Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reading Hypertext
Reading Hypertext
Reading Hypertext
about reading
invasive that it has infiltrated every aspect
of human life in varying degrees. The
intellectual aspect of a person is indeed
hypertext: one of those. Lenhart, Simon, and
Graziano (2001) reported that 94% of
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH
18
reading skills are necessary, but not sufficient, to computer automating the process of connecting
read and learn from information on the Internet.” one piece of information to another.
The same line of argument is supported by
To further understand the reading environments
Anderson (2003) who believes that there are
today’s learners read in, Coiro and Dobler (2007,
differences in processing print and non-print
pp. 219-220) identified four main differences
materials. With the nature of hypertext, he is
between print and hypertext. They agree with
convinced that nonprint and oftentimes nonlinear
other scholars that, first, hypertext prompts
texts present more challenges. He states, “We
readers to employ unique cognitive processes and
cannot assume a simple transfer of L2 reading
strategies (Landow, 1994; Reinking, 2000;
skills and strategies from the hardcopy
Snyder, 1996); second, that though both print and
environment to the online environment” (p. 5).
hypertext environments typically provide
This then calls for more research investigations
supportive navigational features such as table of
knowing that hypertext and hypermedia
contents or network map, the actual content of
environments are relatively young compared with
hypertext is hidden beneath multiple layers of
other areas in literacy (Bolaños, 2008).
information not viewable with traditional
This paper was conceptualized to discuss what previewing procedures such as rapidly leafing
hypertext is, then present a synthesis of different through the pages of a book (Foltz, 1996; Otter &
studies involving hypertext, and as corollary, Johnson, 2000); third, contemporary hypertexts
point out implications these studies have for often incorporate “hyperlinked icons” like
comprehension instruction particularly in the navigation buttons and dynamic image maps to
country. provide a visual representation of a hyperlink,
rather than a textual one (Kinzer & Leander,
2003); and fourth, the authors’ intertextual
What is hypertext? connections are more obvious and immediately
accessible in hypertext compared with printed text
Nelson (1987) described hypertext as a series of (Caney, 1999).
text chunks connected by links that offer the
In addition, Sutherland-Smith (2002, pp. 664-665)
readers different pathways. He further defined it
as non-linear or multi-linear, non-sequential, laid the differences between web text reading and
nodal, and allows for the readers’ navigation print text reading in terms of additional features
the former have, which according to her, would
control. Burbules and Callister (2000) looked at
hypertext as “a kind of informational environment mean that alternative reading strategies are
in which textual materials and ideas are linked to required to decode meaning. Among other
one another in multiple ways” (p. 43). They characteristics, Sutherland-Smith claim that web-
based text a) permits nonlinear strategies of
acknowledge that, at present, there are a variety of
hypertext learning environments and they all share thinking; b) allows nonhierarchical strategies; c)
these common characteristics: a) association of offers non-sequential strategies; d) requires visual
literacy skills to understand multimedia
ideas through links; b) a choice of paths for
readers, and not all readers follow the same path; components; e) is interactive, with the reader able
c) immediate access to reference documents; d) to add, change, or move text; and f) enables a
blurring of the relationship between reader and
movement through hypertext by browsing or
navigating; e) focus of thought is always shifting writer.
in a hypertext environment; and f) hypertext Studies involving hypertext
supports constructivism. They stress that, with this
nature of information presentation, readers must For easy and quick reference, synthesis of studies
take a much more active role in determining the on hypertext is presented in Table 1 noting the
quality and coherence of the texts they read. investigators, the participants, the independent
Snyder (1998) further described hypertext by and dependent variables, and the findings.
saying that it provides a means of arranging
information in a non-linear manner with the
November 2011
19
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH
20
November 2011
21
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH
22
November 2011
23
As can generally be observed, studies present As these studies are still relatively few, more
hypertext as a positive environment where investigations are needed so as to see patterns
today’s learners can read in. Among other good that would lead to improvements in both theories
trends are hypertext’s potential to enhance and practices.
comprehension, to provoke a more interesting
learning environment, to provide challenges that
lead to readers’ discovery of and imperative use
of strategies, and to improve metacognition in
the readers.
