Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TH Role of Sodium Hexametafosfato in The Dissolution Process of Kaolinite and Kaolin. ANDREOLA 2004
TH Role of Sodium Hexametafosfato in The Dissolution Process of Kaolinite and Kaolin. ANDREOLA 2004
www.elsevier.com/locate/jeurceramsoc
Abstract
Suspensions of kaolinite and ceramic grade kaolin in sodium hexametaphosphate solutions at different concentrations were pre-
pared and kept at constant temperature for 4 h: the solutions obtained after centrifugation and filtration were analysed using a ICP
technique to determine the concentration of significant cations. The results allowed to stress the role of NaHMP in the dissolution
process of kaolinite and ceramic grade kaolin. The role of accessory minerals in ceramic grade kaolin dissolution was discussed in
the light of the obtained data.
# 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Chemical properties; Clays; Hexametaphosphate; Surfaces; Suspensions
Huertas et al.9 studied the dissolution phenomena suspension. In fact, even low amount of accessory
that eventually occur in an aqueous suspension of minerals can remarkably modify the chemical and
kaolinite at different pH of the solution; the investi- rheological behaviour of the kaolin with respect to that
gated kaolinite is of very pure grade (95% kaolinite with of kaolinite. The introduction of the deflocculant causes
traces of quartz and anatase) and so the observed surface modifications of the clay minerals and dissolu-
phenomena cannot be transferred directly to the kaolins tion of ions able to interact with the deflocculant itself.
used for industrial purposes. Most of all, when the For this reason the purpose of the whole research is to
sodium hexametaphosphate solution is used instead of determine how the processes of dissolution of the clay in
simple water to prepare a suspension of kaolin, the the presence of sodium hexametaphosphate may influ-
deflocculant equilibria are modified by the presence of ence the deflocculating capability and, overall, the
the clay, which in turn suffers the presence of the rheology of the clay suspension.
sodium hexametaphosphate.
Several papers1012 have been devoted to the interac-
tions between sodium hexametaphosphate and clay: one 2. Experimental
of the mechanisms of action of this deflocculant
involves a chemiadsorption step at the edges of the clay 2.1. Materials
particles. The hexametaphosphate anions interact with
the exposed atoms of aluminium, giving a complexed
anion.10 The chemiadsorption produces a surface excess (a) Well-ordered kaolinite (KGa-1b) from The Clay
of negative charge and therefore the increase of the Minerals Society (The Clay Minerals Society,
repulsion forces between the particles; as a consequence, Source Clays Repository, University of Missouri,
the z potential value of the clay particles increases. This Columbia, MO) was used as reference mineral
mechanism is reaffirmed by Kronberg et al.11 in a study for pure kaolinite (hereafter, KGa-1b).
on the competitive and cooperative adsorption of poly- Some general properties of KGa-1b were mea-
mers and surfactants on the surface of kaolinite. Like sured: density was determined by the liquid
Huertas, Kronberg used high-grade kaolinite and pyknometry method (d=2.647 0.054 g/ml);
deflocculant adsorption was performed with the defloc- Brunauer–Emmitt–Teller (BET) specific surface
culant solution eluting the kaolinite: the measurements area was measured (Micromeritics Gemini 2630)
were made in dynamic conditions, that is, without using nitrogen gas as an adsorbate at liquid
waiting for the system to reach equilibrium. nitrogen temperature; the sample previously had
Choi et al.12 also confirm that the condensed phos- been outgassed at 110 C for 4 h (SBET=11.62
phates are adsorbed to form strong complexes with the m2/g). The particle-size distribution, as ascer-
positive sites on the edges of the kaolinite particles. This tained by laser particle-sizer analyser (Fritsch
adsorption causes a change in the surface charge den- Analyzette 22), had an average particle size
sity, whereby the electrokinetic potential of the kaolinite d50=1.66 mm. The chemical composition by ele-
becomes even more negative. ment oxide weight percentage was measured by
The complexing ability of sodium hexametaphosphate the inducted coupled plasma technique (ICP
toward Ca2+ allows the additive to sequester the floccu- Spectrophotometer, Varian mod. Liberty 200)
lant calcium cations.13 Genichiro Kura and Shigeru (Table 1). The mineralogical composition as
Oashi14 found that hexametaphosphate anion forms with determined by the X-ray powder diffraction
calcium a strong 1:1 complex; they estimated the thermo- technique (Philips PW3710) was proved to be
dynamic stability constant of this complex (K=106.9)
extrapolating to infinite dilution the conditional stability Table 1
constants determined at various ionic strengths. Chemical analysis of KGa-1b and of C.G.K
The aim of the present study is to assess the effects
Component (wt.%) KGa-1b C.G.K.
