BOWMAN GILFILLAN

22 Bree Street, Cape Town

PO Box 248, Cape Town, 8000, South Africa
T +27 21 480 7800 | F +27 21 480 3200
Docex 29 Cape Town
E info-sa@bowmanslaw.com

www.bowmanslaw.com

Our Reference: Johan Kruger / 43/1/2/5/1 Your Reference: KM/Is/D3666

Direct Line: +27 11 669 9537 Date: 20 June 2018
Email Address: Johan.kruger@bowmanslaw.com

Attention: Mr. Manamela

Manamela Marobela & Associates

Bindzu Office Park
130 Gordon Road
Colbyn
Pretoria
Email: khashaneM@manamelainc.co.za

PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

Dear Mr. Manamela,

RE: INVESTIGATION INTO 20 SELECTED CONTRACTS ABOVE R10MILLION AWARDED BY PRASA FROM 2012 TO
DATE - DAVID SEKGOBELA AND ASSOCIATES (PTY) LTD

Your correspondence dated 17 May and 7 June 2018 respectively, refers.

1. We confirm that we were appointed by National Treasury to conduct an investigation into 20

Contracts above R10million awarded by PRASA between 2012 to date.

2. All investigations were concluded and our findings were reported to National Treasury during January
2017.

3. We can find no reason to amend our findings, which were based on information made available to
us at the time of investigation.

4. In respect of your request for a response to various queries as detailed in your correspondence dated
17 May and again on 7 June 2018, we refer you to our duty not to disclose privileged and confidential
information of our client. We therefore request that you raise your queries with Mr. Vukani Nbaba of
National Treasury.

Bowman Gilfillan Inc. Reg. No. 1998/021409/21 Attorneys Notaries Conveyancers

Directors RA Legh (Chairman) | PM Maduna (Deputy Chairman) | AJ Keep (Managing Partner) | AG Anderson | DP Anderson | LJ Anderson | JS Andropoulos | M Angumuthoo | A Arumugam | L Avivi |
AM Barnes-Webb | TL Beira | JM Bellew | F Bhayat | CM Bouwer | IL Brink | REW Burman | LD Campbell | RM Carr | PM Carter | LA Chater | RA Cohen | CN Cunningham | GH Damant | RA Davey | MEC Davids |
D de Klerk | ID Dhladhla | TC Dini | CR Douglas | HD Duffey | CR Dunstan-Smith| L Dyer | S Ellary | L Fleiser | KA Fulton | BJ Garven | TM Gcabashe | DJ Geral | LHM Gerstle | D Gewer | TJ Gordon-Grant | CB Green |
S Grimwood-Norley | A Hale| W Hamer | AS Harris| P Hart-Davies | PA Hirsch | JR Janks | JR Kaapu | CP Kennedy | KM Kern | ID Kirkman | JG Kruger | JP Kruger | R Labuschagne | T Laubscher | DA Lotter | J Lurie |
KS Makapane| HW Mandlana | A McAllister | TP McDougall | M McGillewie| JM McKinnell| MC Mkiva| PI Modika | TL Mongae| L Mongie| SP Naicker | UEBU Naumann | CZ Nduli | HB Ngcobo | TH Nichols | X Nyali |
MAJ Oppenheim| AJPike | P Pillay| JDPrain| MA Purchase| Y Ram| LV Raphulu| CL Reidy| JB Ripley-Evans| MS Rusa | GI Rushton| S Saffy| JWSahli | MY Sass| CGSchafer | DE Serchuk| RZShein | CEC Smith|
EC Steyn | PW Stelling | BGM Strydom | M Strydom | V Subban | H Taylor | CFN Todd | CE Tucker | CL van Heerden | A van Niekerk | MR van Velden | RJ van Voore | NC van Zuylen | MG Vermaak | L Verster |
DS Webb| DCJ Wessels| RS Wessels| JWL Westgate| PE Whelan| EP Williams| HJ Wilsenach| SG Wilson | SA Wood | KS Wright | DD Yuill |
Of Counsel S Esterhuyse | CS Franklyn | F Laher | CS Truter | KL van de Pol | A Voges | Consultants ARL Bertrand | JWD Brand | G Kekesi | JH Schlosberg | Special Counsel CL Valkin
Group COO RJ Smith | Group CFO J Pöhl | Company Secretary NL van Vuuren

KENYA SOUTH AFRICA TANZANIA UGANDA

 Yours faithfully

p.p.
Bowman Gilfillan
per: Johan Kruger

-2-