Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

J O U R N A L O F

CLINICAL
FORENSIC
MEDICINE
Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134
www.elsevier.com/locate/jcfm

Original communication

Jumping and falling death in children, adolescents, and young adults


a,*
}
Klára Töro , Nóra Szlávik a, Árpád Mészáros b, György Dunay a,
Margit Soós a, Éva Keller a
a
Department of Forensic Medicine, Semmelweis University Budapest, Üll}oi út 93, 1091 Budapest, Hungary
b
Population, Health and Welfare Statistics Department, Vital Statistics Section, Hungarian Central Statistical Office, Hungary

Received 5 September 2005; received in revised form 11 October 2005; accepted 20 October 2005
Available online 13 December 2005

Abstract

Introduction: Evaluation of fatal jumps and falls from height in children, adolescents and young adults needs careful medico-legal inves-
tigation. The aim of this study was to examine the distribution of undetermined falling from height, accidental falling, and suicidal jump-
ing cases between 1990–2003.
Methods: Copies of death certificates relating to falling from height and jumping deaths in Hungarian youths from the ages of 0–24 years
of those resident in Hungary were obtained.
Results: 215 (34.1%) accidental falls, 394 (62.6%) suicidal jumping, and 21 (3.3%) undetermined intent were investigated. A significant
increase was detected in suicidal jumping death in the age group of 15–19 years (OR = 0.7, CI = 0.49–0.98, p = 0.039), and in the age
group of 20–24 years (OR = 0.72, CI = 0.54–0.96, p = 0.025) in the most recent 5 year study period.
Conclusion: Data concerning the scene investigation, detailed forensic autopsy, and family history have important role in the differen-
tiation of fatal jumping or falling cases. Further investigation about the characteristics injuries may help the final determination of vio-
lent death causes at youth, and more effort should be directed to an effective prevention strategy for jumping or falling death cases.
Ó 2005 Elsevier Ltd and AFP. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Jumping from height; Homicide; Accident; Suicide; Youth

1. Introduction method in providing for the differentiation between fatal


death cases.
When evaluating falling from height or jumping death The aim of this study was to examine the distribution of
cases in youths the investigator needs to be aware of the undetermined falling from height, accidental falling, and
common scenarios, the risk factors, as well as the cause suicidal jumping cases among children, adolescents and
and manner of death in these fatalities. Jumping from young adults in Hungary. We use 3 cases to demonstrate
height is a frequently chosen method of suicide among ado- the difficulties during the investigation of accidental falling,
lescents and young adults,1–3 however, the final confirma- intentional pushing, and suicidal jumping cases.
tion of suicide, accident or murder requires careful and
systematic medico-legal investigation. There is a great 2. Material and methods
human investment in deterring accidents or suicides,4 and
protecting the young is important in every society. A factor Copies of death certificates relating to falling from high
in these efforts is the development of forensic medicine that and jumping deaths up to 24 years of age of those resident
determines liability for failing to employ reasonable in Budapest and in Hungary were obtained from the Hun-
garian Central Statistical Office. Data were collected from
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +36 12157300; fax: +36 12162676. the 4-year period 1990–2003. Rate of falling or jumping
E-mail address: torok@igaz.sote.hu (K. Tör}
o). death was calculated for the number of all death cases in

1353-1131/$ - see front matter Ó 2005 Elsevier Ltd and AFP. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jcfm.2005.10.002
130 K. Tör}o et al. / Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134

1 (0.06)
9 (0.54)

27 (1.61)
different age groups (0–4, 5–9, 10–14, 15–19, and 20–24

No. (%)
years). The population died under the age of 24 years in

2003

37
the investigated period amounted to 5.168 in Budapest,
and 36.605 in Hungary. Details of all jumping and falling

3 (0.17)
18 (1.00)

29 (1.60)
No. (%)
deaths were examined by forensic pathologists or hospital

2002
pathologists. Scene investigation was made by the police.

