Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full Text 01
Full Text 01
Sammanfattning
Målet för detta examensarbete har varit att förbättra driften av en motkolvs tvåtaktsmotor
med HCCI-förbränning. Huvudfokus för arbetet har varit på gasväxlingsprocessen, då
främst avgasprocessen.
Motorn har studerats med utgångspunkt från hur en tvåtakts Otto-cykel fungerar.
Gasväxlingsprocessen i tvåtaktsmotorer kännetecknas av behovet av att snabbt få ut den
förbrända gasen och införa ny blandning vid varje expansionstakt, samt avsaknaden av
ventiler. Behovet att kunna kontrollera gasflödet genom cylindern ger upphov till två av
de mest karaktäristiska systemen på tvåtaktsmotorer: spolpump samt avgaspipa.
Utformningen och genomförandet av dessa två system har skapat ett flertal uppgifter som
det varit nödvändigt att lösa: porttider har uppmätts, ett luftintag med trycksatt luft har
byggts för att kunna ändra förhållandet på insugningsluften. Olika insprutningssystem har
också testats.
Slutligen har en avgaspipa installerats och trimmats in. Utifrån målsättningen, så har ett
logiskt sätt att angripa problemet gjorts:
Abstract
The aim of this thesis is the improvement of the operation of an opposed piston two
stroke engine with HCCI-combustion. The main focus is the charge exchange process,
concretely the exhaust process.
The engine has been studied from the perspective of the two stroke Otto cycle. Charge
exchange process in two stroke engines is characterized by the need of expelling the
burnt gases and introducing the fresh mix each expansion stroke, and the absence of
valves. Control of the gas flow through the cylinder motivates two of the most
characteristic systems on two-stroke engines: scavenging compressor and exhaust pipe.
The design and implementation of these two systems has needed the development of
several tasks: port timing has been characterized; a compressed air intake installation has
been built in order to be able to modify the inlet air conditions; different injection
systems have been tested as well.
Finally, an exhaust pipe has been installed and tuned. With this aim, a logical approach to
the problem has been done:
• The behavior of compressible gas flow through ducts has been studied.
• The influence of the dimensions of the exhaust pipe has been understood by doing
a design.
HCCI technologies AB and specially Tom Whitlock have delivered a continued interest
and support for this project.
Thanks to Patrick Hellgren, for all his solutions for whatever mechanical problem that
took place. Without him it could have been impossible to develop this work. Thanks as
well to Bengt Aronsson, Jack Ivarsson and Ulf Andorff.
The people of the department have made my stay more pleasant. Thanks to Stefan,
Anders, and all the others.
The Shell Ecomarathon experience in Lausitzring was amazing. I am so grateful to all the
members of the Agilis-V team for his passionate work and dedication. There is nothing
like see the fruits of one´s labour.
This experience would not have the same without all the friends that have accompanied
me. Carlos, Adrián y Antonio, thank you for sharing this great year, for sure one of the
best in all my life.
I am really grateful to my father, for his push, and to my sister and my grandparents, for
giving me happiness from Valencia. To my mother, for allowing me to live the life I
want. Ester, it is impossible to explain with words what I feel towards you.
Finally, to Rafael Villasmil: this is probably my first and last Master of Science, but it has
been the second one for you. You should feel holder of this work as it was yours. Thank
you for behaving like a brother.
Contents
1. Introduction ................................................................................................................... 3
5. Results .......................................................................................................................... 40
5.1. Tests procedure ...................................................................................................... 40
5.2. Exhaust pipe tuning results .................................................................................... 40
5.2.1. Tuned Length .............................................................................................. 40
5.2.2. Tail pipe diameter ....................................................................................... 44
5.3. Comparison between the old exhaust pipe designed
with 1-D simulation software and the new tuned commercial exhaust pipe......... 45
6. Conclusions .................................................................................................................. 47
1
7. Future work ................................................................................................................. 49
8. References .................................................................................................................... 50
2
1. Introduction
22 is an opposed piston, one cylinder, 2-stroke engine, with two operation modes: Spark
Ignition and Homogeneous Charge Compression Ignition. Spark Ignition combustion
consists of burning a premixed charge of gasoline and air by mean of a spark, so a flame
would travel all along the combustion chamber. Combustion takes place with spatial
discontinuity, and close to the flame front, high temperatures promote NOx formation.
On the other hand, the HCCI mode burns a premixed homogeneous lean air-fuel mixture
like a Diesel engine, Compression Ignition. There are differences between HCCI
combustion and Diesel combustion: charge is homogeneous and lean, so there are not
rich zones close to the spray like in diesel engines, and therefore soot is practically
avoided; and flame does not exist. All the regions of the combustion chamber have a
simultaneous temporal evolution. Combustion process, unlike diesel cycle, happens at
constant pressure, as in Otto cycle. Higher compressions ratios are used, which together
with a not-spatial-discontinuity fast combustion allows efficiencies better than both SI
and CI engines. Moreover, absence of a flame front reduces drastically combustion
temperatures and hence NOx formation.
The control of the ignition in HCCI operation can be mainly done by affecting inlet
conditions: lambda, intake temperature and pressure, octane number of fuel, internal and
external EGR…But the most influent parameter is compression ratio. The compression
ratio control is what motivates engine’s unique configuration, given by two opposite
pistons moving in one cylinder. The minimum volume of the combustion chamber (and
so the compression ratio) is controlled by phasing both crankshafts while the engine is
under operation. This is done with a patented system consisting of 4 gearwheels
transmitting the rotation between crankshafts, which can get a phase change because of
the positioning control system of the intermediate not-fixed-shaft wheels. The phase is
adjusted according to the signals of two Hall Effect sensors and a cylinder pressure
transducer. The cylinder pressure measurement allows monitoring the combustion
process, focusing in the cycle to cycle evolution of the start of the ignition. The
gearwheels attached to the crankshafts have a missing tooth. The phase between both
crankshafts is known by identifying when each missing tooth passes in front of each Hall
Effect sensor. The linear actuator that controls the phasing mechanism is activated
according to these signals. Figure 1 shows a view of the engine from the phasing
mechanism side.
3
Figure 1. Engine
Figure 2 shows the transversal section of the engine. Particularly relevant is the
scavenging process, uniflow type.
The engine’s charge exchange process study and improvement is the main topic of this
thesis. The need of expelling the burnt gases and introducing the fresh mix each
expansion stroke and the absence of valves makes control of gas flow through the
cylinder difficult, and motivates two of the most characteristic systems on two-stroke
engines: scavenging compressor and exhaust pipe. The exhaust pipe tuning is the most
important objective of this work. Different injection systems have been tested as well,
and an intake compressed air installation for allowing changes on air’s pressure and
temperature has been proved. All the development of the engine can be consulted within
this thesis.
4
2. Definitions and considerations on angular references
The control of the compression ratio is based on the cylinder pressure and the relative
angular position of both crankshafts, measured with a pressure transducer and Hall Effect
sensors. Many other parameters such as Ignition Angle, Ignition Current, Injection Angle,
are introduced in the ECU with reference to a certain angular position (TDC, Top Dead
Center) of one of the crankshafts. Data taken from crankshaft angle logs must be
referenced also to a crankshaft angle scale, usually with 0 in the TDC. Due to the fact that
the engine has two crankshafts for the same cylinder, it is extremely important to know
which parameters are referenced to which crankshaft. For a better understanding, the
different TDCs will be placed on a common scale.
For building a common scale the most important consideration is that the Exhaust side
crankshaft always reaches its TDC before the Intake side crankshaft does. It is easy to
realize that the exTDC will happen exactly an angle consisting in the phase difference
before the airTDC.
The IDC matches exactly half the phase difference after the exTDC and before the air
TDC. A demonstration of this can be read on Appendix number 1.
Figure 3 clarifies better the concepts explained before, where positive increments of
angle mean crankshaft displacement on the real rotating direction.
5
Figure 3. Volume between pistons vs different angle scales, with 12º of phase difference
Crank Angle PDAQ logs will place its 0 in a TDC that depends on the crankshaft where
the rotary encoder is installed (for more information about the rotary encoder, consult
section 3.).
All the TDCs described in the ECU parameters menu (see table 3 on section 4.1 in Ref
[1]) are referred to a crankshaft scale with 0 on the airTDC. From now on, if no reference
is given, TDC would be referred to airTDC.
Other important nomenclature used in this book is A (after) or B (before) before the
referenced TDC. For example: AairTDC means After air Top Dead Center.
