Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1915 - Scotia 2
1915 - Scotia 2
1915 - Scotia 2
with divided instruments,as the sextantand theo regard the reading of both verniers of a circle as
LITERATURE. dolite, introducing traverse surveying and plane a work of supererogation. In ordinary work we
triangulation; and levelling, including the locating are told that only one vernier is used,and we are
Surveyingand Field Work: A Practical Text-Bookon of contour-lines. A fewchaptersaredevotedto the afraid this is true, but it would have beenas well
Surveying, Levelling,andSetting-Out,
intendedfor the
Use of Students»n TechnicalSchools. By Jamks calculation of areas and of earthwork quantities to havegiven a hint that the centre round which
Williamson, A.M. Inst. C.E. London: Constablerequiredfor excavationandembankmentwork, &c. the vernier revolves may not coincide with that
andCo.,Limited. [Prioe7s.6d.net.] Whatever the character of the measurement,the of the divided circle. It is true that in another
This is an eminentlypractical book, and elemen effectof error is everywhereconsideredin greateror place it is mentioned that when great precision
tary in the sense that it beginsat the beginning. less detail, for, the author rightly observes,it is is required the reading of two verniers may be
The details into which the author has thought it only from the close study of the magnitudeof necessary,and even three verniers are considered
necessaryto enter by their minuteness suggest errors and their effectsthat the surveyoris able to as a possibleadjunct, but the useof three verniers
that he intendedhis book to displaceoral instruc arrange the work to the best advantage,paying is not evenexplained. We admit that everything
tion, but experiencegenerally condemnssuch a due regard to accuracyand economy. the author says is true, is well and clearly ex
course. The practisedteachercan gavethe student He might have added, too, that it is only by pressed,and that he has followedthe lead of many
not only valuabletime, but prevent him pursuing questioning the instrument that we learn how a worthy predecessors. But we also submit that
wronglines that have to be remediedlater. The moreaccurateor more trustworthy result might be each successivetreatise should aim at a higher
writer may think he has foreseen and guarded obtained. There is too great a tendencyto trust standard than the last. We are pleading for
againstthe waywardnessof the pupil, but the per to the instrumentalrecord as absolutely exact— to increased accuracy and the adoption of more
verse ingenuity of the tyro will find opportunity acceptthe instrument as an infallible authority. scientific methods. Instrumental construction is
for straying from the right path, howeverclearly But errors therealways will be, and these can be improving, and to get the full benefitof the care
indicated. Many practicalhints, some almost too removedto a great extent either theoretically or and ingenuity shown by the makers, greater
trifling to be insistedupon, are spread out for the practically. Geometrically it is possible, from a nicety of handling is required and a more refined
guidanceof the beginner,but we fear the minute knowledge of the theory of the instrument, to discussionof the crude records. Some teachers,
detail increases the length of the book without computetheerrorsintroducedby imperfectmechan and, indeed, many practical operators in the
making the true path easier to follow, while the ism, and to apply the necessarycorrection— as, for field, seem to think that the object of all im
surveyor,the engineer,and the architect,for whom example,in the inequalities of the pivots of a provementin construction is to makeall observa
the work is intended as a book of reference,may theodolite: but we doubt if any arithmeticalcorrec tion more mechanicaland easy. This is not our
be irritated by the enunciation of simple truths tions are ever contemplated. Mechanically,errors view. For the bestresults, an intelligent useof the
they have long practised. It might safely be maybe eliminated where the instrument is made instrumentis as necessaryasexcellenceof construc
assumedthat anyonewho is preparedto tackle the adjustable in its parts and can be used under tion. The highest class of observation can be
problemof triangulation is competentto solve a different conditions. Mechanical correctionsare obtained only when every advantageis taken of
plane triangle. more usually insisted upon. The author wisely the power of mechanicaladjustment, and every
Roughly, the book may be divided into three advises the reversion of the theodolite for the ingenuityemployedto eliminateerror. We submit
sections: chain surveying, to which the author removal of collimation error, and this, indeed, is that a teachershouldratherinsist on sucha method
devotes eight chapters; angular measurementan advancein practice. He seems,however, to of observationthat the instrumentalerrors may be
I
ENGINEERING, OCTOBER 29, 1915. PLATE XXIV.
