Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Change Management Arabic
Change Management Arabic
! "
"
'
() *
+ $%
,-
*
4
0 $
"
1 &+# (,'
-
./ &0
+
'
(&/
- $ .
(
3./
4
" '5
$2
./
0 (
( 67 $
9"
7-
:'# ';
.;
0 &+# $#
; <&
"
:'# &
.;
0 1
"
($
$
3./ " :
+ &-'5
( &/
+
-
.%+
&-<2 :
0
"
? &- (
3./ =
>; 12
!
@# $# 0 2 (/+ $
1 2- $ $ 3# (+
.
11
* &- 9
1
5+
:
6
+ ;
+A
- $
0
7 89:
7 ;9:
4
4 <4
:;
;
,
0
3./ 1 0
$
& $
0
و
=8
:! >)
#
$
C
=5
D "
+
"
3 :
/
E-
B
7
";
7
)
F G*
H 1
F G*
18 F
C# 4J2
21 F
C # 5J2
22 F
R
# 6J2
23 <
F
# 7J2
28 F
S
B
8J2
30 <
9J2
32 5
E *
10J2
42 4? : @?
43
F
:#
50 1
F
: A
56 +
$
1 :A A
#8 :@ ,!:
58
S- 1J3
58
, 2J3
59
3J3
60
F
E
# 4J3
61
F 5J3
62 7
C # 6J3
63
, C # 7J3
B< :A? ,!:
65
G7* 1J4
67
F 5
:
S7 2J4
' *
S7 3J4
75
! B< :=C ,!:
84 S7
1J5
88
2J5
ح
/( A#
90
F ,
96 1
F ,
99
/
"
:# (1) & 9
105
(2) & 9
111
.
:
(3) & 9
,# <%
:! ,# ' ,#
56 +
+
1 (1J2)
59 '*
1
R (1J3)
60
F A
2 (2J3)
65
"
$
$
,1 (1 J4)
F
F
68 ( 2 J4)
+A
-
F
69 ( 3 J4)
<
F
70 (4 J4)
71 &-
F
( 5 J4)
72 ( 6 J4)
4
/
"Y
73 ( 7 J4)
'
"Y
74 ( 8 J4)
5<
ط
, 4
"Y
75 (9 J4)
7
(One Sample KolmogorovJSmirnov test) *
76 (10 –4)
( 5
) ,
F
(F
) +
F
F
0
F A@
*
S7
76 F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) (11 J4)
5
11 (&-
F
(
F
) F
0
F A@
*
S7
77 (
F
(<
-
F
(+A
(12 J4)
5
11 (&-
F
5
F
5
;
A# *
0 5 (One Way Anova) $
S7
81 (14 –4)
$
G7* n1
,- <%
:! , ' ,
7
D. (1J1) "
ي
DC*
(+A
F
) 3@ F
0 A@
4
3./ /
/
"
, $
, $ (
/
"
# $
? (280) $
# (" (180) / o
.(
p
("
0 (&
70 . A@ :/1# S7
$
0
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F
.
/
"
11 ( &-
(
( +
:-/#
$
?
' .F
- G $ -+ "
n 4'
+
+
F
:' (/
"
.*
*
ك
Abstract
The Impact of Change Management in Enhancement of
Shareholding Companies Effectiveness at the State of Kuwait
- 1J1
-7#
" 2J1
4
/# 3J1
/# 4J1
' 5J1
D. 6J1
4
7J1
8J1
2
,- ,!:
8 1E1
qF
@q (q- AYq
n+
-
-# # # <
p
0
."
r
0 5
q+
.q*
&<
$
0 4- < - A F
$0
C <
-
&+
/
7+
F 4-
0
q7
7-
F
-'5
, 4
,
,
q2
$q *
/ $ $ ?5 ?
?< Y
&<
$rq
.q (n*# - $
7
$ (- $ 7'# $
q n*;
5
<
?F p 5
< ;
# F )# p
(2002 ($
"q )
q;
q<
++
1
25
&<
.(46G
*
F A
R :/ $# $ <
F
1
q 0 )Yq ).
A
<
,
9+ # *
7
, 5
4
/#
0 A ( +
#
# 4
/;
n
.
F p
0
# .<
s H .
$
' & (
1 F
(
(q*
7
$ :1 - ; <
*
0 + &A 7 #
n $ #
q<
(qY
q $ +
*
$ 5
- (*
AY
42q*
(q+A
F (
AY
("
$
+
(
)
# +
F (
F (
4<
/
/:+ 0 C
'
+
? ? "
+ E
"
- S &/# (
1 7
F
"
&# 6# F
p
0 H . t
n
n
/
"
n 4" $
" $# .0 ./:+ $'
F
A
F
- 2* $ H . ("
3./
AY
+
.* "
0 )+
)
u F
.
F
p
12
"q
q 11 F
0 A# /
3./ $ =F
$0
$
2* $
3./ $ =F
9+ $ .
/
:v
Y
q qF
(+A
F
) 3@ F
A@ / :,- =
< ,F
/
"
11 (&-
F
(
F
(<
-
:/ 5
7;
$ Y
./ $ 9A w
/
"
11 +A
F A@ / :,. : ,F
w
w
/
"
"
11
F A@ / :@ : ,F
w
/
"
11 &-
F A@ / :A? : ,F
w
/
q q
0 70
. 9 / : =
< ,F
q
n1
/
"
11 F
0 A@
w(*
(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
:
0
3./ 4-
.
/
"
11 +A
F
A# J1
/
"
11 <
-
F
A# J2
.
/
"
11
F
A# J3
.
/
"
$
:
u J4
C
H . ("
11 F
0 A#
.
./ "
$
4
H . ( 5
3./ $
4E1
F
0 / ;
0 &- R' - $
/# @
+
).* $ .
-
& - -<
3./ /# $0
?
7
# ;
3./ )A 4 n*#
9
"
, $
-+ -7 ?*
.-7 $ 5
9
x
) 5E1
'5
> $ r -
7;
"
3./ y
:
(0.05≥α) n 70 . A@ :6-
<
):
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F
.
/
"
11 +A
F (0.05≥α)
/
"
11 <
-
F (0.05≥α)
.
/
"
11
F (0.05≥α)
.
"
11 &-
F A@ : ?
:
):
.
/
q q
0 70
. 9 :
<
):
q
n1
/
"
11 F
0 A@
.(*
(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
F
A
-
/#
0
3./ $ =F
9+
?
3.- G* D. & p
& + (,
F
+
.
F
3.- D.
" 6' (1-1) &
"
.+
;
A?
*4
4
:
9 ,
8?
". /
4 E
# # E
:
9 ) E
, <
? A "
E
#
$8
GH
((2005) (
+
((Cooper, 2004)
((2002)
(2002)
.(2012) (
((2011) (
(Beer & Eisnstat, 2009)
8
*!? "
7E1
q
+q
qF
, 5
& +
3./ =
>;
: (
q
q+5
$ - & .(Cisco, 2004: 7) A
0
F
11
:v
F
2* $ H .
q+A :q /
+
&+ F
- + : 4
p
q;
q
1
$ $
+
&+
3./ Y
# q
+
F
" $# - + :
9 ,
8
q
F
" $# + :
#
C q# q<
"q ;
$' /
F p
0
q
# ($
- $# C
-
/1
q 5<
& 9 F
" $# + :$K8
Yq
&q qF H .q (&q-
"q ;
R (
:
# +
9
q
2
(:
;
*
$ 5
;
(2
-
*q
2q* $ n
4
/;
9+
<
/ :
:
-
6 A@
. (- n+
$1
E
-
:v
"Y
2* $
+5
$
$ -
/# " )# 9+ # H
A / :"- /
4 E
.(10 :2011 (
) F
&+
2*
q
$ n * &+ # <
D 0 / :# # E
).
" -72 > :
- 2* $ $ (1
B 3" A 5 *
E0 / ::
9 ) E
Rq S ).
(-
-
1 2* $ > R"
.(10 :2011 (
) &-
$ 5< + 5
' $
.
q
p
q;
, ,
4
"
/ :, <
? A "
E
4q
9q
F
0 $ $0
7
9q
/
"
, / :
q q
q "
, &1 ).
9
;
$ C
q- 9q .0 (
9
-
# B - &
$q
"
) " (180) / o
:
"
, --#
.(2012 (
9
x
9
:
A
.
/
"
:
E1
"
3./
$
$
$ *
& :
? E2
pq
q ("
0 (& C7 (& ) C $F" $.
.(
;
5
/ $
$
3./
0 9F
:
E3
.2013J2012 A
F
) q A
F
0
" :(
)
* E4
5
(&-
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
, 4
(5<
'
(
(4
/;
9+ ) :/
"Y - &
.(7
11
,!:
-
F
0 F
&-5 1J2
F
4
/# 2J2
F
0 /# 3J2
F
C# 4J2
F
C # 5J2
F
R
# 6J2
<
F
# 7J2
F
S
B
8J2
<
9J2
5
E *
10J2
,!:
(q/# (q
/# (q-5 (F +
&/5 ?' 5
./ $'
+ (F
- B 5 $ (
F
C# '# (
( #
.
