Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pole Wind Induced Flyer HLOI0022qqqqqq
Pole Wind Induced Flyer HLOI0022qqqqqq
As an industry leader in light pole design and manufacturing, Hubbell is committed to providing information to help
designers avoid wind induced pole vibration. This paper presents a practical guide for recognizing and minimizing
[OLWV[LU[PHSKHTHNPUNLɈLJ[ZVM^PUKVUSPNO[WVSLZ
+LÄUPUN>PUK0UK\JLK=PIYH[PVU
>PUKPUK\JLKWVSL]PIYH[PVUPZWHY[PHSS`KLÄULKVYJOHYHJ[LYPaLKI`[OL[`WLVMTV]LTLU[VIZLY]LKPU
a pole system.
FIRST MODE VIBRATION is characterized by a side to side movement that has a maximum displacement at
the top of the pole. This behavior may be referred to as “sway”. The frequency of movement is about 1 cycle per
second or less. Because the vibration frequency is comparatively small, the onset of material fatigue will take
longer than poles exhibiting higher modes of vibration.
SECOND MODE VIBRATION is characterized by a symmetric oscillation at or near the midpoint of the pole
shaft. The oscillation frequency typically ranges from 3-6 cycles per second. Second mode vibration occurs when
air moving across a pole reaches “lock-in” velocity. At “lock-in” velocity, Vortex Shedding produces alternating
transverse forces that oscillate the pole at one of its natural frequencies. The onset of fatigue cracking or structural
failure may occur quickly under such conditions.
VORTEX SHEDDING is the phenomenon caused by a steady, constant velocity wind moving across a slender,
ÅL_PISLVIQLJ[SPRLHWVSL=VY[PJLZMVYTPUNVU[OLZPKLZVM[OLWVSLJYLH[LSVJHSPaLKWVJRL[ZVMSV^WYLZZ\YL
These pockets alternate, creating alternating forces that act on the pole perpendicular to the wind direction.
Figure 2: Vortex Shedding simulation about a cylinder demonstrating alternating low pressure zones in wake
,U]PYVUTLU[HS*VUKP[PVUZ[OH[0UJYLHZL9PZR
,U]PYVUTLU[HS]HYPHISLZSPRL^PUKJVUKP[PVUZ[LYYHPUSHUKZJHWLHUKZP[LZ[Y\J[\YLZNYLH[S`PUÅ\LUJL
OV^^PUK^PSSHɈLJ[WVSLZ`Z[LTZ;OPZWHY[PHSSPZ[PUJS\KLZHWWSPJH[PVUH[[YPI\[LZ[OH[TH`MHJPSP[H[L^PUK
induced pole vibration.
9LNPVUHS.LVNYHWO`¶,_WHUZP]LÅH[HYLHZ^P[OSP[[SL
natural or man-made wind breaks as common in the
upper mid-west, plains states, and some coastal
regions.
Fig. 3
-SH[6WLU;LYYHPU¶3VJHSPaLKÅH[HYLHZ^P[OSP[[SLVYUV
^PUKIYLHRZPLSHYNLWHYRPUNSV[ZSHYNLÄLSKZ[VWVM
parking structures, causeways)
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
(PYWVY[Z¶;\YI\SLU[HPYMYVTHPYJYHM[HUKSVJHSPaLKÅH[
HYLHZHIZLU[VMVIQLJ[Z[VIYLHR[OL^PUKJ\YYLU[Z
Fig. 6
Fig. 7
3VJHS*VUKP[PVUZ:P[LZWLJPÄJ[LYYHPUHUKJVUKP[PVUZ
Figure 8: Unique application.
Fig. 8
+LZPNU-HJ[VYZ;V*VUZPKLY
Pole selection can also contribute to the potential for wind induced vibration. Relevant design attributes are:
Loading¶3\TPUHPYLZPaL,7(S\TPUHPYL^LPNO[S\TPUHPYLX\HU[P[`HUKS\TPUHPYLVYPLU[H[PVU^PSSPUÅ\LUJL[OLILOH]PVYVM
the pole and its susceptibility to vibration. Loads that exceed the design limits of the pole may result in structural failure. Also
problematic, very small loads and zero loaded poles (lightly damped) may be prone to vibration.
Height¶7VSLOLPNO[NV]LYUZ[OLHTV\U[VMKLÅLJ[PVUHWVSL^PSSTV]LHUK[OLZPaLVM[OLTVTLU[NLULYH[LKH[[OLWVSLIHZL
An increase in height will increase both values, making it more susceptible to wind induced vibration.
Material¶*VTTVUWVSLTH[LYPHSZPUJS\KLZ[LLSHS\TPU\TJVUJYL[LÄILYNSHZZJHZ[PYVUHUK^VVK4H[LYPHSWYVWLY[PLZ]HY`
between material types. Steel and aluminum are very common materials used in light pole manufacturing. Of the two types,
steel has higher strength of material properties than aluminum.
Shape¶7VSLZOHWLJYVZZZLJ[PVUNLVTL[Y`HSZVPUÅ\LUJLZWVSLWLYMVYTHUJLILJH\ZLHLYVK`UHTPJJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZJOHUNL
I`ZOHWL>OLUJVTWHYPUNZX\HYLWVSLZ[VYV\UKWVSLZZX\HYLWVSLZOH]LOPNOLYKYHNJVLɉ JPLU[Z:X\HYLWVSLZTH`HSZV
OH]LTVYLJVTWSL_HZ`TTL[YPJÅV^WH[[LYUZHYV\UK[OLWVSL;OPZPZLZWLJPHSS`[Y\LMVY^PUKZHWWYVHJOPUNVɈHUNSLMYVT[OL
LP[OLY[OLÅH[Z\YMHJLZVYJVYULYZ
-PN\YL !:PT\SH[LKÅV^HIV\[HZ[YHPNO[ZX\HYL
cylinder at various wind approach angles
Taper – Taper can also change the aerodynamic characteristics of the pole, shifting the critical wind velocity that causes
Second Mode vibration.
