Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RISMET 1 - LIterature Critical Appraisal Journal PDF
RISMET 1 - LIterature Critical Appraisal Journal PDF
Kes
nurul.muslihah@gmail.com / nurul_muslihah.fk@ub.ac.Is
Mata Kuliah
Research Methodology 1
(Carroll, 2006)
Conclusion
From each of the section summaries,
highlight the most relevant points
relate these back to the need for research
reiterate what these mean for the research
design
• Disadvantages
– time consuming
– not always any easy answers or what you hoped to find
– dispiriting if ‘good’ evidence is lacking i.e. little / poor
research done
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical Appraisal/NM 270217
Observational study design measures of disease, measures of risk, and temporality
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical
Appraisal/NM 270217
What is a systematic review?
A review that has been prepared using some kind of
systematic approach to minimising biases and random
errors, and that the components of the approach
will be documented in a materials and methods section
www.cebma.org/ebp-tools
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical
Standard appraisal questions
Postgraduate Course
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical
Appraisal of a case-control study
Postgraduate Course
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical
• Critical appraisal is an essential step in the
process of putting research into practice.
• Asking questions about an article’s research
methodology
• Scrutinizing its data collection and analysis
methods
• And evaluating how its findings are presented
will help you to determine whether that
article’s conclusions should influence practical
decision-making.
RISMET 2/Literatur_critical Appraisal/NM
270217
Different research questions require different
study designs.
For example the best design for studies
evaluating the effectiveness of an intervention or
treatment is a Randomized controlled trial.