F
3# *
(<
.F
.F
r
. 1
+
8
/<
(+
$ 5
< (
<
-" +* 3./ (-
0 <
" A#
H . (
3./ - 9
9+ <
-
v
<
F
9+ R <
$ 3
F (;
& ?
? -5
$# $ ?2
(;
&
B
$ 2
? ' (
./
9
.
R
p
7
/ <
F
4<
/# H
< .
" R
F
&# A
13
(&) $/
-'
< $# # 4
,
" -
.(281 :2003
/:+ $'
F
*0 ( 3 0 /
' F
$r H . .(83 :2006 (
)
4
.
/
<
:+
F
* n
" #
<
F
4
#
4
/# 2 p
0 @ H . <
F
4%
&# &<
R'# :2 0 :/ $# # - <
$ )#
<
$ n
- " @ <
F
4
7
s
" p
0 2* $ H . & $#
- (2"
0
R
{
4/ + F " @ <
F
4
0 "
$ (';
/F #
4- F
&-5 $0
;
/ (F
,
R
(F
/#
5
-
2* $ 9
- @ 4 F
0 #
:2006 (
) 5 - # @ Y
;
.(95
.$
/ - * < +
0 / F
$# p
n
4<
, 5 < / F /< -"
<
$#
-
(D
C # $ - F
A# $@ (-
C #
9 &/5
&+
$ ($
2 $ (
n
./>
5
-
2* $ 9
/ F
0 $# p
n
| @ % 2* "
% +
,
0
,
$ % :5
,q 4q
q# $ &+ )
'
F 0 (<
0 - 4-
$
Cq
A2A H / $r E;
./
($
+
# 9
R'@ -
4<
:/ (F
$ 4- 7
.<
<
p
0 # $ J2
.? $ A
# J3
$q $q- $/ 0 (Pattanayak & Mishra, 2009: 57) " H .
:/ (F
4
/#
.
D
-
# -<0 <
$
6 J1
."
4
/;
9+ - (<
,
J2
&# ).q
F
$0 .- $
-7 <
$ $1
9+
9+ (:
;
n :+
A (<
5
# 9+
q
q (q
$
(5<
$
+ ($
$
16
q
C;
&
*
(+5
" (
7
, $1
0 (
"
nq
4
/;
$ /> <
H
# ) (2"
(q<
F
4
/# $ (46 J45 :2002 (
) #
:/ (<
$
0 4-
)Y F
$# $ ?2
(
7
<
$ $1
$ 9+ .1
.:+
4/ 9+
0 )5
$ + t
F
" $
H F .2
.(
9)
+
F
B 12
2
:
0 <
0 A
*0 .3
.<
.<
$
$ $
2
+ .4
.R
$
+ 1 .6
(q
:
0 $ :
;
$ / ++ &- F
$# p
n
.$
n
+
-
$ 2' (<
17
3E2
qF
C q# R (A &
;
= F
/#
-
F
p
0 $
$
C .0 (
5*
9q
0 F *
$
H
"0 (
G5
2F (
&+
C ).
;
(9
<
A F
/#
Cq q q
1
$-
C C
<
,
&
n
(Hill <
-/ <
0
F '
).q
q
:"
$@ n - (<
*
C@ F
/# $
q $q
$
7- $
. ("F
" / $1
n
? ?A
+
q qA
(
4<
< F
+
<
q
q2*# Yq $ - 9
$ R "
0
F
p
0 *
$ - $ F
/# 1
.9
E
, 2
($
* ;
:
q0 Cq q
(- +
*
:
0
0 A
+
*0 .2
.-
*
$+0
$
/@ C -/# (
F
18
F
/# 1 (*
-7 + -
<
F
.3
q*
qF
,q ,q 4
+
@
./
.<
'5
($q
;
H A@
F
/# - 1
.4
.?'# F :
*v
n
A0
F
p
r :
q
q<
(:+
2 <
/ F
/# $# p
n
Cq
$ H / (? "5
/ 6 " F
p
0 "5
.0 .<
*
H
+
& $ $
($
$
5
9+ (
$1
<
&/# $ F
$#
.<
$' 12
'
&/# $ $1
A
$
q*
Cq# n+ /
$ p <
F
$0
qF
q q *
n+
$ #
? *
n+
C (*
/
"Y
$ A F
H / ."
4q<
q-
0 (<
-
$' *
C; 0 $
(F
:
./ (+
4
/;
:F 0 # 4
/# '0 0 &'
: 9 "
.1
.<
)
F
*0 C
19
q /q (q
$
+
"
F / :'
4
.2
q q
"
$
+
,
" 4 -
0 %F $# <
.
# : -5 =
,q <
D
:- C# $ F
./ S : 9* $ ,
.3
.
F'
* # S )# B
? -
# <
E $# $ :/H- N
.4
$
.0 ( > ," (H-
9. - $# $'
*q $# q<
q $r E;
./
(9
> *
# S
.9
/ $' 12
F
nq
F
*0
$0 :# .5
.*
D
$ ;
.5 - # $ <
)"
)
Rq5 $
n
B
=5*
"Y A :
O P:C .6
=5*
CF C
F
p
0 C (
#
5
.-
$
B
*
,
3./ F
& :4 HC
* QC # .7
q Cq
+
.*
$
+ & # -7
+
.*
q12
'
0 * &- & # C
.
+
.*
20
4
0 ' )Y
4 $0 :?.
# D4 .8
.F
,
+
/
Y
$r (<
(q
5<
n0 "
4' C :.!. ") .9
.?+ .
& 7
5<
$ )# " $0 :
:
9 .# ,: .10
q (-
$'
3:
C;
F
&+ $# <
.-72 -
# *
:/ (F
C# $#
0 (100J98 :2006 (
) "
q
q
'
R2
$0 :
#. ?- .1
5
*
(7
*
r $
& :
!%. ?- .2
("q
-7 #
- ? > &
(
F
C
'
q
&# B5
, $#
$0 :
4
# ?- .3
q 5 q
&-
1 0 $ :1 6#
+ &
* (A
+
.#
q :
q0
0 )Y
C;
$# (283 J282 :2003 (&) n $
21
q
"
$
+
0 (7
F
(
R';
(
q q
-q
F'
1
(<
$
E
(
q q (5<q
$
q
R5
(n*# < , S
(
.B;
(7 *
1# p ($
5E2
q-
q;
$q F
<
3 ).
C;
=q5* # q
$ 4- F
C;
./ & :#
.1
.
;
$ # H" (7 +
.2
.
9
;
0 *
* <
0 2
? " ?2+
22
,
$ $ $;
$ D1 $
@ :'
?*- '
? G
.3
S
q
q :
& (<
, ). F p
0 3
. ;
C
4<
F
$
:2002 (q
) : F
&*
F
R
# 4
(45 J44G
q qF
qA# #
1
./ :<
#
,
.1
# vq q<
$
C # :1
F
$
.r (<
q q r (<
C
"
.0 # 71 F r (1-;
Rq )# p
0 & / 71
, + "
F
0 $ (" F
.71
E A
0 <
$1
& # *
$
q pq ).
F
H . )
F
" :
.2
)q
# ($
$
? <
:
0
;
v
n
.315 #
H F "
A
.3
.F
C>; 4<
& $ 5
,
$ ?*
.1
( R"
)
/ $ n*#
0 /
- $ <
q
q
q- 'q *
F
C .(370G (2007
(q<
q qF p
q0
(7
F
+ < /
7+ " ).
F
/ :(P) C
V
.2
.(370G
9
? 7E2
# #
(+ ' 7
:+
- $'
: 4
:.
(q-+ :
;
&< (&<
/ (
;
H " / F
q<
+ (
7
F , 4
5
=F H . (
24
# F
./ 4+0 $ 31 + ?7+ F /
<
= $# +*
: . $
$q
q q q-
A
&/5
$ F
+A &-5
'# +
2
*
E
*
= p + (&-5
./ A
(
&q-5 ($q-5
$ ?/ ? H / $# <2 $# F H . (+A
F
&-5
"+A
F" &-5 (';
0 ,
F &/ +A $# "F
+A"
# q5 :
q (q/;
qF F
+A $# (12 :2004 ($
) n
:- ,
5
- - (,
n1F +A F
$' 5
.1
.F
$'
, *" , 9
7
,
5 5
C .3
.$*v
'
25
qF
q "q
< 2* $ 35 =-
5
.4
.+A
q ,
'
F
-
Y ,
<
Y .5
+A
Y -
&+
, 5
.,
:
9 ,
8
:
$q
H . AY (n*#
0 S #
0 p
0 )# t
/ #
* F # /YF 0 # <
:" 0 $
# 5<
# <
*
F # Y
-
<
#
<
, $# (460 :2000 (
) n
9q
&) 9
H -" " <
-2" = F (
(&;
= Y , $ $# 0 -
F
$0 )# ((
#
.
+
.*
, 1
q
-
'+
$ < )
&<
$# (299 :2004 (F
) n
(q<
H B AY
$
) &<
$0 .0 ($-
F"
26
q :
;
$ 5*
2
(
) -
&<
) ($ # " # & &# +# &# # 2
3./
./
=5
0 7
9
&-
H . 5<
0
;
,
1
-
F
q- 2* $q
/ &<
5< .<
5< '
#
:q5 &q- :
# $ &-
&/1 $/Y
; F"
.5
7
4
/;
.1
.4
/;
9+ '
"
# .2
q
$q
qA
5
< / -' "
, .3
.)"
