Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sip 2
Sip 2
14 Literature Review 75
15 Research methodology 82
Research Design
Population of the study
Data Collection Method
Data Analysis & Presentation
Limitations of the study
16 Data Analysis & Interpretation 84
17 Findings 99
18 Recommendation 100
19 Conclusion 101
20 Annexure 105
no. no.
1 Net Working Capital 85
2 Net Working Capital Ratio 85
3 Breakup of Working Capital 87
4 Notional Interest on WC @ 9% 87
5 Current Ratio 88
6 Return on Assets (%) 89
7 Return on capital employed (%) 90
8 Return on investment (%) 91
9 Average Collection Period (in days) 92
10 Average Payment Period (in days) 93
11 Inventory Turnover (in days) 94
12 Cash conversion cycle (in days) 95
______________________________________________
Product Portfolio:
As a science-based and patient-oriented healthcare company, Novartis
strive to be a global leader in growing areas of healthcare. Following a
corporate transformation Novartis is focused on three divisions with
global scale and innovation power – pharmaceuticals, eye care and
generic medicines. This has strengthened the future growth prospects
of the company.
Pharmaceuticals:
Sandoz (Generics):
Introduction of Management
Novartis was created in 1996 through the merger of Ciba-Geigy and Sandoz,
two companies with a rich and diverse corporate history. Throughout the
years, Novartis and its predecessor companies have discovered and
developed many innovative products for patients and consumers worldwide.
Novartis has been in India since 1947. The Group operates in India through
four entities namely Novartis India Limited, listed on the Mumbai Stock
Exchange, Novartis Healthcare Private Limited, Sandoz Private Limited and
Chiron-Behring Vaccine Private Limited. In India Novartis have a presence in
pharmaceuticals, generics (pharmaceutical products that are off patent),
Vaccines, OTC (over-the-counter medicines), eye care and Animal Health.
In 1996, the vaccine line was expanded significantly in 1998 with the
acquisition of the European vaccine businesses of Behring (Germany) and
Sclavo (Italy). This was followed in 2003 by the acquisition of PowderJect, the
UK-based vaccines company, making Chiron the second-largest flu vaccines
provider and the fifth-largest vaccines business in the world
Novartis, also known as a global healthcare leader, is a company that has one
of the most exciting product pipelines in the pharmaceutical industry today.
Focused solely on healthcare, this company offers a diversified portfolio to
best meet these needs of innovative medicines, cost-saving generic
Vision:
We will be a preferred global vaccine supplier touching more lives, in more
markets, with more vaccines.
Mission:
Making the world rabies free by providing effective vaccines at affordable
price.
Olivi Jona
er thon
Sour
Schl R.Ra
Ruc
abh
aefli jago
ker
Bhar
Srik
Hea pal Vaid
Hea Raju
dwaj
Mad
anth
d huri Site
d ehi Kuri
Head
Prab
Red
Qual Hea
Tech Som l
Site
haka
dy InasDum Pra d & Kail Joge
ity
Quali bre Ops an Asstt
Ravi
Qualr u bhu direc esh nder
Phar
ty Hum Phar PM . Site
Patel
Rao
ity Cha Ka tor Vach Mish
mNotOps Sn an Na maHe O Ke HeaM
Vali
Qual
Assu kola nan hani ra
Ops d ah
Nom
datio
ity
ranc MSResondki
eha manFact tan Purc
inate
ne
Cont &Tl urceumHS t ory Pa Offihasees
d
rol Pat arE JainAcc til ce hH
Com el Ga Mfgount Fil ari
plaia Pri wd Sup s lin ha
nce ma e port g ra
& ry Pac , & n
Qual Ma kin spec IQ En
ity nuf g, ial P gi
Syst act sup proj ne
em uri ply ects eri
ng cha & ng
in RA
&w
are
hou
se
Raw Materials:
Fertilized Eggs (Chicken eggs)
Rabies Virus
Production Planning:
Production planning is the plan for the future production, in which the
facilities needed are determined and arranged.
In CBVPL, in order to develop production plans, the production
planner work closely together with the marketing & sales department.
They provide sales forecasts, or a listing of customers’ orders.
They makes forecast based on market survey as well as past years
data.
They have the following objectives for production planning.
To ensure right quantity and quality of raw material, equipments etc
are available during the time of production.
To ensure capacity utilization is in tune with forecasted demand at
all the time.
Plant Capacity:
They have the capacity of producing 15 million doses per annumn.
Export:
CBVPL, Ankleshwar sells its entire production to parent and group
companies and from their vaccines are exported.