caused by the addition of sodium hexametaphosphate
to a standard kaolinite suspension and compare the SiO2 44.7 47.1
results with those obtained employing a kaolin used in Al2O3 38.7 36.1
CaO 0.03 0.40
ceramic industry and containing a certain amount of
MgO 0.01 0.27
accessory minerals (impurities). The analysis of the Na2O 0.04 0.59
results gets light on the interaction mechanism of hex- K2O 0.03 1.06
ametaphosphate anion with the clay surface and on the Fe2O3a 0.20 0.75
effect of the deflocculant in kaolinite and kaolin dis- TiO2 1.58 0.24
LOIb 13.87 12.49
solution. Moreover, this comparison enables us to
assess the role played by the accessory minerals of kao- a
Fe total (Fe2O3+FeO) is expressed as Fe2O3.
lin in ion release and reprecipitation phenomena of clay b
LOI=Loss on ignition (1050 C).
F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124 2115
kaolinite with anatase as impurity (CuKa radia- Suspensions of KGa-1b/C.G.K. and deflocculant
tion, 0.02 /s, 5–70 2). The cation exchange solution at different concentrations were kept at a con-
capacity was found to be 2.1 meq/100 g. stant temperature of 30 C in a thermostat; after 4 h
(b) A ceramic-grade kaolin was used in this study (characteristic storage time of an industrial process) a
(hereafter C.G.K.). Some general properties such complete solid–liquid separation was carried out in
as density (d=2.683 0.054 g/ml), Brunauer– order to determine the concentration of some ions (P,
Emmitt–Teller (BET) specific surface area Si, Al, Ca, Mg, K, Na) in the liquid phase. Time-
(SBET=15.01 m2/g), chemical composition by dependent measurements performed on the concen-
element oxide weight percentage (Table 1) and trations of the ions (not reported here)15 have clearly
mineralogical composition were measured with indicated that at least in the range 4–24 h no time
the same instruments and methods used for dependence of the ion concentration, in particular
KGa-1b; the mineralogical composition was HMP, occurs. For this reason all the measurements
found to be mainly kaolinite (91%) with micac- reported in the text have been performed after 4 h of
eous clays (illite), quartz and feldspar as impu- contact between clay and deflocculant solution.
rities. The particle-size distribution (Fritsch The suspensions were prepared in the following
Analyzette 22) covered a broad range (bigger conditions:
than that of kaolinite) with an average particle
size of d50=4.08 mm. The cation exchange capa- 1. Zero NaHMP concentration (plain distilled
city was found to be 3.7 meq/100 g. As kaolin water), which served as a dummy sample for the
employed is not a ‘‘pure’’ material but a mixture following suspensions.
of kaolinite, illite, quartz and feldspar, it is clear 2. NaHMP concentrations in the range 0.005–0.03 M.
that the value of its properties (density, specific
surface area, chemical composition and particle The comparison between the two batches of parallel
size distribution) is forced to be a sort of measurements (performed on KGa-1b and on C.G.K.)
‘‘weighed medium value’’. allows to evaluate the role of clay impurities.
(c) The deflocculant used in this study was sodium A standardized procedure was adopted in order to
hexametaphosphate (hereafter NaHMP) in the ensure the reproducibility of the results:
powder form (Carlo Erba). Chemical analysis:
NaPO3 596%, Cl 40.07%, Pb 40.0025%,
KGa-1b was used as-received.
sulphate 40.24%, As 40.0005%, Fe 40.006%.
C.G.K. underwent a standard treatment to ren-
der it homogeneous: it was delicately crumbled
by hand in a porcelain mortar using a porcelain
2.2. Methods pestle. Each batch of kaolin thus disaggregated
was mixed with the others in order to ensure the
Following the results of some rheological preliminary homogeneous texture of the samples.
tests performed on C.G.K. (i.e. the raw material employed
The required amount of KGa-1b/C.G.K. (93.912
in industrial applications), a clay volumetric fraction of g) was weighed in a beaker; both the suspensions
35% v/v was chosen for both KGa-1b and C.G.K.; in fact, were prepared at 35% v/v.
it allows the kaolin suspensions to have viscosity values
The required amount of the NaHMP powder was
low enough to be measured, yet high enough to fall within weighed in a beaker, then the distilled water
the range of sensitivity of the viscosimeter. needed to prepare the deflocculant solution was
In the paper the deflocculant concentration is given as added (the water volume added was 65.9 ml and
molarity; in any case, due to the remarkable role played 65.0 ml for KGa-1b and C.G.K., respectively).
by the surface area in the adsorption process and in
The KGa-1b/C.G.K. and the deflocculant solu-
order to refer concentration to surface area, the follow- tion were blended and dispersed in a laboratory
ing equation converting deflocculant molarity in weight fast ball mill (300 ml) with 10 alumina grinding
of deflocculant/clay surface area is given: balls (f=1 cm) for 10 min.
