Georgetown University Law Center

Scholarship @ GEORGETOWN LAW

2010

Constitutionalism: A Skeptical View

Jeremy Waldron
New York University School of Law, jeremy.waldron@nyu.edu

This paper can be downloaded free of charge from:

http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/hartlecture/4

This open-access article is brought to you by the Georgetown Law Library. Posted with permission of the author.
Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/hartlecture

Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, and the Jurisprudence Commons


 
  




 

        


   

  
     


 
 ! 
  " 
 #   "
$ 
 

 $ 
 

  $  % 


&'  "    

 "$ 
 (
 " "  

 

    "  "  
)

     !
 

"
* 
 
"    

" +    
      
   

,
 

   
* -".  .

*
  
  +  
 $. 

/#,
0
 
  
%* . 
 . $)112'$)34%
5!


'
)   
  , 

$ 
$. 0,

%  
$!

$
263'$78
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1722771
9  


   $ 

 $(      8:
 #
#    # 
 
$7

    ;,

.        *  "
 " ". 
 


  
 "


 
 
    <
,(  

 =

 " 
 "

 
6$
  

  
 
   
     "  " 
 

" " 
  
  3&    4   > 
   

$&

"" 
 " " 
  

8*9?.:@,**;*:@#A,:B#?C.#@,*#*?,%-"?.  .

9  )11D'; E$)11D
7#
C# $ 
  $64,FC#.;,?AC?0)34
%)114' )32
6A  !,
$
  !"# $ $
18@;AC2)8
%)112'$ GG
3%-   
'
4.,
)114 )1169   


Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1722771

 
 "  

$ 5 


" %    '

#
 
  $
,H 
( 
   
  ,

$




/5/
 
 
 
   "   


. 





    "   $

 
D
*%&$ 
$    "
"$   /I J 
 
 
2# 
  
  
  


     
 
 
. 


"    
,
 

  &   $  

D.
&   D4*+AC
818
*+ A C $)112,H $#  "$KL #
. 
K" <*. 
K" K?,-@@-#.:@,**;*:@H
:B#C.9*?.*,#@K!;AK?C,
B A 
 "  
      

81D
2%&$ 

 $*  "  
D4
K 
*
)@$
* L " . 
  

 
DD2*
2B
2M)*"  "  
.  

8
(  $      (  "
  
 

% &   '
 

, "  H%'  

 
  
     %' 
" 
      
$  
  
 "   "

 ? "

 &
  
   "   # &
 (

 
   
"


1:    $  $
 

    

   $ 
   


  
5 
 " C", &   
 
 $

  + 
%'H
  
    

"  $"   
" 

  

: $  
  
 "  " N" 

1#0K.?F$@*C:K;.*:@*:*9?,*;KF:B*9?A#:B*9?.:@,**;*:@$?"
 
2
6%  
HA.
$
2D)'$8D3$ 
 
    #
      O 

 
  
; , $O 
;     
 
? "



C:-?C,.C;*:@$#K.*:@#CF:BE:A*.#A*9:;-9*%A  H 


2D)'$27

7
     

   


$+ 
$  
% 
 
  
'$
)   

  " 

 ""   "


K  % '? "
 # 
 
$"   
 
 
    

 " 

"     ,

 
%

'   %

+  (

"
  
; , '!  "

 

   "  
  
 
$    $   $

? "
 "     
 
  /@$
/
$  $ 
     
  
"   



( )*   

 


)# 
$ *    

 * 
9 !  $C *%. "H. "; E$
223'$.
D
)3

6
!  
  E "  
 
"      $ 
       

 
 "
 "  
 +$+$ 
( $
    "$  
8
,!  
    (  
#  #
  
(+   
:   $      
      
   
"    
  

 

   
7
# "
 "$" 
 " 
   $
  
   
  " "
   
$!  
 
   " "    

 
 $  &  
    #
+ 9 
 
  "  "'   

8.#
$$!0HI J  " N     $ 
  "  "O

7!  E 
 " 

$*.  . 

A 
? $  (! $81%
227'612$ 6
1H!  $ $ 
   $    / 
"
   

"
 "  
O   
 "
P 

"  
 

$       
 
   $  


  Q 
$& 
 Q  &

3
   
 $
OO  

  

 
 """  
  
$   


      
6

  "  

"    

  


   

+
 
 

 

     <
      5  
% '     


 
    "
  
 <*;L
 
"+    $ !