They export in Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Philippines, China,
Thailand, etc.
Patent:
A patent is an exclusive right granted for an invention, which is a
product or a process that provides, in general, a new way of doing
something, or offers a new technical solution to a problem.
CBVPL has a patent on Rabies Virus.
Material Handling:
Material handling refers to the process of moving, controlling,
protecting as well as storing material such as goods, items, etc. for
manufacture, disposal, and distribution or even for consumption.
Inventory Management
When there is a need for purchasing materials, purchase
department prepares purchase requisition and it is approved by head.
Purchase order is placed online.
Goods Receipt: Warehouse officer is responsible for
receiving and preparing GR in SAP. GR are accompanied by
corresponding supplier’s goods challan or invoice. The supplier challan
or invoice must state its related purchase order, purchase entered into
the SAP.
Transfer & Consumption: SAP assigns lot/Control
number while entering the GR. Lot or control numbers are
systematically and consecutively numbered and can be tracked for all
goods movements. Goods are issued based on first in, first out.
Inventory Control: Physical stock count of all RM, PM, AUX inventory
materials is taken once in three months. For RM respective user and
for PM & AUX Warehouse Officer take the SAP stock statement from
the SAP system on the last working day of the third month. During
physical count, inventory movements are restricted in SAP. Statutory
auditors verifying physical stock lying at non- infected area twice in a
year i.e. Dec & March.
Work Timings
Report to work in the morning: 6:50 am, 8:20 am, 2:50 pm and 10:30
pm depending on shift (I, G, II & III respectively).
Leave work in the evening: 3:30 pm, 5:30 pm, 11:30 pm and 7:10 am
depending on shift (I, G, II & III respectively) or as per work
requirement of overtime.
Dress Code
19 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
Associates are required to wear Business Formal or Business Casual
attire from Monday to Thursday. CBVPL has adopted a casual business
dress code but emphasizes that some positions may call for more
professional attire. The dress code at CBVPL is Business casual, broadly
defined as a clean, neat look that would be appropriate for any office
situation. Few examples of Business casual are collared shirts, formal
trousers, khaki-style pants, corduroy pants and dress shoes. Female
associates’ business casual may be broadly defined as short sleeves,
modest necklines, tailored dresses, skirts and tradition Indian attire.
Business dresses that are more formal than business casual dresses are
always considered more appropriate. On weekends, associates are
allowed to wear Jeans and other casual attire generally acceptable in
professional work environment.
CBVPL is committed to providing a safe and healthy work place for its
Associates and visitors. The Company is equally committed to preventing
the deterioration of the environment and minimizing the impact of its
operations on the land, air, and water. These commitments can be met
only through the awareness and cooperation of all Associates. Personal
safety, as well as that for co-workers and the general public, is the
responsibility of every Associate. They need to always notify their
supervisor of any suspected unsafe or unhealthy conditions in the work
place. This would include hazardous materials or wastes coming in
contact with the environment or being improperly handled or discarded,
or where a potential violation of the law may exist. Job related illnesses
or injuries should be immediately reported to supervisor.
Drug-Free Workplace
Drug and alcohol abuse impairs employees’ ability to perform their job
and to provide the quality service to customers. Associates who work
under the influence of alcohol or drugs may be a danger to themselves
20 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
and others. As a result, the Company prohibits Associates from
working under the influence of, possessing, consuming, distributing, or
selling illegal drugs or alcohol while on company premises or company
arranged vehicles. Due to the increased risk of injury created by drug
and alcohol abuse, the Company reserves the right to administer drug
or alcohol tests to Associates believed to be under the influence of
drugs or alcohol. If employee suspects he/she has an alcohol or drug
abuse problem he/she may consult the HR team for assistance.
Holidays
HR notifies the holidays of the coming years in the month of December of
each year.
Types of Leave
Privilege Leave
PL is earned leave.
All associates having a minimum 240 days attendance during a
year will be eligible for a maximum of 25 PL during the consecutive
year.
All associates who satisfy the above criteria are entitled to 25
working days of PL for the calendar year, which are credited in
their leave book on 1st January every year.
Unauthorized Absence
Unauthorized absence refers to absence from work without
requisite approval.
The Associate need to offer an explanation to his/ her immediate
manager in the event of any unauthorized absence.
In the event of an associate failing to give an explanation to the
satisfaction of the immediate manager, the Company is liable to
Pay Cycle
The payroll cycle is from 1st of the month to end of month.