50
We recorded whether a suicide note was left. Previous sui-
cide attempts and psychiatric history data were also col-

3 (0.16)
11 (0.59)

32 (1.80)
No. (%)
lected. The rate of the levels of alcohol intoxication was

2001
recorded. The blood alcohol concentrations (BACs) were

46
used only, if death occurred on the same day as the injury.
Influence of alcohol was categorized as slight (BAC: 51–

0 (0.00)
17 (0.92)

22 (1.04)
No. (%)
80 mg/100 ml), mild (BAC: 81–150 mg/100 ml), moderate

2000
(BAC: 151–250 mg/100 ml), severe (BAC: 251–350 mg/

39
Number and rates of fatal accidental, suicidal, and not determined falls among all death cases in children, adolescents, and young adults in Hungary
100 ml) and very severe (BAC: above 351 mg/100 ml).

3 (0.14)
17 (0.82)

28 (1.35)
Alcohol-involved deaths were defined as those with detect-

No. (%)
able BAC of more than 50 mg/100 ml.

1999

48
Death cases were collected in three groups: (1) Acciden-
tal falls from high (ICD 9th 881-884, 888 and ICD 10th

1 (0.04)
19 (0.82)

29 (1.25)
No. (%)
W11-W17, W19), (2) intentional self-harm by jumping

1998
from a high place (ICD 9th 987 and ICD 10th X80), (3)

49
falling, jumping or pushed from a high place, undetermined
intent (ICD 9th 957 and ICD 10th Y30). Data include

3 (0.13)
6 (0.26)

34 (1.47)
No. (%)
deaths in each year, using the 9th and 10th revisions of

1997
the international classification of diseases (ICD). The

43
ICD 9th version was used in Hungary between years of
1978 and 1995, and the ICD 10th version with detailed

2 (0.08)
12 (0.47)

30 (1.19)
No. (%)
codes was introduced after 1995.
1996

44
The post-mortem medico-legal examination of the pre-
sented accidental falling, intentional pushing and suicidal
0 (0.00)
14 (0.51)

35 (1.29)
jumping death cases was performed at Semmelweis Univer-
No. (%)

sity Department of Forensic Medicine, Budapest. In every


1995

49
case scene investigation was done by the police. The chi
square test with Yates correction factor was used to com-
0 (0.00)
15 (0.51)

37 (1.25)
No. (%)

pare the numbers of total death and jumping death cases.


1994

52

3. Results
2 (0.06)
16 (0.52)

18 (0.58)
No. (%)

215 (34.1%) accidental falling, 394 (62.6%) suicidal


1993

jumping, and 21 (3.3%) undetermined intent cases were


36

identified. The number and the proportion of jumps and


falls for all death cases among children, adolescents and
1 (0.03)
26 (0.73)

28 (0.79)
No. (%)

young adults in Hungary are presented in Table 1. The pro-


1992

55

portion of accidental falls for all death cases was high in


the age group of 15–19 years (0.23–1.8%), and in the age
1 (0.03)
16 (0.42)

22 (0.58)

group of 20–24 years (0.37–2.04%). The rate of suicidal


No. (%)

jumping shows an increasing rate in the age group of 15–


1991

39

19 years (1.72–4.62%), and in the age of 20–24 years


(1.3–4.4%) from the middle of 1990s.
1 (0.03)
19 (0.50)

23 (0.59)
No. (%)

Table 2 shows the age distribution of suicidal, accidental


1990

and undetermined intent cases. The suicidal jumping was


43

the highest at the age group of 15–19 years, while acciden-


tal falling occurred in high number under the age of 4
Undetermined
Type of death

years, and in age group of 20–24 years.


Accident

Among the 394 suicidal jumps psychiatric treatment was


Table 1

Suicide

identified in medical records of 38 investigated cases


All

(9.6%): 36 in outpatient units and two in inpatient unit.