6
3. Optimization of the engine and test bench
3.1. Second block and spare parts
• Second operative block: cylinder block, pistons, piston rings, connecting rods,
crankshafts, gaskets, hubs, gearwheels, linear actuator, oil tank, connections with
cooling and oil circuits, hall sensors, and cylinder pressure sensor (Optrand
C33233-Q).
• Extra sets: cylinder block, pistons, piston rings, connecting rods, crankshafts,
gaskets, hubs, gearwheels, linear actuator, oil tank, connections with cooling and
oil circuits, injectors, rod sensor, and coupling for the rod sensor.
Figure 5. Set of Bosch 0 280 150 995 for Renault models Twingo and Clio
7
Figure 6. Set of spare parts
3.2. Fuel
Fuel’s octane number has been lowered from 98 to 95 octanes. This reduction makes the
fuel more prone to self ignition.
The original rotary encoder, a Heidenhain sensor model ROD 426, was described on
section 3.2.1 in Ref [2]. The big inertia of the rotary parts made the intermediate
connection between the crankshaft and the coupling and even the threaded end of the
crankshaft to break. It led to a purchase of a smaller model ROD 1000, with 1000
measurements per revolution (every 0.36 degrees).
Figure 7. Comparison between the old and the new rotary encoders
8
3.4. Torque signal filters
The description of torque measurement system can be found on section 3.2.4 in Ref [2]. It
consists basically of a force sensor attached to an arm, which is screwed to the housing of
a hydrostatic pump moved by the engine through a toothed pulley mechanism, so the
pump casing can rotate freely around the impeller, delivering all the reaction torque to the
arm. Figure 8 clarifies the concept. A different gear width on one of the toothed belt
wheels induced breaks of several belts. After replacement with an adequate gearwheel,
torque signal presented a bad behavior since measurements showed cyclic oscillations
instead a constant value under a constant break torque (break torque is applied through a
valve that regulates the pressure drop on the oil circuit driven by the described
hydrostatic pump). Figure 9 shows the cylinder pressure and the measured torque vs time
with combustion. Conclusions point to a change of the old belt deformation properties,
which allow absorption of vibrations to the torque measurement mechanism.
9
Figure 9. Cylinder pressure and Torque vs Time
Some different assemblies were tried, but even with a low elastic constant rubber element
that dumped the high frequency vibrations on the arm-force sensor coupling , and adding
moment of inertia by placing weight a long vertical distance down the rotary housing of
the oil pump (figure 10), the structure still showed resonance in operation (figure 11).
Once revealed vibrations weren’t interfering with the resonance frequency of the forces
sensor (750 Hz according to manufacturer), the natural frequency of the structure was
obtained (figure 12), and according to that, it was decided to install a low pass filter with
a cutoff frequency of 1 Hz (figure 13), and reestablish the original assembly without
rubber element and increased moment of inertia (figure 14). Professor Hans-Erik
Ångström selected the cutoff frequency and added the electronic components to the
original electronic circuit. Measurements are now more accurate (figure 15).
10
Figure 10. Torque measuring structure with low elastic constant and increased moment of inertia.
Figure 11. Cylinder Pressure and Torque vs time with low elastic constant and increased moment of inertia
structure. Low frequency oscillation is about 5.4 Hz and high frequency oscillation is about 185 Hz.
11
Figure 12. Hit to the torque measuring structure with low elastic constant and increased moment of inertia
structure. Natural frequency is about 6 Hz.
300kΩ
300kΩ
Vin
47µF
47µF Vout
Figure 13. 2 stage amplification and 2 stage low pass filter equivalent circuit. The cutoff frequency is 1.11
Hz.
12
Figure 14. Original torque measuring structure.
Figure 15. Cylinder pressure and Torque vs Time with electronic filter.
13
3.5. Pressure and temperature sensors on intake manifold and exhaust circuit
Measurements on temperature and pressure of intake and exhaust gases are extraordinary
important for understanding the engine operation:
Air conditions on the intake provide information for knowing parameters as described:
• Temperature, which will affect the mixing process with the fuel.
• Density, which will affect the mass flow entering to the cylinder.
• Pressure, which will influence the charge exchange process.
Particularly relevant to this work are the exhaust gases conditions: temperature affects the
local acoustic velocity on the flow by changing the bulk modulus. Pressure pulses show
how the exhaust pipe is behaving. More about this can be read on section 4.
The installation of pressure and temperature sensors on intake and exhaust ports is, as
consequence, extremely important. Installed pressure sensors are Gems
2200AGA4001A2UA, while temperature sensors are standard thermocouples. The
placement of the sensors was carried out as close as possible to the ports and on a defined
position at the exhaust piping (justification can be read on section 4), as showed on figure
16.
Pressure
sensors
Temperature
sensors
14
The exhaust pressure sensors need cooling for operation. Cooling boxes were prepared,
taking coolant from the cell installation.
Signals of pressure sensors are read via fast card, while thermocouples measurements are
sent with Datascan-Nudam to the PC controller.
3.6.1. Objective
The inlet conditions must be measured in order to determinate its influence on the engine
operation, and be able to improve it by modifying them.
The scavenging system was already studied by previous developing teams (section 3.1.2,
in Ref [1] or whole contents of Ref [3]). Existent solution was a root compressor
connected to the engine via a belt with changeable gear ratio. Modifying the transmission
ratio to the root compressor could be done by changing the diameter of the wheels of the
transmission system between the intake crankshaft and the root compressor’s shaft,
(keeping the size of the tooth constant). Therefore, different speed ratios can be tested.
Because it is a positive displacement or volumetric pump, it can be assumed that the
delivered volume of air per revolution is constant (losses, volumetric efficiency, air’s
density variations and other factors should be taken in consideration), so the mass flow
depends basically on the rotational speed, which can be changed in the way that has been
described.
The solution applied was to use a compressed air installation for supplying directly the
intake port: it is possible to simulate the behavior of a scavenging compressor by
supplying the engine with compressed air. With the adequate control systems, the air
flow and its conditions can be adjusted as it is desired.
15
3.6.2. Design and configuration
From the
supply
Stabilizing
Pressure tank
regulator
valve Stabilizing
tank
Safety valve
To the
engine
Air
heater
It consists of a commercial model Festo LRP valve. It allows regulating the intake
installation pressure by keeping a constant pressure drop for each degree of openness.
For avoiding damage to the intake installation and even personal injuries, the system is
provided with a security valve (figure 18) with adjustable opening pressure. The
compressed air installation can deliver 6 gauge bar pressure, but the security valve starts
opening at 1.5, and gets fully opened at 2.5 bar, not allowing more pressure on the
system.
16
Figure 18. Disassembly of the homemade security valve
It consists of a differential pressure meter, commercial model Setra 265, measuring the
pressure drop over a laminar restriction catalyst with some channels plugged). It was
already described on section 3.2.4 in Ref [2]. New channels were created on Cell4 for
knowing the air flow and Delivery Ratio according to the intake pressure and air flow
measurements, whose expressions can be consulted on Appendix 7, as well as the airflow
meter calibration procedure.
The air heater consists of a commercial fan heater, Jula brand, article number 411-089
2009-04-22, with three different configurations:
¾ Stop
¾ Fixed power of 1000 w
¾ Fixed power of 1500 w
For getting an exact temperature on the air flow, an output Pulse Width Modulation
channel was introduced on Cell4 setup, based on the intake temperature channel, which
measurement is given by the described intake temperature sensor in this section.
The correct way to establish an intake pressure can be done by following next steps:
• Close the intake port of the engine by rotating the crankshaft so all the intake
system stays under pressure
• Measure the pressure using the intake pressure sensor reading on Cell4.
Manometer has not an adequate precision so its measurement should be taken as
an approximation, and as a security measurement system.
• Correct the valve opening by actuating over the manual regulator.
As an indication, intake pressure shouldn´t be bigger than 0.5 bar (gauge pressure).
17
3.7. Oil pump
The implementation of a compressed air supply to the engine carries the substitution of
the root compressor, which also consisted on an oil pump attached in the same shaft that
provides impulsion to the lubricant, (read on section 4.5 in Ref [3]). To get independence
from the dual pump, an individual oil pump was installed: Biltema article 52-3228, with
12 V voltage supply.
Due to bad operation, the ventilation hose of the oil circuit (description on section 2.3.7
in Ref [4]) was removed.
18
3.8. Injection system modifications
The fuel preparation has been studied by changing intake air conditions, and also
changing injection characteristics, mainly the injector placement and injection timing.
