Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mod3 Performance Analysis Report Team 1
Mod3 Performance Analysis Report Team 1
Mod3 Performance Analysis Report Team 1
November 2018
Document1 1
Purpose
Delightful Duds Décor is a boutique mail-order and internet catalog company.
The 6-year old company caters to women between the ages of 25 to 55, with
household incomes between $60,000 and $100.000 annually. The company’s
signature collection of nostalgic, romantic, and lifestyle products are highly
favored by its customers. Unfortunately, the customer service aspect has come
under fire. Customers have voiced their dismay with the level of customer
service by the company’s Telephone Operators. In response to this concern, the
company has retained the services of our firm to assess the situation and offer a
solution.
The purpose of this report is to advise our client, Delightful Duds Décor of our
findings as it relates to the company’s annual business planning process,
surrounding forecasting revenues, expenses and profits in the coming year.
BluePrint Consulting’s primary focus is on the client’s documented decline in
customer satisfaction which threatens to significantly impact the company’s
profit and loss (P&L) forecast. We have thoroughly analyzed why the major
variances have occurred. Our report will present several factors (with
recommendations) found in the business environment, which we have determined
contribute to these variances:
The root cause contributing to the decline in customer satisfaction
Deficits in workflow processes
Dissension in workplace culture
Training inefficiencies
General operational and HR procedure issues
Additionally, we will address in detail, recommendations the client should
consider implementing. Our scope work for which we been retained, is the
matter concerning call center performance.
Document1 2
An informal interview revealed that a staggering 50% of their telephone
operators want to quit. Telephone operators are the first POC (Point of contact)
for customers. On average, an employee at every level resigns each month. This
high attrition rate directly impacts growth objectives and employee retention.
More than 50% of customers surveyed, voiced their dissatisfaction regarding
customer service, after placing a phone order. Customers expressed dismay and
refusal to do business again with the company, due specifically to the “poor
customer service”. This issue is incongruent with company’s desires for growth,
and customer retention and satisfaction. Profit and growth are a buy -product of
enhanced customer service, when supported by greater product knowledge. This
in turn, is a direct correlation of increased revenue.
Key stakeholders in various positions with direct oversite of customer service,
product knowledge, and past training initiatives have noted elements which may
have contributed to both subpar customer service and employee frustrations.
The Stakeholders iSubject Matter Experts (SMEs) identified are: Commented [jem1]: Actually, at this point, no SMEs
have been identified, per the case study document (the 1st
Mike Merrill – Vice President of Sales one). Since you refer to the list above as key stakeholders,
keep with that language.
o Oversees the catalog call center and catalog production carried out by
the Catalog Director and Merchandizing Director
Jane MacKenzie – Director of Catalog Sales
o Oversees the catalog call center and catalog production carried out by
the Catalog Director and Merchandizing Director and catalog
production
o Judi Thompson – Catalog Director
o Oversees all aspects of the catalog distribution
o Accompanies Sheena Perez to gift, apparel and other trade shows
throughout the year to vet vendors with quality products and
reputations, for reliability in shipping.
o Ensures samples of potential catalog items acquired at the trade show
are brought back to the office and examined by herself, Sheena, and
Sheen’s assistant Ray Johnson. They determine which items get
placement in the catalog.
o Oversees training for customer service supervisors and telephone
operators for catalog issued
o
Sheena Perez – Merchandising Manager
o Responsible for selecting and promoting items for the catalog and
Internet sales venues.
o Accompanies Judi Thompson to gift, apparel and other trade shows
throughout the year to vet vendors with quality products and
reputations, for reliability in shipping.
o Ensures samples of potential catalog items acquired at the trade show
are brought back to the office and examined by Sheena, Judi Thompson
Document1 3
and Sheen’s assistant Ray Johnson. They determine which items get
placement in the catalog.ement of products
o After the product placement selection is decided, Sheena oversees and
collaborates with a contract copywriter and professional service firm to
design and produce the catalog, including:
o Layout, photography, and printingCatalog layout,
photography, printing
o Conducts vendor selections by interviewing, negotiating, inspecting
and managing.
o Conducts product training for Supervisors and Telephone Operators
with Judi Thompson prior to catalogs mailed out.
o Product Training (conducted 4 times a year prior to the release of the
next season’s catalog) is comprised of:
Half day training
PowerPoint Presentation
Product Summary Description (Reference for
automated entry system)
Q&A Session after training (30 mins)
1. Indirect Contributors:
1.o Tsien Yu – Manager of Customization of SimplyOrder Software
2.o Ted Higgins – Internal Business Information
3.o Bruce Bennett- Information TechologyTechnology
4.o Susan Turner - HR
Management believes that an increase in knowledge and skill in describing the
feature and benefits of the products in the catalog and in answering questions not
in the online FAQs, is necessary to increase catalog sales and reduce customer
complaints. Thus, our target audiences are telephone operators and their direct
supervisors.
