Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Butanals: 2. Physical Properties
Butanals: 2. Physical Properties
Butanals
Boy Cornils, formerly Hoechst AG, Frankfurt/M., Federal Republic of Germany
Richard W. Fischer, Celanese Chemicals Europe GmbH, Werk Ruhrchemie, Oberhausen, Federal Republic
of Germany
Christian Kohlpaintner, Celanese Chemicals Europe GmbH, Werk Ruhrchemie, Oberhausen, Federal
Republic of Germany
(TPPTS) in water/organic two-phase systems The fourth generation of oxo catalysts used
the n/iso ratio is significantly enhanced. In for the production of butyraldehyde and espe-
particular at low temperatures, at high carbon cially of higher aldehydes (and thus less impor-
monoxide partial pressure, and at a high lig- tant for synthesis of butyraldehyd) is known as
and concentrations the formation of the straight- the LPO Mk IV version. This process applies
chain isomers is favored [3–5]. highly active bis-phosphite-modified rhodium
Early versions of the oxo process used catalysts which are suitable for both propylene
cobalt catalysts at relatively high pressures and raffinate II feedstocks for butyraldehyde and
(20 – 35 MPa), whereby [HCo(CO)4 ] is the ac- valeraldehyde, respectively. The high catalyst
tive catalyst species. The typical n/iso ratio activity allows this process to be run in single-
is about 4/1 with propylene as feedstock. By pass mode with no olefin-recycle requirements.
the mid-1900s various companies (e.g., BASF, The potential of this process is its flexibility to
ICI, Eastman) had developed their own ver- convert propylene or butenes in the same reactor
sions of the cobalt process. For short-chain system.
olefins like propylene, the cobalt technology
has almost fully been substituted by rhodium- Process Technology. For homogeneous re-
based processes. Only for higher and in par- action systems, the standard processing of the
ticular branched olefins is cobalt still the most crude hydroformylation product, containing n-
widely applied metal. The second-generation, and isobutyraldehyde, rhodium metal, ligand,
phosphine-modified cobalt hydroformylation and byproducts, is generally the distillation of
catalysts were developed in the 1960s by Shell. the reaction mixture to separate the aldehydes
In the 1970s UCC and Celanese developed from the catalyst solution. To minimize cata-
a low-pressure oxo process (LPO) with Rh as lyst decomposition, phosphine-modified cobalt
metal and triphenylphosphine (TPP) as ligand. or rhodium catalysts are separated from the re-
This process operates at a lower pressure and action product by fast flash distillation. The less
yields a n/iso ratio of about 10/1. Versions of volatile catalysts remain at the bottom and are re-
this process with a gas recycle step are com- cycled to the hydroformylation reactor without
monly known as LP Oxo Mk I (early version) further treatment. However, optimized catalyst
or Mk II. A further proposal is the LPO Mk III lifetime and thus improved activity and selec-
process with improved raw material usage and a tivity requires the discharge of a small portion
liquid catalyst recycle. The product/catalyst sep- of the catalyst for workup and addition of fresh
aration is performed in a separate vessel in which catalyst.
