Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alcohol Withdrawal Dynamed
Alcohol Withdrawal Dynamed
Topic Editors
Daniel A. Ostrovsky, MD
Daniel C. Vinson, MD, MSPH
Evaluation
Diagnose alcohol withdrawal if stopping or decreasing heavy and prolonged alcohol use leads to typical symptoms in the absence of
an alternative diagnosis.
Evaluate for reasons leading to sudden reduction or cessation of alcohol intake, such as precipitating illness.
Testing may include blood alcohol level, complete blood count, electrolyte levels, liver function tests, coagulation tests, urine and/or
serum drug screen, and in selected patients lumbar puncture and neuroimaging for assessment of possible head trauma or other
anatomic abnormalities of the central nervous system.
Differential diagnosis is extensive, and one or more conditions may mimic or be associated with alcohol withdrawal.
... /Consider
Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
using a tool such as the Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment-Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar) or another structured
instrument to assess the initial severity of withdrawal and to monitor treatment.
Management
Management involves alleviating symptoms and correcting metabolic abnormalities.
Consider outpatient treatment for patients with mild-to-moderate symptoms who are not at high risk for delirium tremens or
withdrawal seizures.
Admit all other patients for observation and treatment.
Administer thiamine (Strong recommendation), folic acid, and consider giving a multivitamin to patients with alcohol withdrawal.
Consider hydration, nutritional support, and electrolyte replacement as part of the supportive care.
Consider treatment with a benzodiazepine if CIWA-Ar score > 8-10.
Regimen options in the inpatient setting include symptom-triggered dosing, fixed-tapering dosing, or a loading-dose regimen. The
symptom-triggered dosing is generally preferred in institutions capable of close patient monitoring.
Regimen options in the outpatient setting include fixed schedule or symptom-triggered schedule.
Related Summaries
Alcohol use disorder
Wernicke encephalopathy
General Information
Description
acute syndrome of adverse central nervous system, autonomic, and cognitive effects occurring after cessation or reduction of heavy,
prolonged (≥ 2 weeks) alcohol use(2, 3, 5)
Definitions
alcohol withdrawal syndrome consists of ≥ 2 of the following criteria after cessation or reduction of heavy or prolonged use of alcohol
autonomic hyperactivity
hand tremor
insomnia
nausea or vomiting
transient hallucinations or illusions
psychomotor agitation
anxiety
generalized tonic-clonic seizures
Reference - N Engl J Med 2014 Nov 27;371(22):2109 full-text, commentary can be found in N Engl J Med 2015 Feb 5;372(6):580
delirium tremens (also called alcohol withdrawal delirium) consists of the following in patients with alcohol withdrawal syndrome
decreased attention or awareness
disturbances in memory, orientation, language, visuospatial ability, or perception
disturbance is a change from normal level and fluctuates in severity throughout the day
no evidence of coma or other evolving neurocognitive disorders
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
Reference - N Engl J Med 2014 Nov 27;371(22):2109 full-text, commentary can be found in N Engl J Med 2015 Feb 5;372(6):580
Epidemiology
Who is most affected
patients with alcohol dependence who are deprived of alcohol, as during hospitalization(2, 5)
elderly patients are at risk for more rapidly severe alcohol withdrawal syndrome, due to relatively higher alcohol blood concentrations
from lower total body water, increasingly permeable blood-brain barrier, and increased comorbidities and medications(5)
Incidence/Prevalence
overall incidence of alcohol withdrawal symptoms not established
reported rates of alcohol withdrawal syndrome in intensive care units ranges from < 1% in all patients to > 60% among highly
selected patients with alcohol dependence (Intensive Care Med 2013 Jan;39(1):16)
estimated 8% of hospitalized patients will have signs of alcohol withdrawal due to lack of alcohol in inpatient setting(4)
Associated conditions
Wernicke encephalopathy - chronic thiamine deficiency leading to classic triad of confusion, ataxia, and ophthalmoplegia(1, 2, 4, 5)
may result from chronic alcohol use, which depletes magnesium and thiamine, and leads to cell damage in mammillary body,
thalamus, and hippocampal area
can progress to permanent amnesia condition of Korsakoff syndrome
thiamine supplementation is recommended in all patients with acute withdrawal to prevent Wernicke encephalopathy
Pathogenesis
excitatory state results from abrupt removal or reduction of alcohol(2, 4)
prolonged use of alcohol causes adaptation of neuroreceptors in 2 different pathways
overactivation leads to
autonomic symptoms including tachycardia, tremors, sweating
neuropsychiatric symptoms including delirium or seizure
during acute withdrawal, dopamine levels are also increased, which is thought to lead to hallucinations and autonomic hyperarousal(2,
4, 5)
4 generally recognized stages used for reference of expected progression, but stages are not clinically reliable due to potential for
patients(4, 5)
not progressing through them sequentially
presenting with overlapping symptoms from varying stages
approximate stages are(2, 3, 4, 5)
stage 1 - minor symptoms which may occur even in presence of elevated blood alcohol levels
occurs 6-12 hours after last drink
may consist of tremors, anxiety, gastrointestinal upset, anorexia, nausea, excessive sweating (diaphoresis), palpitations,
... / Medications / Thiamine
tachycardia, hypertension and other supplementation
reported to resolve within 24-48 hours if withdrawal does not progress or is treated
stage 2
occurs 10-30 hours after last drink
may consist of hyperactivity, insomnia, and visual, tactile, or auditory hallucinations, which generally resolve within 48 hours
stage 3 - 3% to 5% of patients progress to this stage
occurs 12-48 hours after last drink (though seizures have been reported as soon as 2 hours after last drink)
similar to stage 2 but with tonic-clonic seizures; seizures typically singular or recur only few times, and spontaneously
resolve
Medication history
ask about prior benzodiazepine use (reported risk factor for severe withdrawal)(4)
ask about medications with overdose symptoms similar to delirium tremens, including
lithium
atropine
tricyclic antidepressants
Reference - Ind Psychiatry J 2013 Jul;22(2):100 full-text
Physical
General physical
Diagnosis
Making the diagnosis
diagnosis made clinically in patient with history of heavy and regular alcohol intake and onset of symptoms (listed below) after
cessation of alcohol intake(2)
symptoms typically begin around 6 hours after cessation/reduction
alcohol withdrawal syndrome is unlikely if onset of symptoms is ≥ 1 week after alcohol reduction or cessation
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-5) diagnosis requires the following criteria after exclusion of
other medical or substance-associated causes(4, 5)
history of reduction or cessation of heavy and prolonged alcohol use
≥ 2 of following must be present within a few hours to a few days after alcohol reduction/cessation, and cause clinically significant
distress or impairment
autonomic hyperactivity (sweating or tachycardia > 100 beats/minute)
increased hand tremor
insomnia
nausea or vomiting
transient hallucinations (visual, tactile, or auditory) or illusions
psychomotor agitation
anxiety
generalized tonic-clonic seizures
criteria for delirium tremens (also called alcohol withdrawal delirium) consists of the following in patients with alcohol withdrawal
syndrome
decreased attention or awareness
disturbances in memory, orientation, language, visuospatial ability, or perception
disturbance is a change from normal level and fluctuates in severity throughout the day
no evidence of coma or other evolving neurocognitive disorders
Reference - N Engl J Med 2014 Nov 27;371(22):2109 full-text, commentary can be found in N Engl J Med 2015 Feb 5;372(6):580
assess all patients in acute withdrawal for severity both initially and periodically to guide treatment decisions and assess for
progression of medical or neurological illness(2, 4)
Differential diagnosis
alcohol-induced psychotic disorder
rare complication of long-term alcohol abuse that may occur during or after episode of heavy drinking
consists primarily of auditory hallucinations, and may also have delusions or mood disturbances, all occurring in clear state of
consciousness (unlike delirium tremens)
Reference - Metab Brain Dis 2014 Jun;29(2):231 and Ind Psychiatry J 2012 Jul;21(2):155 full-text
overdoses of medications including anticholinergics, lithium, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), or other
antidepressants
amphetamine abuse
cocaine abuse
benzodiazepine withdrawal
opiate withdrawal
thyrotoxicosis (hyperthyroidism), signs include thyromegaly or exophthalmos
psychosis, symptoms include long-standing duration of delusions or hallucinations without disorientation
hypoglycemia
diagnoses associated with hypoactive delirium rather than hyperactive delirium typical of delirium tremens
hyponatremia, signs include dehydration and uremia
head injury, symptoms/signs include bradycardia, pinpoint pupils, focal neurologic deficits, and ear or nose bleed
Reference - (2), Ind Psychiatry J 2013 Jul;22(2):100 full-text, Am Fam Physician 2004 Mar 15;69(6):1443 full-text
Testing overview
Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar) recommended by many organizations to assess initial severity
and monitor treatment
in patients with suspected alcohol withdrawal, testing includes(5)
basic blood chemistry panel
complete blood cell count - thrombocytopenia or hyperhomocysteinemia may help discern risk for developing severe withdrawal,
including delirium tremens, in inpatients with alcohol withdrawal syndrome (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
alcohol and toxicology screen when clinically indicated
Blood tests
magnesium, thiamine, and electrolyte deficiencies common in patients with alcohol withdrawal(2, 4)
testing for inpatients includes(1, 2, 4, 5)
complete blood count to assess for anemia
serum glucose to assess for hypoglycemia
serum electrolytes including magnesium to detect deficiencies or abnormalities for differential diagnosis and treatment
