Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Re Expansion On Compact Lie Groups 2019-02-15
Re Expansion On Compact Lie Groups 2019-02-15
1. Introduction
In the 50-s (see, e.g., [IT55] or in more detail [Kah70, Chapters II and VI]), the
following problem in Fourier Analysis attracted much attention:
Let {ak }∞
k=0 be the sequence of the Fourier coefficients of the absolutely
Pconvergent
sine (cosine) Fourier series of a function f : T = [−π, π) → C, that is |ak | < ∞.
Under which conditions on {ak } the re-expansion of f (t) (f (t) − f (0), respectively)
in the cosine (sine) Fourier series will also be absolutely convergent?
The obtained sufficient condition, sharp on the whole class, is quite simple and is
the same in both cases:
∞
X
|ak | ln(k + 1) < ∞. (1.1)
k=1
In [Lif14], a similar problem of the integrability of the re-expansion for Fourier
transforms of functions defined on R+ = [0, ∞) has been studied. Surprisingly,
necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of the membership of the sine or cosine
Fourier transform in a certain Hardy space have been found.
In the present paper, we consider a similar problem on compact Lie groups. There
are special features in this study. A natural analogue of the classical re-expansion
problem on a general compact Lie group G can be formulated as follows: given a
ikt
P
function f = ak e on the maximal torus of G, what conditions on its Fourier
k∈Zl
coefficients {ak }k∈Zl are sufficient in order to have that the group Fourier coefficients
Date: February 15, 2019.
Key words and phrases. Fourier series, re-expansion, compact Lie groups, Hilbert transform.
The authors were supported in parts by the FWO Odysseus Project, EPSRC grant EP/R003025/1
and by the Leverhulme Grant RPG-2017-151.
1
2 RAUAN AKYLZHANOV, ELIJAH LIFLYAND, AND MICHAEL RUZHANSKY
of its central extension are summable (namely, to have Ext[f \] ∈ `1 (G), b with the
sch
appearing symbols explained in the following sections). The necessary and sufficient
condition for this will be given in Theorem 3.2 in terms of the root structure of the
group. Consequently, in Theorem 3.6 we show how this problem leads to the re-
expansions of even/odd functions on compact Lie groups, and we derive a necessary
and sufficient condition for it. In Theorem 3.7 we demonstrate the obtained criterion
on the case of the compact Lie group SU(2).
The outline of the paper is as follows. In the next section we present general results
for compact Lie groups G and a special case G = SU(2). Then we give detailed proofs.
In Section 2 we improve those old known results by obtaining necessary and sufficient
conditions rather than just (1.1).
∞
X ak
~a(n) = . (2.1)
k=−∞
n−k
k6=n
∞
X 2nak an
~e a(n) = 2 2
+ , n = 1, 2, . . . . (2.2)
k=1
n −k 2n
k6=n
∞
o
X 2kak an
~ a(n) = 2 2
− ,, n = 0, 1, 2, . . . . (2.3)
k=1
n −k 2n
k6=n
a0
Of course, 0
is considered to be zero.
One of the best sources for the theory of discrete Hilbert transforms and Hardy
spaces is [BC98]. For weighted estimates for them, see [And77], [ST11a], [ST11b] and
[Lif16b].
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 3
2.2. One-dimensional case. The obtained condition is quite simple and is the
same in both cases:
∞
X
|ak | ln(k + 1) < ∞. (2.4)
k=1
Analysing the proof, say, in [IT55], one can see that in fact more general results are
hidden in the proofs. They can be given in terms of the (discrete) Hilbert transform.
P
Theorem 2.1. In order than the re-expansion bk sin kt of f (t) − f (0) with the
absolutely convergent cosine Fourier series be absolutely convergent, it is necessary
and sufficient that the discrete Hilbert transform ~a of the sequence a of the sine
Fourier coefficients of f is summable. P
Similarly, in order than the re-expansion bk cos kt of f with the absolutely con-
vergent sine Fourier series be absolutely convergent, it is necessary and sufficient that
the discrete Hilbert transform ~a of the sequence a of the cosine Fourier coefficients
of f is summable.