&< E@
4* $ 2
$ "
$
9+ .5
. 5
:
#
:
<q
# $ t + &
*
/ $
(4-
27
(
, Rr
&+ .0 (
:+
#
2* A
F
$r H . ( :5 4-
0
# $ H .
0 < #
$ &
<
C># '
+
$# - " $
F
3./ $# <
F +
/1# < F
1
A# $
$ C
./ .? +
p
7 $
&
*
2* $
2* $
*
- 0 <
1q
. q q- *
9
;
6 $ n+
5
.1
.
.C
9
C # +
5
0 .2
.
@
15
&< 2* $ 0 5
+
5
2* $
.
E
28
:$8
:?
q
9
F #
:
0
+
+
:
0 9 F
q71
-
q/# 1 0 $ <
$
<
F
" H .
Rq (q
:
# q+ q 5<
& 9 '# " (
*
$ 5
;
(2
Y
& F H . (&-
" ;
q 0 q'0 (q
4< " (5<
2
(:
;
F
9+ F
0 )Y
C #
:
0 F
p
0
S7 7
5 <
R
n 9A # " F
B
S
+
+ Y5
B p $ $ $
(F
S
q Bq
"Y 4* .
3.- $7 &/ $ $ 7 &/" $
Bq nq AY
7
$ Hailey, 2009, p: 165J 166)
:/ (F
29
q .5
0 Y &-+
,+ $.
(:
* # :
$ :
5( .1
.F
q
1 q (B
, ? ? F
C :
# .2
/q # q 1
5
$ " 2 H / :
@+
: .3
. F
$ $# (F
B $
%( .4
.F $
+
1 # ;
3./
F
q F
A# 12
E+
#
3
:
$
4 .5
.<
&q+ $# $
$
0 (58 :2002 (
) "
:/ (F
B / <
.F
$' $
$ @
&
.1
.' F
+ ).
&
s
.2
<
=F F
5
5
-
F
:
* :2 H $# .3
.-* $ # <
*
$
.0
. )F
S
B *
$
H
"0 .4
.F
:
C;
,
6' .5
.F
C
7
5
6' .6
.<
"
G*" F
R2
.7
30
. 31
F
+
.8
. 5
"
.9
C
$ H / $@ (234 J238G (2005) $' n
:/ (F
B 0 /
$ /.*#
.<
$ $# '
F
Y H / $ $# C :
F .2
.<
&-
E# # ).5
0 $ ).
:
&q
q
?q ? ?'
;
$
$ $# $ :,!. .5
.F
+
&- $
$
C :
.6
.
4<
< 1 :
@ $+ $.
G*";
11 :
.7
9
9E2
<
:
#
-
'
n0 <
A
B &- :
?
0 /< 5
&-5
p (-
/# 9+
-
- =
0 5
&-5 = (- ; -@ <
" #
- #
<
0 < .9
"
3 p $ 5
<
? ?
*
(
(
("
&
* 5
6
.r ("
4
/;
9+ B
+
0 5
&-5 "
9 5
$r
./ ($ &- @ $5 &- r @"
4
/# 9+ $
-
<
$# (Johnson & Scholes, 2002 :198) n
G5
2F
<
n ,4
/;
9+ 5
$ +
.
$ -
7
-
5
n0 (+
;
4
/;
9+ ) B
A p ,-"
&1 5
9+ $# ).
(
;
4
/;
9+ n
(
) 5
9+ ' B
$ (
$
9+
.(16 :2008
$ :5
9+ , &
4
/# '
nY
$ :5 H / $ H . (
0 &< * H /
$ (:5 & , -++ $ 4
/;
.4
/;
B' $ $ 1 ;
$
2
0 " :5
$0 .0 (:5
&-5 $ 5
&-5 4*
9+
0 <
2* $ +
2*
0 *
)# tS7
:5
$ ( 5
&-5 $+ :5
&-5 .n
E+ :5
n
.0 2*
0 *
2* $ 4
/;
9+ 9 $ )
0 "
: =
% ,C 10E2
E - 2* $ $
"Y
$
3./
&
"- /
4 :.
E 9 $ & ).
"
4
/# 9+
$ 9+"
# 4"
- 2* $ & "
4
/# 9+ (? 2
?
G
* /# &-
)
R"
"
"Y
&7
+
$ D* 2* $ H . .R"
F"
" ;
(Wheelen, and
+
.*
H .
"Y
3./ &
*
& n*#
*
1 0 $ 9+
;
n0 "
4
/# 9+
6
+
.*
S7
&+ &+ /
.F
33
"
0 &+ -
" ;
# "
4
/# 9+ A
2* $ $
$0
+
S7
+ "
:
;
5
:
;
$ $
$ .*;
(12
:
0
:
;
./ &+ $# (-
/# 9+ ("
" ; /
" ;
(
.*
-7' &
"Y :
+
6
3
/ $
@ # -
"
-
- ? - - " 4
/;
,'
$
$5<
?15 -
+
) $# C " )# 4
/@
$# C 5
H / (&- : A# &- # C -' $ $5<
$ $#
'
$ $# C "
4
/@ +
"
4
/# *
5
$# / $# $
, ,
=F
$
$ *
$# H" 2 & $0 $# C
;
*
/ 3./ (-
@*
./ A $# (
4
/;
=F
/ $ $5<
*u
0 9 $ 4
/;
&- 4* p 5*
$ &
0 )Y ? >
34
9+ 4
/;
$ $# )'
$ (&+
2"
$ A
C
4- D
* $
2
? A $ 2 2
. + 4
/;
$ $#
$
C - 9 -/ $ $# C
0 2
? A 9
&
0 C 2
? A
2
$ :2
' # +
&-2
$# C .
"
:
#
C
#
2 + 9 4-
9+ C $1
$ $# C $1 4
/;
$
p &12
$ # # :*
p &12
$ # 4-
9+ $1 $
(Wheelen, and 4-
9+
$
$5< ?F' C
(
,
"
:
#
$
- ($
/* A;
&
*
D
, &
*
+
H /
.* &+
/ H . (3
# " n , > ,
9+
5
# 9+ )# (-
$ $ @ 4
/;
- 9+
+
$ ) :1
5 (Effectiveness 5
Efficiency
(
$ (Outputs) *
.5 (Inputs ) 2*
$ 2
0 "
.(10 :2000
35
# # :
<
C>#
1 &/ p
R'
<
/; *
&# -
:
<
3./ -
$# * (&
: #
<
B2
0 <
(:
;
&+ --0 n
$ $ - <
B # 2 " # (*
*
.9
, 9+ (
2F
G7*
5
A
$# (4 :2007 () n
.+
&-> &- , " / ($71 5 $
$
n * &+ # <
D 0 (&
/
, 95 ).
" -72 > :
- 2* $ $ (1
1 ;
(+A
*v /2 $-5
6
($71
< - :/ $< $ 0 <
C
$#
1 5*
/
(&
H-
< - $ .S
< -
S
G7* A
:
;
. ( 5*
;
G7*
$
&
.0
S
$# .0 (
0 ' $71
R 0
0 -
&
# .
:
$
F
C
9+ $ r 3 $
36
*
5
+
$ /
+
$r S
(5
H . (+ R'
& + # *
# S
$ p (&
$#
.- ( 5 S
$
.0 ; t'5* D
5 $ $# - S
$r
+
$# .0 (
+
9+ $ ; $71
' $ 3
./
3
S
$ - 4
5
($71
S
5 $ + $
, +
$ ( Karahasanovic & Lonn, 2007: 1 ) n
$# C
&<
$0 )# t:"
.
5
( A
. ?+ '
5
?+ D
$ C}
+ }
:2008 (2
)
6 G 0 )#
& $ 2
? '
.(34
$ 4- "
# Y
/
$ ( 3 :2007 ($2 ) +
($71
> 9+ (
&
(4
+ (:
;
:$# $+
.5
+
.#
:
Juran $
& /* # 9
9+ R"0 .C
# 5*
;
<
$#
0 (Atem and Yella, 2007: 14) "}
+ S
G7* $# p (
x 5*
+ < 5*
<
37
+ :5 A
.
$ $# C ($71
'
.$71
-
.
$#
( Evans and Collier, 2007: 12) Y
.$71
. &+
#
#
&+ $ <
$ $#
$# ( Slack, et. al, 2004: 45 ) 6'
$ (
1 $ <
$ ( (
.&-> $71
$> $71
$0
0 ( Krajewsky and Ritzman, 2003, p: 62 ) "
# -
G7*
/ (&- $
G7*
($71
> &+
" ($2
- /"
.
