Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Researchpaper
Researchpaper
Researchpaper
A Meta-Analysis of the Pharmacological Effects of LSD and MDMA on PTSD and MDD
Ali Alhafidh
Contents I. Introduction
A Meta-Analysis of the Pharmacological Effects Exposure to traumatic events has been known to
of LSD and MDMA on PTSD and MDD ............ 1 pose a serious risk in inducing mental mood and
Abstract .................................................................. 1 stress disorders such as major depressive disorder
(MDD) and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
I. Introduction ................................................... 1 which can altogether deteriorate the mental and
II. Literature Review .......................................... 3 physical health of patients suffering from them. Pa-
A. LSD General Effects on Empathy, Cognition, tient exposure to stress factors and traumatic events
and Emotion .................................................. 4 are key contributing factors to the initiation of MDD
and/or PTSD which display a function of comorbid-
B. MDMA General Effects on Empathy, ity (can appear together in most cases in that patients
Cognition, and Emotion ................................ 6 exhibit symptoms of both). Although the etiology of
III. Conclusion ...................................................... 7 MDD is less specifically known, it is widely ac-
References .............................................................. 8 cepted that it is related to and shares specific features
to PTSD. The onset of PTSD is usually exposed fol-
lowing certain traumatic life events such as assault,
domestic violence, wartime violence, child abuse,
Abstract and a myriad of other traumatic situations. In the
United States, the lifetime prevalence of PTSD in the
general populace is around 6 to 10% with much
This paper serves as a holistic research and review of higher counts being recorded in countries with en-
pharmacological and biological effects of psychoto- demic warfare and conflict [19]. The comorbid nature
mimetic drugs such as lysergic acid diethylamide of PTSD and MDD has been elucidated in previous
(LSD) and 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine studies—95% of those diagnosed with PTSD also
(MDMA) on relieving stress related issues in patients share symptoms and will be diagnosed with MDD at
suffering from severe trauma or disorders such as some point in their life [3]. High treatment resistance
PTSD as well as mood disorders. Furthermore, phar- towards PTSD and MDD mainly results from recall
macological effects related to changes in stress and of traumatic experiences which is highly associated
prevention as well as treatment will be considered. A with self-harm, induction of anxiety, depression, and
collection of prior research as well as new research substance abuse. In order to alleviate depressive
will comprise the basis of this study to better under- symptoms, a decreased fear response (but not neces-
stand the effectiveness of these drugs on improving sarily decreased emotional response or intensity to-
conditions caused by stress-related issues. The pur- wards the fearful experience) must be generated arti-
pose of this meta-analysis is to demonstrate that the ficially (in this case psychotherapeutic drugs are the
psychotherapeutic nature of LSD and MDMA is pos- topic of discussion) in order to facilitate patient-ther-
itive and effective. apist communication and empathic connection. In
this way, traumatic experiences can be revisited and
worked on and potentially resolved over time.
2
These specific disorders are primarily and often pharmacological therapeutic drugs have been ap-
associated with serotonergic systems (the 5-HT re- proved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
ceptor family) and modulation of these receptors and for PTSD treatment, one of them being Zoloft ® (ser-
their ligands (serotonin or 5-HT, 5-hydroxytrypta- traline) which has marked chronic effects on seroto-
mine) through pharmacological substrates has been nin levels and like other antidepressants has a highly
known to induce positive behavioral effects through addictive nature.
various downstream effects further discussed in the Although research on LSD has been greatly lim-
body of this paper. Exposure to chronic stress or trau- ited by federal regulations marking the drug as
matic events can cause deregulation and impairment Schedule I, its effects have been widely noted, expe-
of serotonin neurotransmission. Pharmacological ap- rienced, and worked with in the lab for many years.
plication of drugs which modulate the 5-HT system The research compiled in this paper serves to analyze
such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors the various effects of LSD and MDMA on PTSD and
(SSRIs) have been seen to positively correlate with MDD and how they might serve as a better alterna-
treatment of both PTSD and MDD and therefore tive to psychotherapy and opioids as treatments.
speaks to the similarity of the mechanisms which In order to understand how drugs such as LSD
cause them. Because psychotomimetic drugs such as and MDMA might alter or better the effects of stress-
LSD and MDMA are known to primarily affect the related disorders, proper knowledge and citation of
serotonergic system it is believed that they can be a prior pharmacological knowledge, such as but not
safer alternative to medicines such as opioids and limited to, receptor-ligand interaction and down-
other anti-depressant drugs which have numerous stream effects of those connections as well as side
side effects and addictive properties of their own effects and the biological nature and health of the pa-
which can easily associate with the substance abuse tient (which will not be taken into account in this
characteristics of patients suffering from PTSD and study). By connecting various research topics from
MDD. In the U.S. market, only two conventional prior literature to the topic at hand, hopefully a better
Figure 1 - Model of serotonergic (5-HT; green arrow), neurogenic (blue arrow), and behavioral effects of stress.