C"
3D2$#;  
414$? 
. #
24
$9 C"#
22D$ 
 C   E
#
2
D)111
      "
 $   
 

   
       " " &
    "  
  "

6#
+ 9 
 $  $    $' $-"
.   A

%  
HAB $)11
'$

4

$  "  
( * 
 

  )  
!) *

I#J

     

 
  "   
    

  $  > 

"  $   
"
" 
  * 

  
    O
3

:  $ 


 " * 5  
   
 "   

"
 $
@R
.  #
2D3:
 
 " 
   $



"
$
,.  
283: 
 $(

"
  "
"  

  "
   
 
   ,? . "+ , 
4
 #  
 
 
? "

   

3   6;,
84%
D18'$ 
44

4"+ , D.C

7%.. E
 I
3
1J'H#   O 
   $ 


 
  
  $  ("

H    
   "   "   $" $

$ 


 
$  (" 
O

D
     
" 
   "
"    
 
   
   :  
 9 
 & 
  H. 
 " 
   "   
"   
D: 
 " # 
"         
   #
+ 9 
       
" 
 
2!  
  

  " 

!  $ 
  

 5 :
 

H 
  5 

    

 

  
9 #   $ # $ 
  .    "


 $

D
 99 
 $
 $ 7?@.F.A:E?K#:B*9?,:.#A,.?@.?,)66
%? ,
"  #
   $
28
'$ C ,L $ 

 $ .:@,**;*:@#A,HE9A:,:E9.#AB:;@K#*:@,
3%A #
+ 
$
22D' 
3

2B  $B?K?C#A,*S7DH

  $ $

    $   "  $ 
    "     "<*  
   


 
#   !
+  $     " 
    
 >     
  
$ "  
$
"  B9 
 $B?K?C#A,*S48H* 

"
    "$  $
  $  
 ""        

      $ 
     
  "  
   $    ,

B?K?C#A,*S)1$  
     !
"
   
2
   
( "$$$ 

    "
   

     $O

   (  $



)1

*  


   

 "   "   #


 
       " 

" 

* &
    " "
   ;L  $$
  $   $   "
   
H(5   
 "
  &" N 
      
          
   " (  
>  K
   

  
+   
 %  

 ' /  +$   $
     ")

  > 
  

!
   

)19 # $(!%9  HE " !$
248'$
64

)
  " +

" 

 
 $   $
%:+H.
  E$
222'$325D4

1
 B$    5 
 
 

 $   
+
   :  +   $
   "   
 $
 "  5 + "  
 
 "        

  

  ))#
$    
 

$
 (" 

 

   5 "   
$      
 "  > 
  $  $     $
  "  
, 
$   ( 

  +

   

 " $ 
  

 $!
  $@
  ""B 
5
 
$


 # $

    $
 > /  B  
 
:      

))%B+ 
$   "# 
  
"
   
 
  $ 

  " " "

  <'

B$
 + 
  


" " 5  


    
 *  
"   5 *   
  "
     % '; L " 
  $  
        
    $"   
 " 
      
 "
" $   " "  $  
 
 % & ' A L "


 5 5 # 

# 

+
  

    
  "   "    &
  
    
  
B & +   
   
  "

,
 


       


";
$ $C
A $ 
 (
    

)
" )8  

 "$
 "$    "
 @  
 

  
,- & (



$ *
 

 # T, (V 
$-!*
.
 )7  , (V&$
, 9
 IJ   "    "
      *   



  " 

 
  

)6*   
. ,    
"  ( 
  
   
)3!"
"  " 
  

 $  "

.9
  $ 
   
>
H

"

   "  )4

)8.A AB

$) 

 $C? %@9  HF
; E$

232'$23
)7,- $
$ *
 

%. "H9  ; E$
222' # T, (V$$-!*
.
 %! H. 
? E$
222'
)6, (V$$+
)3. C,  $. 
 @K
$# !  (! $
1
%
2D4'$
7)
$ 787583
)4.9
  $
  )%  H. 