Generally salary is credited into the Associate’s account in the last
week of every month before last working day. Any change in this
date, for whatever reason, will be intimated in advance to the
Associate. In case of queries on administration of compensation,
clarifications can be sought from payroll.
Other Benefits
Medical & Hospitalization Benefits all the associates of CBVPL
are covered under the Hospitalization & Mediclaim. The company
has obtained the Hospitalization policy with external Insurance
Company.
Delegation of Responsibility
26 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
Department head or section in-charge may delegate their
responsibilities and authorities to other personnel.
The person who is delegating his/her responsibilities and authorities
document the same either through update in job description on
signed memo or email.
Exit Formalities
At the time of leaving the organisation the employee need to submit the
duly filled and signed ‘Exit Check-out Form’ to HR.
7. For entry into production, storage and laboratory areas, all need to
follow respective entry-exit procedures along with all applicable
gowning and safety instruction.
8. Smoking, eating, drinking, chewing tobacco and related products
are not permitted within the site premises of NOVARTIS.
9. Eating, drinking, chewing or keeping food, drink and personal
medicines are not permitted in production, laboratory and storage
areas.
10. Any person who visited live areas and/or handling animals and
microorganisms is not permitted to visit other manufacturing,
storage and testing areas on the same day unless requirements
mentioned in SOP are fulfilled.
11. Personnel shall report pertinent changes in their state of health to
the management before entering any GMP areas. The same
requirements also apply to maintenance, sampling and service
personnel.
12. All personnel must follow the minimum requirements for personnel
hygiene before entering into any GMP areas.
Induction Program:
Genera Safety, basic site layouts, Handling of biological Health, Safety and
materials, and Novartis Emergency Management, On- Environment (HSE)
site emergency plan
Introduction to departmental organisation chart Concerned Department
department’s functions/processes Head/Section In-charge
Formal introduction to individual employees is applicable
Training Categories:
Basic Training: Minimum training required before a person can
become operational in a job function. Includes a general common, not
Training Execution:
Technical Training:
GxP Training:
For GxP responsibilities include initial training on regulatory
requirements in the individual training plan as it pertains to
operations and responsibilities of the function and individuals
role. Training is usually provided by the certified trainer.
Budget
Company is following budgetary control process on calendar year
bases. Initially in the month of September, company prepares a
budget for the following year and presents it to global senior
leadership team.
After adopting top down approach, a target letter is issued by the
global team. Basically budgeting process covers all the important
KPIs like supply volume and realization, quality and compliance,
production volume, yield, cost of goods manufacturing, productivity
initiatives, CAPEX.
On monthly bases target letter review with the global leadership
team. Any deviation between the actual and budget is explained and
corrective actions are taken.
Investment Analysis
Company is having enough reserves & surplus and company’s
liquidity position is also good, hence company has find avenue for
investing surplus fund only with the group company mainly fixed
34 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
deposit of the Group Company as well as short term investment with
the bankers.
Investment Decisions:
Determining Annual CAPEX, Fixed Asset
Propose various projects for investment.
Globally approval by senior management team.
Capital appropriation request when the proposal is above threshold
limit.
Various parameters like NPV, IRR, and PBP are measured.
Approved as per the finance authority matrix.
Taxation:
Company is in the ambit direct and indirect taxation, which covers
income tax, excise, service tax, Value Added Tax (VAT) and CST.
Company is paying taxes regularly to the government authority and
complies with the all necessary regulations.
Accounting Policy:
Accounting Policy covers valuation of fixed assets, depreciation rate,
method of inventory valuation, approach adopted for foreign
currency transaction, revenue recognition, employees benefits &
methodology for taxes on income, provisions and contingent
liabilities and use of estimates.
a) Basis of preparation:
The financial statements are prepared in accordance with the
generally accepted accounting principles in India. These financial
statements are prepared to comply in all material aspects.
c) Investments:
Long-term investments are stated at cost. Provision is made to
recognize a decline, other than temporary, in the value of long-term
investments.
d) Inventories:
Inventories are valued at lower of cost and net realizable value.
Cost is determined on moving weighted average basis. Cost of
work-in-progress and finished goods include labour and
manufacturing overheads, where applicable, based on normal
capacity. Net realizable value is the estimated selling price in the
ordinary course of business less estimated costs of completion and
selling expenses.
g) Employee Benefits:
I. Long-term Employee Benefits
Defined Contribution Plans:
The company has defined contribution plans for post
employment benefits in the form of Provident Fund,
Employees’ Pension Scheme and Employees’ State
Insurance Scheme are classified as Defined Contribution
Plans as the company has no further obligation beyond
making the contributions. The company’s contributions to
Defined Contribution Plans are charged to the statement of
Profit and Loss as incurred.
