Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Revised Argumentative Essay
Revised Argumentative Essay
Darnell Montejo
Professor Batty
English 28
13 December 2018
There are many cases in which immigrant parents are put in a situation where they should
speak the language of the adopted country or they should continue speaking their native language
at home with their children. It is unfortunate when parents force their children to assimilate and
speak another language other than their native language at home. When immigrant parents speak
their native language at home, it usually comes with a very positive outcome for their children.
Not only will it improve their educational journey but by doing so it will expand their language
abilities. Knowing their native language and eventually being bilingual will be great for them
and give them more experiences and opportunities in the future. Some parents who are
immigrants would rather assimilate and speak the adopted language in their household, but I
believe that it is a better option if you speak your native language at home with their children.
I grew up with my parents and my godparents who are immigrants and the four of them
only spoke their native language, Spanish, in their household. It was an amazing experience
because being in my parents or godparents house I would speak Spanish and at school I would
speak English or occasionally some Spanish with fellow students and teachers as well. I also got
to communicate with other family members who only spoke Spanish. It also helped me have a
better connection with my parents and godparents because we could communicate. Being
bilingual has helped me translate many things that were in English for them into Spanish. It
Montejo 2
helped my families a lot that my siblings and I were bilingual and spoke the native language at
home.
I believe immigrant parents should speak their native language, rather than the language
from the adopted country, at home because it benefits the children and the parents positively.
The children will usually learn the adopted country language at a school or some type of learning
facility outside of the household, so they will most likely grow up to be bilingual. They will have
many experiences in education and career opportunities in the future. Being bilingual and
speaking the native language at home will help the child’s identity and they will learn to love,
accept and celebrate their native language and culture. Feng Liang from the University of
Cincinnati discusses in the article “Parental Perceptions toward and Practices of Heritage
Language Maintenance: Focusing on the United States and Canada.” that “…the maintenance of
into the heritage culture. (Fishman 2001)” (Liang 2) and also explains that “..., the
discouragement of children's mother tongue could harm their cultural identity development”
(Liang 2). So, if children are discouraged to use their native language at home it can affect them
deeply in negative ways than you think. Being bilingual and speaking the native language at
home is a big part of someone’s life especially to a child of an immigrant parent, and as Gloria
Anzaldua said on “How to tame a wild tongue” a chapter from her book Borderlands, “Ethnic
Language makes up a person and language is a big part of a person's identity, especially for a
If immigrant parents speak the language of the adopted country at home with their
children, it may benefit them in positive ways as well but not speaking the adopted language
Montejo 3
wouldn’t. Speaking the adopted language will not be convenient for immigrant parents who only
speak the native language as it will be very difficult to communicate with their children, unless
they learn the adopted language as well but if they don’t it will be very difficult on both ends.
Speaking the adopted language at home could be better for the children because they will be able
to speak and communicate more fluently in public and outside of the household. Assimilation
has a lot to do with why parents would want to speak the language from the adopted country
rather than their native language with their children at home. As April Linton wrote in the article
“A critical mass model of bilingualism among U.S.-born Hispanics”, discusses that “Popular
ideals of immigrant assimilation have often placed as much importance on immigrants losing the
characteristics of their homeland as on adopting the ways of the U.S. Immigrants are expected to
stop using their native tongue and not to pass it on to their children.”(Linton 2004). Another
problem that can happen with assimilation and speaking the language of the adopted county at
home is that the children and the parent will start to slowly forget their native language along the
way.
The native language of the immigrant parents should be spoken at home because their
children will have more benefits and opportunities in life and as they grow up in the future.
Liang states that immigrant parents encourage their children to speak their native language
because it is believed that “…knowing more languages leads to gaining more economic benefits
and becoming more capable in the job market.” (Liang 7). By being bilingual they can get more
jobs and educational opportunities more than a person who only spoke one language could which
Some immigrant parents would like to assimilate and speak the language of the adopted
country, that would sound easier for them, so they can fit in and not stick out, but it wouldn't be
Montejo 4
the best option for their children. This is when immigrant parents should take action and speak
their native language at home. Assimilating and speaking the language of the adopted country at
home with your children might sound like a good option, but you may want to rethink that option
Works Cited
Anzaldúa, Gloria. Borderlands/La Frontera, the New Mestize. San Francisco: Aunt Lute Books, 1987.
Liang, Feng. “Parental Perceptions toward and Practices of Heritage Language Maintenance: Focusing
on the United States and Canada.” Online Submission, vol. 12, Apr. 2018, pp. 65–86.
EBSCOhost,
library.lavc.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=E
D581470&site=eds-live.
Linton, April. "A critical mass model of bilingualism among U.S.-born Hispanics *." Social Forces, vol.
http://library.lavc.edu:2102/apps/doc/A124075861/OVIC?u=lavc_main&sid=OVIC&xid=49167