; E$

271'$)7%>- $$ 6'B$ 
>

   * 
  &  N   . 
B$
 
 W"
N  W "  . 
B$

 -!  
*
  &  86583
%7
23D'

8
 ,H    
  $
 

$
" 
. 
%
"'  ,





 )D*      

   5 "$
5
 "$ 5 "
 
 
 " 
#

 
$"<# &

 

$   
< . 
        
    *
 

"  $

   
  
     
 
    
%  ,- &

. 

 ", '@$  




 /
"  $  "  $ 
 

"  /    * 

  "       


&

"  
*  

 " 
  
  "     "  
 

$  
 &"$


)D@,
$*A
B $  

  $ $  

 /$,
9 %. "H; . "E$
22D'$8

7
"  "    

 



 "  

 $+ 
$   
     

 

 
  
   < & 
C  $  $ 
  "  H
   ""   "   "#
         
    

$

 "     
"  
 ,   
"/ " $ "
  
"
$  *  
 "    
$ 
 "
  

    "  
!    
    &


+
   

B $   
  
$
   *
  
        

   ( "     

6
 . 


"   
  (   
 $  
       "  / 


 "  /   


" *    "

"      
 $


$    *  


    
   
"  & !     
   (
  

 
    
 
$  
  "           
 
  " 
 "
 
  $ 
 




       
""  E


N5  
$
(  + 

"$  
  " 
    
 $      " 
)2

)2.A  !  $. 

.N "E#
 "$ 
 0 $38%)11)'$
)D6$ 
)D4,
K"
,$#E0
!

:C"H*  @. 

$0   ($$
8%
2235D')4$
)2581HI.J 
$   

   
 "   $    
"  # +$
 

   
N  O

3
 # "  +
   
  
$
  $   <,


  $

  

     $
     
"
   
  
! 

$ H 

 
  "  
5
 
   
     


   
 $   
N    
  
$ ">   

(+   
$  $ 

 "
   
 "  

 &

(  "    

   

"  

&    

  "
 
    "$ 
 $>  
  
$"$ 
     
 E
 $

 
"
 

"  $   


  
"  $
 A"
 
"  $( "  
  
5  "
 

+  "   ". + 
 

4
)3.  ,# $> 
   

"
   
"
N  " >  "
"   
"
 
$  "
 
     
 "   
"   
>+  "   

  ""    ,# 
 
 -  81F 
 
  C
A    
  
  "%  )3'$
     
"
>
 
   C
A  C
A 

"
 
"  $ 
"  $   
 "" + 
"  
 "  #      "
   "C
A   
 "
 
BM
!  "  $    "
" +
   "  
"

     "
   

( 
   "   
C
A $ 

" 

81-!(  !-  1223%
',#73%..'

D
>  """
  
"   

"    
 
   $
  
. 
  
 
      
(     +  
8
E H & !
 
"5
 $ 
 H   $
$>*

$ @"
 "
 "/ >$ / 

, $ /  
/ 
 $$ >   
 

   (   

    >  
    " *; 
,   / 
   >  
/ 
     >   
 
     

0 /!"

04
6B)
)11%
2D8'$"E 


 "  IJ !

C"
   "  "



 "8)"E  

8
L $$
2

8)E H

2
"  
  $ 

    
"  
 
 
 "   
 
 >

- )

  $
     
%
"
 
' 
<B H
 
  


  
 (    
 * , 9
 ,! 88 
 

 


       
   
     
    " 
 
"
$
"
  $87 %
'       

    
  


#       

 
  
  
  
 " N     
  $ "    
 
     



88,#! $

  .  
74568%)118'
87.$A "A"


)1
"  $

 
  $
     *     
    $
   
    

  $ 


  
 
 
 
  ( 
     
 
 "  " 
   " ">   
 
   *
             
  ! 

 "+  , (V&$IJ     
IJ   "   

 86
! 

 
 " 
$
  
   $ >


 "    
  # 
N
  


 
 
 
 
 " " 
$  "
 "  % '

5  "

 

86, (V$$)

)

   
 

"
 $
> +  $  

 
 
"
   $   " 
+  $   

B  
$    




H  ( 
 / 
5  "$ 
 " "
 $ 
  "  
"
 
?>

    

   
 % '
"
$+$ ( 

  
 "   " 
+? " "
    

  
! 
     