G.
CONSTRUCTED BY SIR. W. ARMSTRONG, WHITWORTH AND CO., LIMITED, AT THEIR SHIPBUILDING WORKS, WALKER-ON-TYNE.
<=A_i: - ---- - C. -
-- >.
officer's -
a
z'ZZ
shaft -1 r---
ruwwel
|
#
* f.o.e,
is fo 42.
Lifespar...
25-oxe-7x2://f
4/resoar-
2s-des:7:2:://#
455spar Al –41
-
25oss-7-2://#"t-
4.
-
-
rel.
,
d's".
O
&
#. **. * s"v.
o, 6"w.
Bor-es-oo- *O/Left
ROOM
*
Ash. E//"MMC -
Fig.5:UPPERDEck.
-
L
J.
Tone *OOM
[[]
*
&
&#~#"
------------ - -
II
£ I
Eyca II]
caeszaw eva
£y
[T]".
***Ance do/-/**oo &ndor
- f//r/vance *A-E
2
Fig.6. *wodeCa. L'A Reft
t
w
dox
)
|
| -* ====
F.
--- Dw/MM//w;
Mrs/ *E
n
wer.s.o.
nod/
{...}
-
w
-
- do/Ifn -->
reveaw e- Coal Coal AfroL_|ffto------------
*
woeces
iiaawr
-
"|
|i
|-
-
warranIMarin
"
|1
|
$
|
$ i $
|
*
ls |: i
| |
| #
|$.|"
àV-|-|
Z|*><--~~
--_^
z|=
I<-s.*
: :#
-
|;i
=
=
$==
-–- --
-==|
-
---
---#.
---|
i-il--|
||l.|:
sP.---
:s--.0th
“g----•o.
SS:-5%.
----40ty
§|s
£S->-|$-- SS-
s#
SSi
s:I.#
à-#.
$ | :r-:
S'sS--##-* -s=
§:
-
-#
|--~~#
| ####
| $'\NSR#Z_f -R§%.K-|
#|H| ; S.-|
s:
:|
|i# -|
£5
| ---: \| f#|R\a'
'uoy
$#-##Š
i|# -,i:|*.-#2.
-s\|]
-
: ||$i*
i| |i|
s| ||i
-#
i
Oct. 29, 19x5.] ENGINEERING. 439
eliminated as far as possible, than to arrange a of the work requiredin the excavationof a pond CANADIAN RAILWAY FERRY-STEAMER
simpler plan that entirely ignorestheseerrors. (page 336). The solution leadsto a quadratic,but "SCOTIA II."
Chain surveying is an operationthat has often only oneroot is discussed. The studentwould like We reproduceon Plate XXIV., this week, seo-
been described,and about which it is difficult to to know what is the meaningof the other root, tional drawingsand plans,andon this andtheoppo
sayanything new. The author's explanationsare and why 14.8ft. is not as good an answeras 5.2 ft. site pageBand on page 446 photographioviews of
very distinct, and cover the usual ground. They The chapterson levelling are, perhaps,the best the railway ferry-steamerScotia II., built to the
leave very little to the intelligence of the pupil, of the book. The various forms of levels in use order of the Minister of Railways and Canals of
whosemathematicalknowledge is supposedto be are well explained, and the description of the the Dominionof Canada, in connectionwith the
very small. We should have preferred to seethe methodsof use leaves little to be desired. The Intercolonial Railway System. This vesselis in
effect of an error of measurementin the side or treatment of longitudinal and cross-sectionsand tendedfor serviceacrossthe Strait of Canso, be
angle of a triangle treated more generally, for the locatingof contour lines is eminentlypractical. tweenthe mainlandof NovaScotiaandCapeBreton.