The injector used is a commercial Bosch model, code 0 280 150 995, installed on Renault
Twingo and Clio. Injector’s selection process can be consulted on section 2.7 in Ref [4].
Its characteristics are shown on table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of Bosch 0 280 150 995 injector
Resistance (Ohm) 14.5 Spray orientation angle -
Spray distribution (area, 4°-20°
Test medium Heptan
spray amount) 70%
Operating pressure (kPa) 300 Allowed fuels -
Q-stat (at operating pressure)
(g/min) 67.5 Version, type 1.3
The injector operation depends basically of two parameters: Injection Angle and Injection
Time. Both of them are implemented on the ECU, which controls the injector by mean of
a voltage signal which incorporates these two parameters in the explained way:
• Injection Angle: the voltage is sent according to hall 1 sensor signal, which allows
knowing the intake side crankshaft angle since the missed tooth on the gearwheel
passes through the sensor a certain known angle before top dead center
(“RefAngle missing 1 Ca bef. TDC” on table 3 section 4.1 in Ref [1]).
19
The retraction of the needle has an electromechanical delay when opening and closing the
injector’s nozzle that depends on the voltage applied to the solenoid actuating the
mechanism. Closing delay is usually neglected due to its short duration compared to
opening delay. The dependence between delay and voltage is assumed to be linear and
was already studied by previous developing team in order to correct the Injection Time.
The parameters set on EcoControl are “Inj. Delay Zero Voltage ms” (current value 2.82
ms) and “Zero inj. Delay Voltage” (current value 22.32897 V), which permit to establish
dependence of Injection Delay and Supply Voltage shown on figure 20. The description
of both parameters is found in Ref [1], where it is specified that only the Injection Time is
corrected.
Figure 20. Injection Delay vs Supply Voltage for Bosch 0280150995 injector
Due to the delay, the Injection Time is corrected by the ECU by adding extra time on the
tail of each injection, but the Injection Angle does not have any correction. Figure 21
shows the injection signal in a test performed at 5979.4 rpm, 12º constant phase angle,
1.3 ms of Injection Time and Injection Angle of 80.2º.
20
Figure 21. Injection Signal vs Crankangle referred to exTDC
As it can be seen, the total injection angular period is 193º-93º=100º, which means an
Injection Time of 2.79 ms for the operation speed. The injection voltage can be taken as
12.3 V, which represents 1.27 ms of delay according to figure 20. Therefore, the Injection
Time is 2.79≈1.3+1.27. However, the Injection Angle is 93º in an Exhaust Side
Crankshaft Angle, which means approximately 81 on an Intake Side Crankshaft Angle,
this is, the value set on the ECU. If the Injection Time correction is also considered valid
for the Injection Angle, according to figure 20, there is an injection delay of 1.27 ms, or
45.72º at the operation speed. Hence, real Injection Angle is 81º+45.72º=126.72º, while
the Injection Signal should be sent on angle 81º-45.72º=35.28º for achieving the desired
Injection Angle.
Henceforth the correction for the injection delay applied to the Injection Time would be
also considered a valid approximation for the Injection Angle correction.
21
3.8.3. Empirical determination of the Injection Time vs Mass of fuel per injection
curve
The fuel flow depends directly on the Injection Time and the engine speed. On the test
bench, a scale is used for measuring the mass of the gasoline tank that feeds the injection
system, so taking logs of the scale signal allows knowing the fuel flow by calculating the
slope of the gasoline tank vs time curve. An important tool for checking and prediction of
fuel consumption would be the opposite: a regression curve that calculates fuel flow from
the Injection Time. Previous working team configured that curve from injection tests, and
it has been compared to values from engine tests performed along the development of the
project. Results are shown on figure 22.
As it can be seen, the engine tests show bigger dispersion, but the match between
injection and engine tests can be considered quite approximated. Therefore, the
regression curve obtained from injection tests can be used for predicting fuel flow with
good enough approximation.
22
3.8.4. Comparison between different injection systems
Notice also that the direct injection port timing is not exactly the same as intake ports
timing although they are aligned on the same circumference, since the injector port is
bigger than intake ports (figure 23). Direct injector port opens at 106º BairTDC while
intake ports open at 119º BairTDC. Another important port timing characteristic is that
with less than 8º phase difference, the direct injection port opens before the exhaust ports
do.
Injector Port
23
3.8.4.1. Port Injection
Port Injector was installed as shown on figure 24. No specifically tests for comparing its
performance compared to other injection systems have been done.
Direct
Injection
Port
Injection
Figure 25 shows results obtained, while table 2 reflects tests characteristics. Notice that
stability reflects the engine behavior in a scale from 1 to 5, meaning 1=inoperability;
2=unstable operation (oscillations of the engine speed over 15% of the test velocity);
3=stability with oscillations of the engine speed between 15% and 3% of the test velocity;
4=stability with oscillations of the engine speed between 3% and 1% of the test velocity;
and 5 completely smooth operation (oscillations of the engine speed lower than 1% of the
test velocity).
Table 2. Tests characteristics
24
Figure 25. Power and Stability (see previous paragraph for the points scale) vs Injection Angle (Injection
Angle referred to airTDC)
The main characteristic revealed while testing was the increase of stability for a same
amount of injected fuel when injecting when intake ports are closing or already closed.
This could mean that with this kind of injection, mixing process is improved by allowing
fuel and air to interact during a longer period of time. Results related on power, however,
are difficult to assess.
The lower fuel efficiency and power compared to Direct Injection determined the change
to the last one. Further investigation should be done with this type of injection, once the
exhaust pipe has been tuned and other improvements have been applied to the engine.
25
3.8.4.2. Direct Injection vs Axial Deflected Direct Injection comparison
A detailed observation of figure 23 would reveal that with Direct Injection the spray is
pointed to the intake ports. The fuel preparation could be improved by making the
gasoline evaporate faster against warmer surfaces, these are, cylinder walls or exhaust
piston head. Axial Deflected Direct Injection consists of a special injector head that
deviates the spray a certain angle from the injector longitudinal axis, with the aim of
focusing the spray to the combustion chamber and allowing the faster evaporation. Figure
26 shows a detail of normal Direct Injector (DI) and Axial Deflected Direct Injector
(Did).
Direct Injection (DI) and Axial Deflected Direct Injection (Did, with an approximated
angular deflection of 45º according to the machining of the hole) have been tested in
order to determinate the better option. Tests characteristics are shown on table 3, while
figures 27 and 28 show Injection Time (in an Intake side crankshaft angle scale), Power
and Specific Fuel Consumption for both types of injection. Power to electric and
electronic issues such as injection, ignition, phase regulator, electronic circuits, electric
lubrication pump, electric cooling pump, electric petrol pump, electric air heater and
intake air pressurization are not considered when calculating specific fuel consumption.
Tests have been done trying to keep the same Injection Time and therefore a constant
lambda (measured values from 0.82 to 0.92), but when it was not possible, Injection Time
was modified till stable operation was reached. Injection angles were swept till the ports
closed: bigger Injection angles showed instability or the need of Injection Times longer
than 2 ms, so no interesting result was achieved. Also, small inexactitudes on Specific
Fuel Consumption can be expected are due to fuel flow calculation by using the scale
measurements.
26
Table 3. Tests characteristics
Figure 27. Power and Injection Time vs Injection Angle (Injection angle referred to airTDC) for both types
of injection
27
Figure 28. Specific Fuel Consumption and Injection Time vs Injection Angle (Injection angle referred to
airTDC) for both types of injection
Engine shows a not affected by injection angle behavior with not Axial Deflected Direct
Injection. It reaches its best specific fuel consumption when fuel is injected while ports
are closed, which reveals that better mixing mechanism is similar to 4-stroke Port Injector
engines, where closed valves play an important role. Notice that injecting over the piston
lateral surface makes the gasoline to evaporate the diluted oil and this worsens the engine
lubrication (the engine uses a mix of 2% oil-98% gasoline as fuel for ensuring the pistons
rings lubrication). This means that it is dangerous to inject when ports are closed. On the
other hand, Axial Deflected Direct Injection behaves better when injecting while ports
start opening or are fully open, which can be understood as a different mixing process,
which was explained as a faster vaporization process due to impact of the spray with
warm surfaces.
Since the angular duration of the injection goes from 46.8º for 1.3 ms to 72º for 2 ms (not
corrected duration, since the injection delay is already considered), it is an expected result
that power decreases and specific fuel consumption increases when injecting from 200º in
advance. The injection is stopped because of the closing of the port.