"H

      "
  


 "

   "


  N    
  "  
    "   
   

            
 / K /     "

 "  +  
 "  

))

"
+83 " 
$   
      $


  $ 
 "  5 
  
 

   
 $

 "  

" 

 
  
 
  "  

5"5"$ 

 



  *  

  
    84        

 
 

 

 "  "

8D
. /
$0
  )

1
     

 $

     "  

 
"   

83.K&        

 
   
"  

HK$$)3D548* 
"
   

    #     ( 
  " %  " 
"

 ( 
  '$"  
    " "    
  
"
!
"
&
  $   
 
   ( "  
 # 
 
 " 
 
"
   " 


 
84B +

       


     $ 
 " $
  
 "  "$, 
  $B "

K $9  A C$
)1%)114'GGG
8D*     

    

9 #  
 $# &. 
E
 K 0

%'

 $
 #  %. "H. "; E$)11
'

)8
    
  $
"H9   "   " 
  (<    

$ 
  $   
+
   


 
<
! >   
  

$>    9

  < 
   <    
>   

%
 
  +$+ 
$
  

"
   
 ("'<9 "


"  <#  

$
  "

> H9 

 

 4 
$    $

  <
 

      

     
     5  5
 "  $

 

  
N $ $
 

$   $  



 " *   

)7
 $  $ 
 "  
   $ 
 

(  " 

* 
.
 
C  "   
? "
  $  " 




  

 

82
  $    
     "    



  " 
#
$  "$!
$>



        $ 
>
 


 
 


   
 "

 
$
   

>
>  
   
 " 

  $ 
  "  
%
'
       
 
#   >
      "  
$ 
 
 
 
  $

82   ".

 
C  "&+
  
374 E HI*J
  
  ? "
  

  "   
$$
 &
    
  "  "   

  "  &&%*K  - 
. 
#$E $
)2:
374$ # , %'&$!%. "H. "
; E$
22D'$
18'
)6
  

>
  
   


  ( 


"
  
 "    


+
     
/ 

   "
%&





>


'H
E

>

H*     


>
$ 
 " 
 "%
"  $+$ $
'$  "
 
 
 
" 



>
$

     

  71
#  "  
5!'

7
 .
" "    "> 
$
B#     
  $

 ,.&    $  
(+  

#
 " B#  
      +

 
 
 $  


>
$ 

71%*
 "  
 #
0%7'
 " $
 "     /B & " 5
  
  /   " !"+$7D;,

%
D72'
7

81,.D43%)1
1'

)3
 
"   

 "  "    #
%)'$

 

7#  $ 

6$
4$
2$ )3#  $ 

 $

 "    " 

 

"
  "+


 "    

  
  
  "$      *

 (  
 "
 
    
   
 "  
"
 
    
 : 
 
  
 "    

  "

 $


 ! "    "    


 $     6

 
 
  $   " 
,$
+ 
$ 

 " 
&
   
     

)4
 (  
7)  " 
  
 $  "   >  (  78
"
 "  
 
 
H


 

  
77   " "  
 "$"      
 "  "@ 

+ ""  @   
 
  "%#  

>    " 


  
 
"'!  "   
   
  


5"  $
  


 

 
+     
 

      "
 
      
"
 &  2$

7)C#, $E

 B
H, .   B
.$

  (! $D4%
222'$
7
6$ 
78D
78,  ,
N@  K 
  $9
:

,
 E ; , H?

, E 
  ; (<
7 !  (! $72%)117'$
 
3
77,$"$A KL $!* 
  0 
(! %@FH:+; E$)117' B 
 $ %#  "'
E"5A
K . 
< 
$7%
222'$
D

,
 * $ /$


%E  HE  
; E$)111'

)D
:      
  

     
   #      
   $    
        
$
     

" /E
O    

.  /     "   
,$+ 
$;,,. )  
!") 
"  
  "
"
 
$"  $ 
 $ 
  $

      "

  (
   

"
 
   ""
 



76
@ 
    
 C !   "">"
 

 
   "   
%  '   73#$
 
   (

76)  
!") 6;,
84%
D18'$ 
43
73,$"$C ?!  $*E
, <.
-"  E

," $280 AC
4)2%)114'
)2
   (74#$   
"

"

  
  ""
 
 "  
"

>
 
 
    5 
    
  
 7DB#  $  
  
 

 " B  +  
/ 
  5
  /  

 " 
" *

 
 

" >  " "
 
    
   
  

"
  
 !   
    " 

   

     

   

 
$ 
"/   
5    # 

$  " "  
"    " 
 
   
 . 
 