Immediately after dispersion, the suspension was
Ws ¼ ð½NaHMP V Mw Þ=ðw SBET Þ transferred to a sealed plastic (PET) vessel and
kept at a temperature of 30 C in an immersion
where: WS is the weight of deflocculant referred to the thermostat (Memmert WB/WB).
clay surface area, [NaHMP] is the NaHMP molar con-
After 4 h the suspension was removed from the
centration, V is the volume of the deflocculant solution thermostat, including the water that condenses
in contact with a mass w of clay, Mw is the molecular on the lid, and rapidly transferred to a multi-
weight of the deflocculant and SBET is the specific speed centrifuge (ALC multi-speed centrifuge PK
surface area of the clay. 121) in a centrifuge batch of 10 ml polycarbonate
2116 F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124
tube. Centrifugation proceeded for 10 min at the centrations in the range 5.4104–1.62102 M show
rate of 14,000 rpm, then the separated liquid phase that the minimum apparent viscosity is obtained for the
was centrifuged again under the same conditions. NaHMP concentration about 2.7103 M (Fig. 1a),
The liquid was filtered by Whatman cellulose corresponding to 0.1 mg/m2.
nitrate membrane, 0.45 mm.
The liquid was subjected to ICP analysis (ICP 3.1.2. C.G.K.
Plasma Varian mod. Liberty 200). Rheological measurements performed on C.G.K.
The ICP measurements were performed twice suspensions prepared with different NaHMP con-
under the same conditions; the findings refer to centrations in the range 7.1103–3.19102 M present
the average of the two series of measurements, a very different behaviour from KGa-1b suspensions: in
which in any event differ by less than 5%. fact, the minimum apparent viscosity is obtained for the
NaHMP concentration about 2.12102 M (Fig. 1b),
Calculations have been performed in order to check if corresponding to 0.6 mg/m2. It is rather surprising that,
the release of cations (Ca, Mg, K) observed in the solutions while the difference between the specific surface area of
are to be attributed only to cation exchange phenomena or KGa-1b and C.G.K. is not so remarkable, C.G.K. sus-
also to contemporaneous clay degradation processes. pensions need very higher dispersant levels (8 in
In fact, if only cation exchange phenomena are pre- molarity) than KGa-1b to reach the minimum apparent
sent, the number of the equivalents of Na+ from viscosity. It is worth to note that the mineralogical
NaHMP and disappeared from solution after contact composition of the clays dramatically influences the
with the clay must be equal to the sum of the equiva-
lents of Ca2+, Mg2+ and K+ ions (i.e. the exchangeable
cations) plus the equivalents of cation charge neutraliz-
ing the adsorbed anions (HMP in our case).
The number of equivalents of exchanged Na+ was
calculated subtracting those observed in solution after 4
h from the initial ones (i.e. the Na+ equivalents intro-
duced with the deflocculant). The number of equivalents
of Ca2+, Mg2+ and K+ were calculated by the respec-
tive concentration measured after 4 h, being known the
volume of the employed deflocculant solution. The
equivalents of positive charge electro-statically co-
adsorbed with the HMP anion onto clay (neutralizing
charge) can also be calculated: in fact, as the HMP bare
anion, which possesses six negative charges, is adsorbed
onto the clay, it carries a number of equivalents of
positive charge (given by cations in solution) corre-
sponding to the negative charge of the bare anion, i.e.
6 the adsorbed moles of HMP; the equivalent number
of positive charge co-adsorbed with the HMP anion
after 4 h numerically corresponds to the equivalent
number of HMP disappeared from solution.
A batch of rheological measurements were performed
on suspensions of both KGa-1b and C.G.K. at different
NaHMP concentrations prepared as described above
and just after the dispersion. These rheological mea-
surements were performed using a Control Rate Haake
viscosimeter (VT 550) at 30 C.
3. Results
3.1.1. KGa-1b :
Fig. 1. Apparent viscosity log values (mPa s) measured at g ¼ 300 s1
Rheological measurements performed on KGa-1b for KGa-1b (a) and C.G.K. (b) 35% v/v suspensions as a function of
suspensions prepared with different NaHMP con- the initial NaHMP concentration.
F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124 2117
Table 2
Molar concentration of a collection of cations after 4 h of contact of KGa-1b and NaHMP solutions as a function of starting concentration of the
deflocculant (expressed both in mg/m2 and molarity and indicated as Ci and [NaHMP]i, respectively) at 30 C and corresponding pH
Ci NaHMP (mg/m2) [NaHMP]i (M) [P] (M) [Si] (M) [Al] (M) [Ca] (M) [Mg] (M) [K] (M) [Na] (M) pH
6 6 6 6 6 6
0 0 / 410 <0.210 210 110 0.310 110 7.26
0.2 0.0054 0.0202 0.0016 0.0016 0.0013 0.0006 0.00002 0.0159 6.03
0.6 0.0162 0.0919 0.0019 0.0062 0.0057 0.0033 0.00005 0.0730 6.06
0.8 0.0223 0.1291 0.0017 0.0061 0.0058 0.0031 0.00005 0.1103 6.08
The mass of the KGa-1b was 93.91 g and the volume of the deflocculant solution 65.9 ml.