considerations
liver and kidney function tests to assess for disease and for possible medication considerations
blood alcohol level, as withdrawal symptoms in presence of elevated blood alcohol level may suggest impending severe withdrawal
toxicology studies to assess for nonalcohol substance use
see also Alcoholic hepatitis - Testing for testing for liver disease
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
Imaging studies
consider imaging if concern for head injury or seizures present ((2), Ind Psychiatry J 2013 Jul;22(2):100 full-text)
Glasgow Modified Alcohol Withdrawal Scale (GMAWS) is a 5-item tool to designed to assess and monitor alcohol withdrawal in acute
settings, and to guide symptom-triggered dosing of benzodiazepines; see Monitoring treatment section for details
factors reported to be associated with more severe withdrawal (including seizures or delirium tremens [DT]) include(1, 2, 4, 5)
increasing time since last drink
history of delirium tremens or alcohol withdrawal seizure
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
moderate-to-severe baseline symptoms (CIWA-Ar score > 10)
prior benzodiazepine use
dehydration
electrolyte disturbance (hyponatremia or hypokalemia)
elevated aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT)
presence of structural brain lesions
prior outcomes of past alcohol withdrawal syndrome may be associated with risk of developing DT, severe withdrawal, or seizure in
patients with acute alcohol withdrawal (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on systematic review of observation studies limited by clinical and statistical heterogeneity
systematic review of 17 observational studies evaluating clinical and medical factors and incident of severe alcohol withdrawal
syndrome (SAWS), DT, and seizure in patients with acute alcohol withdrawal
SAWS definitions were heterogeneous across studies, most relied on cutoff scores from symptom scales
development of DT
DT associated with history of prior DT in analysis of 6 studies with 1,637 patients (odds ratio [OR] 2.58, 95% CI 1.41-4.7), results
limited by heterogeneity
factors not associated with incident DT included
demographic and comorbid variables of age, male sex, acute medical illness, liver disease, or pancreatic disease
substance use disorder variables including history of withdrawal seizure, prior inpatient alcohol detoxifications, history of
prior alcohol withdrawal syndrome, duration of alcohol use disorder, or daily intake of alcohol
Reference - Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2014 Oct;38(10):2664 full-text, commentary can be found in Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2015
Feb;39(2):390
lower initial platelet count in analysis of 4 studies with 1,527 patients (mean difference [MD] -45.64 mm3, p = 0.003),
results limited by heterogeneity
lower initial potassium level in analysis of 4 studies with 1,525 patients (MD -0.26 mEq/L, p = 0.006), results limited by
heterogeneity
factors not associated with incident DT included initial alanine transaminase (ALT), AST, GGT, sodium, systolic or diastolic
blood pressure, heart rate, white blood cell count, mean corpuscular volume, or creatinine
severe alcohol withdrawal syndrome
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
factors associated with SAWS included
lower initial platelet count in analysis of 4 studies with 1,527 patients (MD -45.64 × 103/mcL, p = 0.003), results limited by
heterogeneity
lower initial potassium level in analysis of 4 studies with 1,525 patients (MD -0.26 mEq/L, p = 0.006), results limited by
heterogeneity
higher initial ALT in analysis of 5 studies with 939 patients (MD 20.97 units/L, p = 0.04), results limited by heterogeneity
factors not associated with SAWS included initial AST, GGT, sodium, blood alcohol level, systolic or diastolic blood pressure,
heart rate, white blood cell count, mean corpuscular volume, or creatinine
lower initial platelet count in analysis of 2 studies with 1,160 patients (MD -59.91 × 103/mcL, p = 0.01), results limited by
heterogeneity
lower initial potassium level in analysis of 2 studies with 1,160 patients (MD -0.2 mEq/L, p = 0.0001)
higher initial GGT in analysis of 2 studies with 1,160 patients (MD 202.56 units/L, p = 0.05)
factors not associated with seizure included initial blood alcohol level, systolic or diastolic blood pressure, or heart rate
Reference - Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2014 Oct;38(10):2664 full-text, commentary can be found in Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2015
Feb;39(2):390
thrombocytopenia or hyperhomocysteinemia may help discern risk for developing severe withdrawal, including delirium tremens,
in inpatients with alcohol withdrawal syndrome (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on 2 retrospective cohort studies
normal platelet count may help rule out development of delirium tremens and seizures in patients with alcohol withdrawal
syndrome (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on retrospective cohort study
334 patients ≥ 20 years old admitted for alcohol dependence and withdrawal
delirium tremens in 3%, seizures in 2% (none had co-occurrences)
patients with delirium tremens had increased rate of thrombocytopenia, lower systolic blood pressure and serum potassium,
and higher levels of liver function tests (p < 0.05)
patients with seizures had lower blood platelet count and increased rate of thrombocytopenia (defined as < 150 × 109
platelets/L) (p < 0.05)
thrombocytopenia predicted development of delirium tremens with
sensitivity 70%
specificity 69%
positive predictive value 6%
negative predictive value 99%
hyperhomocysteinemia and thrombocytopenia each might help predict development of delirium tremens in patients admitted
for alcohol withdrawal seizures (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on retrospective cohort study
97 patients (84.5% male) admitted to emergency department with acute seizure precipitated by alcohol withdrawal were
followed for at least 48 hours
35.1% developed delirium tremens
hyperhomocysteinemia and thrombocytopenia each significantly predicted delirium tremens development (p < 0.0001 for
each)
for prediction of delirium tremens
hyperhomocysteinemia with cutoff of 14.5 mg/dL had
sensitivity 81.5%
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
specificity 67.3%
2.5 positive likelihood ratio and 0.28 negative likelihood ratio
Treatment
Treatment overview
treatment goals include minimizing symptoms, preventing complications, and facilitating continued abstinence from alcohol(3)
consider using the Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar) or a similar assessment scale for
establishing baseline severity and monitoring symptoms throughout treatment
identify risk for severe withdrawal or complications
patients with mild-to-moderate symptoms may be treated as outpatients with similar 6-month outcomes (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
indications for inpatient management include
severe alcohol withdrawal symptoms or CIWA score ≥ 15-20
autonomic overactivity and signs of withdrawal in presence of high blood alcohol content (suggests possible impending severe
withdrawal)
high risk or presence of delirium tremens and/or high risk or presence of withdrawal seizure
urine drug screen positive for other substances
serious psychiatric condition such as suicidal ideation or psychosis
poorly controlled chronic medical conditions
consider intensive care in patients with
CIWA score ≥ 20
hallucinations
need for sedation and intensive monitoring
respiratory failure
hemodynamic instability
comorbid conditions such as trauma, gastrointestinal bleeding, ingestion and/or intoxication of other substances, significant
fluid and/or electrolyte disorder, sepsis, or organ failure
medications typically suggested if CIWA-Ar score > 8-10 and tapered and discontinued once when CIWA-Ar < 8-10
... /benzodiazepines
Medicationsare/ first-line
Thiamine and other supplementation
treatment in most patients with alcohol withdrawal syndrome
benzodiazepines may reduce alcohol withdrawal symptoms, seizures, and recurrent seizures (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
different benzodiazepines reported to be similarly effective (level 2 [mid-level] evidence), so consider patient characteristics and
drug metabolism when selecting benzodiazepine agent
for inpatient treatment
regimen options include symptom-triggered dosing, fixed tapering dosing, or loading dose regimen
symptom-triggered dosing generally preferred in institutions capable of close monitoring
fixed-tapering dose may be useful in patients with history of delirium tremens or in patients where symptoms are not easily
assessed
symptom-triggered and fixed-dosing of benzodiazepines appear equally effective for improving withdrawal symptoms overall,
but symptom-triggered schedule may be associated with greater improvement in symptoms at 48 hours (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
loading protocol with long-acting benzodiazepine might reduce symptoms of alcohol withdrawal more rapidly than symptom-
triggered use of short-acting benzodiazepine in inpatient setting (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
for delirium tremens
use sedative hypnotic drugs (benzodiazepine therapy being most commonly used) for delirium tremens (ASAM Grade A)
pentobarbital and propofol can be considered if large doses of benzodiazepines fail to control agitation in patients with
delirium tremens (ASAM Grade C)
goal is to achieve calm, and then light somnolence (ASAM Grade C)
anticonvulsants not suggested in acutely ill medical patients or patients with delirium tremens, but may have a role in patients with
mild-to-moderate withdrawal
anticonvulsants such as carbamazepine, gabapentin, and pregabalin appear at least as effective as lorazepam for reducing
withdrawal symptoms (with studies mainly done in the outpatient setting), but insufficient evidence regarding anticonvulsants for
reducing alcohol withdrawal seizures (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
adjunctive medications
benzodiazepine augmentation with adrenergic medications such as dexmedetomidine or clonidine may be useful in patients with
autonomic symptoms of tachycardia, tremor, and hypertension
beta blockers may be considered in combination with benzodiazepines in patients with persistent hypertension or tachycardia