Transfer Pricing:
Company reveling transaction with their group companies, which
include sales of the product in domestic, import of the essential
raw material from group companies. All the transactions are at the
arm length price.
Dividend Policy:
Liquidity position of the company is analyzed yearly. Based on
next year’s fund requirement it determines current and surplus
balance, which is limited to the shareholders as D/P.
IT Influence:
Company is using SAP
SAP is integrated
system from purchase requisition to sale of finished product or
use of various modules like
FI
Financial Accounting
PPC - Production Planning & Control
CO – Costing
MM – Material Management
SD – Sales and Distribution
FA – Fixed Assets
3. Asset Tagging:
All assets are physically tagged with the unit asset code numbers
appearing in Fixed Assets registered (in SAP) in order to easily
locate the asset. Items like vehicles need to have their license
plates recorded in the Fixed Assets register.
Engineering department tag assets number immediately for
equipments which do not require installation report. For sanctioned
project items a list is furnished by factory accounts to engineering
after capitalization and subsequently engineering tag these assets
accordingly.
Ratio Analysis:
Table 3: Current Ratio
Current Ratio
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Current assets 61.5 76.78 100.73 127.99 109.22
Current Liabilities 14.69 11.86 12 15.56 19.29
Current Ratio 4.186521 6.473862 8.394167 8.225578 5.662001
GP Ratio (%)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
sales 85.82 129.53 152.98 120.81 129.34
Gross Profit 17.09 51.55 60.62 23.27 1.82
GP Ratio (%) 19.91377 39.79773 39.62609 19.26165 1.407144
NP Ratio (%)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
sales 85.82 129.53 152.98 120.81 129.34
net profit after tax 17.74 38.5 46.84 20.6 7.75
NP Ratio 20.67117 29.72284 30.61838 17.05157 5.991959
Proprietory Ratio
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Shareholders fund 148.07 186.57 233.41 254.01 261.76
Total Tangible Assets 180.22 204.35 269.06 276.45 287.94
Proprietory Ratio 0.821607 0.912992 0.867502 0.918828 0.909078
Quotation
Comparison
Purchase
Order
Follow up
Material
Received
1. Purchase Requisition:
Purchase department is responsible for receiving and processing a
Purchase Requisition.
Purchase Requisition is the basic document for Material
Procurement and must be initiated for all material/direct purchases.
Purchase Requisition categorized as:
Non project related Requisition.
Project related Requisition
All Projects related Requisitions are forwarded to Engineering
department.
2. Inquiry
3. Quotation:
5. Purchase Order:
Purchase is responsible for the preparation of PO, and initial
approval of the PO.
49 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
Purchase orders are signed/approved as per the delegation of
Financial Authorities prior to any further processing. Purchase Head
ensures that all the required approvals are obtained before its PO is
issued.
Purchase Head/Finance Head is authorized to approve the PO in
SAP, after that manual print of the PO is duly signed by Purchase
executive, Purchase Head, Finance Head and Site Head and CFO
as per finance approval matrix.
Based on Negotiation, Purchase prepares the Purchase Order
through computerized system SAP.
6. Follow up:
Purchase manager is responsible for follow up for delivery.
Purchase orders are closed when goods are fully received or
the services are fully performed.
Review of the overdue PO from system/manually on a
quarterly base and record the comments on the list of open
PO, which is documented and kept in record.
Goods/Services should deliver on or before delivery date
prescribed in the PO otherwise it will be considered as
overdue.
Purchase department is responsible too in case of follow up
with the supplier for open purchase orders.
If goods are already dispatched or about to be dispatched,
then get the dispatch details like mode of dispatch, LR
number, Courier Docket number etc.
Confirm with transporters regarding arrival of the material at
their go-down.
Enquiry with Stores regarding receipt of material.
Inform the indenter regarding the delivery status.
If goods are not already dispatched, Purchase enquires with
Engineering Department/User Department if PO can be
closed.
Price:
Company is selling its product to the domestic as well as export
market segment. There are two stream for domestic sale namely to
group company and government institution and export to group
companies.
Promotion:
Company is selling mainly to group company and government
institution so promotional activities are absent at CBVPL,
Ankleshwar.
Parent/group Company uses personal selling as a tool of
promotion.
Place:
Company is sending goods directly to customers in case of
government sell & export sell.
In case of Group Company in India they send goods to warehouse
and from there to distributors and from them to agents, wholesaler
and then retailers for trade market.
