Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Systems Approach To Organizational Health
Systems Approach To Organizational Health
Nicholas A. Lofton
December 1, 2017
ABSTRACT
Health cannot be defined as one single variable, making identifying healthy attributes in
individuals a ceaselessly ending effort. Organizational health can also be many variables;
however, health can be evident by a systems’ efficiency. Individuals are limited by the
effectiveness of their body – the human movement system. Principle investigator has found
musculoskeletal dysfunctions of the human movement system. The Functional Movement Screen
(FMS) will be used to determine what compensatory patterns are present at baseline and a
goniometer will measure various joints’ degree of range of motion (ROM). Once data has been
complied for individual health, organizational health data will come from the organizations
expenditures, productivity, and costs. After all data has been collected, a t-test will be used to
compare mean job performance and the presence of musculoskeletal dysfunctions. ANOVA test
will examine how the totality of an individuals’ health influences organization’s health as a
whole. Results will likely show an individuals’ health status correlates with the level of health
within an organization.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract ..................................................................................................................................2
Introduction ............................................................................................................................4
Purpose of Study ........................................................................................................5
Literature Review...................................................................................................................6
Conclusion .................................................................................................................11
Methodology ..........................................................................................................................12
Sample........................................................................................................................12
Instruments .................................................................................................................12
Operational Definition of Independent Variable .......................................................12
Operational Definition of Dependent Variable ..........................................................13
Procedures ..................................................................................................................13
Research Design.........................................................................................................14
Null Hypothesis .........................................................................................................14
Ethical Considerations ...............................................................................................14
Results ....................................................................................................................................15
Discussion ..................................................................................................................17
Discussion of Anticipated Findings ...........................................................................17
Limitation of Findings ...............................................................................................17
Areas for Further Research ........................................................................................17
References ..............................................................................................................................18
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 4
INTRODUCTION
Movement – the human body is made for this. The human movement system relies on
two main sub-systems; the nervous system and the musculoskeletal system which subsequently
can be broken down into more sub-systems (Clark et al., 2014, p. 17). If any of the sub-systems
are not functioning properly, all other sub-systems will be hindered and ultimately the whole
human movement system will be affected. Based on the research by Janda (1988) theorizing
muscle imbalances, the principal investigator chose to measure what effect individuals’ health
have on organizations’ health as a whole based on Systems Theory (Ludwig von Bertalanffy)
(1951, 1967).
Systems are constantly exchanging energy, striving to keep an equilibrium and maintain
homeostasis (Sayin, 2016). Organizations and corporations are no exception, they too are bound
by the same innate laws. Ludwig von Bertalanffy (1951, 1967) conceptualized Systems Theory
which translates a biological theory into an organizational theory. Each part of a system is
Pattern overload, with respect to the human body, is a constant repetitive motion (Clark et
al., 2014, p. 170) of the human movement system. This repetitive motion, such as baseball
pitching, moving boxes, or even sitting for long periods of time can place abnormal stress on the
human body. Davis’s law (1867) explains when dysfunctions arise, our body responds as it
would to an injury; trauma to tissue creates inflammation which triggers the body’s protective
mechanism causing an increase in muscle tension and muscle spasms. Inelastic collagen matrices
form along the lines of stress (adhesions) in soft tissue around the tense muscle fibers. This
to altered joint motion) which, when our brain sends an electric pulse from the central nervous
system to the peripheral nervous system and into the dendrites of muscle fibers, adhesions inhibit
proper movement of the proteins myosin and actin when interacting in the muscle cell thus
The American Psychological Association (2012) developed the Stress in America survey
and administered it online in the United States by Harris Interactive. The study shows 41% of
employees feel stress and tense while at work (2012a). Another study reports 70% of adults sight
Purpose of Study
LITERATURE REVIEW
Munir et al., (2015) studied the relationship between work engagement and occupational
sitting time of Northern Ireland Civil Service (NICS) office-based workers. Out of 26,000 survey
links sent, 5,235 employees (20% response rate) returned the questionnaire. Questionnaires
completed by manual workers and non-permanent staff (n = 641) and office-based workers with
missing data (n = 158) were excluded, resulting in 4,436 questionnaires (1,945 male and 2,491
female) used in analyses. Total mean occupational sitting time was 379.63 minutes per day (s.d.