(ASAM Grade C) but not routinely recommended in all patients with delirium tremens
antipsychotic medications not recommended as monotherapy (ASAM Grade A) but may be considered as adjunct to
benzodiazepine for agitation or cognitive disturbance (ASAM Grade C)
supportive care consists of ensuring quiet environment with reduced stimulation, as well as
hydration
nutritional support
electrolyte abnormality correction
supplements including
folic acid 1 mg/day to prevent macrocytic anemia
thiamine to prevent or treat Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome (thiamine 100 mg/day for ≥ 3 days IV or intramuscularly
recommended for patients with delirium tremens [ASAM Grade C])
multivitamin IV and magnesium replacement in patients with severe alcohol withdrawal
after successful treatment of alcohol withdrawal syndrome, refer all patients to long-term treatment program to maintain abstinence
from alcohol
a visit from a recovering alcoholic may reduce problem drinking in hospitalized patients with alcohol problems (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
integrated medical and substance abuse treatment appears to improve abstinence rates in patients with substance abuse related
medical conditions (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
see Alcohol use disorder
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
Treatment setting
presence of seizure or delirium tremens considered severe withdrawal even if Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol,
revised (CIWA-Ar) score does not correlate(2, 4)
outpatient management
most patients with mild-to-moderate symptoms (CIWA ≤ 15-20) can receive outpatient detoxification with daily assessment(2, 3, 5)
consider outpatient management if(4)
mild-to-moderate symptoms present
no significant concurrent drug use
minimal alcohol craving
inpatient management
indications for inpatient management(1, 2, 3, 4)
severe alcohol withdrawal symptoms or CIWA score ≥ 15-20
autonomic overactivity and signs of withdrawal in presence of high blood alcohol content (suggests possible impending severe
withdrawal)
high risk or presence of delirium tremens
high risk or presence of withdrawal seizure
long-term intake of large amounts of alcohol
abnormal laboratory results, such as elevated aspartate aminotransferase (AST)
acute illness
urine drug screen positive for other substances
poorly controlled chronic medical conditions such as diabetes or heart failure
serious psychiatric condition such as suicidal ideation or psychosis
higher risk patients who
are < 16 years old
are frail
have cognitive impairment, learning difficulties, or multiple comorbidities
lack social support
outpatient detoxification and inpatient detoxification associated with similar rates of self-reported abstinence and use of
alcoholism-treatment services at 6 months in patients with mild-to-moderate alcohol withdrawal syndrome (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on randomized trial with baseline differences
164 male veterans of low socioeconomic status with mild-to-moderate alcohol withdrawal syndrome randomized to 1 of 2 groups
outpatient detoxification including daily clinic visits (except on weekends), medical and psychiatric evaluations, oral oxazepam
(adjusted each day depending on progress), and brief counseling
inpatient detoxification including stay in closed ward of medical center, medical and psychiatric evaluations, oral oxazepam
(adjusted each day depending on progress), and initiation of rehabilitation treatment (including group counseling, discharge
planning, and social therapy)
inpatients had increased severity of alcoholism, alcohol withdrawal syndrome, and medical problems at baseline
successful detoxification defined as meeting each of following criteria
reduction in Selected Severity Assessment scores to ≤ 6 (assessment includes ratings of 11 physical and behavioral symptoms
with score of 0-8 assigned to each symptom)
self-report of nonuse of ethanol
negative breath analysis for ≥ 3 consecutive days
reduction in dose of oxazepam to ≤ 30 mg during preceding 24 hours
Medications
Medication overview
currently there is no standard for medication dosing, administration, or assessment protocols in patients with alcohol withdrawal(3, 4,
5)
patients with Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar) score ≥ 8-10 or Short Alcohol Withdrawal Scale
(SAWS) score ≥ 12 typically receive medication
medication can be tapered and discontinued when CIWA-Ar < 8-10 or SAWS score < 12
in patients with CIWA-Ar score < 8 or mild withdrawal symptoms and without risk factors for severe withdrawal(2)
medication generally not needed
management can include supportive care and monitoring for 36 hours
supplements include
folic acid 1 mg/day to prevent macrocytic anemia
considering multivitamin IV and magnesium replacement in patients with severe alcohol withdrawal
prophylactic thiamine is recommended for all patients with acute alcohol withdrawal
Benzodiazepines
Benzodiazepine overview
benzodiazepines are first-line treatment in most patients with alcohol withdrawal(1, 2, 3, 5)
common agents and equivalent doses(3, 5)
chlordiazepoxide (longer acting [up to several days]) 25 mg
diazepam (long acting) 5 mg
lorazepam (intermediate acting [several hours]) 1 mg
oxazepam (intermediate acting) 15 mg
shorter-acting benzodiazepines, such as lorazepam, should be tapered gradually before being discontinued(2)
adverse events
common adverse events include sedation, fatigue, respiratory depression, retrograde amnesia, ataxia, dependence, and abuse(3)
delirium may result from benzodiazepine toxicity(4)
contraindications include(3)
hypersensitivity to class or ingredient
concomitant alcohol consumption (may lead to respiratory depression and death)
Royal College of Physicians (RCOP) and National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommend(1)
for patients requiring medications without delirium tremens
consider benzodiazepine (chlordiazepoxide and diazepam are most commonly used) or carbamazepine
clomethiazole is alternative, but should be used with caution
in outpatient setting(1, 3)
fixed schedule or symptom-triggered schedule may be considered
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommends fixed schedule for outpatient withdrawal management
loading dose schedule not recommended in outpatient setting
benzodiazepines reported to be similarly effective, so consider patient characteristics and drug metabolism when selecting
benzodiazepine agent(2, 4, 5)
symptom-triggered dosing(1, 2, 3, 5)
drug administration based on assessment symptom severity at set intervals
requires training in use of scales such as CIWA-Ar
generally preferred in institutions capable of close monitoring due to reported efficacy in
using less medication overall
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
shortening treatment duration
potentially reducing risk of over- or under-medication
CIWA-Ar score > 20 - evaluate for transfer to intensive care unit (ICU)
CIWA-Ar score < 8 for 3 consecutive assessments
reassess or redose every 4 hours; if score remains < 8 for 3 more consecutive checks, reassess or redose every 8 hours
if score < 8 for 48 hours, discontinue monitoring
example of symptom-triggered regimen by Glasgow Modified Alcohol Withdrawal Scale (GMAWS) scoring in inpatients
score 0 - repeat scoring in 2 hours; discontinue scoring after 4 consecutive scores of 0, unless it has been < 48 hours after
last drink
score 1-3 points
give diazepam 10 mg
repeat scoring in 2 hours
score 9-10
give diazepam 20 mg
repeat scoring in 1 hour; consult with clinician (if nurse)
Reference - Nurs Times 2012 Jun 26-Jul 2;108(26):15
symptom severity and clinical status including signs of benzodiazepine toxicity assessed before each dose
medication is stopped once patient reaches adequate sedation (after about 3 doses)
Outpatient settings
benzodiazepine regimens in outpatient settings
day 3
diazepam 10 mg orally every 12 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 12 hours
lorazepam 1 mg orally every 8 hours
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
day 4
diazepam 10 mg orally at bedtime
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally at bedtime
lorazepam 1 mg orally every 12 hours
day 5
diazepam 10 mg orally at bedtime
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally at bedtime
lorazepam 1 mg orally at bedtime
symptom-triggered dose(3)
drug administration based on assessment symptom severity at set intervals
in outpatient settings, requires patient and caregiver to reliably rate symptoms, and may not be appropriate in all patients
when CIWA-Ar score < 10 or SAWS score < 12, medication is tapered and discontinued
examples of oral symptom-triggered regimens for outpatients with CIWA-Ar > 9 or SAWS score ≥ 12
day 1
diazepam 10 mg orally every 4 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 4 hours
lorazepam 2 mg orally every 6 hours
day 2
diazepam 10 mg orally every 6 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 6 hours
lorazepam 2 mg orally every 6 hours
day 3
diazepam 10 mg orally every 6 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 6 hours
lorazepam 1 mg orally every 8 hours
day 4
diazepam 10 mg orally every 12 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 12 hours
lorazepam 1 mg orally every 12 hours
day 5
diazepam 10 mg orally every 12 hours
chlordiazepoxide 25-50 mg orally every 12 hours
lorazepam 1 mg orally every 12 hours
symptom-triggered dosing may reduce medication consumption with similar reduction in alcohol withdrawal symptoms
compared to fixed-schedule dosing in adults with alcohol dependence and medical comorbidity in general hospital ward (level 2
[mid-level] evidence)
based on quasi-randomized trial
183 adults with alcohol dependence admitted to general hospital ward for medical comorbidity were assigned by nursing unit to
symptom-triggered vs. fixed-schedule dosing of lorazepam
symptom-triggered group received lorazepam doses based on Revised CIWA-Ar scale
fixed-schedule group received scheduled lorazepam doses with tapering over 4 days
protocol errors (administration of inappropriate lorazepam dose) occurred in 17.6% with symptom-triggered dosing vs. 7.6%
with fixed-schedule dosing (p = 0.042)
symptom-triggered dosing associated with significantly reduced use of lorazepam
no significant difference in reduction in mean CIWA-Ar scores during first 2 days