Region of Market:
Company is having its market in all over India and exporting to
neighboring countries like Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Philippines,
Thailand, China, etc. as well as to PAHO (Pan American Health
Organization) country.
Targeting:
As far as India is concerned, people are not very much concerned about
prevention of rabies vaccine. Company is continuously targeting pre
exposure usage of vaccine.
Market Innovation:
This company is MNC. Its R&D department is in abroad/other country.
CBVPL, Ankleshwar established mainly for manufacturing and selling of
only one product.
Weakness:
1. Brand name harmed due to the legal case against the Indian
government.
2. Controversies regarding their advertising of certain products affected
brand image.
3. FDA charged the company with unethical advertising practices.
4. Charged and fined by US district court for practicing sexual
discrimination against twelve female sales representatives which
ruined the image of the company (2008)
5. No special drug formation for children.
Opportunities:
Threats:
Political
With exhaustive need for new development of medicines to meet all the
medical requirements, Novartis requires political and legal support in order
to venture into this pharmaceutical and biomedical industry. Besides,
Novartis being a MNC, it needs to accordingly abide to the legislations of
different countries. This would greatly influence the development of Novartis
when it's one of the emerging global healthcare leaders.
Despite the heated debate about healthcare costs, people and regulators
(who still demand effective and a high quality medicines) easily forget that
developing new drugs is a lengthy, risky and costly process that is far from
certain which often does not result in a desired outcome, namely a new
approved drug (Schwartz and Moon, 2000, pp.87- 88). Regulatory Approval
for new drugs might take up to ten years and can involve costs of over one
billion USD but productive R&D activities remain vital to the success of
Novartis (Novartis, 2007, p.132). Therefore long patent protection periods
are necessary to enable innovative pharmaceutical companies, such as
Novartis, that do not just produce generics, to get compensation for their
investments in research and development. Furthermore, if healthcare
authorities will start to regulate prices for new medicines, as suggested by
politicians in Europe and the United States, in order to lower prices and thus
costs to the healthcare systems, Novartis and it peers will face further
problems to recover their initial product development costs.
The global economic crisis would greatly impact the trust of the society
towards Novartis. The people believes that the above mentioned crisis might
lead the business and its entrepreneurs to be involved in misleading factors
such as scandals, bankruptcies and unethical practices.
Another important factor that affects Novartis in some way is the situation on
global capital markets. Even though financial markets have recovered to a
somewhat stable situation after the global financial crisis the ex-ante
situation where corporations had almost unlimited access to money will
unlikely be restored. This however, does not pose too much of a problem for
Novartis since it follows a more conservative capital structure.
Socio-Cultural Analysis
Socio-cultural factors are fundamental growth drivers for Novartis and they
remain strong for the foreseeable future increasing demand for healthcare
products. Main drivers are demographic and socio-economic developments
such as increasing population, higher life expectancy as well as changing
lifestyle due to increased prosperity. Novartis expects to keep expanding in
the next years both in traditional markets such as the United States, Europe,
Japan and emerging markets. Emerging markets are considered by IMS
Health as Brazil, China, India, Mexico, Russia, South Korea and Turkey.
Technology
Recent research shows that patients now better understand the benefits of
technology and are embracing it to improve their health. In recent market
research carried out for Novartis, 92 percent of patients and 84 percent of
seniors said that they were comfortable using technology. Almost two-thirds
of patients also think technology is helping them to better manage their
health.
Legal
Companies active in the pharmaceutical industry face already strict and rigid
legal regulation around the world, especially in the United States and
Europe. There, the local health authorities responsible for drugs approvals
and related matters are the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the
European Medicines Agency (EMEA) respectively. These agencies have
immense political and legal power and are pressuring Novartis and other
60 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
industry peers to lower prices and provide enormous loads of information on
safety, efficiency and risk/benefit profile for evaluation and approval
purposes. This development is likely to continue and even increase with
requirements and legislation getting stricter and more involved. Proof for this
is the Food and Drug Administration Amendments Acts 2007 signed by
former President George W. Bush.
Interpretation:
P/E: Pfizer is with the highest P/E which suggests that investors of
Pfizer are expecting higher earnings growth in future compared to other
competitors. GSK is with 76.39 P/E ratios which also suggest that its
investors are expecting higher growth in future. Novartis has 35.35 P/E.
Sanofi’s P/E is 31.22 and MERCK has the lowest P/E.
