Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Busin Modified PK
Busin Modified PK
A
modified penetrating keratoplasty procedure with a new lamellar configuration of the
surgical wound was performed on 8 eyes with endothelial decompensation. This tech-
nique allows complete suture removal by 3 months postoperatively, substantially short-
ening the time necessary for visual rehabilitation. Refractive astigmatism before and
after suture removal was minimized to 4 diopters or less in all of the eyes in our preliminary series.
Because the anterior surface of the donor button is smaller than the posterior one (diameter, 7.0
mm and 9.0 mm, respectively), more endothelial cells can be transplanted while maintaining
the anterior graft surface at a safe distance from the corneoscleral limbus. Finally, no expensive
instrumentation is required for this procedure except for an artificial anterior chamber if whole
globes are not available. The surgical technique and clinical results are presented in this article.
Arch Ophthalmol. 2003;121:260-265
During the past decades, penetrating kera- bly resulting in anisometropia and/or high-
toplasty (PK) surgery has undergone con- degree astigmatism.10-14 Finally, wound de-
tinuous refinement. Various instruments hiscence occurs after suture removal in up
have been developed to improve the qual- to 4% of cases, even if this is done more
ity of trephination in both donor and re- than 1 year after surgery.15-18
cipient corneas, and countless suturing In recent years, different types of lamel-
techniques have been used to reduce tis- larkeratoplasty(LK)procedureshavegained
sue distortion and minimize postopera- popularity among corneal surgeons in an at-
tive refractive errors.1-9 Nevertheless, to tempt to transplant selected layers of the cor-
date, the basic concept of cutting a donor nea, speeding wound healing while optimiz-
disc with a “perfect” margin to fit into a ing postoperative refraction.19,20 With these
“perfect” hole has remained the same. This methodsahorizontal,surface-to-surfacesur-
method produces a vertical, edge-to- gicalwoundresults,andtheintraocularpres-
edge PK wound. Regardless of how per- sure tends to make the layers adhere to each
fectly the donor and recipient cornea fit, other rather than gape. Tight suturing is not
this type of wound requires relatively tight necessary, and removal can safely be per-
sutures to hold the edges together until the formed much earlier than after conventional
healing is sufficient to withstand the effect PK surgery. However, the presence of a la-
of the intraocular pressure; this usually mellar tissue interface may reduce the qual-
takes at least 1 year. ity of vision after LK compared with that ob-
Because of this approach, refraction tained following PK surgery.
is not stable, and astigmatism (often of the To combine the optical superiority of
irregular type) cannot be adequately cor- PK with the wound-healing advantages of
rected in many patients as long as the su- LK, the standard PK technique was modi-
tures are present.1-9 In addition, when the fied by using a full-thickness donor graft in
sutures are removed, substantial changes conjunction with a peripheral lamellar
in refraction are frequently seen, possi- wound configuration (Figure 1). The sur-
gical technique and the results obtained in
From the Departments of Ophthalmology, Casa di Cura Villa Serena Hospital, Forli, 8 eyes of 8 patients with endothelial de-
Italy, and Ospedale S Carlo di Nancy, Rome, Italy. compensation are presented in this article.
Full-Thickness Graft
Recipient Cornea
Figure 1. Schematic representation of the cornea after a nut-and-bolt keratoplasty procedure. Both in the cross section (A) and the frontal view (B), the annular
area of lamellar healing is outlined between the recipient corneal bed (outside) and the full-thickness part of the graft (inside).
Table 1. Preoperative Data Collected From Patients Undergoing Modified Penetrating Keratoplasty Surgery
Patient No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Age, y 68 81 94 63 77 78 72 84
Sex M M F F M F F F
Preoperative diagnosis PBK PBK PBK Fuchs dystrophy PBK PBK PBK ABK
Preoperative visual acuity* HM HM CF HM HM CF CF HM
Abbreviations: ABK, aphakic bullous keratopathy; CF, counting fingers; HM, hand motions; PBK, pseudophakic bullous keratopathy.
*Not improvable because of corneal edema.
