Professional Documents
Culture Documents
China and India in The Global Economy: A Cooperative Knowledge-Based A Cooperative Knowledge Based Development Strategy
China and India in The Global Economy: A Cooperative Knowledge-Based A Cooperative Knowledge Based Development Strategy
China and India in The Global Economy: A Cooperative Knowledge-Based A Cooperative Knowledge Based Development Strategy
A Cooperative Knowledge
Knowledge-Based
Based
Development Strategy
Ashok Bardhan
University of California
Berkeley
Berkeley, California
• Facts and Compulsions
– Both China and India growing at a fast clip
– Need sustainable growth far into future for
economic, social and political reasons; for job
creation social harmony….
creation, harmon
• Questions Raised
– Wh
Whatt can be
b some off the
th elements
l t off a long-term
l t
strategy for development?
– What is the scope for cooperation between India
and China in the course of this strategy?
Among Many Strategies, Our Focus:
Knowledge and Innovation Based
Approach
• Why?
– Globalization/offshoring have made industries, firms,
individual jobs FOOTLOOSE; there can be the next wave
of migration to even cheaper countries
– Only way to create both NEW (i.e. at least temporarily
rooted) jobs
jobs, and BETTER (i.e.
(i e high-paying) jobs is
through innovation - new goods, new technologies
– Human Resources key in the Post Manufacturing-Post
Services Economies
– Scale advantage not just in manufacturing and services, but
also in R&D
Key Elements of Knowledge Economy
Strategy
• Benefits from Offshoringg of R&D and Innovative
Activity from Developed Countries
• Innovation Growth Diagnostics
• Education Policies; Soft Infrastructure and other
Institutional Features
• Early
E l Adoption,
Ad ti RapidR id Dissemination,
Di i ti “New“N Goods”
G d”
Factor
• Scope for Economic Cooperation between India and
China
US R&D Spending and Incremental GDP due to
Productivity Growth
$, Bill
300
250
200
50
0
1988
988 1990
990 1992
99 1994
99 1996
996 1998
998 2000
000
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
00
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
20 The Baumol Paradox with Services!
Source: OECD
Globalization of Innovative Activity: Offshoring of
R&D tot China,
Chi India,
I di E Eastt E
Europe
• Costs
• Design and Research to Market; Early adopters
• Spillover from Offshoring of Manufacturing and Services
• Broaden Access to Expertise
• Complex Interdisciplinary Nature of Contemporary R&D
• Thin End of the Wedge – Market Entry
• Access to Different Scientific Cultures…Value of Scientific and Technical
“Diversity”
50
40 All countries
Asia
30
China
20 India
EU15
10
0
1995-2005, Annual Growth Rate
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Direct Investment Abroad: Financial and
Operating Data for U.S. Multinational Companies (annual series), .
India and China at a Glance
INDIA CHINA
20
10
0
US EU-15 Asia China India
Source: NSF
Science and Engineering Graduates
600 000
600,000
500,000
400 000
400,000
300,000
1990
200,000 2002
100,000
0
China India EU-15 United
States
Science and Engineering PhDs
45 000
45,000
40,000
35,000
30 000
30,000
25,000
20,000 1990
15,000 2003
10,000
5,000
0
China India EU-15 United
States
US Science and Engineering Degrees
Conferred, by Country
3500
3000
2500
2000 China
1500 India
EU-15
1000
500
0
1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003
Source: NSF
• From Early Adoption, Dissemination and Leapfrogging to –
C ti off “NEW”
Creation
– New Goods
– New Processes
– New Companies
– New Jobs
– New Brands
• March to your own Drummer
– Not necessary to emulate
– Let Global as well as Domestic Demand Determine
Innovation
…..Learn - from Advantages and Disadvantages
of Silicon Valley Location to High-Tech
High Tech Firms
ADVANTAGES
Skilled Labor
Professional Network
Quality of Life
Communications
Overseas Markets
DISADVANTAGES
Housing Costs/COL
Labor (and management!) Costs
Transport Congestion
Taxes/Gov't Reg.
Comm'l RE Cost/Avail
Pervasive Computing/
Bio-Info-Nanotech
Networkingg
Innovation Diagnostics System
An Example
Low Level of Innovative Activity
Market Failures –
Need for Public/Pvt Weak Linkage between Labor
Mechanisms g
Mkt & Higher Education
Anomalies in India-China Economic
R l i
Relationship
hi
• Fast growing trade (>$40bill), but…
• Minuscule Mutual FDI
• Mutual People Flows
• Educational and other Contacts
• Insignificant R&D collaboration in
commerciali l sphere
h
Foreign Collaboration in Joint Science and
E i
Engineering
i Articles,
A i l 2003
CHINA INDIA
Other US
27% 28%
Other
26% US
34%
Japan
14%
Japan
Europe 10%
26%
Europe
35%