As in the winter there is considerable ice-flow,the
somewould havebenefited. Someof the " special The examples are selected with judgment. The vesselhas been constructedto break up this ice,
problems" handled at some length will seem author has taken his pupil a little beyondthe ele in order to keep the passageopen for the railway
ridiculouslysimple to those who have read a little mentarystage,and the lengthy explanationswhich service. The vessel,which has severalinteresting
trigonometry; but a straining after extremesim madethe earlier sectionssomewhattediousare not features,was built at the Walker Shipyard of Sir
plicity is a feature of the book. One form of so frequent. It is hinted in the prefacethat it is W. G. Armstrong, Whitworth and Co., Limited,
simplicity, however,doesnot appealto the author, proposed in a subsequentvolume to pursue the Newcastle -on-Tyne,who have made a specialityof
and we would ask him to considerwhetherin some subjectfurther ; in that casewe haveno doubt the this type of steamer,and have consequentlygreat
exampleshe could not dispensewith a few decimal interestand the usefulnessof the treatisewill both experience of thespeoialstructuralrequirements.The
places. When distancesare measuredto a foot, be increased. vesselleft theTyne on August31 last, underthecom
it doesnot seem worth while to apply corrections mand of Captain Manning, and, in spite of heavy
accurateto the thousandth part of a foot. But weatheron the voyage,arrived at Port Mulgraveon
BOOKS RECEIVED. September 15,provingthestructuralstrengthof the
instancesof this viciouspracticeare not so glaring The Motor Manual. Compiledand Illustratedby the
hull and the fact that vesselsof this characteroan
as in manytechnicalworks. Similarly, in thecom Staff of TheMotor. EighteenthEdition. London: safelycrossthe Atlantic.
putation of rectangular co-ordinates (page 170), TemplePress,Rosebery -avenue,E.C. [Price Is. 6d. The principaldimensions of thevesselare:—
five-figure logarithms are introduced somewhat net.]
unnecessarily. A Crelle multiplication table, or Arithmetic of Alternating Current/,containing50Worked ft. in.
Examples and 182Exercises.By Ellis H. Crappkr, Lengthoverall 300 0
possibly a sliding scale,would have been readier B.Eng.. M.I.E.E. London: Whittaker and Co. „ between perpendioulars ... 286 6
and shorter. As a rule, the employmentof loga [Prioe28.6d.net.] Breadth, e xtreme,overfenders ... 50 0
rithms, as a labour-savingdevice in small multi Fifty-FirstAnnualReportonAlkali, <£&, Works. By the Depth,moulded 20 0
plication, is to be deprecated. Chief Inspector. London : Eyre andSpottiswoode, Draught of water 14 2
Traverse surveyingand the useof the theodolite Limited. [Price8d.] Displacement at 11-ft.2-in.draught... 3665tons
RugbyEngineerina Society.Proceeding!, Session1 913-14. As is shownon the crosssectionson Plate XXIV.,
deal with the ordinary problemsthat comebefore Vol. XI. Rugby: Publishedby the Society.