the aldehyde vapors are flashed off and the liq- In contrast to the homogeneous hydro-
uid solution containing the rhodium catalyst is formylation processes, the Ruhrchemie/Rhône-
recycled to the reactor. In this operating mode, Poulenc process (RCH/RP) is designed on a
the aldehyde condensation products serve as a completely different reaction and catalyst recov-
solvent for the catalyst. However, the applica- ery system. In principle the two-phase RCH/RP
tion of all versions is mostly limited to propyl- process applies a stirred tank reactor, followed
ene and butene hydroformylation. Many plants by a phase separator and a stripping column. The
have been converted from high-pressure cobalt reactor containing the aqueous catalyst solution
to LPO technology for new or additional butyr- (Rh/TPPTS) is fed with propylene and synthe-
aldehyde (and thus butanol and 2-ethylhexanol) sis gas. The crude oxo product is passed on to
capacity. the phase separator, where gaseous components
By the mid-1980s Ruhrchemie (now are removed and the liquids separated into two
Celanese) and Rhône-Poulenc developed phases, the aqueous catalyst solution and the or-
a two-phase process with a water-soluble ganic aldehyde phase. The catalyst solution is
rhodium/TPPTS complex. The major advan- recycled to the reactor via a heat exchanger sys-
tages are the simple and mild catalyst recycle, tem, which generates steam. This results in one
the high n/iso ratio of ca. 20/1 and the beneficial of the advantages of the two-phase technology:
low energy consumption of the whole process the high energy efficiency. The P/Rh ratio is kept
[3–5], [8]. above 20/1 to ensure an n/iso ratio of at least
95/5. Almost no rhodium is leached out of the
4 Butanals
water phase. The organic phase containing the air, increases the aldehyde yield but also the for-
crude aldehydes is stripped with synthesis gas to mation of byproducts. Zinc- and/or chromium-
remove dissolved propylene, which is recycled doped copper catalysts are particularly effective
to the reactor. The raw aldehyde mixture is split [20], [21].
into iso- and n-butyraldehydes in a distillation
unit. Fischer – Tropsch synthesis generates
small amounts of n-butyraldhyde, which is of
Hydrogenation of Crotonaldehyde. Be- importance in some local markets [16], [22].
fore the discovery of the hydroformylation re-
action, the aldol condensation of acetaldehyde
to give crotonaldehyde followed by hydrogena- 4. Stabilization, Testing, and Quality
tion to n-butyraldehyde was the most important Specifications
method of producing n-butyraldehyde.
Stabilization. The reactivity of butanals is
determined by the polarity of the carbonyl group.
The inductive effect of the carbonyl group pro-
motes α-proton abstraction, which allows a
broad variety of consecutive intermolecular re-
actions, with addition type reactions as the most
important examples. Thus it is recommended
to handle aldehydes during distillative work-up,
n-Butanol is formed as a byproduct by hy- storage and shipment only under the following
drogenation of the aldehyde moiety during the precautions:
selective hydrogenation of the double bond of Inert
– gas atmosphere for all reaction and work-up
crotonaldehyde. Selective hydrogenation is per- steps
formed in gas- or liquid-phase processes. Typi- Storage
– with exclusion of UV light
cal catalysts applied are supported catalysts on Storage
– at constant and moderate temperature
the basis of Cu, Ni, Pd, Ru, Fe, Cr, or Mn [1], Conversion
– into thermally stable compounds like
[9–14]. acetals, which are easily cleaved back to the
Up to the 1950s this route was still the pre- aldehydes
ferred method for producing n-butyraldehyde Addition
– of stabilizers and antioxidants
[15] on an industrial scale, but the convenient
one-stage oxo processes replaced crotonalde- Testing. The most important method of test-
hyde hydrogenation almost completely. Only ing and continuous control of product quality
countries with massive ethanol production based (Table 4) is gas chromatography with a low in-
on natural resources, such as Brazil, might redis- jection temperature to avoid decomposition of
cover the crotonaldehyde route for producing n- impurities, e.g., aldols.
butyraldehyde [15]. In the analysis of butyraldehydes it is im-
portant to detect trimeric aldehydes, which are
Dehydrogenation of Butanols. Butanols formed readily, especially in the absence of sta-
formed in other processes, such as bilizers. Since these trimerization reactions are
Fischer – Tropsch synthesis [16], alcoholic fer- catalyzed by acids, contact with acidic com-
mentation of sugar with Clostridium saccha- pounds must be strictly avoided during the
robutylacetonium liquefaciens or Bacillus amy- course of aldehyde processing. During the anal-
lobacter [17], and Reppe carbonylation [18], ysis of water in butyraldehyde by Karl Fischer
can be dehydrogenated to butyraldehydes. titration, special precautions must be taken to
avoid condensation to acetals, which is accom-
CH3 CH2 CH2 CH2 OH CH3 CH2 CH2 CHO + H2 panied by formation of water. This is achieved
by the use of a solvent mixture composed of
The reaction is carried out in the gas phase with
four parts pyridine and one part ethylene glycol.