Reference - J Addict Dis 2006;25(2):17
symptom-triggered self-medication and fixed-schedule self-medication in outpatient alcohol treatment unit associated with
similar medication consumption and risk of relapse in patients with mild-to-moderate alcohol withdrawal symptoms (level 2
[mid-level] evidence)
based on randomized trial with baseline differences
163 adults with alcohol dependence and mild-to-moderate alcohol withdrawal symptoms were randomized to symptom-
triggered self-medication vs. fixed-schedule self-medication and followed for 1 year
in symptom-triggered group
patients with SAWS score ≥ 12 at baseline were prescribed chlordiazepoxide (up to 300 mg/day) for 10 days
patients with SAWS score < 12 at baseline were prescribed chlordiazepoxide (up to 120 mg/day) for 10 days
in fixed-schedule group
patients with SAWS score ≥ 12 at baseline were prescribed chlordiazepoxide 200 mg/day as starting dose with 25
mg/day dose tapering
patients with SAWS score < 12 at baseline were prescribed chlordiazepoxide 80 mg/day as starting dose with 10 mg/day
dose tapering
all patients were treated in outpatient setting in specialized alcohol treatment unit
more patients in symptom-triggered group lived alone at baseline
SAWS includes 10 patient-rated symptoms with each item scored on 4-point scale for severity over past 24 hours (0 being no
symptoms and 3 being severe symptoms)
no significant differences in
time to SAWS score < 12
time to SAWS score < 6
median cumulated dose of chlordiazepoxide
relapse rates
well-being
treatment satisfaction
symptom-triggered protocol included lorazepam 1-2 mg orally or IV administered every 2 hours as needed for active
withdrawal symptoms, holding for excessive sedation
primary outcome was change in CIWA-Ar scale score
comparing loading protocol vs. symptom-triggered protocol
free of withdrawal symptoms within 72 hours of admission in 69.6% vs. 41.7% (p = 0.08)
mean decrease in CIWA-Ar score was 2.3 points/day vs. 1.5 points/day (not significant)
total benzodiazepine usage was 103.8 mg vs. 92.4 mg (not significant)
mean decrease in systolic blood pressure was 2.3 mm Hg vs. 2.7 mm Hg (not significant)
Benzodiazepine efficacy
benzodiazepines appear to reduce alcohol withdrawal symptoms, seizures, and recurrent seizures
benzodiazepines may reduce alcohol withdrawal seizures (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on Cochrane review of trials with methodologic limitations
systematic review of 64 randomized trials comparing benzodiazepines with placebo, other benzodiazepines, anticonvulsants, or
nonanticonvulsants in 4,309 patients with alcohol withdrawal symptoms
48 trials had inadequate or unclear sequence generation, and 51 trials had unclear or inadequate allocation concealment
comparing benzodiazepines vs. placebo
benzodiazepines reduced seizures (relative risk 0.16, 95% CI 0.04-0.69, NNT 13-41 assuming seizures in 8% of controls) in
analysis of 3 trials with 324 patients
nonsignificant increase in adverse effects (relative risk 3.28, 95% CI 0.31-34.52) in analysis of 2 trials with 71 patients
benzodiazepines may reduce acute alcohol withdrawal symptoms (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on systematic review without assessment of allocation concealment
systematic review of 11 trials of benzodiazepines vs. placebo or active control with 1,286 patients
therapeutic success defined as reduction in CIWA-Ar scores ≤ 10
benzodiazepines superior to placebo in therapeutic success in 2 days (odds ratio 3.28, 95% CI 1.3-8.28) in analysis of 3 trials
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
with 162 patients
review found no evidence that benzodiazepines were superior to other drugs in terms of efficacy (9 trials with heterogeneity) or
adverse effects (3 trials with 148 patients)
authors conclude that benzodiazepines remain drugs of choice for acute alcohol withdrawal
Reference - CMAJ 1999;160(5):649 PDF
Reference - N Engl J Med 1999 Mar 25;340(12):915 full-text, commentary can be found in N Engl J Med 1999 Aug 19;341(8):609
Benzodiazepine selection
different benzodiazepines appear to have similar safety and efficacy for treatment of alcohol withdrawal (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on Cochrane review of trials with methodologic limitations
systematic review of 64 randomized trials comparing benzodiazepines with placebo, other benzodiazepines, anticonvulsants or
nonanticonvulsants in 4,309 patients with alcohol withdrawal symptoms
48 trials had inadequate or unclear sequence generation, and 51 trials had unclear or inadequate allocation concealment
in direct comparison trials of different benzodiazepines
4 trials reported alcohol withdrawal seizures
4 trials reported delirium tremens
3 trials reported alcohol withdrawal symptom score at 48 hours
3 trials reported alcohol withdrawal symptom score at end of treatment
7 trials reported adverse events
6 trials reported severe, life-threatening adverse events
11 trials reported dropouts
sample sizes in each of these comparison trials ranged from 20 patients to 100 patients
none of these trials found statistically significant differences
Reference - Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2010 Mar 17;(3):CD005063
Anticonvulsants
Overview
recommendations and suggestions
common adverse events include dizziness, ataxia, diplopia, nausea, and vomiting(3)
contraindications include(3)
hypersensitivity to class or ingredient
hypersensitivity to tricyclic antidepressants
monoamine oxidase inhibitor use within past 14 days
hepatic porphyria
Anticonvulsant efficacy
evidence comparing different drug classes for reducing seizures in patients with alcohol withdrawal is limited; only drug class with
significant evidence for reducing seizures is benzodiazepines (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
carbamazepine
NICE guideline recommends considering carbamazepine for acute alcohol withdrawal in patients without delirium tremens(1)
carbamazepine appears at least as effective as benzodiazepine for reducing withdrawal symptoms, but insufficient evidence
regarding anticonvulsants for reducing alcohol withdrawal seizures (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on Cochrane review with limited evidence
systematic review of 56 randomized trials comparing anticonvulsants (not including benzodiazepines) vs. other drugs or
placebo in 4,076 patients with alcohol withdrawal symptoms
anticonvulsants had lower rates of seizures and side effects compared with other drugs but these findings were not statistically
significant
other drugs studied were primarily benzodiazepines
no significant differences in any outcomes comparing anticonvulsants vs. placebo
comparing anticonvulsants to active treatment
only statistically significant finding was improvement in CIWA-Ar score with carbamazepine compared with benzodiazepine
in analysis of 3 trials with 260 patients (mean difference in decrease -1.04, 95% CI -1.89 to -0.2)
no significant difference in any other comparisons
gabapentin
gabapentin appears at least as effective as lorazepam for reducing alcohol withdrawal symptoms and may reduce early return to
drinking (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on randomized trial without intention-to-treat analysis
100 outpatients with alcohol withdrawal and CIWA-Ar score ≥ 10 were randomized to 1 of 3 treatments for 4 days
gabapentin 300 mg 3 times daily for 3 days, then 300 mg twice daily for 1 day
gabapentin 400 mg 3 times daily for 3 days, then 400 mg twice daily for 1 day
lorazepam 2 mg 3 times daily for 3 days, then 2 mg twice daily for 1 day
gabapentin may be as effective as chlordiazepoxide for reducing alcohol withdrawal symptoms in outpatients (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on small randomized trial with high loss to follow up
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
26 patients with alcohol withdrawal (meeting Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder [DSM-IV] criteria) not
requiring hospitalization were randomized to gabapentin vs. chlordiazepoxide for 6 days
gabapentin dosing 1,200 mg orally for 3 days then 900 mg, 600 mg, and 300 mg orally for 1 day each
chlordiazepoxide dosing 100 mg orally for 3 days then 75 mg, 50 mg, and 25 mg orally for 1 day each
35% of patients were lost to follow-up and were excluded from analysis
gabapentin associated with less sleepiness on days 5-7 (p = 0.04)
no significant differences in alcohol craving or alcohol withdrawal symptoms
Reference - Ann Pharmacother 2013 Jul-Aug;47(7-8):961
pregabalin, lorazepam, and tiapride appear similarly effective for preventing withdrawal symptoms, but tiapride may be less
effective for maintaining abstinence (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on investigator-blinded randomized trial with high dropout rate
111 patients aged 18-75 years with alcohol dependence, alcohol consumption > 80 g during previous 24 hours, and CIWA-Ar score
≥ 10 were randomized to 1 of 3 treatments for 14 days
pregabalin up to 450 mg/day
lorazepam up to 10 mg/day
tiapride up to 800 mg/day
doses score-guided to achieve minimum withdrawal symptomatology
patients were in outpatient setting with medication administered by principal investigator from 8 AM to 4 PM and by family
member from 4 PM to 8 AM
52% completed trial
abstinence at day 14 in 62.2% with pregabalin vs. 56.8% in lorazepam vs. 37.8% with tiapride (p = 0.04 between groups)
all treatments associated with similar reduction in scores from baseline (all p < 0.001)
withdrawal
obsessive and compulsive drinking
craving
psychiatric symptoms
quality of life
Adrenergic medications
Adrenergic overview
consider adjunctive antihypertensive agent in patients with persistent cardiac adrenergic symptoms despite treatment of dehydration
and electrolyte imbalances(5)
clonidine or beta blockers are not recommended as monotherapy, but may be adjunctive to benzodiazepine agent(2)
antihypertensive agents can reduce adrenergic symptoms, but will not prevent seizures(3)
Alpha2-adrenergic agonists
Clonidine
clonidine (lacks United States FDA approval for use in alcohol withdrawal syndrome)
consider adjunctive clonidine in patients with
significant increase in blood pressure or nearing hypertensive urgency (pressure > 180/120 mm Hg)(5)
other autonomic symptoms such as tachycardia or tremor(4)
clonidine does not prevent seizure or delirium and is not recommended as monotherapy or to treat general withdrawal symptoms(4,