H B
:+
$ $ &-
+
<
$0
$
Y ( Heizer & Render, 2001: 36 ) #
$ &-> $71
- C - , C
.-++
38
2q* $ ;
& <
B 17 $ % }
} $# p
n
:$' /
$#
- H" 5
3./ $# 0 95
.+
$71
.1
.$71
H . F
&7
&-5
$# .2
.*
" n
+
&-5 .3
:
9 ) :
qA
"q .0 (q<
2
0 #
)"
A
qA
1-;
.<
D
*
&+ ;
++
(q- q-
0 )"
0
+ /+ / F -
@ ( ,
H / $ &
.0 :5 $# $ )"
q
-
Av
C &/
1
$
.5<
'
- $
/;
$
5<
'
R' :0 -# $
5
/
$' (;
&-5 / 5<
'
$# =
n
&q (
:21
(
("
4
"
(<
A - #
39
q> # q
$u /
3./ , $ $# )'
$ E (5<
$
>
R"
# (B
+ 5
"
"
AY
, ( :
:
+A
, (
7 (5<
n) 5
-'q $
:"# $ , 5<
'
$# .2
. *
*
7
q
:
q
q<
($Y
:Y
:21
, 2 :, <
? .1
.H .
9
q+ (q -q ( (&- ( 7 $ ' :;: , .2
.5 *" 4
.:''
(pA;
(4
(:' :,?
"9 .3
.n*
1
C
A :
.4
. ,
4
"
C# A :
4 *- .5
q* q7
3.q/ q :
:;: ,?
<
? F "9 .6
(5<
s
) *
7
((
)
.(
(q
)
*"
5 5 (4<
) $ 9 / :
H .7
.(5*
(3:. ( (
40
&+ <
H B + &/# $ <
$ 5<
'
$q 5
:'
1
+
0 +
5
+ (- $
0 -*
q*
q+ q q
(
./ :+
,
1
R"0 G+
# R"
n $ $1
$ 5<
'
4
)Yq $ $# A
$ .R"
/# 9+ 5
2* $
* /
7* 5 :
(?" 2
?
$# # (q &/
# 31
>
3+5 $# - @" $
(7
#
# 4<
Y
H . $
.0 n 3- ,' 0 @ 3"
(*
5
H
-
$
AY -
"
*
q
0 )Y '
& (
$ 3*@ 1 # *u $ A 5
&q*
$q H / $# (
;
H
3 E ).
+
q
C
5<
' .&+
CF
E2*
R
1
(q
$
=5* / A
x
C
3.- (<
q
- "# 42*
,
7
1 +
)# (CF
/< +
q1 (q
:
# q 4A - . 5
E
1 + 5< $ 5
-
41
3"q Dq
)# (
$ '
3" D /
:
; 5
, <
? A "
:?
.q* $# q- 2* $ 5
, 5 @ 4
4
4q
q $q ).
5
1
4<
,
# q7 $q :
(4<
$
7 4< , 4
$0
1
(
"
, 4 $# C (:
Y
q
q
,q 4q $# C ($Y
<
C $
$ <
4
/;
*
F
?A
$# H" (<
$ + (
&# # 5<
- , ("
q
Y 4<
n $ (
#
S (*
q*
+
* (
+
.*
"0 & <
$ 2/ #
q
<
7
$ # (5<
- E # *"
+q
Cq7
9+ q q5* 5 - S ?F'
q
(
4
, 4
5 C 4<
$r
. .C
q
3.*
- 0 < $# C
:";
&/# $ $# p
n
# 2*;
#
&+
4 * $ &
.0 *
. 4 -
> $
.<
= $
(
3./ R' +
6 p
&
:
3./ $
R' 2 -
43
? *? :.
K
9 4 > 6* '
*
Q # =
% :$
(2001) (&
J
.
9
*
#
C.
q<
q+
R
q #
$
A@
0
3./ /
q (
>
F
= -2 (<
F
0 *
q q
S7 -<# .
"
$
$
#
q+
H . 4<
:
@ 9
+
$
; ,5 A@
q .C
1 *
$ 5
$
n+
,1
+
Cq
q1 5<
$
A "
n+
" G*
+
n
1 "
H
A@
1 p *
$ 5
$q
B
A@
42*
$ .
*
5<
#
q5<
$
$# $ &>
:5<
$ 9
q*"
2q+
q*
q+
:
q0
"
&- & &/A@
q<
q
p
q0
$ 75
H ,
./
&-< # &-
0 C
44
6K* K
4
? "
4
-" :$
(2002)
J
.
-
$q (qF
r -2 +
C ;
4
0
3./ /
q (q ;
/
"
/# F
4
2*
q
$ - $ C ;
3./ $ 2
4
0 ? '# 4-
q+
$0 :q-/# $ S7
$
0
.n*# - $
/# F
q-
F
0 $# p ("
4
/# 9+ ?-
? C
("
n
F )# 9+ *
+
C ;
42* 4* $
42q*
&q> q
.?'q# +
C ;
42* 4* A@ F
4
/# $#
q
;
?+ H / $# 0 *u ) C# $ )/
C q;
$#
q 70
. 2 H / H . .F
-2
.
<
K K K
9
K '
#" :$
(2002) &
1
J
"
[
- .!.
q
q
$q
q $
< -
0
/
q q
1 p ( ;
" <
F
&-/
45
C q;
;
(q<
-
(4
/;
:
7
$q
, $
, $ .
n+
(2
+
7
"q q *
& p (319) &/ o
$# q
3.q/ q- 0
S7
&/# ,
$ (%40.8) - F
q<
qF
$
/
$#
.*
E+
4
/;
:
G* (3.50 J2.51)
+
$'
C ;
;
: ? (
n+
+
<
-
.(3.71) 2
(3.57)
K '
#.
9
":$
(2002)
J
"
9
n $ (
<
7
<
F
n+
.7
<
F
p 5 (5
<
F
q
7
q
q / n <
F
&/# $
0 '0
"# p (
<
7
<
F
n+
&/#
# /
<
4
/; A
5<
/
H / $#
0 S7
46
7
<
F
$
.&-
/# 9+ $5<
; tA
q
&/# $ (/ $ 9
<
7
q
<
F
1# $ $ (5
<
F
4' &A F
S
$
, " 4' :
<
9q+
& F
S
)
&
F
,' 11
.F
4
/; 9
K
* A% "
9
" :$
(2005) $'
J
.
9
;
< --
D.
0
3./ /
q<
3./ F
+ C# F
p
G*
&
$+
q
q+
$
0
3./ (
>
F
= -2
$ 4"
3./ / (F
+ -2 <
3./ F
$
.- AY
$ <
3./ 7
F
9" 4 9" $ G* R 161 & R 159
1 2
? 320
S7q
$q
0
.7
" + /*
& 3 G
.<
F
r +
D. - p $ ;
< 4* :-
F
D. &
R+
=5* ;
< $# $
4' #
0 S7
"# H . .G*
R+
<
(3.5
<
F * 9 G*;
(
<
.q Eq#
C F
* > 7
"
* F
&
&
47
qF
+ -< 4* & (;
< F
+ /# $
0 q qF
+ F /# G*
R+
# &
R+
< $
1
*
$
F $ 0 2 $ # $ 2' .<
F
.F
+ $ 5<
K K K
."'- .!.
(qF
4
q/@ qF
7
C
4
0
/
H .q ($;
q
" F
Av
F
Bq
(F
S
$
B
&/#
4
(q" (29)
q / o
$;
" , $
$
$ &
A > +
,1 & (
"
&/q o
*
E*
"
"
$
$ (%23.2)
" 5 (116)
F p (500)
q#
B
$# :
S7 -<# .
$
(q
& (
:/
$ 4 @ A
<
-
qA;
/ (C
($
' (
(
< ;
(
q
. 9q q &
-<# .A
E*
<
$
?
48
0 # @ 9 A
<
$ (0.05)
n 70
qF q+
n+
(F
R
# (F
(F
4
/@ A
F
q-<# ).q
F
n : A F
Au (F
0 9 (-
9
7q0
. 9 &
-<# H . .H " 6 ?
qF n1q qF
0 q#
# /
$ (0.05) n
q-<# .q*
q ()
n
(
/Y
(
(E *"
.70
. / F
0 # $
, $#
?# :,- 9
:$
(2010) ()
J
[#H
:
q
$# $
%
= B
0
3./ /
q C
7
%
+
.*
F
#
&-% $5<
$ (
-
F 5
S-
&*
.7
"
<
2"
%
- /% Y C F
$
% #
q*
F
- $
% 0 /1 '
*
,'
/ 2 .
H . *} -
/# 9+ - -5 7+
q (
q A
$ C # @ F
# +
C ;
&
*
)
% "
qqqq " / +
/# 9q+ '
F
(q (")
&
*
5
-
2q* "q
% +
,
0
,
$ % :5 (( 1
: 9
* \
9
:$
.(2011) (
J
"
<
F
A
4
0
3./ /
$
$
$
, $ ($
,
&
*
& (" (84) / o
"
3./
.
5
7
C ;
$
? *
(
<
F A@ (/1# $ S7
$
0
.5<
'
4
/;
9+ -
"Y $
"
F
A2A
/@ <
F
$#
S7 -<#
H / $#
$ n
<
+A F
&<
" F
*;
B "
*"
Y
Y *
&
n ?
?A#
$
/
5<
n E
A@
&
$
.<
F
9 ?.
9
:$
((2012) (
J
.
*
*
:
<
# .!. 9 '
* 9 8# '
*
<
F
4
0
3./ 4/
(( ) 7
1
2
(7
1
) 7
1
<
50
&
*
&
4
/# 9+ (- $
< - $ (7
1
& &
#
?