BluePrint Consulting has been tasked with conducting a thorough gap analysis,
including both a performance and training assessment, to ensure that the solution
we propose, meets the company’s financial, customer satisfaction, employee
satisfaction and engagement initiatives.
Scope of Work: The client has allocated $400,000 for 4 training sessions in
advance of, each of the 4 seasonal catalog rollouts.
Research: Surveys, work observations, and interviews of Supervisors and
Telephone Operators.
Data Collection: Job descriptions, Performance Reviews, documented skills and
education levels, employee satisfaction levels, materials from past trainings,
rosters from past trainings, and documented exit interviews of Supervisors and
Telephone Operators
Document1 4
Root Cause Analysis: Deficiencies of Supervisors and Telephone Operators in
knowledge and skills. Understanding of expectations. Technical aptitude.
Procedure compliance and comprehension. Employee engagement. Work
environment. Access to resources.
Work to Date
The work to date includes interviews by key company stakeholders and data
collection of company findings. xx Commented [jem2]: Might be good to have an
introductory statement.
1. Interviewed key company stakeholders:
2.a. Jane MacKenzie
3.b. Judi Thompson
4.c. Sheena Perez
5.d. Tsien Yu
6.e. Ted Higgins
7.f. Susan Turner
8.g. Telephone Supervisors and Operators
2. Data Collection on:
1.a. Customer Complaints
2.b. Telephone Operators Training Concerns
3.c. Telephone Operators Training Preferences
4.d. Current Workflow Processes
5.e. New Technology Integration Timelines
6.f. Prior Training Policies and Procedures
Analysis Methods
To determine causes and recommended non-training and training solutions,
BluePrint Consulting collected data from 6 six activities/methods: Interviews,
Document1 5
Work Observations, Training Documents and Manuals, Customer Relationship
Management Reports (CRM), HR Documents, and Surveys.
Interviews:
1. Interviewed Judi Thompson and Sheena Perez to gain a clearer picture of
the telephone operators and supervisor’s workflow, current state of
product knowledge training and its results, anticipated software training,
customer service needs, and changing company policy, technology and
resources.
2. We were unable to interview Mike Merrill, VP of Sales but we were able
to interview Jane MacKenzie to more clearly understand her perspective
on call center issues that hinder growth and the changes needed to
address these issues.
Susan Turner, the Human Resources Director, was interviewed to
understand recruitment, hiring and orientation practices, new hire train
structure and content, new policies, handbook and the implemented
incentive program, cross-reference monthly meeting data, employee
morale, and exit interview findings.
3. Interviews were conducted of the Information Technology Department
that contained Bruce Bennet and Tsien Yun who explained the additional
hardware and software being added, the roll-out timeline, and state of
customizations.
4. Interviews were held with Customer Service Supervisors and Telephone
Operators to understand their job responsibilities, work flow, how they
handle difficult customers, work attitude, responsiveness and
communication with supervisors and managers, comprehension of
company policy, mission statements, and values, get their opinion about
past and present training needs, customer complaints and survey
procedures.
5. Group Interviews, originally not asked for, were held with Operators and Commented [jem4]: What does this phrase mean? I see
it in a couple of places, and I’m wondering what it refers to.
Supervisors to gain cross-referenced information regarding the
employee’s knowledge of the company’s policies, mission statements Commented [EG5R4]: It means that we didn’t ask for
them in our gap analysis but they came to us by way of the 24
and values, monthly meeting data, and product knowledge. page part 2 of the case study. We are thankful for them but
we unfortunately didn’t ask for them.
Work Observations:
Work Observations of telephone operators and supervisors to better
understand working conditions, employee performance per shift, peer-
interactions and supervisor support, workflow procedures, areas of
inefficiency, motivational strategies and employee morale.
Call Reports, were written based on 15 recorded calls to outline current
work flow procedures and duration, customer interaction and escalation
of complaint, supervisor engagement and telephone operator job
performance.
Training Documents and Manuals:
Document1 6
Interviews were able to shed clarity about the Training Manuals,
presences of job aids, phone scripts, past and present summary of
product descriptions, and vendor notes.