5)
common adverse events include hypotension, dry mouth, dizziness, constipation, and sedation(3)
contraindications include hypersensitivity to drug class or ingredient(3)
Dexmedetomidine
dexmedetomidine
dexmedetomidine is alpha-2 agonist that decreases release of norepinephrine thereby decreasing sympathetic overdrive
dexmedetomidine does not prevent seizures or delirium and should not be used as monotherapy
addition of dexmedetomidine to diazepam may reduce benzodiazepine use and improve sedation outcomes in patients with
alcohol withdrawal in intensive care (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on randomized trial without placebo control
72 patients with alcohol withdrawal in ICU receiving symptom-triggered diazepam 10 mg bolus as needed were randomized to
receive addition of dexmedetomidine vs. receiving diazepam alone
dexmedetomidine was initiated at 0.2-1.4 mcg/kg/hour and titrated up until patient achieved target sedation range (-2 to 0 score
on Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale [RASS])
5 patients were excluded from analysis due to refractory symptoms requiring additional sedative agents
comparing addition of dexmedetomidine vs. usual care, dexmedetomidine associated with
reduced diazepam use at 24 hours (median 20 mg vs. 40 mg, p < 0.001)
reduced overall diazepam use during ICU stay (median 60 mg vs. 90 mg, p < 0.001)
improved sedation outcomes including
greater proportion of time spent in target sedation range (median 90% vs. 64.5%, p < 0.001)
decreased proportion of time of insufficient sedation (7.75% vs. 15%, p < 0.001)
decreased proportion of time of oversedation (2% vs. 15%, p < 0.001)
fewer rescue sedation boluses in 24 hours (median 1.25 vs. 4, p = 0.004)
dexmedetomidine might not affect duration of hospital stay, but may reduce lorazepam dose requirement at 24 hours (level 2
[mid-level] evidence)
based on small randomized trial
24 patients with Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment score ≥ 15 despite lorazepam IV ≥ 16 mg over 4-hour period were
randomized to dexmedetomidine IV (1.2 mcg/kg/hour vs. 0.4 mcg/kg/hour) vs. placebo for up to 5 days
mean reduction in lorazepam dose requirement at 24 hours after study drug compared to 24 hours before study drug
45 mg with dexmedetomidine 1.2 mcg/kg/hour (p = 0.1 vs. placebo)
62 mg with dexmedetomidine 0.4 mcg/kg/hour (p = 0.067 vs. placebo)
8 mg with placebo
no significant difference between either dexmedetomidine group vs. placebo for lorazepam dose requirement at 7 days or
... / Medications / Thiamine
duration of stay in hospital or and
ICU other supplementation
decrease in heart rate > 20 beats/minute in
7 patients (88%) with dexmedetomidine 1.2 mcg/kg/hour (p = 0.04 vs. placebo)
3 patients (38%) with dexmedetomidine 0.4 mcg/kg/hour (not significant vs. placebo)
2 patients (25%) with placebo
1 patient had two 9-second asystolic pauses on telemetry and had dexmedetomidine discontinued
Reference - Ann Intensive Care 2012 May 23;2(1):12 full-text
review of adjunctive dexmedetomidine in the management of severe acute alcohol withdrawal syndrome can be found in Am J
Drug Alcohol Abuse 2015;41(5):382
Beta blockers
beta blockers may be considered in combination with benzodiazepines in patients with persistent hypertension or tachycardia (ASAM
Grade C) but not routinely recommended in all patients with delirium tremens(6)
no evidence they improve clinical outcomes
propranolol may worsen delirium (ASAM Level V)
consider beta blockers only in patients with symptomatic tachycardia or as adjunct to hypertension management(5)
atenolol commonly used; typical single doses are(3)
50 mg if pulse 50-79 beats/minute
100 mg if pulse ≥ 80 beats/minute
common adverse events include bradycardia, hypotension, fatigue, dizziness, cold extremities, and depression(3)
contraindications include(3)
hypersensitivity to drug class or ingredient
second- or third-degree atrioventricular block
uncompensated heart failure
cardiogenic shock
sick sinus syndrome without implantable cardioverter-defibrillator
untreated pheochromocytoma
Antipsychotic medications
neuroleptics not recommended as monotherapy for alcohol withdrawal or delirium tremens due to increased risk of seizures (ASAM
Grade A)(6)
neuroleptics have higher mortality, more complications, and longer duration of delirium compared to sedative-hypnotics in controlled
trials(6)
consider neuroleptics in conjunction with benzodiazepines if agitation, disturbed thinking, or perceptual disturbances not adequately
controlled (ASAM Grade C)(6)
consider haloperidol as adjunctive therapy for agitation(4, 5, 6)
suggested dosing
0.5-5 mg IV every 0.5-2 hours
maximum doses are 0.5 mg/kg/day or 35 mg/day
0.5-5 mg orally every 4 hours as needed for agitation is another option
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
cautions include
lower seizure threshold
extrapyramidal effects
increased risk of arrhythmias due to QTc prolongation
prior to haloperidol administration, perform baseline electrocardiogram and electrolyte panel
if ≥ 2 risk factors for QTc prolongation, avoiding haloperidol suggested; risk factors include
female gender
myocardial infarction diagnosis
septic shock
left ventricular dysfunction
use of other QTc prolonging drugs
age > 68 years
baseline QTc ≥ 450 milliseconds
hypokalemia
haloperidol may be associated with fewer hallucinations and cardiac complications than clonidine as adjunct to benzodiazepine in
postoperative trauma patients with alcohol dependence (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on randomized trial with allocation concealment not stated and without intention-to-treat analysis
180 multiple-injured alcohol-dependent patients in ICUs after operative management randomized to 1 of 3 treatments with need for
medication based on CIWA-Ar score
flunitrazepam plus clonidine
chlormethiazole plus haloperidol
flunitrazepam plus haloperidol
4 patients (7%) in flunitrazepam/clonidine group excluded from further analysis due to hallucinations, no hallucinations reported in
either haloperidol group (no p value reported)
159 patients analyzed
flunitrazepam/clonidine associated with increased risk for cardiac complications (p = 0.0047)
chlormethiazole/haloperidol associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation (p = 0.032) and increased risk for pneumonia (p =
0.041)
no significant differences in mortality, sepsis, upper respiratory tract infections, bleeding, or days in intensive care unit
Reference - Crit Care Med 1996 Mar;24(3):414
DynaMed commentary – trial does not establish need for second drug
haloperidol and clonidine may have similar rates of severe alcohol withdrawal syndrome when used as adjunct to benzodiazepine in
postoperative tumor resection patients with alcohol dependence (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on randomized trial without blinding of patients and without intention-to-treat analysis
220 patients (mean age 53 years) with alcohol dependence admitted to ICU after tumor resection for carcinoma of upper digestive
tract were randomized to 1 of 4 groups
flunitrazepam plus clonidine
chlormethiazole plus haloperidol
flunitrazepam plus haloperidol
ethanol
neuroleptics alone may increase mortality and duration of delirium compared to sedative-hypnotics (benzodiazepines or
barbiturates) in patients with delirium tremens (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on systematic review without assessment of trial quality
systematic review of 9 prospective controlled trials of treatments for delirium tremens
no placebo-controlled trials of sedative-hypnotic agents found
compared to sedative-hypnotics, neuroleptics associated with
increased mortality (relative risk 6.6, 95% CI 1.2-34.7) in analysis of 5 trials with 386 patients
longer duration of delirium in 2 of 4 trials, no significant difference in delirium in 2 trials
Reference - Arch Intern Med 2004 Jul 12;164(13):1405, correction can be found in Arch Intern Med 2004 Oct 11;164(18):2068,
commentary can be found in ACP J Club 2005 Jan, Arch Intern Med 2005 Feb 14;165(3):346, Arch Intern Med 2005 Mar
14;165(5):586
prophylactic thiamine is recommended for all patients with acute alcohol withdrawal(1, 2, 3, 5)
thiamine options
orally in patients in acute alcohol withdrawal, with or at risk of malnourishment, with decompensated liver disease, or before
and during planned medically assisted detoxification
parenterally followed by orally in patients who are seen in the emergency department or admitted to the hospital with an
acute injury or illness and have either of the following
are malnourished or at risk for malnourishment
have decompensated liver disease
parenterally in patients with suspected Wernicke encephalopathy, especially if they are about to receive glucose IV, as
glucose alone may precipitate Wernicke in thiamine-deficient patients
in United Kingdom, each Pabrinex carton of 5 ml ampoules for injection contains 250 mg of thiamine along with other
vitamins and nutrients
suggested dosing for thiamine varies from 100 mg/day to > 500 mg/day for 3-5 days, depending on clinical status
British Association for Psychopharmacology (BAP) guidelines recommended dosing for thiamine in alcohol-related brain
disorder (based on uncontrolled trials)
oral thiamine > 300 mg/day during detoxification in healthy uncomplicated alcohol-dependent or heavy drinkers
250 mg intramuscularly or IV once daily for 3-5 days (or until no further improvement) in patients at high risk for Wernicke
encephalopathy (such as malnourished or unwell patients)
> 500 mg/day intramuscularly or IV for 3-5 days, then 250 mg intramuscularly or IV once daily for 3-5 days if suspected or
established Wernicke encephalopathy
Reference - BAP updated evidence-based guideline on pharmacological management of substance abuse, harmful use,
addiction, and comorbidity (J Psychopharmacol 2012 Jul;26(7):899 full-text)
efficacy
thiamine 200 mg once daily for 2 days reported to improve working memory performance in patients with alcohol
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
dependence, but dose-response relationship not established (level 3 [lacking direct] evidence)
based on randomized trial without clinical outcomes and with high dropout rate
169 patients (mean age 42 years) admitted to alcohol detoxification unit were randomized to 1 of 5 thiamine doses (5 mg vs.