(
(SPSS)
& 7
1
&
*
F 5 $
"
*
<
F &
$#
; A
#
$# (*
"
+A /
<
F
?
? H / $# .5 ?'# : <
*
#
0
.('
( +
()
) <
&
n 70
. 2 #
0 '5
*
$ ?2
R *
<
*
<
F
$ (0.05 ≥α)
.
? +
2
./ (%86.9) o
$# H . (7
1
*#. *? :
:$
(Jiaqin & Huei, 2002)
J
9 ;
A
* F
+
F A
-
q
9q
B
9+
(/
$' - &- ;
A
-
q
(
(+A
(
(
:/
q
,1 & 7
*
? 2
? (27) '0 &
51
32 (%42) /;
p $
+ $
$#
q
?q*# (%8) +A
&A (%13) )
&A ((%32) )
$q <
F
2
$# $ .(%5)
.70
. 0 2
:$
(Baulcomb, 2003)
J
q- $q
q<
5
9+ F
F :
B+ &+
, $ .
3./
'
# 1 *
&-
* $'
:
q* $q $q' :# $ &
' $
, $
D. p
&*
.,
./ $ 5 (100)
& o (
'
.q q'
n+
F
n+
1 p F
0 (Lewin)
> (*
&+ $ 9+ A F
n+
$#
5"
5
(=
-
,'
(
&< r
;
q
( Y
;
> (
# 2+
.R;
-
:$
(Cooper, 2004)
J
q
2*
Y
4"
2* $
&+ F
<
+A 9 G*
&
+
$
q
( D $
S
q $#
q 0
S7 "# .$+
u H
6'
)'q
q
q++ $q - (
& $
6# (Y
q+ q
1 (Y
" # , 9
F
(
q
q' - C (5 < # 7 , - # Y
('# 7
/A#
$ .*@
/ +
Y
(
4
, 4
4/ :+
4/ F
.- 9+ $# # $ (+ 6
.- AY
7
F
$ - :2
(&@
7
:$
(Stewart & Kringas, 2005)
J
q
2q+
q
C#
*
*
2* $ F
B n F
$
)# +
, & (+
0
* .
"
$
-1 &
q<
q qF
S7
0 +
"
$
53
(q
& (5
+
(F
C D.
:/ A
# $q
@q &/
(<
+A
&
(
("
q
0 H . D (
4
/;
9+ ' "
q
9q+ ).q
/
F
$ (&7+
,'
<
D .H . 9
:
0
F
+ - # )# (B
$#
*
, - p
F
0
0
./
.B F
0 +
$ +
#
5 (C# )@ F
&
:$
(Jimmieson; White & Peach, 2006)
J
q<
n0 $ 4< (149) $ 4 @ 2* $ H . (F $5<
$#
q 0 q
S7q q"# .
1 n
q &
?/
-<
F
p
0 $
# $.
$5<
$0
q 0 5q
q
S7 -<# .n*# $#
0 &-+ &-
+ ?+
? 5 <
*
+
$A
.
F :
r "
& 2* $ <
*
4
-q' (q<
-/
- A
C
< # *0
(-q* &
F :
0 (
u &-
$
Y5 S
$q 1 R
*
:
S
,'
0 - ($71
, -2
= -+ (- 71 : 1 -* $ S
G* , (-
.
- 1 F
:$
(Cata, 2008)
E
2q* $q +
$@
*
B
4
0 (F
"#
&q
(" 0 , :/
;
< B
+ &
*
$@
" $# - S7
$
0
<
q $# $ .# :5 ; &+ -72 '# * &+
,
.n*# <
$
&
*
q
$q
,
" ;
B $# S7
-<#
.*
<
7
$'
B
55
":$
(Beer & Eisnstat, 2009)
J
q
# .<
F
./ 9+
5*
7
<
$#
q 0
3./ .
390 $ / <
) $
9
q;
-
/ <
F
:
<
, ).
7
C
q<
qF
9+ 5*
7
$
H / $# .
1
F
$
q+
:
q
$ +
: / :5
q Cq
;
p -
<
&<
q
q- .5
-+
,+
9 +
$ Y
G*"
&
1q
6#
)
B5
C
"
n*# $ .5*
F
$# $ .
$ 9
;
"
+ *
F H / $0 (< *
7
, 4
+
(q5<
&-
q/# $
F
A (* /#
$ &<
4-
C # < ;
-
F
. (1-2)
+
, +
1 6'
4? ,#
4q
0
/ q1/
q 4q
0 / "-
q 11 F
0 A# q
2q* $ F $5<
/
"
<
F
#
"
5
S-
#8
7
/:
0 & ? " 5* 7 # <
?
>
? # ?
q- q $ $ $q q
R $ $% A#
*
.
+
57
@ ,!:
#8
S- 1J3
, 2J3
3J3
F
E
# 4J3
F 5J3
7
C # 6J3
, C # 7J3
58
@ ,!:
#8
.0 (
3.- &+
p
-*
- 5 5
./
-A
,
# H .
,
R 5 $'
.
7
C ;
,
9
$' (-
(
5
C;
p
- ,
$
3./
q q q
/
"
11 F
0 A#
4
4-
q $
$
:
#
4
- 2* $ &
2* $ H . (
$q
F +
& .0 ("
3./
q-
4- H . (E+
F
0
>
F
2*
.
S7 $ '5
*
A# 2E3
(180) / o
/
"
, $
, $
((2012 &q q
"q
q
2
&
9
x
9) ("
."
3./ :# $ 9
(1) 9
r $
$
$
, $ $
#
,
+
9 $" $.
("
3./ F
("q
0 (& C7 (& ) C $F" $ $ A
$
"q
q
, A
"
$ " $ (
p
R1q
q
6 (
9
x
9
/
q+
q
r $ &
( 285) - p
, .0 (
(360)
q q'*
q
q +
> -
+ = $
Rq q
&q
q
6q' (1J3) &
(280) 7
. '*
1
( 1E3 ) ,#
,
** )C
?. >#
)C ?. ?.
?.
<!+ ,
** '
? ' '
? 6*
3E3
/q
"
$
$
$
$
.(
p
("
0 (& C7
60
=
% 4E3
q
D. $ 9
(2) & 9
('5
>
p
&
:/
*
-'*0 & .1 &
q*
).
q -q' &q .0 (-Y
4
/# E
-0 9
(
,
@ -2 n
&
.# $ $ 7/ G*
.
.;
:# $ 9
(3) & 9
q12
q
,q
@
2 n $ @ :- ? ?C :
F , A
2 6' ( 2J3 ) &
(Malhotra, 2004, p: 268)
.
(2E3) ,#
? (
%
: ]?
4: ,*
%70.52 +A
F
8J1
%76.64 <
-
F
17J9
%77.46
F
25J18
%74.67 &-
F
33J26
%72.68 4
/;
9+ 38J34
%71.90
43J39
61
%71.23 5<
'
50J44
%74.01
7 , 4
55J51
%77.3 ?* $ , 55J1
9
3./ -
9 #
p2A p
+ +
-
D.
F
:v
?: (=5* ( (,5) /
/(
;
–
;
) = 75
:
$ H . .1.33 = 3/4 = 3/(1J5)
5E3
:v
;
2* $ & :(
.
(8J1)
& :+A
F
J
q
q (17J9)
& :<
-
F
J
.
.
(25J18)
& :
F
J
.
(33J26)
& :&-
F
J
:v
"Y
2* $ - & :(
:) A?
:
.
(38J34)
- & :4
/;
9+ J
.
(46J39)
- & :
J
62
.
(51J47)
- & :
J
.
(58J52)
- & :5<
'
J
.
(63J59)
- & :*
7
, 4
J
9
,2 5 " 9
) *
E+ p
&*
:$C =
4 :
.(
2 " 9
> ,$2 9
> ,2 3
0 9
,2 4
?* <!+ ,
*
6E3
$q' q
2* $ -
*r p
&
pq
&*q
q (q
=> 9+
*
9 - /
:
C ;
4q H . (7
C
A :
=
4 .1
( q
q
q
/#
F
:
u
.
- $
" n $ )
4
H .
q2
*
$ H . :(Multiple Regression) C . ,
* .2
.,
F
+
F
$
.,
F
+ F
q
. 9q q n * H . :( Anova ) - '
? ,
* ?C .4
q
,
F
+
F
$ $
0 70
.A
5<
*"
5 n1
63
,
#
n * H . (Cronpach’s Alpha) :: ]? ?C .5
.
- "
F
E *
Eq+
D. F
0
F ,' )# (
F $
q ;
q
q/
$ $
3./
&
: A
q* q
q0 2q* $ -
&
/ :
-
? :.
.
-
'5
Y
> p (
3./ R'
q
0 R
2* $ -
&
H / :
? :
: " (
3.- )<
,' H . (+
5*
0 Rq' p
H * (
p;
C .#
. 5
F
. 5
F
0 R' p
7 .C
"q
+
5
F
0 R'
*
.D
.
/
"
$
64
A? ,!:
B<
# G7* 1J4
F 5
:
S7 2J4
' *
S7 3J4
65
A? ,!:
B<
D<!C 1E4
:- 0
&
S7
$
( 1E4) ,#
'
'
A
%
< ?
