Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chess Tragedies
Chess Tragedies
Chess Tragedies
By Bill Wall
Caliph al Walid I (668-715) who was an Umayyad caliph who ruled from 705-715,
was playing chess (shatranj) with one of his courtiers, who was a much stronger
player than the Caliph, but was purposely making bad moves in order for the
Caliph to win. One day, the Caliph observed this and was highly offended. He
seized one of the heaviest chess pieces and hurled it at the courtier’s head saying,
‘May evil befall thee, base sycophant! Art thou in thy senses to play chess with
me in this foolish manner?’ An Arabic manuscript says that the caliph broke his
opponent’s head with a blow with his firzan (equivalent to the modern Queen).
The Arab historian al-Masudi (896-956), writing in his travel diary in 950 A.D.,
described how they played and betted on chess in India. Players would wager
their fingers on a game of chess. If a player lost, he would cut off a finger with his
dagger, then plunge his hand in boiling water with special ointment to cauterize
the wound. Then he returns to the game. Another loss would mean another loss
of another finger. Sometimes a player who continued to lose would cut off
all his fingers, his hand, his fore-arm, his elbow, and other parts of his body. After
each amputation, he could cauterize the wound and return to another game of
chess.
Canute (995-1035), king of England, Denmark, Norway, and part of Sweden, was
said to have killed an earl over chess. The story is found in The Chronicles of the
Kings of Norway called the Saga of Olaf Haraldson. In 1028, the king was playing
a game of chess with his brother-in-law, Earl Godwin Ulfnadson , the husband of
the king’s sister, when the king made a bad move, which led to a loss of one of
the king’s pieces. The king took his move back, replaced his knight, and told the
earl to play a different move. The earl got angry over this, overturned the chess
board and started walking away. The king said “Runnest thou away, Ulf the
coward?” The earl responded, “Thou wouldst have run farther at Helga river if
thou hadst come to battle there. Thou didst not call me Ulf the coward when I
hastened to thy help while the Swedes were beating thee like a dog.” The earl
then left the king’s quarters. The next day, the king ordered the earl to be
killed. The earl was stabbed to death at Saint Lucius’ church. In 1035, Canute
died at the Abbey in Shaftesbury, Dorset. According to Henry Bird in Chess
History and Reminiscences, the king was killed while watching a chess
game. Armed soldiers rushed into the building and slew Canute while his
friend, Valdemar, who was playing chess, was severely
wounded. Valdemar escaped using the chess board as a shield.
Around 1120, King Henry I (1068-1135) of England and King Louis VI (1081-1137)
of France got into a fistfight over a game of chess in Paris. One story says that
Louis threw the chessboard at Henry; another says that Henry hit Louis over the
head with the chessboard. Courtiers stepped in to stop the fight. This episode
supposedly was the start of events that kept England and France at war for almost
12 years.
Around 1213, Joan (1194-1244), Countess of Flanders and the daughter of
Baldwin IX (1172-1205), count of Flanders and first emperor of the Latin Empire of
Constantinople, beat her husband, Ferdinand (1188-1233), prince of Portugal, in a
game of chess. He got so mad that he hit her. In revenge, she left her husband in
French captivity from 1214 to 1226, refusing to ransom him.
In 1251, the first known court case involving chess and violence appeared. It
dealt with a chess player who stabbed his opponent to death. A quarrel arose
between two players of Essex over a chess match. One of the players who lost
was so angered that he stabbed his opponent in the stomach with a knife, from
which he died.
In 1264, another court case was opened when a man stabbed a woman to death
with his sword after a quarrel over a chess game.
In 1495 the Inquisition saw victims of persecutions stand in as figures in a game of
living chess. The game was played by two blind players. Each time the captured
piece was taken, the person representing that piece was put to death.
Atahualpa (1497-1533) was the last sovereign emperor of the Inca Empire. In
1532, the Spaniards sacked the Inca army camp and imprisoned Atahualpa. While
in prison, he was taught chess by the Spaniards and became very good at
it. Atahualpa advised Hernando de Soto in one game of chess that helped defeat
one of the Spanish friars named Riquelme. Popular tradition in Peru says that
Atahualpa would not have been condemned to death if he remained untutored in
chess. Atahualpa was sentenced to death by 13 votes for and 11 against. It
was Riquelme’s vote that broke the tie that called for the death sentence. The
Peruvian people say that Atahualpa paid with his life for the checkmate
that Riquelme suffered because of his advice.
In 1598, Paolo Boi (1528-1598), one of the leading chess players of the 16th
century died in Naples. Historian H.J.R. Murray says he was poisoned in by jealous
rivals. Other sources say he caught a cold when hunting and died as a result of it.
The Puritans were against chess and discouraged chess play. It was considered a
sin to play chess. (source: Victorian Web)
In 1622, Gioacchino Greco was robbed of all his money (5,000 crowns) that he
won in Paris from playing chess while on his way to London.
This could have been a Shakespeare tragedy. On August 30, 1624, playwright
Thomas Middleton (1580-1627) was arrested in London after producing a play, A
Game at Chess, that satirized the proposed marriage of Prince Charles with a
Spanish princess. The play was performed in the Globe Theater in London. Its
nine performances, from August 5-14, 1624, was the greatest box-office hit and
the most talked about dramatic work of early modern London. After Middleton’s
arrest, the play was censored and was not allowed to be shown again. Further
performance of the play was forbidden and Middleton and the actors were
reprimanded and fined. Middleton never wrote another play.
In 1649, Tsar Alexei (1629-1676) banned chess in Russia. Players caught playing
chess were whipped and put in prison.