20 mg vs. 50 mg vs. 100 mg vs. 200 mg) intramuscularly once daily for 2 consecutive days and then tested with attention
task 3 days later
at baseline all patients were free from acute Wernicke encephalopathy (defined as ataxia, eye movement abnormalities, and
reduced consciousness)
primary outcome included assessment of delayed alternation measured by recording number of trials needed to reach
learning criterion (correctly identifying coin location 12 consecutive times on a test with a recurring pattern)
62 patients (37%) were excluded from analyses
43 patients were excluded because they did not complete study
19 patients were excluded to account for baseline differences observed after high patient dropout
mean number of trials needed to reach learning criterion (estimated from graph)
50 with thiamine 5 mg
55 with thiamine 20 mg
38 with thiamine 50 mg
52 with thiamine 100 mg
32 with thiamine 200 mg (p = 0.031 compared to mean of other 4 doses)
normal values and clinically important difference in number of trials needed to reach learning criterion not reported
Reference - Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2001 Jan;25(1):112
Cochrane review evaluating thiamine for prevention and treatment of Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome found only 1 additional
unpublished trial with 8 patients (Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013 Jul 1;(7):CD004033)
thiamine 300 mg/day reported to reduce risk for cognitive deficit during alcohol withdrawal in alcohol-dependent men (level 3
[lacking direct] evidence)
based on controlled trial published in German
45 alcohol-dependent men had 2 weeks of withdrawal treatment in psychiatric clinic
23 given thiamine 300 mg/day, 22 had hospital diet alone with no vitamin substitution
thiamine decreased percentage of weak test performances (details and clinical relevance not reported in abstract), but no
significant difference in mean test performances
Reference - Nervenarzt 1989 Oct;60(10):633 [German]
giving thiamine before glucose (when practical) has been recommended to avoid Wernicke encephalopathy in thiamine-
deficient patients
all case reports of Wernicke encephalopathy have been with patients with prolonged glucose administration and continued
thiamine deficiency
glucose administration should not be delayed in acute situations and thiamine should still be supplemented but not
necessarily before glucose
Reference - JAMA 1998 Feb 25;279(8):583
magnesium supplementation
consider multivitamin IV and magnesium replacement in patients with severe alcohol withdrawal(2, 4)
magnesium not suggested in acutely ill medical patients if magnesium levels are normal(5)
ASAM recommendations
magnesium may not reduce symptoms of acute alcohol withdrawal (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on Cochrane review with limited evidence
systematic review of 4 randomized trials comparing magnesium vs. placebo in 317 hospitalized adults with or at risk of acute
alcohol withdrawal
all trials had unclear allocation concealment and/or unclear blinding
no significant differences in
delirium tremens, grand mal seizures, and other alcohol withdrawal symptoms in 1 trial with 100 adults
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
grip strength in analysis of 3 trials with 226 adults
no clinically important differences in adverse events reported, but meta-analysis precluded by insufficient reporting of data on
serious adverse events
serious adverse events related to magnesium may include central nervous system depression, arrhythmias, heart block,
hypotension, respiratory tract paralysis, coagulopathies, and hyporeflexia
Reference - Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013 Jun 5;(6):CD008358
Other medications
Barbiturates
barbiturates not recommended for outpatient treatment(3)
pentobarbital can be considered if large doses of benzodiazepines fail to control agitation in patients with delirium tremens (ASAM
Grade C)(6)
augmentation of benzodiazepine with phenobarbital may be useful in patients with treatment-resistant withdrawal(4)
close monitoring recommended
intubation and mechanical ventilation may be required
phenobarbital for severe alcohol withdrawal (defined as elevated CIWA score and symptoms refractory to benzodiazepines)
mechanism of action is potentiating synaptic inhibition of GABAA receptor
doses ranging from 65 to 260 mg IV in either weight-based or fixed-dosing have been reported in literature
onset and duration of action
phenobarbital IV action onset is about 5 minutes, with maximal effect at 30 minutes
duration of action reported to be approximately 4-10 hours
GHB 50 mg/kg/day might reduce alcohol withdrawal symptoms and help maintain abstinence (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on Cochrane review of limited evidence
systematic review of 13 randomized trials comparing GHB vs. other active treatment or placebo for treatment of withdrawal
syndrome and prevention of relapse with 648 patients
11 trials conducted in Italy
GHB 50 mg associated with improved withdrawal symptom scores compared to placebo at 1 hour to 7 hours in 1 trial with 23
patients
comparing GHB 50 mg vs. placebo at 3 months in 1 trial with 71 patients
abstinence in 30.6% vs. 5.7% (p = 0.022, NNT 4)
relapse to heavy drinking in 27.8% vs. 77.1% (p = 0.0032, NNT 2)
mean craving score 3.1 vs. 7.6 (p < 0.0001)
no significant differences in CIWA-Ar scores comparing GHB 50 mg or 100 mg to clomethiazole in 1 small trial
no significant differences in abstinence at 12 months comparing GHB to
naltrexone in 1 trial with 55 patients
disulfiram in 1 trial with 59 patients
uncomplicated alcohol withdrawal defined as no history of delirium tremens or withdrawal seizure in prior alcohol withdrawal
episodes
mean CIWA-Ar score was 18.35
follow-up was 10 days post treatment
both groups had significant CIWA-Ar score reduction from baseline (p < 0.0001 each)
comparing sodium oxybate vs. oxazepam no significant differences in
reduction of CIWA-Ar scores from baseline (-15.62 vs. -16.27, not significant)
reduction of sweating, tremor, and anxiety scores
maintaining abstinence throughout follow-up with alcohol breath test measurement (90.2% vs. 84.6%, not significant)
intensity and frequency of craving for study medication
adverse events (≥ 1 events in 31.1% vs. 26.2%, not significant)
drug compliance (96.34% vs. 94.67%, not significant)
1 patient in sodium oxybate group developed delirium tremens, and 1 patient in oxazepam group developed severe dermatitis
Reference - GATE 1 trial (CNS Drugs 2014 Aug;28(8):743)
Reference - Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2007 Apr 18;(2):CD005190 (review updated 2008 Aug 11)
Clomethiazole (chlormethiazole)
Royal College of Physicians (RCOP) concise guidance of NICE guideline recommendations(1)
consider offering clomethiazole as alternative to benzodiazepine or carbamazepine for acute alcohol withdrawal in inpatient
setting
using clomethiazole with caution, only in inpatient settings, and as directed by summary of product characteristics
chlormethiazole (clomethiazole) may produce bronchial hypersection and respiratory depression requiring mechanical ventilation
(Anesth Analg 1999 Apr;88(4):946 full-text)
treatment doses
in surgical ICU settings is chlormethiazole 375 mg bolus (range 45-500 mg) then infusion of 8.2 mg/kg/hour (range 1.5-12
mg/kg/hour)
contraindicated if CIWA-Ar score > 15
Baclofen
baclofen has limited evidence to evaluate for alcohol withdrawal syndrome
based on Cochrane review
systematic review of 2 randomized trials evaluating baclofen in 81 adults with alcohol withdrawal syndrome
baclofen significantly reduced dependence on high-dose lorazepam but had no significant difference in alcohol withdrawal
symptoms vs. placebo in 1 trial with 44 adults, but results limited by high dropout rate (< 80% analyzed)
no significant difference in alcohol withdrawal symptoms comparing baclofen vs. diazepam in 1 trial with 37 adults
Reference - Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2015 Apr 3;(4):CD008502
Ethyl alcohol
ethyl alcohol not recommended (ASAM Grade C)(6)
Phenothiazines
phenothiazines not recommended for outpatient treatment(3)
Propofol
propofol can be considered if large doses of benzodiazepines fail to control agitation in patients with delirium tremens (ASAM Grade
C)(6)
augmentation of benzodiazepine with propofol may be useful in patients with treatment-resistant withdrawal(4)
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
intubation and mechanical ventilation required
doses are approximately 0.3-1.25 mg/kg (20%-50% less than those for anesthesia)
monitor for bradycardia and hypotension
augmentative propofol may be associated with increased time to symptom resolution, and increased duration of mechanical
ventilation, intensive care, and hospital stay in patients with treatment-resistant alcohol withdrawal (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on retrospective cohort study
66 patients with treatment-resistant alcohol withdrawal were assessed for clinical outcomes