5  

5     
   

74A #
+ $. 
C
$. 
,  $ . 

,
 H    . 
, $
 

 
$)1%)118'$832$ 848
7D,A$""$8)2581 86753$ * 9$
!*&$7$
9   %:+H.
  E$
2D8'$84 
8

81
  !   3"  
   
,

 
O   (  
  
$
  
  
  
$    (  
     "    
   
  
5 N

         $ & 

""      &   "
    "    * 
 " "     
 "

 
  $> $   

F & + 
$&

     

   
 " H   
 
 "     $
 N " "$ 

 $    "%"$
  '
 *
     
 $    

 $

 "H  "  

      
 


>
  

"  

8

  
" 

   "   
     72
#  
$    
     "     
   

%'* 

$
    "     /
 /     

 
 
   
  


       

 
%': 
"

$  

"
 
 
 "  ,$ @
R
$ "

@R
!

C"
#/ 
"
     
   
 ( 
221$     (
   @R



 $  
" E 
  $   

# + 
;L9 C"#
22D$" 
72C
K "      " # 
 
$  "   
" 

 

$  "        

 
"   
 4  
5
6 7 %* &
# 
 - 
"  /.  $
+ 
$ ; L "'! " "   $
 " 
 # $  
       
 
  " 

 " "   

8)

   
   
"
 "  H? .    
9 C"%    '
$
; , $  
"


  
 B$
"
  
>    $ 
   
   


 
 "
  
 
  
    (   "  

 %*  
 $"
   


  
 ', 
$ 
    "
 $+



$ "(

 
"
   
 "  
   
     (

$  
 
 
 
(
 
X
%'#
$
   5

 $ 

       
 "  
  ( & 

  " 


"
  
(
*   

 !  $  

 
#
0 K$"     " 


 

88
 " 
 
  %I
J"


$"
 "' 

(
   ""
    
 ". 
   "   %
'" " 

$  

$" 
 
  O:
  $ $ ("5   $ 
   

 $"  $("5

 



  
   

 "
 

      "  $
"  " K 

  
; , !   " $  " 
  " !

C"$   

   "   
    
# 
$  
/
 "    
# 5
!

C" .   
? 

  $" 

!
 

 61

61" 
 
 

  $  
 "  
 "     
$  $" 
    
    

$"   
 
"
        

87
 :L=
 H
"


    

*   
 $ 


 
%'@  
H



 
"
:   $  
  "        
 "
$    
5

   

  
.  .
 E

C"%..EC' 
   
   
-  .   $ 


   
.    "  
*!"      $ 

"
 
   " 

 " 
   "

*  " " 
 
$  $
 ..EC$ 

31  
"
 
  B      $  
      
"
  " 
     * 
 ""   " $ " 

    
    
"     
 %*;,$

86
+ 
$      ..EC&
 "  " '6
! 
 "
   "$  "  


" N   
  * 
      $ (  


  
 H  " 
 "   "
   5
 
  "6):$
 

  /$ /
   

 
  

" (  $ 

 


  " 
@$
 "
 "

 9 "


>
"    
    
 

#
)%)'..EC$+ 
$>
  
"
 "   



 H
6
#
)1%)'  
.  .
 E

C"> I J 
  
$ 

"       $


 



*;,      

"  "$+  .   

; , 

6)% & + "" * 
  $ $..EC
 
% #
)'    & *

  
    &"
  #
7
%
' 
..EC    
   $ 
74  " 
      
#A,*:@#@K,*?@?C$@*?C@#*:@#A9;#@C-9*,@.:@*?Y*
%)111'$482
83
  
 + "
"

 $ , E  . 
     $   
 
O 

     ""
" N  . 

,    #

)%)'

"      " 
 
      
 $ 
 "
", " 5  "!