98.3); this was lower for men (362.4 minutes/day; s.d. 112.5) compared to women (385.7
minutes/day; s.d. 98.9) (t = 7.32; df =4434; p < .0001). Chi-Square analyses revealed the amount
of men (35.9%) reporting low occupational sitting times was significantly greater than for
women (31.3%); and the proportion of women (31.0%) reporting high occupational sitting times
was less than for men (35.2%), (χ2 = 12.89, df = 2 p < 0.002). More women than men reported
high dedication (n = 1108, 44.5% versus n = 806, 41.4%; χ2 = 9.68, df = 2 p < 0.008); high
absorption (n = 1099, 44.1% versus n = 643, 33.1%; χ2 = 53.91, df = 1 p < 0.0001); and work
performance (n = 2054, 82.5% versus n = 1336, 68.7%; χ2 = 115.48, df = 1 p < 0.0001). Higher
work engagement and job performance shows a correlation with lower occupational sitting
times.
Zehetmeir et al., (2015) gathered data from a study, dating back to 2006, of teachers in
Australia who have completed the PFL program (German acronym for ‘Pädagogik und
Fachdidaktik für Lehrinnen und Lehrer’, meaning ‘Pedagogy and Subject Didactics for
Teachers’) (2006) which demonstrates how to put theoretical accounts (Systems theory,
Constructivism, Action research) into practice. A sample of 131 teachers from different types of
schools’ data could be tracked over time, overall a total of 262 teachers participated. Of those
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 7
131, 69% were female and 27% were male (4% did not specify their gender, average was 41
years (standard deviation [SD] = 9.4). While the lowest value at t1 is Mt1 = 3.15, SDt1 = 0.70,
over time there shows to be a significant increase of participants’ interests, particularly in the
PFL program focus areas. In addition, teachers’ assessment of their own possessed knowledge
Bonzini et al., (2014) studied musculoskeletal pain as a cause rather than a consequence
of perceived occupational stress. Researchers in Varese, Italy reached out to 518 nurses, of
which 409 responded (79.0%) to complete a questionnaire from the CUPID study (Cultural and
Psychosocial Influences on Disability) (Coggon et al.) (2012), and the Effort Reward Imbalance
(ERI) questionnaire (Siegrist) (2000). A second follow-up questionnaire was sent out after 12
months to 322 participants (78.7%), 305 participants’ data remained after exclusions.
Participants were 82% female (250), mean age at baseline of 39 years (SD = 9 years), and mean
BMI (body mass index) of 24 kg/m2 (SD = 4.5 kg/m2). From the 305 participants, 55 (18%) had
an ERI >1, 159 (52%) reported LBP (low back pain), and 177 (58%) reported NSP
(neck/shoulder pain), of which 122 (40%) complained of having both LBP and NSP. The risk of
perceived occupational stress (ERI >1) at follow-up then at baseline doubled overall risk of
occupational stress (RR 2.1, 95% CI 1.4–3.3), however, this only included nurses who were free
from occupational stress at baseline (RR 2.7, 95% CI 1.4–5.0) and did not extend to those who
started with ERI >1. This study found only a small increase in the risk of subsequent
musculoskeletal pain from perceived occupational stress, whereas report of pain at baseline
carried a substantial increase in the risk of newly developed stress at follow-up. This study shows
that workers who report musculoskeletal pain are more likely to develop subsequent
apprehension of stress.