treatment-resistant withdrawal defined as requiring ≥ 40 mg diazepam (or equivalent) in 1 hour
33 patients received benzodiazepines alone (usual care), and 33 patients received adjunctive propofol
all patients receiving propofol had invasive mechanical ventilation (42.4% of usual care group had mechanical ventilation) and
propofol group had significantly more males (93.9% compared to 69.7% in usual care group [p = 0.01])
comparing adjunctive propofol vs. usual care, addition of propofol associated with increased
time to withdrawal resolution (mean 7 days vs. 5 days, p = 0.025)
duration of mechanical ventilation (mean 7 days vs. 2.5 days, p = 0.017)
duration of stay in
intensive care (mean 10 days vs. 4 days, p < 0.001)
hospital (mean 16.2 days vs. 6.7 days, p < 0.001)
Comparative efficacy
evidence comparing different drug classes for reducing seizures in patients with alcohol withdrawal is limited; only drug class with
significant evidence for reducing seizures is benzodiazepines (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on Cochrane overview with heterogeneity and trials with methodologic limitations
systematic review of 5 Cochrane reviews with 114 randomized trials evaluating effectiveness and safety of pharmacological
interventions in 7,333 patients with alcohol withdrawal
CD005063 evaluating benzodiazepines included 64 trials with 4,309 patients
CD005190 evaluating psychotropic analgesic nitrous oxide included 5 trials with 212 patients
CD006266 evaluating gamma-hydroxybutyrate included 13 trials with 648 patients
CD008502 evaluated baclofen vs. diazepam in 1 trial with 37 patients
CD005064 evaluating anticonvulsants (excluding benzodiazepines) included 56 trials with 4,076 patients
no significant differences in adverse events or dropouts in most comparative analyses, but most analyses had small numbers of
trials
Reference - Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011 Jun 15;(6):CD008537
Other management
Resistant alcohol withdrawal
resistant alcohol withdrawal(4)
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
defined as not achieving sedation with diazepam > 200 mg or lorazepam 40 mg during first 3-4 hours of treatment
management options
progressively larger benzodiazepine IV bolus doses
continuous infusion of benzodiazepine
augmentation of benzodiazepine with rescue medications including phenobarbital, propofol, or dexmedetomidine
if adjunctive rescue medication used, intubation and mechanical ventilation may be required
a visit from a recovering alcoholic may reduce problem drinking in hospitalized patients with alcohol problems (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on nonrandomized trial
314 patients hospitalized with alcohol-related injuries randomized to 1 of 3 treatments
peer intervention (physician message plus 30- to 60-minute visit with a recovering alcoholic)
brief intervention (5- to15-minute physician-delivered message)
usual care
abstinence rates 6 months after hospital discharge
64% with peer intervention (p = 0.006, NNT 4 vs. usual care)
51% with brief intervention (p = 0.006, NNT 7 vs. usual care)
36% with usual care
integrated medical- and substance-abuse treatment appears to improve abstinence rates at 6 months in patients with substance-
abuse related medical conditions (level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on subgroup analysis of randomized trial
592 patients with alcohol or other substance abuse randomized to integrated care vs. usual care
integrated care consisted of integrated primary healthcare and addiction treatment program
usual care consisted of separate primary care and substance-abuse treatment
both programs were group based for 8 weeks followed by 10 months of optional aftercare
no significant difference in overall abstinence rates (68% vs. 63%, p = 0.18)
no significant difference in subgroup without substance abuse related medical conditions (66% vs. 73%, p = 0.23)
subgroup of 341 patients with substance abuse related medical conditions more likely to be abstinent with integrated care (69% vs.
55%, p = 0.006, NNT 8)
findings significant both for patients with medical conditions and psychiatric conditions
Reference - JAMA 2001 Oct 10;286(14):1715 full-text, editorial can be found in JAMA 2001 Oct 10;286(14):1764
narrative systematic review of studies evaluating patient and program factors associated with transition from detoxification to alcohol
use disorder treatment can be found in J Subst Abuse Treat 2015 May;52:31
see also Alcohol use disorder
Monitoring treatment
clinically assess all patients periodically to monitor for emergence of medical or neurological illness not present at admission(2)
outpatients should be monitored daily until symptoms decrease and medication dosage reduced(3)
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
at each visit, assess
blood pressure and pulse
Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar)
check alcohol breath analysis at random intervals (if available)
Glasgow Modified Alcohol Withdrawal Scale (GMAWS) was designed to assess and monitor alcohol withdrawal in acute settings,
and to guide symptom-triggered dosing of benzodiazepines
Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment – Alcohol, revised (CIWA-Ar) recommended to assess initial severity and monitor
treatment (1, 2, 3, 5)
10-question tool to assess severity of alcohol withdrawal in order to
help make initial treatment decision in addition to history and physical (inpatient vs. outpatient)
guide symptom-triggered treatment regimen
GMAWS Tool*:
Item Scoring
score 9-10
give diazepam 20 mg
repeat scoring in 1 hour; consult with clinician (if nurse)
tonic-clonic seizures(2, 3, 4)
reported 3%-5% of patients develop seizures 12-48 hours after last drink
seizures typically singular or recur only few times, and spontaneously resolve
protracted withdrawal syndrome reported in some patients after acute period of alcohol withdrawal
defined as symptoms of withdrawal persisting or recurring beyond acute period of withdrawal
symptoms may linger after acute period
symptoms may clear for 1-2 months after acute period and then recur
reported symptoms of protracted alcohol withdrawal include anxiety, hostility, irritability, depression, labile mood, fatigue, insomnia,
difficulties concentrating and thinking, reduced interest in sex, and unexplained physical complaints particularly of pain
hypothesized to result from persistence of central nervous system adaptive changes to chronic substance use
Reference - Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) Protracted Withdrawal 2010 PDF
Prognosis
stages of progression
4 generally recognized stages used for reference of expected progression, but stages are not clinically reliable due to potential of
patients(4)
not progressing through them sequentially
presenting with overlapping symptoms from varying stages
stage 2
occurs 10-30 hours after last drink
may consist of hyperactivity, insomnia, and hallucinations (visual, tactile, or auditory)
increased serum potassium levels may be associated with increased risk of mortality in psychiatric inpatients with delirium tremens
(level 2 [mid-level] evidence)
based on retrospective cohort study with nested case control analysis
190 psychiatric inpatients (mean age 51 years) with delirium tremens in Serbia between 2002 and 2011 were assessed for medical
record data and clinical outcomes
14 patients who died were matched for age, sex, and year of hospitalization with 28 controls who had survived
in overall analysis, lethal outcome associated with
increased age (p = 0.037)
higher serum potassium level (p < 0.001); all patients had potassium levels within normal range (mean 4.5 mmol/L in cases and
mean 3.87 mmol/L in all survivors)
see Alcohol use disorder for additional information on interventions to reduce problem drinking
Screening
AUDIT-PC score at admission may help identify hospital inpatients who will develop alcohol withdrawal syndrome (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on diagnostic case-control study
223 medical or surgical inpatients who developed alcohol withdrawal syndrome (AWS) during hospital stay and 466 matched
... / Medications / without
inpatient controls Thiamine andscreened
AWS were otherfor
supplementation
alcohol use disorder with Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test - [Piccinelli]
Consumption (AUDIT-PC) at admission
AUDIT-PC consists of 5 Likert items (score range 0-19) from alcohol use disorders identification test (AUDIT) to screen for
hazardous alcohol use in outpatient primary care
increasing AUDIT-PC score at admission associated with incident AWS (odds ratio 1.68, 95% CI 1.55-1.82 per point increase)
for distinguishing patients with incident AWS from control, AUDIT-PC
with cutoff score ≥ 3 had sensitivity 93.3% and specificity 84.3%
with cutoff score ≥ 4 had sensitivity 91% and specificity 89.7%
with cutoff score ≥ 5 had sensitivity 83% and specificity 94.9%
Reference - J Gen Intern Med 2014 Jan;29(1):34 full-text, editorial can be found in J Gen Intern Med 2014 Jan;29(1):7