What, in fact, is proven in the mentioned papers, for b = {bk }∞
k=0 ,
b = ~e− a (2.5)
in the first part of Theorem 2.1, and
b = ~o− a (2.6)
in the second one, where
∞ ∞
2 X 1 1 4 X nak
b= ~e− a = ak + = (2.7)
π k=1 n+k n−k π k=1 n2 − k 2
k−n odd k−n odd
and
∞ ∞
2 X 1 1 4 X kak
b= ~o− a = ak + = (2.8)
π k=1 n+k k−n π k=1 k − n2
2
k−n odd k−n odd
is the halved even and odd discrete Hilbert transform, respectively. Indeed, for f :
[0, π] → C, with f (0) = 0 for simplicity (which is necessary as well as f (π) = 0), in
the first case
∞
X
fe (t) = ak cos kt, (2.9)
k=1
with a ∈ `1 , while
4 RAUAN AKYLZHANOV, ELIJAH LIFLYAND, AND MICHAEL RUZHANSKY
∞
X
fs (t) = bn sin nt, (2.10)
n=1
with
Z π ∞ Z π
2 2X
bn = f (t) sin nt dt = ak cos kt sin nt dt
π 0 π k=1 0
∞ Z π
1X
= ak [sin(n + k)t + sin(n − k)t] dt
π k=1 0
∞
2 X 1 1
= ak + .
π k=1 n+k n−k
k−n odd
∞
X
fs (t) = ak sin kt, (2.11)
k=1
with a ∈ `1 , while
∞
X
fe (t) = bn cos nt, (2.12)
n=1
with
Z π ∞ Z π
2 2X
bn = f (t) cos nt dt = ak cos nt sin kt dt
π 0 π k=1 0
∞ Z π
1X
= ak [sin(n + k)t + sin(k − n)t] dt
π k=1 0
∞
2 X 1 1
= ak + .
π k=1 n+k k−n
k−n odd
∞ ∞ ∞ X
∞
X X 1 1 X 1 1
ak + = ak +
n + k k − n n+k k−n
k=1
n=1 n=1 k=1
k−n odd k−n odd
∞
1 X 1 1
+ ak +
2 k=1
n+1+k k−n−1
k−n odd,k6=n+1
∞
1 X 1 1
− ak +
2 k=1
n+1+k k−n−1
k−n odd,k6=n+1
∞ ∞ ∞
1 XX 1 1 X 1 1
= ak + + ak −
2 n=1 k=1 n+k k−n k=1
n+k k+n+1
k6=n k−n odd
∞
X 1 1
+ ak − . (2.13)
k=1
k−n k−n−1
k−n odd
Since
∞ ∞ ∞
X X 1 1 X
ak − ≤C |ak |,
k−n k−n−1
n=1 k=1 k=1
k−n odd
1
k~o− ak`1 = k~o ak`1 + O(1). (2.14)
2
In the completely similar way one can prove that
1
k~e− ak`1 = k~e ak`1 + O(1). (2.15)
2
Hence, replacing the necessary and sufficient condition of the summability of the
halved Hilbert transforms, which follows immediately from (2.5) and (2.6), with the
summability of the usual discrete Hilbert transform, one arrives at the proof of the
theorem.
In this case (2.4) is just a sufficient condition for the summability of the discrete
Hilbert transform, though sharp on the whole class.
X Y Y
fη (x) = ak ( cos kj xj )( sin kj xj ), (2.16)
k∈Z+ j:ηj =1 j:ηj =0
with a ∈ `1 , where now `1 := `1 (Zd+ ). The problem is under what conditions in the
re-expansion
X Y Y
f1−η (x) = bm ( cos mj xj )( sin mj xj )
m∈Z+ j:ηj =0 j:ηj =1
we have b ∈ `1 . Since
2d
Z Y Y
bm = d f (x)( cos mj xj )( sin mj xj ) dx (2.17)
π Td+ j:ηj =0 j:ηj =1
2d X
Z Y Y
= d ak ( cos kj xj sin mj xj )( sin kj xj cos mj xj ) dx
π k∈Z Td+ j:η =1 j:η =0
+ j j
d Y Y
2 X 1 1 1 1
= d ak + + .