METHODS
Surgical Technique (Figure 2E). A McNeill-Goldman ring21
was used to fixate the globe. The recipi-
The use of a modified PK procedure in A detailed consent form was signed by ent bed was prepared to closely conform
8 consecutive patients with endothelial all 8 patients undergoing surgery. All pa- to the shape of the donor button. A 7.0-
decompensation (aphakic bullous kera- tients were sedated with 3 mL of intra- mm Barron suction trephine was used to
topathy, n = 1; pseudophakic bullous venous droperidol immediately prior to cut a circular incision 0.3 mm in depth
keratopathy, n=6; and Fuchs endothe- anesthetic injection. Local anesthesia was (Figure 3A). A lamellar stromal dissec-
lial corneal dystrophy, n = 1) is re- administered with a peribulbar injec- tion was carried out with a bevel-up knife
ported. All procedures were performed tion of a mixture of 2% lidocaine and from the base of the incision about 1 mm
by the same surgeon (M.B.) between Sep- 0.5% bupivacaine hydrochloride. peripherally (Figure 3B). The anterior
tember and November 2001, and the re- The donor button was mounted on chamber was then entered, and corneal
sults were evaluated in a prospective anartificialanteriorchamber(Moria,Paris, scissors were used to complete the exci-
study, described as follows. France) after a viscoelastic substance was sion of the corneal button at the periph-
Preoperatively, the medical history placed on the endothelium. The geomet- eral end of the posterior lamellar stromal
of each patient was recorded, and a com- ric center of the cornea was marked, and dissection (Figure 3C). The donor button
plete eye examination was performed in- a7.0-mmBarronsuctiontrephinewasused was positioned by sliding the peripheral
cluding visual acuity testing, slitlamp ex- to make a circular, 0.3-mm-deep incision wing under the 1.0-mm-wide superficial
amination, retinoscopy, and B-scan (Figure 2A). A lamellar stromal dissec- stromal lip of the recipient bed. Four 10-0
ultrasonography when necessary (n=2). tion was carried out with a bevel-up knife nylon cardinal sutures were put in place.
Details regarding preoperative data are from the base of the incision all the way Each suture exited the donor button at the
given in Table 1. Postoperatively, pa- to the limbus (Figure 2B). Then the cor- base of the wing and was then passed
tients were seen twice a week until reepi- nea was removed from the artificial ante- through the superficial recipient lamellae
thelialization was completed, which oc- rior chamber and placed on the plate of a at the end of the dissection. This way, the
curred within 2 weeks of surgery in all Barron suction punch with the endothe- wing was left free to adhere to the poste-
cases. Uncorrected visual acuity was mea- lial side up, taking care to align the mark rior surface of the dissected recipient cor-
sured every week postoperatively. One of the geometric center with the central nea, an effect of the intraocular pressure.
month after surgery, patients underwent hole of the punch. A 9.0-mm donor but- Contrarytowhatistypicallyobservedwith
refraction, and uncorrected and best spec- tonwaspunchedout(Figure2C).Thepre- conventional PK surgery, the injection of
tacle-corrected visual acuity were deter- vious lamellar dissection allowed a super- balanced salt solution into the anterior
mined. In addition, keratometry and ficial annular stromal lamella, 0.3 mm in chamber showed that the surgical wound
corneal topography analysis were ob- thickness, to be removed in the area be- was already completely watertight (Fig-
tained. Monthly examinations were per- tween 7.0 and 9.0 mm in diameter (Fig- ure 3D). The procedure was completed
formed thereafter. Sutures were re- ure 2D). The donor button obtained this with a single 10-0 nylon running suture,
moved 3 months after surgery in all cases. way consisted of a central, full-thickness each bite of which was passed in a fash-
Each patient underwent a repeated com- part, 7.0 mm in diameter, surrounded by ion similar to that previously described for
plete eye examination 1 month after su- a peripheral lamellar wing of deep stroma the cardinal sutures. Finally, the cardinal
ture removal. andendotheliumthatwas1.0mminwidth sutures were removed (Figure 3E). Addi-
C D E
Figure 2. Preparation of the donor button. A, Partial trephination of the donor cornea mounted on the artificial chamber. B, Lamellar dissection from the base of
the incision all the way to the limbus. C, Donor button, 9.0 mm in diameter, with the endothelial side up. D, Superficial annular stromal lamella, 0.3 mm in
thickness, removed from the donor button in the area between 7.0 and 9.0 mm of diameter. E, Donor button consisting of a central, full-thickness part, 7.0 mm in
diameter, surrounded by a peripheral lamellar wing of deep stroma and endothelium, 1.0 mm in width.