EPS: as per the EPS Sanofi is the highest profit making from
shareholders’ prospective as it shows company has more profit to
distribute its’ shareholders. After that Pfizer’s EPS is 74.01 crore which
is also profit making from the shareholders’ prospective. Novartis EPS
is 30.83 crore. MERCK is with the lowest EPS of 26.04 crore.
Net Profit Margin (%): Novartis net profit margin is 11.42%, Sanofi’s
profit margin is 12.91%, GSK’s net profit margin is 14.34%, Pfizer has
the highest net profit margin of 18.08% and MERCK is with the lowest
profit margin of 4.86%.
Current Ratio: Novartis, GSK, Pfizer and MERCK are with the current
ratio of 4.97, 2.13, 3.22, and 3.55 respectively. These shows these
company’s’ liquidity position is good and they can easily pay all
liabilities. Sanofy’s CR is 1.85 which shows it doesn’t have good
liquidity.
The term working capital has several meanings in business and economic
development finance. In accounting and financial statement analysis,
working capital is defined as the firm’s short-term or current assets and
current liabilities. Net working capital represents the excess of current
assets over current liabilities and is an indicator of the firm’s ability to meet
its short term financial obligations. Effective working capital management
consists of applying the methods which remove the risk and lack of ability
in paying short term commitments in one side and prevent over investment
in these assets in the other side by planning and controlling current assets
and liabilities.
Research question:
Is there any significant relationship between profitability (ROA) and
working capital management (ACP, APP, ITID, CCC, CR, OP)?
The general of this study was to analyze the relationship between working
capital management and company profitability. The study had the following
specific objectives and hypotheses.
The study’s findings may help the manufacturing firms and other
companies in general improve on their financial decision making so as to
optimize the value of the shareholders and maintain a favorable trade- off
between liquidity and profitability.
The study will may help CBVPL to understand their present efficiency in
managing working capital management and how they can improve it to
earn higher profitability.
The findings may also be of great benefit to future researchers in the field
of working capital management in providing relevant literature in building
up the course of study. It may benefit other scholars and students of
finance who may use the findings for academic purposes.
This study is limited to Chiron Behring Vaccines Ltd. and the consolidated
financial records from the year 2010 to 2014.
Profit refers to the gain in business activity, which is served for the benefit of
business owners. It is usually measured for a certain period of time such as a
3. Gul, Khan, Rehman, Khan, Khan and Khan (2013) investigated the
influence of working capital management (WCM) on performance of small
medium enterprises (SMEs) in Pakistan. The dependent variable of the
study was Return on Assets (ROA) which was used as a proxy for
profitability. Independent variables were Number of Days Account
Receivable (ACP), Number of Day’s Inventory (INV), Cash Conversion
Cycle (CCC) and Number of Days Account Payable (APP). In addition to
these variables some other variables were used which included Firm Size
(SIZE), Debit Ratio (DR) and Growth (GROWTH). Regression analysis
was used to determine the relationship between WCM and performance
of SMEs in Pakistan. Results suggested that APP, GROWTH and SIZE
have positive association with Profitability whereas ACP, INV, CCC and
DR have inverse relation with profitability.
6. Paul Muoki Nzioki, Stephen Kirwa Kimeli, Marcella Riwo Abudho and
Janiffer Mwende Nthiwa (2013) analysed the effects of working capital
management on the profitability of manufacturing firms listed on the
Nairobi Securities Exchange. Diagnostic research design was utilized and
the study targeted the nine CBVPL trading on the Nairobi Securities
Exchange. Multiple regression and correlation analyses were carried out
to determine the relationships between components of working capital
management and the gross operating profit of the firms. The results from
76 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
the study revealed that gross operating profit was positively correlated
with average collection period and average payment period but negatively
correlated with cash conversion cycle. The relationship between inventory
turnover in days and gross operating profit was insignificant. From this
study, it is recommended that managers focus on reducing cash
conversion cycles and try to collect receivables as soon as possible.
8. Hassan Aftab Qazi, Syed Muhammad Amir Shah, Zaheer Abbas and
Tanzeela Nadeem (2011) investigated the Impact of working capital on
firms’ profitability. Different variables affecting the profitability of firms
were selected. In this study, networking capital, inventory turnover in
days, average account receivable and financial asset to total assets
(FATA) were taken as independent variables. The result shows positive
movement of working capital (WC) on firm’s profitability.
