Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IP-New Research
IP-New Research
IP-New Research
PARADOX IN
Children's Education & Behavior
Evidence from New Research
We dedicate this policy brief in memory of Brown graduate student and DREAM Act
activist Tam Ngoc Tran who passed away at the age of 27 on Saturday May 18, 2010.
Tam embodied everything that this country expects of its citizens: virtue, love of country,
civic engagement, community activism and support for each other.
She was a daughter and a sister. She was born in Germany to Vietnamese refugee
parents who fought Communism in their country. When Tam was six years old, the
family moved to the United States. They requested asylum here, but their application
remains in limbo. Tam and her family are stateless: Germany will not accept them back
because they are not of German origin and return to Vietnam is impossible given the
family's anti-communist history.
A budding scholar, Tam was pursuing her Ph.D. in the Department of American
Civilization at Brown University at the time of her death. Her dissertation planned to
merge historical inquiry with participant observation, documenting the trajectory and
power of student politics over the last half-century.
Tam Tran was a dedicated and fearless leader for immigrant rights. She advocated on
behalf of undocumented immigrant youth in search of education. As an undergraduate
at the University of California, Los Angeles, she worked with fellow undocumented
and documented students to extend public funding to undocumented students. On
May 18, 2007, Tam took the courageous step of testifying in Congress in support of
the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act (The "DREAM Act"), a bill
that would provide pathways to citizenship by granting a six year conditional permanent
legal residency to undocumented students who met certain criteria. Although the bill
failed, Tam continued to work for its passage and was a tireless activist until the day of
her untimely death.
Most of all, Tam embodied true citizenship. She overcame significant obstacles,
embraced an American identity, and fought for justice and equality for all just as the
Founding Fathers did. As she said before Congress, "the truth is, I am culturally an
American...I consider myself a Southern Californian. I grew up watching Speed Racer
and Mighty Mouse every Saturday morning." But ultimately, although not deportable,
she was denied formal legal citizenship, which would bring her full rights and security.
Tam was an organizer for the conference on which this report is based and gave
significant guidance and assistance in the production of this report. In particular, she
put together a panel of undocumented college students who provided testimony of the
needs of this population. Another member of the panel, Cinthya Felix, also died in this
accident. Her unique perspective and strong voice will continue to guide our research.
She was greatly looking forward to the release of this report.
THE IMMIGRANT
PARADOX
Children's Education & Behavior
IN
Evidence from New Research
22 References
2
Foreword
The conventional view in the United States has been that children of
immigrants are a challenge for the American educational system and for
local communities. Many of them don’t speak much English, the thinking
goes, and they are not familiar with American traditions and practices. This
can only make them educational “laggards” and a concern for educators and
policymakers across the country. This conventional view is fundamentally
wrong: new data and research that scholars in education presented at a
conference convened at Brown University last year shows that the children
of immigrants do well in school and in the community. In fact, many studies
show that the children of immigrants outperform their American-born peers
both in school performance and in out-of-school positive behaviors.
of our colleagues from the Taubman Center for Public Policy and American
Institutions at Brown University, Professors Marion Orr and Alexandra
Filindra, provided some thoughts and insights about how these findings apply
to questions of policy. We thank them for their support and ideas.
Now, we want to share some of these very important new data that
challenge the way we think about immigrant children, with educators, school
administrators, policymakers and parents across the country. Our goal is to
start a new dialogue on how to further support immigrant children in their
journey to integrate into American society, and how to learn from their
experience. Through this initiative, we hope to enable students, families,
schools, and government to sustain and strengthen the resiliency that
underlies the immigrant paradox. Children of immigrants have a lot to teach
us about how to foster a love of learning and an appreciation for schooling
among all our students, regardless of their citizenship status.
Professor Evelyn Hu-DeHart, Center for the Study of Race and Ethnicity in America
Professor Cynthia Garcia Coll, Education Department
Research Assistants, Flannery Patton and Tam Tran
4
Introduction
In 2009, President Obama made education a priority for America. The
American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (the “stimulus”) included
substantial investments in education, including $77 billion for primary and
secondary education reform, $5 billion for early childhood programs, and
$5 billion for educational innovation. Improving educational outcomes and
ensuring a better future for all of America’s children is a top concern for the
Administration and for communities across the nation. According to the
White House: “Providing a high-quality education for all children is critical
to America’s economic future. Our nation’s economic competitiveness
and the path to the American Dream depend on providing every child with
an education that will enable them to succeed in a global economy that is
predicated on knowledge and innovation. President Obama is committed to
providing every child access to a complete and competitive education, from
cradle through career.” 1
80
60
40
20
0
1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplements
American- American-
Foreign-born parents Foreign-born parents
born parents born parents
% % % % % %
1994 20 28 41 14 38 48
1996 18 27 39 13 39 49
1998 17 25 39 12 37 45
2000 15 20 30 11 36 43
2002 14 20 27 10 36 41
2004 15 21 30 10 34 42
2006 15 20 30 10 33 39
2008 16 21 30 7 26 29
Source: U.S. Census, CPS, Annual Social and Economic Supplements, 1994-2008
6
The research compared first, second and third plus generation children in
terms of a variety of educational and behavioral outcomes. The key findings
of this new research are:
The research presented at this conference suggest that findings for the
immigrant paradox may be uneven across groups.
