Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sectarian Militancy-Case Study of Jhang
Sectarian Militancy-Case Study of Jhang
Sectarian Militancy-Case Study of Jhang
CONTEXTUALIZING SECTARIAN
MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN: A CASE
STUDY OF JHANG1
TA H I R K AM R A N
University of Southampton
Given the scale and kind of chaos in Iraq after the end of the rule
of Saddam Hussein, the issue of sectarianism has assumed a new
significance, as a possible ‘Clash within Muslim Civilization’ seems
imminent. The issue is one that merits serious scholarly investigation that
goes beyond understanding it as a side-effect of so-called fundamental-
ism or as a response to national or international political developments.
In most of the studies done so far on the issue of sectarianism in Pakistan
the local context has not been fully explored. This article examines
sectarianism in the district of Jhang, which became the epicentre of
violence against the Shi6a in the 1980s and 1990s. From Jhang it spread
to Multan, Faisalabad, Sargodha and Bahawalpur and thence, beyond
Punjab, to Karachi, and also the Tribal and Northern Areas.
If sectarian murders in Jhang could be linked to a single event, it would
be the assassination of the radical Deobandi2 cleric and leader of the
1
The names of persons, places and groups have been spelled out in the
characters of the Latin alphabet as they are most commonly found in the
established usage in Pakistan—formal transliteration would not be helpful to
anyone following up references containing these names. In those instances where
it seemed appropriate, formal transliteration is provided in parentheses at first
occurrence of the name.—Ed.
2
‘In the case of the Deobandis, devotion to the Prophet himself, to his
teaching, and to those who, as his heirs, offered guidance, served as the basis for
new bonds and for cultural and psychological resources in a period of consider-
able socio-political change [. . .] an acceptance of the period of the life of the
Prophet and the first decades of Islam as providing the fundamental examples of
behaviour and belief; all seek self consciously, by a wide variety of means,
ß The Author (2008). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Oxford Centre for Islamic
Studies. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oxfordjournals.org
56 t ah ir k am r an
militant Sunni organization Sipah-i Sahaba (Sip:h-i 4aA:ba), Haqq
Nawaz Jhangvi (Eaqq Naw:z Jhangv;),3 on 22 February 1990. He had
just set foot out of his house around 8 p.m. to attend the wedding of
Shaykh Shawkat 6Al;’s son in nearby Ahrar Park, when two motor-
cyclists emerged from the corner of the street, approached Haqq
Nawaz, sprayed him with bullets and melted away into the darkness
of the wintry night.4 The victim’s diminutive, blood-splattered body was
rushed to the District Headquarters Hospital, Jhang, where he was
pronounced clinically dead. However the legacy of death and hatred that
the incident bequeathed survives to this day. Soon after that incident,
Radicalization of Shii and Sunni Identities’, Modern Asian Studies, 323 (1998):
689–716; Mohammad Waseem, ‘Political Sources of Islamic Militancy in
Pakistan’ in Ian Talbot (ed.), The Deadly Embrace: Religion, Violence and
Politics in India and Pakistan 1947–2002 (Karachi: Oxford University Press,
2007), 145–63.
11
Mukhtar Ahmed Ali, Sectarian Problems of Pakistan: A Case Study of
Jhang (Colombo: Regional Centre for Strategic Studies, 2000).
12
Urban Jhang consists of three distinct parts, namely Jhang City which is the
old historical site and the ruling seat of the Sials; Jhang Meghiana, a relatively
later addition, to which the British gave the name of Jhang Sadar and to which
they shifted the District Courts and offices for fear of floods; and, Satellite Town,
founded during the 1960s. See: Government of Pakistan, District Census Report
of Jhang (Islamabad: Statistical Division, 2000), 13.
13
Ibid, 92–3.
Downloaded from jis.oxfordjournals.org at University Of Illinois Library on October 14, 2010
61
14
Gazetteer of Jhang District 1883–84 (Lahore: Sang-i M;l Publications,
2000), 50. Drawing on the Census of 1881, it states that the total number of
Muslims in the district was 326,919, among whom 11,835 were Shi6a and only 8
Wahhabis.
15
Gazetteer of Jhang District 1929, 69.