9LJVTTLUKH[PVUZ
Evaluate risk0UZWLJ[ZP[LJVUKP[PVUZHUKL]HS\H[L[OLYPZRVMWYVISLTH[PJ^PUKJVUKP[PVUZ
:[YLUN[OLUVYZ[PɈLU[OLWVSL]PHTH[LYPHSZLSLJ[PVUPLJOVVZLZ[LLSV]LYHS\TPU\TPUJYLHZL^HSS[OPJRULZZPUJYLHZL[OL
cross sectional size, and/or minimize height.
Increase Damping;OL\ZLZVMMHJ[VY`VYÄLSKPUZ[HSSHISLKHTWPUNKL]PJLZVɈLYHULJVUVTPJHSVW[PVUMVYTPUPTPaPUN
destructive vibration. Most dampers reduce the amplitude of mechanical vibrations by adding mass that moves at a
KPɈLYLU[YH[L[OHU[OLZOHM[VM[OLWVSL:VTLKHTWLYZHSZVJOHUNL[OLUH[\YHSMYLX\LUJ`VM[OLWVSLI`TV]PUN[OL
excitation frequency, thereby changing the critical velocity and the forces generated by vortex shedding.
/\IILSSVɈLYZH-PYZ[4VKL]PIYH[PVUKHTWLY8[OH[PZMHJ[VY`HZZLTISLKWHPU[LK[VTH[JOHUKYLHK`MVYÄLSKPUZ[HSS0[
is designed for 4”, 5”, and 6” square aluminum and steel lighting poles.
/\IILSSVɈLYZ[^V[`WLZVM:LJVUK4VKL]PIYH[PVUKHTWLYZ
Serpentine Tube ZWLJPHSVYKLY]PIYH[PVUKHTWLYZHYLÄLSKPUZ[HSSLK[OYV\NOOHUK
holes. These devices wrap around the inner surface of the pole shaft, are free
standing, and reduce motion.
Interior Canister (Q42) vibration dampers feature an internal cylinder that houses a
cushioned, weighted rod pendulum. This device moves in the opposite direction of the
shaft, disrupting vibrations. The impact of the pendulum against the cylindrical housing
may be audible under certain conditions. This type of damper is factory installed.
Figure 11: Canister and tube dampers
6IZLY]LWVSLTV]LTLU[K\YPUN^PUK`JVUKP[PVUZ,_JLZZP]LKLÅLJ[PVUYHWPKVZJPSSH[PVUH[[OLZOHM[midpoint, or audible
thumping of electrical conductors in the pole may be indications of pole vibration.
• Low torque values on anchor bolts.
• Loose or missing parts at the luminaire and/or pole top are an early indication that the pole may be vibrating in
HWWSPJH[PVU4PZZPUNWVSLJHWZSVVZL/0+ZVJRL[ZHUKWYLTH[\YLS`MHPSPUN/0+SHTWZHYLHML^L_HTWSLZ*VYYLJ[VY
replace as necessary.
• Look for signs of rust and corrosion above the pole base plate weld and about the hand hole. Corrosion may
PUKPJH[LHUHYLHVMMH[PN\L0MWYLZLU[YLTV]L[OLJVYYVZPVUHUK^PWLJSLHU/HPYSPULJYHJRZQ\Z[HIV]L[OLWVSLIHZL
plate weld may indicate shaft material fatigue. An inexpensive die may be used to aid in detection.
Figure 12: Example of fatigue cracking at
the base plate weld
• For square poles, inspect the corners near the base plate in a similar manner.
9L]PL^[OLLU[PYLWVSLZOHM[MVYZPNUZVMÄUPZOKL[LYPVYH[PVU
0MHU`PUKPJH[PVUZVMMH[PN\LL_PZ[HX\HSPÄLKHUKL_WLYPLUJLKZ[Y\J[\YHSLUNPULLYZOV\SKILJVUZ\S[LK[OLHɈLJ[LKWVSLZOV\SK
IL[HRLUKV^UPTTLKPH[LS`HUKHUPUZWLJ[PVUZOV\SKILWLYMVYTLKMVY[OLLU[PYLZP[L0M]PIYH[PVUOHZVYPZVJJ\YYPUNI\[[OLWVSL
is deemed to be structurally sound, mitigation steps should be taken immediately by adding dampers and monitoring the pole
ILOH]PVY0M]PIYH[PVUJVU[PU\LZHM[LYKHTWLYZHYLHKKLKHUHS[LYUH[LWVSLZOHWLVYJVUZ[Y\J[PVUZOV\SKILJVUZPKLYLK
7VSL>HYYHU[`
Wind induced vibration is a naturally occurring phenomena that may lead to structural failure of poles. Such a failure is not an
indication of inferior design, material, or craftsmanship. As such, Hubbell’s warranty does not apply to and Hubbell shall have no
liability for any failure of the products or damage due to fatigue failure or similar phenomena resulting from induced vibrations,
harmonic oscillation or resonance associated with movement of air currents around the product.