K. Tör}o et al. / Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134 131

They received psychotropic medication. Thirty patients organ damages (suicidal jumping: 92 cases, 23.3%; acciden-
were treated for depression by antidepressants, dysthymia tal jumping: 35 cases, 16.2%), skull fracture, subdural hem-
and behavior problems. Antipsychotics were prescribed orrhage, brain contusion (suicidal jumping: 249 cases, 63%;
for six children to treat anxiety. Two patients received ben- accidental jumping: 98 cases, 45.5%), severe chest or abdo-
zodiazepines for schizophrenia. Prior suicides attempted men injuries by blunt trauma (suicidal jumping: 53 cases,
were detected only in 28 males (7%). Prior suicide attempts 13.4%; accidental jumping: 82 cases, 38%) were reported
were not observed among females in our study. Suicide let- as cause of death. In accidental falls the children under
ters on the scene were found in 31 suicidal jumping cases the age of 10 years had higher rate of thoracic and abdom-
(7.8%). inal blunt injuries (56%) such as traumatic rupture of the
Fig. 1 demonstrates the rate of undetermined intent aorta, laceration of the liver, while victims in older age
cases comparing the proportions of accidental and suicidal groups suffered in higher percentage brain damages and
death cases. In Budapest there were 0-1-2 (2.2%) cases, and skull fractures.
in Hungary there were 0-1-2-3 cases (3.3%) per years in the Blood alcohol concentrations were evaluated such as
undetermined intent death group. Only in two cases were slight in 21 (3.3%), mild in 63 (10%), moderate in 120
collected data as evidences for homicide. There was no dya- (19%), and severe in 29 (4.6%). In the age group of 20–24
dic death reported in these cases. The number of fatal acci- there were four cases positive for amphetamine and one
dental falling (Fig. 2), and the suicidal jumping death cases case positive for cannabis.
(Fig. 3) has been increased for the last years at young In the last five investigated years (1999–2003) a signifi-
adults. cant increase has been detected in suicidal jumping death
Scene investigations showed that all suicides and most at the age group of 15–19 years (OR = 0.7, CI = 0.49–
of the accidents in the age group of 10–14 years happened 0.98, p = 0.039), and at the age group of 20–24 years
at home or at school. In the age group of 15–19 and 20–24 (OR = 0.72, CI = 0.54–0.96, p = 0.025). There were no
years other scenes were evident, e.g. high building, forest, changes detected in the proportion of accidental falling in
hill, park, prison, barrack, bridge. In age group of 20–24 the investigated period.
years there were 33 (36%) accidental falling in connection We present three fatal cases of young adults who died by
with work or sport activities. accidental falling (case 1), suicidal jumping (case 2) and
However, there was no precise information about the
sites of the primary impacts, traumatic shock with multiple
14
0-4 years
5-9 years
12
Table 2 10-14 years
15-19 years
Jumping and falling death cases in different young age groups (1990–2003) 20-24years
10
in Hungary
Age (years) Suicidal jumping Undetermined intent Accidental falling 8
No.

No. (%) No. (%) No. (%)


6
0–4 0 0 42 (100)
5–9 0 0 15 (100) 4
10–14 17 (44.7) 1 (2.6) 20 (52.6)
2
15–19 166 (74.7) 9 (4) 47 (21.3)
20–24 211 (67.4) 11 (3.5) 91 (29)
0
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
years

suicide Fig. 2. Accidental jumping in different age groups.


not defined
accident
100%

25
80% 10-14 years
15-19 years
20 20-24 years
60%
rates

15
No.

40%
10
20%
5
0%
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 0
years 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
years
Fig. 1. Distribution of suicidal, accidental, and not-defined jumping death
cases among the youths in Hungary. Fig. 3. Suicidal jumping in different age groups.
132 K. Tör}o et al. / Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134