dependence of apparent viscosity by deflocculant con- than Si one.Table 3 reports the loss in phosphorus
centration.1,16, 17 concentration after 4 h respect to the amount intro-
duced with the deflocculant for each initial NaHMP
3.2. Adsorption measurements concentration. This 4 h loss in phosphorus concen-
tration can be confidently attributed to adsorption pro-
3.2.1. KGa-1b cesses. The trend of [P] as a function of the introduced
NaHMP concentration shows that increasing the
3.2.1.1. Suspension of KGa-1b in distilled water. The NaHMP concentration the adsorption of NaHMP
KGa-1b suspension prepared in distilled water has an apparently decreases.
initial pH of 7.26; the aluminium concentration is over
one order of magnitude less than silicon and, generally 3.2.2. C.G.K.
speaking, the concentration of all the cations in solu- 3.2.2.1. Suspension of C.G.K. in distilled water. Com-
tion is very low (Table 2). The cation concentration paring the concentrations of the ions present in solution
levels (especially aluminium ones) are of the same (Table 4) with those obtained in the same conditions but
order of instrumental sensibility, but the sound result is employing KGa-1b (Table 2), we can say that these
not their absolute value, but the fact that they are concentrations are at least one order of magnitude
extremely low. higher than those observed in KGa-1b sample. Like
KGa-1b sample in distilled water, the concentration of
3.2.1.2. Suspensions of KGa-1b in NaHMP solutions at Si is higher than that of Al.
different concentrations. Comparing the concentration
of cations observed in KGa-1b suspensions prepared 3.2.2.2. Suspensions of C.G.K. in NaHMP solutions at
with different solutions of NaHMP with that different concentrations. Like KGa-1b, also for C.G.K.
observed in distilled water, one can see immediately the addition of NaHMP produces an increase in the
that the presence of NaHMP produces a relevant concentration of all the cations in solution respect to
increase in the concentration of Si, Al, Ca, Mg and C.G.K. in distilled water (Table 4).
K (Table 2). Moreover, the presence of NaHMP The concentrations of ions in solution are much
produces an inversion in the ratio of the concen- higher than those observed for KGa-1b sample at the
tration of Si and Al respect to distilled water: in fact, different NaHMP concentrations (see Tables 2 and 4)
the Al concentration is higher (or, at least, equal in and much more dependent on the initial NaHMP con-
the case of the NaHMP concentration 0.0054 M) centration.
The main difference between the last set of data
(Table 4) and the others is the remarkably higher
concentrations of Ca, Mg and K ions which con-
Table 3 fidently don’t come from the amount of kaolinite
Phosphorus concentration in KGa-1b suspensions (a) introduced with
present in C.G.K., but from accessory minerals. The
starting NaHMP solutions; (b) measured in solution after 4 h; (c) dif-
ference between (a) and (b) as a function of starting concentration of role of the accessory minerals in the dissolution pro-
the deflocculant at 30 C cess of C.G.K. in the presence of NaHMP is con-
firmed by the ratio of the concentration of Si and Al,
[NaHMP]i (M) (a) [P]i=[Na]i (M) (b) [P] (M) (c) [P] (M)
opposite to that of KGa-1b (see Tables 2 and 4).
0.0054 0.0324 0.0202 0.0122 Analogously to that observed for KGa-1b suspen-
0.0162 0.0973 0.0919 0.0054 sions (Table 3), the trend of [P] as a function of
0.0223 0.1340 0.1291 0.0049 NaHMP concentration (Table 5) shows that at the
The mass of the KGa-1b was 93.91 g and the volume of the defloccu- lowest NaHMP concentration the adsorption process is
lant solution 65.9 ml. the most relevant.
2118 F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124
Table 4
Molar concentration of a collection of cations after 4 h of contact of C.G.K. and NaHMP solutions as a function of starting concentration of the
deflocculant (expressed both in mg/m2 and molarity and indicated as Ci and [NaHMP]i, respectively) at 30 C and corresponding pH
Ci NaHMP (mg/m2) [NaHMP]i (M) [P] (M) [Si] (M) [Al] (M) [Ca] (M) [Mg] (M) [K] (M) [Na] (M) pH
The mass of the C.G.K. was 93.91 g and the volume of the deflocculant solution 65.0 ml.
Table 5
Phosphorus and sodium concentration in C.G.K. suspensions: (a) introduced with starting NaHMP solutions; (b), (d) measured in solution after 4 h,
respectively; (c) difference between (a) and (b) columns; (e) difference between (a) and (d) columns as a function of starting concentration of the
deflocculant at 30 C
[NaHMP]i (M) (a) [P]i=[Na]i (M) (b) [P] (M) (c) [P] (M) (d) [Na] (M) (e) [Na] (M)
The mass of the C.G.K. was 93.91 g and the volume of the deflocculant solution 65.0 ml.
