E 69000000000 N load N unloaded axial stress analytical a

ratio 0.33 a 2.46 0.37 67.000182857 69.10695

fc 0.00061792 b 3.72 0.35 108.03378767 111.4308
fc - analyti 0.00063735 c 1.71 0 54.818331429 56.54205
fc test 2 2.439418E-05 d 1.28 0.38 28.851753383 29.75897
e 2.57 0.5 66.359032782 68.44564
f 2 0.5 48.086255639 49.59829
g 1.77 0.5 40.713029774 41.99322
h 1.74 0.5 39.751304662 41.00125
wrong

r (mm) r (m) a theta sigma (Mpsigma 2 sigma 1

e 3.5 0.0035 0.0036 4.712389 12.6754 -1.165853834 40.66137
f 4.8 0.0048 4.6790050781 22.25622
g 5.98 0.00598 4.3933485941 17.46949
h 7.6 0.0076 3.3088842781 15.05465

Difference in Principal Stresses as a function of Distance from r=a

40

35

30

25
σ1-σ2 (MPa)

Ki rs ch Sol ution
20
Fi ni te El ement Method

15

10

0
0 5 10 15 20 25

Distance from r=a (mm)

 %error test 2
3.04856 2.645026
3.04856 4.264946
3.04856 2.164112
3.04856 1.139006
3.04856 2.619714
3.04856 1.898344
3.04856 1.607264
3.04856 1.569298
wrong