π k∈Z j:η =1
mj + kj mj − kj j:η =0 mj + kj kj − mj
+ j j
kj −mj odd,j=1,2,...,d
~−
ηa (2.18)
X Y 1 1
Y
1 1
= ak + + .
k∈Z+ j:ηj =1
mj + kj mj − kj j:ηj =0
mj + kj kj − mj
kj −mj odd,j=1,2,...,d
(2.19)
The summability of ~− 1
η a is the necessary and sufficient condition for b ∈ ` . This is a
direct multidimensional generalisation of the one-dimensional necessary and sufficient
conditions of the summability of (2.5) and (2.6).
Further, applying (2.13) in each variable, we arrive at an analog of (2.14) and
(2.15):
1 e o X
k~−
η ak`1 = k~η ~1−η ak`1 + O
k~eχ ~oζ ak`1 , (2.20)
2
0≤|χ|+|ζ|<|η|
where
Y Y
~eχ a = ( ~ej )a, ~oζ a = ( ~oj )a,
j:χj =1 j:ζj =1
with ~ej
and ~oj e o
being ~ and ~ , respectively, applied to the jth component of a. In
other words, the operators on the right-hand side of (2.20) are mixed discrete Hilbert
transforms. Their integrability leads, correspondingly, to the hybrid discrete Hardy
spaces (see [Lif16a]).
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 7
Thus, the right-hand side of (2.20) consists of the leading term (repeated discrete
Hilbert transforms applied to EACH of the components of a) and the remainder term
that consists of the `1 norms of the repeated Hilbert transforms applied only to a
proper part of the components of a. Of course, kak`1 is among them.
Therefore, k~eη ~o1−η ak`1 < ∞ is a necessary and sufficient condition for b ∈ `1
provided the remainder term in (2.20) is finite.
And, of course, applying (2.4) in each variable, we have a sufficient condition
X d
Y
|ak | ln(kj + 1) < ∞. (2.21)
k∈Zd+ j=1
∞
X qπ
fe(q) (t) = k q ak cos(kt + ), (2.22)
k=1
2
and
∞
X qπ
(fe(q) )s (t) = nq bn sin(nt + ), (2.23)
n=1
2
while if we start with (2.11), the question reduces to that about
∞
X qπ
fs(q) (t) = k q ak sin(kt + ), (2.24)
k=1
2
and
∞
X qπ
(fs(q) )e (t) = nq bn cos(nt + ). (2.25)
n=1
2
The problem, in fact, reduces to the initial one if one observes that
∞
X
k q |ak | ln(k + 1) < ∞. (2.28)
k=1
2.5. Multidimensional weighted case. We will generalise the results from the
previous subsection to several dimensions. Let now q = (q1 , ..., qd ) be a vector with
integer qj ≥ 0. For k ∈ Zd+ ,
k q = k1q1 ...kdqd .
Our starting assumption will now be k q ak ∈ `1 (Zd+ ).
In what follows Dq f will mean the partial derivative
d
!
Y ∂ qj
Dq f (x) = q f (x).
j=1
∂xjj
Starting from a function f : Td+ = [0, π]d → C, with f (x1 , ..., xj−1 , 0, xj+1 , ..., xd ) =
0, j = 1, 2, ..., d, we consider
X Y qj π Y qj π
Dq fη (x) = k q ak ( cos(kj xj + ))( sin(kj xj + )),
k∈Z j:η =1
2 j:η =0
2
+ j j
q 1 1 1
with k a ∈ ` , where now ` := ` (Zd+ ). The problem is under what conditions in the
re-expansion of f in the form
X Y qj π Y qj π
(Dq fη )1−η (x) = mq b m ( cos(mj xj + ))( sin(mj xj + ))
m∈Z+ j:ηj =0
2 j:η =1
2
j
q 1
we have m b ∈ ` .