a heterogeneous catalyst [19]. The addition of
The density and refractive index of the water-
hydrogen acceptors such as O2 , either pure or as
containing product are strongly affected by the
Butanals 5
Table 4. Delivery specifications for butyraldehydes [23]
Butyraldehyde Isobutyraldehyde
◦
Flash point, closed cup (DIN 51755) C − 13 < − 18
Lower and upper explosive
limit in air at 101.3 kPa vol% 1.94 – 12.5 1.6 – 11
Autoignition temperature
◦
(DIN 51794, ASTM D 2155) C 190 165
Odor threshold low low
LD50 (oral, rat) g/kg 2.5 – 5.9 2.8 – 3.7
LD50 (dermal, rabbit) g/kg 3.56 3.7 – 7.1
LCLo (inhal., rat) mg/15 min 23.9 23.2
LDLo (subcut., rat) g/kg 10
Marking according to Regulations
of the European Community Symbol F F ∗∗
R-Phrases 11 11 ∗∗
S-Phrases (2)-9-29-33 9-16-29-33-36 ∗∗
Hazard classification for transport:
RID/ADR 3b 3b
(Class, Item Number)
IMDG-Code
(Class, UN No., Packing Gp.) 3.2, 1129, II 3.1, 2045, II
IATA-DGR (ICAO Techn. Instr.)
(Class, UN No., Packing Gp.) 3, 1129, II 3, 2045, II
Mail (FRG) max. 125 cm3 per receptacle
and
max. 500 cm3 per
consignment
DOT (USA) flammable liquid
∗ Vapor pressure at 20 ◦ C, solubility of butyraldehydes in water and vice versa: see Tables 1 and 2
∗∗ No EEC regulation; marking corresponds to n-butyraldehyde.
raw material for the syntheses of the amino acids 4. B. Cornils, E. Wiebus, CHEMTECH 25
d,l-valine and d,l-leucine [1]. (1995) no. 1, 33.
The Tishchenko reaction is used to obtain 5. B. Cornils, Org. Proc. Res. &. Dev. 2 (1998)
isobutyl isobutyrate, a specialty solvent. Ac- no. 2, 121.
etals of the butyraldehydes with various alco- 6. J. McGarry, Ind. Eng. Chem. 22 (1983) 313.
hols serve as solvents for cellulose, resins, and 7. C. D. Frohning, C. W. Kohlpaintner in B.
rubber [1], [54]. Cornils, W. A. Herrmann (eds.): Homogeneous
The crossed Tishchenko reaction of n-butyr- Catalysis with Organometallic Compounds ,
aldehyde with acetaldehyde provides commer- VCH, Weinheim, 1996, pp. 29 – 104.
8. B. Cornils, W. A. Herrmann (eds.):
cial ester mixtures. Butyraldehydes and hydrox-
Aqueous-Phase Organometallic Catalysis,
ylamine yield the corresponding aldoximes or
Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 1998.
their salts [1], [54]. 9. V. N. Kulakov et al., SU 172744, 1964.
10. Usines de Melle, DE 814444, 1949.
Other Reactions. Isobutyraldehyde can be
11. BASF AG, DE-OS 2839474, 1980; DE-OS
isomerized to n-butyraldehyde and methyl ethyl 3130805, 1983 (M. Horner et al.).
ketone or converted to diisopropyl ketone [1], 12. V. Macho, CS 131903, 1966.
[54]. The chlorination of butyraldehydes yields 13. L. S. Pakhomova et al., SU 335227, 1969.
fragrances and pharmaceutical intermediates 14. Chem. Werke Hüls, DE-OS 3151086, 1982 (L.