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH
24
Implications for comprehension instruction individuals. Teachers then must devise ways
that will enable them to approach the idea of
Given the results of the studies presented in this reading and its concomitant theories in a
paper and the goal of improving students’ simple way that emphasizes its pragmatic
comprehension while reading in a hypertext application to life. Through this, learners
context, the following implications for will be able to realize better the value of
comprehension instruction are offered: reading. If learners are informed of the true
1. The need for the inclusion of hypertext relevance of reading to their lives, there are
reading in the syllabi. It can be observed bigger chances that they themselves will put
premium on it.
that up to this date, not all tertiary
institutions have incorporated reading in 4. The recognition that regardless of
ICT (information and communication discipline, every teacher is a literacy
technology) in their Communication Arts / teacher. Considering that all fields of
English syllabi. This must be because of the knowledge are heavily available on the
relatively long-standing assumption that a Internet and that teachers are expected to be
reader who can read in print can equally and among the top consumers if not producers of
successfully read in the online setting. As knowledge on the World Wide Web, they
some studies reveal (Bolaños, 2009; Chen, are then expected to acknowledge that they
2009; Dail, 2004; MacDonald, 2005), the can contribute significantly to the literacy
said assumption may not always be the case. development of their students. Every teacher
Hence, the need for syllabi that use blended then can lead their students to the proper use
learning environments. of Internet such as reading useful articles,
answering good exercises, composing, and
2. The demand for stressing comprehension
strategy instruction. Given some findings submitting – all from there. Furthermore, if
that hypertext requires additional if not students see that their teachers are judicious
distinct comprehension strategies (Bolaños, users of the information on the net, they
would be better influenced and this would
2009; Dail, 2004;) and the fact that
strategies enhance comprehension (Duke & lead to the learners’ being able to keep pace
Pearson, 2002; Pressley, 1998), strategy with the rapid technological developments.
instruction, especially explicit teaching or 5. The need to consider coherence in both
teacher modeling and direct instruction of content and structure. Teachers who are
comprehension strategies, should be technology savvy and can design lessons
prioritized in the classroom. Examples of using computer applications must consider
these strategies are scrolling the document, logical and consistent presentation of the
skimming the text, note-taking by hand, text. As the study of Lopez Colon (2008)
summarizing information, relying on prior demonstrates, novice readers would rely on
knowledge (Dail, 2004), and rereading, coherence and structure of the text for them
questioning, inferring (Bolaños, 2009). to gain better comprehension. Thus, every
Doing this will help develop independent educational software designer should
readers who are not intimidated by the consider the mental representation of the
features of multimedia tools which, learners with how they create such
observably, are getting more and more materials. This can also be an opportune
sophisticated if not complex. time to embellish the design with
appropriate audio and visual effects in right
3. The necessity for a simple yet effective
approach to teaching reading. Oftentimes, amount that would heighten interest in the
the process of reading is discussed in a learners and increase the potential of the
material for comprehension.
technical manner that learners do not see the
deeper relevance of this mother skill to their 6. The call for emphasizing metacognition.
overall success as students and as Since hypertext allows for greater learner
November 2011
25
References
Al-Seghayer, K. (2003). The impact of the presence Chen, D.-T. (1993). Reading in hypertext: A
or absence of organizational devices on the comparison of two strategies for teaching middle
construction of a coherent mental representation of school students hypertext processing skills.
hypertext content by intermediate ESL readers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of
Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Oregon.
Pittsburgh.
Chen, H.-Y. (2009). Online reading comprehension
Anderson, N. J. (2003). Scrolling, clicking, and strategies among general and special education
reading English: Online reading strategies in a elementary and middle school students.
second/foreign language [Electronic version]. The Unpublisheddoctoral dissertation, Michigan State
Reading Matrix, 3(3), 1-33. University.
Bolaños, E. A. (2008, December). Comprehension Chiappone, L. L. (2003). A comparative study of
strategies of good L2 readers in printed text and English language learners reading storybooks in
hypertext environments: Implications for classroom traditional print and digital formats. Unpublished
reading and instruction. Paper presented at the 4th doctoral dissertation, University of Miami.
Philippine Association for Language Teaching, Inc.
International Conference on Language Coiro, J., & Dobler, E. (2007). Exploring the online
Education,Manila, the Philippines. reading comprehension strategies used by sixth-grade
Caney, D. (1999). Inside/outside intertextuality. skilled readers to search for and locate information
Paper presented at the On/Off+Across: Language, on theInternet [Electronic version]. Reading
Identity, and Technology Conference, Universityof Research Quarterly, 42(2), 214-257.
Westminster, England. Retrieved December 7, 2008, Dail, J. S. (2004). Reading in an online hypertext
from www.overthere.com.au/digital/textfields.html environment: A case study of tenth grade English
students. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, The
Florida State University.