The proof of the next result is just a superposition and combination of the argu-
ments from the two previous sections. As above, we can think on cos kj xj and sin kj xj
q π q π
instead of cos(kj xj + j2 )) and sin(kj xj + j2 )).
Theorem 2.3. Let Ds f (x1 , ...xj−1 , 0, xj+1 , ..., xd ) = Ds f (x1 , ...xj−1 , π, xj+1 , ..., xd ) =
0, j = 0, 1, ..., qj − 1, for any s = (s1 , ..., sd ) with sj = 0, 1, ..., qj − 1. In order that
the re-expansion
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 9
X Y Y
mq bm ( cos mj xj )( sin mj xj )
m∈Zd j:ηj =0 j:ηj =1
convergent, it is necessary and sufficient that the discrete Hilbert transform ~eη ~o1−η
of the sequence k q a is summable provided
X
k~eχ ~oζ k q ak`1
0≤|χ|+|ζ|<|η|
is finite.
And, of course, applying (2.28) in each variable, we have a sufficient condition
X d
Y
q
k |ak | ln(kj + 1) < ∞. (2.29)
k∈Zd+ j=1
3. Main results
Let G be a compact connected simply connected Lie group of rank l and denote
by G
b its unitary dual, i.e. the set of all irreducible inequivalent representations π.
There is a one-to-one correspondence between G b and the set Λ of the highest weights
Gb 3 π ↔ µ = (µ1 , . . . , µl ) ∈ Λ. (3.1)
Therefore, we use the symbol π to denote both the class of equivalent representations
and the corresponding highest weight µ, i.e.
b 3 π = {ξ ∈ G
G b : ξ is equivalent to π} = (π1 , . . . , πl ) ∈ Λ, (3.2)
where πk = µk , k = 1, . . . , l. Each irreducible representation π ∈ G b has the corre-
sponding highest weight µ = (µ1 , . . . , µl ). The Killing form restricted to t allows us
to define isometric isomorphism between the representation weights and the elements
of t.
Denote by T the maximal abelian subgroup of G. We identify T with the l-
dimensional torus Tl where l is the rank of G. Let R+ be a system of positive roots
and let W denote the Weyl group. If we denote by χπ the character corresponding
to π ∈ Gb we have the Weyl character formula
det(w)ei(w·(µ+δ),H)
P
w∈W
χπ (eiH ) = P , H ∈ t, (3.3)
det(w)ei(w·δ,H)
w∈W
where X
∆(eH ) = det(w)ei(w·δ,H)
w∈W
is the Weyl function and δ denotes the half-sum of all positive roots.
We say that a function g on G is central if it satisfies
g(yty −1 ) = g(t) (3.4)
10 RAUAN AKYLZHANOV, ELIJAH LIFLYAND, AND MICHAEL RUZHANSKY
for all y, t ∈ G. There is also the Weyl integral formula for central functions on G,
Z Z
1
f (g) dg = f (t)|∆(t)|2 dt, (3.5)
G |W | T l
where |W | denotes the cardinality of the Weyl group W (i.e. the number of elements
in W ). It can be easily shown that
Y
∆(t) = (ei(α,H) + e−i(α,H) − 2), (3.6)
α∈R+
with the obvious modification for p = ∞, where S p are the usual Schatten-von
Neumann norms of matrices.
For a function f ∈ L1 (G), as usual, we denote its Fourier coefficients by
Z
f (π) =
b f (g)π(g)∗ dg,
G
where dg is the bi-invariant Haar measure on G. We refer to [RT10] for the necessary
backgrounds for the Fourier analysis on the compact Lie groups.
ak eikt , what conditions on its Fourier coef-
P
Question 3.1. Given a function f =
k∈Zl
\] ∈ `1 (G).
ficients {ak }k∈Zl are sufficient in order to have Ext[f b
sch
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 11
where the number 0 < v ≤ |W | depend only on the Weyl group W and dπ denotes the
dimension of the representation π ∈ G
b
The number v in (3.8) appears as follows: in view of the formula (3.6), only a finite
number of the (toroidal) Fourier coefficients of ∆2 are non-zero, leading to the finite
number v in (3.8).
