Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CD 3. Caltex Phil V CA
CD 3. Caltex Phil V CA
FACTS:
Security Bank and Trust Company (Security Bank), a commercial banking institution,
through its Sucat Branch issued 280 certificates of time deposit (CTDs) in favor of Angel dela
Cruz who deposited with Security Bank the total amount of P1,120,000. Angel delivered the
CTDs to Caltex for his purchase of fuel products. On March 18, 1982: Angel informed Mr.
Tiangco, the Sucat Branch Manager that he lost all CTDs, submitted the required Affidavit of
Loss and received the replacement.
On March 25, 1982: Angel dela Cruz negotiated and obtained a loan from Security Bank in
the amount of P875,000 and executed a notarized Deed of Assignment of Time Deposit. On
November, 1982: Mr. Aranas, Credit Manager of Caltex went to the Sucat branch to verify the
CTDs declared lost by Angel. On November 26, 1982: Security Bank received a letter from
Caltex formally informing it of its possession of the CTDs in question and of its decision to pre-
terminate the same.
On December 8, 1982: Caltex was requested by Security Bank to furnish a copy of the
document evidencing the guarantee agreement with Mr. Angel dela Cruz and the details of Mr.
Angel's obligation against which Caltex proposed to apply the time deposits. Security Bank
rejected Caltex demand for payment because it failed to furnish a copy of its agreement w/
Angel.
On April 1983, the loan of Angel dela Cruz with Security Bank matured. On August 5, 1983:
CTD were set-off w/ the matured loan.
Caltex filed a complaint praying the bank to pay 1,120,000 plus 16% interest.
CA affirmed RTC to dismiss complaint.
ISSUE:
W/N the CTDs are negotiable.
HELD:
Section 1 Act No. 2031, otherwise known as the Negotiable Instruments Law,
enumerates the requisites for an instrument to become negotiable, viz:
(a) It must be in writing and signed by the maker or drawer;
(b) Must contain an unconditional promise or order to pay a sum certain in money;
(c) Must be payable on demand, or at a fixed or determinable future time;
(d) Must be payable to order or to bearer; and -check
(e) Where the instrument is addressed to a drawee, he must be named or otherwise indicated
therein with reasonable certainty.