C"$
   , "  

H+ 
$; , & 5  
   " 

"   
  
.   #"  *
* 
"/
N  / "
    
5

   9& 
+ 
#           
   
   
"  

*   >    

    "   $  
  




 $ 
   "     
  N   
    


84
   "
  
  
 @


     "
* 
 "    
" X# $
 
5

N  

  > 

5
  "    
   

,  " 
5



 $  
   $  

+
   
.
 

 "$-

@  9 C" . 
C"H9  
K 68!     
   
 
" "  
 "

   "5    
 
!#  "  " 

 
67  + 

 " 
 *$    
 "5        
 
 /$  ; , $
  "  " 

68-
A@ $9 C" . 
C"H9   K $66
, AC
D38%)11)5)118',
,E
#
 $#B .  
#
!

C"$ #
 %'EC::*@-9;#@C-9*,*9C:;-9!AA,:B
C-9*,H.:E#C#*0?E?C,E?.*0?,%:;E$
222'
67!# $*C
. 
$D80 AC44
$4425D1%
224'

8D
  

  

# $$
@F;

 "E
#
  $  
  


   "  
 
  "+ " 
5

 $
   
 $(  
  "   
  "

       


66. 


/ 

 
  / 
 
 !  &  

/"

  "/

$ 
  
B
  #  



 "$ 
 /  / 
 &  
  

5
    "
   $
    #"
   

 / 
     /
    !"
* 
   #    "   
         
 $    "   

66%#
 $

'.,?-9#C*$*9?@*?C@#*:@#AA#:B9;#@C-9*,$++

82
    "     
  
@    
   

 "
/ % 
' "/   
  B+ 
$# ?"
#   .  . C" B
$
+ 
$? "
!


C"
3D2 +$
  

  ,


     
   ..EC    



"%
@R
& ,# &'  
* "   
B  "$ 

   

  
   "   

  
N "  
  

  "
N  . 
  
    "    
 +   5  " " "
       
   "  
   + 

5   
  

"  
N     

 
 ( 
 " , 
  

71
 !

    " 

 
/   "  /  "


"$ 



   
"     "5
   $  "     


"$  
5  " 

 = 

5
 $ $
 

5  "  
 
*      ; , 
    " 
  
  " 
 

 ( 
  
5? $    
  5  

      
"   
 "    
   
" " 
 "" 

    "
       
  
   
B 
"
  $  " 
#

 
 "   

" 
 "

   "  "
 
   *   

   "  "  ""

 
   $    

7

 "  
  "       

!!     "  ""

  
 
! 



 "   ? "     "
"    
$
 
 
     




 "   &   5

  "H  $# "  

,
 & !/  $  " $
      
 $  " 
 IJ " 
 .  ; , #   
+  "63# "

   

,.&  (! )116$
( 
 
 $ L  
"
    $ 
   
221; ,  
   "
  
  + "

  
 64? 
 
$ .  QIJ   
"

63* :

 $7D4;,D
6%
2DD'$ D815
%, $.'$D32
%,
 $  "'
64* $E  $, #  $F $@" $KC
. "$ 
. 
7)

 ""  
   "  
( 
 
,
   H  
.P " / # 


 

/"(
 # $
 
$   "  ($
"

  $ 
"
    
. "
 
  
 
" 
"
 
 ? "
 

443,X/ 

  "   " 

      "    
   



   " 
   ,
    "
+

     
  %

  
 .  9

  "  B

 " 
+  $%
  8   !$ 
     " 
  .  ("
  ".    



78
      "  
E

   
6D
#  $  
 
      "  

 "
 +
" $
 
  $ 

    

 "     $ 
  $       
$   

 & $$ 

     
  

H &     
"    &%  
+ 
'
%  
 
'9

 <=&  $ 
*  
   #  
 
#  
$  
  !




     "  
   C   $
    

5  

6D#    "


  "   "/ 


     /  "  
  



$
  
   "  "
 "  $"  
   
77
 #
 


$ H

 /

 
 



 
  "
  
 (     $ 

       & 

 " 
    " 
     

5  % 
   
" '
 " 

"   
"    
 >  
 

"   >

 " "

   
   
*  
    
   $
   

  $ $ " $ 

  <$(

 $
    
 $     "   
 
<&

   <

76