Acute stress (leading left of “STRESS”) increases dorsal raphe (DR) 5-HT firing. Chronic stress resulting from
PTSD and MDD leads to monoaminergic changes (solid box), decreased neurogenesis, and decreased general 5-HT
firing in the dorsal raphe nuclei (DR). Image reproduced from Mahar, I., et al. [21]
3
Figure 4 – In this figure effects on mental states of patients (researchers used the Visual Analog Scale [VAS]) administered LSD
(100µg and 200µg doses) vs placebo doses of the same quantity are compared. These tests were taken about 3-4 hours post-admin-
istration at or around the “plateau phase” in order to mediate patient response and to receive proper data while patients were under the
effect of LSD. According to the VAS all patients actually administered LSD demonstrated increased ratings across the board, however
ratings for ‘Fear’ did not increase that much past control. Figure reproduced from Dolder, et al. [8]
downstream effects) which is neurologically associ- stress-affected 5-HT system without adversely af-
ated to patients with mood disorders and PTSD [16]. fecting a patient’s physical health. The biological and
Chronic stress results in structural changes in brain mental interactions of each drug will be analyzed in-
plasticity (largely reversible by proper psychother- dividually.
apy or pharmacotherapy) due to deregulatory effects
on the 5-HT system (such as that in the hippocampus) A. LSD General Effects on Empathy,
and also negatively impacts hippocampal neurogen- Cognition, and Emotion
esis [21]. These effects can be reversed by application
of SSRIs to reduce reuptake of serotonin as well as LSD acts a partial 5-HT1A and 5-HT2A receptor
various other antidepressants but their efficacy has agonist and the psychedelic effects are controlled by
been shown to be weak to moderate due to patient 5-HT2A receptor stimulatory effects [38]. Its selective
relapse and environmental and mental factors caus- binding to 5-HT2A receptors results in consistent fir-
ing an up-regulation in depression. Also, antidepres- ing of the receptor for many hours due to a strong
sants are largely addictive by nature and can exacer- binding affinity of the ligand to the receptor. It spe-
bate acute and chronic stress effects of PTSD or cifically inhibits firing of the 5-HT1A receptor class
MDD rather than help them [36]. The interactions of as well. This makes LSD a partial agonist because it
drugs such as LSD and MDMA with the 5-HT sys- can modulate its own effects (positive and inhibitory
tem can possibly help in the process of rehabilitation regulation). LSD binds to these receptor classes and
in patients suffering from PTSD and MDD by alter- induces long-lasting (8-10 hours or longer) effects
ing the excitability and inhibitory effects of a chronic such as hallucinogenic visuals, increased somatosen-
sory sensation, and a general elevation in mood and
5
pation of some threat or danger. Nine patients re- sive symptoms, increased sentiment of unity and in-
ceived doses of LSD at 200 µg and were evaluated terpersonal closeness without intense psychedelic ef-
for their STAI trait scores Fig 5. Patients showed high fects comprise the basis of MDMA as a well-suited
levels of state and trait anxiety during baseline but PTSD/MDD therapy agent [7].
exhibited highly decreased scores by the end of the There are several possible mechanisms of func-
study and a sustained decrease in STAI scores even tion for MDMA in psychotherapy. For a drug like
after one year during follow-up studies [12]. First, this MDMA to be effective in therapy, drug exposure
indicates that LSD is capable of a reduction in state must be followed up with therapeutic emotional en-
anxiety which reflects reduced immediate reaction gagement between the therapist and patient and/or
towards traumatic or anxiety-inducing experiences. ‘fear activation’ of prior trauma must be carefully
Second, lowered trait anxiety reflects that patients presented without causing overwhelming emotions
experienced reduced tendencies to react with anxiety to arise [11]. Prior research has defined the degree of
and high emotional tension when dealing with past proper emotional engagement with the patient as a
traumatic experience even when those situations are ‘window of tolerance’. Because patients diagnosed
not readily present. Moreover, state and trait anxiety
demonstrated greatly similar reductions signifying
LSDs shared effects on both forms of anxiety in pa-
tients and possibly shared properties between the two
forms of anxiety themselves.