It is also remarkable that the injection port timing does not influence the injection as the
intake ports timing does. The specific fuel consumption and the power show bad
behaviour when injecting at 115.6º AairTDC (70º AairTDC on the ECU). For that
Injection Angle, the injection port is open but the intake ports are still closed.
28
3.9. Approaches to two-stroke combustion with high compression ratio
The configuration of the engine has significantly changed along the course of this thesis.
After every change, several parameters have been systematically swept in order to
achieve an operation that ensures a fast heat release combustion process every working
cycle. Ranges of values for some parameters that ensure a good approach to this type of
combustion are:
• Intake air pressure: from 0.2 to 0.3 bar.
• Intake air temperature: from 55 to 70ºC.
• Injection angle: depending on the injection system. See previous section.
• Ignition angle: from 55 to 65º BairTDC.
• Ignition current: taken according to section 5.3 in Ref [2] as 60º before ignition
angle at 5000 rpm (2 ms), and changed consequently to every test speed.
The combustion process was already described on section 5.2 in Ref [2]. As it was said, it
is a two stroke fast combustion that needs of the spark plug activation energy for initiate
the ignition by compression heat.
Next results are shown as an example of the type of combustion performed when using
these values. Table 4 describes the test characteristics. Figure 24 shows 20 consecutive
cycles of Cylinder Pressure vs Exhaust side crankshaft angle. Figure 25 shows cycles
from 6 to 9 of the previous figure.
29
Figure 29. Cylinder Pressure vs Crankangle referred to exTDC
Figure 30. Cylinder Pressure vs Crankangle referred to exTDC for cycles from 6 to 9 of figure 29
30
4. Implementation of an exhaust system
4.1. Exhaust gases flow in a two-stroke engine
The exhaust gases flow in a two stroke engine is an unsteady flow, i.e., the pressure,
temperature, and the gas particle velocity are variable with time. This affirmation is valid
even with constant speed and load, since internal combustion engine operate on the basis
of a reciprocating principium. The operation of an exhaust pipe is based on the
propagation of pressure pulses in this kind of flow. See chapter 2 in Ref [5].
Pressure pulses in a two-stroke engine exhaust pipe are created because of the ports
opening and closing operation by the piston. This extremely fast perturbation on the flow
that moves through the port becomes a finite pressure wave (pulse) that travels along the
pipe. This pulse is characterized by having a pressure ratio greater than a sonic wave and
a finite spatial extension. When the pulse crosses a transversal section variation, a part of
it is transmitted and a part of it is reflected. If the section increases, the reflected pulse
switches its sign, while if the section decreases, the reflected pulse continues with its
original sign. The pressure of the flow traveling through the exhaust pipe is taken as
reference pressure when talking about compression (positive) or expansion (negative)
pressure waves.
Figure 31. Compression pulse traveling through a pipe, with the same direction for the flow and the pulse.
Source: Ref [7].
31
Figure 32. Expansion pulse traveling through a pipe, with opposite direction for the flow and the pulse.
Source: Ref [7]
The length and the amplitude of the transmitted and reflected pulses will depend, among
others, on the transversal surface change and its slope referred to the duct´s axial
coordinate.
According to this theory, pressure pulses along the exhaust pipe of a two-stroke engine
can be used to increase the efficiency of the charge exchange process. The installation of
a diffuser-nozzle tune pipe would create a reflected expansion pressure pulse on the
section-diverging, which will help the fresh mix from the intake port to enter the
cylinder; and a reflected compression pressure pulse would be created on the converging-
belly, arriving later than the previous negative pressure pulse, pushing the fresh mix that
comes out of the cylinder to the exhaust pipe back. The lack of port timing control
through valves can be done by affecting the flow through an exhaust pipe on 2-stroke
engines.
An exhaust pipe must fit certain dimensions for behaving correctly: pressure pulses must
affect the exhaust flow adequately. Although the objective of this project was not to build
a new pipe according to a design, but implementing a commercial model to the engine, it
was important to know how its shape modifies its behavior, which can be studied by
designing an exhaust pipe. The design process was based on a set of theoretical-empirical
formulas that can be found on section 6.2.5 in Ref [5].
32
Diagram on figure 33 represents the design process.
The design aims mainly to make the positive pressure pulse originated at the end of the
converging section, to arrive to the exhaust port when it is about to get closed. All the
previous negative pressure pulses created on the diffuser and the positive pressure pulses
generated on the nozzle affect the flow while the exhaust port is open.
The original pressure pulse will travel all the tuned length till the end of the nozzle,
where the reflected positive pressure pulse will be generated, and will again cross all the
tuned length till the exhaust port. This will be done during the time interval when the
exhaust port is open.
33
All the numeric calculations and data from the engine can be consulted on Appendix
number 2 (exhaust port opening angle interval) and 3 (exhaust pipe design).
Since pressure pulses are moving on a flow, their propagation speed would be the sum of
the local speed of sound plus the gas particle velocity:
kJ
a (m / s) = γ ⋅ R ( ) ⋅ T (K ) Expression 2
kg ⋅ K
where γ is the adiabatic coefficient of the exhaust gasses mix, R is the universal constant
for the ideal gasses applied to it, and T its temperature.
Assuming isentropic conditions, the value of the local acoustic velocity on the particles
affected by the pressure pulse (see section 2.1.3 in Ref [5]) is:
γ −1
⎛ p ⎞ 2·γ
a (m / s ) = a 0 (m / s )·⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ Expression 3
⎝ p0 ⎠
The value of the particle velocity is, according to Earnshaw (see section 2.1.3 in Ref [5]):
γ −1
⎡ ⎤
2·a0 (m / s ) ⎢⎛ p ⎞ 2·γ
c (m / s) = ± ⎜ ⎟ − 1⎥ Expression 4
γ − 1 ⎢⎜⎝ p0 ⎟⎠ ⎥
⎢⎣ ⎥⎦
where p is the pressure, and subindex 0 indicates the reference state (as it has been said,
the conditions of the flow). The sign depends on the pressure ratio: plus when
compression waves, and minus when expansion waves.
For the design process, the value of the local acoustic velocity will be taken, according to
Blair (section 2.1.3 in Ref [5]), as the propagation speed in the flow (Expression 2),
simplifying the calculations, since it is taken a unique propagation speed for all pressure
pulses, without considering their pressure ratio. Values of R and γ, which are functions of
T and compound properties of the exhaust gas, have been also simplified and can be
consulted on Appendix 3
A speed for peak power must be selected, since it determinates the exhaust port opening
angle interval, and the exhaust pipe will be tuned for it.
34
Once the speed for peak power and the exhaust port opening angle interval have been
selected and calculated, it is easy to know the exhaust port opening time interval:
θ (º )
t (s) = Expression 5
⎛ rev ⎞ 360 (º / rev )
N⎜ ⎟⋅
⎝ min ⎠ 60 ⎛ s ⎞
⎜ ⎟
⎝ min ⎠
So, the tuned length must be, according to the following expression:
c (m / s)
LT (m) = Expression 6
2·t (s )
The other dimensions are obtained according to Blair´s empirical formulas. Because of
the fact that, as described before, it is not the objective of the project to build an exhaust
pipe according to a design but acquiring and changing a commercial model, the part of
the process of design left is explained on the Appendix 3, as well as the final dimensions
for the obtained design. Only two dimensions will be considered critical:
• Tuned length (LT): 867.4 mm.
• Tail pipe diameter (D7): 13.2 mm.
The design process had been useful to make a first approach of how the dimensions of the
exhaust pipe should be, but the objective of the project was to install and modify a
commercial exhaust pipe. This ensured no manufacturing malfunctions and had
facilitated its adaptation.
The selection of a commercial model had been done by considering different criteria:
• Dimensions: it had to be dimensionally similar to the design, at least with a
slightly shorter tuned length.
• Engines in which it is installed on: it had to work properly installed on engines
with analogue characteristics to the Double Two engine: all moped, 2-stroke, 50
cc engines, with the same range of speed as Double Two Engine.
• Easy modification: the selected exhaust pipe had to be easy to modify, for
changing its dimensions and adapting it to the testing bench.
• Economic cost: given the uncertainty of the outcome, not too much expensive
pipes had to be considered, while meeting a minimum quality.
35
The selected pipe was Tecnigas Next R.
With the aim of tuning the exhaust pipe, the exhaust installation had been modified,
introducing:
• A first stretch between the block exhaust port and the initial exhaust pipe flange,
which allowed changing its total (and so the tuned) length.
• An adequate structure for supporting the exhaust pipe from the test bench.
