Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Karl Marxs The WPS Office
Karl Marxs The WPS Office
Karl Marxs The WPS Office
“Man will come into full possession of his humanity and will
Sources of Marx’s Thought:
dispense with his illusion of God. Religion is a product of man’s
For almost all the major aspects of his philosophy in general immaturity”.
and political ideas in particular Marx is indebted to his predecessors
and his thought on religion is not an exception. His indebtedness to
Feuerbach and Hegel may be mentioned. Feuerbach took this idea of religion from Hegel. There are of
course differences between them. Hegel has used the word Spirit
At an early age Marx read Feuerbach’s Essence of Christianity
whereas Feuerbach speaks of man. Feuerbach’s reality has become
which created a strong impact upon his mind. Feuerbach has stated
Spirit to Hegel.
that the ignorance of man fails to explain the natural and other
phenomena and this leads him to take the help of religion. Earlier thinkers treated religion as a social phenomenon and
this impressed Marx considerably. We observed that religious beliefs
In other words man endeavors all the “unexplained”
and ceremonies were practiced by- men with a great fanfare and this
phenomena to treat as supernatural or religious and for this reason
practice provided social unity.
Feuerbach calls religion a fantasy which compensates his own
inadequacy. People of all sections of society worked, lived and behaved in
a disciplined wav with the help of religious beliefs. Religion also
strengthened social unity and obligation of man to society. Religion these early socialists none had a greater influence on Marx
was thus a great cementing force. For this reason religion was a social than Saint-Simon.
phenomenon and Marx noticed it with great interest.
Marx also took notice of the fact that religion gave man The capitalist class took active interest in the discipline and
comfort and to some extent security. It also removed man’s sense of order of society because without this its exploitation could not
fear. This is because man’s rationality did not develop properly due become a reality. Marx noticed that in the Middle Ages the church
to the inadequate development of education and science. Saint- and priests used religion for the purpose of utilizing common people
Simon for that reason argued for their progress which would be able for their benefit.
to remove the sense of fear and insecurity from the mind of man. The Renaissance and Refor-mation brought about a change
We can, therefore, say that Marx’s idea of religion is linked in the attitude of man towards religion. But these two failed to make
with Saint-Simon’s thought on the same subject. Pointing out Marx’s the change radical. The capitalist class followed the path adopted by
the church.
indebtedness to Saint-Simon, Plamenatz makes the following remark:
The development of science will make minds of men It has also been argued that the progress of science
scientific and rational with which they will be able to disprove the transforms the whole society which brings about a radical change in
unscientific and absurd ideas of religion. society. The existence of religion and progress of society due to the
development of science will lead to the coexistence between the two
Spread of scientific spirit will also cause the disappearance of
impossible.
religious faith and practices. This is due to the fact that the
development of science and scientific spirit will inculcate a feeling in Thus the disappearance of religion or the decline of its
the mind of man to be indifferent to theology. Thus religion will not importance due to the progress of science is not a concept
be forced to disappear, it will, like the withering away of state, wither characterized by oversimplification. Piecemeal progress of science
away. cannot help a radical transfor-mation of society.
Marx and Engels have stressed that because of the It is necessary that science will lead the evolution to a stage
development of science man will be able to realize his potentialities where men will not feel the necessity of religion. This is a more
which will help the rise and strengthening of self-confidence. This will plausible argument. In primitive tribal societies people depended
be a sufficient factor for undermining the importance of religion in upon science not only for comfort but for various other necessities.
society.
When science will meet all the requirements of society man
will no longer resort to religious practices and adhere to religious
beliefs and faiths. If the society reaches that stage the need for Plamenatz says:
religion will decline. “Theological religion, the type presented to us by Feuerbach
The impact of the progress of science and scientific and Marx as the religion of alienated man, is the religion of the
sophisticated. It has been most fully accepted by the educated and
knowledge upon religion has another aspect. A very important
property of scientific development and the emergence of scientific the privileged”.
spirit is it involves man in multifarious activities. This phenomenon
removes the idleness of mind and body.
This indicates that religion has a universal appeal. The
Man finds no time to contemplate about religion. He will alienated worker may be attracted to religion, but the alienated man
concern himself with finding out avenues for accelerating material who is not a worker may also be attracted to religion. Explaining
progress. This is evident when we look at the society that emerged Marx’s position critics say that whenever a man suffers from
after the medieval period. frustration or fails to solve the mysteries of nature he resorts to
religious practices.
He is above all an atheist. It means that a socialist is Party will propagate that members must cultivate atheism.
indifferent to religion. Even if he professes any religious faith he Once a man becomes a victim of religion he will not be able to come
cannot be expected to be dogmatic. Orthodox attitude to religion is out of it. If people are not atheist, establishment of socialism will be
not expected from a socialist. a very difficult task.
In socialism there shall be complete separation between Lenin concludes the essay with the following remark:
state and church. If there is no such separation, Lenin says, “The revolutionary proletariat will succeed in making religion
proletarians will demand the separation. This is because in the name a really private affair, so far as the state is concerned. And in this
of religion some persons exploit the working Class and in a socialist political system, cleansed of medieval mildew, the proletariat will
state there is no place of exploitation. wage a broad and open struggle for the elimination of economic
slavery, the true source of the religious humbugging of mankind.”
Few more words may be said in support of Marx. While Marx
was writing about religion the position and influence of religion of
Criticism of Marx’s Theory of Religion: middle Ages was highly active in his mind. The students of Western
political thought are quite aware of the all-pervading influence of
Marx’s theory of religion is faced with few criticisms. First of
Christianity in general and church in particular over all sections of
all, it is true that with the progress of science the influence of religion
society.
will disappear. Science and technology in the twenty-first century
have reached a stage of unprecedented growth, but still there is Even the powerful emperors were not free from the
influence of religion. It is true that today’s people are not orthodox influence. The pope could dictate the kings in their day-to-day
in their attitude to religion, but they are not absolutely unreligious or activities. There was nobody to challenge the authority of the pope.
atheists. It was the religion which was responsible for the economic
backwardness of medieval Europe.
There is a fear of God or feeling of religion, more or less, in
the mind of many people. So we can ‘say that progress of science and It is also true that there was a time when religion acted as
religion coexist peacefully. It is not true that science contradicts opium. Religion reduced the consciousness of people to the
religion. The fields of the two are different. minimum. In medieval society religion was so powerful that people
failed to consider their own interests. They were forced to think
In the second place, the former Russian leaders claimed that
about the other world which had no physical existence.
they had succeeded in achieving socialism, but it is also true that they
had not been able to banish religion. Religion became a completely Today the orthodox aspect of religion has declined
private affair, but there was religion. remarkably. There are several reasons behind this and the most
important are the progress of science and the development of
We, therefore, see that Lenin’s estimation that in socialism
consciousness.
there cannot be religion is not true. If in former Soviet Union there
were religion there were no socialism, or vice versa. Religion has not disappeared and will not disappear as Marx
predicted. However, the educated people have developed a sort of
Thirdly, it is not correct to hold that religion is the fantasy of
indifference towards religion. There is today less orthodoxy, less
alienated man. In our previous analysis we have said that even the
fanfare and very less humbugging.
privileged and educated people of sophisticated societies practice
religion, but how are these people alienated? If these people are There is religion in miniature form. Lenin is not correct when
alienated then the concept requires to be redefined. There is no such he says that a socialist must be atheist. Many socialist minded people
scope.
have been found to practice religious principles and faiths. This is
because we are interpreting religion in a liberal way.