Customer Relationship Management Reports (CRM):
The company was unable to produce these reports but interviews with
Sheena Perez and Jane MacKenzie yielded much the requested
information regarding sales transactions as compared with customer
service concerns.
HR Documents:
The interview with Susan Turner, the HR Director, was able to satisfy the
need to understand this need. Our interview included questions regarding Commented [jem6]: To what does this refer?
company culture, job descriptions, policies, incentives/rewards,
employee schedules, compensation concerns, benefits and professional
development.
Surveys:
Telephone Operators were asked to take an electronic survey with
questions to gain a clearing understanding of their past product
knowledge trainings, ordering process, job satisfaction, challenges with
customers and customer service survey conclusions, adequacy of
resources, work environment, incentive programs, monthly meetings and
additional training needs.
A survey was given to the supervisors that highlighted their work
attitude, job satisfaction, work flow procedures, job expectations,
understanding of company policy, mission statements and values,
supervisory training, communication with TO’s, and their opinions
regarding anticipated training needs.
Supervisors & previous trainers were given an electronic survey to gain a
better picture of the customer service workflow, previous training,
reference guide availability, attitude, employee responsibilities, error-free
work incentives, operator scripts, and distribution of and content of
customer complaints.
Document1 7
Data Summary: Customer Complaints
Of the 25 operators interviewed, all agree that product knowledge and more
timely training is are not issues. The data indicates overwhelming support for a
new approach to learning. They cite a preference for shorter increments and a
more visual, hands-on approach, which differs significantly from the lecture-
Document1 8
based style that is currently being used. Interestingly, 88% of the respondents
also thought that they needed more efficient computer and computer software.
Of the 30 calls we observed (15 recorded calls and 15 real-time calls), we found
that nearly 65% of the calls were lengthened due to the Operator being unable to
immediately answer a customer’s question and needing to look up the answer.
Document1 9
Current State, Desired State, and Recommended Solutions
To address Delightful Duds and Décor’s issues with call center performance, this table summarizes the performance analysis conducted by
BluePrint Consulting, including the current state, the desired state, and our recommended solution.
Document1 10
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
While Operators are chosen for Clearly defined phone etiquette and Define expectations and script for
their general politeness, they are best practice expectations along with phone etiquette and best practice.
not specifically trained in phone incentives that ensure their
etiquette. consistent use. Develop and implement training
sessions for Operators and Supervisors
that help to develop strategies for best
practices in phone etiquette.
Document1 11
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
Organization and layout of product Product details should beare listed in Organize product information in a
information is inconsistent and/or a consistent layout that is easy to uniform, easy-to-read manner so
missing, making it difficult for review and find informationeasy to operators can look up product
Operators to find specific find. information easily.
information.
Train Operators how to efficiently
search and locate product information.
Document1 12
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
Operators don’t have a clear Clearly defined standards for Create a specific job description for
understanding of their role or performance for Operators, and a Operators and pay scale.
performance expectations. clear and balanced evaluation
process that ensures optimal Implement call monitoring and call
performance. coaching so Operators can have live
examples of best practices (e.g:
etiquette, upselling, cross-selling).
Document1 13
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
There is no specific training for A clearly defined role for Create a specific job description for
Supervisors to help them manage Supervisors with a specific skill set supervisors and competitive pay scale.
Operators. Supervisors are given that aligns with Delightful Duds and
their positions because they Décor's standards. They are trained Determine a hiring track for Operator
performed well as Operators. There in managing Operators, giving promotion or external hires.
is no clear track for this promotion. performance reviews and using best
Develop and implement a 360- degree
etiquette practices.
training program for call center
supervisors in
management/supervision and in
employee evaluation. Implement upon
hire and bi-yearly for continuing
supervisors to refresh their skills.
Document1 14
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
The Client intends to integrate a After the integration of Develop and integrate phase-based
new ordering system, SimplyOrder, SimplyOrder, people should beare training on the SimplyOrder System:
that will be customized by the adept in navigating the menus
company. efficiently and be are able to access Develop a classroom segment that
the necessary information. allows operators to learn the navigation
system of SimplyOrder. through Formatted: Strikethrough
system (
Operators are not provided optimal Operators will beare given the Provide headsets.
resources for the job (e.g.: option to utilize their current headset
headsets) or put in a request for replacement This is the least expensive component
of a new set. of the new system.
Document1 15
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
Operators currently give the Operators have no connection to Develop a simple, short, easy-to-
customer service survey orally. administering the survey, which answer customer survey that is fully
Survey consists of a ten-point scale allows customers to be more honest automated upon completion of the call
(courtesy, accuracy, timeliness, and freer with their responses. that does not involve the Operator.
satisfaction of Operator).