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 8
Blazovich, Smith, and Smith (2014) studied the impact on financial performance and risk
place. Researchers created two datasets: the ‘full dataset’ and the ‘match pair dataset.’ The ‘full
dataset’ is a combination of companies listed on ‘100 Best Companies to Work For’ published
by Fortune magazine, partnered with Great Place to Work Institute (GPWI) resulting in 271
firms (76 unique firms) added to additional data by the Compustat North America Fundamentals
Annual database. The smaller ‘match pair dataset’ consists of only the 271 firms (76 unique
greater, employee-friendly companies have higher market value of equity (p < 0.05) and
Lindegård, et al., (2013) surveyed Swedish health care workers over a two-year period. A
total of 4,739 health care workers were asked to participate, receiving only 3,481 responses, a
73% response rate. One follow-up only consisted of 3,209 of the original participants, the
response rate was now 70% (n = 2,223). Participants answered questions about perceived stress
from a modified version of the QPS-Nordic Questionnaire (Elo et al.) (2003). Baseline data and
follow-up data were analyzed by the log binomial model and noted as risk ratios (RR) consisting
of 95% confidence intervals (CI). Chronic musculoskeletal pain and perceived stress correlates
to the highest risk for reporting decreased work performance (RR 1.7; CI 1.28–2.32) in addition
Wirtz et al., (2013) clinically studied the role of occupational role stress in relation to
levels of the stress hormone cortisol responding to acute psychosocial stress. The sample
consisted of 43 males (mean age ± SEM: 44.5 ± 2.0 years; mean body mass index ± SEM 25.7±
.4), all nonsmokers and not on medication. Participants answered questionnaires prior to
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 9
completing the Trier Social Stress Test (TSST) (Kirschbaum) (1993). Tests were two-tailed with
a level of significance set at p ≤ .05 and level of borderline significance at p ≤ 10. Prior to
analysis data were tested for normality using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, missing data were
list-wise excluded. Significant ANCOVA results were then analyzed by application of post-hoc
tests to determine the observed total stress reactivity effect related to a change in immediate
stress reactivity. Data showed a high degree of role uncertainty was associated with more cortisol
stress reactivity (p = .016), even when the full set of potential confounders were controlled (p <
.001).
Boschman et al., (2012) selected at random 750 bricklayers and 750 supervisors in the
Netherlands. A questionnaire was designed with ad-hoc questions by three ergonomic experts,
assessments of musculoskeletal disorders for both occupations were collected at baseline then a
follow-up questionnaire one year later. The baseline response rate was 39% for the bricklayers
(292/750) and 34% for the construction supervisors (256/750). After excluding partially
completed questionnaires, response rate was 36% (n = 267) for the bricklayers and 31% (n =
232) for the supervisors. No female workers responded. Musculoskeletal disorders among 267
bricklayers was 67% and 232 supervisors were 57%, initially. At follow-up, the response rate
was 80%; 83% for the bricklayers (222/267) and 76% for the supervisors (177/232). Most of the
bricklayers and half of the supervisors contribute their musculoskeletal complaints to work.
Cagnie et al., (2012) clinically studied the change of oxygen saturation and blood flow
within the trapezius muscle of office workers. Participants were right-handed, performed at least
four hours of computer work daily as part of their job, had no history of traumatic injuries, and
underwent no surgical procedures of the neck or upper limbs; a total of ten participants, and ten
controls. Muscle oxygen and blood flow data were collected with the O2C device (white light
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 10
spectroscopy and the laser Doppler technique) seven times at six different spots. A significant
main effect for time (p < 0.001) and muscle part (p < 0.001) and an interaction effect for muscle
part × group (p = 0.049) yielded a variance during the multivariate analysis. Over time, post hoc
tests show a decrease from T1 and T3 (p < 0.022), although no differences between T3 and T5,
and again a decrease at T6 and T7 when compared to T1-T5 (p < 0.050). This study shows one
hour of consecutively typing influenced both the oxygen saturation and blood flow in all three
Siško, Videmšek, and Karpljuk (2011) studied the degree of joint range of motion (ROM)
and the level of musculoskeletal ache, pain, or discomfort experienced of office workers. There
were 19 female employees, aged from 40 and 54 years old (mean age 46 ± 4.6 years; average
hours using computer at work 6.2 ± 1.2 hours; mean number of hours sitting during work day 8.2
± 2.4). They all answered The Cornell Musculoskeletal Discomfort Questionnaire (The Human
Factors and Ergonomics Laboratory at Cornell University) (1994). Researchers compared the
mean results of measurements before and after the first and the last session for cervical flexion,
cervical extension, lumbar flexion, and lumbar extension (level of significance p < 0.05). The
amount of discomfort and interference with ability to work were lower (p < 0.05). A reduction
was shown for the neck (p = 0.002) and the upper back (p = 0.017) from the second to third
phase; for the neck (p = 0.004), and the upper back (p = 0.027) from the first and third phase.