undetermined intent (case 3). In every case the post-mor- 3.3. Case 3
tem medico-legal examination was hardly supported by
the results of police investigation to conclude the final deci- A young woman was hiking in the hills with her hus-
sion of the cause of death. band. In unspecified circumstances she fell in an approx-
imately 9843 feet (30 m) deep cleft. She died at the scene.
3.1. Case 1 The scene investigation did not show any evidence for sui-
cidal jumping or accidental falling. During the medico-
A 23-year-old young man was drinking two bottles of legal autopsy bruises on the face, a laceration above the
wine with his friends on the side of a hill in Budapest. eyebrow and on the chin could be seen by external exam-
He jumped over the barrier of a road traffic tunnel situ- ination. Multiple fractures of the maxilla and mandible
ated in the hillside; he slipped on the rocks, and fell from were found. Several lacerations on the bottom, on the
8 m high. He died at the scene. At external examination outer side of the right tight, on the left hand and on
several bruises and abrasions on the right arm and on the inner side of the right ankle could be seen. The
the neck were found. Laceration of the skin of the head autopsy reported multiple fragmentation of the skull base
was seen, with blood leaking from the right ear. Lacera- and skull cap; fracture of the right collarbone, bilateral
tion of the right upper arm has been detected, and in the multiple fractures of the ribs and fracture of the breast-
base of humerus was broken. The autopsy report indi- bone. Compression of the VI–VII vertebras, contusion
cated right humerus fracture, bilateral multiple rib frac- of the spinal marrow, multiple fragmentation of the hip
tures, skull cup and base fracture, pubic joint fracture; bones, open fractures of the elbows, right tight bone were
thoracic haemorrhage, contusion of the right lung, sub- also detected. Rupture of the right lung and liver had
arachnoidal haemorrhage, brain contusion, rupture of been seen. The autopsy revealed that the woman was
the liver. Natural pathological diseases have not found about 11 weeks old pregnant. Cause of death was defined
during the autopsy. Moderate alcohol intoxication was as traumatic shock caused by severe blunt injury. Careful
measured. The blood alcohol concentration (BAC) was forensic post-mortem examination has not detected any
196 mg/100 ml, and the urine alcohol concentration defensive injuries, abrasions on the neck or wrist. Stran-
was 232 mg/100 ml. No other drugs or chemical agents gulation, grabbing, or signs of physical abuse could be
were detected by toxicological testing. Based on the excluded. Pathomorphological changes of any acute or
information collected at the scene, and the results of chronic natural disease or organ default could not be
autopsy and laboratory tests accidental death was observed by the post-mortem investigation. No alcoholic
concluded. or drug related intoxication was detected by toxicology
testing. The forensic medical investigation failed to deter-
3.2. Case 2 mine the exact method of the injuries caused fatal compli-
cation, further investigation was suggested to characterize
A 22-year-old young man was found dead at the side the partner relationship or potential previous domestic
of a rocky hill of Budapest. At the scene investigation violence in the family. During the following police inter-
empty beer can and box of clonazepam were found by rogation the husband confessed that he had pushed his
the body. Information collected from the parents sug- wife from the rocks. The relationship between them was
gested any social-economic disadvantage in the family, not without trouble. The investigation revealed that he
or any psychiatric disorders or treatment. At external would have been the inheritor of a flat and the beneficiary
examination numerous bruises on the head, chest, bot- of three valuable life assurances taken out before the
tom, back, laceration of the lower limbs, and fracture death occurred.
of the left upper limb were found. During the autopsy
linear fracture of the skull, subarachnoidal haemorrhage, 4. Discussion
multiple contusion of the brain, multiple rib fractures of
the left side, contusions of the lungs and anaemic organs Evaluation of fatal jumps and falls from height in chil-
were found. Cause of death was defined as traumatic dren, adolescents and young adults needs a careful med-
shock. Any pathological diseases or any natural changes ico-legal investigation. The present study demonstrates
could not be seen during the post mortem investigation. that among the youth 1.7% of all death cases was jumping
However, data from the scene might have suggested pre- or falling from height in Hungary during the period of
vious alcohol or drug consumption; the detailed toxicol- 1990–2003 years. However, scene investigation was per-
ogy test could not detect any drugs or alcohol. Suicidal formed, and detailed medico-legal investigation was done
notes were found at home of the young man. Interview in every case, 3.3% of death remained undetermined intent
with parents suggested suicide attempts, however, there without any evidence or characteristics for suicidal, acci-
was not any psychological, or psychiatric treatment in dental, or intentional death. In the investigated period
the past history. Based on the results of scene investiga- there were two homicide cases among children, adolescents
tion, and autopsy findings the final conclusion was sui- and young adults died by pushing from height and hitting
cidal jumping death. the ground.
K. Tör}o et al. / Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134 133