• A tail flanged-based-on coupling that allowed changing the tail pipe and holds a
flexible pipe that prevented vibrations of the engine to be transmitted to the rest
of the exhaust circuit. Silencer had been removed.
• New lambda sensor placement in the exhaust circuit, close to the exhaust pipe
end.
• An intermediate stabilization tank where the emissions probe was attached, and
collected exhaust condensates, allowing its removal through a valve on its
bottom.
• Commercial particulate filters Festo LF-1/8-D-brrr-MINI (5 to 40 µm) and
LFMB-1/8-D-brrr-MINI (0.01 to 1 µm), which protected the emissions
measurement instruments.
Since the emission rack, Boo Instruments model, had incorporated heated lines and
particulate filters, two points of measure, A and B on the diagram on figure 36, were
allowed.
36
4.4. Exhaust pipe tuning
The objective of the tuning was to improve the charge exchange process by adjusting the
exhaust pipe dimensions. The design process was extremely simplified. The dimensions
of the exhaust pipe (specially the designed tuned length) could be empirically modified in
order to achieve an improvement of the engine operation.
Charge exchange process can be defined by the use of three parameters: Trapping
Efficiency, Delivery Ratio and Charging Efficiency, whose expressions can be found on
expressions 7 to 9.
mass of delivered fresh air
DR = Expression 7
displacement volume * ambient density
More about these parameters can be read along section 1.5 in Ref [5].
The tuning process had been done for an operational working point of the engine.
Delivery Ratio is kept constant by fixing intake pressure and temperature, and rotating at
the selected tuning speed. Therefore, Trapping Efficiency will not be affected by changes
on intake conditions, and will depend on the exhaust flow. The exhaust flow would
depend on combustion process (which determinates its temperature and other conditions)
and, as it has been discussed before, on the dimensions of the exhaust pipe. Notice that
interaction between charge exchange process, affected by trapping efficiency, and
combustion process, makes the tuning process to be iterative. For a certain exhaust flow
conditions, a modification on exhaust pipe dimensions would affect the Trapping
Efficiency, ensuring more or less fresh mix trapped on the cylinder and so modifying the
combustion process, which would make the exhaust flow conditions change again.
Changes on these two dimensions would be done according to the observation of pressure
pulses travelling along the exhaust pipe.
37
The interpretation of pressure pulses by means of pressure measurements is extremely
difficult. In a specific transversal section of the pipe and instant, the usual circumstance is
the superposition of different pressure pulses travelling in opposite directions (see section
2.2 in Ref [5]). Because of that, the measurement of a pressure sensor placed somewhere
along the pipe will usually represent the amplitude of at least two pressure pulses
superposed. However, some attempts to identify correctly which section variation
generates each peak on the pressure measurement can be tried, by using a simply
cinematic relation:
L ( m)
a (m / s) = Expression 11
t (s)
In a crankshaft angle log, with a known speed of the engine, angles can be turned to
times, and each peak can be translated to a traveled length along the pipe. If the pressure
pulse corresponding to the end of the diffuser reaches the sensor when the exhaust port is
almost closed (notice that there is a little distance between the sensor and the exhaust port
that should not be mispriced), then the tuning is perfect. But the main problem to make
these calculations is the propagation speed of pressure pulses: each pressure pulse,
according to expression 3, has a different propagation velocity because of the different
pressure ratios. Although despising particle speed and considering only the local acoustic
velocity without pressure ratio, the temperature introduced on expression 2 can not be
taken as exhaust temperature sensor measurement, since it represents an average of the
different temperatures experienced in its position during the whole working cycle of the
engine. According to Heywood (section 6.5 in Ref [6]), exhaust gas temperature can vary
even a 50% during a cycle (although the referenced tests were performed on a 4-stroke
spark ignited engine, results can be applied also to 2-stroke engines).
Due to the difficulties to establish a proper exhaust flow temperature, the pressure pulses’
propagation velocity was obtained by using a second sensor placed on a known distance
from the first one on the exhaust installation, so the first opening pressure pulse can be
identified in both sensors, and angle which it takes place on is obtained.
38
By keeping the engine configuration and working point unchanged, a fine tuning will
reveal:
• Increase of Trapping Efficiency
• Increase of Torque
• Increase of Power
• Increase of Fuel Efficiency
• Decrease of Specific Fuel Consumption
So these five parameters will be measured and calculated for every change on the exhaust
pipe dimensions during the tuning process.
C8H18 + a·(O2 + N2) → b·CO2 + c·H2O + d·N2 + f·C8H18 + g·(O2 + N2)Non trapped
g O2 g exhaust
[O2 ]exhaust
mass
( ) ⋅ m& exhaust ( )
g air g exhaust min
m& air int ake ( )−
min
[O2 ]intmassake ( g O2 )
g air
TrEff = Expression 12
g air
m& air int ake ( )
min
The need of a rich lambda for calculating the Trapping Efficiency determines low fuel
efficiencies and high specific fuel consumptions. It has to be considered that the aim of
the calculation of these two parameters is comparing the behavior of the different
configurations of the exhaust pipe, and not bringing the engine to an efficient working
point. Power to electric and electronic issues such as injection, ignition, phase regulator,
electronic circuits, electric lubrication pump, electric cooling pump, electric petrol pump,
electric air heater and intake air pressurization are not considered when calculating
specific fuel consumption and fuel efficiency.
39
5. Results
5.1. Tests procedure
As it was said on previous section, Injection Time has been chosen in order to achieve
rich combustion. Lambda measured values oscillated between 0.77 and 0.86.
Figure 37 shows the initial dimensions of the exhaust pipe. Tuned length was taken
according to the design done on section 4.2.
Port Duct
Sensor Sensor
Ø19mm
L1 L1 ’ L2 L3 L5 L6 L7
1050
Figure 37. Dimensions of the initial configuration of the exhaust pipe
40
Figure 38 shows measurements of pressure transducers over Exhaust port Total Surface
Opened vs Crankangle referred to exTDC.
Figure 38. ETSO (Exhaust port Total Surface Opened), Exhaust Port Pressure and Duct Pressure vs
Crankangle referred to exTDC, for 865 mm of tuned length
As it can be seen, initial opening pulse reaches the port sensor on angle 154º, while
arrives to the duct sensor aproximately on angle 239º. This means that the average
propagation speed is 445 m/s. According to this speed and the angle for the reflected
pulse of the converging section, 306º, the exhaust pipe should be 370 mm shorter for
fitting the last pulse when the exhaust port is about to close. This calculation doesn’t
consider changes on exhaust flow temperature, which will change when trapping
efficiency increases and combustion and charge exchange processes change, as said
before.
A deeper analysis would reveal that reflected compression and expansion pulses arrive to
exhaust port when supposed according to the calculated propagation speed.
41
Final configuration after dimensional modifications become as shown on figure 39.
Port Duct
Sensor Sensor
Ø19mm
L1 L1 ’ L2 L3 L5 L6 L7
965
Figure 39. Dimensions of the final configuration of the exhaust pipe
Figure 40. ETSO (Exhaust port Total Surface Opened), Exhaust Port Pressure and Duct Pressure vs
Crankangle referred to exTDC, for 630 mm of tuned length
As it can be seen, compression pulse reflected from the nozzle reaches now the exhaust
port exactly when it closes.
42
Evolution of Fuel Efficiency, Power, Torque, Specific Fuel Consumption and Trapping
Efficiency is shown on figure 41.
Figure 41. Evolution of Fuel Efficiency, Power, Torque, Specific Fuel Consumption and Trapping
Efficiency vs dimensional change on tuned length
43
5.2.2. Tail pipe diameter
Once the exhaust pipe has been tuned according to the tuned length, the tail pipe diameter
influence would be tested for noticing its influence on the engine behavior.
Results on the pressure transducer measurements over Exhaust port Total Surface
Opened for the original 19 mm tail pipe diameter were already shown on figure 40.
Pressure transducers measurements over Exhaust port Total Surface Opened vs
Crankangle referred to exTDC for 14 mm of tail pipe diameter are shown on figure 42.
Figure 42. ETSO (Exhaust port Total Surface Opened), Exhaust Port Pressure and Duct Pressure vs
Crankangle referred to exTDC, for 19mm of tail pipe diameter
First fo all, notice that the four characterisitc pressure peaks correspondent to the port
opening have turn to two. The reason is that the graph is built from an average of 20
cycles. Individual cycles show the previous behavior.