<:
83.6 234 . =#
16.4 46
A #
4.3 12 30
21.8 61 35 J 31
56.1 157 40 J 36
9.3 26 45 J 41
8.6 24 A@ 46
25.0 70 &
* ,F
60.0 168 E
10.3 29
4.7 13 3
12.5 35 @
5 ?C
32.1 90
10 J 6
43.2 121 15J 11
12.2 34 A@ 16
%100 280 * >#
7"
$#
(
,
p
.
95 5 $ (
$# q .
9 * ,
* 2 ,# . 6
q q
/
"
-
;
p
"
.
, + B
n $
1
9
x
9
$# q (q
q
;
7
;
&/ .
/ C
q
$;
#
D*
<5
C"
>
+
.
5 1
D* / C
36)
75
$1
$
$
;
# $0 : .2
q
75
&A (
0 $ % 56.1
" ( 40 J
( q 45 J 41)
75
&A (%21.8
" ( 35 J 31)
,1
./ 5 .%4.3
" ( 30)
75
*#
q q q; &+
/
75
3./ ()
7
)
D'
$
?
$@ &- $ ( #
# $#
0
3./ " ."
3./
;
n
).q
)5
/.
"
$ $
75
3./
.H-
# 9/
C E
$ &7
" $ &-
67
A;
&/ ( E
)
;
-"
$0 $ :
* ,F .3
-" &A (% 60.0 F (? (168) &/ o p (
(% 10.3
" (
-" &A (% 25.0
" &
$ &> (
9
* 2 ?# ? # &
0
,
.,
.-
/@
75
$1
$
$
;
* $# :?C .4
q75
&A (
0 $ %43.2
" (( 15J 11)
q 16)
75
*# (%32.1
" (
10 J 6)
$ E@
? H / $# ,1
./ 5 .% 12.5
" (A@
3.q/
+
$' ).
&-
* $ $
Cq
q $# pq
n .'# *
*
- "
*
$# $
:Y/
& ).
"
3./ *
5<
4
.+
C
0
:! 5!+ B< 2E4
: 4
( 2 E4) ,#
4
.
?
R
".
-
? ?
5 1
+
&+ F
0 "
1
.6259 4.122
Y
+A : /
5 3
0 -+A 2* $ "
2
.7025 3.973
.$
n Y
+A
5 5 +A 9
"
+A &
6
.6656 3.766 .,
n
$
+A
F
F $#
0 (2J4)
"
n +A
F
F $
+5
+ : $ (6) (5) (4) (3)
- $
/
"
11 +A
F A@ $
69
o + )
4
# ( 3.837) &
R
o p (
<
.(.7130)
:
9 ,
8
*
.
?
R ". ?
-
?
"
<
-
F &
,5 3 .6887 3.8267 9
- 47< # &# p
?+ <
-
"
,5 4 .7640 3.7614 10
-/
"
7 .7640 3.6484 11
<
<
-/
F "
p
,5 2 .7640 3.8684 12
,5 1 .7225 4.0088 <
-/ "
&+ 13
,5 6 .8060 3.7281
F "
p 14
$
* "
&+
8 .8060 3.6281 15
-#
,5 5 .7614 3.7018
<
-/ &+ "
&+ 16
9 .8014 3.6277 =
-' ,
S "
&+ 17
0.7642 3.7554 $
5 <
-
F
F $#
0 (3J4)
"
n <
-
F
F $
+5
+ : $ ((14) (16)
70
11 <
-
A@ $ ,5 n
0
"
o p (
< - $
/
"
:
#
( 4 E4) ,#
#
*
.
?
R ". ?
-
?
1-;
F
0 "
,5 4 .8399 3.8333 18
.
F
C
/ *
7 &+
C
"
,5 1 .8170 3.9737 19
C ;
p# *0
0 "
,5 5 .8263 3.7947 20
.
*
.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n
F
$
+ 5 :
71
$ 24 +5
23 +5
21 & +5
: $ 25 22 20 18 19 &;
0
" .A@
$
n
F
F
/
"
11
F A@ $
n
)
4
# ( 3.7374) &
R
o p (
.(0.7925) o +
:$8
*
.
?
R ".
?
-
?
& 9 F
0 "
,5 3 .8011 3.859 26
5<
$ 5
;
F
"
,5 4 .7805 3.749 31
:
;
*
2
F "
p
7 .8440 3.658 32
5<
-
0 $
7 "
65
,5 6 .8251 3.736 33
.5*
$
+ 6 : 3.638 – 4.0000 $
- F (A@
$ ,5
72
26 30 27 &;
.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n &-
F
&-
F
F $ 28 +5
32 & +5
: $ 33 53 31
.A@
$
n
o p (
< - $
/
"
: :A?
? 4* B< :C
$
;
9 7;
$ E* F
./ $'
7q;
$q
A
9 (4
/;
9+ "Y 38J34
+5
+5
&' / A A
# (
"Y 43J39
+5
"
q
7 , 4
"Y
&' 5<
'
"Y 9 50J44
v
$ $ .55J50
+5
&'
"- /
4 F E1
( 6 E4) ,#
"- /
4 F
.
?
? $%
- $
4
/;
$
0 "
,5 4 .48451 3.9684 37
7
5
4
/;
;
+
"
,5 1 .48682 4.0228 38
( 7 E4) ,#
# # F
.
?
? $%
R ".
?
-
?
5
"
9+
,5 3 .05060 4.0000 39
(1v
)
,5 4 .50590 3.9737 - "
&+ 40
:2
:
u R2 "
&+
,5 2 .3192 4.1140 41
-
,5 1 .3192 4.1240 :2
' "
&+ 42
* - "
,'*
,5 5 .7477 3.8599 43
.3885 4.0143 # # F $
3.8599 –4.1240 $
"Y
$0
74
:
9 ) F E3
( 8 E4) ,#
:
9 ) F
.
?
? $%
R ".
?
-
?
C# $ B $
"
,5 4 .7283 3.8912 44
."
*
,
$
> $
} "
$0
,5 1 .6171 3.9940 45
$
$ &
+ $
"
,5 6 .7288 3.8758 46
." $
:Y
:21
"
$
G
,5 2 .6618 3.9702 47
."
D* *
AY " $
+
67
9
,5 5 .7242 3.8843 48
."
$
B
$
, "
0
,5 3 .7058 3.9526 49
.5"
"
"
0 &-
,5 7 .7281 3.8617 50
."
D* *
$
75
, <
? A "
F E4
( 9 E4) ,#
, <
? A "
F
.
?
? $%
R ".
?
-
?
, 4
+
"
H
,5 2 .66407 3.9684 51
7
4<
:2
, "
4
,5 1 .62253 4.0088 52
7
F
, "
4
,5 4 .70146 3.9277 55
*
(3.9529) &
R
o p (
+5
, 3.9118
) ?C B< 3E4
,1
R0 $ @
& + (
' *
9 :
:- 0
&
S7
$ ;
76
(
0.493 0.229
:
(7
n $ # / (0.493) F ( 5
) ,
F
G
1
1
<
?
.
,1
$ $F
2 $#
,1 $r ((σ2) $ (¦) (30) $ #
& $
.0
:6-
<
): ?C :.
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F
(0.05≥α)
."
/
"
11 (&-
F
(
( 11 E4) ,#
[ 4
)
[
#
[
9 ,
8
4 F F
R2 Sig. *4
<!+
# ? R
= 3.84 7.65 .659 79.2 .000 F
0
F
77
(7.65) /
F $# ( 11 J4) 9
$ 6'
(q'5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+ ((3.84)
- F
q q
'5
= & r H . (
+
$
+
$# $
qF
) 3@ F
70 . A@ "
G
'5
3Y
./ ("
< - $ H .
/
"
#
n 70
. () 3
. 2
3./
.(0.05)
n $
q
&
*
& + 3
5
F
0
F A# $ 9+
$ 6' (3
' * Simple Regression
:-
&
S7
( 12 E4) ,#
[ 4
)
[
#
[
9 ,
8
4 T
? T R2 Sig. ,4
<!+
#
= 1.648 7.27 .428 .000
9 ,
8
= 1.648 5.69 .402 .000 $8
78
((1.648)
- F ( 6.87) /
T $# S7
-<# .1
+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G
'5
'5
= & r H . (
+
$
+A
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
(Sig.)
F .0 ("
/
"
11
3./ +A
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .417)
((1.648)
- F ( 7.27) /
T $# S7
-<# .2
+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G
'5
'5
= & r H . (
+
$
-
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
3./ <
-
F
5 .%5 $ # /
?5 (Sig.)
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .428)
((1.648)
- F ( 4.11) /
T $# S7
-<# .3
+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G
'5
'5
= & r H . (
+
$
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $#"
(Sig.)
F .0 ("
/
"
11
79
3./
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .334)
((1.648)
- F ( 5.69) /
T $# S7
-<# .4
+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G
'5
'5
= & r H . (
+
$
&-
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
(Sig.)