16
Tabarra: i.e. cursing the first three caliphs, Ab< Bakr, 6Umar and 6Uthm:n,
who according to the Shi6a deceitfully deprived 6Al;, the Prophet’s son-in-law and
cousin, of his right to succession. Therefore the Shi6a resort to tabarra. To
counter that agitation Majlis-i AAr:r started the practice of madh-i BaA:ba,
wherein the Sunnis recited verses praising the four rightly-guided caliphs. That
movement forced UP Government to put a ban on tabarra, which stirred the
Shi6a up a great deal. Dietrich Reetz, Islam in the Public Sphere: Religious
Groups in India, 1900–1947 (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2006), 257.
17
The Shi6a activists were sent to Lucknow at the behest of Mub:rak 6Al;
Sh:h, a leading member of the Shah Jiwana clan. Bil:l Zubayr;, T:8rikh-i Jhang
(Jhang, 1973), 371; Siddiq Sadiq, Jhang, 237–8.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 63
BIR2DAR>S
Almost eighteen bir:dar;s inhabit rural Jhang, Sials being the most
influential because of their numbers, affluence and political clout.18 The
Syeds are also politically powerful and wealthy. In population terms
Jhang is overwhelmingly a rural district. Nevertheless, migrants from
East Punjab form an important group in Jhang City. They are drawn
from the trading and weaving communities. Despite their wealth these
communities were traditionally marginalized in the realm of power
politics by the dominant local landholders.
23
NaB;r AAmad Sal;m;, ‘Jhang mayn Sh;6a-Sunn; tan:zu6a: :gh:z say anj:m
tak’ in Zindag; (Lahore, 14–20 December 1991), 19–21.
24
Ian Talbot, ‘Understanding Religious Violence in Contemporary Pakistan:
Themes and Theories’ in R. Kaur (ed.), Religion, Violence and Political
Mobilization in South Asia (New Delhi: Sage Publications, 2005), 157.
66 t ah ir k am r an
the 1980s onwards, they were a crucial element of the SSP’s electoral
strength in Jhang City.25
33
Interview with Mawl:n: Ilyas Balakoti, Jhang, August 2006.
34
Ziau l-Qasimi (Diy:8 al-Q:sim;), MuAammad Diy:8 al-Q:sim;, S:w:nih
Aay:t am;r-i 6aCmat n:m<s-i 4aA:ba, Mawl:n: Eaqq Naw:z Shah;d: Ayk
shawBiyyat, ayk ta8r;kh, ayk 3<f:n (Faisalabad: Maktaba-i Q:simiyya, 1991), 44.
35
Ibid, 45.
36
Ibid, 47–9.
37
Interview with Sayyid Than:8 al-Eaqq Tirmidh;, Jhang, August 2006.
38
Jhang City has three gates: Nur Shah Gate, Khewa Gate and Mamna Gate.
The Khewa gate was given the second name of B:b-i 6Umar during MuAarram of
1969. Interview with Mehr Afzal Sial (Af@ul Siy:l), a renowned advocate in
Jhang, of Shi6a persuasion, Jhang, August 2006.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 69
put up on the way. The only condition, put forward by the Shi6a organ-
izers of the procession, was that the inscription on the board should be
shrouded. After the compromise was reached, the procession started off.
After coursing through the narrow streets of Jhang City, as it reached
close to the two mosques, someone unveiled the board. Subsequently,
a processionist by the name of Ashraf Baloch, an underling of the Sials
from Jhang City soaked his shirt in the nearby drain, then hurled it on to
where the name 6Umar was written. This was an act of utter desecration
for the Sunnis.39 Tumult ensued. It was nothing short of a pitched battle
between the rival sects. By the time the fury had subsided, six people had
39
The whole event was narrated by Sayyid Than:8 al-Eaqq Tirmidh;, an eye-
witness to the episode. August, 2006.
40
Mawl:n: Sh;r;n was an Urdu speaking Muh:jir. Afterwards the Masjid-i
Taqwa was named after him, Interview with MuAammad F:r<q, resident of
Jhang city, 2 September 2006.
41
Interview with Eajj; 6Abd al-6Az;z, Jhang Sadar, 12 August 2006.
70 t ah ir k am r an
institutionalized Hindu–Muslim riot systems of such UP cities as
Aligarh.42 Interestingly, Habibullah Khan Sial himself was Shi6a like
the Syeds of Shah Jiwana. However, in the particular case, factional clan
and kinship rivalry took precedence over sectarian affinities; they were
used as a ploy to scuttle the political influence of a rival bir:dar;. The
ploy worked very well to serve the ambitions of Habibullah though it
would wreak havoc in the days ahead. The two main characters in that
episode were, according to Sayyid Than:8 al-Eaqq Tirmidh;, a local Shi6a
notable, MuAammad Arshad and Ashraf Baloch. It was Arshad who
uncovered the board exactly when the MuAarram procession reached the
45
‘Political quietism’ here means taqiyya or dissimulation of Shi6i adherence.
