a | Epistemology Futures STEPHEN HETHERINGTON CLARENDON PRESS + OXFORD9 On the Gettier Problem problem Wien GIy cto yes pope get eis ha hte wt meth wong ‘ih the Gere Polen By the ay 197, + numb of asd re ‘Mize wo axommodee Ge (1963) cane ape te non TTR, ver Michael Cas (1963) sme s-helemmas propo aur inudebiity sne begining with Ee (198) md Late a Pae (056) and Galena 907 erga ca ony among ohn Thee es ad nts fre eateries esas eon had en fe ‘ny oe fier end mare cone outros Nel war So Sinai the wes soreen acne fbn coor "nial gba anual sans ipl We mghe pest the opin ofthe mow eae pcos ove ben nde oy nee he mal age fprofeainl pins B the aes Pen ‘ts dings well ha shad bona eed pe 1. THE GETTIER PROBLEM PROBLEM Some eines wre piney ge and toe gee ws ng ‘ell tpl down the Gee Plea bre toy septal ‘nett cases oe ough hy i ot ano tee lone ay ‘See neal de Geir robe eae tinge a {dancin wi the fin and comet of al ‘lo Inne cane enchant led ot ine a te ‘cena 9 the kon tt con. Tha scm ‘Shans wih te compe comeony mad hat amen sac pi ‘Sphesth areas mtd genta ath pola gan ‘Roping elton cour ely tobe sean oe pls i SES i i ee a (te onion ren 1 ‘Boop she ae ie fr pose andenanding Ante poplar ‘nr ofthe pood wa, "Why dot you go publ» ike mein aces?) ‘Aboreal mr sogsted at he Geir roe ws nfl pois {ima poop” ‘One ate de poset ayes hago show ees is ‘he cnpiny sinetmermeandergeomfieny Fee ere a 0 hd ae i i ig (acta ns Sepsniaere eh Sed bee Tpit weyers date neta ea ec cape ‘End a's me me me omg 3 Fk {shrek mel etd (Wee nba oilseed shreae w HIE) oy oe poptios {rok Sofi tng noe ea echo des apt “Tejalntcingy mere sane wagon eon ster of mente fcr Cv manay omer anal ee ‘Shc ged cy member Cs tam ef Pad Foetus tm be of Be cg hae ato ped say yt a edn omer ‘eed with ch «monte, we may be mbl to hink of fahren ‘ump briny arora ened severe ‘thea coins ‘eon simia apo sched 1 the. nny sir cing je fr exe she Gan aa af pearing thea SAR Re aeRO ays scaulaea ae ntama Sams tanger saree serene $eeoikiaatennabra scleroapeqetanenhetae ovinl Poet nage Otel goal Serer ate ch oad mth ded ag aarp ene150 am yen soc emensoninaygrted by Dvd Levit he Kepler ‘henry of ngs ering the ec fx tt of perl ny gh tie he near a uy. Why Pepe he eee ‘ata hist cet of cing penalty. Or eg ws ja a ‘how ene fave neve ee he esting spent te ‘hac did i el emia oni hat ao er ana ply ‘ope sy secany and seat cones fr» Pipl nur oct har ere sed Ade shel bees nite ‘he Gate roe lem ve ousped al ates in heen fairey cd the oer ane poe ne ach he ee fe comply at he Genny Mare egy te seng won ‘dhe Gee peje? Dost eon tee presen? "What sale he ‘Geer Poon enh of ening wha cnn meg ihe Gti pos The har esse cep erty pases thspeper ioe andes te Lalo ‘Either acing mong nth he peje pope ocean threo ‘hou proces coho a gy int mh ans 1M, UNINTERESTING SOLUTIONS Otay se Geir Pb aca atthe ec theft oo of nog codon to be adda ')T and Boeck Gee comet ‘can theicneyoFJTB Thera k lads es ea eR ont ian eal ee Sle (975.0 ea Hoek rastoadmea ease tink (anes hme i he eet Showiatiea cetacean Ea en mmntemerenar eee Lame pa a did tn ae Note peg he inne (One Ge Pi pri 151 “anceps the acini faking» phil inreting ston ‘niga od sf cnc neat sn fen oc the ‘dot ng exempt Oger and ancl ounretale ena ‘roeallowedofenne, bases eon posy wold bene ‘heca caiman eenty or aficen “That tur slone wold have made oe lwpbes orn the Gir poe, Deca af ely Quinn sep soa oneepl rand Ec? th very ides ofa concep ath sia then ek concep ‘el athe sour Knowing obs minaed (And Geer pcan (24 pica le thm vesgning he concept of Knowing een into th 1970) Bat een fone rs Quinn sept, thea the as sth thn sacar slo oe Geer ren pole oe the ‘Qelean complaint pple sco the bart doe no eel orn wa ‘wh the Gener pj that snot wrong wih any ter mt compa (eet sch a thar of eying alae cooly or lng ween, ofr ‘Siemans eying 0 celne ‘cnt or Schl ‘Se. Son, one anne mpl, spine. fr example, he pesca ey Ire a he Spptheal cera al malo wi scene onal a ody concept do ot bar ha one riny The counersmpe hat et ‘he Gerinerrare heap aay ually ae atar any aero ‘Seer fvonl rts er cones bs omalopeay poste Soe ar il Tied, by the sme tke. eniely Fost by any ‘sandal hae TB without knowing: people acy do that Soo al hat ‘57 Quinn bas show, eso only fsa bt very rng 0 ak ‘whe mu be aed w mee JD inorder eo connie tee of kon any ner ae mee centr robe robin, tap inlighy seeming ref erating Denying: Baty was ocasnaly ogee that Gere wee tec bese adn ay J wt ye (her hr no ttr amet cota eviece isocnyee pa ‘tin Thagh blr S rece war on gh onary nt ‘noieetring war ac erence ig rand 2 ‘sly jst ator 190). “This unereing bc eb Wha the example showed hat soamountornteagh fede thar ofenalingeiene wos d,s ‘her jntaon wares not een Gee chars way dot inete have gt eran adn ois avengh These dint 1 Dna Qn 90 50. Re in i ce ‘ryaglapne ear Setter gh sma in Meat sen pea mopeds cn pt ie