Table 6
Number of milliequivalents of the species involved in the cation exchange process in KGa-1b suspensions referred to a mass of 100 g of the clay as a
function of starting concentration of the deflocculant at 30 C. Volume of the deflocculant solution 70.2 mla
[NaHMP]i (M) (a) No. meq. (b) No. meq. (c) No. meq. (d) No. meq. positive charge (e) Sum of meq.
Na+ exchanged Ca2+ released Mg2+ released co-adsorbed with HMP anion (b)+(c)+(d)
silicon and aluminium in solution is difficult to explain cations towards HMP,13 they are always fully com-
with a simple precipitation of a new phase richer in sili- plexed at all the investigated deflocculant concentra-
con; in fact, in the investigated systems, the conditions tions.
requested for the precipitation of quartz and amor- The observed rheological measurements could be
phous silica (pH < 2) are never reached.20 Moreover, the explained taking into account the other mechanism of
precipitation of aluminium–silicates compounds should action of NaHMP: the adsorption on kaolinite.1012 In
give a contemporary decrease in calcium and/or mag- fact, the minimum apparent viscosity is found to be just
nesium and/or sodium concentrations which, as pre- in correspondence of the highest amount of the adsor-
viously demonstrated, depend only on the cation bed NaHMP (in this condition the extent of the octa-
exchange phenomena. hedral planes of aluminium on which NaHMP can
X-ray diffraction spectra of KGa-1b do not show adsorbs is the highest). For high NaHMP concentra-
appreciable differences after treatment with NaHMP tions, instead, its adsorption and resulting deflocculant
solutions, even at the higher concentrations. action is more limited, probably due to the progressive
The obtained data (Table 2) show that the silicon removal of Al octahedral planes on which NaHMP is
concentration doesn’t change appreciably at increasing adsorbed.
NaHMP concentration, while that one of aluminium
increases until a constant value. This behaviour agrees 4.2. C.G.K.
with a progressive solubilization of the aluminium
accessible to the deflocculant solution (i.e. potentially 4.2.1. Suspension of C.G.K. in distilled water
removable). These results can justify the anomalous C.G.K. in distilled water—considering the system
adsorption of the deflocculant observed in correspon- after 4 h of clay-water contact—doesn’t show a
dence of low NaHMP concentrations (Table 3): in fact, remarkable dissolution process (Table 4), even though
as HMP adsorbs only (or anyway preferentially) on the concentrations of the cations in the centrifuged and
aluminium sites,1012 the selective dissolution of octa- filtered solutions are at least one order of magnitude
hedral planes observed at the higher deflocculant con- higher than the KGa-1b corresponding ones, probably
centrations leads to a decrease of the surface disposable due to the presence of the accessory minerals.
for adsorption. In this way, in the presence of low In fact the high concentration of the cations Ca, Mg,
NaHMP concentration, the surface disposable for K and Na shows that the dissolution of the accessory
adsorption is more extended since the aggressive action minerals21 present in the C.G.K. is a remarkable phe-
of the deflocculant towards aluminium sites is weaker; nomenon with respect to that of KGa-1b. Table 4 also
at higher NaHMP concentrations, instead, the removal shows a non stoicheiometric molar ratio between Si and
of the octahedral planes due to Al complexation dimin- Al concentration, already observed for KGa-1b in dis-
ishes the surface able to adsorb the deflocculant. tilled water (Table 2): as above proposed, this result can
The rheological measurements show that the apparent be explained as a reprecipitation phenomena of Al ion
viscosity increases when the NaHMP molar concen- in the form of gibbsite.9
tration increases from 2.7103 to 1.62102 M
(Fig. 1a). This fact apparently contradicts one of the 4.2.2. Suspensions of C.G.K. in NaHMP solutions at
deflocculating mechanisms of NaHMP which consists in different concentrations
the inactivation of flocculant alkaline-earth cations by Also in C.G.K. suspensions NaHMP shows a
complexation: in fact, as the NaHMP concentration remarkable ability to solubilize cations (Table 4) as the
increases, also its complexation power towards calcium, consequence of cation exchange phenomena and che-
magnesium and aluminium cations should become mical aggression processes towards the minerals of the
stronger and then lead to a decrease of the apparent clay. The disappearance of sodium ions and the con-
viscosity. Indeed, due to the high affinity of these comitant appearance of calcium, magnesium and
2120 F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124
potassium ions in solution after 4 h can be only partially in NaOH 1 N. So it is clear that, even though the solu-
attributed to cation exchange processes; in fact, a simple bility of calcium phosphate, magnesium ammonium
cation exchange process should give a total equivalent phosphate, magnesium hydrogen phosphate, aluminium
concentration of Ca, Mg and K released into the solu- phosphate and hydroxyapatite at room temperatures is
tion and a number of equivalents of disappeared sodium very low (KPS=2.071033, KPS=21013,
6 19
cations lower or at least equal to that of CEC (3.7 meq/ KPS=1.710 , KPS=610 and KPS=3.2 1058,
100 g). Looking at the data obtained (Table 7), one can respectively), the precipitation of any phosphate com-
see that starting from the NaHMP concentration of pound can be excluded in our experimental conditions.