F .0 ("
/
"
11
( .402)
3./ &-
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
.,
F
$ $
&
* p
&
F $ '# ,'
D. F
0
F ,' )# (Stepwise Regression )
D. $
.0 ( $ 5
/# - A@ E+
$ (
) 2
6'
-
&
# $ @
$ S7
= :
$ ( 5
F
0
F
@ (F
5
;
$ (Multicollinearty) *
"
) ((variance inflation factor) $ &*'
# C p
&
5
;
$ *
" 5 $ # / ( VIF= 1.881
S7 ++ > /
D.
A@
+
( 13 E4) ,#
: ?- ?C. Stepwise Regression #
. ,
* B<
:
+
Sig* Sig* (R2)
β DF F (R) ا
ى01ﻡ ى01ﻡ )ﻡ$+ﻡ
ار,.6(ﻡ) ا$+ﻡ /ی. ت ا$3در /#01. ا ط$%ا(رﺕ "#$ ا
/ (, ا / (, ا ,ی,. ا
.000 0.039 اف, ا(ه9:.ﺕ ;#
1
.000 0.034 "ﻡ$< ا
ت$<= دة ا03
0.000 2.29 . 20 .447 / $+A ا
.000 0.051 ?AB0 ا$C ا 279 ?@ا0% ا
.000 0.044 /EEEF# "EE ﻡGEEH ا
280 ع0< ا
)+ ا
(α ≤ 0.05)
*אא
0
F $@ (13 J4 ) 9
-<
S7 "
F
) /@ F
0 5 $# 5
A@
/# - F
2*2 ( &-
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
G*
A@
$# (% 0.05 $ # / 0.000
n
Sig $#
. +
t &
0
?
) F
0
F $
:
<
): ?C :
q q
0 70
. 9 :
'5
3./ G
q
n1
/
"
11 F
0 A@
.(*
(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
F q
.0
'5
'5
= #
+
G
.05 $
Sig.
n
F $
81
( 14 E4) ,#
D<!C R
?# %:* (One Way Anova) '
? ,
* B<
'
?
#
n F F R $
F
Sig
df
1 .251
$ =#
.363 3.84 .829 279 127.585
*
280 127.836
$
5 1.464
$
275 126.373
*
.305 3.84 1.213
280 127.836
$
4 2.346
$ ,F
276 126.295
*
*
.325 3.84 2.289
280 128.531
$
4 3.440
$
276 124.396
*
?C
.443 3.84 2.312
280 127.836
$
((3.84)
- F $ (.829) /
F $# :=# .1
./ (
+
$
F $# 6' - +
0 70
. 9 &
G
'5
n1
/
"
11 F
0 A@
((3.84)
- F $ (1.213) /
F $# : .2
=
./ (
+
$
F $# 6' - +
. 9 & "
G
'5
'5
82
"
11 F
0 A@
0 70
((.305)
n 3Y
./ . n1
/
- F $ (2.289) /
F $# :* ,F .3
./ (
+
$
F $# 6' - + ((3.84)
. 9 & "
G
'5
'5
=
"
11 F
0 A@
0 70
n 3Y
./ .
/Y n1
/
- F $ (2.312) /
F $# :?C .4
./ (
+
$
F $# 6' - + ((3.84)
. 9 & "
G
'5
'5
=
"
11 F
0 A@
0 70
n 3Y
./ .*
n1
/
=C ,!:
! B<
S7
1J5
2J5
84
=C ,!:
! B<
q5
.q/ $r (
,
5
& ).
:'
&
S7
3./ :'
(p
- 0
S7
?'
:
S7 &/# G* $ (
$
&+ & - 0
B< 1E5
:
'5
*
S7 G* $
F
) 3@ F
70 . A@
S7 -<#
qF $0 (
< - $ H .
/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .659)
3./ F
0
q-<# + + 3
5
F
0
F A@ 9 #
: S7
: 4
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .417) +A
F
./ $0 (-+A : /
+
&+ F
0
"
$# $ .0 (
.$
n Y
+A
, 9
&
$ 9+ -+A
G "
$# '# $
:
9 ,
8
. 5
,
F
$ $
<
-
F
F $#
0
S7 "# H .
$
/
"
11 A@
p $ n
5
F p - 0 <
-/ &+ "
$# $ .0 (
< -
.
<
-/
<
-/ &+ &+
?+ <
-
/
.
:
#
F
F ("
/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .334)
86
F
F $#
0
S7 "# H .
/
"
11
F A@ $ ,5 n
7 7-
&+
C
"
$# $ .0 (
/
F
C
/ *
1-;
F
0
"
$
.
*
C ;
p# *0
0
:$8
&-
F
F ("
/
"
.,
F
$ $ (.402)
n &-
F
F $#
0
S7 "# H .
.5<
& 9 F
4< "
/ (:
;
*
$ 5
;
F
"
$# '# $
7 65 (2
Y
&
F p
0
.5*
-
0 $
87
'
*
!C ,? 4* B< :C
: S7
-<#
F
0 A@
0 70
. 9 & .1
E n1
/
"
11
F
0 A@
0 70
. 9 & .2
F
0 A@
0 70
. 9 & .3
.
/Y n1
/
"
11
F
0 A@
0 70
. 9 & .4
.*
n1
/
"
11
88
! 2E5
5
0 -
$ &+ $ (
S7 :'
:
3./ (
/
"
11 F
0
11 $# - @" $
(
( +
.1
.F
- G $
(/
"
' .2
.*
*
F
:'
C
'
$
@- $# - @" $ * & /
"
& .3
F :
0 (<
-/ :F 0 # (p
F
, ,
5
2"
6 , (
.
.:2 *
&+ +
&- 0 2* $
&- "
/@ /
"
& .4
Y
3./ " 4A (* C
.F
5*
* $ 52
*
/# & F $A@ $.
$
;
H
"0 .5
.F
C
7
5
$ , (3.5
(/
"
<
+A
:2
1
.6
.4-
-
0
3./ $'
7
.5
;
"
7
,
/
"
5 $
.9
.*
*
4<
4
-
/
"
+ 11 .10
.4<
4
3./ , 4
(7
+
1v
-" 4*
/
"
.11
.-
&
*
<
F
n*#
F
" + p :
0 .12
3./ +0
0
(
, C #
.n*#
90
A# <%
? *? A# :.
K
4
? K :
4
- .(2002) "" " (
J
:q ;
q
(" > (
- 6*
.$;
($
.$;
($ R (5
E+
" (
;
(
9
$
/
<
F
.(2002) & # $@ (
J
F
- B ,
<
.(88)
(+ *# ,<
.$ ()5
(
;
(,- 9
9 ((2002) (# ($/
J
(
qF (,K. 6*
? . s? ((2007) ($ * R"
J
.*
("
( 9
9 ((2010) (&< + ( $ * (R"
J
.,1
"
:$
91
."
(/+
(,1
" Y (1 [
9 r* .(2005) ( (
J
.
5
(
( (;*
,
* , .(2007) ( (
J
.
+
R
#
$
A@ E .(2001) F
$ !
(&
J
.(85)
(+ *# (<
F
* <
1-
$
,
((2006) ( (
J
.
(=
(
- (p
(
9 ?.
9
[
*
*
:
<
# .!. 9 '
* 9 8# '
&
&
(
C " ,
Y
0 +
:A
<
<
F
R
Y
(
.7
1
(2012 19J18 $ 5
2* +
( C
.!.
9
'
# .(2002) 1 (&
1
J
.$;
(0 :H
(" > (
-
.)#
, :$
92
?# :,- 9
.H
;
(
&
& (" > [#H
(
*
!
.,1
"
:$ (
" 9"
[( # : r*) [ 9 r* ((2003) ( (
J
.$;
$ (
;
,1
." 7
:$
7
:$ (#
? :
? ((2010) (5 (+
J
.,1
"
p
0 (
:/+
(
9 r* .(2003) (&/
0 ()
J
.
(q A
q
(,- 9
9 r* ((2003) $ ($
J
.$;
(7
($
" 9"
:$ [$
9 9
9 .(2010) & (+
J
.,1
.9"
($ ( A
[
+
.!.
.$;
($ :
$ (" > 3
# ('-
93
(
;
(K
* ! $9
4 ((2008) & $> (2
J
.$;
($ (,1
" :
A
("
(
$
:
9
.(2009)
()1
J
.,1
" 7
:$
(
;
[
(+ r?
#
+ + (B5
(F
J
.300J299 :G(2004 ( (
- H
.2012 (
9
x
9 $
"
J
7
(
+ $*
<!+
- ((2004) ($ $
B2 (-
J
.$;
($ ("
"q
:$ ((1) (* 9 ,- .(2000) " (
E
.,1
.,1
"
:$ (
(
9 r* .(2004) $ (& J
.,1
"
:$
.,1
"
:$ (
(9 ((2003) $ (& J
C
(, ,!- 9 $* ((2009) ( ($ J
.
("
+
(
(+
! C # ,
* ((2007) ( $
( J
1
(p A
Y
($ 2
4
.7
1
(
(;
<
9 [L
*? #*
-
C
v
:
E
Y
[#H
t ?# A%
.
- (
(;
&
$'
.
1
K
* AK% K :
9
.
: 9
\
9
.$;
(
:+
:+
("
.2012 &
"
2
& (
9
x
9 J
: [ + [(2008) (11
&/
0 (" J
."