See Ian Talbot, ‘Understanding Religious Violence’, 154.
46
Interview with Maulana Ilyas Balakoti, Jhang, August 2006.
47
Vali Nasr, The Shia Revival: How Conflicts within Islam Will Shape the
Future (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2006), 138.
48
Sayyid 62rif Eusayn Naqv;, Tadhkira-i 6Ulam:8-i Im:miyya-i P:kist:n
(Islamabad: Markaz-i TaAqiqat-i F:rs;-i Īr:n wa P:kist:n, 1984) quoted in
Qasim Zaman, ‘Sectarianism in Pakistan’, 689–716.
49
Hussain Haqqani, ‘Weeding out the Heretics: Sectarianism in Pakistan’,
Current Trends in Islamist Ideology, 4 (Hudson Institute, Washington D.C.;
November 2006) at www.futureofmuslimworld.com/research/pubID.58/pub_
detail.asp
72 t ah ir k am r an
and it grew intense.’50 Nasr’s assertion of course seems quite sweeping as
the phenomenon of sectarian differentiation was inextricably complex,
emanating from the interplay of myriad currents and cross-currents.
Nevertheless the Iranian revolution and the impact it had on the
Pakistani Shi6a spurred Deobandi reaction, which had so far been
sporadic. ManC<r Nu6m:n;’s book, Ir:n; Inqil:b: Im:m Khumayn; awr
Shi 6iyyat with its preface written by Ab< l-Easan Nadw; represents a
concerted response to the mounting Iranian influence in Pakistan. That
book was later to become ‘the gospel of Deobandi militant organizations
that in 1980s mushroomed across Pakistan to press the fight against
oversight have been cited as principal factors in the dramatic rise in the numbers
of mad:ris (European Commission, 2002), quoted in Ali Riazi, Global Jihad, 5.
55
Zindag; (Lahore, 8–14 June 1991).
56
Ibid.
57
See Azmat Abbas, Sectarianism, 7. However, Vali Nasr (‘The Shi6a Revival’,
161) puts the figure of Shi6a activists who gathered in Islamabad at 25,000.
58
Ibid.
59
A group of students from Lahore University of Engineering and Technology
founded ISO on 22 May 1972 to provide an All-Pakistan Shi6a platform.
Dr. Majid Noroze Abidi (M:jid Nawroz 62bid;) and Ali Reza Naqvi (6Al; Ri@:
Naqv;) were among the founders of the organization. The numerical strength and
organizational capability of ISO leaders became evident during the 1979–80
agitation of the Shi6a against Zia’s Zakat and 6Ushr Ordinance. See Azmat
Abbas, Sectarianism, 9.
60
Ibid, 7.
61
Seyyed Vali Reza Nasr, ‘Islam, the State, and the Rise of Sectarian Militancy
in Pakistan’, in Christophe Jaffrelot (ed.) Pakistan: Nationalism Without a
Nation (London: Zed Books, 2001), 87–90.
74 t ah ir k am r an
safeguarding the interests of their community. Hence TNFJ62 came into
being in 1979 in Bhakkar, under the leadership of Muft; Ja6far Eusayn.63
It became palpably more assertive in its political stance when 62rif
al-Eusayn; succeeded him as leader in 1984.64 In 1993 there emerged its
armed offshoot by the name of Sip:h-i MuAammad (SMP) under the
leadership of Ghul:m Ri@: Naqv;, the then district President of Tahr;k-i
Ja6fariyya, Jhang. By the end of 1994, SMP established its headquarters
at Thokar Niaz Beg, a suburb of Lahore which possessed a sizable Shi6a
population.