Before the first session and after the last session were the greatest for cervical lateral flexion
(average of left and right measurements), which was 11.4º (28.8%), 7.7º (12.7%) for cervical
extension, 5º (9.6%) for cervical flexion, 5.5º (8%) for lumbar flexion, and a negative change of
Murata et al., (2003) clinically studied localized muscular fatigue of the upper trapezius
muscle. Five undergraduate students, males ages 19 to 23, participated in an experimental task.
Measuring the maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) and root mean square (RMS) value of an
EMG signal and force relation. The scores were tested with a Friedman nonparametric test, χ2(4,
N = 5) = 13.316, p < .01, and found a significant main effect of block, then using ANOVA test
on mean power frequency (MPF) researchers showed there to be significant main effect of block,
F(4, 20) = 8.384, p < .01, also a Student–Newman–Keuls post-hoc test showed differences in the
following pairs were significant: BT and T60 (p < .01), BT and T90 (p < .01), and BT and T120
(p < .01). Localized muscular fatigue did appear in the shoulder and accumulated during the two-
hour experimental task. However, accumulated localized muscular fatigue did not affect the
Conclusion
The health status of the human body should not be neglected when discussing
organizational health. Future research should emphasize how organizations can benefit by
allocating focus on smaller systems to accomplish equilibrium in the system as a whole. The
human body’s natural reaction to stress can cause musculoskeletal dysfunction. More research
needs to be done on how stressors affect performance and what corrective measures must be
taken to reduce, or better adapt, to today’s work environments. Once more research is published
on the effects of organizational induced stress on individual health, more organizations will
invest in their own research to better equip employees with a proactive work-life balance
program.
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 12
METHODOLOGY
Sample
Principle investigator will study the health of office workers in the oil and gas industry of
Houston, Texas. Participants will be free of past injuries and surgical procedures, not prescribed
any medications, possess no chronic health conditions, and must be able to physically exercise
with no apparent risk to health. This study will use both male and female participants, ranging
from 25 to 60 years in age, and participants must sit at a desk a minimum of two hours per work
day.
Instruments
Modified versions of the Chek Nutrition and Lifestyle Questionnaire (Chek) (2004) and
The Cornell Musculoskeletal Discomfort Questionnaire (The Human Factors and Ergonomics
incorporate the Functional Movement Screen (FMS) and a goniometer will measure the degrees
Employee health is “not the absence of ill-ness rather the presence of well-being.” This
definition of health “requires that individuals possess symptoms of both positive feelings and
Procedures
The principal investigator seeks approval from the University of Houston Downtown’s
Institutional Review Board (IRB) committee allowing the facilitation of physical assessments
and gathering measurements of joints ROM, as well as administer modified versions of the Chek
Nutrition and Lifestyle Questionnaire (Chek) (2004) and The Cornell Musculoskeletal
University) (1994). Physical assessments will incorporate the Functional Movement Screen
(FMS) and a goniometer will measure the degrees of ROM at the trapezius and levator scapula,
pectoralis major/minor and sternocleidomastoid; the pelvis and hip flexors, lumbar spine and
hamstring complex; and at the iliopsoas and rectus femoris. These measurements will give a
baseline for individual health. Organizational health will be measured by organizations’ data
productivity, and costs. Data will be collected at baseline then once every three months for a
year. Participants will work with certified personnel to incorporate some type of mental
stimulation, physical stimulation, and spiritual stimulation into their daily routine. Follow-up
assessments will take place every three months up to a year, four assessments in total.
Research Design
individual health, discrete and continuous variables will be converted into categorical variables.
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 14
Composite FMS scores will then be dichotomized and individual scores examined for asymmetry
or a score of 1 (yes versus no). Principle investigator will use χ2 statistics to examine the
association between musculoskeletal dysfunctions and FMS summed score and between
for each analysis. Then a t-test will be used to compare mean job performance and the presence
of musculoskeletal dysfunctions. ANOVA test will examine how the totality of an individual’s
Null Hypothesis
Individual health is not related organizational health as based on Systems Theory (von
Ethical Considerations
working with the principal investigator to ensure no laws, local or federal, will be violated.