the surveyor. The subjectof planetabling,geodetic 10s.6d.] [Price (Figs. 8 and 9), the vessel is of the single-deck
surveying, and astronomical work do not come RussiaandDemocracy : The GermanCankerin Ruuia. type ; as all thescantlingsaregiven,it is only neces
within the scopeof the book. The same may be Bv G. de Wessklitsky. London: W. Heinemann.sary to direot attention to the inoreasedstrength
said of the employment of photogrammetric [Price Is. net] introducedin theframingof thedeckin orderto sup
Industrialand ManufacturingChem istrv. Vol. I. : In- port the weight of heavylocomotiveson the centre
methods of topographic surveying, and the use organic. By Geoffrey Martin. SecondEdition, track. Fig. 7 showsona larger scalethe connection
of photographyas an aid to practical surveying. revisedandenlarged.London: CrosbyLockwoodand at the upper deck, stringer angle,deok beam,and
Theselimitationsrather narrow the view, and the Son. [Price21s.net.] garboardstroke. The vesselconformsto the condi
student has to restrict his ambitions to the con Shipform. Resistance and ScrewPropulsion. By G. S. tions of Lloyd's highestclassificationand also with
sideration of very commonplaceproblems. He Baker. London: Constable andCo.,Limited. [Price Board of Trade
12s.6d. net.] requirements. The three lines of
will have the satisfaction of finding the simplest The Analysisof Son-FerrousAlloys. By Fred Ibbot- traok,well shownin the photogrophio view, Fig. 13,
workedout at length and with great thoroughness. son,B.Sc, andLeslie Aitchison. M. Met. London: on page 446,are laid to standard4 ft. 8J-in. gauge,
The vernier is not difficult to understand,but its Longmans, GreenandCo. [Price7e.6d. net.] andtheoarswill be shippedand discharged over the
explanation occupies several pages. That the McGibbon'sMarine Engineers' Pocket-Book.Bv W. C. forward end only (Fig. 12). It will beseenthat the
author has preferred to give numerousdiagrams McGibbon.Glasgow: JamesMunroandCo.,Limited. four bunkerswith whioh the vesselis fitted are so
[Prioe 10s.net.[
with lengthy explanationsinstead of the general Anuario arrangedthat theyoan be loadedfrom cars on the
de Mineria,Metalurgia,Electricidady Derails
theory indicatesthe classof student for whomthe Industrias de Espaiia. Bajo )a Direction de Don railway traok on deok (Fig. 5). The longitudinal
book is intended. With this care to preventthe Adriano Contreras y Don Rohan Oriol. Tomo elevationshows,Fig 2, the ram form introducedin
order to break up the ioe in front of the forward
studentstumbling, we were surprisedto find that dncimoquinto.Alio 1915.Madrid: EnriqueTeodoro. propeller. The structural arrangementaft is for a
in the solution of plane triangles he is allowed [Price7pesetas.]
the chanceof comingto grief over the "ambiguous TheStability of Masonryand otherStructures Subjectto single-sorew propellerwith theordinaryrudder. The
the Pressureof Earth and Water. By Ernest H. hull is speciallystrengthenedat thewater-line,fore
case." Another instance in which this excessive Sprague,Assoc. M. Inst.C.E. London: Scott,Green andaft, andwater-ballasttanks are arrangedat the
watchfulnessslumbers occurs in the computation woodandSon. [Price4s.net.] forwardand after ends. Theseoanquioklybe filled
440 ENGINEERING. [Oct. 29, 1915.
THE CANADIAN RAILWAY FERRY Limited,at their Walker yard, to the orderof the The maohineryhad,of course,to be arrangedto suit are placedin the wings,in order to affordthemaxi
Ministerof Railwaysand Cacalsof theDominionof thelatter purpose, andtherewerethereforefittedtwo mum of deck spacefor the accommodation of the
STEAMER "SCOTIA II." in conneotion
Canada, with theInter-ColonialRailway setsof engineson thefore and aft line,the forward railwaytrains,as shownin Fig. 15. The boilersare
is
{Concluded
from page440.) system. The vessel intendedto transportrailway enginesbeingarrangedto work the bow propeller,also arranged in the wingsof the ship, enablingthe
A
built bySir W. O. Armstrong, Whitworth and Co., vesselhasbeen designed to aot alsoasan ioe-breaker.14) or independently. The engine-room ventilators illustrated by the longitudinalsectionand plan,
ENGINEERING, NovKMBER 19, 1915.
(For Descript,
deck house.S.
DECK houses
| - sy: -*
~~ - 1--
E w; t w=s. £ - - 'M-1--. <----
5L//wrer
Jo wear o
I sor
Fig.18.
--
--L--/-/*
Co
Edwarer
"re-d
*exhausraranch wris-PA/R
--"
Jamiers
conn *ainreford-PsATA
- \le -
\
\
E/WGine
/
ERS STORE
/ Re
Co
5-/-ER
PLATE XXVIII.
e Page512.)
DECA house.s
COAL Bunker
Shafr Tunnel
* Tank/ * Tank%
-
-** wear
\
* /
w.Tank /
THE MAIN PROPELLING ENGINES OF THE CANADIAN RAILWAY FERRY AND ICE-BREAKING STEAMER "SCOTIA II."