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH
26
Duke, N., & Pearson, D. (2002). Effective practices 336). Newark: DE: International Reading
for developing reading comprehension. In A.E. Association.
Farstrup & S. J. Samuels (Eds.), What research has
Leu, D. J. Jr., Kinzer, C. K., Coiro, J., & Cammack,
to say about reading instruction (pp. 205-242).
D. (2004). Towards a theory of new literacies
Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
emerging from the Internet and other ICT. In R. B.
Foltz, P. W. (1993). Readers' comprehension and Ruddell & N. Unrau (Eds.), Theoretical models and
strategies in linear text and hypertext. Unpublished processes of reading (5th ed., pp. 1570-1613).
doctoral dissertation, University of Colorado at Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
Boulder.
Lopez Colon, G. (2008). Reading comprehension of
Foltz, P. W. (1996). Comprehension, coherence, and novice readers in a hypertext structured with devices
strategies in hypertext and linear text. In J. F. Rouet, designed to facilitate reading comprehension.
J. J. Levonen, A. Dillon, & R. J. Spiro (Eds.), Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of
Hypertext and cognition (pp. 109-136). Mahwah, NJ: Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras (Puerto Rico).
Erlbaum.
MacDonald, E. C. (2005). A comparison of students'
Hayden, S. B. (1997). An investigation into the effect use of surveying, predicting, and setting purposes
and patterns of usage of a computer-mediated text in for reading as a reading comprehension strategy in
reading comprehension in French. Unpublished linear text and hypertext. Unpublished doctoral
doctoral dissertation, The Pennsylvania State dissertation, Widener University.
University.
MacNeal, L. G. (2000). Epistemic beliefs and
Hermosa, N. N. (2006). ICT applications in the comprehension in a hypertext system. Unpublished
reading classroom. The RAP Journal, 29, 14-17. doctoral dissertation, Widener University.
Hoffman, S. Q. (1998). The effect of hypertext Nelson, T. H. (1987). Literary machines. Sausalito,
environment on the reading comprehension of second CA, USA: Mindful Press.
language learners in an intermediate-level
Otter, M., & Johnson, H. (2000). Lost in hyperspace:
collegeGerman course. Unpublished doctoral
Metrics and mental models. Interacting With
dissertation, University of South Alabama.
Computers, 13, 1-40.
Hsu, C.-Y. (1997).Tailoring the presentation of non-
Pressley, M. (1998). Comprehension strategies
linear text for reading comprehension: A literate
instruction. In J. Osborn & F. Lehr (Eds.), Literacy
programming approach based on intersegment
for all: Issues in teaching and learning (pp. 113 -
textcohesion similarity. Unpublished doctoral
133). New York: The Guilford Press.
dissertation, Stevens Institute of Technology.
Reinking, D. (2000). Me and my hypertext:): A
Kinzer, C.K. & Leander, K. (2003). Technology and
multiple digression analysis of technology and
the Language Arts: Implications of an expanded
literacy (sic). In N. D. Padak et al. (Eds.),
definition of literacy. In J. Flood, D. Lapp,
Distinguished educators on reading:
J.R.Squire, & J.M. Jensen (Eds.), Handbook of
Contributions that have shaped effective
research on teaching the English language arts (2nd
literacyinstruction (pp. 280-304). Newark, DE:
ed., pp. 546-566). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
International Reading Association.
Landow, G. P. (1994). What’s a critic do? Critical
Retterer, O. J. (1991). Learning from a hypertext:
theory in the age of hypertext. In G. P. Landow
The effect of reading interactive text containing non-
(Ed.), Hyper/Text/Theory (pp. 1-48). Baltimore, MD:
sequential, associative linkages on
Johns Hopkins University Press.
comprehension.Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
Lenhart, A., Simon, M., & Graziano, M. (2001). The The University of Toledo.
Internet and education: Findings of the Pew
Snyder, I. (1996). Hypertext: The electronic
Internet & American Life Project. Washington, DC:
labyrinth. Melbourne, Australia: Melbourne
Pew Internet & American Life Project.
University Press.
Leu, D. J., Jr. (2002). The new literacies: Research on
Snyder, I. (1998). Beyond the hype: Reassessing
reading instruction with the Internet. In A. E.
hypertext. London & New York: Routledge.
Farstrup & S. J. Samuels (Eds.), What research has
to say about reading instruction (3rd ed.) (pp. 310-
November 2011
27
Position Statement on
New Literacies and 21st Century Technologies
Summary
Bolaños…What research says about reading hypertext: Implications for reading instruction RESEARCH