(q< q5
&+ < ((2008)
$
(
J
.54J33 G (1
(+ (+
95
:/+
((1) (O# /
6* C , /
5? .(2010) (C/
J
.2
"
,1
("
(
9 r* s? ((2005) ($
B2 (
J
.
: q
[
# $
# ,C :5- $
.
'-
+A
1 (
9 r* 9 ((2004) ("
( J
.$
(: (
q
1 (
? F
% (( 2004 ) ($Y
($
J
.$;
($ (&
(/q+
(=:K $K* 5K) , @ ( (2001) ( E (= J
.4
. ;
C
1 ($ (
+ $
: ((2000) ($ (* J
HC
C
)
+ ? ((2010) ( (
( J
.
(
[5- $
" $5
:$ (/
?
9 '
? + .(2002) (C+ ($
" J
.,1
96
*#. *? A#
- Hill. G, & Jones, R. (2010). Organization Theory: Text & Cases. Third
Edition. Prentice Hall.
- Jiaqin, J. and Huei, L. (2002). Identifying Key Factors for Successful
Joint Venture in China. Industrial Management and Data Systems.
102/2, pp: 98-109.
- Jimmieson, N.; White, Katherine, & Peach, Megan,(2006). Employee
Readiness for Change: Utilizing The Theory of Planned Behavior to
Inform Change Management, Academy of Management. California:
USA.
- Johnson, Gery & Scholes, Kevan (2002), Exploring Corporate Strategy,
6th edition, Prentice Hall International.
- Karahasanovic. Ermin, and Lonn. Henrik, (2007). Selecting the best
strategy to Improve Quality, Keeping in View the Cost and Other Aspects
Valj den basta Strategic for at for battra Kvaliten med Hansyn till kostnader
och andra as pekter, Department of Terotechnology, School of
Technology and Design.
- Kotler. P. and Keller. K.L, (2009) .Marketing Management. New Jersey
.Pearson : Prentice Hall.
- Krajewski. Lee, J. & Ritzman. Larry, P. (2003) .Operation
Management: Strategy and Analysis, 5th edition, Wesley Publishing Com
USA.
- Malhotra, N. K. (2004), Marketing research, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
- Paton R.A. and McCalman J. (2001). Change Management: A Guide to
Effective Implementation. Second Edition. Sage Publications.
- Pattanayak, B. and Mishra P.K. (1999). Change for Growth:
Understanding Organizational Development. New Delhi: Wheeler
Publishing.
- Simons. Robert. (2000). Performance Measurement: Control Systems
for Implementing Strategy. Prentice Hall – new Jersey. U.S.A.
98
r? >%
H .1
;
9"
H .2
H.&. $ H .3
S*
H .4
H .5
)
H
.6
$ H .7
/;
H
.8
.9
. >%
A2
"
.10
'+
," " .11
9
;
" .12
1
.13
A
" .14
*
A
.15
# " .16
A
"
.17
A
" .18
2-
" .19
A2 /;
"
.20
A
" .21
A2 ;
9"
" .22
A2 $;
" .23
A
$# " .24
A2
*
"
.25
('+
) 5
" .26
'+
" .27
"
" .28
A
" .29
100
9
;
.30
A2
.31
A2
;
"
.32
A2 $ " .33
A
"
.34
('+
)
"
.35
A2 5
" .36
A
" .37
A
" .38
"
.39
A
4 .40
A2
" .41
A
.42
;
A
," " .43
H.&. $
" .44
'+
$ " .45
'+
< " .46
A2 " .47
'+
9
" .48
A
$
" .49
'+
H " .50
.51
A
" .52
'
>%
$
" .53
$
0 " .54
$ S*
" .55
$
;
"
.56
$ /;
"
.57
$ 9A " .58
$ " .59
5+ 4 >%
+ " .60
+
Y Y " .61
101
+
6
" .62
+
1 0 .63
+
"
.64
'+
+
"
.65
+
n
"
" .66
+
" .67
+
$
" .68
+
"
.69
+
$
1 " .70
+
& " .71
'+
1
" .72
)+
A
" .73
+
"
.74
A
"
"
.75
+
: v
" .76
)+
:
" .77
+
$# " .78
+
" .79
)+
A2
" .80
+
"
.81
-
+
# " .82
" .83
"
.84
+
A2 + " .85
'+
A
" .86
+
$# " .87
+
" .88
+
," " " .89
'+
*
9;
" .90
)+
" .91
+
$;
" .92
)+
" .93
! >%
('+
)
.94
102
7-
2 S*
" .95
"
" .96
" .97
,"
" .98
* *
"
.99
E
"
.100
5
*
C v
"
.101
$5
: +A
-
" .102
$
" .103
$ " .104
4F
"
.105
'+
" .106
$+
" .107
# " .108
*
+
" .109
C
" .110
D1
S*
" .111
:
"
.112
'+
" .113
s
" .114
$1*
" .115
2 # " .116
*
*
" .117
2-
# " .118
:
" .119
E
2-
"
.120
C >%
" .121
($1) +
" .122
4<
"
.123
+
2
"
.124
*
"
.125
'+
E#
" .126
/;
&
" .127
103
A2 *
.128
v
5 $ " .129
1
D *
" .130
'+
D
;
" .131
9
;
.132
2 " .133
+ " .134
4
2 " .135
7
@ :
"
.136
'+
H 5
" .137
9 5 5
" .138
'+
*
1
" .139
¨
"
.140
'+
5
" .141
+
:
"
.142
+ S*
" .143
7
.F
$ 1 " .144
'+
" .145
9 5
" .146
(
)
$1*
" .147
'+
.148
'+
" .149
15
"
.150
¨
"
.151
'+
$/ " .152
'+
4 " .153
;
4 " .154
+ "
" .155
+
4" " .156
'+
" .157
2
+
" .158
/1
"
.159
&+
" .160
,1 v
"
" .161
104
S
* " .162
*
,"
" .163
'+
$
" .164
$
"
.165
+
$
5 " .166
'+
G*
,"
"
.167
+
;
& E0 " .168
v
< v
" .169
$1*
+
" .170
+
" .171
9
;
" .172
" .173
1
$
" .174
HV- >%
"
+ " .175
7
.F
" .176
7
.F
.177
7
.F
5
" .178
$
"
.179
(
) .>x
"
.180
.2012 (
9
x
9 $
"
:!
105
;?
,-
*
+ $%
&
$
!
&
(((
*#
(((C
*#
(((+ &
:!ل !"!ع$ ا
+ (×) "0 ,' H . (
3./
7;
p
=
>; 4 - $
$ (&# C
.+
3./
$ u
@?
! "
!C
? :,- $4
106
:=# E1
A # .
: E2
35J31 @ 30
45 – 41 40J36
A@ 46
:
* ,F E3
3
:?C E4
10 –6
5
A@ 16 15 J11
107
.
, * : $4
q q &# $ -:
(
F A 7+
3./
. .
(x) "0 ,' H . (-
4
/
+
&+ F
0 "
1
Y
+A :
+A
0 -+A 2* $ "
2
.$
n Y
.-
4
/x ?+ "
+A F & 3
&
0 "
+A
4
.H . ?+ /F
&
$ 9+ -+A $ "
5
.:2
+A , 9
.,
+A 9
"
+A & 6
.- * 1 +A ? "
7
9 p
; F
0 "
8
-
9 ,
8
p
"
<
-
F &
9
- 47< # &#
?+ <
-
"
10
<
-/
"
11
<
-/
F "
p
12
108
<
-/ "
&+ 13
F "
p 14
-# $
* "
&+
15
<
-/ &+ "
&+ 16
=
-' ,
S "
&+ 17
#
1-;
F
0 "
18
.
F
C
/ *
7 7-
&+
C
"
19
.
C ;
p# *0
0 "
20
.
*
$8
5<
& 9 F
0 "
26
:
# +
"
27
0
&-
" ;
R F "
&+
28
$
Y
&
F "
p 29
109
2
4< " F
0 "
30
*
$ 5
;
F
0 "
31
:
;
2
F "
p
32
5<
-
0 $
7 "
65
33
.5*
: :A?
V /
V /
/ 6 / ?
/ ?
?
"- /
4
9+ +
4
/;
,'
"
34
4
/# "
4
/# $ E 9 H /
35
- $
4
/;
$
0 "
37
7
5
4
/;
;
+
"
38
# #
(1v
)
5
"
9+ 39
- "
&+ 40
:2
:
u R2 "
&+
41
-
:2
' "
&+ 42
* - "
,'* 43
110
:
9 )
$
C# $ B $
"
44
."
*
,
> $
} "
$0
45
$
:Y
$ &
+ $
"
46
." $
:21
"
$
G
47
."
D* *
B
AY " $
+
67
9
48
."
$
$
, "
49
.5"
$
"
"
&-
50
."
D* *
, <
? A "
4<
, 4
+
"
H
51
7
:2
, "
4 52
9
, "
4 53
7 *
F
, "
4
54
*
*
7
F
, "
4 55
& &
"
-
111
;
9"
F
.;
1
)
1
&
.;
2
>
B
.;
3
;
9"
4
;
9"
p
5
2
&
6
/;
$ / C-
7