[1], [54], [58–60]. n-Butyraldehyde is used as Fischer et al.).
a catalyst component for special polymerization 15. O. Horn in Ullmann, 3rd ed., vol. 4, p. 796.
reactions [61–64]. Isobutyraldehyde can be con- 16. H. Schulz, J. H. Cronjéin Ullmann, 4th ed.,
verted to isobutene on special molybdenum cat- p. 329.
alysts [65]. 17. B. Cornils, E. Zilly in F. Korte (ed.):
Additional reactions and applications can be Methodicum Chimicum, vol. 5, p. 88.
found in [1], [54] and references therein. 18. see [15], p. 20.
19. L. Bexten, J. Weber in F. Korte (ed.):
Methodicum Chimicum, vol. 5, p. 281.
7. Toxicology 20. C. D. Frohning, G. Horn in J. Falbe, U.
Hasserodt (eds.): Katalysatoren, Tenside und
Butyraldehydes have low acute toxicity (Ta- Mineralöladditive, G. Thieme Verlag,
ble 5). Exposure limits have not yet been es- Stuttgart 1978, p. 63.
tablished. Butyraldehyde liquids and vapors 21. Hoechst AG: Katalysatoren Hoechst,
strongly irritate the skin, eyes, and respiratory Frankfurt 1979, p. 44.
organs, possible due to rapid oxidation to the 22. C. D. Frohning et al. in J. Falbe (ed.);
carboxylic acids on contact with air. The symp- Chemierohstoffe aus Kohle, G. Thieme
toms are coughing, watering eyes, and a burn- Verlag, Stuttgart 1977, p. 289.
ing sensation on the skin and in the nose and 23. Hoechst AG: Delivery specifications,
Frankfurt 1984. Chemische Werke Hüls AG:
throat. On exposure to higher doses, the CNS
Data sheet for n-butyraldehyde, dry, 1983.
is impaired, resulting in depression, dizziness,
24. Ruhrchemie AG, DE 2905267, 1981 (J.
headaches, and a slight narcotic effect. The re-
Weber, V. Falk, C. Kniep).
pugnant smell of butyraldehydes occasionally 25. Allied Chem. Corp., US 2808429, 1954.
causes nausea and vomiting. Subcutaneous in- 26. Universal Oil Prod. Co., US 2683174, 1949.
jection of n-butyraldehyde causes hemolysis. 27. V. M. Polyakov et al., Khim. Promst. (Moscow)
1972, no. 10, 48, 743; Chem. Abstr. 78 (1973)
42812.
8. References 28. W. Rupilius in F. Korte (ed.): Methodicum
Chimicum, vol. 5, p. 325.
1. Ullmann, 4th ed., 9, p. 42; Ullmann, 5th ed.,
29. J. Simonik, L. Beranek, J. Catal. 24 (1972)
A4, p. 447.
no. 2, 348.
2. Kirk-Othmer, 3rd. ed., vol. 4, p. 376.
3. B. Cornils in J. Falbe (ed.): New Syntheses 30. C. E. Loeffler, L. Stautzenberger, I. D. Unruh,
with Carbon Monoxide, Springer Verlag, Encycl. Chem. Process. Des. 1977, no. 5,
Berlin-Heidelberg-New York 1980. 358 – 405.
Butanals 9
31. Mitsubishi Chemical Industries Co. Ltd., 48. B. Cornils, H. Feichtinger in J. Falbe, U.
DE-OS 2928002, 1980 (T. Masuko, S. Fukaya, Hasserodt (eds.): Katalysatoren, Tenside und
N. Murai, J. Noma); JP 78105412, 1977 (T. Mineralöladditive, G. Thieme-Verlag,
Maki); JP 78105413, 1977 (T. Maki); JP Stuttgart 1978, p. 45.
7909203, 1977 (T. Maki); JP 78108915, 1977 49. BASF AG, DE-OS 820518, 1979 (F. Merger,
(T. Maki). H. J. Förster).
32. Chisso Corp., JP 7378116, 1973 (M. Fukin, T. 50. Eastman Kodak Co., US 4225726, 1980 (D. L.
Hirai, T. Ohashi, S. Furukawa, I. Koga). Morris, A. W. McCollun).