Until recently, in Hungary coding of cause of death was gation of family members, and reports of scene examina-
performed by the death-certifying doctors, whereas in Wes- tion) the final conclusion on cause of death would not
tern Europe this was done by trained persons at the statis- have been declared.
tical office.5 However, this fact was not expected to affect Jumping is reported as a frequent suicidal method
our results in the comparison between the two investigated among males,11–14 however, some of the studies did not
periods. As a consequence, the distribution of diagnostic find any significant gender difference in fatal jumping cases
groups within the ICD category of falling or jumping in the youth2,15 and some studies16,17 reported more jump-
was defined by the similar trained forensic medical doctors ing suicidal rates amid females. Jumping was found as the
in the period 1990–1994 with ICD version 9th, and in the most frequent suicidal method amid psychiatric patients,18
period 1995–2003 with ICD version 10th. In the presented people with schizophrenia the rate of jumping was detected
cases examination and investigation were made by forensic about 40%.19 Suicides letter play an important role in
medical doctors to determine the cause and manner of determination of the manner of the death. Only one of
death. our presented cases was left a hand-writing suicidal note,
Jumping from height, as well as hanging and running which was used to characterize the type of jumping. If a
over by a train are so-called ‘‘hard’’ suicidal methods, suicide note or evidence showing that the subject has inten-
usually with a high degree of auto-aggressive, self- tionally harmed him/herself can be found, then determina-
destructive behaviour.6 Suicidal jumping rate was tion of the intent is not very difficult.20 Based on the
reported as an incidence of five cases per 100.000 inhab- information collected from the family, victims have not
itants per year, or one fourth of all suicides.7 In our been sending alarming or understandable signals. In our
material the proportion of suicidal jumps shows an suicidal jumping case the suicidal letter and the informa-
increasing tendency (from 0.58% to 1.8%) for all death tion collected from the parents were important evidences
cases in the youth. Jumping from the height is one of in the characterization of death cause. Characteristic inju-
the most common suicidal methods among the youth,2 ries of recreational sport climbers were reported20,21 as dig-
especially in urban areas compared to the rural popula- ital fibro-osseous sheath ruptures and PIP joint collateral
tion.8,9 Räsänen et al.9 found seasonal distribution in sui- ligament strains. Evaluation of these injuries may help in
cidal jumping with the predominance of summer and the final differentiation of suicidal jumping and accidental
autumn in Finland. Suicide safety barriers in metropoli- falling in fatal cases. Goren et al.16 stated that the age range
tan area provide an effective prevention,10 and following of accidental and suicidal jumping were not similar,
the removal of the barriers from the bridge the rate of because accidental death were the highest at age 0–5, and
suicide by jumping in question did not change but the the suicidal death was the most frequent in age group of
pattern of suicides changes significantly with more sui- 16–20. In our material data both suicidal and accidental
cides from the bridge in question and fewer at other jumping cases were the most common at age 15–24 years.
sites. The age distribution suggests that the prevalence In the last investigated years there was a significant rise
of suicidal jumping was sharply increasing in adolescents in the proportion of suicidal jumps in the age group of
and young adults, counted in our material there was a 10–14 years. Scene investigation in every jumping or falling
good agreement with data reported in former forensic case seems to be essential in the determination of suicide,
studies.2,6 In our material jumping was a common accidents or as an act of homicide. The point of trajectory,
method of suicide at age group 15–19, and the most fre- the horizontal distance and the impact point are closely
quent suicidal method at age 20–24. In our material related to the initial velocity, angle, and height. Shaw
there was no suicidal jumping under the age 10. Bridges, et al.22 investigated the horizontal distance and height is
high buildings are popular places of suicide attempts. legitimate measures to use in speculating on the falling pat-
The distribution of jumping comparing to total death tern and the manner of death.
rates demonstrates that there is a significant increase in In the presented homicide case the death happened on
the last years in the proportion of suicidal jumping at hills, the bodies were found with skull fractures and brain
age 20–24. damages. No signs of homicide were discovered during
The investigation of injuries caused by jumping or fall- the investigation, however, moderate alcohol level was
ing represents a challenge for forensic pathologists, because detected in one case, and toxicology was negative in all
the characteristics of injuries are very similar independently cases. About 37% of all women were murdered by their
from the pathomechanisms of falling. Only the careful current or former intimate partner compared to 6% of
scene investigation, evaluation of previous data, collection men in the UK,23 and among females approximately 1 in
all the information from family circle can provide evidences 3 homicides are intimate partner homicides.24 In intimate
for the exact final decision. Despite of the different methods partner homicide 80% of women were killed in homes,25
of falling, our cases showed similar injury patterns and lab- and firearms were used as the method of killing most
oratory tests results had moderate level of BAC and the often.26 However, high percentage of female victims was
toxicology did not detect anything. Without the results of killed by husband or partner, little research has examined
the police investigation (provided anamnestic data, interro- the rate among pregnant women. Martin et al.27 showed
134 K. Tör}o et al. / Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine 13 (2006) 129–134