Alexandre Deschapelles (1780-1847) was arrested for being involved in the French
insurrection of June 1832. He was released a month later after writing to the king
that he was too old, too infirmed, and innocent. Earlier, when he was a soldier,
he was very seriously wounded on the battlefield against the Austrians and was
left for dead. He was covered with so many wounds, he was not recognizable.
Louis-Charles Mahe de La Bourdonnais (1795-1840), strongest player of the
19th century, died of a stroke. He died penniless in London, having been forced to
sell all his possessions to satisfy creditors. He was only 44 or 45.
In 1848, the suppression of the Hungarian Revolution banned chess clubs in
Hungary until 1864. As a chess player, Johann Loewenthal was forced to leave
Hungary.
On May 18, 1853, Lionel Kieseritzky (1806-1853), died penniless at a charity
hospital (La Charite) for the insane in Paris. A hat was passed around to collect
money for his funeral but nothing was raised. As a result, he was buried in a
pauper’s grave. Only one person came to his funeral, a waiter at the Café de
la Régence. The location of his exact plot has not been found.
William Henry Russ (1833-1866) one of America’s leading compiler of chess
problems, died in a hospital after trying to commit suicide. He adopted an 11-year
old girl and proposed to her when she was 21. When he rejected him, he shot her
four times in the head. He left her for dead (she survived), then tried to commit
suicide by jumping into the river to drown himself. However, the tide was out and
the water was not deep enough. He climbed out of the river and shot himself in
the head. He died 10 days later in a hospital, lacking a will to live. He was only 33.
In 1875, Albert William Ensor (1843-1883) was arrested for counterfeiting in New
York. In 1873, he was the first Canadian Chess Champion. He was later arrested
in Germany for gambling and in France for forgery.
In 1879, Carl Goering (1841-1879), a German professor, philosopher, and chess
master, committed suicide in Eisenach, Germany. He got sick with rheumatism in
1872 and was suffering from depression.
Tragedy struck Johannes Zukertort (1842-1888) when he was playing in a chess
tournament at Simpson’s, a London coffee-house. He fell unconscious while
playing his game against Sylvain Meyer. Instead of calling for medical help, he
was carried to another site, the British Chess Club, a few blocks away. He was
then taken to Charing Cross hospital where they diagnosed the problem as a
cerebral attack (stroke). He never gained consciousness and died the next
day. At the time, Zukertort was in 1st place of the tournament.
On January 23, 1890 the New Orleans Chess, Checkers, and Whist Club was
destroyed by fire. The valuable library of the chess club and all the Morphy
memorabilia were all destroyed.
In 1890, Walter Grimshaw (1832-1890), a famous chess problemist, committed
suicide just after Christmas by cutting his throat with a razor. He became
despondent and his mind became “unhinged.”
On April 14, 1891, George Mackenzie (1837-1891) was found dead at a hotel in
New York. A hotel worker called at his room and found him dead in bed. He had
terminal tuberculosis before his death. The day before, he visited the Manhattan
Chess Club and was arranging to challenge the winner of the forthcoming match
between Blackburne and Gunsberg. William Steinitz reported that his death was
from an intentional overdose of morphine. This rumor was started by a doctor
who refused to sign a certificate for an insurance policy because the doctor had
not been paid a fee. During the Civil War, Mackenzie was arrested for desertion.
On May 11, 1894, Austrian-Hungarian chess master Alexander Wittek (1852-1894)
died in a lunatic asylum in Graz. He was diagnosed with a "paralytic mental
disorder" the previous year. One source says that he committed suicide but
another cites tuberculosis.
In 1897, William Wilson, age 55, a prominent member of the Franklin Chess Club
in Philadelphia and bookseller, was robbed and killed in his store.
In 1897, Norman Willem van Lennep (1872-1897), a Dutch chess master, killed
himself by jumping into the North Sea from a ship at the age of 25. His father had
disowned him unless he gave up chess and found a steady job.
On August 12, 1900, former world champion William Steinitz died in the
Manhattan State Hospital on Ward’s Island. For months, he had been confined
there, diagnosed as insane. He was committed by his wife. In 1897, he began to
have the illusion that he could talk on the phone without thread or elauricular and
his secretary often surprised him waiting for a response through the invisible
hearing aid. He also used to approach to the window where he spoke and
singed, remaining after waiting for an answer. The secretary informed about this
to the American consul who suggested that Steinitz should be taken to
a sanatorium. In 1900, he thought he could deliver electric charges, with
the help of which it would be feasible to move the pieces at will. Claimed to be in
electrical communication with God and could give him a pawn ahead and White
pieces.
In November 2011, Quinton Smith, age 17, was competing in the K-12 Nationals in
Dallas. During the tournament, he climbed to the roof of the Hilton Anatole (27
stories) and fell (or jumped) to his death. He laid on the ground for several hours
while being attended by bystanders and police. He had lost his first four games
and was given a bye in the 5th round. (source: USCF)
In 2012, chess master John Charles Yoos of Vancouver, British Columbia, was a
victim of identity theft. A person with the same name and age had been charged
with attempted murder in New York.
On March 2, 2012, Isaac Braswell, age 32, committed suicide a day after playing in
a match in the Chicago Chess League (CICL). He persevered through a lifetime of
mental illness and poverty to be ranked among the top 60 players in Illinois.
(source: Chicago Tribune)
In May, 2012, Shanker Roy, age 36, one of Bengal’s leading chess players,
committed suicide. He hung himself from a ceiling fan using his wife’s long scarf.
He had been suffering from depression.
home