10. Parul Mehra (2013) analysed the effect of working capital management
on the profitability of the Indian Pharmaceutical Sector. An attempt has
been made to study the relationship of working capital management with
its important components such as profitability, liquidity and debt used by
these Indian pharmaceutical firms. In this study they used cash
conversion cycle model. Using descriptive statistic they concluded that
the firm can increase their profitability by reducing the cash conversion
cycle which is used as a proxy of the working capital management in
research. They found negative relationship between the APP and the net
operating profitability and positive relationship between current ration and
profitability. They found negative relationship between debt ratio and
profitability.
Research has been carried out to know how the working capital affects the
firms’ Profitability. For this the following research methodology has been
followed.
Data Collection:
The data has been obtained from document analysis of consolidated
financial reports of years ending March 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2014
of CBVPL.
The use of the secondary data enabled me to collect reliable information
from the target population. These reports enabled me to save time in data
collection; they were cost effective and contained the required information.
Rs In Crores
Particulars 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Current Assets
Inventory 43.32 62.89 83.87 102.97 94.16
Debtors 15.35 10.81 14.20 21.79 12.88
Others 2.83 3.08 2.66 3.23 2.18
Total Current Assets (A) 62 77 101 128 109
Current Liability
Creditors 13.29 8.83 9.12 13.07 16.59
Others 1.40 3.03 2.88 2.49 2.70
Total Current Liability (B) 14.69 11.86 12.00 15.56 19.29
Interpretation:
Inventory
Work-in-progress 28 28 28 28 28
Interpretation:
CR is also called working capital ratio. In 2010, CR was 4.19 which was
good for the company as it shows that company’s liquidity position is good
and it can easily pay all of its current liabilities and still have current assets
left over. And in the following years in 2011, 2012, 2013 it was improved
more and slight fall in 2014 though it represents high liquidity and low risk.
Profitability Ratios Relating to Investment
Interpretation:
As per the above chart, Return on Capital Employed(ROCE) was 23.61%
in 2010 further it increased by 33.32% and reached to 56.93% in 2011
which is good sign because of increase in EBIT by 35.63% whereas
capital employed was increased by 19.25%. In 2012 it was decreased by
4.04% because of increase in capital employed. Again in continued to fall
by 34.45% & 16.07% in 2013 & 2014 respectively. It was because of
excess of capital employed which can not give high return in case of less
profit. This shows that company is not employing its capital effectively and
is not generating shareholders’ value.
Interpretation:
As per the above chart in 2010, ROI was 11.81% which was increased by
16.66% in 2011 which shows efficient investment. Year on year it
continuously decreased by 2.02%, 17.22% & 8.04% in 2012, 2013, & 2014
respectively. It was because of excess of investment. Even a small
investment with the greater profit can earn good return.
Interpretation:
As per the above chart in 2010, average collection period was 65.28 days
which shows company was not able to manage its collection well. After
that ACP fall down and reached to 30.46 days in 2011 which company
usually wish to have. In 2012 it was 33.88 days which is also okay but in
2013 it again reached to 65.83 days because of poor communication with
customers regarding their debts and company’s’ expectation of payment.
In 2014, it decreases and reached to 36.35 days which shows
improvement in management of collections.
Interpretation:
As per the above chart in 2010, Average Payment Period (APP) was 70.58
days which was a very long period which shows that it was not good for
companys’ creditworthyness and it might happen that company would not
have been able to buy on credit from the same supplier in future. In 2011
APP went down and reached to 41.33 days which shows that companys’
credibility was improved. In 2012 it was 36.04 days and in 2013 it was
increased by 12.87 days and reached to 48.91 days. Same in 2014 APP
was 47.49 days. This shows that company was taking full advantage of
credit terms allowed by suppliers.
Interpretation:
As per the above chart, inventory turnover in days was of 230.06 days.
Year on year it was increased by 64.30 days, 37.08 days & 53.87 days
and reached to 294.37 days, 331.45 days & 385.32 days in 2011, 2012 &
2013 respectively, which shows that excessive maintanance of inventory
needlessly that means poor inventory management. In 2014, it was
improved little bit and reached to 269.51 days which shows that
management of inventory was done carefully.
Interpretation:
As per the above chart in 2010, cash conversion cycle of CBVPL was
178.96 days. In 2011 it was decreased in reached to 166.35 days because
of decrease in all the three factors (ACP, APP & Sales inventory). In 2012
CCC was increased by 31.60 days and reached to 197.95 days because of
increase in days of sales inventory and decrease in APP. In 2013 CCC was
increased by 130.08 days which is not good sign for the company. It was
because of company was not efficient in managing its collection from
94 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
debtors and also because of increase in days of sales inventory. In 2014 it
was decreased by 73.44 days because of improvement in debtor’s
collection & decrease in days of sales inventory.