0.014 M the sum of the equivalent of calcium, magne- It is worth to note that in the case of C.G.K. the
sium and potassium ions in solution is higher than solubilization processes are considerably wider than in
CEC, and at the NaHMP concentration of 0.028 M also KGa-1b (see Tables 2 and 4). The concentrations of the
the equivalents of sodium disappeared after 4 h is higher cations are much higher and more dependent on the
than CEC. In all the cases, however, the reported data NaHMP concentration than in the cases of kaolinite.
(Table 7) show that the equivalents of disappeared This means that in C.G.K. suspensions chemical degra-
sodium (exchanged and possibly coadsorbed with dation processes are evident and involve especially the
HMP) are much lower than those of calcium magne- accessory minerals21 which represent a not-negligible
sium and potassium released in solution. These results weight percentage (9%) of the clay.
indicate that CEC doesn’t account for all the complex Also the concentrations of silicon and aluminium are
phenomena that take place in solution; the particularly much higher than those observed for KGa-1b in the
high concentration of calcium, magnesium, potassium, same conditions; moreover, it is worth to note that the
aluminium and silicon in solution reveals the presence silicon-aluminium molar ratio is opposite to KGa-1b
of remarkable chemical aggression process toward the case. This observation further supports the hypothesis
accessory minerals due to the NaHMP. that most of the cations comes from degradation pro-
The strong complexing ability exerted by NaHMP cesses acting on the accessory minerals (illite, feldspar,
towards cations present in the accessory minerals of quartz and amorphous) and not on the kaolinite present
C.G.K. accounts for the remarkable chemical aggres- in C.G.K.
sion process which leads to the above mentioned high X-ray diffraction spectra of C.G.K. reveal some
concentration of the cations. For example, it is possible remarkable differences after treatment with NaHMP
to demonstrate that in the presence of NaHMP even solutions (Fig. 2). Most of all the peaks of illite result
high concentrations of Ca ions in solution do not pro- broader and doubled as a consequence of the interac-
voke precipitation of CaCO3 or CaSO4 (the concentra- tion with NaHMP: this fact suggests the presence of
tions of CO2 3 and SO24 anions have not been adsorption processes involving also the interlayer frame
determined here, but they are commonly observed in of this mineral. Even though a random pattern cannot
clay suspensions), due to the high stability constant provide quantitative information for the analysis of the
(K298
st
K
=106.9) of the 1:1 strong outer-sphere complex impurity minerals, the X-ray spectra suggest also a
formed between Ca and HMP;14 in fact, the presence of decrease in illite amount in the clays. No evidence of a
the related complexation equilibrium causes the solubi- new phase appearance is observed.
lity equilibrium of the salt to be shifted towards the The dependence of the concentrations of the various
solution form (see Appendix). cations on that of NaHMP is closely linked to their
The absence of phosphate precipitation is also related nature:
to the fact that the time of investigation (4 h) is not
enough to obtain monophosphate units from NaHMP Si: the release of Si exhibits a peculiar behaviour, in
hydrolysis: it is known from literature4 that NaHMP is fact the concentration of Si in solution shows a
particularly stable in aqueous solution, in fact the ring maximum at the NaHMP concentration of 2.12102
cleavage is characterised by a half living time of 1000 h M (Fig. 3, Table 4).
Table 7
Number of milliequivalents (1) of Na+ disappeared (see text) from solution after 4 h; (2) of Ca2+; (3) of Mg2+; (4) of K+ released in solution after 4
h; (5) sum of columns (2), (3) and (4) in C.G.K. suspensions referred to a mass of 100 g of the clay as a function of starting concentration of the
deflocculant at 30 C. Volume of the deflocculant solution 69.2 ml
[NaHMP]i (M) (1) No. meq Na+ disappeared (2) No. meq Ca++ (3) No. meq Mg++ (4) No. meq K+ (5) Sum of meq (2)+(3)+(4)
Table 8
Number of mols of phosphorus lost from solution after 4 h: (a) absolute values referred to a mass of 100 g of both KGa-1b (1) and C.G.K. (2); (b)
referred to the specific surface area as a function of starting concentration of the deflocculant, expressed in mass of deflocculant/clay surface area
(see Section 2) at 30 C
Ci NaHMP (mg/m2) No. mols P (a1) No. mols P (b1) No. mols P (a2) No. mols P (b2)
Volume of the deflocculant solution 70.2 and 69.2 ml for KGa-1b and C.G.K., respectively.