Informed consent forms will be issued describing the purpose of the study, identifying the
principle investigator and organization, identifying the expected length of study, and explaining
RESULTS
individual’s level of stress, subsequent results are anticipated to indicate a significant effect on
organizational health when compared to individual health. According to Blazovich et al., (2014)
organizational performance of employee-friendly firms is better than those of the control firms
superior market value of equity, in addition to a higher return on assets, and lastly a better return
on equity. Table 1 shows the comparison of employee-friendly list firms to control firms.
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 16
Table 1
DISCUSSION
Findings from this study could be beneficial in bridging the gap between organization
health and individual health. By making individuals’ health a priority, organizations are liaising
opportunities for individuals to live a healthier lifestyle which has a significant effect on job
costs. An individuals’ health level can be associated with their quality of life, at home and in
life. Once society can operate as a system with equilibrium untold achievements are plausible.
Limitation of Findings
Office workers in the oil and gas industry of Houston, Texas do not share the same life
style of other office workers in the oil and gas industry throughout the United States. Not all
The compensatory patterns of organizations have not been identified. Further research
explain why such compensation patterns exist, and what corrective exercises are needed to
REFERENCES
American Psychological Association. (2012a). APA survey finds feeling valued at work linked
https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/stress/2009/stress-exec-summary.pdf
American Psychological Association. (2012b). Stress in America: Our health at risk. Retrieved
from http://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/stress/2011/final-2011.pdf
Blazovich, J. L., Taken Smith, K., & Smith, L. M. (2014). Employee-Friendly Companies and
Bonzini, M., Bertu', L., Veronesi, G., Conti, M., Coggon, D., & Ferrario, M. M. (2015). Is
612. doi:10.1007/s00420-014-0982-1
Boschman, J. S., van der Molen, H. F., Sluiter, J. K., & Frings-Dresen, M. H. (2012).
Cagnie, B., Dhooge, F., Van Akeleyen, J., Cools, A., Cambier, D., & Danneels, L. (2012).
2322-z
Clark, M., Sutton, B. G., & Lucett, S. (2014). NASM essentials of personal fitness training.
Janda, V. 1988. Muscles and Cervicogenic Pain Syndromes. In Physical Therapy of the Cervical
and Thoracic Spine, ed. R. Grand. New York: Churchill Livingstone. 2002:182-199
Lindegård, A., Larsman, P., Hadzibajramovic, E., & Ahlborg, G. J. (2014). The influence of
perceived stress and musculoskeletal pain on work performance and work ability in
Munir, F., Houdmont, J., Clemes, S., Wilson, K., Kerr, R., & Addley, K. (2015). Work
engagement and its association with occupational sitting time: results from the Stormont
Murata, A., Uetake, A., Matsumoto, S., & Takasawa, Y. (2003). Evaluation of Shoulder
Page, K., & Vella-Brodrick, D. (2009). The ‘What’, ‘Why’ and ‘How’ of Employee Well-Being:
9270-3
Pescud, M., Teal, R., Shilton, T., Slevin, T., Ledger, M., Waterworth, P., & Rosenberg, M.
Orvik, A., & Axelsson, R. (2012). Organizational health in health organizations: towards a
doi:10.1111/j.1471-6712.2012.00996.x
Systems Approach to Organizational Health 20
and Basic Structures of the Systems in Quantum Physics, Biology and Neuroscience.
Siško, P. K., Videmšek, M., & Karpljuk, D. (2011). The effect of a corporate chair massage
Journal Of Alternative And Complementary Medicine (New York, N.Y.), 17(7), 617-622.
doi:10.1089/acm.2010.0400
Wirtz, P. H., Ehlert, U., Kottwitz, M. U., La Marca, R., & Semmer, N. K. (2013). Occupational
role stress is associated with higher cortisol reactivity to acute stress. Journal Of
Learning.
Zehetmeier, S., Andreitz, I., Erlacher, W., & Rauch, F. (2015). Researching the impact of teacher
doi:10.1080/09650792.2014.997261