with PTSD and MDD suffer from emotional numb- stage 1 non-placebo patients initially administered
ing and extreme anxiety attacks, they naturally have full doses of MDMA [24].
a small window in which they are between the
thresholds for under and over-arousal [26]. MDMA III. Conclusion
may establish its therapeutic effects by broadening
this window of therapy and allowing patients to re- By analyzing prior and current data on LSD and
main emotionally engaged without having anxiety MDMA, it is undeniable that these drugs can serve
overpower them while revisiting past trauma. Also, as therapeutic aids in helping treat PTSD and MDD.
increased oxytocin post-MDMA intake has been Deficiencies in the 5-HT serotonergic system is
noted to increase sociability, excitability, and interest closely tied to these stress disorders, and the ability
in communication with other persons [10]. of LSD and MDMA to modulate the 5-HT system
A proposed ‘neurocircuitry’ model for PTSD actively and safely (from a physical standpoint)
suggests that there is a deficit in the extinction of fear demonstrates their useful function in therapeutics.
conditioning mediated by the amygdala and the ven- However, LSD research and usage is heavily moni-
tral/medial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) [30]. A human tored and regulated due to its drug scheduling in the
Positron Emission Tomography (PET) test con- United States and other areas. Because of this, con-
ducted by Mithoefer et al. about 75 min. following trolled patient studies are difficult to conduct and
MDMA administration to test subjects showed an in- sparse. Regardless, quite a bit of information is
crease in cerebral blood flow to the ventromedial known about the neurophysiological effects of LSD
frontal and occipital cortices and a decrease to the and countless experience reports have been docu-
left portion of the amygdala [24]. MDMA may instill mented. Given that LSD has very few lasting side ef-
some of its therapeutic effects by affecting brain fects even shortly after administration, LSD can be
plasticity through a reversal of negative abnormali- an especially effective as a therapy agent even with
ties caused by intense trauma; this would also aid in its characteristically psychedelic qualities and long
allowing for more effective processing and commu- duration of effect. On the other hand, MDMA pre-
nication during therapy sessions. sents its therapeutic qualities on a shorter time scale
To specifically diagnose for levels of chronic which is far easier for therapists to handle from a
PTSD treatment-resistant symptoms, DSM-V-R cri- time perspective during extended therapy sessions.
teria utilizes a Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale Also, MDMA does not provide an intense psyche-
(CAPS score) which consists of questions held dur- delic experience which many users (especially for
ing a therapist and patient interview and defines a their first time) might be averse to especially given
score of ≥50 as moderate to severe and scores <40 as their high stress and high anxiety states. Because of
moderate to low. The MDMA study on twenty pa- this, it can be argued that MDMA may not neces-
tients conducted by Mithoefer, et al. defined a >30% sarily be more effective at reducing depression, stress
reduction from baseline CAPS scores as a clinical re- and anxiety compared to LSD, but may be more ef-
sponse to the drug Fig 6. In a double blind test con- ficient and reliable in doing so with a broader collec-
ducted as a preliminary stage of testing, the clinical tion of patients. Essentially, LSD and MDMA should
response was found to be 83.3% for MDMA admin- be used specifically and thoughtfully depending on
istered patients (10 out of 12 patients responded with each patient’s specific situation and needs in order to
greatly lowered CAPS severity scored) compared to maximize psychotherapeutics for patients suffering
25% in the placebo group (2 out of 8 people showed from PTSD and MDD.
lower CAPS severity scores but not nearly as de-
creased as those given MDMA). In stage 2 of the
study, seven of the eight placebo subjects chose to
participate in a crossover test in which they were
given MDMA and CAPS severity scores were re-
tested for. Significant decreases in CAPS scores
were identified and were of similar magnitude to
8
[19] Kessler RC, Chiu WT, Demler O, Merikangas [28] Passie, T., Halpern, J. H., Stichtenoth, D. O.,
KR and Walters EE (2005) Prevalence, severity, and Emrich, H. M. and Hintzen, A. (2008), The Pharma-
comorbidity of 12-month DSMIV disorders in the cology of Lysergic Acid Diethylamide: A Review.