that before pregnancy, women who were physically 7. Perret G, Flomenbaum M, La Harpe R. Suicides by fall from height in
assaulted by their partners were more likely to drink alco- Geneva, Switzerland, from 1991 to 2000. J Forensic Sci 2003;48:821–6.
8. Petrauskiene J, Kalediene R, Starkuviene S. Methods of suicides in
hol and use illicit drugs compared with women who did not Lithuana and their associations with demographic factors. Medicina
experience such violence. (Kaunas).
Whereas most of the murder cases are fairly well recog- 9. Räsänen P, Hakko H, Jokelainen J, Tiihonen J. Seasonal variation in
nised by the police and medico-legal investigations, the lit- specific methods of suicide: a national register study of 20234 Finnish
erature contains little information regarding cases by people. J Affect Disord 2002;71:51–9.
10. Beautrais AL. Effectiveness of barriers at suicide jumping sites: a case
intentional pushing from height. Shaw et al.28 reported that study. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2001;35:557–62.
intentional pushing as a method was found among young 11. Yip PS. Suicides in Hong Kong and Australia. Crisis 1998;19:24–34.
male perpetrators, who kill stranger victims. Wyatt et al.29 12. Copeland AR. Suicide by jumping from buildings. Am J Forensic
emphasised there is little potential to reduce the death rate Pathol 1989;10:295–8.
from suicidal falls by improving hospital treatment, it is 13. Reuhl J, Lutz FU. Suicide in a large West German city (1985–1989).
Versicherungsmedizin 1992;44:13–5.
worth considering whether some of the falls might have 14. Lindqvist P, Jonsson A, Eriksson A, Hedelin A, Bjönstig U. Are
been prevented. Legal and health care professionals should suicides by jumping off bridges preventable? An analysis of 50 cases
be aware that women are vulnerable to both intimate part- from Sweden. Acc Ana Prev 2004;36:691–4.
ner violence and homicide from partners. The forensic med- 15. Zachariakis CA, Hadjivassilis V, Madianos MG, Papadimitriou GN,
ical investigation and the co-operation between the medical Stefanis CN. Suicide in Cyprus 1988–1999. Eur Psychiatry
2005;20:110–4.
experts and the local authorities or the police seem to be 16. Goren S, Subasi M, Tyrasci Y, Gurkan F. Fatal falls from heights in
essential to discover all data for differentiation suicidal and around Diyarbakir, Turkey. Forensic Sci Int 2003;137:37–40.
jumping, accidental falling, or intentional pushing. Data 17. Nachman R, Yanai O, Goldin L, Swartz M, Barak Y, Hiss J. Suicide
of the scene investigation, detailed forensic autopsy, results in Israel: 1985–1997. J Psychiatry Neurosci 2002;27:423–8.
of the laboratory tests, previous data, and family history 18. Fukuchi T, Kanemoto K, Kato M, Ishida S, Yuasa S, Kawasaki J,
et al. Death in epilepsy with special attention to suicide cases. Epilepsy
