Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Roy Ellen PDF

    Uploaded by

    IncaOre
    20 views16 pages

    Original Title

    Roy Ellen.pdf

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf
    20 views16 pages

    Roy Ellen PDF

    Uploaded by

    IncaOre

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf
    of 16
    Enironment, subsistence and system appropiton i» diecly cawsally slated to sgo appropriation, SREB te ethnography doc nate Ha ag procening oe Pane ie could portunities for hunting, Rates, both a prt an yy ie nyt rl epee = opotioal ts inresne i anal rare eesaary tobe propery acolo converting sai ene eed econo Vranas sa Spc un etona sunt proceses sero Fansemmental ratone The ind of uses entertained DY sara oneal were the most pa a tosinple and ave ec rine completes ttc vrais which weno KO eat Notte eet these hat envionment variates ae {peeks put ofthe interaction between human a nan themeel Sls The. cus corsations are rarely those BOS, tea he relationships between totalies but rather the subtle and ‘Ndden connections between particulates, Possibilism and limiting factors Ia the United States, Germany and Russia environmentaliom had 3 . deep impact on the study of human ecological relations. But a 6 Somehow inevitable with grand theoreti generalization ater st ‘ents while acknowledging the source of her ineptation) came tobe Sospicious ofthe al-embracing lame i made. Wiser, despite Nis ‘work on cultural aeas and adited debt to Rate, could not be persuaded to accept wholeheartedly theposive formativectfect of the "vironment Forhin, the environment wae passive lining agency ther than causal factor (Wssler 192939}. The environment set | Tits but didnot determine It was this negative formulation of geo rapa! determinism, posson, which was to influence macl fr fore work. \ THs ress to locate the precise intellectual rigins of possibilm sine It must have etd fr as long as speculation on human inter ‘tion with the environment. An cary geographical version nfound in the work of Vidal dela Blache (102) ar In Soviet wetings of the Slit period wer ind the supreme example of deologial an sien Llc expression of ant-environmentalis (Malley 1972116, 119). The response among anthropologists came a itl ater. In part refeted theoretical wesknesees within the environmentalist triton, bt was ko the produc of historia particular, sociological functional | the conduct of ethnographic eldwark, and an ineeasing appreciation ofthe degre to whch the environment had been modiaed by Homo] ‘apes. Environment, subsistence and sytem tthe impertat reser ie deme fener eet aa tae © nally ee Tee se ny ann nl ao ct sro esha pap dead, om ain eso ‘Ens Ocampo le cea rary coins. Bag he oe ery ek gs bang supe ty eng a et of aul ete erty tat Spe atten eens eee ae can momma minal eh ‘Merri he ita cmon fo Mar tr Fo ea ae sal tay fea ivr atten (lohan 1478-1) and George eins Mash {nic mony on gett a9) el Ce peep nay nseriache anne Minty tre Hoey ame ond sina eihc oem Seopa ovement ee fechas eee tncere ng tk eee erae ten compu ook rh oe npn dt Phew environments are uninfluenced by humans and almost el tsa nly els xe ay See decor ar See Wa cone eee met te Aan pas ne rene hah ee thc ae more an te human tris or example pane and micro-organisms The acti sa se isp ee et, Cone amen eat ste of ap sel tn ee Even thet rede ear el enter pe hi paren ee seme cc ud ves age mone te et eporsente ay tester SS nA eA a eyed in that amas wer peri eettncon a Pleistocene mogafaun n Europe aid that grassland sree ch Se bh Meco rate eo SETS he gn ets wh prance ern tes bryce ter een re asc Sbimte we aeeneye os Sst ated fe say, Foes share Posstilism and limiting factors damaged by grass fies, and much graslind owes its origin and ‘maintenance fires, Notral fires are either absent fre cs are iten started to tap small game deiteratly or nena ot provide warmth or for pre pleasure. Even ave the it of garde i the environznent has ben altered by hight trading paths tna foe hunting an gathering (Marner 197721) Calivated land nove occupies I0 pe ent ofthe surface ofthe cath, anda considenbly ngerpecenapect hose pats capable ofp port ingvepetation rown 197038). The proces f pant cultivation heed torenarmeus changes in the store of bei assoction eld larane alone has destroyed forests ative rsa and many ‘ther types of natral community. The Kinds of cope grown ad the techniques used hae affected the quai of the sol (Crk ae Strect 1867). The pact ot grctareon the native for of northern Earope an leewhere i well own (Clark 1954, Dsy 1959) Swiddening has alo gresty altered the ecology of montane New Guines, and many induced plans have established themselves wid ncuding theroxius weed of altvaton and ee plans anne! 19721) Ho tapes has increased the productviy of domestaed species fgenctially and through narre.Agclare has been lntesed through techniques foraltering the energy, ater, nitrogen and nerd cycles of the biosphere; through mechani, rigaon, fries fon and chemical contol of weeds and inset, Re-thaping the hy. rule eye trough the iverson of tver wae on olan hs aise the water table. By draining swamps and bulding wigaton schemes the landscape is re-worked new Kinds of habit are crested eer beneficial, oi the case f wet ce terraces or destructive, a the se of nent rasan formed through extensive forest ara ln New Guinea, or inthe incense of Schstesoninsvetors following selberate flooding (own 1910, Waste product polation, tel ‘eal practices and induced erosion have Gestoyed eal cron ‘ments In many places, domestiated srimalspeies have replaced ‘id dominant and fod production has ater ot only the lave Sundance of species bt also ther lal Gsibution nd he ecology ofthe plant mater pon which hy ed Anal detain a Tested in an incresse in predators, pacttes and other ype of {socation, Allo these changes have sfc teresa and esh ‘eater ecosystems and, ton fener extent, marie one; le the ‘hacer of such changes, their vanety and oer ave ow well ‘locumented by biologts,ethnographers and ecologist In Goth professional and popular publcallons (Sangster 1971, Thomas ol, Tse, Ucko and Dimi 195), Encionment, subsistence ane system PARTICULARISM, FUNCTIONALISM AND THE NEGLECT Some ofthe objections to envionmental determinism have been re ‘iewed in Chapter Within anthropology these have mos often been ‘Rccited ith what has become hnove aa eal” (or “istria) “pantculrom’,and the work ofFrane Beas, Allred Kroeber and Robert ‘Eien the United States, Thee etanronyin hein Between the active "Bosna poss. Although Bous asserted that {environment only fd certain ining effect 186-906), he was esponable for noting one of theirs convicingcultre-environment Coucatons the ratonship between the Toston of Eskimo sete ‘ments the formation of sea ce and the movements of inshore seals {Gtest7). A comporable enduring para found in the essay by Minune and Bouchet (190) on Eskimo seasonal variations. Ths has {een interpreted as a tndleaton of store materialism onthe one Tanda ayn attack on geographical determinism on the other. Fox 19791, Douglas 1972420), The Desi partulvist poston i that cultures, ensronments and tnatorice ae 9 variable that any generlzation is hazardous, I 0, then to deste envionment varobles as constants gives the recognition without asigning status, Raised tothe level of abstract theory, clare wes ating sul gener (he supesergaie, while iolgy {the organic) was constant The immediate causes of cultural phe- Nomen were held to be primariy ater cultural phenomena, wile ical change proceeded independently of environmental conditions {Kroeber D7. 19301), However for Kroober (929205): cares whol ineligible witbutrefernce othe nama 30 i rrnmentl ats with whch isn elation ad which onion ISS {Eamon ef he elle an envionment become exceedingly “on whe eed copies oc

    You might also like