As it can be seen, changing the tail pipe diameter does not almost affect propagation of
the pulses, since they reach the port at about the same angles. Although pressure ratios
have increased notably (notice the change of vertical scale from this graph to the previous
ones), from expression 3 it can be deduced that these does not modify notoriusly the
propagation velocity. On that expression, pressure ratio should be huge for compensating
the influence of the exponent.
44
Figure 43 shows the evolution of Fuel Efficiency, Power, Torque, Specific Fuel
Consumption and Trapping Efficiency when tail pipe diameter is changed.
Figure 43. Evolution of Fuel Efficiency, Power, Torque, Specific Fuel Consumption and Trapping
Efficiency vs dimensional changes on tail pipe diameter
5.3. Comparison between the old exhaust pipe designed with 1-D simulation
software and the new tuned commercial exhaust pipe
The old exhaust pipe designed with 1-D simulation software looks dimensionally very
different to the tuned commercial pipe. Figure 44 shows its really high tuned length (960
mm), as well as its little section variation compared to the commercial pipe (with a tuned
length of 630 mm).
Figure 44. Commercial exhaust pipe (left) and designed exhaust pipe (right)
45
Figure 45 shows the Cylinder Pressure and the Exhaust Port Pressure vs Crankangle
referred to exTDC for both pipes. The Injection Time was lowered to 1.1 ms for the
designed exhaust pipe to reach a stable operation. Lambda did not almost experience
change, since for the same intake pressure, the air flow decreased from 150 to 135 l/min.
Figure 45. Cylinder Pressure and Exhaust Port Pressure vs Crankangle referred to exTDC for the
commercial and the designed exhaust pipes
It is a remarkable observation that although both tuned lengths are much different, the
compression pulse reaches the exhaust port when it should, so both are correctly tuned.
However, the 1-D simulation software designed pipe produces more cycle to cycle
variation. It does not ensure one combustion per cycle, and the maximum pressure for the
average of is lower than the commercial pipe one. It can be also notice that for the
designed exhaust pipe, there is a backflow for the first pressure peak after the opening of
the exhaust port, since the intake port is already open and the intake pressure oscillates
always under 0.21 bar.
46
6. Conclusions
The 2-stroke Otto operation of the engine has been studied and improved.
The main and most notorious improvement for the engine during the development of this
thesis has been the increase of reliability for both the engine and the test bench. Many
sensors have been recalibrated, new ones have been introduced, and some measuring
systems have been optimized. The prevention of failures (preparation of a second block,
spare parts, etc) has enabled a more efficient process of investigation. Test continuity has
increased exponentially along the course of this thesis.
The learning process about the interpretation and prediction of the engine operation has
encouraged the team to reach more efficient solutions to each problem that arises. The
planning, close collaboration with the mechanics, the collective discussion of problems,
and team work have leaded to a the prosecution of an objective of which all the previous
developing teams should fell holders as well: the participation on Shell Ecomarathon
2010, where the Agilis-HCCI-powered car drove for more than 22 km and achieved the
Shell Technical Innovation Award.
47
Figure 46. Agilis-V team and car with the Shell Technical Innovation Award in Lausitzring, Germany
48
7. Future work
The tolerances between the gearwheels and shafts of the compression ratio control system
cause a big fraction of the engine failures. Although the mechanical problems have been
reduced and the engine operation is more secure, a deeper study of the mechanical
transmission should be done in order to prevent vibrations and improve the engine
performance. . It is required an extensive study with the objective to determinate the
exact tolerances for allowing a proper operation of the crankshaft-gearwheels
transmission.
The torque measuring system shows a small variability whenever a change on the test
bench or engine is introduced. Improvement of this system or skipping the gearwheel/belt
transmission is recommended.
The main measuring computer shows slowdown operation when operating different
regulators. This affects the engine operation, specially the speed regulator. A change for a
faster processor is required.
The fuel preparation and mixing process have to be studied and improved. Values of
temperature, pressure, flow, etc, for both air and fuel have to be swept and optimized.
The interactions between spark ignition and compression detonation must be studied in
order to achieve a SI to HCCI transfer procedure. Combustion can still be optimized.
The charge exchange process can be still developed for obtaining different configurations
through combinations of Delivery Ratios and Trapping Efficiencies.
49
8. References
[1] David Larsson, “Development of 22”
Master of Science Thesis MMK2008:36
KTH Industrial engineering and management
[2] John Larsson, “Development of a counter piston two stroke HCCI engine”
Master of Science Thesis MMK2009:74
KTH Industrial engineering and management
[4] Àlez Poyo Muñoz, “Design and assembly of a throttle for an HCCI engine”
Master of Science thesis MMK 2009
50
Appendix 1: Demonstration concerning the Internal DC
θex crank
EPP
Figure 47. Crankshaft, connecting rod and piston assembly, with its dimensions and angular coordinates.
All the units are mm.
c·sin(θ ex crank )
EPP = h + c·cos(θ ex crank ) + l ·cos(arcsin( ) Expression 13
l
Taking in consideration some of the explanations of section 1, the IPP (Intake Piston
Position) is:
c·sin(θ in crank )
IPP = h + c·cos(θ in crank ) + l ·cos(arcsin( )=
l
Expression 14
c·sin(θ ex crank − phase)
h + c·cos(θ ex crank − phase) + l ·cos(arcsin( )
l
The volume of the cylinder contained between the two piston faces can be calculated as:
⎛ D2 ⎞
V = (π ·⎜⎜ ⎟⎟)·( L − EPP − IPP) + Vspark plug & pressure sensor Expression 15
⎝ 4 ⎠
51
For getting the minimum volume, the first and second derivatives are calculated on
expressions 16 and 17.
dV dEPP dIPP
=− − =
dθ ex crank dt dt
h·sin(θ ex crank )
· cos(θ ex crank )
1 h
− c·sin(θ ex crank ) − l·sin(arcsi n( )·
l c 2 ·sin 2 (θ ex crank ) l
1−
l2
− c·sin(θ ex crank − phase)
− l·cos(arcsi n( )·⎜
1 ⎟ ⎛h
·⎜ cos (θ )⎞
⎟
⎜ 1 − c ·sin (θ ex crank ) ⎟ ⎝
l ⎟ l ex crank
2 2
⎠
⎜ 2 ⎟
⎝ l ⎠
⎛
⎜
h·sin(θ ex crank ) ⎜ c 2 ·sin (θ ex crank ) h
cos 2 (θ ex crank )
1
− l·sin(arcsi n( )·⎜ · 2·
⎜ 3 2 1 − c ·sin (θ ex crank )
2
l 2 2 l l
⎜
⎝ l2
⎞
⎟
· sin (θ ex crank )⎟
1 h ⎟
−
c ·sin (θ ex crank )
2 2
l
⎟
1− ⎟
l2 ⎠
2
⎛ ⎞
⎜ ⎟
h·sin(θ ex crank − phase) ⎜ 2
52
⎛
⎜
h·sin(θ ex crank − phase) ⎜ c 2·sin (θ ex crank − phase ) h
cos 2 (θ ex crank − phase )
1
− l·sin(arcsi n( )·⎜ 2
l ⎜ 2 1−
3 c 2
·sin 2
(θ ex crank − phase ) l 2
l
⎜
⎝ l2
⎞
⎟
⎟
· sin (θ ex crank − phase )⎟
1 h
−
c ·sin (θ ex crank ) − phase l
2 2
⎟
1− ⎟
l2 ⎠
Expression 17
Trying with phase/2 as θex crank in the first derivative the solution becomes 0, as it can be
seen on expression 18.
dV
= 0 = −c·sin( phase ) − c·sin(− phase )
dθ ex crank 2 2
h·sin( phase ) 1 h
− l ·sin(arcsin( 2 )· · cos⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟
l l ⎝ 2⎠
c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟
⎝ 2⎠
1−
l2
h·sin(− phase ) 1 h
− l ·sin(arcsin( 2 )· · cos⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟
l l ⎝ 2⎠
c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟
⎝ 2⎠
1− 2
l
Expression 18
While the second derivative of the volume evaluated in the same value is found on
expression 19.