National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen CNS Neuroscience & Therapeutics, 14: 295-314.
Psychiatry 62: 617–627.
[29] Payne, J. D., Nadel, L., Britton, W. B., & Jacobs,
[20] Lazarus, R. S. (I 991). Emotion and adaptation. W. J. (2004). The Biopsychology of Trauma and
London: Oxford University Press. Memory.
[21] Mahar, I., et al., Stress, serotonin, and hippo- [30] Rauch SL, Shin LM and Phelps EA (2006) Neu-
campal neurogenesis in relation to depression and rocircuitry models of posttraumatic stress disorder
antidepressant effects. Neuroscience Biobehavioral and extinction: human neuroimaging research – past,
Review (2013) present, and future. Biol. Psychiatry 60: 376–382.
[22] Marks, I., Lovell, K., Noshirvani, H., Livanou, [31] Schmid Y, Enzler F, Gasser P, Grouzmann E,
M., & Thrasher, S. (1998). Treatment of posttrau- Preller KH, Vollenweider FX et al (2015). Acute ef-
matic stress disorder by exposure and/or cognitive fects of lysergic acid diethylamide in healthy sub-
restructuring: A controlled study. Archives of general jects. Biol. Psychiatry 78(8): 544–553.
psychiatry, 55(4), 317-325.
[32] Sessa, B. (2011). Could MDMA be useful in the
[23] Miller, N. S., & Gold, M. S. (1994). LSD and treatment of post‐traumatic stress disorder?. Pro-
ecstasy: Pharmacology, phenomenology, and treat- gress in Neurology and Psychiatry, 15(6), 4-7.
ment. Psychiatric Annals, 24(3), 131-133.
[33] Sessa, B. (2017). MDMA and PTSD treatment:
[24] Mithoefer, M. C., Wagner, M. T., Mithoefer, A. “PTSD: From novel pathophysiology to innovative
T., Jerome, L., & Doblin, R. (2011). The safety and therapeutics”. Neuroscience letters, 649, 176-180.
efficacy of±3, 4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine-
assisted psychotherapy in subjects with chronic, [34] Southwick, S. M., Krystal, J. H., Bremner, J. D.,
treatment-resistant posttraumatic stress disorder: the Morgan, C. 3., Nicolaou, A. L., Nagy, L. M., ... &
first randomized controlled pilot study. Journal of Charney, D. S. (1997). Noradrenergic and sero-
Psychopharmacology, 25(4), 439-452. tonergic function in posttraumatic stress disorder. Ar-
chives of general psychiatry, 54(8), 749-758.
[25] Oehen, P., Traber, R., Widmer, V., & Schnyder,
U. (2013). A randomized, controlled pilot study of [35] Spielberger, C. D. (1972). Anxiety: Current
MDMA (±3, 4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine)- trends in theory and research: I. New York, N.Y.: Ac-
assisted psychotherapy for treatment of resistant, ademic Press.
chronic post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Jour-
nal of Psychopharmacology, 27(1), 40-52. [36] Stein, M. B., Jang, K. L., Taylor, S., Vernon, P.
A., & Livesley, W. J. (2002). Genetic and environ-
[26] Ogden PKM and Pain C (2006) Trauma and the mental influences on trauma exposure and posttrau-
body. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Company. matic stress disorder symptoms: a twin study. Amer-
ican Journal of Psychiatry, 159(10), 1675-1681.
[27] Olivier, J.D., Van Der Hart, M.G., Van Swelm,
R.P., Dederen, P.J., Homberg, J.R., Cre-mers, T., [37] Van Etten, M. L., & Taylor, S. (1998). Compar-
Deen, P.M., Cuppen, E., Cools, A.R., Ellenbroek, ative efficacy of treatments for post‐traumatic stress
B.A., 2008. A study of inmale and female 5-HT disorder: A meta‐analysis. Clinical Psychology &
transporter knockout rats: an animal model for anxi- Psychotherapy: An International Journal of Theory
ety and depression disorders. Neuroscience 152, and Practice, 5(3), 126-144.
573–584.
10