Haqq Nawaz Jhangvi was influenced by all these national and inter-
national currents as well as by the earlier model of sectarian mobilization
provided by Ahrar. It was under his leadership that sectarianism was
institutionalized with the formation of Anjuman-i Sip:h-i 4aA:ba on
6 September 1985. Soon afterwards, its name was changed into Sipah-i
4aA:ba P:kist:n (SSP). The association came into being in the J:mi6a
Masjid Piplianwali, where Haqq Nawaz had been a prayer leader (im:m)
and given sermons since 1973.65 Then Haqq Nawaz was n:8ib am;r
(deputy leader) of J:mi6at al-6Ulam:-i Isl:m, Punjab. The SSP’s central
executive comprised 28 founding members. Sectarianism was institution-
alized when the SSP was formed with radd-i r:fi@iyy:t (refutation of
the Shi6as) as its core objective. Interestingly, Haqq Nawaz took on the
62
The TNFJ was renamed as Tahr;k-i Ja6fariyya P:kist:n in a convention held
in March 1993 at Faisalabad. See Azmat Abbas, Sectarianism, 8.
63
Ja6far Eusayn (1916–83) was born in Gujranwala, educated in Lucknow,
India and Najaf, in southern Iraq. He then taught at a Shi6a seminary in his native
city. He served on various government committees including the Council of
Islamic Ideology. Qasim Zaman, ‘Sectarianism in Pakistan’, 694–5.
64
6All:m: 2rif Eusayn al-Eusayn; was a Turi Pushtun from the Shi6a
stronghold of Parachinar in northern Pakistan. He had received instruction from
Najaf and Qum and was sent to Pakistan by the Iranian government in 1978.
However, according to his official biography, he was expelled from Iran before
the Revolution. Azmat Abbas, Sectarianism, 8.
65
Dast<r, Anjuman-i Sip:h-i 4aA:ba (Jhang: Markaz; Daftar Anjuman-i
Sip:h-i 4aA:ba P:kist:n, J:mi6a Masjid Pipliawali, n.d) and also see Ziau
l-Qasimi, S:w:nih Aay:t, 39. It was registered on 21 January 1986 under the
Societies Registration Act, XXI of 1860; see the Certificate of Registration,
no. RP/799–F/S/86/352.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 75
Barelvis at the outset of his political career. The mun:Cara (religious
debate) held at Kot Lakhnana, Jhang, between him and Mawl:n: Ashraf
Siy:lv; strained relations between the Barelvis and Deobandis. Haqq
Nawaz lost that mun:zara. Barelvi–Deobandi tension grew into physical
confrontation in 1987 when two Barelvis were murdered by an SSP
supporter in Purani Eidgah. Soon afterwards Haqq Nawaz realized that
the Barelvi–Deobandi confrontation was counterproductive, changed
course and started working to forge a Sunni alliance against the Shi6a.66
SSP ideologues like Ziau l-Qasimi, Ilyas Balakoti and MuAammad
Sal;m Butt link the emergence of their organization with such events as
Barring Haqq Nawaz himself and to a far lesser extant Shaykh Hakim
Ali, there was no local influential SSP leader. Most of its leadership cadre
was drawn from the Partition migrants’ community. Zia-ul Qasimi
69
Muhammad Qasim Zaman while quoting Omer Noman dates the process
of the proliferation of the middle class in the Punjab to the 1970s and 1980s. The
outflow of labour overseas brought about remarkable changes in status and
expectations. There was an encouragement to radical sectarianism in Pakistan.
See: Zaman, The Ulema in Contemporary Islam: Custodians of Change
(Karachi: Oxford University Press, 2002), 126.
70
Mukhtar Ahmed Ali, ‘Sectarianism in Pakistan’. My thanks to Sal;m Butt
for pointing out an error in the table prepared by Mukhtar Ahmed Ali. The first
Secretary-General, according to Sal;m Butt, was Nas;m 4idd;q and not Y<suf
Muj:hid.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 77
(Diy:8 al-Q:sim;), Esar-ul Haq Qasimi (Asr:r al-Eaqq Q:sim;) and
Zia-ur Rehman Farooqi (Diy:8 al-RaAm:n F:r<qi) were East Punjab
migrants who had originally settled in Faisalabad, whereas Azam Tariq
(A6zam F:riq) hailed from Chichawantani, district Sahiwal.
From the outset, the SSP adopted an aggressive posture. This was seen
at Kull P:kist:n Dif:h-i 4aA:ba Conference (All Pakistan Conference for
the Defence of the Prophet’s Companions) held on 7th February 1986 at
Chandan Wala Mohalla, Jhang Sadar. Haqq Nawaz Jhangvi presented
a welcome address which amounted to an indictment against the Shi6a
community at large. The real motive of Haqq Nawaz in the text of the
74
Interview with Mehr Zafarullah Khan Bharwana Sial, an ex-member of the
Provincial Assembly Punjab, former Chairman District Council Jhang, Jhang,
August 2006.