The explicit expression of dπ is given by Weyl’s dimension formula in (3.3).
Proof of Proposition
3.5. Let f be even. The case of odd function is analogous. De-
note h = f Tl . We write
e2πit1 0 0
e2πit = .. .
0 . 0
0 0 e2πitn
Since f is central and odd (see Definition 3.4), we have
h(t) = f (e2πit ) = f (e−2πit ) = h(−t).
12 RAUAN AKYLZHANOV, ELIJAH LIFLYAND, AND MICHAEL RUZHANSKY
\ 1
Ext[f odd ] ∈ `sch (G), (3.15)
b
if and only if
!
X Xdπ v
X X Xd π Xv
dπ
~ c2 (πmm − j) ≤ C
aj ∆ dπ
c2 (πmm − j) ,
aj ∆ (3.16)
m=1
m=1
π∈G
b j=1 π∈G
b j=1
Theorem 3.7. Let f ∈ L1 (SU(2)). Suppose that f is even and its Fourier coefficients
\
fb are integrable over SU(2):
fb ∈ `1 (SU(2)).
\
sch (3.17)
\
Then the Fourier coefficients Ext[f odd ] of its odd re-expansion fodd are integrable
\ 1 \
Ext[f odd ] ∈ `sch (SU(2)), (3.18)
provided that
X
(2l + 1) log(2l + 1)|a2l+1 | < +∞. (3.19)
l∈ 12 N0
4. Proofs
Proof of Theorem 3.7. It can be checked straightforwardly
2l+1
X
(am−2 − 2am + am+2 ) = a−1 − a1 − a2l − a2l+1 + a2l+2 + a2l+3 ,
m=1
where without the loss of generality we can assume that a0 = a−1 = 0. Thus, we get
2l+1
X
am−2 − 2am + am+2 = −a2l − a2l+1 + a2l+2 + a2l+3 . (4.1)
m=1
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 13
By repeating the relevant lines of proof in [IT55, page 251], we can show that the
sufficient condition is as follows
X
n log(n)|an |.
n∈N
= M + N,
Then we have
n−1 ∞
X
2
X 1
M= k |ak |
k=1 n=k
(n + k)(n − k)
∞
n−1 2k
!
X X 1 X 2
≤ k 2 |ak | +
k=1 n=k
n(n − k) n=2k+1 n2
n−1
X
≤C k|ak | log(k).
k=1
By definition, we have Z
fb(π) = f (u)π(u)∗ du. (4.9)
G
RE-EXPANSIONS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS 15
Since f and π(u)mm are central functions for m = 1, . . . , dπ , the application of Weyl’s
integral formula (3.5) yields
Z
1
f (π)mm =
b f (t)π(t)mm ∆2 (t) dt. (4.10)
|W |
Tl
where R+ are the positive roots associated with G. Thus, using expansion (3.7),(4.11)
and (4.12), we obtain
Z X
f (π)mm =
b ak e2πi(k,t) e−2πi(µm ,t) ∆2 (t) dt. (4.13)
l
Tl k∈Z
Since the Weyl group W is finite, the last sum can be represented as follows
X ν
fb(π)mm = c2 (k − πmm ).
ak ∆ (4.14)
k=1
By the assumption, f is even function (see Definition 3.4). Then its Fourier coeffi-
cients fb(π) are self-adjoint operators (Proposition 3.3)
fb(π)∗ = fb(π).
Therefore, we have
dπ
X
kfb(π)kS 1 (Hπ ) = |fb(π)mm |. (4.15)
m=1
By definition, we have
X X Xd π Xv
kfbk`1 = dπ kfb(π)kS 1 (Hπ ) = dπ
c2 (πmm − j) .
aj ∆ (4.16)
sch (G)
b
m=1
π∈G
b π∈G
b j=1
References
[And77] K. F. Andersen. Inequalities with weights for discrete Hilbert transforms. Canad. Math.
