Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pip Assignment
Pip Assignment
Pip Assignment
EFFECTIVE QUESTIONING
The objective of this Professional Inquiry Project was to focus on how I could utilise
rationale for this focus was chosen after a self-review of my pre-service teaching
The Year 5 and Year 6 description in The Australian Curriculum identifies Literacy as
one of the three strands of English that is used for ‘developing students’ knowledge,
understanding and skills in listening, reading, viewing, speaking, writing and creating’
(ACARA 2018). Literature argues that ‘effective questioning can support students’
curiosity and active engagement with learning because they are able to express their
thinking from various viewpoints’ (Baker 2014, p.63). Using effective questioning can
(Baker 2014, p. 53). Being able to utilise effective questioning to engage and scaffold
all teachers.
1
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
The R-7, Index 6 public Primary School had 389 students. (Department for Education
and Child Development 2018). The classroom was a composite year 5/6 class with 29
students. Three students had Negotiated Education Plans. There was one ESL
student. After observation and discussion, there were many levels of literacy ability.
The Literacy unit of work was to research, write and publish an Information Report.
Through a series of lessons students would learn the structure and features of an
Information Report in order to produce their own. From the Australian Curriculum area
of English the content descriptions of Literacy to guide this unit of work were:
Identify and explain characteristic text structures and language features used in
imaginative, informative and persuasive tests to meet the purpose of the text.
Analyse how text structures and language features work together to meet the purpose
of a text (ACELY1711).
To establish the data required I researched the structure and features of an information
report, with reference to The Australian Curriculum. I then determined the learning
outcomes for each lesson. Research argues that ‘Teachers who are able to organize
2
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
scaffolding questions that are not too easy nor too difficult can assist the child in
constructing knowledge and facilitate learning’ (Baker 2014, p. 52). Using this I
established questions I would ask in order to engage and scaffold students in the
response to student questions. This critical reflection would also record areas for
The second was teacher observation; using an observation sheet to record the types
The third was student reflection by using thumbs up/ down/ sideways to check for
engagement and understanding, that I would record on a checklist. I would use this to
3
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
The data collected from teacher observations shows that I asked an average of 15
questions during a literacy lesson. Keeping a tally of the types of questions I was
asking; open-ended, whole class, group or individual, was difficult for the teacher to
continually observe. Therefore the data is not a true reflection of the amount or types
techniques- usually to focus and extend the focus- whole class and at group level’. My
reflection after each lesson shows that I felt I had asked many.
the students answers when they answer a question, this has taken some time for me
to get used to doing. I ask for several answers, so students see there are many
answers’. The observing teacher said ‘your questions became more targeted, clear
and gained extended responses as the students worked with the focus of the lesson’
and ‘you were more effective at building upon students answers when discussing at
group or individual times’. The unit of work became more individually focused as the
students began their Information report, this meant my questioning did as well, this
was not my initial intention. ‘Today I was able to speak with students individually to
see how they were progressing, it is clear that some students are struggling with
writing their introductions- this can be a focus for the start of tomorrows lesson’ The
impact of individual questioning was that I was able to scaffold and really identify the
areas individuals needed help. I could also identify the need to regroup as a whole
4
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
The data from the teacher observations shows questioning for student engagement
varied between being effective and ineffective. ‘Engagement noticeable in whole class
work, group work at times some students attending to ‘other business’ if finished or
not engaged with the task’. The student observations that I completed showed that
many students did ‘appear’ engaged, however when they were given an individual
task they appeared to not understand what they were meant to do.
The teacher observed (Melissa) ‘used a range of techniques- soft and loud-
language used’. My personal reflections also noted ‘I feel as though I can tell by the
students faces as to whether or not they have understood my questions. If they haven’t
In my reflections I had noted ‘When I ask a question, using wait time is really working
well, more and more students are raising their hands- not just the same ones, some
students who have never had a say in the class are starting to!’. I had also noted ‘Now
that I know the students better I feel as though I know how long I need to wait when
they are answering a question before I ask them if they want me to go to somebody
else’.
Initially data was collected from students using thumbs up/ down/ sideways, however
the use of this and my reflection soon identified it as ‘not a great technique to collect
data on questioning’. After discussing this method with my critical friend I established
that this is best used to gain an insight into whether they are understanding what they
5
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
observation; looking for listening, responding, participating and then question students
individually during task completion. I changed this for the next lesson and found
‘personally observing student engagement today worked well for me - will continue’.
This was a positive change in my inquiry as I felt I was more aware of students being
engaged or not. When I felt students were not engaged I utilised questioning to find
out whether I needed to explain or scaffold further. Most of these students were of
lower ability, however I ensured that ‘low achieving students are asked complex
questions at the same rate and depth as high achieving students’ (Baker 2014, p. 31).
Reflection:
During the unit I was able to collected data to improve the effectiveness of my
specific to the focus. Overall my inquiry focus was important to examine how I
et.al, 2011). I recognise that my focus was too wide and I should have focused on one
type of questioning. However from the data and my analysis I can identify the areas
where I need to improve my future practice. I recognise that there were areas of
content, that I did not have enough knowledge to extend student answers with
evidence’ (Baker 2014, p.17). I also found that student responses to some learning
experiences were not what I had expected and therefore could not find the right
6
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
encouraged me to ‘include specific questions that re-emphasise the key focus of the
lesson, so all students can feel confident to know what they are learning about’. My
the learning content, I will continue to work on this area. I feel positive about my growth
in this area and feel that my use of individual and small group questioning is effective.
I could see the positive impact of using wait time for answers and will continue to use
this.
Conclusion
The inquiry focus has given me an awareness of my teaching behaviour. I have learnt
the importance of knowing the content I am teaching and how brainstorming the way
students may respond to your questions can prepare you for having an effective
answer or question to respond with. I will continue my research and practice of whole
7
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
Appendix
8
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
9
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
10
Professional Experience 4; Teacher as Inquirer SP5 2018 Melissa Hylan
Professional Inquiry Project 110137261
References
Ciardiello, AV 1998, Did You Ask a Good Question Today? Alternative Cognitive and
Metacognitive Strategies, Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, vol. 42, no. 3, pp.
210-219.
11