Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gas Condensate Stabilization Unit - Different Design Approaches PDF
Gas Condensate Stabilization Unit - Different Design Approaches PDF
6, December 2012
TABLE I: FEED PROPERTIES OF KHANGIRAN GAS PROCESSING PLANT suggest that a lower pressure may be more economic. Hence,
Comp. H2O N2 CO2 H2S COS C1 the second separator pressure was assumed 25 psia. In
practice, a higher pressure should be selected to compensate
(mol% for the pressure losses in the transport pipeline and to allow
0 0.02 7.47 11.20 0 11.43
)
recovering the flashed gas in the second separator and
Comp. C2 C3 i-C4 n-C4 i-C5 n-C5 sending it to the fuel gas system on demand.
(mol%
0.97 0.59 0.91 1.27 1.12 1.12
)
Comp. C6 C7 C8 C9 C10+
(mol%
1.83 10.41 6.90 6.90 37.86
)
Second separator pressure (psia)
77 413 595.8 53.1 0.569 235.9 251
Fig. 2. Total heat duty versus second separator pressure in Khangiran case
3310
III. MULTISTAGE FLASH VAPORIZATION
Stab. Cond. flow rate (bbl.d‐1)
3305
Our main objectives were to recover as much as liquid
condensate as possible while keeping its RVP at 10 psia for 3300
the summer case. However, heat duties of steam heaters and 3295
shell and tube heat exchangers (so as their surface areas)
should be minimized to reduce the operating and capital costs 3290
to the least possible amount. The liquid stream leaving the 3285
second separator (L3 stream in Fig. 1) is recycled to preheat
3280
the liquid stream leaving the first one (L1 stream in Fig. 1)
aiming at lowering the heat duty of the following steam 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
462
International Journal of Chemical Engineering and Applications, Vol. 3, No. 6, December 2012
very low (3.5%) and the H2S content was much higher than of stabilized condensate in NGL3100 case are depicted in
that of fractionation. We can conclude that flash vaporization figures 6 and 7. It can be seen that the addition of stages
is not practical in NGL3100 case. further than 26 has small effect on the reboiler duty and the
condensate flow rate. Hence, this number may be primarily
TABLE III: STABILIZED CONDENSATE SPECIFICATIONS IN KHANGIRAN AND
NGL3100 CASES considered as the optimized one. If the overall tray efficiency
is considered as 0.85, the actual number of stages will be 31
Khangiran RVP (psia) H2S (ppm) CFR2 (%) THD3 (btu.h-1) which equals to 30 trays. The valve tray type with one pass,
Two Flash Tanks flooding fractional approach of 0.8, and tray spacing of 1.5 ft
10 4467 87 5.730 x105
were chosen. The calculated values for diameter and column
Fractionation
10 6635 70 8.484 x106 pressure drop were 3.07 ft and 1.57 psi respectively. A
NGL3100 similar procedure in Khangiran case indicates 10 theoretical
and 13 actual stages. The column diameter and pressure drop
Three Flash Tanks
10 206 3.5 5.438x106 were calculated as 2.17 ft and 0.76 psi respectively (at 1 ft
Fractionation
10 <1 30 5.639x106
tray spacing). Considering the diameter of column (2.17 ft),
choosing a packed column would be better. If we use 1 in. (25
mm) pall ring packing with approximate HETP4 of 1.48 ft
(0.45 m), the column diameter and pressure are calculated as
IV. FRACTIONATION 2.02 ft and 0.04 psi respectively. The properties of product
A distillation column with a reboiler and without any and the total heat duty of reboiler and heat exchangers are
condenser (non-refluxed column) was used (Figs. 4 and 5). listed in table III.
The pressure of top tray and reboiler are primarily considered
as 130 and 135 psia in Khangiran case and 140 and 145 psia
in NGL3100 case respectively. Boil-up ratio was adjusted
aiming at having the bottom product RVP at 10 psia. The feed
is preheated to an extent that the preheater, reboiler, and
cooler (E-101 in Fig. 4) heat duties are lowered as much as
possible in Khangiran case. It is notable that the stabilized
condensate flow rate and the total heat duty variations have
the same trend indicating that there’s a trade-off between the
heating cost and the stabilized condensate profit.