C.G.K. this condition is not reached even at the Since the difference in composition between kaolin
NaHMP concentration 2.83102 M (Table 4). The and kaolinite is the presence of accessory minerals and
fact that the minimum apparent viscosity for C.G.K. the dissolution process is more pronounced in kaolin
suspensions is obtained with an amount of deflocculant rather than in kaolinite, the higher level of released ions
which is remarkably higher than the amount required (among which Si and Al) in kaolin suspension respect to
for KGa-1b is probably due to the particularly high that one of kaolinite can be confidently attributed to the
calcium and magnesium concentration of C.G.K. solu- presence of accessory minerals and, possibly, amor-
tions: in fact, high levels of Ca and Mg ions, easily phous materials.
complexed by HMP anion, can reduce its deflocculant Research is now in progress to define the relationship
capability and cause an increase in the NaHMP demand that exists between the rheological response of the sys-
to give deflocculation. Moreover, it is worth to note that tem and the above-reported phenomena.
also the structure of the clays can play a remarkable role
in dispersant activity.27
Acknowledgements
Ca2þ
CaCO3 ðsÞ! 2 7.083103 0.00679 2.98104 2.87106
ðaqÞ þ CO3 ðaqÞ ðA1Þ
1.418102 0.0131 1.08103 1.53106
2.127102 0.0189 2.37103 1.00106
Ca2þ þ Na2 ðPO3 Þ4 2
6 ! Na2 CaðPO3 Þ6 ðA2Þ 2.837102 0.025 3.37103 9.34107
KPS ¼ Ca2þ CO2
3 ¼ 1:96108 ðA3Þ Na2 ðPO3 Þ4
6 ¼ Na2 ðPO3 Þ4 2
6 i Na2 CaðPO3 Þ6
2þ
Kst ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2 4 ¼ Na2 ðPO3 Þ4
6 i x
6 = Na2 ðPO3 Þ6 Ca ðA4Þ
¼ 106:9 KPS ¼ x2 = 106:9 Na2 ðPO3 Þ4 ¼ 1:96108
6 i x
Na2 ðPO3 Þ4
6 i ¼ 2:12710
2
If we solve this equation for the four initial NaHMP
concentrations, we find the results reported in Table 9.
Resolution: The concentration of calcium ions present in solution
2þ and found by ICP analysis is the sum of calcium free
CO2
3 ¼ Ca þ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2
6 ðA5Þ ions and calcium complexed ions, but as the concen-
tration of free calcium ions is extremely low ( 1 mM),
as Kst of the complex Na2Ca(PO3)26 is very high we can this sum may be considered equal to the concentration
consider [Ca2+] negligible and write: of calcium complexed ions.
Obviously, the values of calcium concentration
CO2
3 ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ26 ðA6Þ reported in Table 4 are not ‘‘exactly’’ those of Table 9
because of the two equilibria discussed in this example
moreover: are not the only equilibria present in the real solution
(moreover, the results of the problem are referred to the
Na2 ðPO3 Þ4 4
6 i ¼ Na2 ðPO3 Þ6 temperature of 25 C, while experimental data are
referred to 30 C), but the order of magnitude of the
þ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2
6 ðA7Þ result obtained in the problem justifies the experimental
data. This is true once again when we consider the pre-
we can get [Ca2+] from Eq. (A4) cipitation of CaSO4 instead of CaCO3, because CaSO4
2þ 6:9 has a higher KPS.
Ca ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2 4
6 = Na2 ðPO3 Þ6 10 ðA8Þ
References
so Eq. (A3) can be written:
6:9 1. Manfredini, T., Pellacani, G. C., Pozzi, P. and Corradi, A. B.,
KPS ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2 4
6 = Na2 ðPO3 Þ6 10 CO2
3
Monomeric and oligomeric phosphates as deflocculants of con-
centrated aqueous clay suspensions. Appl. Clay Sci., 1990, 5, 193–
201.
¼ 1:96 108 2. Lagalay, G., Principles of flow of kaolin and bentonite disper-
sions. Appl. Clay Sci., 1989, 4, 105–123.
and for the Eq. (A6) 3. Corbridge, D. E. C., Condensed phosphates. In Studies in Inorganic
Chemistry 2, Phosphorus. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1980, pp. 134–135.
2 6:9 4. Thilo, E., The structural chemistry of condensed inorganic phos-
KPS ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2
6 = Na2 ðPO3 Þ4
6 10 phate. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed, 4 (12), 1965, 1061–1071.
5. Indelli, A., Reazione fra trimetafosfato di sodio e sali alcalino-
¼ 1:96 108 terrosi in ambiente alcalino (Reaction between sodium trimeta-
phosphate and alkaline-earth salts in alkaline environment). Ann.
