives for
the Gender Equality Law (2006), as well as policy women to enter a broader range of occupations
efforts to take into account women from ethnic in the labour market, for instance to enter newly
minorities and rural areas, and to increase women’s created jobs in high-tech industries.
participation in decision-making through specific
projects and activities.
Viet Nam
• Revise education curricula as well as teaching
and learning materials to better promote gender
equality; through addressing gender stereotyping
and taking into account cultural and linguistic
differences in preparation for the new curriculum
to be completed by 2015.
110
UNESCO Bangkok Office Korean Women’s Development Institute (KWDI)
Mom Luang Pin Malakul Centenary Building 225 Junheung-ro, Eunpyeong-gu (1-363, Bulgwang-dong),
920 Sukhumvit Road, Prakanong, Klongtoey Seoul, 122-707
Bangkok 10110, Thailand Republic of Korea
Email: epr.bgk@unesco.org Website: http://www.kwdi.re.kr
Website: www.unesco.org/bangkok Tel: +82 2 3156 7000 Fax: +82 2 3156 7007
Tel: +66-2-3910577 Fax: +66-2-3910866