Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CoolingTower (ECP 09) AFCESA M&V Workbook
CoolingTower (ECP 09) AFCESA M&V Workbook
Totals
surement Criteria, Data Measurements, and Cost Results
The acceptance M&V check for ECP-09 - Cooling Towers was performed on 4/22/03. The
"CT Data" worksheet lists thefans and pumps that were inspected and verified during
acceptance in columns marked "Post-ECP Acceptance."
All items in the "Accept_Checklist" were completed and six deficiencies were found. All
deficiencies have been corrected.
Measurements taken during acceptance were recorded in the appropriate acceptance columns
and the cost of the verifications and measurements was recorded in "MeasSpecs" of this
spreadsheet, "ECP_09_CLGTWR.xls".
The Acceptance Report will be contain all tabs (worksheets) in this workbook, updated with
current measurements and data.
The following table lists the individuals that performed the acceptance tests:
Documents Yes
Inspect design docs for complete set x
Inspect docs for design conditions documentation x
Complete all required sections of "ECP09_CLGTWR.xls" x
All equipment / users manuals in place x
All operations and maintenance requirements documented and accepted x
Vendor Certifications / Tests
Certificate for construction performed to local / OSHA codes and requirements x
Perform structural analysis for new cooling tower mounting
Vendor tests (include results) x
Overall condition
Specified equipment is installed per manufacturers specifications x
Verify inverter rated motors installed if inverters used. x
Adequate air flow to motors x
Proper paint priming and exterior coatings x
Access to maintenance and inspection areas at local / OSHA requirements x
Verify hearing protection accessible if required by codes x
Color coding and proper labeling on equipment (if required by USAF) x
Performance
Verify performance tests specification / all parameters specified complete x
Measure Power of each motor at full speed. x
Perform load calculations, deliver to USAF. x
Specify all parameters and equipment used in testing - Record in Excel Spreadsheet x
Controls
Verify starter sequence is correct (w/ mfrs requirements) - Record information x
Verify all safety controls operate correctly - Record information x
Verify blowdown controls operate correctly - Record information x
Verify fan / pump motor sequences operate correctly - Record information x
Verify water treatment controls operate correctly - Record information x
The annual reconciliation for the ECP-09 - Cooling Tower requires that all fans, pumps and fill
materials be inspected for deterioration on an annual basis. Inspection will occur at the end of
each year to ensure that all systems are functioning as guaranteed. The annual verification and
reconciliation calculations can found in the "ECP09_CLGTWR.xls" worksheet. After the
inspection was conducted, all deficiencies were corrected.
A summary of the predicted savings along with the savings guarantee is listed in the table
below. As a result of meeting the guaranteed savings, full payment with no deductions will be
made.
The Annual Report contains all tabs (worksheets) in this workbook ("ECP09_CLGTWR.xls"),
updated with current measurements and data.
Savings Summary
Predicted Savings $ -
Guaranteed Savings $ -
Measured Savings $ -
Amount Over Guarantee $ -
Payment Deductions $ -
Other Contract
Specified
Deliverables
Required after
Year 1 thru 21
Cooling Tower Data Column Definitions
Column Symbol Definition / Equations
Bld ID
Rm Name / #
Loc
Op Hours
Demand (kW)
Date
By
umn Definitions
Definition / Equations
Building identification name or number.
Room name or number where the controlled equipment is located.
Location of the equipment in the room.
Annual measured operating hours.
Measured power of the equipment includes fan and pump power.
The date that the observation(s) was made.
The initials or name of the individual performing the inspection.