kirsch kirsch full r-a r sigma 1 sigma 2 kirsch full Middle Prin
41.82722 0 0.0036 38.0262 0 38.0262 2.53E+06
17.57721 4.43E-04 0.004043 29.65667 3.121291 26.53538 3.11E+06
13.07614 8.85E-04 0.004485 24.64746 4.358102 20.28936 3.68E+06
11.74576 1.33E-03 0.004928 4.731763 #VALUE! 4.26E+06
1.77E-03 0.005371 19.36089 4.704383 14.6565 4.83E+06
2.21E-03 0.005814 17.90155 4.495085 13.40646 4.64E+06
2.66E-03 0.006256 16.85852 4.211005 12.64752 4.28E+06
3.10E-03 0.006699 16.09138 3.905122 12.18626 3.90E+06
3.54E-03 0.007142 15.5134 3.603598 11.9098 3.67E+06
3.98E-03 0.007584 15.0684 3.318552 11.74985 3.35E+06
4.43E-03 0.008027 14.71931 3.055019 11.66429 3.03E+06
4.87E-03 0.00847 14.4409 2.81434 11.62656 2.83E+06
5.31E-03 0.008913 14.21557 2.595989 11.61959 2.63E+06
5.76E-03 0.009355 14.03081 2.398558 11.63225 2.42E+06
6.20E-03 0.009798 13.87752 2.220277 11.65724 2.25E+06
6.64E-03 0.010241 13.749 2.059295 11.68971 2.06E+06
7.08E-03 0.010683 13.64021 1.913817 11.7264 1.89E+06
Ki rs ch Sol ution 7.53E-03 0.011126 13.54733 1.782177 11.76515 1.76E+06
Fi ni te El ement Method
7.97E-03 0.011569 13.46741 1.662859 11.80455 1.63E+06
8.41E-03 0.012012 13.39812 1.554487 11.84363 1.51E+06
8.85E-03 0.012454 13.33769 1.455903 11.88178 1.39E+06
9.30E-03 0.012897 13.28465 1.36602 11.91863 1.29E+06
9.74E-03 0.01334 13.23784 1.283899 11.95394 1.20E+06
1.02E-02 0.013782 13.19634 1.208765 11.98758 1.10E+06
1.06E-02 0.014225 13.1593 1.139744 12.01956 1.03E+06
25 1.11E-02 0.014668 13.12615 1.076303 12.04985 9.46E+05
1.15E-02 0.01511 13.09642 1.018003 12.07842 8.62E+05
1.20E-02 0.015553 13.06953 0.964084 12.10545 7.97E+05
1.24E-02 0.015996 13.04518 0.914242 12.13094 7.22E+05
1.28E-02 0.016439 13.02307 0.868088 12.15498 6.38E+05
1.33E-02 0.016881 13.00296 0.825367 12.17759 5.53E+05
1.37E-02 0.017324 12.98453 0.78558 12.19895 4.87E+05
1.42E-02 0.017767 12.96765 0.748554 12.2191 4.37E+05
1.46E-02 0.018209 12.95217 0.714118 12.23805 3.93E+05
1.51E-02 0.018652 12.93788 0.681898 12.25598 3.54E+05
1.55E-02 0.019095 12.92469 0.65178 12.27291 3.15E+05
1.59E-02 0.019537 12.91251 0.623649 12.28886 2.84E+05
1.64E-02 0.01998 12.90119 0.597219 12.30397 2.56E+05
1.68E-02 0.020423 12.89068 0.572414 12.31827 2.27E+05
1.73E-02 0.020866 12.8809 0.549106 12.33179 1.98E+05
1.77E-02 0.021308 12.8718 0.527224 12.34457 1.69E+05
1.82E-02 0.021751 12.86328 0.506567 12.35671 1.41E+05
1.86E-02 0.022194 12.85531 0.487088 12.36822 1.13E+05
1.90E-02 0.022636 12.84787 0.468741 12.37912 87165
1.95E-02 0.023079 12.84086 0.451363 12.3895 61517
1.99E-02 0.023522 12.83428 0.434926 12.39936 35875
2.04E-02 0.023965 12.8281 0.419363 12.40873 10277
2.08E-02 0.024407 12.82228 0.404647 12.41763 -3399.2
2.13E-02 0.02485 12.81678 0.390655 12.42613 -3322.9
Maximum finite
Pr finite (MpaS (m) S (mm)
3.65E+07 3.40E+07 3.40E+01 0 0
3.24E+07 2.93E+07 2.93E+01 4.43E-04 0.44271
2.83E+07 2.47E+07 2.47E+01 8.85E-04 0.88542
2.42E+07 2.00E+07 2.00E+01 1.33E-03 1.3281
2.02E+07 1.53E+07 1.53E+01 1.77E-03 1.7708
1.86E+07 1.40E+07 1.40E+01 2.21E-03 2.2135
1.76E+07 1.33E+07 1.33E+01 2.66E-03 2.6562
1.65E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 3.10E-03 3.099
1.60E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 3.54E-03 3.5417
1.56E+07 1.22E+07 1.22E+01 3.98E-03 3.9844
1.52E+07 1.21E+07 1.21E+01 4.43E-03 4.4271
1.49E+07 1.21E+07 1.21E+01 4.87E-03 4.8698
1.47E+07 1.20E+07 1.20E+01 5.31E-03 5.3125
1.45E+07 1.20E+07 1.20E+01 5.76E-03 5.7552
1.43E+07 1.21E+07 1.21E+01 6.20E-03 6.1979
1.42E+07 1.21E+07 1.21E+01 6.64E-03 6.6406
1.41E+07 1.22E+07 1.22E+01 7.08E-03 7.0833
1.40E+07 1.22E+07 1.22E+01 7.53E-03 7.526
1.39E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 7.97E-03 7.9687
1.38E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 8.41E-03 8.4115
1.37E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 8.85E-03 8.8542
1.37E+07 1.24E+07 1.24E+01 9.30E-03 9.2969
1.36E+07 1.24E+07 1.24E+01 9.74E-03 9.7396
1.36E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.02E-02 10.182
1.35E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.06E-02 10.625
1.35E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.11E-02 11.068
1.34E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 1.15E-02 11.51
1.34E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 1.20E-02 11.953
1.34E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 1.24E-02 12.396
1.33E+07 1.27E+07 1.27E+01 1.28E-02 12.839
1.33E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.33E-02 13.281
1.33E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.37E-02 13.724
1.32E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.42E-02 14.167
1.32E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.46E-02 14.609
1.31E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.51E-02 15.052
1.31E+07 1.28E+07 1.28E+01 1.55E-02 15.495
1.30E+07 1.27E+07 1.27E+01 1.59E-02 15.937
1.29E+07 1.27E+07 1.27E+01 1.64E-02 16.38
1.29E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 1.68E-02 16.823
1.28E+07 1.26E+07 1.26E+01 1.73E-02 17.266
1.27E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.77E-02 17.708
1.26E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.82E-02 18.151
1.26E+07 1.25E+07 1.25E+01 1.86E-02 18.594
1.25E+07 1.24E+07 1.24E+01 1.90E-02 19.036
1.24E+07 1.24E+07 1.24E+01 1.95E-02 19.479
1.23E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 1.99E-02 19.922
1.23E+07 1.23E+07 1.23E+01 2.04E-02 20.365
1.22E+07 1.22E+07 1.22E+01 2.08E-02 20.807
1.21E+07 1.21E+07 1.21E+01 2.13E-02 21.25