Bull., 20(1):9–16, 1977.
[BC98] S. Boza and M. J. Carro. Discrete Hardy spaces. Studia Math., 129(1):31–50, 1998.
[Dix77] J. Dixmier. C ∗ -algebras. North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam-New York-Oxford,
1977. Translated from the French by Francis Jellett, North-Holland Mathematical Library,
Vol. 15.
[Eym64] P. Eymard. L’algèbre de Fourier d’un groupe localement compact. Bull. Soc. Math. France,
92:181–236, 1964.
[Fle58] T. M. Flett. Some theorems on odd and even functions. Proc. London Math. Soc. (3),
8:135–148, 1958.
[HL36] G. H. Hardy and J. E. Littlewood. Some more theorems concerning Fourier series and
Fourier power series. Duke Math. J., 2(2):354–382, 1936.
16 RAUAN AKYLZHANOV, ELIJAH LIFLYAND, AND MICHAEL RUZHANSKY
[IT55] S.-i. Izumi and T. Tsuchikura. Absolute convergence of fourier expansions. Tohoku Math-
ematical Journal, Second Series, 7(3):243–251, 1955.
[Kah70] J.-P. Kahane. Séries de Fourier absolument convergentes. Springer-Berlin, 1970.
[Kin09] F. W. King. Hilbert transforms. Vol. 1, volume 124 of Enc.Math/Appl. Cambridge Univ.
Press, Cambridge, 2009.
[Lif14] E. Liflyand. On Fourier re-expansions. J. Fourier Anal. Appl., 20(5):934–946, 2014.
[Lif16a] E. Liflyand. Multiple Fourier transforms and trigonometric series in line with Hardy’s
variation. In Nonlinear analysis and optimization, volume 659 of Contemp. Math., pages
135–155. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2016.
[Lif16b] E. Liflyand. Weighted estimates for the discrete Hilbert transform. In Methods of
Fourier analysis and approximation theory, Appl. Numer. Harmon. Anal., pages 59–69.
Birkhäuser/Springer, [Cham], 2016.
[Ros78] J. Rosenberg. Square-integrable factor representations of locally compact groups. Trans.
Amer. Math. Soc., 237:1–33, 1978.
[RT10] M. Ruzhansky and V. Turunen. Pseudo-differential operators and symmetries, volume 2 of
Pseudo-Differential Operators. Theory and Applications. Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, 2010.
Background analysis and advanced topics.
[ST11a] V. D. Stepanov and S. Y. Tikhonov. Two power-weight inequalities for the Hilbert trans-
form on the cones of monotone functions. Complex Var. Elliptic Equ., 56(10-11):1039–1047,
2011.
[ST11b] V. D. Stepanov and S. Y. Tikhonov. Two-weight inequalities for the Hilbert transform on
monotone functions. Dokl. Akad. Nauk, 437(5):606–608, 2011.
[Vil68] N. J. Vilenkin. Special functions and the theory of group representations. Translated from
the Russian by V. N. Singh. Translations of Mathematical Monographs, Vol. 22. American
Mathematical Society, Providence, R. I., 1968.
[Wik65] I. Wik. Extrapolation of absolutely convergent Fourier series by identically zero. Ark. Mat.,
6:65–76 (1965), 1965.
Rauan Akylzhanov:
School of Mathematical Sciences
Queen Mary University of London
United Kingdom
E-mail address r.akylzhanov@qmul.ac.uk
Elijah Liflyand:
Department of Mathematics
Bar-Ilan University
Israel
E-mail address liflyand@gmail.com
Michael Ruzhansky:
Department of Mathematics: Analysis, Logic and Discrete Mathematics
Ghent University, Belgium
and
School of Mathematical Sciences
Queen Mary University of London
United Kingdom
E-mail address michael.ruzhansky@ugent.be