75
Mawl:n: Diy:8 al-Rahm:n F:r<q; became the Chief Patron of SSP after
Haqq Nawaz Jhangvi’s assassination. Before that he was im:m and khat;b of a
mosque run by the Awqaf Dept. at Sumundri District, Faisalabad: Zindag;
(Lahore, 14–20 March 1991).
76
The chairpersons have been: Abid Hussain, Muhammad Arif Khan Sial,
Abida Hussain (two tenures), Mehr Akhter Bharwana, Mehr Muhammad
Zafarullah Bharwana, Sughra Imam: Siddiq Sadiq, ‘Jhang: The Land of Two
Rivers’, 403.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 79
leaders of the SSP for negotiation. Malik Saleem Iqbal, the Health
Minister of the Punjab, presided over the proceedings on 16 July 1990.
District administration, the SSP leadership and other important persons
were made part of the negotiations and taken into confidence. An amn
mu6:hada (peace treaty) was concluded to the satisfaction of the
government.77 But only a few days after the treaty, a bomb exploded
at Chowk Bab-i 6Umar in Jhang City, killing 3 Sunnis and injuring 28.
This effectively sabotaged the peace efforts. The very site of the bomb
explosion was not far away from Amanullah Khan Sial’s Aavayl; in
Jhang City. This is highly suggestive of the fact that the efforts to bring
79
International Crisis Group, ‘The State of Sectarianism in Pakistan’, 15.
80
Owais Tohid, ‘An Eye for an Eye, in Death, as in Life. Interview: Qari
Shafiqur Rehman’, October 2003 at www.newsline.com.pk/newsoct2003/
stopoct1.htm
81
‘Sipah-i Sahaba Pakistan, Terrorist Group of Pakistan’ at www.satp.org/
satporgtp/countries/Pakistan/terroristoutfits/ssp.htm, accessed 3 March 2007.
82
‘In the Spotlight: Sipah-i Sahaba Pakistan (SSP)’, 9 July 2004, at http://
www.cdi.org/program/document.cfm?documentid=2308&programID=39&from_
page=../friendlyversion/printversion.cfm, accessed 3 March 2007.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 81
of leading Shi6is were assassinated. They included Tajamal Abbass
(Tajamm al-6Abb:s), the Commissioner Sargodha, Ali Reza, Deputy
Commissioner Khanewal, Zainul Abideen (Zayn al-62bid;n), Jail
Superintendent Jhang, and ISO’s Dr. Naqvi, to name a few instances.
Indiscriminate firing on worshippers in mosque/im:mb:ra was the other
method that resulted in numerous killings. The Momenpura incident
on 11 January 1998 was a case in point with 27 Shi6is massacred;
17 were killed in Muzaffargarh in January 1999;83 and 57 in two sepa-
rate incidents in Quetta on 9 June and 4 July 2003.84 However, it was
not a one-sided affair, to say the least. Countless Sunnis also lost their
89
Zindag; (Lahore), 14–20 December 1991; Shaykh Eaqq Naw:z was later
hanged in Mianwali jail on 28th February 2001. K:ka Ball;, kin of Amanullah
Sial, was sentenced to life imprisonment for the assassination of Haqq Nawaz
Jhangvi. ‘Sipah-i Sahaba Pakistan, Terrorist Group of Pakistan’ at www.satp.org/
satporgtp/countries/Pakistan/terroristoutfits/ssp.htm, accessed 3 March 2007.
See also: Azmat Abbas, Sectarianism, 13.
90
Owais Tohid, ‘An Eye for an Eye’.
91
Brass, ‘Production of Hindu–Muslim Violence’, 377.
SECTARIAN MILITANCY IN PAKISTAN 83
and favourite Shaykh Iqbal with a margin of almost 10,000 votes.92 Esar
al-Qasimi did not live long after winning the election. He was the victim
of a political assassination in January 1991 while returning from the
polling station on the southern corner of Jhang Sadar. His murder took
place on the very day of the by-election for the Provincial Assembly
seat PP–65 Jhang V. Ironically, Esar al-Qasimi’s assassination was
not orchestrated by any Shi6a machination. He was allegedly killed at the
behest of the local Sunni power broker, Shaykh Iqbal. His son was the
principal accused and Shaykh Iqbal had to pay the huge sum of
Rs. 3.5 million as blood-money to Esar al-Qasimi’s family to settle the
CONCLUSION