The criterion of preheating extent is different in NGL3100
case. It is determined in such a way that the temperature of Fig. 5. Fractionation (Distillation) scheme with the recycle of hot
cooled stabilized condensate (DL2 in Fig. 5) reaches to 95 F stabilized condensate (bottom product) in NGL3100 case
(which is almost the stock tank temperature). Since the feed
pressure of NGL3100 is high (413.4 psia) it passes through a 5.10E+06
4.50E+06
4.30E+06
4.10E+06
3.90E+06
0 10 20 30 40
Number of stages
1500
Fig. 4. Fractionation (Distillation) scheme with the recycle of hot
1400
stabilized condensate (bottom product) in Khangiran case
1300
For a definite separation, the reflux and boil-up ratios
(consequently the total heat duty of condenser and reboiler 1200
and their respective surface area) decrease as the number of 1100
stages increases. However, increase in the number of stages
results in higher capital costs due to higher heights of column 1000
463
International Journal of Chemical Engineering and Applications, Vol. 3, No. 6, December 2012
into account. The capital cost of column is related to the FP = 0.8510 + 0.1292 ⎜ ⎟ + 0.0198 ⎜ ⎟ (13)
vessel, trays or packings, internals, and the reboiler (a kettle ⎝ 600 ⎠ ⎝ 600 ⎠
type shell and tube heat exchanger). This cost may be
b
annualized via dividing by payback period in years. The ⎛ A ⎞
operating costs account for the energy required for generation FM = a + ⎜ ⎟ (14)
⎝ 100 ⎠
of high pressure steam passing through the reboiler tubes to
partially vaporize the bottom liquid. Total annual cost (TAC)
may be then calculated from (1). The number of trays which (
CB = exp 11.967 − 0.8709 [ ln(A) ] + 0.09005 [ ln(A) ]
2
) (15)
yields the minimum TAC may be considered as the optimized
number of trays. where, FP is the pressure factor, P is the shell side pressure
(psig), FM is the material factor, a and b are 2.70 and 0.07 for
capital cost S.S./S.S. material, A is the surface area (ft2), and CB is the
TAC = + energy cost (1)
base cost ($). Energy cost may be considered as 6 $.GJ-1.
payback period
The aforementioned equipment cost formulas are indexed to
the year 2000 and should be updated to the year 2011. It can
The f.o.b. purchase cost of the distillation column can be be done by multiplying the base cost by the cost index ratio as
calculated by (2) to (11) [5]. stated in (16). We used Chemical Engineering (CE) index
which is 394 and 585.7 for the years 2000 and 2011
C p =Cs +CT (2) respectively.
⎛I ⎞ (16)
Current cost = base cost ⎜ 2011 ⎟
CS =FM .CV +CPL (3) ⎝ I 2000 ⎠
The diagram of TAC with respect to the number of trays is
( )
CV = exp 7.0374 + 0.18255 [ ln(W ) ] + 0.02297 ⎡⎣ ln(W ) 2 ⎤⎦ (4) shown in Fig.8. It implies that the number of trays at which
the minimum TAC occurs is 9 (or 10 stages).
W = π(Di + ts )(L + 0.8Di )ts .ρ (5) 360,000
355,000
350,000
C PL = 285.1(Di ) 0.73960 (D ) 0.70684 (6) 345,000
TAC ($)
340,000
335,000
CT = NTN .FNT .FTT .FTM .CBT (7) 330,000
325,000
2.25 320,000
FNT = NT < 20 (8) 315,000
1.0414 NT
0 10 20 30 40
Number of trays
FNT = 1 NT < 20 (9)
Fig. 8. Total annual cost versus number of trays of distillation column in
NGL3100 case
FTM = 1.401 + 0.0724 Di (316 S .S . ) (10)
Since the stabilized condensate flow rate increases with
CBT = 369 exp(0.1739 Di ) (11) respect to the increase in number of stages, it is better to
choose the optimized number of trays by maximizing the
where, CP is the distillation column cost ($), CS is the shell annual profit stated in (17). Annual sale is calculated by
cost ($), CT is the tray cost ($), FM is the material factor which multiplication of gas condensate price (in $.bbl-1) by gas
is 2.1 for 316 stainless steel (S.S.), CV is the cost of empty condensate flow rate (in bbl.y-1). The stabilized condensate
vessel including nozzles, manholes, and supports ($), CPL is price was taken as 100 $.bbl-1. For simplicity, we calculated
the platform and ladder cost ($),W is the weight of shell and the annual profit obtained by the addition of each tray (profit
two heads (lb), Di is the inside diameter (in), ts is the shell per tray) instead, by assuming the number of two trays as a
thickness (in), L is the column height (in), ρ is the base. Since the duty and area of the preheater and the
construction material density (lb.in-3), NT is the number of associated equipments do not change significantly with
trays, FTT accounts for the tray type which is 1.18 for valve respect to the addition of column trays, the aforementioned
trays, FTM is the correction factor for the material of trick would be rational. Fig. 9 shows the annual profit
construction, and CBT is the base cost of trays. obtained by the addition of each tray. It’s obvious that profit
The f.o.b. purchase cost of the reboiler which is a kettle earned by using more than 9 up to about 30 trays is
type shell and tube heat exchanger is calculated by (12) to (15) considerable. Hence, the number of 30 trays (or 31 stages)
[5]. which was suggested earlier sounds reasonable.
464
International Journal of Chemical Engineering and Applications, Vol. 3, No. 6, December 2012
(12 trays), 2.17 ftf in diameterr, and 14.4 ftt in height orr a
6.E+06
packked column wiith the same nnumber of stag ges but 2.02 ftt in
5.E+06 diam
meter and 21.33 ft in height in Khangiran n case; and tw wo
cylin
ndrical horizonntal separatorrs with dimenssions of 4.5 ftt in
Profit/tray ($)
Profit/tray ($)
4.E+06
diam
meter and 15.775 ft in lengthh in Khangiraan case. Finallly,
3.E+06
detaiiled cost benefit
b analyysis togetherr with safeety
2.E+06 conssiderations andd environmenntal concerns would
w determiine
1.E+06 the final
f selection of the right teechnique.