tional procedures performed in combina- with time, and reepithelialization was spectacle best-corrected visual acu-
tionwithPKsurgeryinthisseriesincluded completed within 2 weeks of sur- ity further improved, and 6 of 8 pa-
anterior vitrectomy (n=4), anterior vitrec- gery. Data recorded preoperatively, tients could see 20/60 or better with
tomy combined with the exchange of the 1 month after surgery, and 1 month spectacle correction. Reasons for best-
intraocular lens implant (n=1), anterior
after suture removal are summa- corrected vision worse than 20/60
vitrectomycombinedwithintraocularlens
implantation (n=1), and pupilloplasty rized in Tables 1 to 3. The 10-0 ny- were macular myopic degeneration
(n=1). After surgery the patients under- lon running suture was removed 3 (patient 4) and cystoid macular
went pressure patching overnight. Begin- months after surgery in all patients edema (patient 8). One month after
ning the next morning, 0.1% dexameth- (Figure 4). As early as 1 month af- surgery (Table 2), the refractive
asone sodium phosphate and gentamicin ter surgery (Table 2), an uncor- spherical equivalent ranged from
sulfate antibiotic eyedrops were adminis- rected visual acuity of at least 20/ +0.75 diopters (D) to −8.5 D. Mean
tered every 2 hours and tapered for 10 200 in the affected eye was recorded keratometric readings ranged from
weeks. in all but 1 patient (patient 4 in the 40.5 D to 44.5 D. The refractive astig-
tables), who had high-degree myo- matic error was 4 D or less in all
RESULTS pia. Best spectacle-corrected visual cases. Computerized analysis of cor-
acuity ranged between 20/100 and 20/ neal topography showed regular
Surgery was uneventful in all pa- 40. One month after suture removal morphologic characteristics of the
tients. All corneas gradually cleared (Table 3), both uncorrected and astigmatism in all patients at all
C D E
Figure 3. Main surgical steps of the nut-and-bolt keratoplasty procedure. A, Partial trephination of the recipient bed, 7.0 mm in diameter (same as for the donor
cornea) and 0.3 mm in depth. B, Lamellar stromal dissection carried out from the base of the incision about 1 mm peripherally. C, Excision of the corneal
button using corneal scissors at the peripheral end of the posterior lamellar stromal dissection. D, Injection of balanced salt solution into the anterior chamber
shows that the surgical wound is perfectly watertight with just 4 cardinal sutures in place. E, A single running 10-0 nylon suture is used to complete
the procedure.
examination times (Figure 5). Sur- curvature. In addition, even if all other PK, LK offers the substantial advan-
prisingly, suture removal did not sub- variables could theoretically be opti- tage of creating a horizontal, surface-
stantially affect refraction in any pa- mized, recovery of vision can be de- to-surface type of surgical wound. In-
tient (Table 3). Again, refractive layed by corneal distortion second- traocular pressure helps the surfaces
astigmatism was 4 D or less in all ary to the presence of sutures; some adhere to one another, so the sutures
cases. Notably, the preoperative spec- degree of tension-induced tissue roll- require minimal tension and may be
tacle cylinder in patient 4 was 4 D. ing is necessary to obtain a water- removed 2 to 4 months after surgery.
tight wound. Healing of these verti- To date, however, most of these meth-
COMMENT cal, edge-to-edge corneal wounds odshavenotgainedpopularity,mainly
requires a minimum of 6 months and because of the lower postoperative op-
Despite the excellent prognosis of typically 1 year in adults. In a rela- tical quality of the cornea. The use of
PK, visual rehabilitation of patients tively high number of patients, stable the microkeratome to perform lamel-
undergoing this procedure is slow vision is not achieved until many lar dissections in laser-assisted in situ
and frequently hampered by high- months after PK surgery, often fol- keratomileusis has shown that LK can
degree astigmatism, often of the lowing suture removal.1-14 result in postoperative visual acuity
irregular type.1-9 Factors including Lamellar keratoplasty has been of 20/20. We recently published the
host-graft disparity, trephination tech- proposed in different forms as an al- initial results of endokeratoplasty, a
nique, and suturing technique are be- ternative surgical treatment for vari- posteriorLKprocedureaimedattrans-
lieved to affect the regularity of graft ous corneal diseases. Compared with planting the posterior stroma and en-
Table 2. Data Collected 1 Month Postoperatively From Patients Undergoing Modified Penetrating Keratoplasty Surgery
Patient No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
UCVA 20/200 20/100 20/60 HM 20/100 20/60 20/50 20/200
BCVA 20/60 20/60 20/40 20/200 20/60 20/50 20/40 20/100
Spherical equivalent, D −1.75 −1.25 −0.5 −8.5 −1.5 +0.75 −0.5 −1.0
Refractive astigmatism, D 2.25 1.5 1.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 2.75
Mean keratometry reading, D 44.5 43.0 42.5 40.5 41.25 41.0 42.75 42.5
Abbreviations: BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; D, diopters; HM, hand motions; UCVA, uncorrected visual acuity.
Table 3. Data Collected 1 Month After Suture Removal From Patients Undergoing Modified Penetrating Keratoplasty Surgery
Patient No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
UCVA 20/100 20/200 20/50 HM 20/100 20/60 20/50 20/100
BCVA 20/60 20/60 20/40 20/200 20/40 20/30 20/25 20/100
Spherical equivalent, D −2.25 −1.5 −0.5 −7.5 −1.75 +1.0 −1.0 −1.0
Refractive astigmatism, D 2.5 1.75 0.75 4.0 3.0 1.5 1.0 2.25
Mean keratometry reading, D 44.75 43.0 43.0 40.5 42.0 41.0 43.0 42.5
Abbreviations: BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; D, diopters; HM, hand motions; UCVA, uncorrected visual acuity.