53
d 2V
=
dθ ex crank
2
− l·cos(arcsi n( 2 ⎛
)·⎜ ⎟ ⎜· cos ⎜
⎝ 2 ⎟⎠ ⎟⎠
l ⎝l
⎜ c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟ ⎟
⎜ 1− ⎝ 2⎠⎟
⎜ 2 ⎟
⎝ l ⎠
⎛
⎜
phase ⎜ 2·c 2 ·sin ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟
h·sin( ) ⎜ 1 ⎝ 2⎠h
− l·sin(arcsi n( 2 )·⎜ cos 2 ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟
l l 2
l ⎝ 2⎠
⎜3 c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟
⎜ 1−
2 ⎝ 2 ⎠
⎜
⎝ l2
⎞
⎟
⎟
1 h ⎛ phase ⎞ ⎟
− · sin ⎜
l ⎝ 2 ⎟⎠ ⎟
c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ phase ⎞⎟ ⎟
⎝ 2⎠
1− ⎟⎟
l2 ⎠
2
⎛ ⎞
⎜ ⎟
phase ⎜ ⎟
h·sin( − ) ⎜ 1 ⎟ ·⎛ h cos⎛ − phase ⎞ ⎞
2
− l·cos(arcsi n( 2 )·⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟
l ⎟ l ⎝ 2 ⎠⎠
⎜ c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟ ⎟ ⎝
⎝ 2 ⎠⎟
⎜⎜ 1 − ⎟
⎝ l2 ⎠
⎛
⎜
h·sin( − phase ) ⎜
⎜ 2·c 2 ·sin ⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟
1 ⎝ 2⎠h
− l·sin(arcsi n( 2 )·⎜ cos 2 ⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟
l l 2
l ⎝ 2⎠
⎜3 c 2 ·sin 2 ⎛⎜ − phase ⎞⎟
⎝ 2 ⎠
⎜⎜ 1 −
2
⎝ l2
⎞
⎟
⎟
1 h ⎛ phase ⎞ ⎟
− · sin ⎜ − >0
2⎛ phase ⎞ l ⎝ 2 ⎟⎠ ⎟
c ·sin ⎜ −
2
⎟
⎝ 2 ⎟⎠
1− ⎟⎟
l2 ⎠
Expression 19
54
Appendix 2: Geometrical description MS Excel worksheet
1. Engine dimensions
55
Figure 50. Section of the block showing the exhaust ports.
56
Table 6. Engine geometrical data
Intake half side geometrical data Exhaust half side geometrical data
Intake Port Area 266.5 mm2 Exhaust Port Area 280.6 mm2
Sparkplug and pressure sensor cavities volume (Vspark plug & pressure sensor) 94 mm3
57
2. Calculations
As explained in appendix 1:
c·sin(θ ex crank )
EPP = h1 + c·cos(θ ex crank ) + l ·cos(arcsin( ) Expression 20
l
c·sin(θ in crank )
IPP = h2 + c·cos(θ in crank ) + l ·cos(arcsin( )=
l
Expression 21
c·sin(θ ex crank − phase)
h2 + c·cos(θ ex crank − phase) + l ·cos(arcsin( )
l
The ITSO (Intake port Total Surface Opened) and ETSO (Exhaust port Total Surface
Opened) are calculated according to “if” programming sentences, which can be
simplified in the way explained below.
For ITSO:
• If IPP> e1→ ITSO = 0
⎡ a
• If e1>IPP>(e1-r1)→ ITSO = n1·⎢(e1 − IPP)·( π ·D· 1 ) − 2·( e1 − IPP)·r1
⎣ 360
r12 ⎧⎪⎛⎜ ⎡ ⎛ IPP − (e1 − r1 ) ⎞⎤ ⎞⎟
+ 2· ·⎨ [arcsin (1)] − ⎢arcsin⎜⎜ ⎟⎟⎥
2 ⎪⎜⎝ ⎣ ⎝ r ⎠⎦ ⎟⎠
⎩ 1
58
For ETSO:
• If EPP> e2→ ETSO = 0
⎡ a
• If e2>EPP>(e2-r2)→ ETSO = n 2 ·⎢(e2 − IPP)·( π ·D· 2 ) − 2·( e2 − IPP)·r2
⎣ 360
r 2 ⎧⎪⎛ ⎡ ⎛ EPP − (e2 − r2 ) ⎞⎤ ⎞⎟
+ 2· 2 ·⎨⎜ [arcsin (1)] − ⎢arcsin⎜⎜ ⎟⎟⎥
2 ⎪⎜⎝ ⎣ ⎝ r2 ⎠⎦ ⎟⎠
⎩
1⎛ ⎡ ⎛ EPP − (e2 − r2 ) ⎞⎤ ⎞⎟⎫⎪⎤
+ ⎜ [sin (2·arcsin(1)] − ⎢sin( 2·arcsin ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟⎥ ⎬⎥ Expression 25
2 ⎜⎝ ⎣ ⎝ r2 ⎠⎦ ⎟⎠⎪⎭⎥⎦
⎡ a π ·r 2 ⎤
If (e2-r2)>EPP>(b2+r2)→ ETSO = n 2 ·⎢(e2 − EPP)·( π · D· 2 ) − 2·r2 + 2· 2 ⎥
2
•
⎣ 360 4 ⎦
Expression 26
⎡ a π ·r 2
If (b2+r2)>EPP>b2→ ETSO = n 2 ·⎢(e2 − EPP )·( π · D· 2 ) − 2·r2 + 2· 2
2
•
⎣ 360 4
r 2 ⎧⎪⎛ ⎡ ⎛ EPP − (b2 + r2 ) ⎞⎤ ⎞
− 2·( b2 + r2 − EPP )·r2 + 2· 2 ·⎨⎜ ⎢arcsin⎜⎜ ⎟⎟⎥ − [arcsin (0 )]⎟
2 ⎪⎜⎝ ⎣ ⎝ r2 ⎠⎦ ⎟
⎠
⎩
1 ⎛⎡ ⎛ EPP − (b2 + r2 ) ⎞⎤ ⎞⎫⎪⎤
+ ⎜ ⎢sin ⎜⎜ 2·arcsin( ⎟⎟⎥ − [sin(2·arcsin (0 )]⎟⎬⎥ Expression 27
2 ⎜⎝ ⎣ ⎝ r2 ⎠⎦ ⎟ ⎪⎥
⎠ ⎭⎦
⎡ a π ·r 2 ⎤
If b2>EPP→ ETSO = n1·⎢(e2 − b2 )·( π ·D· 2 ) − 4·r2 + 4· 2 ⎥
2
• Expression 28
⎣ 360 4 ⎦
It can be demonstrated that the error made by taking the circular surface of the ports as
planar and not curve is not so big.
Figure 51. Section of the block showing the exhaust ports and the detail of circular surface of the ports.
59
⎛ ⎛ r ⎞⎞
⎜ 2·arcsin ⎜ 1 ⎟ ⎟
⎜ ⎜ D 2⎟⎟
π · D·⎜ ⎝ ⎠ − 2·r
360 ⎟ 1
⎜ ⎟
⎜ ⎟ 2.0011552 − 2
ε1 = ⎝ ⎠ ·100 = ·100 = 0.0577% Expression 29
⎛ ⎛ r1 ⎞ ⎞ 2.0011552
⎜ 2·arcsin ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ ⎟
⎜ ⎝ D 2 ⎠⎟
π ·D·⎜ ⎟
⎜ 360 ⎟
⎜ ⎟
⎝ ⎠
⎛ ⎛ r ⎞⎞
⎜ 2·arcsin ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎟
⎜ ⎜ D 2⎟⎟
π ·D·⎜ ⎝ ⎠ − 2·r
360 ⎟ 2
⎜ ⎟
⎜ ⎟ 2.0011552 − 2
ε2 = ⎝ ⎠ ·100 = ·100 = 0.2316% Expression 30
⎛ ⎛ r2 ⎞ ⎞ 2.0011552
⎜ 2·arcsin ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟
⎜ ⎝ D 2 ⎟⎠ ⎟
π ·D·⎜ ⎟
⎜ 360 ⎟
⎜ ⎟
⎝ ⎠
The volume of the cylinder contained between the two piston faces can be calculated, as
said on Appendix 1, with the expression 31.
⎛ D2 ⎞
V = (π ·⎜⎜ ⎟⎟)·( L − EPP − IPP) + Vspark plug & pressure sensor Expression 31
⎝ 4 ⎠
Trapping Compression Ratio is calculated with excel programming, by looking for the
minimum volume and the volume when both ports are closed in the compression stroke,
expression 32.
Vtrapped
TCR = Expression 32
Vmin imum
Many other calculations can be easily done over IPP and EPP with MS excel
programming, such as the angular period where one port is open, the angle interval
during which both ports are open, etc.
60
3. Graphs
Figure 53. Exhaust and Intake ports Total Surface Opened, Pistons´ height, and Volume between pistons vs
Intake side Crankshaft Angle
61
Appendix 3: Exhaust Pipe designer MS Excel worksheet
The process of design has been described on section 4.2.