I
S
6
0
1
4
12
In,*. J V&et
fcjj-^nm ifi
l/
0^, „-h— s=
CYLINDERS
21-3*- 64'Dia.
30'Stroke
leCLbsMorhtigPress.
It will be a
j
Fige. 17and 18,on Plate XXVIII. breakers,anda studyof the drawingsgivenwill show Cederval gland. Eaoh propellerhas four blndes, It will be seenthat the whole of the auxiliaries
e
is
that the: are four single-eided boilers, whioh are that specialconsiderationhas been givento provide and madeof nickel steel,extra thick,for working conneotcdwith the propellingmachinery are placed
3
9
each15ft. in. in diameter by 10ft. in. long,con againstthe shocksdue to sudden stoppages of the amorgstioe. on the port wing,the starboard wing beingreserved
a
is
tracted for workingpressure of 160lb. per sq.in. propellerswhen working againstice. The engines There onecondenser commonto thetwo engines.for the eleotrio generatingset, air-pumps,and air-
is
is
under natural draught. More than adequatetube are of the eingle-ecrewtriple-expansioninverted It of the Weir " Uniflux " type,and piecedon receivers, stores.
for ship service,andfor engineer's
is
a
Eurfaoe provided,as considerable amountof heat direct-actingsurface-condensingtype, each working the port tide centrally,beingcarriedon thecolumns The maohinery was designed to indicate3000horse
is
ing requiredfor ship'spurposes, and specialconnec on threecranks. Normally theywill be coupledup of thetwo high-pressurecylinders,asshown in Figs. power,atd on trial this was easilyattained.
;
is
tionsareled from the boilersto various partsof the to work togetherthe bow and stern propellers,but 17,19,and20 its methodof support well shownin
is
a
ship. Eachboilerhasan independent connectionwith there short portablelengthof shaftingbetween Fig. 19. This simplifiesgreatly the exhaust-pipe
the main tteam-pipe, so thao any one boiler maybe thetwo engines, as shownonthe plan,Fig. 18,bythe arrangement from eaohof the low-pressure cylinders. Sodth Australian Railways.— At the close of
putout of notion. The coal-bunkersare arranged at withdrawalof whichthe engines canbe operatedinde The air-pumpsare separate, andareof the Weir dual June, 1914,therewere403locomotives andsteammotor
the forward and after endsof the boiler-rooms, and pendently.Thecylindersin eachenginearerespeotivelytype,18in. by 10in. by 15in. Two setsof indepen cars uponthe South AustralianGovernmentrailways.
5
a
thesearefilled fromhatchesfrom,the upper,or train, 21 in., 34 in.,and54in. in diameter,with strokeof dently-driven12^-in.centrifugalpumpsare fitted Of these, 194were upon ft. 3-in. gauge, and209upon
6
;a
is
deck. 30in. The crank-shaftsareof thebuilt type,10}in. one of them sufficientfor the maximumduty, the 3-ft. -in. gauge.The numberof vehiclesin usein
was 518,besidestramcars.Of
a
The main engines,of whiohtheetd andfront eleva in diameter,eaohshaft beingin three interchangeother servingas stand-by. the coaching department
tionsare givenin Figs. 19and 20,on the presentpage, able pieces. The thrust-shaftsare of forged ingot The feed-pumps are locatedat the forwardendof these,366 carriages, besides13 tramcars, were upona
areof thestandardtypeof the WalWendSlipwayand steel,lOf in. in diameter. The thrust-blocksare of the main engineroomon the portside. Thesearecf 5-ft. 3-in. gauge,and 182 carriages and two tramcars
a
J
a
machineryof the ship. The firmhavehadconsider meter,and the propeller-shafts are of forgedingot 74in. by in. by in. stroke,whilein the wingsare wereupon 5-ft.3-in. gauge, and£032upon 3-ft.6-:c.
able experiencein the designof enginesfor ine- Bteel,12in. in diameter,eachshaft beingfittedwith the generalservicepumpsandotherauxiliaries. gauge.