We state: Chimica, 1956, 46, 717–730.
6. Wieker, W., ‘‘Darstellung und Eigenschaften von 32P-markierten
Penta-, Hexa-, Hepta- und Oktaphosphaten’’ (Presentation and
x ¼ Na2 CaðPO3 Þ2
6 characterization of 32P labelled Penta-, Hexa-, Hepta- and Octa-
phosphates). Z. Elektrochem., Ber. Bunsenges. Physik. Chem.,
and therefore: 1960, 64, 1047–1050.
2124 F. Andreola et al. / Journal of the European Ceramic Society 24 (2004) 2113–2124
7. (a) Crowther, J. P. and Westman, A. E. R., The hydrolysis of the 17. Blasco Fuentes, A., Feliu Mingarru, C., Monzò Fuster, M. and
condensed phosphates I. Sodium pyrophosphate and sodium tri- Enrique Navarro, J. E., Measure to save spray dryer energy in
phosphate. Can. J. Chem., 1954, 32, 42–48; (b) Crowther, J. P. wall and floor tile plants. Interbrick, 1986, 2, 30–33.
and Westman, A. E. R., The hydrolysis of the condensed phos- 18. Diz, H. M. M. and Rand, B., The variable nature of the iso-
phates III. Sodium tetrametaphosphate and sodium tetrapho- electric point of the edge surface of kaolinite’’. Br. Ceram. Trans.
sphate. Can. J. Chem., 1956, 34, 969–981. J., 1989, 88, 162–166.
8. Dombrowsky, T., The origins of kaolinite—implication for utli- 19. Yuan, J., Garforth, W. L. and Pruett, R., Influence of dispersants
zation. In Science of Whiteware, ed. W. Carty. NY, 2000, pp. 3–12. on the solubility of calcined kaolin’’. Appl. Clay Sci., 1998, 13,
9. Huertas, F. J., Chou, L. and Wollast, R., Mechanism of kaolinite 137–149.
dissolution at room temperature and pressure. Part II: kinetic 20. Rochow, E. G., Silicon. In Comprehensive inorganic chemistry, Vol.
study. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 1999, 63(19/20), 3261–3275. 1, ed. J. C. Bailar, H. J. Emeleus, Sir R. Nyholm and A. F. Trotman-
10. Van Olphen, H., Peptization of clay suspensions. In An Intro- Dickenson. Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1973, pp. 1413.
duction to Clay Colloid Chemistry. Interscience, New York, 1963, 21. Knauss, K. G. and Wolery, T., Muscovite dissolution kinetics as
pp. 112–113. function of pH and times at 70 C. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta,
11. Kronberg, B., Kuortti, J. and Stenius, P., Competitive and 1989, 53, 1493–1501.
cooperative adsorption of polymers and surfactants on kaolinite 22. Drever, J. I., The Chemistry of the Naturals Water, 2nd ed.
surface. Colloids and Surfaces, 1986, 18, 411–425. Prentice Hall, 1988.
12. Choi, J. K., Wen, W. W. and Smith, R. W., Tecnical note: the 23. Ward, N. E. and Bassett, R. L., Adsorption of hexavalent chro-
effect of a long chain phosphate on the adsorption of collectors mium on kaolinite and illite. Trace Substances in Environmental
on kaolinite. Minerals Engineering, 1993, 6, 1191–1197. Health, Volume Date 1990, 1991, 24, 193–206.
13. Smith, R. M. and Martell, A. E., Group V Ligands. In Critical 24. Dumat, C., Reduced adsorption of caesium on clay minerals
Stability Constants: Inorganic Complexes. Plenum Press, New caused by various humic substances. Journal of Environmental
York, 1976, Vol. 4, p. 70. Radioactivity, 1999, 46(2), 187–200.
14. Kura, G. and Ohashi, S., Complex formation of cyclic phosphate 25. de Haan, F. A. M., Interaction of certain inorganic anions
anions with bivalent cations. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem., 1974, 36, with clays and soils. Verslag. Landbouwk. Onderzoek, 1965,
1605–1609. 655, 167.
15. Andreola, F., Castellini, E. and Romagnoli, M., Adsorption of 26. Data Summaries Clay Minerals Society. In Data Handbook for
sodium hexametaphosphate on kaolinite and kaolin: thermo- Clay Materials and Other non-Metallic Minerals, ed. H. Van
dynamic and kinetic aspects. Clays and Clay Minerals (submitted Olphen and J. J. Fripiat. Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1979, pp. 47.
for publication). 27. Pozzi, P., Comportamento reologico delle materie prime
16. Parfitt, R. L., Anion adsorption by soils and soil materials. Adv. ceramiche. In La reologia dei materiali ceramici tradizionali, ed.
Agron, 1978, 30, 11–50. P. Pozzi e C. Galassi. Faenza, 1994, pp. 93–120.