A note on terminology
In this report, the term immigrant refers to individuals who are foreign-
born, regardless of their immigration status (e.g., naturalized citizens,
permanent residents, undocumented). Immigrant families refers to
families that are headed by foreign-born parents. The children in these
families may be foreign-born or American-born. Further we define first,
second and third plus generations as follows:
Significantly more likely than their second or third plus generation peers to
report that they have never tried alcohol, tobacco or other drugs. 3 (Fig. 2)
Significantly more likely to have their first sexual experience at an older age
than their second or third plus generation peers. 5 (Fig. 4)
The "Immigrant Paradox" Findings in Detail 9
Figure 2. Rates of Abstaining from Substance Use and Sexual Activity During
Adolescence by Immigrant Generation, Among U.S. Asians & Latinos
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
First Generation Second Generation Third Plus Generation
2.4
1.6
1.2
0.8
0.4
0
White Black Asian Latino
15.2
15
14.8
14.6
14.4
14.2
14
13.8
1st Generation 2nd Generation 3rd Generation
Figure 5. Standardized Test Scores of 3rd through 8th graders for American-
born and Immigrant Youth, New York Sample
0.050
0.045
0.041
0.040
0.030
0.020
0.010
0.000
Native-born Immigrant
Figure from Conger, D., Schwartz, A., Stiefel, L. (2003) Who Are Our Students: A Statistical
Portrait of Immigrant Students in New York City Elementary and Middle Schools. New York, NY:
The Urban Research Center. (New York Public School Data, 1999-2000, 3rd – 8th grade.)
First generation immigrant 1st – 8th graders are less likely to attend special
education classes than their American-born peers.
12
Figure 6. Trends in Math Scores for Latino Kindergarten through Fifth Graders
Across Language Groups
52
51
50
49
48
47
46
45
Kindergarten Kindergarten First Grade Third Grade Fifth Grade
(Fall) (Spring)
Non-English Non-English
dominant Bilingual monolingual
It must be noted that these trends are documented within the Latino population.
While foreign-born Latinos show resilience across many outcomes there is
still a significant gap between Latino children and White or Asian children in
standardized measures of academic achievement.
In addition, while foreign-born children show incredible resilience during early
education for foreign-born Latinos there appears to be a loss of advantage
during high school. While school attitudes and school behaviors (i.e. time spent
on homework) remain high, educational achievement and attainment do not
reflect this positive trend. In 2009, the high school drop-out rate for foreign-
born Latinos was 33 percent. 14 Policy should aim to capitalize on early learning
gains of foreign-born youth and support transitions to middle and high school.
14
First generation adolescents (both white and Latino) report more parental
control than their third plus generation peers. 16
Policymakers, school officials and advocates can also seek out important
lessons from the educational and social practices of some immigrant groups
whose community institutions have great success at helping children excel
in school and outside. Careful study and migration of these practices into
other communities could have beneficial effects and further support these
children. Public-private partnerships that develop innovative ideas for
in-school and afterschool programs must be supported with public and
institutional funding. And the educators among us, both those in primary or
secondary education and those in colleges and universities, should develop
a public forum for the exchange of ideas and the sharing of new research and
information. This report is a step in that direction.
20
The children of immigrants today are being viewed with suspicion in many
states and localities: their educational performance is doubted, their progress
in school contested, their morality and social behaviors questioned. Political
leaders are concerned about the economic effects of immigrant children to
their budgets and the social effects to their communities. The conventional
view may be wrong, but it is strong and widely held. It is our responsibility and
duty to these children who will be the future leaders of our country to provide
them with an educational environment that fosters learning and to support
them in their quest to overcome the challenges of poverty, foreignness and
social exclusion.
Information on the Research Findings Behind this Report 21
http://brown.edu/Departments/Education/paradox/
22
References
3 Hussey, J.M., Hallfors, D.D., Waller, M.W., Iritani, B.J., Halpern, C.T. & Bauer, D.J.
(2007). Sexual Behavior and Drug Use Among Asian and Latino Adolescents:
Association with Immigrant Status. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health,
9:85-94.
7 Pong, S-L & Zeiser, K. L (In Preparation) Student Engagement, School Climate,
and Academic Achievement of Immigrants’ Children. In C. T. Garcia Coll & A.
K. Marks (Eds.) Is becoming American a developmental risk? New York, NY:
APA. Expected 2010.
14 Pew Research Center. "Between Two Worlds: How Young Latinos Come of Age
in America," Washington, D.C. (December, 2009).
24
Design by
Leticia Tejada
leticia@studiosouthcreations.com
Printed by
Alphagraphics of Rhode Island
on FSC Certified Paper
(401) 351-4000
www.alphagraphics.com