0.E+00
0 10 20 30 40
ACKNOWLEEDGMENT
N
Number of trays Thhe authors woould like to apppreciate Mr. Bolourian froom
Khanngiran Gas Refinery
R for tthe technical information he
Fig. 9. Annuual profit per tray versus number of trays of distillattion prov
vided.
column in NGL3100 case
REFEREENCES
[1] S. Mokhatab, W. A. Poe, and J. G. Speight, Handbook of Natural Gas
V. PROCEESS SELECTION
N Transmission and Processing, Gulf professional publishing, 2006.
[2] J. Campbell, “Gas conditioning and processing,” Campbell Petroleum
We saw that the multistagee flash vaporizzation is a praactical Series, 8th ed., vol. 2, 2004.
m
method to stabiilize the condeensate in Khanngiran case, as
a it is [3] J. Benoy and R. N. Kale, “Condensate stabilization,” Offshore World,
allready utilizedd in the aforem mentioned gas processing plant.
p pp. 34-37, August 2010.
[4] Aspen HYSYS: Simulation Basis, Aspen technology inc., version 7.1,
H
However, in NGL3100
N casse, it doesn’tt sound prom mising 2009.
coonsidering thee low condenssate recovery and high totall heat [5] W. D. Seider, J. D. Seader, D. R. Lewin, and S. Widagdo, Product and
duuty. Capital costs of thhe process equipments e a
aside, Process Design Principles: Synthesis, Analysis, and Evaluation, John
Wiley, 2rd ed., 2004.
m
multistage flassh vaporizatioon is more suitable thann the
fractionation inn terms of totaal heat duty annd the flow raate of
stabilized conddensate (or condensate to t feed ratioo) in
K
Khangiran casee. However, inn NGL3100 caase, it is clear from
taable III that frractionation iss far better thaan flashing sinnce it
prrovides more condensate reecovery, less heat h duty, andd H2S
coontent within the standard range.
r It seem
ms that RVP of o the
feeed has a greatt effect on the performance
p o stabilizationn unit
of
w
which, in thesee cases, were 155.7 psia annd 235.9 psiaa. We
shhould take this fact into acccount that disstillation colum mn is Navid Moghadam was born in Iran. He got his BSc
fuurther capable of handling variations in thhe feed composition in chemical engineering from the Iranian University
(wwhich affects itsi RVP). H2S content is higgh in both methods of Science and Technology (IUST), Tehran, Iran in
inn Khangiran casec and mustt be reduced to standard values
v 2006 and his MSc in chemical engineering from
Tarbiat Modares University (TMU), Tehran, Iran in
(ee.g. less than 50
5 ppm). 2009. He is a lecturer and department executive
officer at Hakim Sabzevari University (HSU),
Sabzevar, Iran since 2010. He had some part time jobs
VI. CONCLUSION
O as a chemical process engineer and also a chemical
engineering tutor before his employment as a faculty member at HSU. He
In the preseent study, tw wo methods of o multistage flash has taught several courses in chemical engineering such as Thermodynamics
vaaporization and non-rrefluxed fraactionation were I & II, chemical reactions engineering, numerical computations, chemical
engineering software etc. His research interests include chemical and
innvestigated to stabilize gas condensate
c byy reducing its RVP
biochemical processes design, simulation, and improvement; and energy and
too 10 psia in sum
mmer. Gas coondensates of two t gas proceessing environment.
pllants were studdied. Results show that deppending on thee feed
prroperties (esppecially its RVP) one or both off the
afforementionedd techniques iss/are applicablle and/or econnomic.
Inn Khangiran caase (RVP and GCR of the feeed were 155.77 psia
annd 179 respecttively), multisstage flashing provides lesss total
heeat duty, morre condensate recovery andd less H2S coontent
w
which makes it more interesting. In NGL3100 case (RVP P and Masoud Samadi was born in Iran. He obtained his
G
GCR of the feeed were 2355.9 psia and 251 respectivvely), BSc in chemical engineering from University of
fractionation yields
y less tottal heat duty and much higher
h Guilan, Rasht, Iran in 2007 and his MSc in chemical
engineering from the Iranian University of Science
coondensate reccovery. It is also capable of loweringg H2S and Technology (IUST), Tehran, Iran in 2009. He is a
cooncentration too less than 1 ppm. Therefoore, fractionatiion is lecturer at Hakim Sabzevari University (HSU),
hiighly preferrred. Calculatiions made to t determinee the Sabzevar, Iran since 2010. He was working as a
sppecifications of
o distillation columns and flash separatoors as chemical process engineer before his employment as a
faculty member at HSU. He has taught multiple
foollows: a non-refluxed trayyed distillation column witth 31 courses in chemical engineering like heat and mass transfer, process control,
stages (30 trayss), 3.07 ft in diameter, andd 54 ft in heigght in petroleum refinery principles etc. His research interests include transport
N
NGL3100 case; and a similaar type of coluumn with 13 stages
s phenomena, CFD, and renewable energies.
465