The client is losing 50% of Customers feel valued and respected Develop and implement a customer
customers. loyalty program (e.g.: for completing
the survey, customers will get 15% off
next purchase, birthday rewards,
referral bonuses.)
No formal interview structure or A clearly stated hHiring process Identify vacancy and evaluate need
candidate criteria. A clear hiring with criteria-based practices would Commented [jem7]: I like this, but I’m not sure you
process is not stated in the company create a constant supply of well- Develop position description have solid data to support the assertion.
documentation. qualified, well-informed applicants.
Develop a recruitment plan
more criteria-based, stepped out,
team-oriented approach. Review applicants against job
description
Select candidate
Document1 16
Current State Desired State Recommendation to Achieve Desired State
There is high turnover and low High motivation, lower turnover. Clearly define criteria for optimal
motivation among call center Satisfied employees performance in the call center.
employees.
Develop and implement a clear
Current incentive program: incentives program (e.g.: compensation
Operators receive a discount on time [time off with pay] for time
company product for error free efficient sales that exceed company
work. sales expectations. exceptional work
No visual display of organizational Employees understand how their Organizational chart clearly displayed
chart. Workers can’t visualize work affects other people/business in company material.
where they are in the workflow units
process, and how their work Commented [jem8]: Process and org charts are two
overlaps and/or impacts other different things. What do you really mean here?
business units
Document1 17
Proposed Solutions for Consulting Firm to Carry Out
Blueprint Consulting proposes carrying out the stated solutions in the following
order of priority.
Document1 18
Priority Solution Description
Formatted: Strikethrough
Formatted: Strikethrough
Document1 19
Priority Solution Description
evaluating Operators’
customer service skills.
IInstruct Operators to work Formatted: Font color: Text 1
with Supervisorson effective
customer service skills, to Formatted: Font color: Text 1
improve their customer
service skills and instruct how
to up-sell, cross-sell, and deal
with difficult customers.
sal
Document1 20
Priority Solution Description
Evaluation Plan
We will evaluate the following solutions in the following ways:
Priority 1 - Easily Referenceable Transparency of Product Information
Consistently track the number of calls per hour. Compare these numbers Formatted: Font color: Text 1
every 6 months to determine if Operators are able to consistently meet Formatted: Body Text, Bulleted + Level: 4 + Aligned at:
the six calls per hour. 1.75" + Indent at: 2"
Track data to determine if there are fewer calls regarding product Formatted: Font color: Text 1
information.
Track sales volume to show that product transparency is increasing sales. Formatted: Font color: Text 1
Track rate of returns and survey customers on their reasons for return to Formatted: Font color: Text 1
determine whether product transparency minimized rate of returns.
Measure the reaction of the management and staff upon introducing and
implementing product transparency model and the new layout of the
catalog and website. This would be measured through a smile chart after
the initial presentation.program. Commented [jem9]: What are you measuring? What is
the metric?
Assess how the job of a telephone operator/supervisor change due to the
implementation of the program. Assess how it effects workflow,
productivity, ordering frequency, the number of calls taken per hour by
telephone operators, etc. through surveys and catalog product
information metadata tracking.
Track data to determine if fewer calls regarding product information.
Track the average length of call before and after the product information Formatted: Font color: Text 1
transparency implementation to determine of product transparency
reduces call time. because
Track call content to det transparent to the customer. ermine if product Formatted: Font color: Text 1
transparency has changed the type of information people call in for. Formatted: Font color: Red
Document1 21
Continue to track customer service performance of the TO’s and
Supervisors. Given that 5/6 calls received were to learn about products,
product transparency eliminates those needs allowing the TO more time
to give advice about products and up and cross-sell similar items to the
happier more well-informed customer.
Add a question about product information availability to the customer
survey to determine the reactions of the customer to the change.
Document1 22
Measure efficiency in management, team-building, mentoring,
communication, evaluation/feedback, dealing with customers using a
rubric with clear criteria.
Gather reactions and reflections from learners.
Gather reactions and reflections from learners in order to make
improvements to the course.
Monitor and measure every six months how training has impacted
impacts Operator productivity and attitude, customer service quality
though data collection reports, surveys, company. Re-evaluate or provide
remedial training for those who need it.
Document1 23
the “Proposed Solutions for Consulting Firm to Carry Out” section of this document.
Delightful Duds and Décor would like the opportunity to submit a proposal to
develop and implement our proposed solutions
Document1 24