have important role in the examination of fatal jumping Res 2002;51:233–6.
and falling cases. Further investigation about the character- 19. Kreyenbuhl JA, Kelly DL, Conley RR. Circumstances of suicide
istics injuries may help the final determination of violent among individuals with schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Res
death causes at youth, and more effort should be directed 2002;58:253–61.
to the effective prevention strategy of jumping or falling 20. Young CC. Extreme sports: injuries and medical coverage. Curr Sports
Med Rep 2002;1:306–11.
death cases. The statistical data and the presented cases 21. Wyatt J, McNaughton G, Grant P. Prospective study of rock climbing
emphasised the importance of careful investigation in jump- injuries. Br J Sports Med 1996;30:148–50.
ing, pushing or falling cases. The scene investigation and the 22. Shaw KP, Hsu SY. Horizontal distance and height determining falling
detailed medico-legal autopsy can be failed in the final pattern. J Forensic Sci 1998;43:765–71.
determination without the evaluation of previous data 23. Aldridge ML, Browne KD. Perpetrators of spousal homicide. Trauma
Violence Abuse 2003;3:265–76.
and the family history, family circumstances. 24. Martin SL, Beaumont JL, Kupper LL. Substance use before and
during pregnancy: links to intimate partner violence. Am J Drug
References Alcohol Abuse 2003;3:599–617.
25. Paulozzi JL, Saltzman LE, Thompson MP, Holmgreen P. Surveillance
1. Shek DT, Tang V. Adolescent suicide in Hong Kong during 1980– for homicide among intimate partners, United States, 1981–1998.
2000. Int J Adolesc Med Health 2003;15:245–65. MMWR CDC Surveill Summ 2001;3:1–15.
2. Ung EK. Young suicide and parasuicide in Singapore. Ann Acad Med 26. Farooque RS, Stout RG, Ernst FA. Heterosexual intimate partner
Singapore 2003;32:12–8. homicide: review of 10 years of clinical experience. J Forensic Sci
3. Havasi B, Magor K, Toth A, Kiss L. Fatal suicide cases from 1991 to 2005;3:648–51.
2000 in Szeged, Hungary. Forensic Sci Int 2005;147:25–8. 27. Moracco KE, Runyan CW, Butts JD. Female intimate partner
4. Centner TJ. Examining legal rules to protect children from injuries in homicide: a population-based study. J Am Med WomenÕs Assoc
recreational and sport activities. J Safety Res 2005;36:1–7. 2003;1:20–5.
5. Nolte E, Scholtz R, Shkolnikov V, McKee M. The contribution of 28. Shaw J, Amos T, Hunt IM, Flynn S, Turnbull P, Kapur N. Mental
medical care to changing life expectancy in Germany and Poland. illness in people who kill strangers: longitudinal study and national
Social Sci Med 2002;55:1905–21. clinical survey. BMJ 2004;328:734–7.
6. Schmidt P, Müller R, Dettmeyer R, Madea B. Suicide in children, 29. Wyatt JP, Beale JP, Graham CA, Beard D, Busuttil A. Suicidal high
adolescents and young adults. Forensic Sci Int 2002;127:161–9. falls. J Clin Forensic Med 2000;7:1–5.

You might also like