Once the tuned length and the equivalent initial diameters are found (expression 6), the
design is based on empirical expressions for calculating lengths and internal diameters of
each stretch.
62
Figure 55. Nomenclature of the dimensions of the designed exhaust pipe
Lengths are obtained according to these coefficients applied to the tuned length (see table
6).
Table 7. Calculations of the stretches’ lengths
KL1 KL2 KL3 KL4 KL5 KL6 KL7
0.1 0.275 0.183 0.092 0.11 0.24 0.24
While diameters D2 and D3 are calculated by coefficients defined in a more complex way,
multiplying D1 (consult table 8).
63
With 1.25<kh<2.0. kh is called “horn coefficient” and determinates the area profile
evolution of the diffuser with respect to its axial coordinate.
L1 86.7 mm d1 21.3 mm
L2 238.5 mm d2 35.4 mm
L3 158.7 mm d3 35.6 mm
L4 79.8 mm d4 42.0 mm
L5 95.4 mm d7 13.2 mm
L6 208.2 mm
L7 208.2 mm
64
Appendix 4: Calibration of the Optrand C33233-Q pressure
transducer
The description of Optrand C33233-Q pressure sensor can be found on section 3.2.3 in
Ref [2] (notice that the old code was C32233-Q). Since it is a dynamic sensor, the static
calibration procedure needs of some particularities that will be commented:
• Prepare the sensor with a standard connection, following the scheme on figure 56
and table 12.
2 2
3 3
1 1
4 4
Table 12. Wires, its functions, and the pins of the connector where they should be attached
Color Function Pin number
Red Power Supply 1
White Signal 2
Bare Case ground-shield 3
Black Ground 4
Green Diagnostic-static calibration -
• Couple correctly the sensor to the calibration circuit by fitting the seating ring of
the sensor (5.8 mm diameter). Ensure that there isn´t (too much) air between the
sensor membrane and the oil level, by taking the last to an adequate height. On
this purpose, the use of the calibration circuit should be learnt: valve 1 allows
flow from the tank, valve 2 permits the oil to reach the open-end of the circuit
(that would be closed by the sensor), while the intermediate volume can be filled
or emptied by turning the bolt. So close the open-end valve, open the tank valve,
fill the intermediate volume by unscrewing the bolt, close the tank valve, open the
open-end valve, and screw the bolt to making the oil of the intermediate volume
to reach and adequate level on the open end. If more oil is needed, repeat the
operation.
65
Platform on a cushion of oil 2) Open-end valve
Oil Tank
1) Tank valve
Bolt
• By using the potentiometer, adjust the output signal of the sensor to 0.6 V in order
to achieve static calibration. This value should be constant during 20 minutes
before starting calibration.
• Load and unload pressures (weights) in the rotating platform on a cushion of oil,
by screwing clockwise and unscrewing anticlockwise the bolt (ensure the open-
end valve is open and the tank valve is closed). Loads should follow always 0 bar
intercalated series, like the one shown on table 12. Ensure 0 bar pressure by
opening the valve 1. While following the process, take the times for each load and
take also a slow PDAQ log is with the PDAQslowlog application.
66
Table 12. Applied pressure and time when it was applied
Time Pressure (bar)
0 0
1:23 25
1:39 0
2:16 50
2:35 0
3:42 60
4:05 0
4:52 85
5:10 0
5:52 105
6:07 0
• Open the log file with MS Excel and look for stable points for each pressure.
Figure 58. Cylinder pressure sensor output voltage vs Time graph on the load and unload stages.
• Use Pkalz program to make an analysis of the log and obtain the calibration
coefficients.
• Get the constant variation with temperature, and extrapolate the value of the
calibration constant at the correct working temperature (for the engine operation,
about 150ºC inside the combustion chamber), by using the slope between the
manufacturer values.
67
Figure 59. Sensor data on its label.
Figure 60. Sensor constant vs Temperature, for manufacturer and calibration values.
68
Appendix 5: Calibration of the Gems 2200AGA4001A2UA
pressure transducer
The description of Gems R114684 pressure sensor can be found on section 3.2.
Vacuum-
Pressure
valve
DPI 705
PV411A
manometer
hand
pump
Pump
actuator
69
• Open the log file with MS Excel and look for stable points for each load.
Figure 62. Intake pressure signal vs Time graph on the load and load stages, with its correspondent
trendlines.
• Build a Pressure vs Pressure sensor signal table or graph, and calculate the
trendline parameters, slope and intercept.
Figure 63. Pressure vs Intake pressure sensor signal graph on the load stage with its correspondent
trendline.
70
SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 1.0000
R Square 1.0000
Adjusted R
Square 1.0000
Standard
Error 0.0037
Observations 6
• Introduce the results in the Pressure channel of Cell4. Remember the correct way
to introduce them (expression 33).
71
Appendix 6: Calibration of the torque sensor
The torque sensor is based on a commercial Burster 8523-50 S/N 307215 force sensor
attached to an arm. Its descriptions can be found on section 3.7 and on (see section 3.2.4
in Ref[2]).
Figure 65. Force sensor signal vs Time graph on the load and load stages.
• Calculate the moment due to each load by simply using expression 34.
72
where g is the gravitational acceleration.
• Build a Moment vs Force Sensor Signal table or graph, and calculate the trendline
parameters, slope and intercept.
Figure 66. Moment vs Force Sensor signal graph on the load and load stages, with its correspondent
trendlines.
SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 0.9999
R Square 0.9998
Adjusted R
Square 0.9998
Standard
Error 0.0087
Observations 15
73
• Introduce the results in the Torque channel of Cell4. Remember the correct way to
introduce them, as in expression 35.
74
Appendix 7: Calibration of the air flow meter
The air flow meter is a differential pressure based on, type Setra 265 (complete code
26512RWD2BT1C), installed on an exhaust gases catalyst the intake circuit.
75
Table 14. Average flow over ten measurements and time when average was taken
Time (min:sec) Flow (l/min)
0:00 0
1:33 2.093
2:10 6.499
22:40 10.02
3:08 12.56
3:32 14.39
4:00 17.3
• Open the log file with MS Excel and look for stable points for each output signal
step. Notice that Setra 265 differential pressure sensor has not sensibility working
under 6 l/min when working as flow meter. Therefore, that working points should
be avoided or skipped (in the table above, all the flows under 6 L/min should be
taken as 0 l/min, since sensor will deliver voltage equivalent to this flow).
Figure 69. Setra 265 differential pressure sensor signal vs Time graph.
76
• Build a Flow vs Differential pressure sensor signal table or graph, and calculate
the trendline parameters, slope and intercept.
Figure 70. Flow vs Setra 265 differential-pressure-meter signal, with its correspondent trendlines.
SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 0.9995
R Square 0.9990
Adjusted R
Square 0.9987
Standard
Error 0.1471
Observations 5
77
• Introduce the results in the Air flow channel of Cell4. Remember the correct way
to introduce them, as in expression 36.
• For other expressions, like Mass flow or Delivery Ratio, create the adequate
channels on Cell4 and follow expressions 37 and 38.
⎛ g ⎞ ⎛ l ⎞ ⎛g⎞
Mass flow ⎜ ⎟ = Volumetric flow ⎜ ⎟·ρ ⎜ ⎟ =
⎝ min ⎠ ⎝ min ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠
101325 Pa
Intake Absolute Pr essureChannel Cell 4 (bar )·
⎛ l ⎞ 1 bar 1 m3
Volumetric flowChannel Cell 4 ⎜ ⎟· · =
⎝ min ⎠ ⎛ J ⎞ 1 kg 1000 l
R ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟· ·Room Absolute TemperatureChannel Cell 4 (K )
⎝ kg ·K ⎠ 1000 g
⎛ l ⎞ Intake Absolute Pr essureChannel Cell 4 (bar )
Volumetric flowChannel Cell 4 ⎜ ⎟· ·353.05
⎝ min ⎠ Room Absolute TemperatureChannel Cell 4 (K )
Expression 37
1
=
Atmospheric Pr essure (Pa )
·
⎛ J ⎞ 1 kg
R ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟· ·Room Absolute TemperatureChannel Cell 4 (K )
⎝ kg ·K ⎠ 1000 g
⎛ g ⎞
Mass flowChannel Cell 4 ⎜ ⎟
⎝ min ⎠ ·0.0578
⎛ rev ⎞ 1
Angular Speed Channel Cell 4 ⎜ ⎟·
⎝ min ⎠ Room Absolute TemperatureChannel Cell 4 (K )
Expression 38
78
Appendix 8: 12 V power electric map
79