33. A. Benning, L. Mußler, H. Tummes in F. Korte 51. Chisso Corp., JP 7715582, 1977 (J. Tsuchiya
(ed.): Methodicum Chimicum, vol. 5, p. 558. et al.); JP 7323411, 1973 (R. Takakashi, J.
34. B. Lappe, E. Schulz, in B. Cornils, W. A. Tsuchiya); JP 7334574, 1973 (S. Matsumoto,
Herrmann (eds.): Applied Homogeneous K. Gunji, T. Hamahata).
Catalysis with Organometallic Compounds, 52. Hoechst AG, DE-OS 3102826, 1982 (H.
vol. 1, VCH Verlagsgesellschaft, Weinheim Baltes, E. J. Leupold).
1996, p. 424. 53. Eastman Kodak Co., DE-OS 2652224, 1977
35. Mitsubishi Rayon Co., Ltd., JP 7882715, 1978 (B. W. Palmer, H. N. Wright).
(H. Matsuzawa, M. Kobayashi, H. Ishii, M. 54. H. J. Hagemeyer, G. DeCroes: The Chemistry
Kato); JP 7214085, 1972 (T. Kita, C. Ishii); of Isobutyraldehyde and its Derivatives,
DE-OS 2633593, 1978 (T. Onoda, M. Otake). Tennessee Eastman Comp., Kingsport, Tenn.,
36. Union Carbide Corp., DE-OS 2836309, 1979 1953.
(D. W. McNeil, B. Phillips). 55. B. Cornils, H. Feichtinger, Chem. Ztg. 100
37. Chisso Corp., JP 7946705, 1979 (M. Fukui, N. (1976) 504 – 514.
Otake, N. Nagata). 56. BASF AG, DE-OS 2758883, 1979 (H. Distler,
38. Johnson, Matthey PLC, GB 2094782, 1982 (E.
W. Goetze).
Shutt).
57. VEB-Jenapharm, GB 1345459, 1974 (J.
39. Rhône-Progil, US 3987103, 1976 (G. Gobrou,
Schmidt et al.); DE-OS 2228641, 1973 (J.
C. Falize, H. Dufour).
40. B. Cornils, A. Mullen, Hydrocarbon Process. Schmidt, H. Grunert, C. Weigelt).
1980 (11) 93. 58. Allied Chemical Corp., US 4096187, 1978
41. Ruhrchemie AG, DE-OS 2713434, 1978 (H. (J. H. Bonfield, A. Murthy, D. Pickens).
Tummes, H. Noeske, B. Cornils, W. Kascha); 59. Dow Chemical Co., US 3801645, 1974 (D. A.
DE-OS 2437957, 1976 (G. Kessen). Dalman).
42. Bayer AG, DE-OS 2702582, 1978 (O. Immel, 60. Shell International Research Maatschappij,
H. H. Schwarz, O. Weissel, H. Krimm). DE-OS 2641356, 1977 (A. Reinink, J.
43. L. Cairati et al., Chim. Ind. (Milan) 63 (1981) Grendelman).
no. 11, 723 – 725. 61. Daicel Ltd., JP 7411480, 1974 (A. Tanaka et
44. Mitsubishi Chemical Industries Co., Ltd., JP al.).
7424891, 1974 (A. Matsukuma, I. Takakishi, 62. Thiokol Chemical Corp., DE 1545025, 1974
K. Yoshida); JP 7406887, 1974 (J. Takakishi, (R. M. Gobran, S. W. Osborn).
K. Yoshida). 63. Japan Synthetic Rubber Co. Ltd., DE-OS
45. B. Cornils, H. Feichtinger, Chem. Ztg. 101 2444681, 1975 (M. Ikeda et al.).
(1977) 107 – 117. 64. Ube Industries Ltd., DE-OS 2445776, 1975
46. Texaco Inc., US 4299985, 1981 (J. F. Knifton, (H. Ueno et al.).
P. H. Moss). 65. Toa Nenryo Kogyo K. K., JP 7748603, 1977
47. BASF AG, DE-OS 2725669, 1978 (K. Merkel (K. Kaneko, H. Furukawa).
et al.).