Interpretation:
The credit period that CBVPL granted its customer is on an average 46
days with a standard deviation of 18 days. Minimum time that company
takes to collect the receivables is 30 days and maximum 66 days.
The inventory takes on an average 302 days to be sold with a standard
deviation of 59 days. Minimum time the company takes to sell its
inventories is 230 days and maximum 385 days.
The company itself takes on an average 49 days to pay its’ bills to
suppliers and a standard deviation of 13 days. Minimum time the
company takes to pay its bills is 36 days and maximum 71 days.
Overall the cash conversion cycle is ranged at an average of 225 days
with standard deviation of 67 days. Minimum cash conversion cycle is
166 days and maximum 328 days.
There exist a positive coefficient (1) between ITID and profitability. This
positive relationship implies that when the average time required in
converting materials into finished goods and then to sell those goods
decreases, it leads to decrease in profitability.
Other 2 variables which are, ACP and APP has a negative impact on
profitability.
Gul, S., Khan, M. B., Raheman, S.U., Khan, M.T., Khan, M., & Khan, W.
(2013). “Influence of working capital management (WCM) on
performance of small medium enterprises (SMEs)” in Pakistan.
European Journal of Business and management, 5(1), 60-68.
Webliography
_______________________________________
https://ycharts.com/companies/NVS/profit_margin
http://www.indianexporters.com/NOVARTIS-INDIA-LIMITED-com-
555612326.html
http://www.grow-trees.com/corporates/corporate_supporters.aspx?id=132
http://www.indiamart.com/shivroyallifecare/novartis.html
http://www.moneycontrol.com/financials
http://www.novartis.ie/innovation/
www.novartis.com
www.mbaskool.com
www.managementstudyguide.com
www.wipo.int/patent/en/
www.kardex-remstar.com/en/lift-stor
www.thomasnet.com/articles/material
http://www.investopedia.com/articles/06/
Expenses
cost of material consumed 3466 3849
changes in inventories of finished goods & 1456 -1943
working progress
employee benefit expense 1292 1189
depreciation & amortization expense 988 776
other expense 5550 5883
total expenses 12752 9754
profit before tax 1208 3106
tax expense
current tax 552 1010
deferred tax -119 433 36 1046
profit for the year 775 2060
earnings per share-basic & diluted( Rs. Per 7.75 20.6
equity share of Rs 10 each)
Expenses
cost of material consumed 3849 3715
changes in inventories of finished goods & -1943 -1725
working progress
employee benefit expense 1189 1061
depreciation & amortization expense 776 658
other expense 5883 5527
total expenses 9754 9236
profit before tax 3106 7013
tax expense
current tax 1010 2380
deferred tax 36 1046 -51 2329
profit for the year 2060 4684
earning per share-basic & diluted( Rs. Per 20.6 46.84
equity share of Rs 10 each)
Expenses
cost of material consumed 3715 3629
changes in inventories of finished goods & -1725 -2103
working progress
employee benefit expense 1061 1050
depreciation & amortization expense 658 639
other expense 5527 4583
total expenses 9236 7798
profit before tax 7013 5883
tax expense
current tax 2380 2015
deferred tax -51 -13
2329 2002
for earlier years- Current Tax - 31
2329 2033
profit for the year 4684 3850
earnings per share-basic & diluted( Rs. Per 46.84 38.5
equity share of Rs 10 each)
Statement of profit & loss for the year ended 31st March,2011
Rs in thousands
Particulars Year ended 31st Year ended 31st
March,2011 March,2010
Income
gross sales 1293581 858222
less: excise duty on sales 299 -
net sales 1293282 858222
other income 74898 43413
1368180 901635
Expenditure
111 Dharmika Bhavsar/Narmada College of Management
material's cost 152632 121544
personnel cost 105006 106702
manufacturing & other expenses 458277 392471
depreciation 63901 66625
779816 687342
profit before taxation 588364 214293
provision for taxation
for the year
current tax 201540 64500
deferred tax -1315 8933
200225 73433
for earlier years
current tax 3100 -36476
fringe benefits tax - -33
203325 36924
profit after taxation 385039 177369
balance brought forward from 1201223 1158200
previous years
1586262 1335569
Appropriations
Transfer to general reserves 17737
proposed dividend 100000
tax on proposed dividend 16609
balance carried to balance sheet 1586262 1201223
1586262 1335569
earnings per share- basic & 38.5 17.74
diluted ( Rs per Equity Share of
Rs 10 each)