AUDIT screen identifies hospital patients who develop clinically significant alcohol withdrawal symptoms (level 2 [mid-level]
evidence)
based on prospective cohort study
874 patients admitted to acute medical ward screened with AUDIT
98 (11%) screened positive for alcohol use disorder
17 (2%) had clinically significant alcohol withdrawal symptoms
AUDIT score ≥ 8 had 100% sensitivity, 90.5% specificity, 17.3% positive predictive value, and 100% negative predictive value
AUDIT score ≥ 8 PLUS at least 2 abnormal blood tests (out of gamma-glutamyltransferase [GGT], aspartate aminotransferase
[AST], alanine aminotransferase [ALT], and mean corpuscular volume [MCV]) had 94% sensitivity, 97.3% specificity, 47% positive
predictive value, and 99.9% negative predictive value
Reference - Alcohol Alcohol 2005 Nov-Dec;40(6):515 full-text
British Association for Psychopharmacology (BAP) updated evidence-based guideline on pharmacological management of substance
abuse, harmful use, addiction, and comorbidity can be found in J Psychopharmacol 2012 Jul;26(7):899
European guidelines
S3 Leitlinie Screening, Diagnose und Behandlung alkoholbezogener Störungen finden Sie unter AWMF 2016 PDF [Deutsch]
European Federation of Neurological Societies (EFNS) guideline on alcohol-related seizures can be found at EFNS 2010 Sep PDF
New South Wales (NSW) Ministry of Health guideline on management of patients with acute severe behavioral disturbance in
emergency departments can be found at NSW 2015 Aug 10 PDF
Review articles
literature review of clinical management of alcohol withdrawal can be found in Ind Psychiatry J 2013 Jul;22(2):100 full-text
literature review of treatment of severe alcohol withdrawal can be found in Ann Pharmacother 2016 May;50(5):389
Applied Evidence review can be found in J Fam Pract 2004 Jul;53(7):545, commentary regarding baclofen can be found in J Fam Pract
2005 Jan;54(1):24
review of recognition and management of delirium tremens can be found in N Engl J Med 2014 Nov 27;371(22):2109
review of pharmacological strategies for detoxification from substances including alcohol can be found in Br J Clin Pharmacol 2014
Feb;77(2):302 full-text
review of alpha2-adrenorecepter agonists in treatment of withdrawal syndromes can be found in J Med Toxicol 2014
Dec;10(4):369 full-text
review of management of drug and alcohol withdrawal can be found in N Engl J Med 2003 May 1;348(18):1786, commentary can be
found in N Engl J Med 2003 Jul 24;349(4):405
review of ambulatory detoxification of patients with alcohol dependence can be found in Am Fam Physician 2005 Feb 1;71(3):495
review of alcohol abuse in the critically ill patient can be found in Lancet 2006 Dec 23;368(9554):2231
review of common problems in patients recovering from chemical dependency can be found in Am Fam Physician 2003 Nov
15;68(10):1971
case report of patient with delirium tremens receiving emergency exploratory laparotomy for perforated viscus can be found in Indian
J Anaesth 2012 Mar;56(2):189 full-text
MEDLINE search
to search MEDLINE for (Alcohol withdrawal syndrome) with targeted search (Clinical Queries), click therapy, diagnosis, or prognosis
Patient Information
handout from American Academy of Family Physicians or in Spanish
handout from Harm Reduction for Alcohol
handout on alcohol detoxification from Patient UK PDF
ICD-9/ICD-10 Codes
ICD-9 codes
291 alcoholic psychoses
291.0 alcohol withdrawal delirium
291.1 alcohol amnestic syndrome
291.2 other alcoholic dementia
291.3 alcohol withdrawal hallucinosis
291.8 other specified alcoholic psychosis
291.81 alcohol withdrawal
291.82 alcohol induced sleep disorders
291.89 other alcoholic psychosis
291.9 unspecified alcoholic psychosis
ICD-10 codes
F10 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol
F10.0 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with acute intoxication
F10.1 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with harmful use
F10.2 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with dependence syndrome
F10.3 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with withdrawal state
F10.4 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with withdrawal state delirium
... / Medications / Thiamine and other supplementation
F10.5 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with psychotic disorder
F10.6 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with amnesic disorder
F10.7 mental and behavioural disorders due to use of alcohol with residual and late-onset psychotic disorder
References
General references used
1. Stewart S, Swain S; National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE), Royal College of Physicians, London. Assessment
and management of alcohol dependence and withdrawal in the acute hospital: concise guidance. Clin Med. 2012 Jun;12(3):266-71
2. Sachdeva A, Choudhary M, Chandra M. Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome: Benzodiazepines and Beyond. J Clin Diagn Res. 2015
Sep;9(9):VE01-VE07 full-text
3. Muncie HL Jr, Yasinian Y, Oge' L. Outpatient management of alcohol withdrawal syndrome. Am Fam Physician. 2013 Nov
1;88(9):589-95 full-text
4. Perry EC. Inpatient management of acute alcohol withdrawal syndrome. CNS Drugs. 2014 May;28(5):401-10
5. Gortney JS, Raub JN, Patel P, Kokoska L, Hannawa M, Argyris A. Alcohol withdrawal syndrome in medical patients. Cleve Clin J Med.
2016 Jan;83(1):67-79 full-text
6. Mayo-Smith MF, Beecher LH, Fischer TL, et al; Working Group on the Management of Alcohol Withdrawal Delirium, Practice
Guidelines Committee, American Society of Addiction Medicine. Management of alcohol withdrawal delirium. An evidence-based
practice guideline. Arch Intern Med. 2004 Jul 12;164(13):1405-12
levels of evidence
Level I – randomized trials with low false-positive and low false-negative errors
Level II – randomized trials with high false-positive and high false-negative errors
Level III – nonrandomized, concurrent cohort comparisons
Level IV – nonrandomized, historical cohort comparisons
Level V – case series without controls
Reference - ASAM guideline on management of alcohol withdrawal delirium (Arch Intern Med 2004 Jul 12;164(13):1405 full-text)
Special acknowledgements
Daniel A. Ostrovsky, MD (Assistant Professor of Medicine and Pediatrics, Duke University School of Medicine; North Carolina, United
States)
Dr. Ostrovsky has declared that he has no financial conflicts of interest.
Daniel C. Vinson, MD, MSPH (Professor of Family and Community Medicine, University of Missouri; Missouri, United States)
Esther Jolanda van Zuuren, MD (Head of Allergy, Dermatology, and Venereology, Leiden University Medical Centre; Netherlands; Editor,
Cochrane Skin Group)
Brian C. Weiner, MD, MS, FACP, AGAF (Deputy Editor of Gastroenterology; Medical Director, Manalapan Surgery Center; New Jersey,
United States)
Dr. Weiner declares relevant financial relationships with Marlboro Medical Devices, LLC and Forest Labs (Consultant).
The American College of Physicians (Marjorie Lazoff, MD, FACP; ACP Deputy Editor, Clinical Decision
... / Medications / Thiamine
Resource) provided and
review in other supplementation
a collaborative effort to ensure DynaMed provides the most valid and
clinically relevant information in internal medicine.
DynaMed Plus topics are written and edited through the collaborative efforts of the above individuals. Deputy Editors, Section Editors,
and Topic Editors are active in clinical or academic medical practice. Recommendations Editors are actively involved in development
and/or evaluation of guidelines.
Topic Editors define the scope and focus of each topic by formulating a set of clinical questions and
suggesting important guidelines, clinical trials, and other data to be addressed within each topic. Topic
Editors also serve as consultants for the internal DynaMed Plus Editorial Team during the writing and
editing process, and review the final topic drafts prior to publication.
Section Editors have similar responsibilities to Topic Editors but have a broader role that includes the
review of multiple topics, oversight of Topic Editors, and systematic surveillance of the medical literature.
Recommendations Editors provide explicit review of DynaMed Plus Overview and Recommendations
sections to ensure that all recommendations are sound, supported, and evidence-based. This process is
described in "Synthesized Recommendation Grading."
Deputy Editors are employees of DynaMed and oversee DynaMed Plus internal publishing groups. Each is
responsible for all content published within that group, including supervising topic development at all
stages of the writing and editing process, final review of all topics prior to publication, and direction of an
internal team.
How to cite
National Library of Medicine, or "Vancouver style" (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors):
DynaMed Plus [Internet]. Ipswich (MA): EBSCO Information Services. 1995 - . Record No. 114807, Alcohol withdrawal syndrome;
[updated 2016 Apr 29, cited place cited date here]; [about 29 screens]. Available from http://www.dynamed.com/login.aspx?
direct=true&site=DynaMed&id=114807. Registration and login required.